Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 DOI 10.1140/epjc/s10052-016-4120-y Regular Article - Experimental Physics Muon reconstruction performance √ of the ATLAS detector in proton–proton collision data at s=13 TeV ATLAS Collaboration CERN, 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland Received: 18 March 2016 / Accepted: 29 April 2016 / Published online: 23 May 2016 © CERN for the benefit of the ATLAS collaboration 2016. This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com Abstract This article documents the performance of the ATLAS muon identification and reconstruction using the √ LHC dataset recorded at s = 13 TeV in 2015. Using a large sample of J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ decays from 3.2 fb−1 of pp collision data, measurements of the reconstruction efficiency, as well as of the momentum scale and resolution, are presented and compared to Monte Carlo simulations. The reconstruction efficiency is measured to be close to 99 % over most of the covered phase space (|η| < 2.5 and 5 < pT < 100 GeV). The isolation efficiency varies between 93 and 100 % depending on the selection applied and on the momentum of the muon. Both efficiencies are well reproduced in simulation. In the central region of the detector, the momentum resolution is measured to be 1.7 % (2.3 %) for muons from J/ψ → μμ (Z → μμ) decays, and the momentum scale is known with an uncertainty of 0.05 %. In the region |η| > 2.2, the pT resolution for muons from Z → μμ decays is 2.9 % while the precision of the momentum scale for low- pT muons from J/ψ → μμ decays is about 0.2 %. ments closer to the interaction point. Moreover, the muon reconstruction software was updated and improved. After introducing the ATLAS muon reconstruction and identification algorithms, this article describes the performance of the muon reconstruction in the first dataset collected √ at s = 13 TeV. Measurements of the muon reconstruction and isolation efficiencies and of the momentum scale and resolution are presented. The comparison between data and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation and the determination of the corrections to the simulation used in physics analyses are also discussed. The results are based on the analysis of a large sample of J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ decays reconstructed in 3.2 fb−1 of pp collisions recorded in 2015. This article is structured as follows: Sect. 2 describes the ATLAS subdetectors that are most relevant to this work; Sects. 3 and 5 describe the muon reconstruction and identification in ATLAS, respectively; Sect. 4 describes the data samples used in the analysis; the reconstruction and isolation efficiencies are described in Sects. 6 and 7, respectively, while the momentum scale and resolution are described in Sect. 8. Finally, conclusions are given in Sect. 9. 1 Introduction 2 ATLAS detector Muons are key to some of the most important physics results published by the ATLAS experiment [1] at the LHC. These results include the discovery of the Higgs boson [2] and the measurement of its properties [3–5], the precise measurement of Standard Model processes [6,7], and searches for physics beyond the Standard Model [8–11]. The performance of the ATLAS muon reconstruction dur√ ing the LHC run at s = 7–8 TeV has been documented in recent publications [12,13]. During the 2013–2015 shutdown, the LHC was upgraded to increase the centre-of-mass energy from 8 to 13 TeV and the ATLAS detector was equipped with additional muon chambers and a new innermost Pixel layer, the Insertable B-Layer, providing measure e-mail: atlas.publications@cern.ch A detailed description of the ATLAS detector can be found in Ref. [1]. Information primarily from the inner detector (ID) and the muon spectrometer (MS), supplemented by information from the calorimeters, is used to identify and precisely reconstruct muons produced in pp collisions. The ID consists of three subdetectors: the silicon pixels (Pixel) and the semiconductor tracker (SCT) with a pseudorapidity1 coverage up to |η| = 2.5, and the transition radi1 ATLAS uses a right-handed coordinate system with its origin at the nominal interaction point (IP) in the centre of the detector and the z-axis along the beam pipe. The x-axis points from the IP to the centre of the LHC ring, and the y-axis points upward. Cylindrical coordinates (r, φ) are used in the transverse plane, φ being the azimuthal angle around the beam pipe. The pseudorapidity and the transverse momentum are defined in terms of the polar angle θ as η = − ln tan(θ/2) and pT = 123 292 Page 2 of 30 ation tracker (TRT) with a pseudorapidity coverage up to |η| = 2.0. The ID measures the muon track close to the interaction point, providing accurate measurements of the track parameters inside an axial magnetic field of 2 T. The MS is the outermost ATLAS subdetector. It is designed to detect muons in the pseudorapidity region up to |η| = 2.7, and to provide momentum measurements with a relative resolution better than 3 % over a wide pT range and up to 10 % at pT ≈ 1 TeV. The MS consists of one barrel (|η| < 1.05) and two endcap sections (1.05 < |η| < 2.7). A system of three large superconducting air-core toroidal magnets, each with eight coils, provides a magnetic field with a bending integral of about 2.5 Tm in the barrel and up to 6 Tm in the endcaps. Resistive plate chambers (RPC, three doublet layers for |η| < 1.05) and thin gap chambers (TGC, one triplet layer followed by two doublets for 1.0 < |η| < 2.4) provide triggering capability to the detector as well as (η, φ) position measurements with typical spatial resolution of 5–10 mm. A precise momentum measurement for muons with pseudorapidity up to |η| = 2.7 is provided by three layers of monitored drift tube chambers (MDT), with each chamber providing six to eight η measurements along the muon trajectory. For |η| > 2, the inner layer is instrumented with a quadruplet of cathode strip chambers (CSC) instead of MDTs. The single-hit resolution in the bending plane for the MDT and the CSC is about 80 and 60 µm, respectively. The muon chambers are aligned with a precision between 30 and 60 µm. During the shutdown preceding the LHC Run 2, the MS was completed to its initial design [14] by adding the last missing chambers in the transition region between the barrel and the endcaps (1.0 < |η| < 1.4). Four RPC-equipped MDT chambers were also installed inside two elevator shafts to improve the acceptance in that region compared to Run 1. Some of the new MDT chambers are made of tubes with a smaller radius compared to the ones used in the rest of the detector, allowing the detector to cope with higher rates. The material between the interaction point (IP) and the MS ranges approximately from 100 to 190 radiation lengths, depending on η, and consists mostly of calorimeters. The lead/liquid-argon electromagnetic calorimeter covers |η| < 3.2. It is surrounded by hadronic calorimeters made of steel and scintillator tiles for |η| < 1.7, and copper or tungsten and liquid argon for |η| > 1.7. 3 Muon reconstruction Muon reconstruction is first performed independently in the ID and MS. The information from individual subdetectors is then combined to form the muon tracks that are used in p sin θ, respectively. The η–φ distance between two particles is defined as R = (η)2 + (φ)2 . 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 physics analyses. In the ID, muons are reconstructed like any other charged particles as described in Refs. [15,16]. This section focuses on the description of the muon reconstruction in the MS (Sect. 3.1) and on the combined muon reconstruction (Sect. 3.2). 3.1 Muon reconstruction in the MS Muon reconstruction in the MS starts with a search for hit patterns inside each muon chamber to form segments. In each MDT chamber and nearby trigger chamber, a Hough transform [17] is used to search for hits aligned on a trajectory in the bending plane of the detector. The MDT segments are reconstructed by performing a straight-line fit to the hits found in each layer. The RPC or TGC hits measure the coordinate orthogonal to the bending plane. Segments in the CSC detectors are built using a separate combinatorial search in the η and φ detector planes. The search algorithm includes a loose requirement on the compatibility of the track with the luminous region. Muon track candidates are then built by fitting together hits from segments in different layers. The algorithm used for this task performs a segment-seeded combinatorial search that starts by using as seeds the segments generated in the middle layers of the detector where more trigger hits are available. The search is then extended to use the segments from the outer and inner layers as seeds. The segments are selected using criteria based on hit multiplicity and fit quality and are matched using their relative positions and angles. At least two matching segments are required to build a track, except in the barrel–endcap transition region where a single highquality segment with η and φ information can be used to build a track. The same segment can initially be used to build several track candidates. Later, an overlap removal algorithm selects the best assignment to a single track, or allows for the segment to be shared between two tracks. To ensure high efficiency for close-by muons, all tracks with segments in three different layers of the spectrometer are kept when they are identical in two out of three layers but share no hits in the outermost layer. The hits associated with each track candidate are fitted using a global χ 2 fit. A track candidate is accepted if the χ 2 of the fit satisfies the selection criteria. Hits providing large contributions to the χ 2 are removed and the track fit is repeated. A hit recovery procedure is also performed looking for additional hits consistent with the candidate trajectory. The track candidate is refit if additional hits are found. 3.2 Combined reconstruction The combined ID–MS muon reconstruction is performed according to various algorithms based on the information Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 provided by the ID, MS, and calorimeters. Four muon types are defined depending on which subdetectors are used in reconstruction: • Combined (CB) muon: track reconstruction is performed independently in the ID and MS, and a combined track is formed with a global refit that uses the hits from both the ID and MS subdetectors. During the global fit procedure, MS hits may be added to or removed from the track to improve the fit quality. Most muons are reconstructed following an outside-in pattern recognition, in which the muons are first reconstructed in the MS and then extrapolated inward and matched to an ID track. An inside-out combined reconstruction, in which ID tracks are extrapolated outward and matched to MS tracks, is used as a complementary approach. • Segment-tagged (ST) muons: a track in the ID is classified as a muon if, once extrapolated to the MS, it is associated with at least one local track segment in the MDT or CSC chambers. ST muons are used when muons cross only one layer of MS chambers, either because of their low pT or because they fall in regions with reduced MS acceptance. • Calorimeter-tagged (CT) muons: a track in the ID is identified as a muon if it can be matched to an energy deposit in the calorimeter compatible with a minimum-ionizing particle. This type has the lowest purity of all the muon types but it recovers acceptance in the region where the ATLAS muon spectrometer is only partially instrumented to allow for cabling and services to the calorimeters and inner detector. The identification criteria for CT muons are optimised for that region (|η| < 0.1) and a momentum range of 15 < pT < 100 GeV. • Extrapolated (ME) muons: the muon trajectory is reconstructed based only on the MS track and a loose requirement on compatibility with originating from the IP. The parameters of the muon track are defined at the interaction point, taking into account the estimated energy loss of the muon in the calorimeters. In general, the muon is required to traverse at least two layers of MS chambers to provide a track measurement, but three layers are required in the forward region. ME muons are mainly used to extend the acceptance for muon reconstruction into the region 2.5 < |η| < 2.7, which is not covered by the ID. Overlaps between different muon types are resolved before producing the collection of muons used in physics analyses. When two muon types share the same ID track, preference is given to CB muons, then to ST, and finally to CT muons. The overlap with ME muons in the muon system is resolved by analyzing the track hit content and selecting the track with better fit quality and larger number of hits. Page 3 of 30 292 The muon reconstruction used in this work evolved from the algorithms defined as Chain 3 in Ref. [12]. These algorithms were improved in several ways. The use of a Hough transform to identify the hit patterns for seeding the segmentfinding algorithm makes the reconstruction faster and more robust against misidentification of hadrons, thus providing better background rejection early in the pattern recognition process. The calculation of the energy loss in the calorimeter was also improved. An analytic parameterization of the average energy loss is derived from a detailed description of the detector geometry. The final estimate of the energy loss is obtained by combining the analytic parameterization with the energy measured in the calorimeter. This method yields a precision on the mean energy loss of about 30 MeV for 50 GeV muons. 