PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) Editors' Suggestion Featured in Physics Observation of CP Violation in Charm Decays R. Aaij et al.* (LHCb Collaboration) (Received 21 March 2019; revised manuscript received 2 May 2019; published 29 May 2019) A search for charge-parity (CP) violation in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays is reported, using pp collision data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 5.9 fb−1 collected at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV with the LHCb detector. The flavor of the charm meson is inferred from the charge of the pion in D ð2010Þþ → D0 π þ decays or from the charge of the muon in B̄ → D0 μ− ν̄μ X decays. The difference between the CP asymmetries in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays is measured to be ΔACP ¼ ½−18.2  3.2ðstatÞ  0.9ðsystÞ × 10−4 for π-tagged and ΔACP ¼ ½−9  8ðstatÞ  5ðsystÞ × 10−4 for μtagged D0 mesons. Combining these with previous LHCb results leads to ΔACP ¼ ð−15.4  2.9Þ × 10−4 , where the uncertainty includes both statistical and systematic contributions. The measured value differs from zero by more than 5 standard deviations. This is the first observation of CP violation in the decay of charm hadrons. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.211803 The noninvariance of fundamental interactions under the combined action of charge conjugation (C) and parity (P) transformations, so-called CP violation, is a necessary condition for the dynamical generation of the baryon asymmetry of the universe [1]. The standard model (SM) of particle physics includes CP violation through an irreducible complex phase in the Cabibbo-KobayashiMaskawa (CKM) quark-mixing matrix [2,3]. The realization of CP violation in weak interactions has been established in the K- and B-meson systems by several experiments [4–12], and all results are well interpreted within the CKM formalism. However, the size of CP violation in the SM appears to be too small to account for the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry [13–15], suggesting the existence of sources of CP violation beyond the SM. The observation of CP violation in the charm sector has not been achieved yet, despite decades of experimental searches. Charm hadrons provide a unique opportunity to measure CP violation with particles containing only up-type quarks. The size of CP violation in charm decays is expected to be tiny in the SM, with asymmetries typically of the order of 10−4 − 10−3 , but due to the presence of low-energy strong-interaction effects, theoretical predictions are difficult to compute reliably [16–34]. Motivated by the fact that contributions of beyond-the-SM virtual particles may alter the size of CP violation with respect to the SM expectation, a number of theoretical analyses have been performed [19,27,32,35]. Unprecedented experimental precision can be reached at LHCb in the measurement of CP-violating asymmetries in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays. The inclusion of charge-conjugate decay modes is implied throughout except in asymmetry definitions. Searches for CP violation in these decay modes have been performed by the BABAR [36], Belle [37], CDF [38,39], and LHCb [40–44] Collaborations. The corresponding CP asymmetries have been found to be consistent with zero within a precision of a few per mille. This Letter presents a measurement of the difference of the time-integrated CP asymmetries in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays, performed using pp collision data collected with the LHCb detector at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV, and corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 5.9 fb−1 . The time-dependent CP asymmetry, ACP ðf; tÞ, between states produced as D0 or D̄0 mesons decaying to a CP eigenstate f at time t is defined as * where Γ denotes the time-dependent rate of a given decay. For f ¼ K − K þ or f ¼ π − π þ, ACP ðf; tÞ can be expressed in terms of a direct component associated with CP violation in the decay amplitude and another component associated with CP violation in D0 -D̄0 mixing or in the interference between mixing and decay. Full author list given at the end of the article. Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. Funded by SCOAP3. 0031-9007=19=122(21)=211803(12) ACP ðf; tÞ ≡ 211803-1 Γ(D0 ðtÞ → fÞ − ΓðD̄0 ðtÞ → f) ; Γ(D0 ðtÞ → fÞ þ ΓðD̄0 ðtÞ → f) ð1Þ © 2019 CERN, for the LHCb Collaboration PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) A time-integrated asymmetry, ACP ðfÞ, can be determined, and its value will exhibit a dependence on the variation of the reconstruction efficiency as a function of the decay time. To first order in the D0 -D̄0 mixing parameters, it can be written as [38,45] ACP ðfÞ ≈ adir CP ðfÞ − htðfÞi AΓ ðfÞ; τðD0 Þ ð2Þ where htðfÞi denotes the mean decay time of D0 → f decays in the reconstructed sample, incorporating the effects of the time-dependent experimental efficiency, 0 0 adir CP ðfÞ is the direct CP asymmetry, τðD Þ the D lifetime 0 and AΓ ðfÞ the asymmetry between the D → f and D̄0 → f effective decay widths [46,47]. In the limit of U-spin symmetry, the direct CP asymmetry is equal in magnitude and opposite in sign for K − K þ and π − π þ , though the size of U-spin-breaking effects at play is uncertain [19]. Taking AΓ to be independent of final state [19,48,49], the difference in CP asymmetries between D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays is ΔACP ≡ ACP ðK − K þ Þ − ACP ðπ − π þ Þ ≈ Δadir CP − Δhti AΓ ; τðD0 Þ dir − þ dir − þ where Δadir CP ≡ aCP ðK K Þ − aCP ðπ π Þ and Δhti is the difference of the mean decay times htðK − K þ Þi and htðπ − π þ Þi. The D0 mesons considered in this analysis are produced either promptly at a pp collision point (primary vertex, PV) in the strong decay of D ð2010Þþ mesons (hereafter referred to as Dþ ) to a D0 π þ pair or at a vertex displaced from any PV in semileptonic B̄ → D0 μ− ν̄μ X decays, where B̄ denotes a hadron containing a b quark, and X stands for potential additional particles. The flavor at production of D0 mesons from Dþ decays is determined from the charge of the accompanying pion (π tagged), whereas that of D0 mesons from semileptonic b-hadron decays is obtained from the charge of the accompanying muon (μ tagged). The raw asymmetries measured for π-tagged and μ-tagged D0 decays are defined as Aπ−tagged ðfÞ ≡ raw N(Dþ → D0 ðfÞπ þ ) − N(D− → D̄0 ðfÞπ − ) ; N(Dþ → D0 ðfÞπ þ ) þ N(D− → D̄0 ðfÞπ − ) ðfÞ ≡ Aμ−tagged raw N(B̄ → D0 ðfÞμ− ν̄μ X) − N(B → D̄0 ðfÞμþ νμ X) ; N(B̄ → D0 ðfÞμ− ν̄μ X) þ N(B → D̄0 ðfÞμþ νμ X) where N is the measured signal yield for the given decay. These can be approximated as Aπ−tagged ðfÞ ≈ ACP ðfÞ þ AD ðπÞ þ AP ðD Þ; raw ðfÞ ≈ ACP ðfÞ þ AD ðμÞ þ AP ðBÞ; Aμ−tagged raw ð5Þ where AD ðπÞ and AD ðμÞ are detection asymmetries due to different reconstruction efficiencies between positive and negative tagging pions and muons, whereas AP ðD Þ and AP ðBÞ are the production asymmetries of D mesons and b hadrons, arising from the hadronization of charm and beauty quarks in pp collisions [50]. Owing to the smallness of the involved terms, which averaged over phase space for selected events are Oð10−2 Þ or less [50–53], the approximations in Eq. (5) are valid up to corrections of Oð10−6 Þ. The values of AD ðπÞ and AP ðD Þ, as well as those of AD ðμÞ and AP ðBÞ, are independent of the final state f and, thus, cancel in the difference, resulting in ΔACP ¼ Araw ðK − K þ Þ − Araw ðπ − π þ Þ: ð6Þ This simple relation between ΔACP and the measurable raw asymmetries in K − K þ and π − π þ makes the