PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 121, 121801 (2018) Editors' Suggestion Featured in Physics Observation of Higgs Boson Decay to Bottom Quarks A. M. Sirunyan et al.* (CMS Collaboration) (Received 24 August 2018; published 17 September 2018) The observation of the standard model (SM) Higgs boson decay to a pair of bottom quarks is presented. The main contribution to this result is from processes in which Higgs bosons are produced in association with a W or Z boson (VH), and are searched for in final states including 0, 1, or 2 charged leptons and two identified bottom quark jets. The results from the measurement of these processes in a data sample recorded pffiffiffi by the CMS experiment in 2017, comprising 41.3 fb−1 of proton-proton collisions at s ¼ 13 TeV, are pffiffiffi described. When combined with previous VH measurements using data collected at s ¼ 7, 8, and 13 TeV, an excess of events is observed at mH ¼ 125 GeV with a significance of 4.8 standard deviations, where the expectation for the SM Higgs boson is 4.9. The corresponding measured signal strength is 1.01  0.22. The combination of this result with searches by the CMS experiment for H → bb̄ in other production processes yields an observed (expected) significance of 5.6 (5.5) standard deviations and a signal strength of 1.04  0.20. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.121.121801 Since the discovery of a new boson with a mass near 125 GeV by the ATLAS [1] and CMS [2,3] Collaborations, rapid progress in the understanding of its properties and couplings has revealed that the new particle is compatible with the standard model (SM) Higgs boson H [4–9]. Observation of Higgs boson decays in the γγ, ZZ, WW, and ττ modes have been reported [10–20], and all measured properties [21–29] support this hypothesis. Recently, the CMS and ATLAS Collaborations reported observations of the Higgs boson produced in association with a top quark pair that are compatible with the SM prediction, representing the first direct measurements of the Higgs boson coupling to quarks [30,31]. The decay H → bb̄, with a predicted branching fraction of about 58% [32] for a Higgs boson mass of mH ¼ 125 GeV, is the most prevalent decay mode but has not yet been established unequivocally. A precise measurement of the rate for this process directly probes the Yukawa coupling of the Higgs boson to a down-type quark, and provides a necessary test of the hypothesis that the Higgs field is the source of mass generation in the charged fermion sector of the SM [33,34]. At both the LHC and the Tevatron the most sensitive production process in the search for H → bb̄ decays is when the Higgs boson is produced in association with a vector boson (VH). The * Full author list given at the end of the article. Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. Funded by SCOAP3. 0031-9007=18=121(12)=121801(20) CDF and D0 Collaborations at the Tevatron reported an excess of events in this channel with a significance of 2.8 standard deviations (σ) at a mass of mH ¼ 125 GeV [35]. Last year, the ATLAS and CMS Collaborations reported evidence for the VH, H → bb̄ process at a mass of mH ¼ 125 GeV corresponding to observed (expected) significances of 3.6 ð4.0Þσ and 3.8 ð3.8Þσ, respectively, pffiffiffi combining data collected during run 1 at s ¼ 7 and 8 TeV, and run 2 at 13 TeV [36,37]. Searches for the H → bb̄ decay in other production processes, with less sensitivity than VH, have also been reported at the LHC [38–44]. In this Letter we present the observation of the Higgs boson decay to bottom quarks. The measurement described here examines the VH production process, where the Higgs boson is produced in association with a W or Z boson and decays into bb̄. The data comprise proton-proton (pp) pffiffiffi collisions recorded at s ¼ 13 TeV by the CMS detector at the LHC in 2017, corresponding to a total integrated luminosity of 41.3 fb−1 [45]. Five distinct final states are considered: ZðννÞH, WðμνÞH, WðeνÞH, ZðμμÞH, and ZðeeÞH, corresponding to three channels with 0, 1, or 2 charged leptons from the vector boson decay. In addition, two identified jets due to hadronization of bottom quarks (b jets) from the Higgs boson decay are required. Important background processes include the production of W and Z bosons in association with jets (V þ jets), production of top quark pairs (tt̄) and single top quarks (t), diboson (WW, WZ, ZZ), and multijet (QCD) events. The analysis presented here closely follows the methods previously used to search for the VH, H → bb̄ process [37] and incorporates several improvements, including more 121801-1 © 2018 CERN, for the CMS Collaboration PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 121, 121801 (2018) efficient identification of b jets, better dijet mass resolution, and the use of different multivariate discriminant techniques that better separate signal from background. For each channel, a signal region enriched in VH events is selected together with several control regions, each enriched in events from individual background processes. A simultaneous binned-likelihood fit to the shape and yield (normalization) of specific distributions for the signal and control regions for all channels combined is used to extract a possible Higgs boson signal. To validate the procedure, the same methodology is used to extract