PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS PRL 117, 182301 (2016) week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 Correlated Event-by-Event Fluctuations of Flow Harmonics pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi in Pb-Pb Collisions at sNN = 2.76 TeV J. Adam et al.* (ALICE Collaboration) (Received 4 May 2016; published 28 October 2016) We report the measurements of correlations between event-by-event fluctuations of amplitudes of anisotropic flow harmonics in nucleus-nucleus collisions, obtained for the first time using a new analysis method based on multiparticle cumulants in mixed harmonics. This novel method is robust against systematic biases originating from nonflow effects and by construction any dependence on symmetry planes is eliminated. We demonstrate that correlations of flow harmonics exhibit a better sensitivity to medium properties than the individual flow harmonics. The new measurements are performed in Pb-Pb pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi collisions at the center-of-mass energy per nucleon pair of sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV by the ALICE experiment at the Large Hadron Collider. The centrality dependence of correlation between event-by-event fluctuations of the elliptic v2 and quadrangular v4 flow harmonics, as well as of anticorrelation between v2 and triangular v3 flow harmonics are presented. The results cover two different regimes of the initial state configurations: geometry dominated (in midcentral collisions) and fluctuation dominated (in the most central collisions). Comparisons are made to predictions from Monte Carlo Glauber, viscous hydrodynamics, AMPT, and HIJING models. Together with the existing measurements of the individual flow harmonics the presented results provide further constraints on the initial conditions and the transport properties of the system produced in heavy-ion collisions. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.117.182301 The properties of an extreme state of matter, the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), are studied by colliding heavy ions at BNL’s Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider (LHC). One of the most widely utilized physical phenomena in the exploration of QGP properties is collective anisotropic flow [1,2]. The large elliptic flow discovered at RHIC energies [3], which at the LHC energy of 2.76 TeV is 30% larger [4] and is recently reported in Ref. [5] to increase even further at 5.02 TeV, demonstrated that the QGP behaves like a strongly coupled liquid with a very small ratio of the shear viscosity to entropy density, η=s, which is close to a universal lower bound of 1=4π [6]. Anisotropic flow is traditionally quantified with harmonics vn and corresponding symmetry plane angles ψ n in the Fourier series decomposition of the particle azimuthal distribution (parametrized with azimuthal angle φ) in the plane transverse to the beam direction [7]: ∞ X dN ∝1þ2 vn cos½nðφ − ψ n Þ: dφ n¼1 ð1Þ * Full author list given at the end of the article. Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. 0031-9007=16=117(18)=182301(14) The shape of the intersecting zone of two identical heavy ions in noncentral collisions is approximately ellipsoidal. This initial anisotropy is transferred via interactions among constituents and the pressure gradients developed in the QGP medium to an observable final-state anisotropic emission of particles with respect to the symmetry plane(s) of the intersecting zone. The resulting anisotropic flow for such an idealized ellipsoidal geometry is determined solely by even Fourier harmonics v2n , and only one symmetry plane (the reaction plane) exists. Recently, the importance of flow fluctuations and related additional observables has been identified. This has led to new concepts such as nonvanishing odd harmonics v2n−1 at midrapidity [8], nonidentical symmetry plane angles ψ n and their intercorrelations [9–14], the stochastic nature of the harmonic vn and its probability density function Pðvn Þ [15–20], and, finally, the importance of higher order flow moments hvkn i (where the angular brackets denote an average over all events, and k ≥ 2) [21]. Two distinct regimes for anisotropic flow development are nowadays scrutinized separately: geometry dominated (in midcentral collisions) and fluctuation dominated (in the most central collisions) [11]. Anisotropic flow is generated by the initial anisotropic geometry and its fluctuations coupled with an expansion of the produced medium. The initial coordinate space anisotropy can be quantified in terms of the eccentricity coefficients εn and the corresponding symmetry plane angles Φn [8,15,22]. A great deal of effort is being invested 182301-1 © 2016 CERN, for the ALICE Collaboration PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS to understand the relations between the momentum space Fourier harmonics vn and the symmetry planes ψ n on one side, and their spatial counterparts εn and Φn on the other side. These relations describe the response of the produced system to the initial coordinate space anisotropies, and therefore provide a rich repository of constraints for the system properties. In the early studies it was regularly assumed that, for small eccentricities, the harmonics vn respond linearly to the eccentricities εn of the same order, vn ∝ εn , and that ψ n ≃ Φn [8,10,23,24]. However, for sizable eccentricities recent studies argue that the anisotropies in momentum and coordinate space are related instead with the matrix equation connecting a set of anisotropic flow harmonics fvn g and a set of eccentricity coefficients fεn g; it was demonstrated that the hydrodynamic response is both nondiagonal and nonlinear, and that in general ψ n ≠ Φn [9,11,25,26]. The first realization led to the conclusion that a relationship between eventby-event fluctuations of the amplitudes of two different flow harmonics vm and vn can exist. This is hardly surprising for even flow harmonics in noncentral collisions because the ellipsoidal shape generates nonvanishing values for all even harmonics v2n [27], not only for elliptic flow. However, this simple geometrical argument cannot explain the possible relation between the even and week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 odd flow harmonics in noncentral collisions, and the argument is not applicable in the central collisions, where all initial shapes are equally probable since they originate solely from fluctuations. Recently a linear correlation coefficient cða; bÞ was defined in this context, which becomes 1 (−1) if observables a and b are fully linearly (antilinearly) correlated and zero in the absence of correlation [25]. Model calculations of this new observable showed that neither v2 and v3 nor v2 and v4 are linearly correlated in noncentral collisions. Most importantly, it was demonstrated that cðv2 ; v4 Þ depends strongly both on η=s of the QGP and on the value of cðε2 ; ε4 Þ, which quantifies the relationship between corresponding eccentricities in the initial state [25]. Therefore, it was concluded that new observables cðvn ; vm Þ, depending on the choice of flow harmonics vn and vm , are sensitive both to the fluctuations of the initial conditions and to the transport properties of the QGP, with the potential to discriminate between the two respective contributions when combined with a measurement of individual flow harmonics [25]. In this Letter we study the relationship between eventby-event fluctuations of magnitudes of two different flow harmonics of order n and m by using a recently proposed four-particle observable [28]: ⟪cosðmφ1 þ nφ2 − mφ3 − nφ4 Þ⟫c ¼ ⟪cosðmφ1 þ nφ2 − mφ3 − nφ4 Þ⟫ − ⟪cos½mðφ1 − φ2 Þ⟫⟪cos½nðφ1 − φ2 Þ⟫ ¼ hv2m v2n i − hv2m ihv2n i with the condition m ≠ n for two positive integers m and n. We refer to these new observables as the symmetric twoharmonic four-particle cumulant, and use the notation SCðm; nÞ, or just SC. The double angular brackets indicate that the averaging procedure has been performed in two steps—first, averaging over all distinct particle quadruplets in an event, and then in the second step weighting the singleevent averages with the “number of combinations.” The latter for single-event average four-particle correlations is mathematically equivalent to a unit weight for each individual quadruplet when the multiplicity differs event by event [29]. In both two-particle correlators above all distinct particle pairs are considered in each case. The four-particle cumulant in Eq. (2) is less sensitive to nonflow correlations than any twoor four-particle correlator on the right-hand side taken individually [30,31]. The last equality is true only in the absence of nonflow effects [32]. The observable in Eq. (2) is zero in the absence of flow fluctuations, or if the magnitudes of the harmonics vm and vn are uncorrelated [28]. It is also unaffected by the relationship between the symmetry plane angles ψ m and ψ n . The four-particle cumulant in Eq. (2) is proportional to the linear correlation coefficient cða; bÞ ð2Þ introduced in Ref. [25] and discussed above, with a ¼ v2m and b ¼ v2n . Experimentally, it is more reliable to measure the higher order moments of the flow harmonics vkn ðk ≥ 2Þ with two- and multiparticle correlation techniques [31,33,34], than to measure the first moments vn with the event plane method, due to the systematic uncertainties involved in the event-by-event estimation of the symmetry planes [35,36]. Therefore, we have used the new multiparticle observable in Eq. (2) as meant to be the least biased measure of the correlation between event-by-event fluctuations of magnitudes of the two different harmonics vm and vn [28]. The two- and four-particle correlations in Eq. (2) were evaluated in terms of Q vectors [33]. The Q vector (or flow vector) in harmonic n for a set of M particles, where throughout this Letter M is the multiplicity of an event, is P inφk [7,37]. We have used for a singledefined as Qn ≡ M e k¼1 event average two-particle correlation hcosðnðφ1 − φ2 ÞÞi the following definition and analytic result in terms of Q vectors: 182301-2 M 1 X 1 einðφi −φj Þ ¼ M ½jQn j2 − M: M ð 2 Þ2! i;j¼1 ð 2 Þ2! ði≠jÞ ð3Þ PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 For four-particle correlation hcosðmφ1 þ nφ2 − mφ3 − nφ4 Þi we used M 1 X 1 eiðmφi þnφj −mφk −nφl Þ ¼ M fjQm j2 jQn j2 − 2Re½Qmþn Qm Qn  − 2Re½Qm Qm−n Qn  M ð 4 Þ4! i;j;k;l¼1 ð 4 Þ4! ði≠j≠k≠lÞ þ jQmþn j2 þ jQm−n j2 − ðM − 4ÞðjQm j2 þ jQn j2 Þ þ MðM − 6Þg: In order to obtain the all-event average correlations, denoted by ⟪    ⟫ in Eq. (2), we have weighted singleevent expressions in Eqs. (3) and (4) with weights MðM − 1Þ and MðM − 1ÞðM − 2ÞðM − 3Þ, respectively [29]. The data used in this analysis were obtained with the ALICE detector [38,39]. They consist of minimum-bias Pb-Pb collisions recorded during the 2010 LHC Pb-Pb run pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi at sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV. With the default event and track selection criteria described below, we have obtained in total about 1.8 × 105 events per 1% centrality bin width. All individual systematic variations were combined in quadrature to obtain the final uncertainty. The centrality was determined with the V0 detector [40–42]. As a part of systematic checks the centrality was determined independently with the time projection chamber (TPC) [43] and the silicon pixel detector [44,45], which have slightly worse resolution [42]. A systematic difference of up to 3% was observed in the SCðm; nÞ results when using different centrality estimations. Charged particles were reconstructed with the TPC and the inner tracking system [44,45] immersed in a 0.5 T solenoidal field. The TPC is capable of detecting charged particles in the transverse momentum range 0.1 < pT < 100 GeV=c, with a pT resolution of less than 6% for tracks below 20 GeV=c. Because of TPC dead zones between neighboring sectors, the track finding efficiency is about 75% for pT ¼ 200 MeV=c and then it saturates at about 85% for pT > 1 GeV=c in Pb-Pb collisions. The TPC covers the full azimuth and has a pseudorapidity coverage of jηj < 0.9. Tracks reconstructed using the TPC and inner tracking system are referred to as global, while tracks reconstructed only with the TPC are referred to as TPC only. For online triggering, the V0 and silicon pixel detectors were used [39]. The reconstructed primary vertex is required to lie within 10 cm of the nominal interaction point in the longitudinal direction along the beam axis. The cut on the position of the primary vertex along the beam axis was varied from 12 to 6 cm; the resulting SC measurements are consistent with those obtained with the default cut. The main analysis was performed with global tracks selected in the transverse momentum interval 0.2 < pT < 5.0 GeV=c and the pseudorapidity region jηj < 0.8. With this choice of a low pT cutoff we are reducing event-byevent biases from a smaller reconstruction efficiency at lower pT , while the high pT cutoff was introduced to reduce the contribution to the anisotropies from the jets. ð4Þ Reconstructed tracks were required to have at least 70 TPC space points (out of a maximum of 159). Only tracks with a transverse distance of closest approach (DCA) to the primary vertex less than 3 mm are accepted to reduce the contamination from secondary tracks. Tracks with kinks (the tracks that appear to change direction due to multiple scattering, K  decays) were rejected. An independent analysis was performed with TPC-only and hybrid tracks (see below). For TPC-only tracks, the DCA cut was relaxed to 3 cm, providing a different sensitivity to contamination from the secondary tracks. Both the azimuthal acceptance and the reconstruction efficiency as a function of transverse momentum differ between the TPC-only and global tracks. The resulting difference between independent analyses with global and TPC-only tracks was found to be 1%–5% in all the centrality ranges studied, both for SC(3,2) and SC(4,2). In another independent analysis with hybrid tracks, three different types of tracks were combined, in order to overcome the nonuniform azimuthal acceptance due to dead zones in the silicon pixel detector, and to achieve the best transverse momentum resolution [39]. In this analysis the DCA cut was set to 3.2 cm in the longitudinal and to 2.4 cm in the transverse direction. The results between the global and hybrid tracks differ by 3% to 5%, depending on the observable considered. One of the largest contributions to the systematic uncertainty originates from the nonuniform reconstruction efficiency as a function of transverse momentum. For the observables SC(3,2) and SC(4,2) the uncertainty is 7% and 8%, respectively. In order to correct the measurements of these azimuthal correlators for various detector inefficiencies, we have constructed the particle weights as a function of azimuthal angle φ and transverse momentum pT , and used the prescription outlined in Ref. [28]. In particular, pT weights were constructed as a ratio of the transverse momentum distribution obtained from Monte Carlo generated tracks and from tracks reconstructed after they have passed through the detector simulated with GEANT3 [46]. We have used four Monte Carlo models in this Letter. The HIJING model [47,48] was utilized to obtain the pT weights [28]. Second, the HIJING model was used to estimate the strength of the nonflow correlations (typically few-particle correlations insensitive to the collision geometry). We have evaluated the observables of interest in coordinate space by modeling the initial conditions with a Monte Carlo Glauber model [49]. We have compared the 182301-3 ×10−6 3 week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS PRL 117, 182301 (2016) 3 ×10−6 ALICE Pb-Pb s NN = 2.76 TeV ALICE Pb-Pb sNN = 2.76 TeV 2 SC(4,2) SC(4,2) 2 SC(3,2) 1 SC(m,n) SC(3,2) SC(m,n) 1 0 0 −1 Hydrodynamics SC(4,2), η/s=0.20 SC(4,2), η/s(T) param1 −1 −2 HIJING SC(3,2), η/s=0.20 SC(4,2) −2 SC(4,2), η/s(T) param4 −3 SC(3,2) SC(3,2) SC(3,2), η/s(T) param4 SC(4,2) 10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 1 Centrality percentile 0.8 20 30 40 50 60 70 SC(4,2)/ 〈 v24 〉 〈 v22 〉 SC(3,2)/ 〈 v23 〉 〈 v22 〉 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 − 0.2 Hydrodynamics SC(4,2)/ 〈 v24 〉 〈 v22 〉 , η/s=0.20 − 0.4 SC(4,2)/ 〈 v24 〉 〈 v22 〉 , η/s(T) param1,2,3,4 AMPT: String Melting SC(3,2)/ 〈 v23 〉 〈 v22 〉 SC(3,2)/ 〈 v23 〉 〈 v22 〉 , η/s=0.20 − 0.6 SC(4,2)/ 〈 v24 〉 〈 v22 〉 SC(3,2)/ 〈 v23 〉 〈 v22 〉 , η/s(T) param1,2,3,4 10 1 20 30 40 50 60 70 MC-Glauber 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 SC(4,2)ε/ 〈 ε4〉 〈 ε2〉 , WN SC(m,n)ε/ 〈ε 2m〉〈ε 2n〉 centrality dependence of our observables with the theoretical model from Ref. [50], where the initial energy density profiles are calculated using a next-to-leading order perturbative-QCD+saturation model [51,52]. The subsequent spacetime evolution is described by relativistic dissipative fluid dynamics with different parametrizations for the temperature dependence of the shear viscosity to entropy density ratio η=sðTÞ. Each of the η=sðTÞ parametrizations is adjusted to reproduce the measured vn from central to midperipheral collisions. Finally, we provide an independent estimate of the centrality dependence of our observables by utilizing the AMPT model [53]. The centrality dependence of SC(4,2) (red squares) and SC(3,2) (blue circles) is presented in Fig. 