determination of ΔACP largely insensitive to systematic uncertainties. ð3Þ ð4Þ The LHCb detector is a single-arm forward spectrometer designed for the study of particles containing b or c quarks, as described in detail in Refs. [54,55]. The LHCb tracking system exploits a dipole magnet to measure the momentum of charged particles. Although the analysis presented in this Letter is expected to be insensitive to such effects, the magnetic-field polarity is reversed periodically during data taking to mitigate the differences of reconstruction efficiencies of particles with opposite charges. Data sets corresponding to about one half of the total integrated luminosity are recorded with each magnetic-field configuration. The online event selection is performed by a trigger, which consists of a hardware stage based on information from the calorimeter and muon systems, followed by two software stages. In the first software stage, events used in this analysis are selected if at least one track has large transverse momentum and is incompatible with originating from any PV, or if any two-track combination forming a secondary vertex, consistent with that of a D0 decay, is found in the event by a multivariate algorithm [56,57]. In between the first and second software stages, detector alignment and calibration are performed, and updated constants are made available to the software trigger [58]. In the second stage, D0 candidates are fully reconstructed using kinematic, topological and particle-identification 211803-2 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) (PID) criteria. Requirements are placed on: the D0 decay vertex, which must be well separated from all PVs in the event, the quality of reconstructed tracks, the D0 transverse momentum, the angle between the D0 momentum and its flight direction, PID information, and the impact-parameter (IP) significances (χ 2IP ) of the D0 decay products with respect to all PVs in the event, where the χ 2IP is defined as the difference between the χ 2 of the PV reconstructed with and without the considered particle. In the analysis of the μ-tagged sample, B candidates are formed by combining a D0 candidate with a muon under the requirement that they are consistent with originating from a common vertex. In addition, requirements on the invariant mass of the D0 μ system, mðD0 μÞ, and on the corrected mass (mcorr ) are applied. The corrected mass partially recovers the missing energy of the unreconstructed particles and is defined as pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mcorr ≡ mðD0 μÞ2 þ p⊥ ðD0 μÞ2 þ p⊥ ðD0 μÞ [59], where p⊥ ðD0 μÞ is the momentum of the D0 μ system transverse to the flight direction of the b hadron, determined from the primary and D0 μ vertices. In the off-line selection, trigger signals are associated to reconstructed particles. Selection requirements are applied on the trigger decision, taking into account the information on whether the decision was taken due to the signal decay products or to other particles produced in the event. Fiducial requirements are imposed to exclude kinematic regions characterized by large detection asymmetries for the tagging pion or muon. Very large raw asymmetries, up to 100%, occur in certain kinematic regions because, for a given magnet polarity, low-momentum particles of one charge at large or small polar angles in the horizontal plane may be deflected out of the detector or into the (not instrumented) LHC beam pipe, whereas particles with the other charge are more likely to remain within the acceptance [60]. About 35% and 10% of the selected candidates are rejected by these fiducial requirements for the π-tagged and μ-tagged samples, respectively. In the retained samples, raw asymmetries are typically at the percent level or below. For π-tagged D0 mesons, a requirement on the D0 χ 2IP is applied to suppress the background of D0 mesons from B decays, and PID requirements on the D0 decay products are further tightened. Then the D0 and pion candidates are combined to form Dþ candidates by requiring a good fit quality of the Dþ vertex and the invariant mass of D0 candidates to lie within a range of about 3 standard deviations around the known D0 mass. The Dþ vertex is determined as a common vertex of D0 and tagging π þ candidates, and is constrained to coincide with the nearest PV [61]. For μ-tagged mesons, the B candidates are further filtered using a dedicated boosted decision tree (BDT) to suppress the combinatorial background due to random combinations of charged kaon or pion pairs not originating from a D0 decay. The variables used in the BDT to discriminate signal from combinatorial background are the fit quality of the D0 and the B decay vertices, the D0 flight distance, the D0 impact parameter, i.e., the minimum distance of its trajectory to the nearest PV, the transverse momenta of the D0 decay products, the significance of the distance between the D0 and B decay vertices, the invariant mass mðD0 μÞ, and the corrected mass mcorr . To suppress background from b-hadron decays to cc̄π  X (cc̄K  X), where the cc̄ resonance decays to a pair of muons, D0 candidates are vetoed if the invariant mass of the μ∓ π  (μ∓ K  ) pair, where the pion (kaon) is given the muon mass hypothesis, lies within a window of about 50 MeV=c2 around the J=ψ or ψð2SÞ known masses. The data sample includes events with multiple Dþ and B candidates. The majority of these events contain the same reconstructed D0 meson combined with different tagging pions or muons. When multiple candidates are present in the event, only one is kept randomly. The fractions of events with multiple candidates are about 10% and 0.4% in the π-tagged and μ-tagged samples, respectively. A small fraction of events, of the order of per mille, belong to both the selected π-tagged and μ-tagged samples. As the detection and production asymmetries are expected to depend on the kinematics of the reconstructed particles, the cancellation in the difference between the raw asymmetries in Eq. (6) may be incomplete if the kinematic distributions of reconstructed Dþ or B candidates and of the tagging pions or muons differ between the K − K þ and π − π þ decay modes. For this reason, a small correction to the K − K þ sample is applied by means of a weighting procedure [60]. For the π-tagged sample, candidate-by-candidate weights are calculated by taking the ratio between the three-dimensional background-subtracted distributions of transverse momentum, azimuthal angle, and pseudorapidity of the Dþ meson in the K − K þ and π − π þ modes. An analogous procedure is followed for the μ-tagged sample, where D0 distributions are used instead of those of the Dþ meson. It is then checked a posteriori that the distributions of the same variables for tagging pions and muons are also equalized by the weighting. The application of the weights leads to a small variation of ΔACP , below 10−4 for both the π-tagged and μ-tagged samples. The raw asymmetries of signal and background components for each decay mode are free parameters determined by means of simultaneous least-square fits to the binned mass distributions of Dþ and D− candidates for the π-tagged sample, or D0 and D̄0 candidates for the μ-tagged sample. In particular, in the analysis of the π-tagged sample, the fits are performed to the mðD0 π þ Þ and mðD̄0 π − Þ distributions. As outlined in Ref. [38], using these distributions has the advantage that they are the same for both D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decay modes. The signal mass model, which is obtained from simulation, consists of the sum of three Gaussian functions and