4 Data and Monte Carlo samples The efficiency measurements presented in this article are obtained from the analysis of 3.2 fb−1 of pp collision data √ recorded at s = 13 TeV at the LHC in 2015 during the data-taking period with 25 ns spacing between bunch crossings. About 1.5 M Z → μμ and 3.5 M J/ψ → μμ events are reconstructed and used for the analysis. For the study of the momentum calibration, 2.7 fb−1 of data were used, rejecting the runs in which the longitudinal position of the beam spot was displaced by about 3 cm with respect to the centre of the detector. Events are accepted only if the ID, the MS, and the calorimeters were operational and the solenoid and toroid magnet systems were both active. The online event selection was performed by a two-level trigger system derived from the one described in Ref. [18]. The Z → μμ candidates are triggered by the presence of at least one muon candidate with a transverse momentum, pT , of at least 20 GeV. For the reconstruction efficiency and momentum calibration studies, the muon firing the trigger is required to be isolated (see Sect. 7). The J/ψ → μμ candidates used for the momentum calibration are triggered by a dedicated dimuon trigger that requires two opposite-charge muons, each with pT > 4 GeV, compatible with the same vertex, and with a dimuon invariant mass in the range 2.5–4.5 GeV. The J/ψ → μμ sample used for the efficiency measurement is selected using a combination of single-muon triggers and triggers requiring one muon with transverse momentum of at least 4 GeV and an ID track such that the invariant mass of the muon+track pair, under a muon mass hypothesis, is compatible with the mass of the J/ψ. Monte Carlo samples for the process pp → (Z /γ ∗ )X → μμX are generated using the POWHEG BOX [19] interfaced to PYTHIA8 [20] and the CT10 [21] parton distribution functions. The PHOTOS [22] package is used to simulate final-state photon radiation in Z 123 292 Page 4 of 30 boson decays. Samples of prompt J/ψ → μμ decays are generated using PYTHIA8 complemented with PHOTOS to simulate the effects of final-state radiation. A requirement on the minimum transverse momentum of each muon ( pT > 4 GeV) is applied at the generator level. The samples used for the simulation of the backgrounds to Z → μμ include: Z → τ τ , W → μν, and W → τ ν, generated with POWHEG BOX; W W , Z Z , and W Z generated with SHERPA [23]; t t¯ samples generated with POWHEG BOX + PYTHIA8; and bb̄ and cc̄ samples generated with PYTHIA8. All the generated samples are passed through the simulation of the ATLAS detector based on GEANT4 [24,25] and are reconstructed with the same programs used for the data. The ID and the MS are simulated with an ideal geometry assuming no misalignment. The effect of multiple pp interactions per bunch crossing (“pile-up”) is modelled by overlaying simulated minimumbias events onto the original hard-scattering event. Monte Carlo events are then reweighted so that the distribution of the average number of interactions per event agrees with the data. 5 Muon identification Muon identification is performed by applying quality requirements that suppress background, mainly from pion and kaon decays, while selecting prompt muons with high efficiency and/or guaranteeing a robust momentum measurement. Muon candidates originating from in-flight decays of charged hadrons in the ID are often characterized by the presence of a distinctive “kink” topology in the reconstructed track. As a consequence, it is expected that the fit quality of the resulting combined track will be poor and that the momentum measured in the ID and MS may not be compatible. Several variables offering good discrimination between prompt muons and background muon candidates are studied in simulated t t¯ events. Muons from W decays are categorized as signal muons while muon candidates from light-hadron decays are categorized as background. For CB tracks, the variables used in muon identification are: • q/p significance, defined as the absolute value of the difference between the ratio of the charge and momentum of the muons measured in the ID and MS divided by the sum in quadrature of the corresponding uncertainties; • ρ , defined as the absolute value of the difference between the transverse momentum measurements in the ID and MS divided by the pT of the combined track; • normalised χ 2 of the combined track fit. 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 To guarantee a robust momentum measurement, specific requirements on the number of hits in the ID and MS are used. For the ID, the quality cuts require at least one Pixel hit, at least five SCT hits, fewer than three Pixel or SCT holes, and that at least 10 % of the TRT hits originally assigned to the track are included in the final fit; the last requirement is only employed for |η| between 0.1 and 1.9, in the region of full TRT acceptance. A hole is defined as an active sensor traversed by the track but containing no hits. A missing hit is considered a hole only when it falls between hits successfully assigned to a given track. If some inefficiency is expected for a given sensor, the requirements on the number of Pixel and SCT hits are reduced accordingly. Four muon identification selections (Medium, Loose, Tight, and High-pT ) are provided to address the specific needs of different physics analyses. Loose, Medium, and Tight are inclusive categories in that muons identified with tighter requirements are also included in the looser categories. Medium muons The Medium identification criteria provide the default selection for muons in ATLAS. This selection minimises the systematic uncertainties associated with muon reconstruction and calibration. Only CB and ME tracks are used. The former are required to have ≥3 hits in at least two MDT layers, except for tracks in the |η| < 0.1 region, where tracks with at least one MDT layer but no more than one MDT hole layer are allowed. The latter are required to have at least three MDT/CSC layers, and are employed only in the 2.5 < |η| < 2.7 region to extend the acceptance outside the ID geometrical coverage. A loose selection on the compatibility between ID and MS momentum measurements is applied to suppress the contamination due to hadrons misidentified as muons. Specifically, the q/p significance is required to be less than seven. In the pseudorapidity region |η| < 2.5, about 0.5 % of the muons classified as Medium originate from the inside-out combined reconstruction strategy. Loose muons The Loose identification criteria are designed to maximise the reconstruction efficiency while providing good-quality muon tracks. They are specifically optimised for reconstructing Higgs boson candidates in the four-lepton final state [5]. All muon types are used. All CB and ME muons satisfying the Medium requirements are included in the Loose selection. CT and ST muons are restricted to the |η| < 0.1 region. In the region |η| < 2.5, about 97.5 % of the Loose muons are combined muons, approximately 1.5 % are CT, and the remaining 1 % are reconstructed as ST muons. Tight muons Tight muons are selected to maximise the purity of muons at the cost of some efficiency. Only CB muons with hits in at least two stations of the MS and satisfying the Medium selection criteria are considered. The normalised χ 2 of the combined track fit is required to be <8 to remove pathological tracks. A two-dimensional cut in the ρ and q/p significance variables is performed as a function of the muon Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 5 of 30 292 Table 1 Efficiency for prompt muons from W decays and hadrons decaying in-flight and misidentified as prompt muons computed using a t t¯ MC sample. The results are shown for the four identification selection criteria separating low (4 < pT < 20 GeV) and high (20 < pT < 100 GeV) momentum muons for candidates with |η| < 2.5. The statistical uncertainties are negligible Selection 4 < pT < 20 GeV MC μ [%] MC Hadrons [%] A different methodology, described in Sect. 6.2, is used in the region 2.5 < |η| < 2.7 where muons are reconstructed using only the MS detector. 6.1 Efficiency measurement in the region |η| < 2.5 20 < pT < 100 GeV MC μ [%] MC Hadrons [%] Loose 96.7 0.53 98.1 0.76 Medium 95.5 0.38 96.1 0.17 Tight 89.9 0.19 91.8 0.11 High-pT 78.1 0.26 80.4 0.13 pT to ensure stronger background rejection for momenta below 20 GeV where the misidentification probability is higher. High-pT muons The High-pT selection aims to maximise the momentum resolution for tracks with transverse momentum above 100 GeV. The selection is optimised for searches for high-mass Z and W resonances [8,9]. CB muons passing the Medium selection and having at least three hits in three MS stations are selected. Specific regions of the MS where the alignment is suboptimal are vetoed as a precaution. Requiring three MS stations, while reducing the reconstruction efficiency by about 20 %, improves the pT resolution of muons above 1.5 TeV by approximately 30 %. The reconstruction efficiencies for signal and background obtained from tt simulation are reported in Table 1. The results are shown for the four identification selection criteria separating low (4 < pT < 20 GeV) and high (20 < pT < 100 GeV) transverse momentum muon candidates. No isolation requirement is applied in the selection shown in the table. When isolation requirements are applied, the misidentification rates are reduced by more than an order of magnitude. It should be noted that the higher misidentification rate observed for Loose with respect to Medium muons is mainly due to CT muons in the region |η| < 0.1. The misidentification probability estimated with the MC simulation is validated in data by measuring the probability that pions are reconstructed as muons. An unbiased sample of pions from K S0 → π + π − decays is collected with calorimeter-based (photon, electron, jet) triggers. Good agreement between data and simulation is observed independent of the pT , η, and impact parameter of the track. The tag-and-probe method is employed to measure the efficiency of the muon identification selections within the acceptance of the ID (|η| < 2.5). The method is based on the selection of an almost pure muon sample from J/ψ → μμ or Z → μμ events, requiring one leg of the decay (tag) to be identified as a Medium muon that fires the trigger and the second leg (probe) to be reconstructed by a system independent of the one being studied. A selection based on the event topology is used to reduce the background contamination. Three kinds of probes are used to measure muon efficiencies. ID tracks and CT muons both allow a measurement of the efficiency in the MS, while MS tracks are used to determine the complementary efficiency of the muon reconstruction in the ID. Compared to ID tracks, CT muons offer a more powerful rejection of backgrounds, especially at low transverse momenta, and are therefore the preferred probe type for this part of the measurement. ID tracks are used as a cross-check and for measurements not directly accessible to CT muons. A direct measurement of the CT muon reconstruction efficiency is possible using MS tracks. The efficiency measurement for Medium, Tight, and High-pT muons consists of two stages. First, the efficiency (X|CT) (X = Medium/Tight/High-pT ) of reconstructing these muons assuming a reconstructed ID track is measured using a CT muon as probe. Then, this result is corrected by the efficiency (ID|MS) of the ID track reconstruction, measured using MS probes: (X) = (X|ID) · (ID) = (X|CT) · (ID|MS) (X = Medium/Tight/High-pT ). (1) A similar approach is used when using ID probe tracks for cross-checks. This approach is valid if two assumptions are satisfied: • the ID track reconstruction efficiency is independent from the muon spectrometer track reconstruction ( (ID) = (ID|MS)). • the use of a CT muon as a probe instead of an ID track does not affect the probability for Medium, Tight, or High-pT reconstruction ( (X|ID) = (X|CT)). 6 Reconstruction efficiency As the muon reconstruction in the ID and MS detectors is performed independently, a precise determination of the muon reconstruction efficiency in the region |η| < 2.5 is obtained with the tag-and-probe method, as described in the Sect. 6.1. Both assumptions have been tested using generator-level information from simulation and small differences are taken into account in the systematic uncertainties. The muons selected by the Loose identification requirements are decomposed into two samples: CT muons within 123 292 Page 6 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 |η| < 0.1 and all other muons. The CT muon efficiency is measured using MS probe tracks, while the efficiency of other muons is evaluated using CT probe muons in a fashion similar to the Medium, Tight, and High-pT categories. The level of agreement of the measured efficiency, Data (X), with the efficiency measured with the same method in simulation, MC (X), is expressed as the ratio of these two numbers, called the “efficiency scale factor” (SF): SF = Data (X) MC (X) . Z ,t t¯ MC Z ,t t¯ MC Data + T · NSC − NSC N Bkg = NOC (3) (2) This quantity describes the deviation of the simulation from the real detector behaviour, and is of particular interest to physics analyses, where it is used to correct the simulation. 6.1.1 The tag-and-probe method with Z → μμ events Events are selected by requiring muon pairs with an invariant mass within 10 GeV of the Z boson mass. The tag muon is required to satisfy the Loose isolation (see Sect. 7.2) and Medium muon identification selections and to have a transverse momentum of at least 24 GeV. Requirements on the significance of the transverse impact parameter d0 (|d0 |/σ (d0 ) < 3.0) and on the longitudinal impact parameter |z 0 | (|z 0 | < 10 mm) of the tag muon are imposed. Finally, the tag muon is required to have triggered the readout of the event. The probe muon is required to have a transverse momentum of at least 10 GeV and to satisfy the Loose isolation criteria. While this is sufficient to ensure high purity in the case of MS probe tracks, further requirements are applied to both the ID track and CT muon probes. In the case of ID tracks, an isolation requirement is applied which is considerably stricter than the Loose selection in order to suppress backgrounds as much as possible. In addition, the invariant mass window is tightened to 5 GeV around the Z boson mass, rather than the 10 GeV used in the other cases. For CT muon probes, additional requirements on the compatibility of the associated calorimeter energy deposit with a muon signature are applied to further enhance the purity. The ID probe tracks and calorimeter-tagged probe muons must also have transverse and longitudinal impact parameters consistent with being produced in a primary pp interaction, as required for tag muons. A probe is considered successfully reconstructed if a reconstructed muon is found within a cone in the η–φ plane of size R = 0.05 around the probe track. A small fraction (about 0.1 %) of the selected tag–probe pairs originates from sources other than Z → μμ events. For a precise efficiency measurement, these backgrounds must be estimated and subtracted. Contributions from Z → τ τ and t t¯ decays are estimated using simulation. Additionally, multijet events and W → μν decays in association with 123 jet activity (W +jets) can yield tag–probe pairs through secondary muons from heavy- or light-hadron decays. As these backgrounds are approximately charge-symmetric, they are estimated from the data using same-charge (SC) tag–probe pairs. This leads to the following estimate of the oppositecharge (OC) background, N Bkg , for each region of the kinematic phase-space: Z ,t t¯ MC where NOC is the contribution from Z → τ τ and t t¯ Data is the number of SC pairs measured in data decays, NSC Z ,t t¯ MC and NSC is the estimated contribution of the Z → μμ, Z → τ τ , and t t¯ processes to the SC sample. T is a global transfer factor that takes into account the charge asymmetry of the multijet and W +jets processes, estimated in data using a control sample of events obtained by inverting the probe isolation requirement. For MS (ID) tracks, a value of T = 1.7 (1.1) is obtained, while for calorimeter-tagged muon probes the transfer factor is T = 1.2. The systematic uncertainties in the transfer factor vary between 40 % and 100 % and are included in the systematic error in the reconstruction efficiency described in Sect. 6.1.3. The efficiency measured in the data is corrected for the background contributions described above by subtracting the predicted probe yields attributed to these sources from the number of observed probes, Bkg = NRData − NR Bkg NPData − NP , (4) where NP denotes the total number of probes and NR the number of successfully reconstructed probes. The resulting efficiency can then be compared directly to the result of the simulation. 