1. Positive values of SC(4,2) are observed for all centralities. This suggests a correlation between the event-by-event fluctuations of v2 and v4 , which indicates that finding v2 larger than hv2 i in an event enhances the probability of finding v4 larger than hv4 i in that event. On the other hand, the negative results of SC(3,2) show the anticorrelation between the v2 and v3 magnitudes, which further imply that finding v2 larger than hv2 i enhances the probability of finding v3 smaller than hv3 i. We have calculated the SC observables using HIJING, which does not include anisotropic collectivity but, e.g., azimuthal correlations due to jet production [47,48]. It is found that in HIJING both ⟪cosðmφ1 þnφ2 −mφ3 −nφ4 Þ⟫ and ⟪cos½mðφ1 −φ2 Þ⟫⟪cos½nðφ1 −φ2 Þ⟫ are nonzero. However, the calculated SC observables from HIJING are compatible with zero for all centralities, which suggests that the SC measurements are nearly insensitive to nonflow correlations. We have also performed a study using the likesign technique, which is another powerful approach to estimate the nonflow effects [4]. It was found that the difference between the correlations for like-sign and all charged combinations is within 10%. This demonstrates SC(m,n)/ 〈v2m〉〈v2n〉 FIG. 1. Centrality dependence of the observables SC(4,2) (red filled squares) and SC(3,2) (blue filled circles) in Pb-Pb collisions at 2.76 TeV. Systematic errors are represented with boxes. The results for the HIJING model are shown with hollow markers. AMPT: String Melting SC(3,2), η/s(T) param1 SC(4,2)ε/ 〈 ε4〉 〈 ε2〉 , BC 0.8 SC(3,2)ε/ 〈 ε3〉 〈 ε2〉 , WN 0.6 SC(3,2)ε/ 〈 ε3〉 〈 ε2〉 , BC SC(4,2)/ 〈 v 2 〉 〈 v 2 〉 4 0.4 2 SC(3,2)/ 〈 v 2 〉 〈 v 2 〉 3 2 0.2 0 −0.2 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Centrality percentile FIG. 2. AMPT model predictions are shown as hollow symbols in the (top) and (middle) panels. Top: comparison of the observables SC(4,2) (red filled squares) and SC(3,2) (blue filled circles) to the theoretical model from Ref. [50]. The solid lines indicate the predictions with constant η=s, while the dashed lines indicate predictions for different parametrizations of the η=s temperature dependence (labeled in the same way as in Fig. 1 in Ref. [50]). Middle: results divided by hv2m ihv2n i. Bottom: comparison to the Monte Carlo Glauber model using wounded nucleon (WN) and binary collision (BC) weights. that nonzero values of SC measurements cannot be explained by nonflow effects. A study based on the AMPT model showed that the observed (anti)correlations are also sensitive to the transport properties, e.g., the partonic and hadronic interactions [20,28]. Figure 2 shows the comparison of SC(3,2) and 182301-4 week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS in Ref. [54]. Since the normalized SC(3,2) appears to be sensitive only to the initial conditions and not to η=sðTÞ, see Fig. 2 (middle), the Monte Carlo Glauber model captures better its centrality dependence than it does for the normalized SC(4,2) observable, see Fig. 2 (bottom). The relationship between the flow harmonics v2 , v3 , v4 has also been investigated by the ATLAS Collaboration using the event shape engineering technique [54–56]. For events with a larger v2, the ATLAS Collaboration showed these have a smaller than average v3 , and a larger than average v4 . For events with a smaller v2, the opposite trend occurred. These observations are consistent with the patterns observed via the SC measurements presented in this Letter. The SC observables, however, provide a compact quantitative measure of these correlations, without fitting correlations between vn and vm . This simplifies the quantitative comparison of the SC observables with hydrodynamical calculations as shown in Fig. 2. In the most central collisions the anisotropies originate mainly from fluctuations; i.e., the initial ellipsoidal ×10−9 0 SC(m,n) SC(4,2) to the AMPT calculations, which generally predict the correct sign but underestimate their magnitude. The comparison between experimental data and the theoretical calculations [50], which incorporate both the initial conditions and the system evolution, is shown in Fig. 2 (top). The model captures qualitatively the centrality dependence, but not quantitatively. Most notably, there is no single centrality for which a given η=sðTÞ parametrization describes simultaneously both SC(4,2) and SC(3,2). On the other hand, the same theoretical model captures quantitatively the centrality dependence of the individual v2 , v3 , and v4 harmonics with a precision better than 10% in the central and midcentral collisions [50]. We therefore conclude that the individual flow harmonics vn and new SCðm; nÞ observables together provide a better handle on the initial conditions and η=sðTÞ than each of them alone. This is emphasized in Fig. 2 (middle), where the SC(3,2) and SC(4,2) observables were divided with the products hv23 ihv22 i and hv24 ihv22 i, respectively, in order to obtain the normalized SC observables (the result for 60%–70% is omitted due to the large statistical uncertainty). These products were obtained with two-particle correlations and using a pseudorapidity gap of jΔηj > 1.0 to suppress biases from few-particle nonflow correlations. We have found that the normalized SC(4,2) observable exhibits much better sensitivity to different η=sðTÞ parametrizations than the normalized SC(3,2) observable, see Fig. 2 (middle), and than the individual flow harmonics [50]. These findings indicate that the normalized SC(3,2) observable is sensitive mainly to the initial conditions, while the normalized SC(4,2) observable is sensitive to both the initial conditions and the system properties, which is consistent with the prediction from Ref. [25]. It can be seen in Fig. 1 that SC(4,2) and SC(3,2) increase nonlinearly up to centrality 60%. Assuming only a linear response, vn ∝ εn , we expect that the normalized SCðm; nÞ evaluated in coordinate space can capture the measurement of the centrality dependence of the normalized SCðm; nÞ in the momentum space. The correlations between the nth and mth order harmonics were estimated with calculations of ðhε2n ε2m i − hε2n ihε2m iÞ=hε2n ihε2m i, i.e., a normalized SC observable in the coordinate space, which we denote SCðm; nÞε =hε2n ihε2m i. Here, εn (εm ) is the nth (mth) order coordinate space anisotropy, following the definition in Ref. [8]. Different scenarios of the Monte Carlo Glauber model, named the wounded nucleon and binary collision weights, have been used. An increasing trend from central to peripheral collisions with different sign has been observed in Fig. 2 (bottom) for SC(4,2) and SC(3,2). A dramatic deviation of SC(4,2) between data and the model calculation is observed for noncentral collisions. This deviation increases from midcentral to peripheral, which could be understood as the contribution of the nonlinear response (ε2 contributes to v4 ) increasing as a function of centrality, which is consistent with that reported ALICE Pb-Pb s NN = 2.76 TeV −50 SC(4,2) SC(3,2) 1 2 MC-Glauber 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ALICE Pb-Pb s NN = 2.76 TeV Centrality percentile SC(4,2)ε / 〈ε 24 〉〈ε 22 〉, WN SC(4,2)ε / 〈ε 24 〉〈ε 22 〉, BC SC(3,2)ε / 〈ε 23 〉〈ε 22 〉, WN SC(3,2)ε / 〈ε 23 〉〈ε 22 〉, BC 0.2 SC(m,n)/ 〈v2m〉〈v2n〉 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) SC(4,2)/〈v24 〉〈v22 〉 SC(3,2)/〈v23 〉〈v22 〉 0.1 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Centrality percentile FIG. 3. Top: correlated and anticorrelated event-by-event fluctuations in coordinate (Monte Carlo Glauber model) and momentum space (data). Bottom: normalized SC observables, where the pseudorapidity gap jΔηj > 1.0 was applied in both twoparticle correlations in the denominator used to estimate the individual flow harmonics. 