a Johnson SU function [62], whose parameters are free to be adjusted by the fit to the data. The mean values of the 211803-3 ×103 LHCb 6000 Data 5000 D0 → K −K + 4000 Comb. bkg. 3000 2000 1000 0 2005 2010 2015 Candidates / ( 0.1 MeV/c2 ) Candidates / ( 0.1 MeV/c2 ) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) 2020 ×103 2200 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 2005 ×103 600 LHCb 500 Data 400 D0 → K −π + 300 Comb. bkg. D0 → K −K + 200 100 0 1850 1900 m(D0) [MeV/c2] Data D0 → π −π + Comb. bkg. 2010 2015 2020 m(D0π +) [MeV/c2] Candidates / ( 1 MeV/c2 ) Candidates / ( 1 MeV/c2 ) m(D0π +) [MeV/c2] LHCb 160 ×103 LHCb 140 Data 120 D0 → π −π + 100 D0 → K −π + 80 Comb. bkg. 60 40 20 0 1800 1850 1900 m(D0) [MeV/c2] FIG. 1. Mass distributions of selected (top) π  -tagged and (bottom) μ -tagged candidates for (left) K − K þ and (right) π − π þ final states of the D0 -meson decays, with fit projections overlaid. Gaussian functions are distinct for positive and negative tags, whereas widths and fractions are shared. The parameters of the Johnson SU function, which accounts for the slight asymmetric shape of the signal distribution due to the proximity of the mðD0 Þ þ mðπ þ Þ threshold, are also shared. The combinatorial background is described by an empirical function of the form ½mðD0 π þ Þ − mðD0 Þ − 0 þ mðπ þ Þα eβmðD π Þ , where α and β are two free parameters which are shared among positive and negative tags. In the analysis of the μ-tagged sample, the fits are performed to the mðD0 Þ distributions. The signal is described by the sum of two Gaussian functions convolved with a truncated power-law function that accounts for final-state photon radiation effects, whereas the combinatorial background is described by an exponential function. A small contribution from D0 → K − π þ decays with a misidentified kaon or pion is also visible, which is modeled as the tail of a Gaussian function. Separate fits are performed to subsamples of data collected with different magnet polarities and in different years. All partial ΔACP values corresponding to each subsample are found to be in good agreement and then averaged to obtain the final results. If single fits are performed to the overall π-tagged and μ-tagged samples, small differences of the order of a few 10−5 are found. The mðD0 π þ Þ and mðD0 Þ distributions corresponding to the entire samples are displayed in Fig. 1 (see also Ref. [60] for the corresponding asymmetries as a function of mass). The π-tagged (μ-tagged) signal yields are approximately 44 (9) million D0 → K − K þ decays and 14 (3) million D0 → π − π þ decays. In the case of π-tagged decays, the fits to the mðD0 π þ Þ distributions do not distinguish between background that produces peaks in mðD0 π þ Þ, which can arise from Dþ decays where the correct tagging pion is found but the D0 meson is misreconstructed, and signal. The effect on ΔACP of residual peaking backgrounds, suppressed by selection requirements to less than 1% of the number of signal candidates, is evaluated as a systematic uncertainty. Studies of systematic uncertainties on ΔACP are carried out independently for the π-tagged and μ-tagged samples. Several sources affecting the measurement are considered. In the case of π-tagged decays, the dominant systematic uncertainty is related to the knowledge of the signal and background mass models. It is evaluated by generating pseudoexperiments according to the baseline fit model, then fitting alternative models to those data. A value of 0.6 × 10−4 is assigned as a systematic uncertainty, corresponding to the largest variation observed using the alternative functions. Possible differences between D0 π þ and D̄0 π − invariant-mass shapes are investigated by studying a sample of 232 million Dþ → D̄0 ðK − π þ Þπ þ and D− → D̄0 ðK þ π − Þπ − decays. The effect on ΔACP is estimated to be on the order of 10−5 at most, hence, negligible. A similar study with pseudoexperiments is also performed with the μ-tagged sample and a value of 2 × 10−4 is found. In the case of μ-tagged decays, the main systematic uncertainty is due to the possibility that the D0 flavor is not tagged correctly by the muon charge because of misreconstruction. The probability of wrongly assigning the D0 flavor (mistag) is studied with a large sample of μ-tagged D0 → K − π þ decays by comparing the charges of kaon and muon candidates. Mistag rates are found to be at the percent level and compatible for positively and negatively tagged decays. The corresponding systematic uncertainty is estimated to be 4 × 10−4 , also taking into account the fact that wrongly tagged decays include a fraction of doubly Cabibbo-suppressed D0 → K þ π − and mixed D0 → D̄0 → K þ π − decays, calculated to be 0.39% with negligible uncertainty for both the K þ π − and K − π þ final states using input from Ref. [63]. Systematic uncertainties of 0.2 × 10−4 and 1 × 10−4 accounting for the knowledge of the weights used in the kinematic weighting procedure are assessed for π-tagged and μ-tagged decays, respectively. Although suppressed by the requirement that the D0 trajectory points back to the PV, a fraction of D0 mesons from B decays is still present in the final π-tagged sample. As D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays may have different levels of contamination, the value of ΔACP may be biased because of an incomplete cancellation of the production asymmetries of b hadrons. The fractions of D0 mesons from B decays are estimated by performing a fit to the distribution of the D0 -candidate impact parameter in the plane transverse to the beam direction [60]. The corresponding systematic uncertainty 211803-4 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) is estimated to be 0.3 × 10−4 . A systematic uncertainty associated to the presence of background components peaking in mðD0 πÞ and not in mðD0 Þ is determined by fits to the mðD0 Þ distributions [60], where these components are modeled using fast simulation [64]. The main sources are the D0 → K − π þ π 0 decay for the K þ K − final state, and the D0 → π − μþ νμ and D0 → π − eþ νe decays for the π þ π − final state. Yields and raw asymmetries of the peaking-background components measured from the fits are then used as inputs to pseudoexperiments designed to evaluate the corresponding effects on the determination of ΔACP . A value of 0.5 × 10−4 is assigned as a systematic uncertainty. In the case of μ-tagged decays, the fractions of reconstructed B̄ decays can be slightly different between the K − K þ and π − π þ decay modes, which could lead to a small bias in ΔACP . Using the LHCb measurements of the b-hadron production asymmetries [50], the systematic uncertainty on ΔACP is estimated to be 1 × 10−4 . The combination of a difference in the B reconstruction efficiency as a function of the decay time between the D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ modes and the presence of neutral B-meson oscillations may also cause an imperfect cancellation of AP ðBÞ in ΔACP . The associated systematic uncertainty is estimated to be 2 × 10−4 . All individual contributions are summed in quadrature to give total systematic uncertainties on ΔACP of 0.9 × 10−4 and 5 × 10−4 for the π-tagged and μ-tagged samples, respectively. A summary of all systematic uncertainties is reported in Table I. Other possible systematic uncertainties are investigated and found to be negligible. Numerous additional robustness checks are carried out [60]. The measured value of ΔACP is studied as a function of several variables, notably including the azimuthal angle, χ 2IP , transverse momentum, and pseudorapidity of