6.1.2 The tag-and-probe method with J/ψ → μμ events The reconstruction efficiencies of the Loose, Medium, and Tight muon selections at low pT are measured from a sample of J/ψ → μμ events selected using a combination of single-muon triggers and the dedicated “muon + track” trigger described in Sect. 4. Tag–probe pairs are selected within the invariant mass window of 2.7–3.5 GeV and requiring a transverse momentum of at least 5 GeV for each muon. The tag muon is required to satisfy the Medium muon identification selection and to have triggered the readout of the event. In order to avoid lowmomentum curved tracks sharing the same trigger region, tag and probe muons are required to be R > 0.2 apart when extrapolated to the MS trigger surfaces. Finally, they 103 2 10 Page 7 of 30 292 ATLAS Relative Uncertainty [%] Relative Uncertainty [%] Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Medium muons s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Total Z→ μμ Truth Closure Background 10 Statistics Statistics (MC) 1 10−1 10−2 103 ATLAS Medium muons s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 2 10 J/ ψ →μμ 10 Truth closure Background Signal Statistics (MC) Statistics Total 1 10−1 10−2 10−−32.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 10−−32.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 η 1.5 2 2.5 η tag probe are selected with z 0 ≡ |z 0 − z 0 | < 5 mm, to suppress background. A probe is considered successfully reconstructed if a selected muon is found within a R = 0.05 cone around the probe track. The background contamination and the muon reconstruction efficiency are measured with a simultaneous maximumlikelihood fit of two statistically independent distributions of the invariant mass: events in which the probe is or is not successfully matched to the selected muon. The fits are performed in six pT and nine η bins of the probe tracks. The signal is modelled with a Crystal Ball function [26] with a single set of parameters for the two independent samples. Separate first-order polynomial fits are used to describe the background shape for matched and unmatched probes. Relative Uncertainty [%] Fig. 1 Total uncertainty in the efficiency scale factor for Medium muons as a function of η as obtained from Z → μμ data (left) for muons with pT > 10 GeV, and from J/ψ → μμ data (right) for muons with 5 < pT < 20 GeV. The combined uncertainty is the sum in quadrature of the individual contributions 3 10 2 10 10 ATLAS -1 s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb Medium muons J/ ψ →μμ Truth closure Background Signal Statistics (MC) Statistics Total Z→μμ Truth closure Background Statistics (MC) Statistics Total 1 10−1 10−2 6 7 8 910 20 30 102 40 50 60 p [GeV] T 6.1.3 Systematic uncertainties Fig. 2 Total uncertainty in the efficiency scale factor for Medium muons as a function of pT as obtained from Z → μμ (solid lines) and J/ψ → μμ (dashed lines) decays. The combined uncertainty is the sum in quadrature of the individual contributions The main contributions to the systematic uncertainty in the measurement of the efficiency SFs with Z → μμ and J/ψ → μμ events are shown in Figs. 1 and 2, as a function of η and pT , respectively. The uncertainty in the background estimate is evaluated in the Z → μμ analysis by taking the maximum variation of the transfer factor T when estimated with a simulation-based approach as described in Ref. [12] and when assuming the background to be charge-symmetric. This results in an uncertainty of the efficiency measurement below 0.1 % over a large momentum range, but reaching ∼1 % for low muon momenta where the contribution of the background is most significant. In the J/ψ → μμ analysis, the background uncertainty is estimated by changing the function used in the fit to model the background, replacing the first-order polynomial with an exponential function. An uncertainty due to the signal modelling in the fit, labelled as “Signal” in Figs. 1 and 2, is also estimated using a convolution of exponential and Gaussian functions as an alternative model. Each uncertainty is about 0.1 %. The cone size used for matching selected muons to probe tracks is optimised in terms of efficiency and purity of the matching. The systematic uncertainty deriving from this choice is evaluated by varying the cone size by ±50 %. This yields an uncertainty below 0.1 % in both analyses. Possible biases in the tag-and-probe method, such as biases due to different kinematic distributions between reconstructed probes and generated muons or correlations between ID and MS efficiencies, are estimated in simulation by comparing the efficiency measured with the tag-and-probe method with the “true” efficiency given by the fraction of generator-level muons that are successfully reconstructed. This uncertainty is labelled as “Truth Closure” in Figs. 1 and 2. In the Z → μμ analysis, agreement better than 0.1 % is observed in the high momentum range. This uncertainty 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Efficiency 292 Page 8 of 30 1 0.98 0.96 0.65 ATLAS Z→μμ s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Data / MC Data Medium muons 0.6 MC Loose muons (|η| < 0.1) 1.02 Stat only Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.98 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 1 Efficiency Efficiency η 0.95 0.9 0.6 0.55 0.5 0.45 1.05 0.5 ATLAS ATLAS Z→μμ Z→μμ s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Data s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Data Tight muons MC High-p T muons MC Stat only Data / MC Data / MC 0.85 1 Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.95 1.1 Stat only Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.9 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 η η Fig. 3 Muon reconstruction efficiency as a function of η measured in Z → μμ events for muons with pT > 10 GeV shown for Medium (top), Tight (bottom left), and High-pT (bottom right) muon selections. In addition, the top plot also shows the efficiency of the Loose selection (squares) in the region |η| < 0.1 where the Loose and Medium selections differ significantly. The error bars on the efficiencies indicate the statistical uncertainty. Panels at the bottom show the ratio of the measured to predicted efficiencies, with statistical and systematic uncertainties grows at low pT , and differences up to 0.7 % are found in the J/ψ → μμ analysis. A larger effect of up to 1–2 % is measured in both analyses in the region |η| < 0.1. In the extraction of the efficiency scale factors, the difference between the measured and the “true” efficiency cancels to first order. To take into account possible imperfections of the simulation, half of the observed difference is used as an additional systematic uncertainty in the SF. No significant dependence of the measured SFs with pT is observed in the momentum range considered in the Z → μμ analysis. An upper limit on the SF variation for large muon momenta is extracted from simulation, leading to an additional uncertainty of 2–3 % per TeV for muons with pT > 200 GeV. The efficiency scale factor is observed to be independent of the amount of pile-up. muon selections. The efficiency as measured in data and the corresponding scale factors for the Medium selection are also shown in Fig. 4 as a function of η and φ. The efficiency at low pT is reported in Fig. 5 as measured from J/ψ → μμ events as a function of pT in different η regions. The efficiencies of the Loose and Medium selections are very similar throughout the detector with the exception of the region |η| < 0.1, where the Loose selection fills the MS acceptance gap using the calorimeter and segment-tagged muons contributions. The efficiency of these selections is observed to be in excess of 98 %, and between 90 and 98 % for the Tight selection, with all efficiencies in very good agreement with those predicted by the simulation. An inefficiency due to a poorly aligned MDT chamber is clearly localised at (η, φ) ∼ (−1.3, 1.6), and is the most significant feature of the comparison between collision data and simulation for these three categories. In addition, a 2 %-level local inefficiency is visible in the region (η, φ) ∼ (1.9, 2.5), traced to temporary failures in the SCT readout system. Further local inefficiencies in the barrel region around φ ∼ −1.1 are also 6.1.4 Results Figure 3 shows the muon reconstruction efficiency as a function of η as measured from Z → μμ events for the different 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 ATLAS -1 s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb 99.4 3 98.3 98.9 99.3 Medium muons 99.4 99.7 98.9 99.2 99.7 99.5 99.4 99.4 7.9 98.3 99.5 99.4 99.5 99.6 99.3 99.4 98.9 98.5 98.6 99.2 99.7 99.5 99.4 98.6 99.3 99.2 99.4 81.9 99.1 99.1 99.4 98.7 99.4 99.4 100.0 98.1 99.2 98.8 98.5 98.5 99.2 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.6 99.6 98.1 2.7 97.4 99.7 99.5 99.5 99.8 99.4 99.7 97.7 99.2 98.6 2 98.5 99.5 99.2 99.4 99.2 98.8 98.9 99.4 99.2 99.3 86.1 99.1 99.2 99.1 98.5 99.1 99.2 99.6 99.1 99.6 98.7 98.4 98.6 99.4 98.9 100.0 97.5 82.1 99.4 99.4 99.6 99.5 44.9 99.5 99.7 99.6 99.5 99.4 98.6 99.7 98.9 99.7 98.1 98.7 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.1 95.8 98.3 99.2 98.2 99.0 90.3 99.2 99.3 99.3 98.4 99.5 98.9 99.5 99.3 99.6 98.8 99.0 99.7 99.6 98.3 98.6 98.5 98.6 98.6 60.8 98.6 99.4 99.1 99.4 99.5 99.6 99.5 99.4 99.5 98.5 98.8 99.4 98.9 99.5 99.5 99.2 98.5 99.2 99.0 99.0 91.2 99.3 98.9 99.0 98.2 99.3 99.6 99.6 99.3 99.7 98.7 97.7 98.9 99.0 99.5 99.4 98.9 99.4 99.3 99.3 99.5 55.2 99.6 99.7 99.5 99.7 99.1 99.5 99.6 99.3 99.5 98.2 98.4 99.4 99.3 99.6 99.4 99.2 98.8 99.2 99.2 99.4 87.9 99.3 99.5 99.2 98.5 99.1 99.3 99.5 99.5 99.6 99.1 99.0 99.5 −1 98.5 99.5 99.4 99.8 99.4 98.2 99.6 99.4 99.5 99.5 16.2 99.5 99.4 99.5 99.4 98.6 99.2 99.7 99.0 99.5 98.3 99.2 99.4 99.1 98.9 98.6 94.0 98.8 97.8 86.8 97.6 98.6 87.4 98.5 98.8 99.0 99.7 99.2 99.5 99.0 98.1 1 97.9 98.8 0 99.4 99.3 99.7 99.5 99.3 99.4 98.7 99.5 99.3 61.8 99.3 99.5 99.5 99.4 99.8 99.7 99.5 99.3 99.5 98.8 −2 99.0 99.5 99.2 99.6 99.3 98.9 98.6 97.5 99.1 97.7 86.4 97.7 98.9 98.2 98.5 98.7 99.0 99.4 99.2 99.6 98.9 98.7 99.0 99.0 99.9 99.3 98.4 99.0 99.0 98.8 98.9 17.0 98.4 98.4 98.5 99.0 98.5 99.5 99.6 99.2 99.5 99.1 98.9 99.6 99.1 99.2 99.5 98.9 98.6 99.2 99.0 99.3 84.4 99.3 99.2 99.4 99.0 99.3 99.6 99.5 99.1 99.4 98.8 −3 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 100 80 60 40 Data Efficiency [%] φ Fig. 4 Reconstruction efficiency measured in data (top), and the data/MC efficiency scale factor (bottom) for Medium muons as a function of η and φ for muons with pT > 10 GeV in Z → μμ events. The thin white bins visible in the region |φ| ∼ π are due to the different bin boundaries in φ in the endcap and barrel regions Page 9 of 30 292 20 0 2.5 η 99.5 3 98.7 99.4 99.5 Medium muons 99.8 100.0 99.8 99.7 99.7 100.1 100.1 99.8 99.8 99.9 100.2 99.7 99.7 99.3 98.6 98.9 99.7 99.7 99.8 99.5 99.6 99.6 99.8 99.9 100.3 99.9 100.2 98.5 99.4 99.1 99.5 99.7 100.1 99.8 100.0 99.9 100.2 90.6 99.3 99.9 99.7 99.8 100.6 99.9 100.0 98.1 99.4 98.9 99.7 99.8 99.6 99.8 99.8 99.6 99.7 99.3 99.6 99.6 99.5 99.5 100.1 99.8 99.9 99.5 99.8 99.0 99.4 100.0 99.3 99.9 98.5 99.8 99.9 99.6 100.0 99.9 100.0 99.6 98.6 98.9 2 98.9 99.7 99.7 98.8 99.3 98.9 99.7 99.3 100.3 98.2 82.6 99.8 99.7 99.9 99.8 101.1 99.8 100.0 99.8 99.7 99.0 99.5 99.8 99.7 99.7 96.5 99.4 99.6 98.6 99.3 99.7 99.6 99.8 99.7 99.4 100.5 99.5 99.8 99.8 99.8 99.3 99.5 99.9 99.9 99.0 99.0 98.9 98.9 99.1 98.7 99.0 99.8 99.5 99.7 100.0 100.0 99.8 99.8 99.8 99.0 99.6 99.3 99.8 100.0 99.8 99.4 99.7 99.4 99.3 99.3 99.7 99.3 99.4 99.2 100.2 100.1 99.9 99.7 99.8 99.0 0 98.0 99.1 1 98.3 99.1 99.0 99.9 99.9 99.8 99.7 99.6 98.6 99.6 100.0 99.8 99.8 99.8 99.8 99.4 99.7 99.9 99.5 99.6 98.6 99.7 99.9 99.7 99.7 99.3 99.8 100.3 100.1 99.8 99.7 99.8 99.1 99.7 99.6 99.8 99.2 99.9 99.6 99.8 99.6 99.9 100.1 100.0 99.7 99.5 99.6 99.1 99.4 99.7 99.9 99.6 99.8 99.6 99.5 100.0 99.6 99.8 100.0 99.8 100.0 99.9 98.7 99.6 99.7 99.8 99.9 99.8 99.8 99.6 99.6 99.7 99.3 99.7 99.9 99.6 99.4 99.7 −1 98.8 99.7 99.9 100.0 99.8 99.1 100.0 99.8 99.8 99.9 103.4 99.8 99.8 100.0 99.8 99.5 99.6 99.6 99.7 99.6 99.0 94.9 99.3 99.7 100.0 99.4 99.1 88.1 98.9 99.7 98.4 99.6 99.6 99.8 99.8 99.9 99.8 99.1 99.8 99.6 100.6 99.6 99.8 99.8 99.3 99.7 99.6 99.9 100.0 99.6 99.1 98.3 99.7 99.7 99.1 99.6 99.5 99.0 98.9 99.5 99.6 99.1 99.4 99.5 100.2 99.7 99.2 99.3 99.3 99.2 99.3 105.3 98.7 98.8 98.8 99.4 99.4 99.9 99.2 99.8 99.5 99.5 99.6 99.5 99.6 99.5 99.6 98.8 99.6 99.6 99.8 −2 −3 −2.5 −2 99.9 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 110 100 90 Data/MC [%] φ ATLAS s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 80 70 60 2.5 Efficiency Efficiency η 1 0.9 1 0.8 Data / MC 0.7 1.05 ATLAS s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Data Loose muons MC p (5-15) GeV T ATLAS J/ ψ→μμ Stat only 0.6 Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.95 5 5 .0 .1 .5 .1 .5 2.0 .5 -1 -0 <<2 <0 <2 1.0 1.0 <1 η< <η< <η <η <η <η η< <η 5 . 5< <η .0< 05 1< 2.0 1.5 0.1 5 0 . . -2 . . 1 -2 0 -1 -1 Data / MC 0.8 1.1 J/ ψ→μμ s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb-1 Data Tight muons MC p (5-15) GeV T Stat only Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.9 5 5 .1 .0 .5 .1 .5 2.0 .5 -0 -1 <0 <<2 <2 1.0 1.0 <1 η< η< <<η <η <η <η η< <η 5 . 