182301-5 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS geometry characteristic for midcentral collisions plays little role in this regime. Therefore, we have performed a separate analysis for the centrality range 0%–10% in centrality bins of 1%. The results are presented in Fig. 3. We observe that event-by-event fluctuations of v2 and v4 remain correlated, and of v2 and v3 anticorrelated, also in this regime. However, the strength of the (anti) correlations exhibits a different centrality dependence than for the wider centrality range shown in Fig. 1. As seen in Fig. 3 (top) the centrality dependence cannot be linearly extrapolated from the 0%–10% region to the full centrality range. Comparison with the two different parametrizations of the Monte Carlo Glauber initial conditions for the normalized SC observables presented in Fig. 3 (bottom) suggests that the binary collision parametrization (binary collision weights) is favored by the data in most central collisions. This agreement may suggest the scaling with the number of quark participants [57–61] in central collisions at the LHC energies. In summary, we have measured for the first time the new multiparticle observables, the symmetric two-harmonic four-particle cumulants, which quantify the relationship between the event-by-event fluctuations of two different flow harmonics. We have found that the fluctuations of v2 and v3 are anticorrelated in all centralities; however, the details of the centrality dependence differ in the fluctutation-dominated (most central) and the geometry-dominated (midcentral) regimes. The fluctuations of v2 and v4 are correlated for all centralities. The SC observables were used to discriminate between the state-of-the-art hydro model calculations with different parametrizations of the temperature dependence of η=s, for all of which the centrality dependence of elliptic, triangular, and quadrangular flow has a weaker sensitivity at the LHC. In particular, the centrality dependence of SC(4,2) cannot be captured with the constant η=s. We have also used our results to discriminate between two different parametrizations of the initial conditions and have demonstrated that in the fluctuation-dominated regime (in central collisions) the Monte Carlo Glauber initial conditions with binary collision weights are favored over wounded nucleon weights. The ALICE Collaboration would like to thank Harri Niemi for providing the latest predictions from the state-ofthe-art hydrodynamic model. The ALICE Collaboration would like to thank all its engineers and technicians for their invaluable contributions to the construction of the experiment and the CERN accelerator teams for the outstanding performance of the LHC complex. The ALICE Collaboration gratefully acknowledges the resources and support provided by all Grid centers and the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid (WLCG) Collaboration. The ALICE Collaboration acknowledges the following funding agencies for their support in building and running the ALICE detector: State Committee of Science, World Federation of Scientists (WFS) and Swiss Fonds Kidagan, Armenia; week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Financiadora de Estudos e Projetos (FINEP), Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP); Ministry of Science and Technology of China (MSTC), National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) and Ministry of Education of China (MOEC); Ministry of Science, Education and Sports of Croatia and Unity through Knowledge Fund, Croatia; Ministry of Education and Youth of the Czech Republic; Danish Natural Science Research Council, the Carlsberg Foundation and the Danish National Research Foundation; The European Research Council under the European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme; the Helsinki Institute of Physics and the Academy of Finland; the French Centre national de la recherche scientifique-Institut national de physique nucléaire et de physique des particules (CNRS-IN2P3), the “Region Pays de Loire,” “Region Alsace,” “Region Auvergne” and CEA, France; German Bundesministerium fur Bildung, Wissenschaft, Forschung und Technologie (BMBF) and the Helmholtz Association; General Secretariat for Research and Technology, Ministry of Development, Greece; National Research, Development and Innovation Office (NKFIH), Hungary; Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), New Delhi; Department of Atomic Energy and Department of Science and Technology of the Government of India; Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN) and Centro Fermi—Museo Storico della Fisica e Centro Studi e Ricerche “Enrico Fermi,” Italy; Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) KAKENHI and MEXT, Japan; National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF); Consejo Nacional de Cienca y Tecnologia (CONACYT), Direccion General de Asuntos del Personal Academico (DGAPA), México, Amerique Latine Formation academique—European Commission (ALFA-EC) and the EPLANET Program (European Particle Physics Latin American Network); Stichting voor Fundamenteel Onderzoek der Materie (FOM) and the Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (NWO), Netherlands; Research Council of Norway (NFR); Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú; National Science Centre, Poland; Ministry of National Education/Institute for Atomic Physics and National Council of Scientific Research in Higher Education (CNCSI-UEFISCDI), Romania; Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna; Ministry of Education and Science of Russian Federation, Russian Academy of Sciences, Russian Federal Agency of Atomic Energy, Russian Federal Agency for Science and Innovations and The Russian Foundation for Basic Research; Ministry of Education of Slovakia; Department of Science and Technology, South Africa; Centro de Investigaciones Energeticas, Medioambientales y Tecnologicas (CIEMAT), E-Infrastructure shared between Europe and Latin America (EELA), Ministerio 182301-6 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS de Economía y Competitividad (MINECO) of Spain, Xunta de Galicia (Consellería de Educación), Centro de Aplicaciones Tecnológicas y Desarrollo Nuclear (CEADEN), Cubaenergía, Cuba, and IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency); Swedish Research Council (VR) and Knut & Alice Wallenberg Foundation (KAW); National Science and Technology Development Agency (NSDTA), Suranaree University of Technology (SUT) and Office of the Higher Education Commission under NRU project of Thailand; Ukraine Ministry of Education and Science; United Kingdom Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC); the United States Department of Energy, the United States National Science Foundation, the State of Texas, and the State of Ohio. [1] J.-Y. Ollitrault, Anisotropy as a signature of transverse collective flow, Phys. Rev. D 46. 229 (1992). [2] S. A. Voloshin, A. M. Poskanzer, and R. Snellings, Collective phenomena in noncentral nuclear collisions, arXiv:0809.2949. [3] K. H. Ackermann et al. (STAR Collaboration), Elliptic Flow pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi in Au þ Au Collisions at sNN ¼ 130 GeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 402 (2001). [4] K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Elliptic Flow of Charged Particles in Pb-Pb Collisions at 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 252302 (2010). [5] J. Adam et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Anisotropic Flow of pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Charged Particles in Pb-Pb Collisions at sNN ¼ 5.02 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 132302 (2016). [6] P. K. Kovtun, D. T. Son, and A. O. Starinets, Viscosity in Strongly Interacting Quantum Field Theories from Black Hole Physics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 111601 (2005). [7] S. Voloshin and Y. Zhang, Flow study in relativistic nuclear collisions by Fourier expansion of azimuthal particle distributions, Z. Phys. C 70, 665 (1996). [8] B. Alver and G. Roland, Collision geometry fluctuations and triangular flow in heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 81, 054905 (2010); 82, 039903(E) (2010). [9] G.-Y. Qin, H. Petersen, S. A. Bass, and B. Muller, Translation of collision geometry fluctuations into momentum anisotropies in relativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 82, 064903 (2010). [10] D. Teaney and L. Yan, Triangularity and dipole asymmetry in heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 83, 064904 (2011). [11] Z. Qiu and U. W. Heinz, Event-by-event shape and flow fluctuations of relativistic heavy-ion collision fireballs, Phys. Rev. C 84, 024911 (2011). [12] K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Higher Harmonic Anisotropic Flow Measurements of Charged Particles in pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Pb-Pb Collisions at sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 032301 (2011). [13] A. Adare et al. (PHENIX Collaboration), Measurements of Higher-Order Flow Harmonics in Au þ Au Collisions at pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi sNN ¼ 200 GeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 252301 (2011). week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 [14] G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Measurement of pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi event-plane correlations in sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV lead-lead collisions with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. C 90, 024905 (2014). [15] S. A. Voloshin, A. M. Poskanzer, A. Tang, and G. Wang, Elliptic flow in the Gaussian model of eccentricity fluctuations, Phys. Lett. B 659, 537 (2008). [16] C. Gale, S. Jeon, B. Schenke, P. Tribedy, and R. Venugopalan, Initial state fluctuations and higher harmonic flow in heavy-ion collisions, Nucl. Phys. A904–905, 409c (2013). [17] G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Measurement of the distributions p offfiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi event-by-event flow harmonics in lead-lead collisions at sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV with the ATLAS detector at the LHC, J. High Energy Phys. 11 (2013) 183. [18] L. Yan and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Universal Fluctuation-Driven Eccentricities in Proton-Proton, Proton-Nucleus and Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 082301 (2014). [19] L. Yan, J.