π-tagged and μ-tagged D0 mesons as well as of the tagging pions or muons; the χ 2 of the Dþ and B vertex fits; the track quality of the tagging pion; and the charged-particle multiplicity in the event. Furthermore, the total sample is split into subsamples taken in different run periods within the years TABLE I. Systematic uncertainties on ΔACP for π- and μ-tagged decays (in 10−4 ). The total uncertainties are obtained as the sums in quadrature of the individual contributions. Source Fit model Mistag Weighting Secondary decays Peaking background B fractions B reco. efficiency Total π tagged μ tagged 0.6  0.2 0.3 0.5   0.9 2 4 1   1 2 5 of data taking, also distinguishing different magnet polarities. No evidence for unexpected dependences of ΔACP is found in any of these tests. A check using more stringent PID requirements is performed, and all variations of ΔACP are found to be compatible within statistical uncertainties. An additional check concerns the measurement of ΔAbkg , that is the difference of the background raw asymmetries in K − K þ and π − π þ final states. As the prompt background is mainly composed of genuine D0 candidates paired with unrelated pions originating from the PV, ΔAbkg is expected to be compatible with zero. A value of ΔAbkg ¼ ð−2  4Þ × 10−4 is obtained. The difference of time-integrated CP asymmetries of D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays is measured using 13 TeV pp collision data collected with the LHCb detector and corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 5.9 fb−1 . The results are ΔAπ−tagged ¼ ½−18.2  3.2ðstatÞ  0.9ðsystÞ × 10−4 ; CP ¼ ½−9  8ðstatÞ  5ðsystÞ × 10−4 : ΔAμ−tagged CP Both measurements are in good agreement with world averages [65] and previous LHCb results [42,43]. By making a full combination with previous LHCb measurements [42,43], the following value of ΔACP is obtained ΔACP ¼ ð−15.4  2.9Þ × 10−4 ; where the uncertainty includes statistical and systematic contributions. The significance of the deviation from zero corresponds to 5.3 standard deviations. This is the first observation of CP violation in the decay of charm hadrons. The interpretation of ΔACP in terms of direct CP violation and AΓ requires knowledge of the difference of reconstructed mean decay times for D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays normalized to the D0 lifetime, as shown in Eq. (3). The values corresponding to the present measurements are Δhtiπ−tagged =τðD0 Þ ¼ 0.135  0.002 and Δhtiμ−tagged =τðD0 Þ ¼ −0.003  0.001, whereas that corresponding to the full combination is Δhti=τðD0 Þ ¼ 0.115  0.002. The uncertainties include statistical and systematic contributions, and the world average of the D0 lifetime is used [66]. By using in addition the LHCb average AΓ ¼ ð−2.8  2.8Þ × 10−4 [46,47], from Eq. (3), it is possible to derive −4 Δadir CP ¼ ð−15.7  2.9Þ × 10 ; which shows that, as expected, ΔACP is primarily sensitive to direct CP violation. The overall improvement in precision brought by the present analysis to the knowledge of Δadir CP is apparent when comparing with the value obtained 211803-5 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) from previous measurements, Δadir CP ¼ ð−13.4  7.0Þ × −4 10 [65]. In summary, this Letter reports the first observation of a nonzero CP asymmetry in charm decays, using large samples of D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays collected with the LHCb detector. The result is consistent with, although in magnitude at the upper end of, SM expectations, which lie in the range 10−4 − 10−3 [16–34]. In particular, the result challenges predictions based on firstprinciple QCD dynamics [19,33]. It complies with predictions based on flavor-SU(3) symmetry, if one assumes a dynamical enhancement of the penguin amplitude [16,26– 30,32]. In the next decade, further measurements with charmed particles, along with possible theoretical improvements, will help clarify the physics picture and establish whether this result is consistent with the SM or indicates the presence of new dynamics in the up-quark sector. We express our gratitude to our colleagues in the CERN accelerator departments for the excellent performance of the LHC. We thank the technical and administrative staff at the LHCb institutes. We acknowledge support from CERN and from the national agencies: CAPES, CNPq, FAPERJ, and FINEP (Brazil); MOST and NSFC (China); CNRS/ IN2P3 (France); BMBF, DFG, and MPG (Germany); INFN (Italy); NWO (Netherlands); MNiSW and NCN (Poland); MEN/IFA (Romania); MSHE (Russia); MinECo (Spain); SNSF and SER (Switzerland); NASU (Ukraine); STFC (United Kingdom); NSF (USA). We acknowledge the computing resources that are provided by CERN, IN2P3 (France), KIT, and DESY (Germany), INFN (Italy), SURF (Netherlands), PIC (Spain), GridPP (United Kingdom), RRCKI and Yandex LLC (Russia), CSCS (Switzerland), IFIN-HH (Romania), CBPF (Brazil), PL-GRID (Poland), and OSC (USA). We are indebted to the communities behind the multiple open-source software packages on which we depend. Individual groups or members have received support from AvH Foundation (Germany); EPLANET, Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions and ERC (European Union); ANR, Labex P2IO and OCEVU, and Région Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes (France); Key Research Program of Frontier Sciences of CAS, CAS PIFI, and the Thousand Talents Program (China); RFBR, RSF and Yandex LLC (Russia); GVA, XuntaGal and GENCAT (Spain); the Royal Society and the Leverhulme Trust (United Kingdom); Laboratory Directed Research and Development program of LANL (USA). [1] A. D. Sakharov, Violation of CP invariance, C asymmetry, and baryon asymmetry of the universe, Phys.-Usp. 34, 392 (1991). [2] N. Cabibbo, Unitary Symmetry and Leptonic Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10, 531 (1963). [3] M. Kobayashi and T. Maskawa, CP-violation in the renormalizable theory of weak interaction, Prog. Theor. Phys. 49, 652 (1973). [4] J. H. Christenson, J. W. Cronin, V. L. Fitch, and R. Turlay, Evidence for the 2π Decay of the K 02 Meson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 138 (1964). [5] A. Alavi-Harati et al. (KTeV Collaboration), Observation of Direct CP Violation in K S;L → ππ Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 22 (1999). [6] A. Lai et al. (NA48 Collaboration), A precise measurement of the direct CP violation parameter Reðε0 =εÞ, Eur. Phys. J. C 22, 231 (2001). [7] B. Aubert et al. (BABAR Collaboration), Observation of CP Violation in the B0 Meson System, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 091801 (2001). [8] K. Abe et al. (Belle Collaboration), Observation of Large CP Violation in the Neutral B Meson System, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 091802 (2001). [9] B. Aubert et al. (BABAR Collaboration), Direct CP Violating Asymmetry in B0 → K þ π − Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 131801 (2004). [10] Y. Chao et al. (Belle Collaboration), Evidence for Direct CP Violation in B0 → K þ π − Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 191802 (2004). [11] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), First Observation of CP Violation in the Decays of B0s Mesons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 221601 (2013). [12] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Observation of CP violation in B → DK  decays, Phys. Lett. B 712 (2012) 203; Erratum, Phys. Lett. B 713, 351(E) (2012). [13] A. G. Cohen, D. B. Kaplan, and A. E. Nelson, Progress in electroweak baryogenesis, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 43, 27 (1993). [14] A. Riotto and M. Trodden, Recent progress in baryogenesis, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 49, 35 (1999). [15] W.