5< <η .0< 05 1< 1.5 2.0 0.1 5 0 . . -2 . . 1 0 -2 -1 -1 Fig. 5 Muon reconstruction efficiency in different η regions measured in J/ψ → μμ events for Loose (left) and Tight (right) muon selections. Within each η region, the efficiency is measured in six pT bins (5–6, 6–7, 7–8, 8–10, 10–12, and 12–15 GeV). The resulting values are plotted as distinct measurements in each η bin with pT increasing from 5 to 15 GeV going from left to right. The error bars on the efficiencies indicate the statistical uncertainty. The panel at the bottom shows the ratio of the measured to predicted efficiencies, with statistical and systematic uncertainties linked to temporary faults during data taking. The efficiency of the High-pT selection is significantly lower, as a consequence of the strict requirements on momentum resolution. Local disagreements between prediction and observation are more severe than in the case of the other muon selections. Apart from the poorly aligned MDT chamber, they are most prominent in the CSC region. Figure 6 shows the reconstruction efficiencies for the Medium muon selection as a function of transverse momentum, including results from Z → μμ and J/ψ → μμ, for 123 Efficiency 292 Page 10 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 detector activity around a muon candidate, referred to as muon isolation, is therefore a powerful tool for background rejection in many physics analyses. 1 0.98 J/ ψ →μμ Data J/ ψ →μμ MC Z→μμ Data Z→μμ MC ATLAS 0.96 -1 s = 13 TeV, 3.2 fb Data / MC Medium muons, |η|>0.1 1.02 Stat only 7.1 Muon isolation variables Sys ⊕ Stat 1 0.98 6 7 8 910 20 30 40 50 60 102 p [GeV] T Fig. 6 Reconstruction efficiency for the Medium muon selection as a function of the pT of the muon, in the region 0.1 < |η| < 2.5 as obtained with Z → μμ and J/ψ → μμ events. The error bars on the efficiencies indicate the statistical uncertainty. The panel at the bottom shows the ratio of the measured to predicted efficiencies, with statistical and systematic uncertainties muons with 0.1 < |η| < 2.5. The efficiency is stable and slightly above 99 % for pT > 6 GeV. Values measured from J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ events are in agreement in the overlap region between 10 and 20 GeV. The efficiency scale factors are also found to be compatible. 6.2 Muon reconstruction efficiency for |η| > 2.5 As described in the previous sections, the reconstruction of combined muons is limited by the ID acceptance to the pseudorapidity region |η| < 2.5. For |η| > 2.5, the efficiency is recovered by using the ME muons included in the Loose and Medium muon selections. A measurement of the efficiency SF for muons in the region 2.5 < |η| < 2.7 (high-η region) is performed using the method described in Ref. [12]. The number of muons observed in Z → μμ decays in the high-η region is normalised to the number of muons observed in the region 2.2 < |η| < 2.5. This ratio is calculated for both data and simulation, applying all known performance corrections to the region |η| < 2.5. The SFs in the high-η region are defined as the ratio of the aforementioned ratios and are provided in 4 η and 16 φ bins. The values of the SFs measured using the 2015 dataset are close to 0.9 and are determined with a 3–5 % uncertainty. 7 Isolation Muons originating from the decay of heavy particles, such as W , Z , or Higgs bosons, are often produced isolated from other particles. Unlike muons from semileptonic decays, which are embedded in jets, these muons are well separated from other particles in the event. The measurement of the 123 Two variables are defined to assess muon isolation: a trackbased isolation variable and a calorimeter-based isolation variable. The track-based isolation variable, pTvarcone30 , is defined as the scalar sum of the transverse momentaof the tracks with μ pT > 1 GeV in a cone of size R = min 10 GeV/ pT , 0.3 μ around the muon of transverse momentum pT , excluding the muon track itself. The cone size is chosen to be pT -dependent to improve the performance for muons produced in the decay of particles with a large transverse momentum. topocone20 , is The calorimeter-based isolation variable, E T defined as the sum of the transverse energy of topological clusters [27] in a cone of size R = 0.2 around the muon, after subtracting the contribution from the energy deposit of the muon itself and correcting for pile-up effects. Contributions from pile-up and the underlying event are estimated using the ambient energy-density technique [28] and are corrected on an event-by-event basis. The isolation selection criteria are determined using the relative isolation variables, which are defined as the ratio of the track- or calorimeter-based isolation variables to the transverse momentum of the muon. The distribution of the relative isolation variables in muons from Z → μμ events is shown in the top panels of Fig. 7. Muons included in the plot satisfy the Medium identification criteria and are well separated from the other muon from the Z boson (R μμ > 0.3). The bottom panel shows the ratio of data to simulation. 7.2 Muon isolation performance Seven isolation selection criteria (isolation working points) are defined, each optimised for different physics analyses. Table 2 lists the seven isolation working points with the discriminating variables and the criteria used in their definition. The efficiencies for the seven isolation working points are measured in data and simulation in Z → μμ decays using the tag-and-probe method described in Sect. 6. To avoid probe muons in the vicinity of a jet, the angular separation R between the probe muon and the closest jet, reconstructed using an anti-kt algorithm [29] with radius parameter 0.4 and with a transverse momentum greater than 20 GeV, is required to be greater than 0.4. In addition, the two muons originating from the Z boson decay are required to be separated by R μμ > 0.3. Figure 8 shows the isolation efficiency measured for Medium muons in data and simulation Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 11 of 30 292 Fig. 7 Distributions of the track-based (left) and the calorimeter-based (right) relative isolation variables measured in Z → μμ events. Muons are selected by the Medium identification algorithm. The dots show the distribution for data while the histograms show the distribution from Table 2 Definition of the seven isolation working points. The discriminating variables are listed in the second column and the criteria used in the definition are reported in the third column Isolation WP LooseTrackOnly Loose Tight Gradient GradientLoose FixedCutTightTrackOnly FixedCutLoose simulation. The bottom panels show the ratio of data to simulation with the corresponding statistical uncertainty. The pile-up reweighted simulated distribution is normalised to the number of events selected in data Discriminating variable(s) Definition μ pTvarcone30 / pT topocone20 μ μ pTvarcone30 / pT , E T / pT topocone20 μ μ pTvarcone30 / pT , E T / pT topocone20 μ μ pTvarcone30 / pT , E T / pT topocone20 μ μ pTvarcone30 / pT , E T / pT μ pTvarcone30 / pT topocone20 μ μ pTvarcone30 / pT , E T / pT 99 % efficiency constant in η and pT as a function of the muon pT for the LooseTrackOnly, Loose, GradientLoose, and FixedCutLoose working points, with the respective data/MC ratios included in the bottom panel. The systematic uncertainties in the SFs are estimated by varying the background contributions within their uncertainties and by varying some of the selection criteria, such as the invariant mass selection window, the isolation of the tag muon, the minimum quality of the probe muon, the opening angle between the two muons, and the R between the probe muon and the closest jet. In Fig. 8, the largest systematic uncertainty contribution over the entire pT region arises from having neglected the η dependence of the SFs, which are usually provided as a function of η and pT . In the low- pT region, other important contributions are due to the background estimation and the mass window variation, while the high- pT region is dominated by statistical uncertainties in data and simulation. The total uncertainty is at the per mille level over a wide range of pT and reaches the percent level in the high- pT region. The suppression factor for muons from light mesons or b/c semileptonic decays is estimated from simulation and depends on the isolation working point, ranging from a minimum of 15 for LooseTrackOnly to a maximum of 40 for Gradient. 99 % efficiency constant in η and pT 96 % efficiency constant in η and pT ≥90(99) % efficiency at 25 (60) GeV ≥95(99) % efficiency at 25 (60) GeV μ pTvarcone30 / pT < 0.06 μ topocone20 pTvarcone30 / pT < 0.15, E T μ / pT < 0.30 8 Momentum scale and resolution The muon momentum scale and resolution are studied using J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ decays. Although the simulation contains an accurate description of the ATLAS detector, the level of detail is not enough to describe the muon momentum scale to the per mille level and the muon momentum resolution to the percent level. To obtain such a level of agreement between data and simulation, a set of corrections is applied to the simulated muon momentum. The methodology used to extract these corrections is described in Sect. 8.1. In Sect. 8.2, measurements of the muon momentum scale and resolution in data and simulation are presented for various detector regions and for a wide range of pT . To improve the precision of the procedure, the pT and η distributions of the Z and J/ψ resonances in simulation are reweighted to the distributions observed in data. 8.1 Muon momentum calibration procedure In the following, the “muon momentum calibration” is defined as the procedure used to identify the corrections to the simulated muon transverse momenta reconstructed in the ID and MS subdetectors to precisely describe the measure- 123 292 Page 12 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Fig. 8 Isolation efficiency for the LooseTrackOnly (top left), Loose (top right), GradientLoose (bottom left), and FixedCutLoose (bottom right) muon isolation working points. The efficiency is shown as a function of the muon transverse momentum pT and is measured in Z → μμ events. The full (empty) markers indicate the efficiency measured in data (MC) samples. The errors shown on the efficiency are statistical only. The bottom panel shows the ratio of the efficiency measured in data and simulation, as well as the statistical uncertainties and combination of statistical and systematic uncertainties ment of the same quantities in data. Only CB muons are used to extract the calibration parameters. The transverse momentum of the ID and MS components of a CB track, referred to as pTID and pTMS , respectively, are used. The ID (MS) tracks are reconstructed using the hits from the ID (MS) detector and are extrapolated to the interaction point. In the case of MS tracks, the fit corrects for the energy loss in the calorimeters as described earlier. The corrected transverse momentum, pTCor,Det (Det = ID, MS), is described by the following equation: divided into two φ bins separating the two types of φ sectors: those that include the magnet coils (small sectors) and those between two coils (large sectors). The small and large MS sectors employ independent alignment techniques and cover detector areas with different material distribution. Therefore, relevant scale and resolution differences exist. The numerator of Eq. (5) describes the momentum scales. The s1Det term corrects for inaccuracy in the description of the magnetic field integral and the dimension of the detector in the direction perpendicular to the magnetic field. The s0MS (η, φ) term models the effect on the MS momentum from the inaccuracy in the simulation of the energy loss in the calorimeter and other materials between the interaction point and the MS. As the energy loss between the interaction point and the ID is negligible, s0ID (η) is set to zero. The denominator of Eq. (5) describes the momentum smearing that broadens the relative pT resolution in simulation, σ ( pT )/ pT , to properly describe the data. The corrections to the resolution assume that the relative pT resolution can be parameterized as follows: pTCor,Det = pTMC,Det + 1+ 2 m=0 1 n=0 n snDet (η, φ) pTMC,Det , m−1 rmDet (η, φ) pTMC,Det gm (5) where pTMC,Det is the uncorrected transverse momentum in simulation, gm are normally distributed random variables with zero mean and unit width, and the terms rmDet (η, φ) and snDet (η, φ) describe the momentum resolution smearing and the scale corrections applied in a specific (η, φ) detector region, respectively. The corrections described in Eq. (5) are defined in η–φ detector regions that are homogeneous in terms of detector technology and performance. Both the ID and the MS are divided into 18 pseudorapidity regions. In addition, the MS is 123 σ ( pT ) = r 0 / pT ⊕ r 1 ⊕ r 2 · pT , pT (6) with ⊕ denoting a sum in quadrature. In Eq. (6), the first term accounts mainly for fluctuations of the energy loss in the tra- Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 13 of 30 292 versed material, the second term accounts mainly for multiple scattering, local magnetic field inhomogeneities and local radial displacements of the hits, and the third term mainly describes intrinsic resolution effects caused by the spatial resolution of the hit measurements and by residual misalignment of the muon spectrometer. The energy loss term is negligible in both the ID and MS measurements, and therefore r0ID and r0MS are set to zero. The corrected momentum of the combined muons, pTCor,CB , is obtained by combining the ID and MS corrected momenta using a weighted average: sub-leading (leading) muon greater than 5 or 9 (22 or 47) GeV, respectively. Similarly, the MS corrections are extracted using the distributions of the MS-reconstructed dimuon invariant mass, m MS μμ . Since there are more parameters and more ROFs in the MS version of Eq. (5), an additional variable is added to the MS fit. This is defined by the following equation pTCor,CB = f · pTCor,ID + (1 − f ) · pTCor,MS , which represents the pT imbalance between the measurement in the ID and in the MS. In Eq. (9), the momentum of the ID, pTCor,ID , contains the appropriate pT corrections. The variable ρ is used only in Z → μμ candidate events and is binned according to pTMS of the muon with lower bin boundaries of pTMS = 22, 35, 47, 60, 90 GeV. MS Templates for the m ID μμ , m μμ , and ρ are built using J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ simulated signal samples. In the Z → μμ sample, the small background component (approximately 0.1 %) is extracted from simulation and added to the templates. A much larger (about 15 %) non-resonant background from decays of light and heavy hadrons and from continuum Drell–Yan production is present in the J/ψ → μμ sample. As this background is not easy to simulate, a datadriven approach is used. The dimuon invariant mass distribution in data is fitted in each ROF using a Crystal Ball function added to an exponential background distribution in the ID and MS fits. The background model and its normalisation are then used in the template fit. The results are shown in Tables 3 and 4, averaged over three η regions. The quoted errors include systematic uncertainties evaluated by varying several parameters of the template fit. The main contributions to the final systematic uncertainty are: (7) with the weight f derived from the following linear equation pTMC,CB = f · pTMC,ID + (1 − f ) · pTMC,MS (8) which assumes that the relative contribution of the two subdetectors to the combined track remains unchanged before and after momentum corrections. 