-Y. Ollitrault, and A. M. Poskanzer, Eccentricity distributions in nucleus-nucleus collisions, Phys. Rev. C 90, 024903 (2014). [20] Y. Zhou, K. Xiao, Z. Feng, F. Liu, and R. Snellings, Anisotropic distributions in a multi-phase transport model, Phys. Rev. C 93, 034909 (2016). [21] R. S. Bhalerao, J.-Y. Ollitrault, and S. Pal, Characterizing flow fluctuations with moments, Phys. Lett. B 742, 94 (2015). [22] B. Alver et al. (PHOBOS Collaboration), System Size, Energy, Pseudorapidity, and Centrality Dependence of Elliptic Flow, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 242302 (2007). [23] B. H. Alver, C. Gombeaud, M. Luzum, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Triangular flow in hydrodynamics and transport theory, Phys. Rev. C 82, 034913 (2010). [24] R. A. Lacey, D. Reynolds, A. Taranenko, N. N. Ajitanand, J. M. Alexander, F.-H. Liu, Y. Gu, and A. Mwai, Acoustic scaling of anisotropic flow in shape-engineered events: Implications for extraction of the specific shear viscosity of the quark gluon plasma, arXiv:1311.1728. [25] H. Niemi, G. S. Denicol, H. Holopainen, and P. Huovinen, Event-by-event distributions of azimuthal asymmetries in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 87, 054901 (2013). [26] L. Yan and J.-Y. Ollitrault, ν4 , ν5 , ν6 , ν7 : Nonlinear hydrodynamic response versus LHC data, Phys. Lett. B 744, 82 (2015). [27] P. F. Kolb, v4 : A Small, but sensitive observable for heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 68, 031902 (2003). [28] A. Bilandzic, C. H. Christensen, K. Gulbrandsen, A. Hansen, and Y. Zhou, Generic framework for anisotropic flow analyses with multiparticle azimuthal correlations, Phys. Rev. C 89, 064904 (2014). [29] A. Bilandzic, Ph.D. thesis, Utrecht U., 2012, https:// inspirehep.net/record/1186272/files/CERN‑THESIS‑2012‑ 018.pdf. [30] N. Borghini, P. M. Dinh, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, A new method for measuring azimuthal distributions in nucleus-nucleus collisions, Phys. Rev. C 63, 054906 (2001). [31] N. Borghini, P. M. Dinh, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Flow analysis from multiparticle azimuthal correlations, Phys. Rev. C 64, 054901 (2001). 182301-7 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS [32] R. S. Bhalerao, M. Luzum, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Determining initial-state fluctuations from flow measurements in heavyion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 84, 034910 (2011). [33] A. Bilandzic, R. Snellings, and S. Voloshin, Flow analysis with cumulants: Direct calculations, Phys. Rev. C 83, 044913 (2011). [34] S. Wang, Y. Z. Jiang, Y. M. Liu, D. Keane, D. Beavis, S. Y. Chu, S. Y. Fung, M. Vient, C. Hartnack, and H. Stocker, Measurement of collective flow in heavy ion collisions using particle pair correlations, Phys. Rev. C 44, 1091 (1991). [35] A. M. Poskanzer and S. A. Voloshin, Methods for analyzing anisotropic flow in relativistic nuclear collisions, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1671 (1998). [36] M. Luzum and J.-Y. Ollitrault, Eliminating experimental bias in anisotropic-flow measurements of high-energy nuclear collisions, Phys. Rev. C 87, 044907 (2013). [37] J. Barrette et al. (E877 Collaboration), Observation of Anisotropic Event Shapes and Transverse Flow in Au þ Au Collisions at AGS Energy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 2532 (1994). [38] K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE Collaboration), The ALICE experiment at the CERN LHC, J. Instrum. 3, S08002 (2008). [39] B. B. Abelev et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Performance of the ALICE Experiment at the CERN LHC, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 29, 1430044 (2014). [40] P. Cortese et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Report No. CERNLHCC-2004-025, https://cds.cern.ch/record/781854/files/ lhcc‑2004‑025.pdf. [41] E. Abbas et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Performance of the ALICE VZERO system, J. Instrum. 8, P10016 (2013). [42] B. Abelev et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Centrality deterpffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi mination of Pb-Pb collisions at sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV with ALICE, Phys. Rev. C 88, 044909 (2013). [43] J. Alme et al., The ALICE TPC, a large 3-dimensional tracking device with fast readout for ultra-high multiplicity events, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 622, 316 (2010). [44] G. Dellacasa et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Report No. CERNLHCC-99-12, https://cds.cern.ch/record/391175?ln=en. [45] K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Alignment of the ALICE Inner Tracking System with cosmic-ray tracks, J. Instrum. 5, P03003 (2010). [46] R. Brun, F. Carminati, and S. Giani, Report No. CERNW5013, 1994, https://cds.cern.ch/record/1082634/files/ geantall_CERN‑W5013.pdf. [47] X.-N. Wang and M. Gyulassy, HIJING: A Monte Carlo model for multiple jet production in pp, pA and AA collisions, Phys. Rev. D 44, 3501 (1991). week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 [48] M. Gyulassy and X.-N. Wang, HIJING 1.0: A Monte Carlo program for parton and particle production in high-energy hadronic and nuclear collisions, Comput. Phys. Commun. 83, 307 (1994). [49] M. L. Miller, K. Reygers, S. J. Sanders, and P. Steinberg, Glauber modeling in high energy nuclear collisions, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 57, 205 (2007). [50] H. Niemi, K. J. Eskola, and R. Paatelainen, Event-by-event fluctuations in perturbative QCD þ saturation þ hydro model: pinning down QCD matter shear viscosity in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 93, 024907 (2016). [51] R. Paatelainen, K. J. Eskola, H. Holopainen, and K. Tuominen, Multiplicities and pT spectra in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions from a next-to-leading order improved perturbative QCD þ saturation þ hydrodynamics model, Phys. Rev. C 87, 044904 (2013). [52] R. Paatelainen, K. J. Eskola, H. Niemi, and K. Tuominen, Fluid dynamics with saturated minijet initial conditions in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Lett. B 731, 126 (2014). [53] Z.-W. Lin, C. M. Ko, B.-A. Li, B. Zhang, and S. Pal, A Multi-phase transport model for relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 72, 064901 (2005). [54] G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Measurement of the correlation between flow harmonics of different order in pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi lead-lead collisions at sNN ¼ 2.76 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. C 92, 034903 (2015). [55] J. Schukraft, A. Timmins, and S. A. Voloshin, Ultrarelativistic nuclear collisions: Event shape engineering, Phys. Lett. B 719, 394 (2013). [56] H. Petersen and B. Muller, Possibility of event shape selection in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 88, 044918 (2013). [57] S. Eremin and S. Voloshin, Nucleon participants or quark participants?, Phys. Rev. C 67, 064905 (2003). [58] M. Miller and R. Snellings, Eccentricity fluctuations and its possible effect on elliptic flow measurements, arXiv: nucl-ex/0312008. [59] L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR Collaboration), Azimuthal anisotropy in U þ U and Au þ Au collisions at RHIC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 222301 (2015). [60] A. Adare et al. (PHENIX Collaboration), Transverse energy production and charged-particle multiplicity at pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi midrapidity in various systems from sNN ¼ 7.7 to 200 GeV, Phys. Rev. C 93, 024901 (2016). [61] C. Loizides, Glauber modeling of high-energy nuclear collisions at sub-nucleon level, Phys. Rev. C 94, 024914 (2016). J. Adam,39 D. Adamová,85 M. M. Aggarwal,89 G. Aglieri Rinella,35 M. Agnello,111 N. Agrawal,48 Z. Ahammed,134 