-S. Hou, Source of CP violation for the baryon asymmetry of the universe, Chin. J. Phys. 47, 134 (2009); arXiv:0803.1234. [16] M. Golden and B. Grinstein, Enhanced CP violations in hadronic charm decays, Phys. Lett. B 222, 501 (1989). [17] F. Buccella, M. Lusignoli, G. Miele, A. Pugliese, and P. Santorelli, Nonleptonic weak decays of charmed mesons, Phys. Rev. D 51, 3478 (1995). [18] S. Bianco, F. L. Fabbri, D. Benson, and I. Bigi, A Cicerone for the physics of charm, Riv. Nuovo Cimento 26, 1 (2003). [19] Y. Grossman, A. L. Kagan, and Y. Nir, New physics and CP violation in singly Cabibbo suppressed D decays, Phys. Rev. D 75, 036008 (2007). [20] M. Artuso, B. Meadows, and A. A. Petrov, Charm meson decays, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 58, 249 (2008). [21] J. Brod, A. L. Kagan, and J. Zupan, Size of direct CP violation in singly Cabibbo-suppressed D decays, Phys. Rev. D 86, 014023 (2012). [22] H.-Y. Cheng and C.-W. Chiang, Direct CP violation in twobody hadronic charmed meson decays, Phys. Rev. D 85, 034036 (2012); Erratum, Phys. Rev. D 85, 079903(E) (2012). [23] H.-Y. Cheng and C.-W. Chiang, SU(3) symmetry breaking and CP violation in D → PP decays, Phys. Rev. D 86, 014014 (2012). 211803-6 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) [24] H.-n. Li, C.-D. Lu, and F.-S. Yu, Branching ratios and direct CP asymmetries in D → PP decays, Phys. Rev. D 86, 036012 (2012). [25] E. Franco, S. Mishima, and L. Silvestrini, The Standard Model confronts CP violation in D0 → π þ π − and D0 → K þ K − , J. High Energy Phys. 05 (2012) 140. [26] D. Pirtskhalava and P. Uttayarat, CP violation and flavor SU(3) breaking in D-meson decays, Phys. Lett. B 712, 81 (2012). [27] T. Feldmann, S. Nandi, and A. Soni, Repercussions of flavour symmetry breaking on CP violation in D-meson decays, J. High Energy Phys. 06 (2012) 007. [28] J. Brod, Y. Grossman, A. L. Kagan, and J. Zupan, A consistent picture for large penguins in D → π þ π − ; K þ K − , J. High Energy Phys. 10 (2012) 161. [29] G. Hiller, M. Jung, and S. Schacht, SU(3)-flavor anatomy of nonleptonic charm decays, Phys. Rev. D 87, 014024 (2013). [30] Y. Grossman and D. J. Robinson, SU(3) sum rules for charm decay, J. High Energy Phys. 04 (2013) 067. [31] B. Bhattacharya, M. Gronau, and J. L. Rosner, CP asymmetries in singly-Cabibbo-suppressed D decays to two pseudoscalar mesons, Phys. Rev. D 85, 054014 (2012). [32] S. Müller, U. Nierste, and S. Schacht, Sum Rules of Charm CP Asymmetries beyond the SUð3ÞF Limit, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 251802 (2015). [33] A. Khodjamirian and A. A. Petrov, Direct CP asymmetry in D → π − π þ and D → K − K þ in QCD-based approach, Phys. Lett. B 774, 235 (2017). [34] F. Buccella, A. Paul, and P. Santorelli, On SUð3ÞF breaking through final state interactions and CP asymmetries in D → PP decays, arXiv:1902.05564 [Phys. Rev. D (to be published)]. [35] D. Atwood and A. Soni, Searching for the origin of CP violation in Cabibbo-suppressed D-meson decays, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2013, 093B05 (2013). [36] B. Aubert et al. (BABAR Collaboration), Search for CP Violation in the Decays D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ , Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 061803 (2008). [37] M. Starič et al. (Belle Collaboration), Search for a CP asymmetry in Cabibbo-suppressed D0 decays, Phys. Lett. B 670, 190 (2008). [38] T. Aaltonen et al. (CDF Collaboration), Measurement of CP-violating asymmetries in D0 → π þ π − and D0 → K þ K − decays at CDF, Phys. Rev. D 85, 012009 (2012). [39] T. Aaltonen et al. (CDF Collaboration), Measurement of the Difference of CP-Violating Asymmetries in D0 → K þ K − and D0 → π þ π − Decays at CDF, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 111801 (2012). [40] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Evidence for CP Violation in Time-Integrated D0 → h− hþ Decay Rates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 111602 (2012). [41] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Search for direct CP violation in D0 → h− hþ modes using semileptonic B decays, Phys. Lett. B 723, 33 (2013). [42] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of CP asymmetry in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays, J. High Energy Phys. 07 (2014) 041. [43] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of the Difference of Time-Integrated CP Asymmetries in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 191601 (2016). [44] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of CP asymmetry in D0 → K þ K − decays, Phys. Lett. B 767, 177 (2017). [45] M. Gersabeck, M. Alexander, S. Borghi, V. V. Gligorov, and C. Parkes, On the interplay of direct and indirect CP violation in the charm sector, J. Phys. G 39, 045005 (2012). [46] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of indirect CP asymmetries in D0 → K − K þ and D0 → π − π þ decays using semileptonic B decays, J. High Energy Phys. 04 (2015) 043. [47] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of the CP Violation Parameter AΓ in D0 → K þ K − and D0 → π þ π − Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 261803 (2017). [48] A. L. Kagan and M. D. Sokoloff, Indirect CP violation and implications for D0 –D̄0 and Bs –B̄s mixing, Phys. Rev. D 80, 076008 (2009). [49] D.-S. Du, CP violation for neutral charmed meson decays to CP eigenstates, Eur. Phys. J. C 50, 579 (2007). [50] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of B0 , B0s , Bþ and Λ0b production asymmetries in 7 and 8 TeV proton-proton collisions, Phys. Lett. B 774, 139 (2017). [51] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of the flavour-specific CP-violating asymmetry assl in B0s decays, Phys. Lett. B 728, 607 (2014). [52] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of the D production asymmetry in 7 TeV pp collisions, Phys. Lett. B 718, 902 (2013). [53] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Measurement of the − Dþ s –Ds production asymmetry in 7 TeV pp collisions, Phys. Lett. B 713, 186 (2012). [54] A. A. Alves, Jr. et al. (LHCb Collaboration), The LHCb detector at the LHC, J. Instrum. 3, S08005 (2008). [55] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), LHCb detector performance, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 30, 1530022 (2015). [56] V. V. Gligorov and M. Williams, Efficient, reliable and fast high-level triggering using a bonsai boosted decision tree, J. Instrum. 8, P02013 (2013). [57] T. Likhomanenko, P. Ilten, E. Khairullin, A. Rogozhnikov, A. Ustyuzhanin, and M. Williams, LHCb topological trigger reoptimization, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 664, 082025 (2015). [58] G. Dujany and B. Storaci, Real-time alignment and calibration of the LHCb detector in run II, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 664, 082010 (2015). [59] K. Kodama et al. (E653 Collaboration), Measurement of the Relative Branching Fraction ΓðD0 → KμνÞ=ΓðD0 → μXÞ, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 1819 (1991). [60] See Supplemental Material at http://link.aps.org/ supplemental/10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.211803 for additional numerical values and plots. [61] W. D. Hulsbergen, Decay chain fitting with a Kalman filter, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 552, 566 (2005). [62] N. L. Johnson, Systems of frequency curves generated by methods of translation, Biometrika 36, 149 (1949). 