8.1.1 Determination of the pT calibration constants The MS and ID correction parameters contained in Eq. (5) are extracted from data using a binned maximum-likelihood fit with templates derived from simulation which compares the invariant mass distributions for J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ candidates in data and simulation. The exceptions are r0ID , r0MS , and s0ID , which are set to zero, and r2MS , which is determined from alignment studies using special runs with the toroidal magnetic field off. The J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ candidates are selected by requiring two oppositely charged CB muons satisfying the Medium identification criteria. Both muons must have impact parameters compatible with tracks produced by the primary interaction and pseudorapidity within the acceptance of both the ID and MS detectors (|η| < 2.5). Both muons from J/ψ → μμ (Z → μμ) candidate decays are required to have momenta in the range 5–20 (22–300) GeV and to form an invariant mass in the range 2.65–3.6 (76–106) GeV. Muons from Z boson decays need to be isolated, while no isolation criterion is imposed on muons from J/ψ decays. The extraction of the correction parameters is performed in η–φ regions of fit (ROFs) defined separately for the ID and the MS. Events are assigned to a specific ROF if at least one muon falls in the corresponding η–φ region. The ID corrections are extracted using the distributions of the ID dimuon invariant mass, m ID μμ . To enhance the sensitivity to pT -dependent correction effects, the m ID μμ is classified according to the pT of the muons. For J/ψ → μμ (Z → μμ) decays, the fit is performed in two exclusive categories defined requiring the candidates to have pTID of the ρ= pTMS − pTCor,ID pTCor,ID , (9) • Mass window width for the Z → μμ candidate selection. Non-Gaussian smearing effects are accounted for by varying the m μμ selection by ±5 GeV. Table 3 Summary of ID muon momentum resolution and scale corrections used in Eq. (5), averaged over three main detector regions. The corrections are derived in 18 pseudorapidity regions, as described in Sect. 8, and averaged, assigning a weight to each region proportional to its η width. The uncertainties represent the sum in quadrature of the statistical and systematic uncertainties Region r1ID (×10−3 ) r2ID [TeV−1 ] s1ID (×10−3 ) |η| < 1.05 +0.6 4.1−0.9 +0.04 0.17−0.03 +0.1 −0.6−0.2 9+9 −2 0.05± 0.01 1.0+3.5 −1.6 1.05 ≤ |η| < 2.0 |η| ≥ 2.0 +2.5 5.5−0.8 +0.07 0.34−0.09 +0.2 −0.5−0.5 123 292 Page 14 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Table 4 Summary of MS momentum resolution and scale corrections for small and large MS sectors, averaged over three main detector regions. The corrections for large and small MS sectors are derived in 18 pseudorapidity regions, as described in Sect. 8, and averaged assigning a weight to each region proportional to its η width. The energy loss term r0MS is negligible and therefore fixed to zero in the fit for all η. The uncertainties represent the sum in quadrature of the statistical and systematic uncertainties Region r1MS (×10−3 ) r2MS [TeV−1 ] s0MS [MeV] s1MS (×10−3 ) |η| < 1.05 (small) 17± 1 0.080 ± 0.006 −23 ± 5 −0.9 ± 0.3 |η| < 1.05 (large) 15± 1 0.162 ± 0.007 −26+8 −5 +0.4 1.8−0.3 1.05 ≤ |η| < 2.0 (small) 25+3 −1 0.20 ± 0.03 −13 ± 6 −1.4 ± 0.4 1.05 ≤ |η| < 2.0 (large) 23+3 −1 0.160 ± 0.015 −15 ± 10 +0.5 −1.1−0.6 |η| ≥ 2.0 (small) 17+3 −1 0.08 ± 0.01 −6+6 −7 +0.4 0.7−0.3 |η| ≥ 2.0 (large) 15+4 −3 0.112 ± 0.010 −3+13 −10 +0.6 0.3−0.7 • Background parameterization for the J/ψ fit as well as increased muon pT cut (from 5 to 7 GeV) to reduce the weight of the contribution of low- pT muons. • Scale parameter for the ID corrections obtained by fitting separately the J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ samples, to include possible non-linear scale effects. • As r2MS is sensitive to the alignment of the MS chambers, its systematic uncertainty is determined from alignment studies performed on special runs where the toroidal magnetic field was turned off. 8.2 Dimuon mass scale and resolution after applying momentum corrections The samples of J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ decays are used to study the muon momentum scales and resolution in data and simulation and to validate the momentum corrections obtained with the template fit method described in the previous section. The invariant mass distributions for the J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ candidates are shown in Fig. 9 and compared with uncorrected and corrected simulation. In the uncorrected simulation, it is noticeable that the signal distributions are narrower and slightly shifted with respect to data. After correction, the lineshapes of the two resonances in simulation agree with the data within the systematic uncertainties, demonstrating the overall effectiveness of the pT calibration. A better demonstration of the effectiveness of the momentum calibration is obtained by comparing, in data and simu3 35 ATLAS Data s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb MC Z→μ μ MC (uncor.) -1 30 Entries / 0.01 GeV Entries / 0.60 GeV 3 ×10 Syst. uncert. 25 140 ATLAS 120 s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb-1 J/ ψ →μ μ 100 60 15 10 40 5 20 0 1.2 1.2 Data/MC 0 1.1 1 0.9 0.8 75 Data MC MC (uncor.) Background Syst. uncert. 80 20 Data/MC ×10 1.1 1 0.9 0.8 80 85 90 95 100 105 2.9 2.95 3 3.05 3.1 3.15 3.2 3.25 m μ μ [GeV] m μ μ [GeV] Fig. 9 Dimuon invariant mass distribution of Z → μμ (left) and J/ψ → μμ (right) candidate events reconstructed with CB muons. The upper panels show the invariant mass distribution for data and for the signal simulation plus the background estimate. The points show the data. The continuous line corresponds to the simulation with the MC momentum corrections applied while the dashed lines show the simulation when no correction is applied. Background estimates are added to the signal simulation. The band represents the effect of the systematic uncertainties on the MC momentum corrections. The lower panels show the data to MC ratios. In the Z sample, the MC background samples are added to the signal sample according to their expected cross sections. In the J/ψ sample, the background is estimated from a fit to the data as described in the text. The sum of background and signal MC distributions is normalised to the data 123 92.5 Page 15 of 30 292 ATLAS Data -1 92 m μ μ [GeV] m μ μ [GeV] Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb MC Z→μ μ Syst. uncert. 91.5 3.25 3.2 ATLAS Data s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb-1 MC J/ ψ →μ μ Syst. uncert. 3.15 91 3.1 90.5 3.05 Data/MC Data/MC 90 1.002 1 0.998 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 1.005 1 0.995 −2.5 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 η (μ lead) η (μ lead) Fig. 10 Fitted mean mass of the dimuon system for CB muons for Z → μμ (left) and J/ψ → μμ (right) events for data and corrected simulation as a function of the pseudorapidity of the highest- pT muon. The upper panels show the fitted mean mass value for data and corrected simulation. The small variations of the invariant mass estimator as a function of pseudorapidity are due to imperfect energy loss correc- tions and magnetic field description in the muon reconstruction. Both effects are well reproduced in the simulation. The lower panels show the data/MC ratio. The error bars represent the statistical uncertainty; the shaded bands represent the systematic uncertainty in the correction and the systematic uncertainty in the extraction method added in quadrature lation, the measurement of the position m μμ and resolution σμμ of the dimuon mass peaks, extracted in bins of η and pT from fits to the J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ invariant mass distributions. When the two muons have similar momentum resolution and angular effects are neglected, the relative mass resolution, σμμ /m μμ , is directly proportional to the relative muon momentum resolution, σ pμ / pμ : position and width of the Crystal Ball function are used as estimators for the m μμ and σ (m μμ ) variables in the various η and pT bins. Figure 10 shows the position of the peak of the invariant mass distribution, m μμ , obtained from the fits to the Z boson and J/ψ samples as a function of the pseudorapidity of the highest- pT muon for CB pairs. The distributions are shown for data as well as corrected simulation, with the ratio of the two in the lower panel. The simulation is in very good agreement with the data. Minor deviations are contained within the scale systematic uncertainties of 0.05 % in the barrel region, increasing with |η| to 0.1 %(0.3 %) in the region |η| ∼ 2.5 for Z → μμ (J/ψ → μμ) decays. The systematic uncertainties shown in the plots include the effects of the uncertainties in the calibration constants described in Sect. 8.1 and the changes in the fit parameterization. The observed level of agreement demonstrates that the pT calibration for combined muon tracks described above provides a very accurate description of the momentum scale in all η regions, over a wide pT range. Similar levels of data/MC agreement are observed for the ID and MS components of the combined tracks. Figure 11 displays the dimuon mass resolution σ (m μμ ) as a function of the leading-muon η for the two resonances. The dimuon mass resolution is about 1.2 and 1.6 % at small η values for J/ψ and Z bosons, respectively, and increases to 1.6 and 1.9 % in the endcaps. This corresponds to a relative muon pT resolution of 1.7 and 2.3 % in the centre of the detector and 2.3 and 2.9 % in the endcaps for J/ψ and Z boson decays, respectively. After applying the momentum corrections described above, the simulation reproduces the resolution measured in data, well within the systematic σμμ 1 σ pμ = √ . m μμ 2 pμ (10) Similarly, the total muon momentum scale, defined as s = ( p meas − p true )/ p true , is directly related to the dimuon true true mass scale, defined as sμμ = (m meas μμ − m μμ )/m μμ : sμμ = √ sμ1 sμ2 , (11) where sμ1 and sμ2 are the momentum scales of the two muons. The dimuon mass resolution is obtained by fitting the width of the invariant mass peaks. In J/ψ → μμ decays, the intrinsic width of the resonance is negligible with respect to the experimental resolution. The bulk of the peak is modelled by a Crystal Ball function; a Gaussian distribution centred on the Crystal Ball function is added to the signal description to model the tails of the distribution. The non-resonant background is described by an exponential function. In Z → μμ decays, the fits use a convolution of the true lineshape (modelled by a Breit–Wigner function) with an experimental resolution function (a combination of a Crystal Ball and a Gaussian function). Similarly to the J/ψ, the non-resonant background is described by an exponential function. The peak 123 4 3.5 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 ATLAS Data s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb-1 MC Z→μ μ Syst. uncert. σμ μ [GeV] σμ μ [GeV] 292 Page 16 of 30 0.09 0.08 ATLAS Data s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb-1 MC J/ ψ →μ μ Syst. uncert. 0.07 3 0.06 2.5 0.05 2 0.04 1.5 Data/MC Data/MC 0.03 1.2 1 0.8 −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 1 0.9 −2.5 2.5 η (μ lead) −2 −1.5 −1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 η (μ lead) Fig. 11 Dimuon invariant mass resolution for CB muons for Z → μμ (left) and J/ψ → μμ (right) events for data and corrected simulation as a function of the pseudorapidity of the highest- pT muon. The upper panels show the fitted resolution value for data and corrected simulation. The lower panels show the data/MC ratio. The error bars represent the statistical uncertainty; the shaded bands represent the systematic uncertainty in the correction and the systematic uncertainty in the extraction method added in quadrature uncertainties. The systematic uncertainties are estimated following the same procedure described for the determination of the energy scale. Good agreement between the dimuon mass resolution measured in data and simulation is also observed for the ID and MS components of the combined tracks. The relative dimuon mass resolution σμμ /m μμ depends approximately on the average momentum of the muons, as shown in Eq. (10). This allows a direct comparison of the momentum resolution function determined with J/ψ and Z boson decays. This is shown in Fig. 12, where the relative dimuon mass resolution from J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ events is compared to simulation. The J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ resolutions are in good agreement. For the J/ψ, the average momentum is defined as pT = 21 ( pT,1 + pT,2 ) while for the Z boson it is defined as σμ μ / m μ μ −2.5 1.1 pT∗ = m Z sin θ1 sin θ2 , 2(1 − cos α12 ) (12) where m Z is the Z boson mass [30], θ1 and θ2 are the polar angles of the two muons, and α12 is the opening angle of the muon pair. This definition, based on angular variables only, removes the correlation between the measurement of the dimuon mass and the average pT . 9 Conclusions The performance of the ATLAS muon reconstruction has been measured using 3.2 fb−1 of data from pp collisions at √ s = 13 TeV recorded during the 25 ns run at the LHC in 2015. A large calibration sample consisting of Z → μμ 123 0.06 ATLAS s = 13 TeV, 2.7 fb-1 0.05 J/ψ →μμ Data Z→μμ Data J/ψ →μμ MC Z→μμ MC Syst. uncert. 0.04 0.03 0.02 Data/MC 0.01 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 10 102