S. Ahmad,18 S. U. Ahn,69 S. Aiola,138 A. Akindinov,55 S. N. Alam,134 D. S. D. Albuquerque,122 D. Aleksandrov,81 B. Alessandro,111 D. Alexandre,102 R. Alfaro Molina,64 A. Alici,12,105 A. Alkin,3 J. R. M. Almaraz,120 J. Alme,22,37 T. Alt,42 S. Altinpinar,22 I. Altsybeev,133 C. Alves Garcia Prado,121 C. Andrei,79 A. Andronic,98 V. Anguelov,94 T. Antičić,99 F. Antinori,108 P. Antonioli,105 L. Aphecetche,114 H. Appelshäuser,61 S. Arcelli,27 R. Arnaldi,111 O. W. Arnold,36,95 182301-8 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 I. C. Arsene,21 M. Arslandok,61 B. Audurier,114 A. Augustinus,35 R. Averbeck,98 M. D. Azmi,18 A. Badalà,107 Y. W. Baek,68 S. Bagnasco,111 R. Bailhache,61 R. Bala,92 S. Balasubramanian,138 A. Baldisseri,15 R. C. Baral,58 A. M. Barbano,26 R. Barbera,28 F. Barile,32 G. G. Barnaföldi,137 L. S. Barnby,35,102 V. Barret,71 P. Bartalini,7 K. Barth,35 J. Bartke,118,† E. Bartsch,61 M. Basile,27 N. Bastid,71 S. Basu,134 B. Bathen,62 G. Batigne,114 A. Batista Camejo,71 B. Batyunya,67 P. C. Batzing,21 I. G. Bearden,82 H. Beck,61,94 C. Bedda,111 N. K. Behera,49,51 I. Belikov,65 F. Bellini,27 H. Bello Martinez,2 R. Bellwied,123 R. Belmont,136 E. Belmont-Moreno,64 L. G. E. Beltran,120 V. Belyaev,76 G. Bencedi,137 S. Beole,26 I. Berceanu,79 A. Bercuci,79 Y. Berdnikov,87 D. Berenyi,137 R. A. Bertens,54 D. Berzano,35 L. Betev,35 A. Bhasin,92 I. R. Bhat,92 A. K. Bhati,89 B. Bhattacharjee,44 J. Bhom,118,129 L. Bianchi,123 N. Bianchi,73 C. Bianchin,136 J. Bielčík,39 J. Bielčíková,85 A. Bilandzic,36,82,95 G. Biro,137 R. Biswas,4 S. Biswas,4,80 S. Bjelogrlic,54 J. T. Blair,119 D. Blau,81 C. Blume,61 F. Bock,75,94 A. Bogdanov,76 H. Bøggild,82 L. Boldizsár,137 M. Bombara,40 J. Book,61 H. Borel,15 A. Borissov,97 M. Borri,84,125 F. Bossú,66 E. Botta,26 C. Bourjau,82 P. Braun-Munzinger,98 M. Bregant,121 T. Breitner,60 T. A. Broker,61 T. A. Browning,96 M. Broz,39 E. J. Brucken,46 E. Bruna,111 G. E. Bruno,32 D. Budnikov,100 H. Buesching,61 S. Bufalino,26,35 P. Buncic,35 O. Busch,129 Z. Buthelezi,66 J. B. Butt,16 J. T. Buxton,19 J. Cabala,116 D. Caffarri,35 X. Cai,7 H. Caines,138 L. Calero Diaz,73 A. Caliva,54 E. Calvo Villar,103 P. Camerini,25 F. Carena,35 W. Carena,35 F. Carnesecchi,27 J. Castillo Castellanos,15 A. J. Castro,126 E. A. R. Casula,24 C. Ceballos Sanchez,9 J. Cepila,39 P. Cerello,111 J. Cerkala,116 B. Chang,124 S. Chapeland,35 M. Chartier,125 J. L. Charvet,15 S. Chattopadhyay,134 S. Chattopadhyay,101 A. Chauvin,36,95 V. Chelnokov,3 M. Cherney,88 C. Cheshkov,131 B. Cheynis,131 V. Chibante Barroso,35 D. D. Chinellato,122 S. Cho,51 P. Chochula,35 K. Choi,97 M. Chojnacki,82 S. Choudhury,134 P. Christakoglou,83 C. H. Christensen,82 P. Christiansen,33 T. Chujo,129 S. U. Chung,97 C. Cicalo,106 L. Cifarelli,12,27 F. Cindolo,105 J. Cleymans,91 F. Colamaria,32 D. Colella,35,56 A. Collu,75 M. Colocci,27 G. Conesa Balbastre,72 Z. Conesa del Valle,52 M. E. Connors,138,‡ J. G. Contreras,39 T. M. Cormier,86 Y. Corrales Morales,26,111 I. Cortés Maldonado,2 P. Cortese,31 M. R. Cosentino,121 F. Costa,35 P. Crochet,71 R. Cruz Albino,11 E. Cuautle,63 L. Cunqueiro,35,62 T. Dahms,36,95 A. Dainese,108 M. C. Danisch,94 A. Danu,59 D. Das,101 I. Das,101 S. Das,4 A. Dash,80 S. Dash,48 S. De,121 A. De Caro,12,30 G. de Cataldo,104 C. de Conti,121 J. de Cuveland,42 A. De Falco,24 D. De Gruttola,12,30 N. De Marco,111 S. De Pasquale,30 R. D. De Souza,122 A. Deisting,94,98 A. Deloff,78 E. Dénes,137,† C. Deplano,83 P. Dhankher,48 D. Di Bari,32 A. Di Mauro,35 P. Di Nezza,73 B. Di Ruzza,108 M. A. Diaz Corchero,10 T. Dietel,91 P. Dillenseger,61 R. Divià,35 Ø. Djuvsland,22 A. Dobrin,59,83 D. Domenicis Gimenez,121 B. Dönigus,61 O. Dordic,21 T. Drozhzhova,61 A. K. Dubey,134 A. Dubla,54 L. Ducroux,131 P. Dupieux,71 R. J. Ehlers,138 D. Elia,104 E. Endress,103 H. Engel,60 E. Epple,36,95,138 B. Erazmus,114 I. Erdemir,61 F. Erhardt,130 B. Espagnon,52 M. Estienne,114 S. Esumi,129 J. Eum,97 D. Evans,102 S. Evdokimov,112 G. Eyyubova,39 L. Fabbietti,36,95 D. Fabris,108 J. Faivre,72 A. Fantoni,73 M. Fasel,75 L. Feldkamp,62 A. Feliciello,111 G. Feofilov,133 J. Ferencei,85 A. Fernández Téllez,2 E. G. Ferreiro,17 A. Ferretti,26 A. Festanti,29 V. J. G. Feuillard,15,71 J. Figiel,118 M. A. S. Figueredo,121,125 S. Filchagin,100 D. Finogeev,53 F. M. Fionda,24 E. M. Fiore,32 M. G. Fleck,94 M. Floris,35 S. Foertsch,66 P. Foka,98 S. Fokin,81 E. Fragiacomo,110 A. Francescon,29,35 A. Francisco,114 U. Frankenfeld,98 G. G. Fronze,26 U. Fuchs,35 C. Furget,72 A. Furs,53 M. Fusco Girard,30 J. J. Gaardhøje,82 M. Gagliardi,26 A. M. Gago,103 K. Gajdosova,82 M. Gallio,26 C. D. Galvan,120 D. R. Gangadharan,75 P. Ganoti,90 C. Gao,7 C. Garabatos,98 E. Garcia-Solis,13 C. Gargiulo,35 P. Gasik,36,95 E. F. Gauger,119 M. Germain,114 M. Gheata,35,59 P. Ghosh,134 S. K. Ghosh,4 P. Gianotti,73 P. Giubellino,35,111 P. Giubilato,29 E. Gladysz-Dziadus,118 P. Glässel,94 D. M. Goméz Coral,64 A. Gomez Ramirez,60 A. S. Gonzalez,35 V. Gonzalez,10 P. González-Zamora,10 S. Gorbunov,42 L. Görlich,118 S. Gotovac,117 V. Grabski,64 O. A. Grachov,138 L. K. Graczykowski,135 K. L. Graham,102 A. Grelli,54 A. Grigoras,35 C. Grigoras,35 V. Grigoriev,76 A. Grigoryan,1 S. Grigoryan,67 B. Grinyov,3 N. Grion,110 J. M. Gronefeld,98 J. F. Grosse-Oetringhaus,35 R. Grosso,98 L. Gruber,113 F. Guber,53 R. Guernane,72 B. Guerzoni,27 K. Gulbrandsen,82 T. Gunji,128 A. Gupta,92 R. Gupta,92 R. Haake,35 Ø. Haaland,22 C. Hadjidakis,52 M. Haiduc,59 H. Hamagaki,128 G. Hamar,137 J. C. Hamon,65 J. W. Harris,138 A. Harton,13 D. Hatzifotiadou,105 S. Hayashi,128 S. T. Heckel,61 E. Hellbär,61 H. Helstrup,37 A. Herghelegiu,79 G. Herrera Corral,11 B. A. Hess,34 K. F. Hetland,37 H. Hillemanns,35 B. Hippolyte,65 D. Horak,39 R. Hosokawa,129 P. Hristov,35 C. Hughes,126 T. J. Humanic,19 N. Hussain,44 T. Hussain,18 D. Hutter,42 D. S. Hwang,20 R. Ilkaev,100 M. Inaba,129 E. Incani,24 M. Ippolitov,76,81 M. Irfan,18 M. Ivanov,98 V. Ivanov,87 V. Izucheev,112 B. Jacak,75 N. Jacazio,27 P. M. Jacobs,75 M. B. Jadhav,48 S. Jadlovska,116 J. Jadlovsky,56,116 C. Jahnke,121 M. J. Jakubowska,135 H. J. Jang,69 M. A. Janik,135 P. H. S. Y. Jayarathna,123 C. Jena,29 S. Jena,123 R. T. Jimenez Bustamante,98 P. G. Jones,102 A. Jusko,102 P. Kalinak,56 A. Kalweit,35 J. Kamin,61 J. H. Kang,139 V. Kaplin,76 S. Kar,134 A. Karasu Uysal,70 O. Karavichev,53 T. Karavicheva,53 L. Karayan,94,98 E. Karpechev,53 U. Kebschull,60 182301-9 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 R. Keidel,140 D. L. D. Keijdener,54 M. Keil,35 M. Mohisin Khan,18,§ P. Khan,101 S. A. Khan,134 A. Khanzadeev,87 Y. Kharlov,112 B. Kileng,37 D. W. Kim,43 D. J. Kim,124 D. Kim,139 H. Kim,139 J. S. Kim,43 J. Kim,94 M. Kim,139 S. Kim,20 T. Kim,139 S. Kirsch,42 I. Kisel,42 S. Kiselev,55 A. Kisiel,135 G. Kiss,137 J. L. Klay,6 C. Klein,61 J. Klein,35 C. Klein-Bösing,62 S. Klewin,94 A. Kluge,35 M. L. Knichel,94 A. G. Knospe,119,123 C. Kobdaj,115 M. Kofarago,35 T. Kollegger,98 A. Kolojvari,133 V. Kondratiev,133 N. Kondratyeva,76 E. Kondratyuk,112 A. Konevskikh,53 M. Kopcik,116 M. Kour,92 C. Kouzinopoulos,35 O. Kovalenko,78 V. Kovalenko,133 M. Kowalski,118 G. Koyithatta Meethaleveedu,48 I. Králik,56 A. Kravčáková,40 M. Krivda,56,102 F. Krizek,85 E. Kryshen,35,87 M. Krzewicki,42 A. M. Kubera,19 V. Kučera,85 C. Kuhn,65 P. G. Kuijer,83 A. Kumar,92 J. Kumar,48 L. Kumar,89 S. Kumar,48 P. Kurashvili,78 A. Kurepin,53 A. B. Kurepin,53 A. Kuryakin,100 M. J. Kweon,51 Y. Kwon,139 S. L. La Pointe,111 P. La Rocca,28 P. Ladron de Guevara,11 C. Lagana Fernandes,121 I. Lakomov,35 R. Langoy,41 K. Lapidus,36,95 C. Lara,60 A. Lardeux,15 A. Lattuca,26 E. Laudi,35 R. Lea,25 L. Leardini,94 G. R. Lee,102 S. Lee,139 F. Lehas,83 S. Lehner,113 R. C. Lemmon,84 V. Lenti,104 E. Leogrande,54 I. León Monzón,120 H. León Vargas,64 M. Leoncino,26 P. Lévai,137 S. Li,7,71 X. Li,14 J. Lien,41 R. Lietava,102 S. Lindal,21 V. Lindenstruth,42 C. Lippmann,98 M. A. Lisa,19 H. M. Ljunggren,33 D. F. Lodato,54 P. I. Loenne,22 V. Loginov,76 C. Loizides,75 X. Lopez,71 E. López Torres,9 A. Lowe,137 P. Luettig,61 M. Lunardon,29 G. Luparello,25 T. H. Lutz,138 A. Maevskaya,53 M. Mager,35 S. Mahajan,92 S. M. Mahmood,21 A. Maire,65 R. D. Majka,138 M. Malaev,87 I. Maldonado Cervantes,63 L. Malinina,67,∥ D. Mal’Kevich,55 P. Malzacher,98 A. Mamonov,100 V. Manko,81 F. Manso,71 V. Manzari,35,104 M. Marchisone,26,66,127 J. Mareš,57 G. V. Margagliotti,25 A. Margotti,105 J. Margutti,54 A. Marín,98 C. Markert,119 M. Marquard,61 N. A. Martin,98 J. Martin Blanco,114 P. Martinengo,35 M. I. Martínez,2 G. Martínez García,114 M. Martinez Pedreira,35 A. Mas,121 S. Masciocchi,98 M. Masera,26 A. Masoni,106 A. Mastroserio,32 A. Matyja,118 C. Mayer,118 J. Mazer,126 M. A. Mazzoni,109 D. Mcdonald,123 F. Meddi,23 Y. Melikyan,76 A. Menchaca-Rocha,64 E. Meninno,30 J. Mercado Pérez,94 M. Meres,38 