211803-7 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) [63] R. Aaij et al. (LHCb Collaboration), Updated determination of D0 − D̄0 mixing and CP violation parameters with D0 → K þ π − decays, Phys. Rev. D 97, 031101 (2018). [64] G. A. Cowan, D. C. Craik, and M. D. Needham, RapidSim: An application for the fast simulation of heavy-quark hadron decays, Comput. Phys. Commun. 214, 239 (2017). [65] Y. Amhis et al. (Heavy Flavor Averaging Group), Averages of b-hadron, c-hadron, and τ-lepton properties as of summer 2016, Eur. Phys. J. C 77, 895 (2017), updated results and plots available at https://hflav.web.cern.ch. [66] M. Tanabashi et al. (Particle Data Group), Review of particle physics, Phys. Rev. D 98, 030001 (2018). R. Aaij,28 C. Abellán Beteta,6 B. Adeva,43 M. Adinolfi,50 C. A. Aidala,77 Z. Ajaltouni,6 S. Akar,61 P. Albicocco,19 J. Albrecht,11 F. Alessio,44 M. Alexander,55 A. Alfonso Albero,42 G. Alkhazov,41 P. Alvarez Cartelle,57 A. A. Alves Jr.,43 S. Amato,2 Y. Amhis,8 L. An,18 L. Anderlini,18 G. Andreassi,45 M. Andreotti,17 J. E. Andrews,62 F. Archilli,28 P. d’Argent,13 J. Arnau Romeu,7 A. Artamonov,40 M. Artuso,63 K. Arzymatov,37 E. Aslanides,7 M. Atzeni,46 B. Audurier,23 S. Bachmann,13 J. J. Back,52 S. Baker,57 V. Balagura,8,b W. Baldini,17,44 A. Baranov,37 R. J. Barlow,58 S. Barsuk,8 W. Barter,57 M. Bartolini,20 F. Baryshnikov,74 V. Batozskaya,32 B. Batsukh,63 A. Battig,11 V. Battista,45 A. Bay,45 F. Bedeschi,25 I. Bediaga,1 A. Beiter,63 L. J. Bel,28 S. Belin,23 N. Beliy,66 V. Bellee,45 N. Belloli,21,i K. Belous,40 I. Belyaev,34 E. Ben-Haim,9 G. Bencivenni,19 S. Benson,28 S. Beranek,10 A. Berezhnoy,35 R. Bernet,46 D. Berninghoff,13 E. Bertholet,9 A. Bertolin,24 C. Betancourt,46 F. Betti,16,e M. O. Bettler,51 M. van Beuzekom,28 Ia. Bezshyiko,46 S. Bhasin,50 J. Bhom,30 M. S. Bieker,11 S. Bifani,49 P. Billoir,9 A. Birnkraut,11 A. Bizzeti,18,u M. Bjørn,59 M. P. Blago,44 T. Blake,52 F. Blanc,45 S. Blusk,63 D. Bobulska,55 V. Bocci,27 O. Boente Garcia,43 T. Boettcher,60 A. Bondar,39,x N. Bondar,41 S. Borghi,58,44 M. Borisyak,37 M. Borsato,13 M. Boubdir,10 T. J. V. Bowcock,56 C. Bozzi,17,44 S. Braun,13 M. Brodski,44 J. Brodzicka,30 A. Brossa Gonzalo,52 D. Brundu,23,44 E. Buchanan,50 A. Buonaura,46 C. Burr,58 A. Bursche,23 J. Buytaert,44 W. Byczynski,44 S. Cadeddu,23 H. Cai,68 R. Calabrese,17,g S. Cali,17 R. Calladine,49 M. Calvi,21,i M. Calvo Gomez,42,m A. Camboni,42,m P. Campana,19 D. H. Campora Perez,44 L. Capriotti,16,e A. Carbone,16,e G. Carboni,26 R. Cardinale,20 A. Cardini,23 P. Carniti,21,i K. Carvalho Akiba,2 G. Casse,56 M. Cattaneo,44 G. Cavallero,20 R. Cenci,25,p M. G. Chapman,50 M. Charles,9,44 Ph. Charpentier,44 G. Chatzikonstantinidis,49 M. Chefdeville,5 V. Chekalina,37 C. Chen,3 S. Chen,23 S.-G. Chitic,44 V. Chobanova,43 M. Chrzaszcz,44 A. Chubykin,41 P. Ciambrone,19 X. Cid Vidal,43 G. Ciezarek,44 F. Cindolo,16 P. E. L. Clarke,54 M. Clemencic,44 H. V. Cliff,51 J. Closier,44 V. Coco,44 J. A. B. Coelho,8 J. Cogan,7 E. Cogneras,6 L. Cojocariu,33 P. Collins,44 T. Colombo,44 A. Comerma-Montells,13 A. Contu,23 G. Coombs,44 S. Coquereau,42 G. Corti,44 C. M. Costa Sobral,52 B. Couturier,44 G. A. Cowan,54 D. C. Craik,60 A. Crocombe,52 M. Cruz Torres,1 R. Currie,54 C. D’Ambrosio,44 C. L. Da Silva,78 E. Dall’Occo,28 J. Dalseno,43,v A. Danilina,34 A. Davis,58 O. De Aguiar Francisco,44 K. De Bruyn,44 S. De Capua,58 M. De Cian,45 J. M. De Miranda,1 L. De Paula,2 M. De Serio,15,d P. De Simone,19 C. T. Dean,55 W. Dean,77 D. Decamp,5 L. Del Buono,9 B. Delaney,51 H.-P. Dembinski,12 M. Demmer,11 A. Dendek,31 D. Derkach,38 O. Deschamps,6 F. Desse,8 F. Dettori,23 B. Dey,69 A. Di Canto,44 P. Di Nezza,19 S. Didenko,74 H. Dijkstra,44 F. Dordei,23 M. Dorigo,25,y A. Dosil Suárez,43 L. Douglas,55 A. Dovbnya,47 K. Dreimanis,56 L. Dufour,44 G. Dujany,9 P. Durante,44 J. M. Durham,78 D. Dutta,58 R. Dzhelyadin,40,† M. Dziewiecki,13 A. Dziurda,30 A. Dzyuba,41 S. Easo,53 U. Egede,57 V. Egorychev,34 S. Eidelman,39,x S. Eisenhardt,54 U. Eitschberger,11 R. Ekelhof,11 L. Eklund,55 S. Ely,63 A. Ene,33 S. Escher,10 S. Esen,28 T. Evans,61 A. Falabella,16 N. Farley,49 S. Farry,56 D. Fazzini,21,i P. Fernandez Declara,44 A. Fernandez Prieto,43 F. Ferrari,16,e L. Ferreira Lopes,45 F. Ferreira Rodrigues,2 S. Ferreres Sole,28 M. Ferro-Luzzi,44 S. Filippov,36 R. A. Fini,15 M. Fiorini,17,g M. Firlej,31 C. Fitzpatrick,44 T. Fiutowski,31 F. Fleuret,8,b M. Fontana,44 F. Fontanelli,20,h R. Forty,44 V. Franco Lima,56 M. Frank,44 C. Frei,44 J. Fu,22,q W. Funk,44 C. Färber,44 M. Féo,44 E. Gabriel,54 A. Gallas Torreira,43 D. Galli,16,e S. Gallorini,24 S. Gambetta,54 Y. Gan,3 M. Gandelman,2 P. Gandini,22 Y. Gao,3 L. M. Garcia Martin,76 B. Garcia Plana,43 J. García Pardiñas,46 J. Garra Tico,51 L. Garrido,42 D. Gascon,42 C. Gaspar,44 G. Gazzoni,6 D. Gerick,13 E. Gersabeck,58 M. Gersabeck,58 T. Gershon,52 D. Gerstel,7 Ph. Ghez,5 V. Gibson,51 O. G. Girard,45 P. Gironella Gironell,42 L. Giubega,33 K. Gizdov,54 V. V. Gligorov,9 D. Golubkov,34 A. Golutvin,57,74 A. Gomes,1,a I. V. Gorelov,35 C. Gotti,21,i E. Govorkova,28 J. P. Grabowski,13 R. Graciani Diaz,42 L. A. Granado Cardoso,44 E. Graugés,42 E. Graverini,46 G. Graziani,18 A. Grecu,33 R. Greim,28 P. Griffith,23 L. Grillo,58 L. Gruber,44 B. R. Gruberg Cazon,59 C. Gu,3 X. Guo,67 E. Gushchin,36 A. Guth,10 Yu. Guz,40,44 T. Gys,44 C. Göbel,65 T. Hadavizadeh,59 C. Hadjivasiliou,6 G. Haefeli,45 C. Haen,44 S. C. Haines,51 B. Hamilton,62 Q. Han,69 X. Han,13 T. H. Hancock,59 S. Hansmann-Menzemer,13 N. Harnew,59 T. Harrison,56 C. Hasse,44 M. Hatch,44 J. He,66 M. Hecker,57 K. Heinicke,11 211803-8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) A. Heister,11 K. Hennessy,56 L. Henry,76 E. van Herwijnen,44 J. Heuel,10 M. Heß,71 A. Hicheur,64 R. Hidalgo Charman,58 D. Hill,59 M. Hilton,58 P. H. Hopchev,45 J. Hu,13 W. Hu,69 W. Huang,66 Z. C. Huard,61 W. Hulsbergen,28 T. Humair,57 M. Hushchyn,38 D. Hutchcroft,56 D. Hynds,28 P. Ibis,11 M. Idzik,31 P. Ilten,49 A. Inglessi,41 A. Inyakin,40 K. Ivshin,41 R. Jacobsson,44 S. Jakobsen,44 J. Jalocha,59 E. Jans,28 B. K. Jashal,76 A. Jawahery,62 F. Jiang,3 M. John,59 D. Johnson,44 C. R. Jones,51 C. Joram,44 B. Jost,44 N. Jurik,59 S. Kandybei,47 M. Karacson,44 J. M. Kariuki,50 S. Karodia,55 N. Kazeev,38 M. Kecke,13 F. Keizer,51 M. Kelsey,63 M. Kenzie,51 T. Ketel,29 B. Khanji,44 A. Kharisova,75 C. Khurewathanakul,45 K. E. Kim,63 T. Kirn,10 V. S. Kirsebom,45 S. Klaver,19 K. Klimaszewski,32 S. Koliiev,48 M. Kolpin,13 R. Kopecna,13 P. Koppenburg,28 I. Kostiuk,28,48 S. Kotriakhova,41 M. Kozeiha,6 L. Kravchuk,36 M. Kreps,52 F. Kress,57 S. Kretzschmar,10 P. Krokovny,39,x W. Krupa,31 W. Krzemien,32 W. Kucewicz,30,l M. Kucharczyk,30 V. Kudryavtsev,39,x G. J. Kunde,78 A. K. Kuonen,45 T. Kvaratskheliya,34 D. Lacarrere,44 G. Lafferty,58 A. Lai,23 D. Lancierini,46 G. Lanfranchi,19 C. Langenbruch,10 T. Latham,52 C. Lazzeroni,49 R. Le Gac,7 A. Leflat,35 R. Lefèvre,6 F. Lemaitre,44 O. Leroy,7 T. Lesiak,30 B. Leverington,13 H. Li,67 P.-R. Li,66,ab X. Li,78 Y. Li,4 Z. Li,63 X. Liang,63 T. Likhomanenko,73 R. Lindner,44 P. Ling,67 F. Lionetto,46 V. Lisovskyi,8 G. Liu,67 X. Liu,3 D. Loh,52 A. Loi,23 I. Longstaff,55 J. H. Lopes,2 G. Loustau,46 G. H. Lovell,51 D. Lucchesi,24,o M. Lucio Martinez,43 Y. Luo,3 A. Lupato,24 E. Luppi,17,g O. Lupton,52 A. Lusiani,25 X. Lyu,66 R. Ma,67 F. Machefert,8 F. Maciuc,33 V. Macko,45 P. Mackowiak,11 S. Maddrell-Mander,50 O. Maev,41,44 K. Maguire,58 D. Maisuzenko,41 M. W. Majewski,31 S. Malde,59 B. Malecki,44 A. Malinin,73 T. Maltsev,39,x H. Malygina,13 G. Manca,23,f G. Mancinelli,7 D. Marangotto,22,q J. Maratas,6,w J. F. Marchand,5 U. Marconi,16 C. Marin Benito,8 M. Marinangeli,45 P. Marino,45 J. Marks,13 P. J. Marshall,56 G. Martellotti,27 M. Martinelli,44,21 D. Martinez Santos,43 F. Martinez Vidal,76 A. Massafferri,1 M. Materok,10 R. Matev,44 A. Mathad,46 Z. Mathe,44 V. Matiunin,34 C. Matteuzzi,21 K. R. Mattioli,77 A. Mauri,46 E. Maurice,8,b B. Maurin,45 M. McCann,57,44 A. McNab,58 R. McNulty,14 J. V. Mead,56 B. Meadows,61 C. Meaux,7 N. Meinert,71 D. Melnychuk,32 M. Merk,28 A. Merli,22,q E. Michielin,24 D. A. Milanes,70 E. Millard,52 M.