, p T* [GeV] Fig. 12 Dimuon invariant mass resolution divided by the dimuon invariant mass for CB muons measured from J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ events as a function of the average transverse momentum variables pT and pT∗ defined in the text. Both muons are required to be in the same |η| range. The error bars represent the statistical uncertainty while the bands show the systematic uncertainties decays and J/ψ → μμ decays allows for a precise measurement of the reconstruction and isolation efficiency as well as of the momentum resolution and scale over a wide pT range. The muon reconstruction efficiency is close to 99 % over most of the pseudorapidity range of |η| < 2.5 for pT > 5 GeV. The Z → μμ sample enables a measurement of the efficiency with a precision at the 0.2 % level for pT > 20 GeV. The J/ψ → μμ sample provides a measurement of the reconstruction efficiency between 5 and 20 GeV with a precision better than 1 %. The Z → μμ sample is also used to measure the isolation efficiency for seven isolation working points in the Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 momentum range 10–120 GeV. The isolation efficiency varies between 93 and 100 % depending on the selection and on the momentum of the particle, and is well reproduced in the simulation. The muon momentum scale and resolution have been studied in detail using J/ψ → μμ and Z → μμ decays. These studies are used to correct the simulation to improve the agreement with data and to minimise the systematic uncertainties in physics analyses. For Z → μμ decays, the uncertainty in the momentum scale varies from a minimum of 0.05 % for |η| < 1 to a maximum of 0.3 % for |η| ∼ 2.5. The dimuon mass resolution is about 1.2 % (1.6 %) at small values of pseudorapidity for J/ψ (Z ) decays, and increases to 1.6 and 1.9 % in the endcaps for J/ψ and Z decays, respectively. This corresponds to a relative muon pT resolution of 1.7 and 2.3 % at small values of pseudorapidity and 2.3 and 2.9 % in the endcaps for J/ψ and Z decays, respectively. After applying momentum corrections, the pT resolution in data and simulation agree to better than 5 % for most of the η range. Acknowledgments We thank CERN for the very successful operation of the LHC, as well as the support staff from our institutions without whom ATLAS could not be operated efficiently. We acknowledge the support of ANPCyT, Argentina; YerPhI, Armenia; ARC, Australia; BMWFW and FWF, Austria; ANAS, Azerbaijan; SSTC, Belarus; CNPq and FAPESP, Brazil; NSERC, NRC and CFI, Canada; CERN; CONICYT, Chile; CAS, MOST and NSFC, China; COLCIENCIAS, Colombia; MSMT CR, MPO CR and VSC CR, Czech Republic; DNRF and DNSRC, Denmark; IN2P3-CNRS, CEA-DSM/IRFU, France; GNSF, Georgia; BMBF, HGF, and MPG, Germany; GSRT, Greece; RGC, Hong Kong SAR, China; ISF, I-CORE and Benoziyo Center, Israel; INFN, Italy; MEXT and JSPS, Japan; CNRST, Morocco; FOM and NWO, Netherlands; RCN, Norway; MNiSW and NCN, Poland; FCT, Portugal; MNE/IFA, Romania; MES of Russia and NRC KI, Russian Federation; JINR; MESTD, Serbia; MSSR, Slovakia; ARRS and MIZŠ, Slovenia; DST/NRF, South Africa; MINECO, Spain; SRC and Wallenberg Foundation, Sweden; SERI, SNSF and Cantons of Bern and Geneva, Switzerland; MOST, Taiwan; TAEK, Turkey; STFC, United Kingdom; DOE and NSF, United States of America. In addition, individual groups and members have received support from BCKDF, the Canada Council, CANARIE, CRC, Compute Canada, FQRNT, and the Ontario Innovation Trust, Canada; EPLANET, ERC, FP7, Horizon 2020 and Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions, European Union; Investissements d’Avenir Labex and Idex, ANR, Région Auvergne and Fondation Partager le Savoir, France; DFG and AvH Foundation, Germany; Herakleitos, Thales and Aristeia programmes co-financed by EU-ESF and the Greek NSRF; BSF, GIF and Minerva, Israel; BRF, Norway; Generalitat de Catalunya, Generalitat Valenciana, Spain; the Royal Society and Leverhulme Trust, United Kingdom. The crucial computing support from all WLCG partners is acknowledged gratefully, in particular from CERN and the ATLAS Tier-1 facilities at TRIUMF (Canada), NDGF (Denmark, Norway, Sweden), CC-IN2P3 (France), KIT/GridKA (Germany), INFN-CNAF (Italy), NL-T1 (Netherlands), PIC (Spain), ASGC (Taiwan), RAL (UK) and BNL (USA) and in the Tier-2 facilities worldwide. Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecomm ons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Page 17 of 30 292 Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. Funded by SCOAP3 . References 1. ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS experiment at the CERN large hadron collider. JINST 3, S08003 (2008). doi:10.1088/1748-0221/ 3/08/S08003 2. ATLAS Collaboration, Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC. Phys. Lett. B 716, 1–29 (2012). doi:10.1016/j.physletb. 2012.08.020. arXiv:1207.7214 [hep-ex] 3. ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the Higgs boson mass from the H → γ γ and H → Z Z ∗ → 4l channel with the ATLAS detector using 25 fb−1 of pp collision data. Phys. Rev. D 90, 052004 (2014). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.052004. arXiv:1406.3827 [hep-ex] 4. ATLAS Collaboration, Study of the spin and parity of the Higgs boson in diboson decays with the ATLAS detector. Eur. Phys. J. C 75, 476 (2015). doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-015-3685-1. arXiv:1506.05669 [hep-ex] 5. ATLAS Collaboration, Measurements of Higgs boson production and couplings in the four-lepton channel in pp collisions at center-of-mass energies of 7 and 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector. Phys. Rev. D 91, 012006 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91. 012006. arXiv:1408.5191 [hep-ex] 6. ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the transverse momentum and φη∗ distributions of Drell–Yan lepton pairs in proton–proton √ collisions at s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector. Submitted to PLB (2015). arXiv:1512.02192 [hep-ex] 7. ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the Z Z production cross √ section in pp collisions at s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector. Phys. Rev. Lett. 116(10), 101801 (2016). arXiv:1512.05314 [hepex] 8. ATLAS Collaboration, √ Search for high-mass dilepton resonances in pp collisions at s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector. Phys. Rev. D 90, 052005 (2014). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.052005. arXiv:1405.4123 [hep-ex] 9. ATLAS Collaboration, Search for new particles in events with √ one lepton and missing transverse momentum in pp collisions at s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector. JHEP 09, 037 (2014). doi:10. 1007/JHEP09(2014)037. arXiv:1407.7494 [hep-ex] 10. ATLAS Collaboration, Combination√of searches for W W , W Z , and Z Z resonances in pp collisions at s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector. Phys. Lett. B 755, 285–305 (2016). arXiv:1512.05099 [hep-ex] 11. ATLAS Collaboration, Search for new light gauge bosons in Higgs √ boson decays to four-lepton final states in pp collisions at s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector at the LHC. Phys. Rev. D 92, 092001 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.092001. arXiv:1505.07645 [hep-ex] 12. ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the muon reconstruction performance of the ATLAS detector using 2011 and 2012 LHC proton–proton collision data. Eur. Phys. J. C 74, 3130 (2014). doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-3130-x. arXiv:1407.3935 [hep-ex] 13. ATLAS Collaboration, Muon reconstruction efficiency and momentum resolution of the ATLAS experiment in proton–proton √ collisions at s = 7 TeV in 2010. Eur. Phys. J. C 74, 3034 (2014). doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-3034-9. arXiv:1404.4562 [hep-ex] 14. ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS muon spectrometer: technical design report. CERN-LHCC-97-22, ATLAS-TDR-10 (1997) 123 292 Page 18 of 30 15. T. Cornelissen et al., Concepts, design and implementation of the ATLAS new tracking (NEWT). ATL-SOFT-PUB-2007-007 (2007). http://cds.cern.ch/record/1020106 16. ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the ATLAS silicon √ pattern recognition algorithm in data and simulation at s = 7 TeV. ATLAS-CONF-2010-072 (2010). http://cds.cern.ch/record/ 1281363 17. J. Illingworth, J. Kittler, A survey of the Hough transform. Comput. Vis. Graph. Image Process. 44, 87–116 (1988). ISSN: 0734-189X. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/ pii/S0734189X88800331 18. ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the ATLAS trigger system in 2010. Eur. Phys. J. C 72, 1849 (2012). doi:10.1140/epjc/ s10052-011-1849-1. arXiv:1110.1530 [hep-ex] 19. S. Alioli et al., A general framework for implementing NLO calculations in shower Monte Carlo programs: the POWHEG BOX. JHEP 06, 043 (2010). arXiv:1002.2581 [hep-ph] 20. T. Sjöstrand, S. Mrenna, P. Skands, A brief introduction to PYTHIA 8.1. Comput. Phys. Commun. 178, 852 (2008). doi:10.1016/j.cpc. 2008.01.036. arXiv:0710.3820 [hep-ph] 21. H.-L. Lai et al., New parton distributions for collider physics. Phys. Rev. D 82, 074024 (2010). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.82.074024. arXiv:1007.2241 [hep-ph] Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 22. P. Golonka, Z. Was, PHOTOS Monte Carlo: a precision tool for QED corrections in Z and W decays. Eur. Phys. J. C 45, 97 (2006). doi:10.1140/epjc/s2005-02396-4. arXiv:0506026 [hep-ph] 23. T. Gleisberg et al., Event generation with SHERPA 1.1. JHEP 02, 007 (2009). doi:10.1088/1126-6708/2009/02/007. arXiv:0811.4622 [hep-ph] 24. ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS simulation infrastructure. Eur. Phys. J. C 70, 823 (2010). arXiv:1005.4568 [physics.ins-det] 25. S. Agostinelli et al., Geant4, a simulation toolkit. Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 506, 250 (2003). doi:10.1016/S0168-9002(03)01368-8 26. M. Oreglia, Ph.D. thesis. SLAC-R-0236 (1980) Appendix D 27. ATLAS Collaboration, Jet energy measurement √ with the ATLAS detector in proton–proton collisions at s = 7 TeV. Eur. Phys. J. C 73, 2304 (2013). doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-013-2304-2. arXiv:1112.6426 [hep-ex] 28. M. Cacciari, G.P. Salam, Pileup subtraction using jet areas. Phys. Lett. B 659, 119 (2008). doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2007.09.077 29. M. Cacciari, G.P. Salam, G. Soyez, The anti-kt jet clustering algorithm. JHEP 04, 063 (2008). doi:10.1088/1126-6708/2008/04/063 30. K.A. Olive et al., Review of particle physics. Chin. Phys. C 38, 090001 (2014). doi:10.1088/1674-1137/38/9/090001 ATLAS Collaboration G. Aad87 , B. Abbott114 , J. Abdallah65 , O. Abdinov12 , B. Abeloos118 , R. Aben108 , M. Abolins92 , O. S. AbouZeid138 , N. L. Abraham150 , H. Abramowicz154 , H. Abreu153 , R. Abreu117 , Y. Abulaiti147a,147b , B. S. Acharya164a,164b,a , L. Adamczyk40a , D. L. Adams27 , J. Adelman109 , S. Adomeit101 , T. Adye132 , A. A. Affolder76 , T. Agatonovic-Jovin14 , J. Agricola56 , J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra127a,127f , S. P. Ahlen24 , F. Ahmadov67,b , G. Aielli134a,134b , H. Akerstedt147a,147b , T. P. A. Åkesson83 , A. V. Akimov97 , G. L. Alberghi22a,22b , J. Albert169 , S. Albrand57 , M. J. Alconada Verzini73 , M. Aleksa32 , I. N. Aleksandrov67 , C. Alexa28b , G. Alexander154 , T. Alexopoulos10 , M. Alhroob114 , M. Aliev75a,75b , G. Alimonti93a , J. Alison33 , S. P. Alkire37 , B. M. M. Allbrooke150 , B. W. Allen117 , P. P. Allport19 , A. Aloisio105a,105b , F. Alonso73 , C. Alpigiani139 , M. Alstaty87 , B. Alvarez Gonzalez32 , D. Álvarez Piqueras167 , A. Alonso38 , 105a,105b 16 68 26a , B. T. Amadio , K. Amako , Y. Amaral Coutinho , C. Amelung25 , D. Amidei91 , M. G. Alviggi 127a,127c 127a,127b 32 25 140 , A. Amorim , S. Amoroso , G. Amundsen , C. Anastopoulos , L. S. Ancu51 , S. P. Amor Dos Santos 109 11 60b N. Andari , T. Andeen , C. F. Anders , G. Anders32 , J. K. Anders76 , K. J. Anderson33 , A. Andreazza93a,93b , V. Andrei60a , S. Angelidakis9 , I. Angelozzi108 , P. Anger46 , A. Angerami37 , F. Anghinolfi32 , A. V. Anisenkov110,c , N. Anjos13 , A. Annovi125a,125b , M. Antonelli49 , A. Antonov99 , J. Antos145b , F. Anulli133a , M. Aoki68 , L. Aperio Bella19 , G. Arabidze92 , Y. Arai68 , J. P. Araque127a , A. T. H. Arce47 , F. A. Arduh73 , J-F. Arguin96 , S. Argyropoulos65 , M. Arik20a , A. J. Armbruster32 , L. J. Armitage78 , O. Arnaez32 , H. Arnold50 , M. Arratia30 , O. Arslan23 , A. Artamonov98 , G. Artoni121 , S. Artz85 , S. Asai156 , N. Asbah44 , A. Ashkenazi154 , B. Åsman147a,147b , L. Asquith150 , K. Assamagan27 , R. Astalos145a , M. Atkinson166 , N. B. Atlay142 , K. Augsten129 , G. Avolio32 , B. Axen16 , M. K. Ayoub118 , G. Azuelos96,d , M. A. Baak32 , A. E. Baas60a , M. J. Baca19 , H. Bachacou137 , K. Bachas75a,75b , M. Backes32 , M. Backhaus32 , P. Bagiacchi133a,133b , P. Bagnaia133a,133b , Y. Bai35a , J. T. Baines132 , O. K. Baker176 , E. M. Baldin110,c , P. Balek130 , T. Balestri149 , F. Balli137 , W. K. Balunas123 , E. Banas41 , Sw. Banerjee173,e , A. A. E. Bannoura175 , L. Barak32 , E. L. Barberio90 , D. Barberis52a,52b , M. Barbero87 , T. Barillari102 , T. Barklow144 , N. Barlow30 , S. L. Barnes86 , B. M. Barnett132 , R. M. Barnett16 , Z. Barnovska5 , A. Baroncelli135a , G. Barone25 , A. J. Barr121 , L. Barranco Navarro167 , F. Barreiro84 , J. Barreiro Guimarães da Costa35a , R. Bartoldus144 , A. E. Barton74 , P. Bartos145a , A. Basalaev124 , A. Bassalat118 , R. L. Bates55 , S. J. Batista159 , J. R. Batley30 , M. Battaglia138 , M. Bauce133a,133b , F. Bauer137 , H. S. Bawa144,f , J. B. Beacham112 , M. D. Beattie74 , T. Beau82 , P. H. Beauchemin162 , P. Bechtle23 , H. P. Beck18,g , K. Becker121 , M. Becker85 , M. Beckingham170 , C. Becot111 , A. J. Beddall20e , A. Beddall20b , V. A. Bednyakov67 , M. Bedognetti108 , C. P. Bee149 , L. J. Beemster108 , T. A. Beermann32 , M. Begel27 , J. K. Behr44 , C. Belanger-Champagne89 , A. S. Bell80 , G. Bella154 , L. Bellagamba22a , A. Bellerive31 , M. Bellomo88 , K. Belotskiy99 , O. Beltramello32 , N. L. Belyaev99 , O. Benary154 , D. Benchekroun136a , M. Bender101 , K. Bendtz147a,147b , N. Benekos10 , Y. Benhammou154 , E. Benhar Noccioli176 , J. Benitez65 , J. A. Benitez Garcia160b , D. P. Benjamin47 , J. R. Bensinger25 , S. Bentvelsen108 , L. Beresford121 , 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 19 of 30 292 M. Beretta49 , D. Berge108 , E. Bergeaas Kuutmann165 , N. Berger5 , J. Beringer16 , S. Berlendis57 , N. R. Bernard88 , C. Bernius111 , F. U. Bernlochner23 , T. Berry79 , P. Berta130 , C. Bertella85 , G. Bertoli147a,147b , F. Bertolucci125a,125b , I. A. Bertram74 , C. Bertsche114 , D. Bertsche114 , G. J. Besjes38 , O. Bessidskaia Bylund147a,147b , M. Bessner44 , N. Besson137 , C. Betancourt50 , S. Bethke102 , A. J. Bevan78 , W. Bhimji16 , R. M. Bianchi126 , L. Bianchini25 , M. Bianco32 , O. Biebel101 , D. Biedermann17 , R. Bielski86 , N. V. Biesuz125a,125b , M. Biglietti135a , J. Bilbao De Mendizabal51 , H. Bilokon49 , M. Bindi56 , S. Binet118 , A. Bingul20b , C. Bini133a,133b , S. Biondi22a,22b , D. M. Bjergaard47 , C. W. Black151 , J. E. Black144 , K. M. Black24 , D. Blackburn139 , R. E. Blair6 , J.