Y. Miake,129 M. M. Mieskolainen,46 K. Mikhaylov,55,67 L. Milano,35,75 J. Milosevic,21 A. Mischke,54 A. N. Mishra,49 D. Miśkowiec,98 J. Mitra,134 C. M. Mitu,59 N. Mohammadi,54 B. Mohanty,80 L. Molnar,65 L. Montaño Zetina,11 E. Montes,10 D. A. Moreira De Godoy,62 L. A. P. Moreno,2 S. Moretto,29 A. Morreale,114 A. Morsch,35 V. Muccifora,73 E. Mudnic,117 D. Mühlheim,62 S. Muhuri,134 M. Mukherjee,134 J. D. Mulligan,138 M. G. Munhoz,121 K. Münning,45 R. H. Munzer,36,61,95 H. Murakami,128 S. Murray,66 L. Musa,35 J. Musinsky,56 B. Naik,48 R. Nair,78 B. K. Nandi,48 R. Nania,105 E. Nappi,104 M. U. Naru,16 H. Natal da Luz,121 C. Nattrass,126 S. R. Navarro,2 K. Nayak,80 R. Nayak,48 T. K. Nayak,134 S. Nazarenko,100 A. Nedosekin,55 L. Nellen,63 F. Ng,123 M. Nicassio,98 M. Niculescu,59 J. Niedziela,35 B. S. Nielsen,82 S. Nikolaev,81 S. Nikulin,81 V. Nikulin,87 F. Noferini,12,105 P. Nomokonov,67 G. Nooren,54 J. C. C. Noris,2 J. Norman,125 A. Nyanin,81 J. Nystrand,22 H. Oeschler,94 S. Oh,138 S. K. Oh,68 A. Ohlson,35 A. Okatan,70 T. Okubo,47 J. Oleniacz,135 A. C. Oliveira Da Silva,121 M. H. Oliver,138 J. Onderwaater,98 C. Oppedisano,111 R. Orava,46 M. Oravec,116 A. Ortiz Velasquez,63 A. Oskarsson,33 J. Otwinowski,118 K. Oyama,77,94 M. Ozdemir,61 Y. Pachmayer,94 D. Pagano,132 P. Pagano,30 G. Paić,63 S. K. Pal,134 J. Pan,136 A. K. Pandey,48 V. Papikyan,1 G. S. Pappalardo,107 P. Pareek,49 W. J. Park,98 S. Parmar,89 A. Passfeld,62 V. Paticchio,104 R. N. Patra,134 B. Paul,101,111 H. Pei,7 T. Peitzmann,54 X. Peng,7 H. Pereira Da Costa,15 D. Peresunko,76,81 E. Perez Lezama,61 V. Peskov,61 Y. Pestov,5 V. Petráček,39 V. Petrov,112 M. Petrovici,79 C. Petta,28 S. Piano,110 M. Pikna,38 P. Pillot,114 L. O. D. L. Pimentel,82 O. Pinazza,35,105 L. Pinsky,123 D. B. Piyarathna,123 M. Płoskoń,75 M. Planinic,130 J. Pluta,135 S. Pochybova,137 P. L. M. Podesta-Lerma,120 M. G. Poghosyan,86,88 B. Polichtchouk,112 N. Poljak,130 W. Poonsawat,115 A. Pop,79 H. Poppenborg,62 S. Porteboeuf-Houssais,71 J. Porter,75 J. Pospisil,85 S. K. Prasad,4 R. Preghenella,35,105 F. Prino,111 C. A. Pruneau,136 I. Pshenichnov,53 M. Puccio,26 G. Puddu,24 P. Pujahari,136 V. Punin,100 J. Putschke,136 H. Qvigstad,21 A. Rachevski,110 S. Raha,4 S. Rajput,92 J. Rak,124 A. Rakotozafindrabe,15 L. Ramello,31 F. Rami,65 R. Raniwala,93 S. Raniwala,93 S. S. Räsänen,46 B. T. Rascanu,61 D. Rathee,89 K. F. Read,86,126 K. Redlich,78 R. J. Reed,136 A. Rehman,22 P. Reichelt,61 F. Reidt,35,94 X. Ren,7 R. Renfordt,61 A. R. Reolon,73 A. Reshetin,53 K. Reygers,94 V. Riabov,87 R. A. Ricci,74 T. Richert,33 M. Richter,21 P. Riedler,35 W. Riegler,35 F. Riggi,28 C. Ristea,59 E. Rocco,54 M. Rodríguez Cahuantzi,2 A. Rodriguez Manso,83 K. Røed,21 E. Rogochaya,67 D. Rohr,42 D. Röhrich,22 F. Ronchetti,35,73 L. Ronflette,114 P. Rosnet,71 A. Rossi,29 F. Roukoutakis,90 A. Roy,49 C. Roy,65 P. Roy,101 A. J. Rubio Montero,10 R. Rui,25 R. Russo,26 E. Ryabinkin,81 Y. Ryabov,87 A. Rybicki,118 S. Saarinen,46 S. Sadhu,134 S. Sadovsky,112 K. Šafařík,35 B. Sahlmuller,61 P. Sahoo,49 R. Sahoo,49 S. Sahoo,58 P. K. Sahu,58 J. Saini,134 S. Sakai,73 M. A. Saleh,136 J. Salzwedel,19 S. Sambyal,92 V. Samsonov,76,87 L. Šándor,56 A. Sandoval,64 M. Sano,129 D. Sarkar,134 N. Sarkar,134 P. Sarma,44 E. Scapparone,105 F. Scarlassara,29 C. Schiaua,79 R. Schicker,94 C. Schmidt,98 H. R. Schmidt,34 M. Schmidt,34 S. Schuchmann,61 J. Schukraft,35 M. Schulc,39 182301-10 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 Y. Schutz,35,114 K. Schwarz,98 K. Schweda,98 G. Scioli,27 E. Scomparin,111 R. Scott,126 M. Šefčík,40 J. E. Seger,88 Y. Sekiguchi,128 D. Sekihata,47 I. Selyuzhenkov,98 K. Senosi,66 S. Senyukov,3,35 E. Serradilla,10,64 A. Sevcenco,59 A. Shabanov,53 A. Shabetai,114 O. Shadura,3 R. Shahoyan,35 M. I. Shahzad,16 A. Shangaraev,112 A. Sharma,92 M. Sharma,92 M. Sharma,92 N. Sharma,126 A. I. Sheikh,134 K. Shigaki,47 Q. Shou,7 K. Shtejer,9,26 Y. Sibiriak,81 S. Siddhanta,106 K. M. Sielewicz,35 T. Siemiarczuk,78 D. Silvermyr,33 C. Silvestre,72 G. Simatovic,130 G. Simonetti,35 R. Singaraju,134 R. Singh,80 V. Singhal,134 T. Sinha,101 B. Sitar,38 M. Sitta,31 T. B. Skaali,21 M. Slupecki,124 N. Smirnov,138 R. J. M. Snellings,54 T. W. Snellman,124 J. Song,97 M. Song,139 Z. Song,7 F. Soramel,29 S. Sorensen,126 F. Sozzi,98 M. Spacek,39 E. Spiriti,73 I. Sputowska,118 M. Spyropoulou-Stassinaki,90 J. Stachel,94 I. Stan,59 P. Stankus,86 E. Stenlund,33 G. Steyn,66 J. H. Stiller,94 D. Stocco,114 P. Strmen,38 A. A. P. Suaide,121 T. Sugitate,47 C. Suire,52 M. Suleymanov,16 M. Suljic,25,† R. Sultanov,55 M. Šumbera,85 S. Sumowidagdo,50 A. Szabo,38 I. Szarka,38 A. Szczepankiewicz,135 M. Szymanski,135 U. Tabassam,16 J. Takahashi,122 G. J. Tambave,22 N. Tanaka,129 M. Tarhini,52 M. Tariq,18 M. G. Tarzila,79 A. Tauro,35 G. Tejeda Muñoz,2 A. Telesca,35 K. Terasaki,128 C. Terrevoli,29 B. Teyssier,131 J. Thäder,75 D. Thakur,49 D. Thomas,119 R. Tieulent,131 A. Tikhonov,53 A. R. Timmins,123 A. Toia,61 S. Trogolo,26 G. Trombetta,32 V. Trubnikov,3 W. H. Trzaska,124 T. Tsuji,128 A. Tumkin,100 R. Turrisi,108 T. S. Tveter,21 K. Ullaland,22 A. Uras,131 G. L. Usai,24 A. Utrobicic,130 M. Vala,56 L. Valencia Palomo,71 S. Vallero,26 J. Van Der Maarel,54 J. W. Van Hoorne,35,113 M. van Leeuwen,54 T. Vanat,85 P. Vande Vyvre,35 D. Varga,137 A. Vargas,2 M. Vargyas,124 R. Varma,48 M. Vasileiou,90 A. Vasiliev,81 A. Vauthier,72 O. Vázquez Doce,36,95 V. Vechernin,133 A. M. Veen,54 M. Veldhoen,54 A. Velure,22 E. Vercellin,26 S. Vergara Limón,2 R. Vernet,8 M. Verweij,136 L. Vickovic,117 J. Viinikainen,124 Z. Vilakazi,127 O. Villalobos Baillie,102 A. Villatoro Tello,2 A. Vinogradov,81 L. Vinogradov,133 Y. Vinogradov,100,† T. Virgili,30 V. Vislavicius,33 Y. P. Viyogi,134 A. Vodopyanov,67 M. A. Völkl,94 K. Voloshin,55 S. A. Voloshin,136 G. Volpe,32,137 B. von Haller,35 I. Vorobyev,36,95 D. Vranic,35,98 J. Vrláková,40 B. Vulpescu,71 B. Wagner,22 J. Wagner,98 H. Wang,54 M. Wang,7 D. Watanabe,129 Y. Watanabe,128 M. Weber,35,113 S. G. Weber,98 D. F. Weiser,94 J. P. Wessels,62 U. Westerhoff,62 A. M. Whitehead,91 J. Wiechula,34 J. Wikne,21 G. Wilk,78 J. Wilkinson,94 M. C. S. Williams,105 B. Windelband,94 M. Winn,94 P. Yang,7 S. Yano,47 Z. Yasin,16 Z. Yin,7 H. Yokoyama,129 I.-K. Yoo,97 J. H. Yoon,51 V. Yurchenko,3 A. Zaborowska,135 V. Zaccolo,82 A. Zaman,16 C. Zampolli,35,105 H. J. C. Zanoli,121 S. Zaporozhets,67 N. Zardoshti,102 A. Zarochentsev,133 P. Závada,57 N. Zaviyalov,100 H. Zbroszczyk,135 I. S. Zgura,59 M. Zhalov,87 H. Zhang,7,22 X. Zhang,7,75 Y. Zhang,7 C. Zhang,54 Z. Zhang,7 C. Zhao,21 N. Zhigareva,55 D. Zhou,7 Y. Zhou,82 Z. Zhou,22 H. Zhu,7,22 J. Zhu,7,114 A. Zichichi,12,27 A. Zimmermann,94 M. B. Zimmermann,35,62 G. Zinovjev,3 and M. Zyzak42 (ALICE Collaboration) 1 A.I. Alikhanyan National Science Laboratory (Yerevan Physics Institute) Foundation, Yerevan, Armenia 2 Benemérita Universidad Autónoma de Puebla, Puebla, Mexico 3 Bogolyubov Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kiev, Ukraine 4 Bose Institute, Department of Physics and Centre for Astroparticle Physics and Space Science (CAPSS), Kolkata, India 5 Budker Institute for Nuclear Physics, Novosibirsk, Russia 6 California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, California, USA 7 Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China 8 Centre de Calcul de l’IN2P3, Villeurbanne, France 9 Centro de Aplicaciones Tecnológicas y Desarrollo Nuclear (CEADEN), Havana, Cuba 10 Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain 11 Centro de Investigación y de Estudios Avanzados (CINVESTAV), Mexico City and Mérida, Mexico 12 Centro Fermi—Museo Storico della Fisica e Centro Studi e Ricerche “Enrico Fermi”, Rome, Italy 13 Chicago State University, Chicago, Illinois, USA 14 China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing, China 15 Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique, IRFU, Saclay, France 16 COMSATS Institute of Information Technology (CIIT), Islamabad, Pakistan 17 Departamento de Física de Partículas and IGFAE, Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, Spain 18 Department of Physics, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India 19 Department of Physics, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA 20 Department of Physics, Sejong University, Seoul, South Korea 21 Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway 182301-11 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 22 week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 Department of Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università ’La Sapienza’ and Sezione INFN Rome, Italy 24 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Cagliari, Italy 25 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Trieste, Italy 26 Dipartimento di Fisica dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Turin, Italy 