-N. Minard,5 L. Minzoni,17,g D. S. Mitzel,13 A. Mogini,9 R. D. Moise,57 T. Mombächer,11 I. A. Monroy,70 S. Monteil,6 M. Morandin,24 G. Morello,19 M. J. Morello,25,t J. Moron,31 A. B. Morris,7 R. Mountain,63 F. Muheim,54 M. Mukherjee,69 M. Mulder,28 C. H. Murphy,59 D. Murray,58 A. Mödden,11 D. Müller,44 J. Müller,11 K. Müller,46 V. Müller,11 P. Naik,50 T. Nakada,45 R. Nandakumar,53 A. Nandi,59 T. Nanut,45 I. Nasteva,2 M. Needham,54 N. Neri,22,q S. Neubert,13 N. Neufeld,44 R. Newcombe,57 T. D. Nguyen,45 C. Nguyen-Mau,45,n S. Nieswand,10 R. Niet,11 N. Nikitin,35 N. S. Nolte,44 D. P. O’Hanlon,16 A. Oblakowska-Mucha,31 V. Obraztsov,40 S. Ogilvy,55 R. Oldeman,23,f C. J. G. Onderwater,72 J. D. Osborn,77 A. Ossowska,30 J. M. Otalora Goicochea,2 T. Ovsiannikova,34 P. Owen,46 A. Oyanguren,76 P. R. Pais,45 T. Pajero,25,t A. Palano,15 M. Palutan,19 G. Panshin,75 A. Papanestis,53 M. Pappagallo,54 L. L. Pappalardo,17,g W. Parker,62 C. Parkes,58,44 G. Passaleva,18,44 A. Pastore,15 M. Patel,57 C. Patrignani,16,e A. Pearce,44 A. Pellegrino,28 G. Penso,27 M. Pepe Altarelli,44 S. Perazzini,16 D. Pereima,34 P. Perret,6 L. Pescatore,45 K. Petridis,50 A. Petrolini,20,h A. Petrov,73 S. Petrucci,54 M. Petruzzo,22,q B. Pietrzyk,5 G. Pietrzyk,45 M. Pikies,30 M. Pili,59 D. Pinci,27 J. Pinzino,44 F. Pisani,44 A. Piucci,13 V. Placinta,33 S. Playfer,54 J. Plews,49 M. Plo Casasus,43 F. Polci,9 M. Poli Lener,19 M. Poliakova,63 A. Poluektov,7 N. Polukhina,74,c I. Polyakov,63 E. Polycarpo,2 G. J. Pomery,50 S. Ponce,44 A. Popov,40 D. Popov,49,12 S. Poslavskii,40 E. Price,50 C. Prouve,43 V. Pugatch,48 A. Puig Navarro,46 H. Pullen,59 G. Punzi,25,p W. Qian,66 J. Qin,66 R. Quagliani,9 B. Quintana,6 N. V. Raab,14 B. Rachwal,31 J. H. Rademacker,50 M. Rama,25 M. Ramos Pernas,43 M. S. Rangel,2 F. Ratnikov,37,38 G. Raven,29 M. Ravonel Salzgeber,44 M. Reboud,5 F. Redi,45 S. Reichert,11 A. C. dos Reis,1 F. Reiss,9 C. Remon Alepuz,76 Z. Ren,3 V. Renaudin,59 S. Ricciardi,53 S. Richards,50 K. Rinnert,56 P. Robbe,8 A. Robert,9 A. B. Rodrigues,45 E. Rodrigues,61 J. A. Rodriguez Lopez,70 M. Roehrken,44 S. Roiser,44 A. Rollings,59 V. Romanovskiy,40 A. Romero Vidal,43 J. D. Roth,77 M. Rotondo,19 M. S. Rudolph,63 T. Ruf,44 J. Ruiz Vidal,76 J. J. Saborido Silva,43 N. Sagidova,41 B. Saitta,23,f V. Salustino Guimaraes,65 C. Sanchez Gras,28 C. Sanchez Mayordomo,76 B. Sanmartin Sedes,43 R. Santacesaria,27 C. Santamarina Rios,43 M. Santimaria,19,44 E. Santovetti,26,j G. Sarpis,58 A. Sarti,19,k C. Satriano,27,s A. Satta,26 M. Saur,66 D. Savrina,34,35 S. Schael,10 M. Schellenberg,11 M. Schiller,55 H. Schindler,44 M. Schmelling,12 T. Schmelzer,11 B. Schmidt,44 O. Schneider,45 A. Schopper,44 H. F. Schreiner,61 M. Schubiger,45 S. Schulte,45 M. H. Schune,8 R. Schwemmer,44 B. Sciascia,19 A. Sciubba,27,k A. Semennikov,34 E. S. Sepulveda,9 A. Sergi,49,44 N. Serra,46 J. Serrano,7 L. Sestini,24 A. Seuthe,11 P. Seyfert,44 M. Shapkin,40 T. Shears,56 L. Shekhtman,39,x V. Shevchenko,73 E. Shmanin,74 B. G. Siddi,17 R. Silva Coutinho,46 L. Silva de Oliveira,2 G. Simi,24,o S. Simone,15,d I. Skiba,17 N. Skidmore,13 T. Skwarnicki,63 M. W. Slater,49 J. G. Smeaton,51 E. Smith,10 I. T. Smith,54 M. Smith,57 M. Soares,16 l. Soares Lavra,1 M. D. Sokoloff,61 F. J. P. Soler,55 B. Souza De Paula,2 B. Spaan,11 E. Spadaro Norella,22,q P. Spradlin,55 F. Stagni,44 211803-9 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) M. Stahl,13 S. Stahl,44 P. Stefko,45 S. Stefkova,57 O. Steinkamp,46 S. Stemmle,13 O. Stenyakin,40 M. Stepanova,41 H. Stevens,11 A. Stocchi,8 S. Stone,63 S. Stracka,25 M. E. Stramaglia,45 M. Straticiuc,33 U. Straumann,46 S. Strokov,75 J. Sun,3 L. Sun,68 Y. Sun,62 K. Swientek,31 A. Szabelski,32 T. Szumlak,31 M. Szymanski,66 S. T’Jampens,5 Z. Tang,3 T. Tekampe,11 G. Tellarini,17 F. Teubert,44 E. Thomas,44 J. van Tilburg,28 M. J. Tilley,57 V. Tisserand,6 M. Tobin,4 S. Tolk,44 L. Tomassetti,17,g D. Tonelli,25 D. Y. Tou,9 R. Tourinho Jadallah Aoude,1 E. Tournefier,5 M. Traill,55 M. T. Tran,45 A. Trisovic,51 A. Tsaregorodtsev,7 G. Tuci,25,44,p A. Tully,51 N. Tuning,28 A. Ukleja,32 A. Usachov,8 A. Ustyuzhanin,37,38 U. Uwer,13 A. Vagner,75 V. Vagnoni,16 A. Valassi,44 S. Valat,44 G. Valenti,16 H. Van Hecke,78 C. B. Van Hulse,14 R. Vazquez Gomez,44 P. Vazquez Regueiro,43 S. Vecchi,17 M. van Veghel,28 J. J. Velthuis,50 M. Veltri,18,r A. Venkateswaran,63 M. Vernet,6 M. Veronesi,28 M. Vesterinen,52 J. V. Viana Barbosa,44 D. Vieira,66 M. Vieites Diaz,43 H. Viemann,71 X. Vilasis-Cardona,42,m A. Vitkovskiy,28 M. Vitti,51 V. Volkov,35 A. Vollhardt,46 D. Vom Bruch,9 B. Voneki,44 A. Vorobyev,41 V. Vorobyev,39,x N. Voropaev,41 J. A. de Vries,28 C. Vázquez Sierra,28 R. Waldi,71 J. Walsh,25 J. Wang,4 M. Wang,3 Y. Wang,69 Z. Wang,46 D. R. Ward,51 H. M. Wark,56 N. K. Watson,49 D. Websdale,57 A. Weiden,46 C. Weisser,60 M. Whitehead,10 G. Wilkinson,59 M. Wilkinson,63 I. Williams,51 M. R. J. Williams,58 M. Williams,60 T. Williams,49 F. F. Wilson,53 M. Winn,8 W. Wislicki,32 M. Witek,30 G. Wormser,8 S. A. Wotton,51 K. Wyllie,44 D. Xiao,69 Y. Xie,69 H. Xing,67 A. Xu,3 M. Xu,69 Q. Xu,66 Z. Xu,3 Z. Xu,5 Z. Yang,3 Z. Yang,62 Y. Yao,63 L. E. Yeomans,56 H. Yin,69 J. Yu,69,aa X. Yuan,63 O. Yushchenko,40 K. A. Zarebski,49 M. Zavertyaev,12,c M. Zeng,3 D. Zhang,69 L. Zhang,3 W. C. Zhang,3,z Y. Zhang,44 A. Zhelezov,13 Y. Zheng,66 X. Zhu,3 V. Zhukov,10,35 J. B. Zonneveld,54 and S. Zucchelli16,e (LHCb Collaboration) 1 Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Físicas (CBPF), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 3 Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China 4 Institute Of High Energy Physics (ihep), Beijing, China 5 Univ. Grenoble Alpes, Univ. Savoie Mont Blanc, CNRS, IN2P3-LAPP, Annecy, France 6 Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS/IN2P3, LPC, Clermont-Ferrand, France 7 Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS/IN2P3, CPPM, Marseille, France 8 LAL, Univ. Paris-Sud, CNRS/IN2P3, Université Paris-Saclay, Orsay, France 9 LPNHE, Sorbonne Université, Paris Diderot Sorbonne Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris, France 10 I. Physikalisches Institut, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany 11 Fakultät Physik, Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany 12 Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik (MPIK), Heidelberg, Germany 13 Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany 14 School of Physics, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland 15 INFN Sezione di Bari, Bari, Italy 16 INFN Sezione di Bologna, Bologna, Italy 17 INFN Sezione di Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy 18 INFN Sezione di Firenze, Firenze, Italy 19 INFN Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati, Italy 20 INFN Sezione di Genova, Genova, Italy 21 INFN Sezione di Milano-Bicocca, Milano, Italy 22 INFN Sezione di Milano, Milano, Italy 23 INFN Sezione di Cagliari, Monserrato, Italy 24 INFN Sezione di Padova, Padova, Italy 25 INFN Sezione di Pisa, Pisa, Italy 26 INFN Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata, Roma, Italy 27 INFN Sezione di Roma La Sapienza, Roma, Italy 28 Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics, Amsterdam, Netherlands 