-B. Blanchard137 , J. E. Blanco79 , T. Blazek145a , I. Bloch44 , C. Blocker25 , W. Blum85,* , U. Blumenschein56 , S. Blunier34a , G. J. Bobbink108 , V. S. Bobrovnikov110,c , S. S. Bocchetta83 , A. Bocci47 , C. Bock101 , M. Boehler50 , D. Boerner175 , J. A. Bogaerts32 , D. Bogavac14 , A. G. Bogdanchikov110 , C. Bohm147a , V. Boisvert79 , T. Bold40a , V. Boldea28b , A. S. Boldyrev164a,164c , M. Bomben82 , M. Bona78 , M. Boonekamp137 , A. Borisov131 , G. Borissov74 , J. Bortfeldt101 , D. Bortoletto121 , V. Bortolotto62a,62b,62c , K. Bos108 , D. Boscherini22a , M. Bosman13 , J. D. Bossio Sola29 , J. Boudreau126 , J. Bouffard2 , E. V. Bouhova-Thacker74 , D. Boumediene36 , C. Bourdarios118 , S. K. Boutle55 , A. Boveia32 , J. Boyd32 , I. R. Boyko67 , J. Bracinik19 , A. Brandt8 , G. Brandt56 , O. Brandt60a , U. Bratzler157 , B. Brau88 , J. E. Brau117 , H. M. Braun175,* , W. D. Breaden Madden55 , K. Brendlinger123 , A. J. Brennan90 , L. Brenner108 , R. Brenner165 , S. Bressler172 , T. M. Bristow48 , D. Britton55 , D. Britzger44 , F. M. Brochu30 , I. Brock23 , R. Brock92 , G. Brooijmans37 , T. Brooks79 , W. K. Brooks34b , J. Brosamer16 , E. Brost117 , J. H. Broughton19 , P. A. Bruckman de Renstrom41 , D. Bruncko145b , R. Bruneliere50 , A. Bruni22a , G. Bruni22a , BH Brunt30 , M. Bruschi22a , N. Bruscino23 , P. Bryant33 , L. Bryngemark83 , T. Buanes15 , Q. Buat143 , P. Buchholz142 , A. G. Buckley55 , I. A. Budagov67 , F. Buehrer50 , M. K. Bugge120 , O. Bulekov99 , D. Bullock8 , H. Burckhart32 , S. Burdin76 , C. D. Burgard50 , B. Burghgrave109 , K. Burka41 , S. Burke132 , I. Burmeister45 , E. Busato36 , D. Büscher50 , V. Büscher85 , P. Bussey55 , J. M. Butler24 , C. M. Buttar55 , J. M. Butterworth80 , P. Butti108 , W. Buttinger27 , A. Buzatu55 , A. R. Buzykaev110,c , S. Cabrera Urbán167 , D. Caforio129 , V. M. Cairo39a,39b , O. Cakir4a , N. Calace51 , P. Calafiura16 , A. Calandri87 , G. Calderini82 , P. Calfayan101 , L. P. Caloba26a , D. Calvet36 , S. Calvet36 , T. P. Calvet87 , R. Camacho Toro33 , S. Camarda32 , P. Camarri134a,134b , D. Cameron120 , R. Caminal Armadans166 , C. Camincher57 , S. Campana32 , M. Campanelli80 , A. Camplani93a,93b , A. Campoverde149 , V. Canale105a,105b , A. Canepa160a , M. Cano Bret35e , J. Cantero84 , R. Cantrill127a , T. Cao42 , M. D. M. Capeans Garrido32 , I. Caprini28b , M. Caprini28b , M. Capua39a,39b , R. Caputo85 , R. M. Carbone37 , R. Cardarelli134a , F. Cardillo50 , I. Carli130 , T. Carli32 , G. Carlino105a , L. Carminati93a,93b , S. Caron107 , E. Carquin34b , G. D. Carrillo-Montoya32 , J. R. Carter30 , J. Carvalho127a,127c , D. Casadei19 , M. P. Casado13,h , M. Casolino13 , D. W. Casper163 , E. Castaneda-Miranda146a , A. Castelli108 , V. Castillo Gimenez167 , N. F. Castro127a,i , A. Catinaccio32 , J. R. Catmore120 , A. Cattai32 , J. Caudron85 , V. Cavaliere166 , E. Cavallaro13 , D. Cavalli93a , M. Cavalli-Sforza13 , V. Cavasinni125a,125b , F. Ceradini135a,135b , L. Cerda Alberich167 , B. C. Cerio47 , A. S. Cerqueira26b , A. Cerri150 , L. Cerrito78 , F. Cerutti16 , M. Cerv32 , A. Cervelli18 , S. A. Cetin20d , A. Chafaq136a , D. Chakraborty109 , S. K. Chan59 , Y. L. Chan62a , P. Chang166 , J. D. Chapman30 , D. G. Charlton19 , A. Chatterjee51 , C. C. Chau159 , C. A. Chavez Barajas150 , S. Che112 , S. Cheatham74 , A. Chegwidden92 , S. Chekanov6 , S. V. Chekulaev160a , G. A. Chelkov67,j , M. A. Chelstowska91 , C. Chen66 , H. Chen27 , K. Chen149 , S. Chen35c , S. Chen156 , X. Chen35f , Y. Chen69 , H. C. Cheng91 , H. J. Cheng35a , Y. Cheng33 , A. Cheplakov67 , E. Cheremushkina131 , R. Cherkaoui El Moursli136e , V. Chernyatin27,* , E. Cheu7 , L. Chevalier137 , V. Chiarella49 , G. Chiarelli125a,125b , G. Chiodini75a , A. S. Chisholm19 , A. Chitan28b , M. V. Chizhov67 , K. Choi63 , A. R. Chomont36 , S. Chouridou9 , B. K. B. Chow101 , V. Christodoulou80 , D. Chromek-Burckhart32 , J. Chudoba128 , A. J. Chuinard89 , J. J. Chwastowski41 , L. Chytka116 , G. Ciapetti133a,133b , A. K. Ciftci4a , D. Cinca55 , V. Cindro77 , I. A. Cioara23 , A. Ciocio16 , F. Cirotto105a,105b , Z. H. Citron172 , M. Citterio93a , M. Ciubancan28b , A. Clark51 , B. L. Clark59 , M. R. Clark37 , P. J. Clark48 , R. N. Clarke16 , C. Clement147a,147b , Y. Coadou87 , M. Cobal164a,164c , A. Coccaro51 , J. Cochran66 , L. Coffey25 , L. Colasurdo107 , B. Cole37 , S. Cole109 , A. P. Colijn108 , J. Collot57 , T. Colombo32 , G. Compostella102 , P. Conde Muiño127a,127b , E. Coniavitis50 , S. H. Connell146b , I. A. Connelly79 , V. Consorti50 , S. Constantinescu28b , C. Conta122a,122b , G. Conti32 , F. Conventi105a,k , M. Cooke16 , B. D. Cooper80 , A. M. Cooper-Sarkar121 , K. J. R. Cormier159 , T. Cornelissen175 , M. Corradi133a,133b , F. Corriveau89,l , A. Corso-Radu163 , A. Cortes-Gonzalez13 , G. Cortiana102 , G. Costa93a , M. J. Costa167 , D. Costanzo140 , G. Cottin30 , G. Cowan79 , B. E. Cox86 , K. Cranmer111 , S. J. Crawley55 , G. Cree31 , S. Crépé-Renaudin57 , F. Crescioli82 , W. A. Cribbs147a,147b , M. Crispin Ortuzar121 , M. Cristinziani23 , V. Croft107 , G. Crosetti39a,39b , T. Cuhadar Donszelmann140 , J. Cummings176 , M. Curatolo49 , J. Cúth85 , C. Cuthbert151 , H. Czirr142 , P. Czodrowski3 , S. D’Auria55 , M. D’Onofrio76 , M. J. Da Cunha Sargedas De Sousa127a,127b , C. Da Via86 , W. Dabrowski40a , T. Dado145a , T. Dai91 , O. Dale15 , F. Dallaire96 , C. Dallapiccola88 , M. Dam38 , J. R. Dandoy33 , N. P. Dang50 , A. C. Daniells19 , N. S. Dann86 , M. Danninger168 , M. Dano Hoffmann137 , V. Dao50 , G. Darbo52a , S. Darmora8 , J. Dassoulas3 , A. Dattagupta63 , W. Davey23 , C. David169 , T. Davidek130 , M. Davies154 , P. Davison80 , E. Dawe90 , I. Dawson140 , R. K. Daya-Ishmukhametova88 , K. De8 , R. de Asmundis105a , A. De Benedetti114 , S. De Castro22a,22b , 123 292 Page 20 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 S. De Cecco82 , N. De Groot107 , P. de Jong108 , H. De la Torre84 , F. De Lorenzi66 , D. De Pedis133a , A. De Salvo133a , U. De Sanctis150 , A. De Santo150 , J. B. De Vivie De Regie118 , W. J. Dearnaley74 , R. Debbe27 , C. Debenedetti138 , D. V. Dedovich67 , I. Deigaard108 , M. Del Gaudio39a,39b , J. Del Peso84 , T. Del Prete125a,125b , D. Delgove118 , F. Deliot137 , C. M. Delitzsch51 , M. Deliyergiyev77 , A. Dell’Acqua32 , L. Dell’Asta24 , M. Dell’Orso125a,125b , M. Della Pietra105a,k , D. della Volpe51 , M. Delmastro5 , P. A. Delsart57 , C. Deluca108 , D. A. DeMarco159 , S. Demers176 , M. Demichev67 , A. Demilly82 , S. P. Denisov131 , D. Denysiuk137 , D. Derendarz41 , J. E. Derkaoui136d , F. Derue82 , P. Dervan76 , K. Desch23 , C. Deterre44 , K. Dette45 , P. O. Deviveiros32 , A. Dewhurst132 , S. Dhaliwal25 , A. Di Ciaccio134a,134b , L. Di Ciaccio5 , W. K. Di Clemente123 , C. Di Donato133a,133b , A. Di Girolamo32 , B. Di Girolamo32 , B. Di Micco135a,135b , R. Di Nardo49 , A. Di Simone50 , R. Di Sipio159 , D. Di Valentino31 , C. Diaconu87 , M. Diamond159 , F. A. Dias48 , M. A. Diaz34a , E. B. Diehl91 , J. Dietrich17 , S. Diglio87 , A. Dimitrievska14 , J. Dingfelder23 , P. Dita28b , S. Dita28b , F. Dittus32 , F. Djama87 , T. Djobava53b , J. I. Djuvsland60a , M. A. B. do Vale26c , D. Dobos32 , M. Dobre28b , C. Doglioni83 , T. Dohmae156 , J. Dolejsi130 , Z. Dolezal130 , B. A. Dolgoshein99,* , M. Donadelli26d , S. Donati125a,125b , P. Dondero122a,122b , J. Donini36 , J. Dopke132 , A. Doria105a , M. T. Dova73 , A. T. Doyle55 , E. Drechsler56 , M. Dris10 , Y. Du35d , J. Duarte-Campderros154 , E. Duchovni172 , G. Duckeck101 , O. A. Ducu96,m , D. Duda108 , A. Dudarev32 , L. Duflot118 , L. Duguid79 , M. Dührssen32 , M. Dumancic172 , M. Dunford60a , H. Duran Yildiz4a , M. Düren54 , A. Durglishvili53b , D. Duschinger46 , B. Dutta44 , M. Dyndal40a , C. Eckardt44 , K. M. Ecker102 , R. C. Edgar91 , N. C. Edwards48 , T. Eifert32 , G. Eigen15 , K. Einsweiler16 , T. Ekelof165 , M. El Kacimi136c , V. Ellajosyula87 , M. Ellert165 , S. Elles5 , F. Ellinghaus175 , A. A. Elliot169 , N. Ellis32 , J. Elmsheuser27 , M. Elsing32 , D. Emeliyanov132 , Y. Enari156 , O. C. Endner85 , M. Endo119 , J. S. Ennis170 , J. Erdmann45 , A. Ereditato18 , G. Ernis175 , J. Ernst2 , M. Ernst27 , S. Errede166 , E. Ertel85 , M. Escalier118 , H. Esch45 , C. Escobar126 , B. Esposito49 , A. I. Etienvre137 , E. Etzion154 , H. Evans63 , A. Ezhilov124 , F. Fabbri22a,22b , L. Fabbri22a,22b , G. Facini33 , R. M. Fakhrutdinov131 , S. Falciano133a , R. J. Falla80 , J. Faltova130 , Y. Fang35a , M. Fanti93a,93b , A. Farbin8 , A. Farilla135a , C. Farina126 , T. Farooque13 , S. Farrell16 , S. M. Farrington170 , P. Farthouat32 , F. Fassi136e , P. Fassnacht32 , D. Fassouliotis9 , M. Faucci Giannelli79 , A. Favareto52a,52b , W. J. Fawcett121 , L. Fayard118 , O. L. Fedin124,n , W. Fedorko168 , S. Feigl120 , L. Feligioni87 , C. Feng35d , E. J. Feng32 , H. Feng91 , A. B. Fenyuk131 , L. Feremenga8 , P. Fernandez Martinez167 , S. Fernandez Perez13 , J. Ferrando55 , A. Ferrari165 , P. Ferrari108 , R. Ferrari122a , D. E. Ferreira de Lima60b , A. Ferrer167 , D. Ferrere51 , C. Ferretti91 , A. Ferretto Parodi52a,52b , F. Fiedler85 , A. Filipčič77 , M. Filipuzzi44 , F. Filthaut107 , M. Fincke-Keeler169 , K. D. Finelli151 , M. C. N. Fiolhais127a,127c , L. Fiorini167 , A. Firan42 , A. Fischer2 , C. Fischer13 , J. Fischer175 , W. C. Fisher92 , N. Flaschel44 , I. Fleck142 , P. Fleischmann91 , G. T. Fletcher140 , R. R. M. Fletcher123 , T. Flick175 , A. Floderus83 , L. R. Flores Castillo62a , M. J. Flowerdew102 , G. T. Forcolin86 , A. Formica137 , A. Forti86 , A. G. Foster19 , D. Fournier118 , H. Fox74 , S. Fracchia13 , P. Francavilla82 , M. Franchini22a,22b , D. Francis32 , L. Franconi120 , M. Franklin59 , M. Frate163 , M. Fraternali122a,122b , D. Freeborn80 , S. M. Fressard-Batraneanu32 , F. Friedrich46 , D. Froidevaux32 , J. A. Frost121 , C. Fukunaga157 , E. Fullana Torregrosa85 , T. Fusayasu103 , J. Fuster167 , C. Gabaldon57 , O. Gabizon175 , A. Gabrielli22a,22b , A. Gabrielli16 , G. P. Gach40a , S. Gadatsch32 , S. Gadomski51 , G. Gagliardi52a,52b , L. G. Gagnon96 , P. Gagnon63 , C. Galea107 , B. Galhardo127a,127c , E. J. Gallas121 , B. J. Gallop132 , P. Gallus129 , G. Galster38 , K. K. Gan112 , J. Gao35b,87 , Y. Gao48 , Y. S. Gao144,f , F. M. Garay Walls48 , C. García167 , J. E. García Navarro167 , M. Garcia-Sciveres16 , R. W. Gardner33 , N. Garelli144 , V. Garonne120 , A. Gascon Bravo44 , C. Gatti49 , A. Gaudiello52a,52b , G. Gaudio122a , B. Gaur142 , L. Gauthier96 , I. L. Gavrilenko97 , C. Gay168 , G. Gaycken23 , E. N. Gazis10 , Z. Gecse168 , C. N. P. Gee132 , Ch. Geich-Gimbel23 , M. P. Geisler60a , C. Gemme52a , M. H. Genest57 , C. Geng35b,o , S. Gentile133a,133b , S. George79 , D. Gerbaudo13 , A. Gershon154 , S. Ghasemi142 , H. Ghazlane136b , M. Ghneimat23 , B. Giacobbe22a , S. Giagu133a,133b , P. Giannetti125a,125b , B. Gibbard27 , S. M. Gibson79 , M. Gignac168 , M. Gilchriese16 , T. P. S. Gillam30 , D. Gillberg31 , G. Gilles175 , D. M. Gingrich3,d , N. Giokaris9 , M. P. Giordani164a,164c , F. M. Giorgi22a , F. M. Giorgi17 , P. F. Giraud137 , P. Giromini59 , D. Giugni93a , F. Giuli121 , C. Giuliani102 , M. Giulini60b , B. K. Gjelsten120 , S. Gkaitatzis155 , I. Gkialas155 , E. L. Gkougkousis118 , L. K. Gladilin100 , C. Glasman84 , J. Glatzer32 , P. C. F. Glaysher48 , A. Glazov44 , M. Goblirsch-Kolb102 , J. Godlewski41 , S. Goldfarb91 , T. Golling51 , D. Golubkov131 , A. Gomes127a,127b,127d , R. Gonçalo127a , J. Goncalves Pinto Firmino Da Costa137 , L. Gonella19 , A. Gongadze67 , S. González de la Hoz167 , G. Gonzalez Parra13 , S. Gonzalez-Sevilla51 , L. Goossens32 , P. A. Gorbounov98 , H. A. Gordon27 , I. Gorelov106 , B. Gorini32 , E. Gorini75a,75b , A. Gorišek77 , E. Gornicki41 , A. T. Goshaw47 , C. Gössling45 , M. I. Gostkin67 , C. R. Goudet118 , D. Goujdami136c , A. G. Goussiou139 , N. Govender146b,p , E. Gozani153 , L. Graber56 , I. Grabowska-Bold40a , P. O. J. Gradin57 , P. Grafström22a,22b , J. Gramling51 , E. Gramstad120 , S. Grancagnolo17 , V. Gratchev124 , H. M. Gray32 , E. Graziani135a , Z. D. Greenwood81,q , C. Grefe23 , K. Gregersen80 , I. M. Gregor44 , P. Grenier144 , K. Grevtsov5 , J. Griffiths8 , A. A. Grillo138 , K. Grimm74 , S. Grinstein13,r , Ph. Gris36 , J.-F. Grivaz118 , S. Groh85 , J. P. Grohs46 , E. Gross172 , J. Grosse-Knetter56 , G. C. Grossi81 , Z. J. Grout150 , L. Guan91 , W. Guan173 , J. Guenther129 , F. Guescini51 , D. Guest163 , O. Gueta154 , E. Guido52a,52b , T. Guillemin5 , S. Guindon2 , U. Gul55 , C. Gumpert32 , J. Guo35e , Y. Guo35b,o , 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 21 of 30 292 S. Gupta121 , G. Gustavino133a,133b , P. Gutierrez114 , N. G. Gutierrez Ortiz80 , C. Gutschow46 , C. Guyot137 , C. Gwenlan121 , C. B. Gwilliam76 , A. Haas111 , C. Haber16 , H. K. Hadavand8 , N. Haddad136e , A. Hadef87 , P. Haefner23 , S. Hageböck23 , Z. Hajduk41 , H. Hakobyan177,* , M. Haleem44 , J. Haley115 , G. Halladjian92 , G. D. Hallewell87 , K. Hamacher175 , P. Hamal116 , K. Hamano169 , A. Hamilton146a , G. N. Hamity140 , P. G. Hamnett44 , L. Han35b , K. Hanagaki68,s , K. Hanawa156 , M. Hance138 , B. Haney123 , P. Hanke60a , R. Hanna137 , J. B. Hansen38 , J. D. Hansen38 , M. C. Hansen23 , P. H. Hansen38 , K. Hara161 , A. S. Hard173 , T. Harenberg175 , F. Hariri118 , S. Harkusha94 , R. D. Harrington48 , P. F. Harrison170 , F. Hartjes108 , M. Hasegawa69 , Y. Hasegawa141 , A. Hasib114 , S. Hassani137 , S. Haug18 , R. Hauser92 , L. Hauswald46 , M. Havranek128 , C. M. Hawkes19 , R. J. Hawkings32 , A. D. Hawkins83 , D. Hayden92 , C. P. Hays121 , J. M. Hays78 , H. S. Hayward76 , S. J. Haywood132 , S. J. Head19 , T. Heck85 , V. Hedberg83 , L. Heelan8 , S. Heim123 , T. Heim16 , B. Heinemann16 , J. J. Heinrich101 , L. Heinrich111 , C. Heinz54 , J. Hejbal128 , L. Helary24 , S. Hellman147a,147b , C. Helsens32 , J. Henderson121 , R. C. W. Henderson74 , Y. Heng173 , S. Henkelmann168 , A. M. Henriques Correia32 , S. Henrot-Versille118 , G. H. Herbert17 , H. Herde25 , Y. Hernández Jiménez167 , G. Herten50 , R. Hertenberger101 , L. Hervas32 , G. G. Hesketh80 , N. P. Hessey108 , J. W. Hetherly42 , R. Hickling78 , E. Higón-Rodriguez167 , E. Hill169 , J. C. Hill30 , K. H. Hiller44 , S. J. Hillier19 , I. Hinchliffe16 , E. Hines123 , R. R. Hinman16 , M. Hirose158 , D. Hirschbuehl175 , J. Hobbs149 , N. Hod160a , M. C. Hodgkinson140 , P. Hodgson140 , A. Hoecker32 , M. R. Hoeferkamp106 , F. Hoenig101 , M. Hohlfeld85 , D. Hohn23 , T. R. Holmes16 , M. Homann45 , T. M. Hong126 , B. H. Hooberman166 , W. H. Hopkins117 , Y. Horii104 , A. J. Horton143 , J-Y. Hostachy57 , S. Hou152 , A. Hoummada136a , J. Howarth44 , M. Hrabovsky116 , I. Hristova17 , J. Hrivnac118 , T. Hryn’ova5 , A. Hrynevich95 , C. Hsu146c , P. J. Hsu152,t , S.