27 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Bologna, Italy 28 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Catania, Italy 29 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia dell’Università and Sezione INFN, Padova, Italy 30 Dipartimento di Fisica ‘E.R. Caianiello’ dell’Università and Gruppo Collegato INFN, Salerno, Italy 31 Dipartimento di Scienze e Innovazione Tecnologica dell’Università del Piemonte Orientale and Gruppo Collegato INFN, Alessandria, Italy 32 Dipartimento Interateneo di Fisica ‘M. Merlin’ and Sezione INFN, Bari, Italy 33 Division of Experimental High Energy Physics, University of Lund, Lund, Sweden 34 Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany 35 European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), Geneva, Switzerland 36 Excellence Cluster Universe, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany 37 Faculty of Engineering, Bergen University College, Bergen, Norway 38 Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovakia 39 Faculty of Nuclear Sciences and Physical Engineering, Czech Technical University in Prague, Prague, Czech Republic 40 Faculty of Science, P.J. Šafárik University, Košice, Slovakia 41 Faculty of Technology, Buskerud and Vestfold University College, Vestfold, Norway 42 Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany 43 Gangneung-Wonju National University, Gangneung, South Korea 44 Gauhati University, Department of Physics, Guwahati, India 45 Helmholtz-Institut für Strahlen- und Kernphysik, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn, Bonn, Germany 46 Helsinki Institute of Physics (HIP), Helsinki, Finland 47 Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan 48 Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IIT), Mumbai, India 49 Indian Institute of Technology Indore, Indore (IITI), India 50 Indonesian Institute of Sciences, Jakarta, Indonesia 51 Inha University, Incheon, South Korea 52 Institut de Physique Nucléaire d’Orsay (IPNO), Université Paris-Sud, CNRS-IN2P3, Orsay, France 53 Institute for Nuclear Research, Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia 54 Institute for Subatomic Physics of Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands 55 Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics, Moscow, Russia 56 Institute of Experimental Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Košice, Slovakia 57 Institute of Physics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic 58 Institute of Physics, Bhubaneswar, India 59 Institute of Space Science (ISS), Bucharest, Romania 60 Institut für Informatik, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany 61 Institut für Kernphysik, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany 62 Institut für Kernphysik, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster, Münster, Germany 63 Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico 64 Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico 65 Institut Pluridisciplinaire Hubert Curien (IPHC), Université de Strasbourg, CNRS-IN2P3, Strasbourg, France 66 iThemba LABS, National Research Foundation, Somerset West, South Africa 67 Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR), Dubna, Russia 68 Konkuk University, Seoul, South Korea 69 Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information, Daejeon, South Korea 70 KTO Karatay University, Konya, Turkey 71 Laboratoire de Physique Corpusculaire (LPC), Clermont Université, Université Blaise Pascal, CNRS–IN2P3, Clermont-Ferrand, France 72 Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et de Cosmologie, Université Grenoble-Alpes, CNRS-IN2P3, Grenoble, France 73 Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, INFN, Frascati, Italy 74 Laboratori Nazionali di Legnaro, INFN, Legnaro, Italy 75 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, USA 76 Moscow Engineering Physics Institute, Moscow, Russia 77 Nagasaki Institute of Applied Science, Nagasaki, Japan 23 182301-12 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS PRL 117, 182301 (2016) 78 week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 National Centre for Nuclear Studies, Warsaw, Poland National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest, Romania 80 National Institute of Science Education and Research, Bhubaneswar, India 81 National Research Centre Kurchatov Institute, Moscow, Russia 82 Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark 83 Nikhef, Nationaal instituut voor subatomaire fysica, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 84 Nuclear Physics Group, STFC Daresbury Laboratory, Daresbury, United Kingdom 85 Nuclear Physics Institute, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Řežu Prahy, Czech Republic 86 Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, USA 87 Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute, Gatchina, Russia 88 Physics Department, Creighton University, Omaha, Nebraska, USA 89 Physics Department, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India 90 Physics Department, University of Athens, Athens, Greece 91 Physics Department, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa 92 Physics Department, University of Jammu, Jammu, India 93 Physics Department, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur, India 94 Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany 95 Physik Department, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany 96 Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA 97 Pusan National University, Pusan, South Korea 98 Research Division and ExtreMe Matter Institute EMMI, GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, Darmstadt, Germany 99 Rudjer Bošković Institute, Zagreb, Croatia 100 Russian Federal Nuclear Center (VNIIEF), Sarov, Russia 101 Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics, Kolkata, India 102 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom 103 Sección Física, Departamento de Ciencias, Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, Lima, Peru 104 Sezione INFN, Bari, Italy 105 Sezione INFN, Bologna, Italy 106 Sezione INFN, Cagliari, Italy 107 Sezione INFN, Catania, Italy 108 Sezione INFN, Padova, Italy 109 Sezione INFN, Rome, Italy 110 Sezione INFN, Trieste, Italy 111 Sezione INFN, Turin, Italy 112 SSC IHEP of NRC Kurchatov Institute, Protvino, Russia 113 Stefan Meyer Institut für Subatomare Physik (SMI), Vienna, Austria 114 SUBATECH, Ecole des Mines de Nantes, Université de Nantes, CNRS-IN2P3, Nantes, France 115 Suranaree University of Technology, Nakhon Ratchasima, Thailand 116 Technical University of Košice, Košice, Slovakia 117 Technical University of Split FESB, Split, Croatia 118 The Henryk Niewodniczanski Institute of Nuclear Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Cracow, Poland 119 The University of Texas at Austin, Physics Department, Austin, Texas, USA 120 Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa, Culiacán, Mexico 121 Universidade de S ao Paulo (USP), Sao Paulo, Brazil 122 Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP), Campinas, Brazil 123 University of Houston, Houston, Texas, USA 124 University of Jyväskylä, Jyväskylä, Finland 125 University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom 126 University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee, USA 127 University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa 128 University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan 129 University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan 130 University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia 131 Université de Lyon, Université Lyon 1, CNRS/IN2P3, IPN-Lyon, Villeurbanne, France 132 Università di Brescia, Brescia, Italy 133 V. Fock Institute for Physics, St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, Russia 134 Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre, Kolkata, India 135 Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw, Poland 136 Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, USA 79 182301-13 PRL 117, 182301 (2016) PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS week ending 28 OCTOBER 2016 137 Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary 138 Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA 139 Yonsei University, Seoul, South Korea 140 Zentrum für Technologietransfer und Telekommunikation (ZTT), Fachhochschule Worms, Worms, Germany † Deceased. Also at Georgia State University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA. § Also at Department of Applied Physics, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India. ∥ Also at M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, D.V. Skobeltsyn Institute of Nuclear, Physics, Moscow, Russia. ‡ 182301-14