a signal for the associated production process VZ, with Z → bb̄, which has an identical final state to VH with H → bb̄, but with a production cross section 5 to 15 times larger, depending on the kinematic regime considered. The result from this measurement is combined with those of similar measurements performed by the CMS Collaboration using 2016 data and run 1 data, in the VH and other production processes. This combination leads to an observation of the Higgs boson decay to bottom quarks. An observation of this decay mode by the ATLAS Collaboration [46] was submitted for publication at the same time as this Letter. The central feature of the CMS apparatus is a superconducting solenoid of 6 m internal diameter, providing a magnetic field of 3.8 T. A silicon pixel and strip tracker, a lead tungstate crystal electromagnetic calorimeter, and a brass and scintillator hadron calorimeter, each composed of a barrel and two end cap sections, reside within the solenoid. Forward calorimeters extend the pseudorapidity coverage provided by the barrel and end cap detectors. Muons are detected in gas-ionization chambers embedded in the steel flux-return yoke outside the solenoid. A more detailed description of the CMS detector, together with a definition of the coordinate system and the relevant kinematic variables, can be found in Ref. [47]. Signal and background processes are simulated with several Monte Carlo (MC) event generators, while the CMS detector response is modeled with GEANT4 [48]. The quarkinduced ZH and WH signal processes are generated at nextto-leading order (NLO) QCD accuracy using the POWHEG v2 [49–51] event generator extended with the MiNLO procedure [52,53], while the gluon-induced ZH process is generated at leading order (LO) accuracy with POWHEG v2. The Higgs boson mass is set to 125 GeV for all signal samples. Diboson background events are generated with MADGRAPH 5_AMC@NLO v2.4.2 [54] at NLO with the FxFx merging scheme [55] and up to two additional partons. The same generator is used at LO accuracy with the MLM matching scheme [56] to generate V þ jets events in inclusive and b-quark enriched configurations with up to four additional partons, and to generate a sample of QCD events. The tt̄ [57] and single t production processes in the tW [58] and t [59] channels are generated to NLO accuracy with POWHEG v2, while the s channel [60] single t process is generated with MADGRAPH 5_AMC@NLO v2.4.2. The parton distribution functions used to produce all samples are the next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) NNPDF3.1 set [61]. For parton showering and hadronization, the matrix element generators are interfaced with PYTHIA v8.230 [62]. For all samples, simulated additional pp interactions (pileup) are added to the hard-scattering process with the multiplicity distribution matched to the 2017 data. The production cross sections for the signal samples are rescaled as a function of the vector boson transverse momentum, pT ðVÞ, to NNLO QCD þ NLO electroweak accuracy combining the VHNNLO [63–66], VH@NNLO [67,68], and HAWK v2.0 [69] generators as described in Ref. [32]. The production cross sections for the tt̄ samples are rescaled to the NNLO prediction with the next-to-nextto-leading-log result obtained from TOP++ v2.0 [70], while the V þ jets samples are rescaled to the NNLO cross sections using FEWZ 3.1 [71]. In the V þ jets samples used in this analysis, the pT ðVÞ spectrum in data is observed to be softer than in simulated samples, as expected from higherorder electroweak corrections to the production processes [72]. Events in each channel are reweighted to account for electroweak corrections to pT ðVÞ, which reach up to 10% for pT ðVÞ near 400 GeV. In addition, a differential LO-toNLO correction is applied as a function of the separation in η between the two jets from the Higgs boson decay [37]. The tt̄ samples are reweighted as a function of top quark pT to account for the known difference between data and simulation [73]. The CMS particle-flow (PF) event algorithm [74] is used to reconstruct and identify individual particles (PF objects) with an optimized combination of information from the various elements of the CMS detector. This algorithm is employed at the trigger level, and in the more detailed reconstruction of data that occurs off-line. The objects identified by the algorithm comprise candidate electrons, muons, photons, and charged as well as neutral hadrons. Jets are reconstructed from PF objects using the anti-kt clustering algorithm [75] implemented in the FASTJET package [76,77], with a distance parameter of 0.4. The missing transverse momentum vector ⃗pmiss is defined as the T negative vectorial pT sum of all the PF objects identified in the event, and its magnitude is referred to as pmiss T . The reconstructed vertex with the largest value of summed physics-object pT 2 is considered to be the primary pp interaction vertex. The physics objects used in this calculation are jets clustered using the jet finding algorithm with the tracks assigned to the vertex as inputs, and the associated missing transverse momentum computed as the negative vectorial pT sum of those jets. All charged hadrons that originate from pileup are removed from consideration in the event. In addition, the average neutral energy density from pileup is evaluated from PF objects and subtracted from the reconstructed jets as well as from the summed energy in the vicinity of leptons (isolation), as described in Ref. [74]. 