29 Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics and VU University Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands 30 Henryk Niewodniczanski Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences, Kraków, Poland 31 AGH—University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, Kraków, Poland 32 National Center for Nuclear Research (NCBJ), Warsaw, Poland 33 Horia Hulubei National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest-Magurele, Romania 34 Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics NRC Kurchatov Institute (ITEP NRC KI), Moscow, Russia, Moscow, Russia 35 Institute of Nuclear Physics, Moscow State University (SINP MSU), Moscow, Russia 36 Institute for Nuclear Research of the Russian Academy of Sciences (INR RAS), Moscow, Russia 2 211803-10 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) 37 Yandex School of Data Analysis, Moscow, Russia National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia 39 Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics (SB RAS), Novosibirsk, Russia 40 Institute for High Energy Physics NRC Kurchatov Institute (IHEP NRC KI), Protvino, Russia, Protvino, Russia 41 Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute NRC Kurchatov Institute (PNPI NRC KI), Gatchina, Russia, St.Petersburg, Russia 42 ICCUB, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain 43 Instituto Galego de Física de Altas Enerxías (IGFAE), Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, Spain 44 European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), Geneva, Switzerland 45 Institute of Physics, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Lausanne, Switzerland 46 Physik-Institut, Universität Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland 47 NSC Kharkiv Institute of Physics and Technology (NSC KIPT), Kharkiv, Ukraine 48 Institute for Nuclear Research of the National Academy of Sciences (KINR), Kyiv, Ukraine 49 University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom 50 H.H. Wills Physics Laboratory, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom 51 Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom 52 Department of Physics, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom 53 STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Didcot, United Kingdom 54 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom 55 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United Kingdom 56 Oliver Lodge Laboratory, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom 57 Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom 58 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom 59 Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom 60 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA 61 University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA 62 University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland, USA 63 Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, USA 64 Laboratory of Mathematical and Subatomic Physics, Constantine, Algeria [associated with Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil] 65 Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio de Janeiro (PUC-Rio), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil [associated with Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil] 66 University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China (associated with Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China) 67 South China Normal University, Guangzhou, China (associated with Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China) 68 School of Physics and Technology, Wuhan University, Wuhan, China (associated with Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China) 69 Institute of Particle Physics, Central China Normal University, Wuhan, Hubei, China (associated with Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China) 70 Departamento de Fisica, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogota, Colombia (associated with LPNHE, Sorbonne Université, Paris Diderot Sorbonne Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris, France) 71 Institut für Physik, Universität Rostock, Rostock, Germany (associated with Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany) 72 Van Swinderen Institute, University of Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands (associated with Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics, Amsterdam, Netherlands) 73 National Research Centre Kurchatov Institute, Moscow, Russia (associated with Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics NRC Kurchatov Institute (ITEP NRC KI), Moscow, Russia, Moscow, Russia) 74 National University of Science and Technology “MISIS”, Moscow, Russia (associated with Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics NRC Kurchatov Institute (ITEP NRC KI), Moscow, Russia, Moscow, Russia) 75 National Research Tomsk Polytechnic University, Tomsk, Russia (associated with Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics NRC Kurchatov Institute (ITEP NRC KI), Moscow, Russia, Moscow, Russia) 76 Instituto de Fisica Corpuscular, Centro Mixto Universidad de Valencia—CSIC, Valencia, Spain (associated with ICCUB, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain) 77 University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA (associated with Institution Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, USA) 78 Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), Los Alamos, New Mexico, USA (associated with Institution Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, USA) 38 211803-11 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 122, 211803 (2019) † Deceased. Also at Universidade Federal do Triângulo Mineiro (UFTM), Uberaba-MG, Brazil. b Also at Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet, Palaiseau, France. c Also at P.N. Lebedev Physical Institute, Russian Academy of Science (LPI RAS), Moscow, Russia. d Also at Università di Bari, Bari, Italy. e Also at Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy. f Also at Università di Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy. g Also at Università di Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy. h Also at Università di Genova, Genova, Italy. i Also at Università di Milano Bicocca, Milano, Italy. j Also at Università di Roma Tor Vergata, Roma, Italy. k Also at Università di Roma La Sapienza, Roma, Italy. l Also at AGH - University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Computer Science, Electronics and Telecommunications, Kraków, Poland. m Also at LIFAELS, La Salle, Universitat Ramon Llull, Barcelona, Spain. n Also at Hanoi University of Science, Hanoi, Vietnam. o Also at Università di Padova, Padova, Italy. p Also at Università di Pisa, Pisa, Italy. q Also at Università degli Studi di Milano, Milano, Italy. r Also at Università di Urbino, Urbino, Italy. s Also at Università della Basilicata, Potenza, Italy. t Also at Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy. u Also at Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy. v Also at H.H. Wills Physics Laboratory, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom. w Also at MSU - Iligan Institute of Technology (MSU-IIT), Iligan, Philippines. x Also at Novosibirsk State University, Novosibirsk, Russia. y Also at Sezione INFN di Trieste, Trieste, Italy. z Also at School of Physics and Information Technology, Shaanxi Normal University (SNNU), Xi’an, China. aa Also at Physics and Micro Electronic College, Hunan University, Changsha City, China. ab Also at Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, China. a 211803-12