121801-2 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 121, 121801 (2018) Events of interest are selected on-line using a two-tiered trigger system [78] based on custom hardware processors and a farm of commercial processors running a version of the full off-line reconstruction software optimized for speed. Events in the 0-lepton channel are selected primarily by a trigger requiring both pT miss and H miss to be larger than T miss 120 GeV, where H T is defined as the magnitude of the negative vectorial pT sum of all jets. Single-lepton triggers are used to select events in the 1-lepton channel, where the leptons are required to be isolated from other PF objects. The single-muon trigger requires pT > 27 GeV, while the single-electron trigger requires pT > 32 GeV. For the 2-lepton channel, dilepton triggers are employed with minimum pT requirements of (17, 8) GeV for the two muons and (23, 12) GeV for the two electrons. After offline requirements, the 0-lepton trigger efficiency reaches 100% above pmiss ∼ 220 GeV, while the 1-lepton triggers T have efficiencies of approximately 95% for muons and 90% for electrons, and the dilepton trigger efficiency is approximately 91% for muons and 96% for electrons. Events are selected off-line based on the presence of 0, 1, or 2 leptons (muons or electrons) and two identified b jets. Muons and electrons from W or Z boson decays are identified using the selection criteria defined in Ref. [37], including stringent quality and isolation requirements. The lepton pT requirements are pT > 25ð30Þ GeV for muons (electrons) in the 1-lepton channel, and pT > 20 GeV for each lepton in the 2-lepton channel. In the 0- and 1-lepton channels, events with additional isolated muons or electrons are rejected. Minimum pT requirements of (60, 35), (25, 25), and (20, 20) GeV are applied on the two jets forming the Higgs boson candidate in the 0-, 1-, and 2-lepton channels, respectively, which are also required to satisfy jηj < 2.5. The reconstruction of vector boson decays differs by channel. In the 0-lepton channel, pT miss is interpreted as the pT of the Z boson, while in the 2-lepton channel the Z boson is reconstructed directly from lepton pairs requiring an invariant mass in the range 75–105 GeV. In the 1-lepton channel, the W boson candidate is reconstructed from the ⃗pT of the single isolated lepton and ⃗pmiss T . Higgs boson candidates are reconstructed from the pair of jets (“jj”) in the event most likely to originate from b quarks, as determined by a combined secondary vertex algorithm (deepCSV) based on a deep neural network discriminant (DNN) [79]. The deepCSValgorithm provides a continuous discriminator score combining information about tracks displaced from the primary vertex, identified secondary vertices, jet kinematic variables, and information related to the presence of soft leptons in the jet. Of the two jets forming the Higgs boson candidate, the one with a larger deepCSV score is required to satisfy a tight working point with misidentification rate of 0.1% for light quark and gluon jets, while the jet with a lower deepCSV score (DCSV2) must satisfy a loose working point with a 10% misidentification rate. All backgrounds are substantially reduced by requiring large pT ðVÞ [80]. The requirements are pmiss > 170 GeV T and pT ðVÞ > 150 GeV in the 0- and 1-lepton channels, respectively, while two regions are used in the 2-lepton channel: 50 < pT ðVÞ ≤ 150 GeV and pT ðVÞ > 150 GeV. Residual backgrounds from tt̄ and QCD processes are reduced in the 1-lepton channel by rejecting events with more than one extra jet satisfying pT >30GeV and jηj < 2.5, and in the 0-lepton channel with additional requirements on and its nearest jet. the angular separation between ⃗pmiss T After all event selection criteria are applied, the resolution on the dijet invariant mass mðjjÞ of reconstructed Higgs boson decays is approximately 15%. The mass resolution is improved by applying a multivariate regression technique similar to that employed in Ref. [37], with a DNN trained on b jets from simulated tt̄ events with input variables that include several properties of any secondary vertices in the jet, as well as the energy and composition of the jet. In addition, recovery of final-state radiation is achieved by adding to the mðjjÞ calculation the momenta of jets near to either of the Higgs boson candidate jets. In the 2-lepton channel, with no genuine ⃗pmiss from the hardT scattering process, a kinematic fit of the entire event is performed requiring pT balance between the dilepton and dijet systems within the experimental uncertainty. All three improvements are validated in data by studying the pT ðllÞ=pT ðjjÞ distribution in samples of Z → ll events containing at least one b-tagged jet, and by studying the top quark mass distribution in a high-purity sample of tt̄ events. After these improvements, the average resolution on mðjjÞ is in the 10%–13% range, depending on the channel and the pT of the reconstructed Higgs boson. For each channel, a signal region enriched in VH events is selected together with several control regions, each enriched in events from individual background processes. The signal regions are defined as 60