-C. Hsu139 , D. Hu37 , Q. Hu35b , Y. Huang44 , Z. Hubacek129 , F. Hubaut87 , F. Huegging23 , T. B. Huffman121 , E. W. Hughes37 , G. Hughes74 , M. Huhtinen32 , T. A. Hülsing85 , P. Huo149 , N. Huseynov67,b , J. Huston92 , J. Huth59 , G. Iacobucci51 , G. Iakovidis27 , I. Ibragimov142 , L. Iconomidou-Fayard118 , E. Ideal176 , Z. Idrissi136e , P. Iengo32 , O. Igonkina108,u , T. Iizawa171 , Y. Ikegami68 , M. Ikeno68 , Y. Ilchenko11,v , D. Iliadis155 , N. Ilic144 , T. Ince102 , G. Introzzi122a,122b , P. Ioannou9,* , M. Iodice135a , K. Iordanidou37 , V. Ippolito59 , M. Ishino70 , M. Ishitsuka158 , R. Ishmukhametov112 , C. Issever121 , S. Istin20a , F. Ito161 , J. M. Iturbe Ponce86 , R. Iuppa134a,134b , W. Iwanski41 , H. Iwasaki68 , J. M. Izen43 , V. Izzo105a , S. Jabbar3 , B. Jackson123 , M. Jackson76 , P. Jackson1 , V. Jain2 , K. B. Jakobi85 , K. Jakobs50 , S. Jakobsen32 , T. Jakoubek128 , D. O. Jamin115 , D. K. Jana81 , E. Jansen80 , R. Jansky64 , J. Janssen23 , M. Janus56 , G. Jarlskog83 , N. Javadov67,b , T. Javůrek50 , F. Jeanneau137 , L. Jeanty16 , J. Jejelava53a,w , G.-Y. Jeng151 , D. Jennens90 , P. Jenni50,x , J. Jentzsch45 , C. Jeske170 , S. Jézéquel5 , H. Ji173 , J. Jia149 , H. Jiang66 , Y. Jiang35b , S. Jiggins80 , J. Jimenez Pena167 , S. Jin35a , A. Jinaru28b , O. Jinnouchi158 , P. Johansson140 , K. A. Johns7 , W. J. Johnson139 , K. Jon-And147a,147b , G. Jones170 , R. W. L. Jones74 , S. Jones7 , T. J. Jones76 , J. Jongmanns60a , P. M. Jorge127a,127b , J. Jovicevic160a , X. Ju173 , A. Juste Rozas13,r , M. K. Köhler172 , A. Kaczmarska41 , M. Kado118 , H. Kagan112 , M. Kagan144 , S. J. Kahn87 , E. Kajomovitz47 , C. W. Kalderon121 , A. Kaluza85 , S. Kama42 , A. Kamenshchikov131 , N. Kanaya156 , S. Kaneti30 , L. Kanjir77 , V. A. Kantserov99 , J. Kanzaki68 , B. Kaplan111 , L. S. Kaplan173 , A. Kapliy33 , D. Kar146c , K. Karakostas10 , A. Karamaoun3 , N. Karastathis10 , M. J. Kareem56 , E. Karentzos10 , M. Karnevskiy85 , S. N. Karpov67 , Z. M. Karpova67 , K. Karthik111 , V. Kartvelishvili74 , A. N. Karyukhin131 , K. Kasahara161 , L. Kashif173 , R. D. Kass112 , A. Kastanas15 , Y. Kataoka156 , C. Kato156 , A. Katre51 , J. Katzy44 , K. Kawagoe72 , T. Kawamoto156 , G. Kawamura56 , S. Kazama156 , V. F. Kazanin110,c , R. Keeler169 , R. Kehoe42 , J. S. Keller44 , J. J. Kempster79 , K Kentaro104 , H. Keoshkerian159 , O. Kepka128 , B. P. Kerševan77 , S. Kersten175 , R. A. Keyes89 , F. Khalil-zada12 , A. Khanov115 , A. G. Kharlamov110,c , T. J. Khoo30 , V. Khovanskiy98 , E. Khramov67 , J. Khubua53b,y , S. Kido69 , H. Y. Kim8 , S. H. Kim161 , Y. K. Kim33 , N. Kimura155 , O. M. Kind17 , B. T. King76 , M. King167 , S. B. King168 , J. Kirk132 , A. E. Kiryunin102 , T. Kishimoto69 , D. Kisielewska40a , F. Kiss50 , K. Kiuchi161 , O. Kivernyk137 , E. Kladiva145b , M. H. Klein37 , M. Klein76 , U. Klein76 , K. Kleinknecht85 , P. Klimek147a,147b , A. Klimentov27 , R. Klingenberg45 , J. A. Klinger140 , T. Klioutchnikova32 , E.-E. Kluge60a , P. Kluit108 , S. Kluth102 , J. Knapik41 , E. Kneringer64 , E. B. F. G. Knoops87 , A. Knue55 , A. Kobayashi156 , D. Kobayashi158 , T. Kobayashi156 , M. Kobel46 , M. Kocian144 , P. Kodys130 , N. M. Koehler102 , T. Koffas31 , E. Koffeman108 , T. Koi144 , H. Kolanoski17 , M. Kolb60b , I. Koletsou5 , A. A. Komar97,* , Y. Komori156 , T. Kondo68 , N. Kondrashova44 , K. Köneke50 , A. C. König107 , T. Kono68,z , R. Konoplich111,aa , N. Konstantinidis80 , R. Kopeliansky63 , S. Koperny40a , L. Köpke85 , A. K. Kopp50 , K. Korcyl41 , K. Kordas155 , A. Korn80 , A. A. Korol110,c , I. Korolkov13 , E. V. Korolkova140 , O. Kortner102 , S. Kortner102 , T. Kosek130 , V. V. Kostyukhin23 , A. Kotwal47 , A. Kourkoumeli-Charalampidi155 , C. Kourkoumelis9 , V. Kouskoura27 , A. B. Kowalewska41 , R. Kowalewski169 , T. Z. Kowalski40a , W. Kozanecki137 , A. S. Kozhin131 , V. A. Kramarenko100 , G. Kramberger77 , D. Krasnopevtsev99 , M. W. Krasny82 , A. Krasznahorkay32 , J. K. Kraus23 , A. Kravchenko27 , M. Kretz60c , J. Kretzschmar76 , K. Kreutzfeldt54 , P. Krieger159 , K. Krizka33 , K. Kroeninger45 , H. Kroha102 , J. Kroll123 , J. Kroseberg23 , J. Krstic14 , U. Kruchonak67 , H. Krüger23 , N. Krumnack66 , A. Kruse173 , M. C. Kruse47 , M. Kruskal24 , T. Kubota90 , H. Kucuk80 , S. Kuday4b , J. T. Kuechler175 , S. Kuehn50 , A. Kugel60c , F. Kuger174 , A. Kuhl138 , T. Kuhl44 , V. Kukhtin67 , R. Kukla137 , Y. Kulchitsky94 , S. Kuleshov34b , M. Kuna133a,133b , 123 292 Page 22 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 T. Kunigo70 , A. Kupco128 , H. Kurashige69 , Y. A. Kurochkin94 , V. Kus128 , E. S. Kuwertz169 , M. Kuze158 , J. Kvita116 , T. Kwan169 , D. Kyriazopoulos140 , A. La Rosa102 , J. L. La Rosa Navarro26d , L. La Rotonda39a,39b , C. Lacasta167 , F. Lacava133a,133b , J. Lacey31 , H. Lacker17 , D. Lacour82 , V. R. Lacuesta167 , E. Ladygin67 , R. Lafaye5 , B. Laforge82 , T. Lagouri176 , S. Lai56 , S. Lammers63 , W. Lampl7 , E. Lançon137 , U. Landgraf50 , M. P. J. Landon78 , V. S. Lang60a , J. C. Lange13 , A. J. Lankford163 , F. Lanni27 , K. Lantzsch23 , A. Lanza122a , S. Laplace82 , C. Lapoire32 , J. F. Laporte137 , T. Lari93a , F. Lasagni Manghi22a,22b , M. Lassnig32 , P. Laurelli49 , W. Lavrijsen16 , A. T. Law138 , P. Laycock76 , T. Lazovich59 , M. Lazzaroni93a,93b , B. Le90 , O. Le Dortz82 , E. Le Guirriec87 , E. Le Menedeu13 , E. P. Le Quilleuc137 , M. LeBlanc169 , T. LeCompte6 , F. Ledroit-Guillon57 , C. A. Lee27 , S. C. Lee152 , L. Lee1 , G. Lefebvre82 , M. Lefebvre169 , F. Legger101 , C. Leggett16 , A. Lehan76 , G. Lehmann Miotto32 , X. Lei7 , W. A. Leight31 , A. Leisos155,ab , A. G. Leister176 , M. A. L. Leite26d , R. Leitner130 , D. Lellouch172 , B. Lemmer56 , K. J. C. Leney80 , T. Lenz23 , B. Lenzi32 , R. Leone7 , S. Leone125a,125b , C. Leonidopoulos48 , S. Leontsinis10 , G. Lerner150 , C. Leroy96 , A. A. J. Lesage137 , C. G. Lester30 , M. Levchenko124 , J. Levêque5 , D. Levin91 , L. J. Levinson172 , M. Levy19 , A. M. Leyko23 , M. Leyton43 , B. Li35b,o , H. Li149 , H. L. Li33 , L. Li47 , L. Li35e , Q. Li35a , S. Li47 , X. Li86 , Y. Li142 , Z. Liang138 , B. Liberti134a , A. Liblong159 , P. Lichard32 , K. Lie166 , J. Liebal23 , W. Liebig15 , A. Limosani151 , S. C. Lin152,ac , T. H. Lin85 , B. E. Lindquist149 , E. Lipeles123 , A. Lipniacka15 , M. Lisovyi60b , T. M. Liss166 , D. Lissauer27 , A. Lister168 , A. M. Litke138 , B. Liu152,ad , D. Liu152 , H. Liu91 , H. Liu27 , J. Liu87 , J. B. Liu35b , K. Liu87 , L. Liu166 , M. Liu47 , M. Liu35b , Y. L. Liu35b , Y. Liu35b , M. Livan122a,122b , A. Lleres57 , J. Llorente Merino84 , S. L. Lloyd78 , F. Lo Sterzo152 , E. Lobodzinska44 , P. Loch7 , W. S. Lockman138 , F. K. Loebinger86 , A. E. Loevschall-Jensen38 , K. M. Loew25 , A. Loginov176 , T. Lohse17 , K. Lohwasser44 , M. Lokajicek128 , B. A. Long24 , J. D. Long166 , R. E. Long74 , L. Longo75a,75b , K. A. Looper112 , L. Lopes127a , D. Lopez Mateos59 , B. Lopez Paredes140 , I. Lopez Paz13 , A. Lopez Solis82 , J. Lorenz101 , N. Lorenzo Martinez63 , M. Losada21 , P. J. Lösel101 , X. Lou35a , A. Lounis118 , J. Love6 , P. A. Love74 , H. Lu62a , N. Lu91 , H. J. Lubatti139 , C. Luci133a,133b , A. Lucotte57 , C. Luedtke50 , F. Luehring63 , W. Lukas64 , L. Luminari133a , O. Lundberg147a,147b , B. Lund-Jensen148 , D. Lynn27 , R. Lysak128 , E. Lytken83 , V. Lyubushkin67 , H. Ma27 , L. L. Ma35d , Y. Ma35d , G. Maccarrone49 , A. Macchiolo102 , C. M. Macdonald140 , B. Maček77 , J. Machado Miguens123,127b , D. Madaffari87 , R. Madar36 , H. J. Maddocks165 , W. F. Mader46 , A. Madsen44 , J. Maeda69 , S. Maeland15 , T. Maeno27 , A. Maevskiy100 , E. Magradze56 , J. Mahlstedt108 , C. Maiani118 , C. Maidantchik26a , A. A. Maier102 , T. Maier101 , A. Maio127a,127b,127d , S. Majewski117 , Y. Makida68 , N. Makovec118 , B. Malaescu82 , Pa. Malecki41 , V. P. Maleev124 , F. Malek57 , U. Mallik65 , D. Malon6 , C. Malone144 , S. Maltezos10 , S. Malyukov32 , J. Mamuzic167 , G. Mancini49 , B. Mandelli32 , L. Mandelli93a , I. Mandić77 , J. Maneira127a,127b , L. Manhaes de Andrade Filho26b , J. Manjarres Ramos160b , A. Mann101 , B. Mansoulie137 , R. Mantifel89 , M. Mantoani56 , S. Manzoni93a,93b , L. Mapelli32 , G. Marceca29 , L. March51 , G. Marchiori82 , M. Marcisovsky128 , M. Marjanovic14 , D. E. Marley91 , F. Marroquim26a , S. P. Marsden86 , Z. Marshall16 , S. Marti-Garcia167 , B. Martin92 , T. A. Martin170 , V. J. Martin48 , B. Martin dit Latour15 , M. Martinez13,r , S. Martin-Haugh132 , V. S. Martoiu28b , A. C. Martyniuk80 , M. Marx139 , A. Marzin32 , L. Masetti85 , T. Mashimo156 , R. Mashinistov97 , J. Masik86 , A. L. Maslennikov110,c , I. Massa22a,22b , L. Massa22a,22b , P. Mastrandrea5 , A. Mastroberardino39a,39b , T. Masubuchi156 , P. Mättig175 , J. Mattmann85 , J. Maurer28b , S. J. Maxfield76 , D. A. Maximov110,c , R. Mazini152 , S. M. Mazza93a,93b , N. C. Mc Fadden106 , G. Mc Goldrick159 , S. P. Mc Kee91 , A. McCarn91 , R. L. McCarthy149 , T. G. McCarthy31 , L. I. McClymont80 , E. F. McDonald90 , K. W. McFarlane58,* , J. A. Mcfayden80 , G. Mchedlidze56 , S. J. McMahon132 , R. A. McPherson169,l , M. Medinnis44 , S. Meehan139 , S. Mehlhase101 , A. Mehta76 , K. Meier60a , C. Meineck101 , B. Meirose43 , B. R. Mellado Garcia146c , M. Melo145a , F. Meloni18 , A. Mengarelli22a,22b , S. Menke102 , E. Meoni162 , S. Mergelmeyer17 , P. Mermod51 , L. Merola105a,105b , C. Meroni93a , F. S. Merritt33 , A. Messina133a,133b , J. Metcalfe6 , A. S. Mete163 , C. Meyer85 , C. Meyer123 , J-P. Meyer137 , J. Meyer108 , H. Meyer Zu Theenhausen60a , R. P. Middleton132 , S. Miglioranzi52a,52b , L. Mijović23 , G. Mikenberg172 , M. Mikestikova128 , M. Mikuž77 , M. Milesi90 , A. Milic32 , D. W. Miller33 , C. Mills48 , A. Milov172 , D. A. Milstead147a,147b , A. A. Minaenko131 , Y. Minami156 , I. A. Minashvili67 , A. I. Mincer111 , B. Mindur40a , M. Mineev67 , Y. Ming173 , L. M. Mir13 , K. P. Mistry123 , T. Mitani171 , J. Mitrevski101 , V. A. Mitsou167 , A. Miucci51 , P. S. Miyagawa140 , J. U. Mjörnmark83 , T. Moa147a,147b , K. Mochizuki87 , S. Mohapatra37 , W. Mohr50 , S. Molander147a,147b , R. Moles-Valls23 , R. Monden70 , M. C. Mondragon92 , K. Mönig44 , J. Monk38 , E. Monnier87 , A. Montalbano149 , J. Montejo Berlingen32 , F. Monticelli73 , S. Monzani93a,93b , R. W. Moore3 , N. Morange118 , D. Moreno21 , M. Moreno Llácer56 , P. Morettini52a , D. Mori143 , T. Mori156 , M. Morii59 , M. Morinaga156 , V. Morisbak120 , S. Moritz85 , A. K. Morley151 , G. Mornacchi32 , J. D. Morris78 , S. S. Mortensen38 , L. Morvaj149 , M. Mosidze53b , J. Moss144 , K. Motohashi158 , R. Mount144 , E. Mountricha27 , S. V. Mouraviev97,* , E. J. W. Moyse88 , S. Muanza87 , R. D. Mudd19 , F. Mueller102 , J. Mueller126 , R. S. P. Mueller101 , T. Mueller30 , D. Muenstermann74 , P. Mullen55 , G. A. Mullier18 , F. J. Munoz Sanchez86 , J. A. Murillo Quijada19 , W. J. Murray170,132 , H. Musheghyan56 , M. Muškinja77 , A. G. Myagkov131,ae , M. Myska129 , B. P. Nachman144 , O. Nackenhorst51 , J. Nadal56 , K. Nagai121 , R. Nagai68,z , 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 23 of 30 292 K. Nagano68 , Y. Nagasaka61 , K. Nagata161 , M. Nagel102 , E. Nagy87 , A. M. Nairz32 , Y. Nakahama32 , K. Nakamura68 , T. Nakamura156 , I. Nakano113 , H. Namasivayam43 , R. F. Naranjo Garcia44 , R. Narayan11 , D. I. Narrias Villar60a , I. Naryshkin124 , T. Naumann44 , G. Navarro21 , R. Nayyar7 , H. A. Neal91 , P. Yu. Nechaeva97 , T. J. Neep86 , P. D. Nef144 , A. Negri122a,122b , M. Negrini22a , S. Nektarijevic107 , C. Nellist118 , A. Nelson163 , S. Nemecek128 , P. Nemethy111 , A. A. Nepomuceno26a , M. Nessi32,af , M. S. Neubauer166 , M. Neumann175 , R. M. Neves111 , P. Nevski27 , P. R. Newman19 , D. H. Nguyen6 , T. Nguyen Manh96 , R. B. Nickerson121 , R. Nicolaidou137 , J. Nielsen138 , A. Nikiforov17 , V. Nikolaenko131,ae , I. Nikolic-Audit82 , K. Nikolopoulos19 , J. K. Nilsen120 , P. Nilsson27 , Y. Ninomiya156 , A. Nisati133a , R. Nisius102 , T. Nobe156 , L. Nodulman6 , M. Nomachi119 , I. Nomidis31 , T. Nooney78 , S. Norberg114 , M. Nordberg32 , N. Norjoharuddeen121 , O. Novgorodova46 , S. Nowak102 , M. Nozaki68 , L. Nozka116 , K. Ntekas10 , E. Nurse80 , F. Nuti90 , F. O’grady7 , D. C. O’Neil143 , A. A. O’Rourke44 , V. O’Shea55 , F. G. Oakham31,d , H. Oberlack102 , T. Obermann23 , J. Ocariz82 , A. Ochi69 , I. Ochoa37 , J. P. Ochoa-Ricoux34a , S. Oda72 , S. Odaka68 , H. Ogren63 , A. Oh86 , S. H. Oh47 , C. C. Ohm16 , H. Ohman165 , H. Oide32 , H. Okawa161 , Y. Okumura33 , T. Okuyama68 , A. Olariu28b , L. F. Oleiro Seabra127a , S. A. Olivares Pino48 , D. Oliveira Damazio27 , A. Olszewski41 , J. Olszowska41 , A. Onofre127a,127e , K. Onogi104 , P. U. E. Onyisi11,v , M. J. Oreglia33 , Y. Oren154 , D. Orestano135a,135b , N. Orlando62b , R. S. Orr159 , B. Osculati52a,52b , R. Ospanov86 , G. Otero y Garzon29 , H. Otono72 , M. Ouchrif136d , F. Ould-Saada120 , A. Ouraou137 , K. P. Oussoren108 , Q. Ouyang35a , M. Owen55 , R. E. Owen19 , V. E. Ozcan20a , N. Ozturk8 , K. Pachal143 , A. Pacheco Pages13 , C. Padilla Aranda13 , M. Pagáčová50 , S. Pagan Griso16 , F. Paige27 , P. Pais88 , K. Pajchel120 , G. Palacino160b , S. Palestini32 , M. Palka40b , D. Pallin36 , A. Palma127a,127b , E. St. Panagiotopoulou10 , C. E. Pandini82 , J. G. Panduro Vazquez79 , P. Pani147a,147b , S. Panitkin27 , D. Pantea28b , L. Paolozzi51 , Th. D. Papadopoulou10 , K. Papageorgiou155 , A. Paramonov6 , D. Paredes Hernandez176 , A. J. Parker74 , M. A. Parker30 , K. A. Parker140 , F. Parodi52a,52b , J. A. Parsons37 , U. Parzefall50 , V. R. Pascuzzi159 , E. Pasqualucci133a , S. Passaggio52a , F. Pastore135a,135b,* , Fr. Pastore79 , G. Pásztor31,ag , S. Pataraia175 , J. R. Pater86 , T. Pauly32 , J. Pearce169 , B. Pearson114 , L. E. Pedersen38 , M. Pedersen120 , S. Pedraza Lopez167 , R. Pedro127a,127b , S. V. Peleganchuk110,c , D. Pelikan165 , O. Penc128 , C. Peng35a , H. Peng35b , J. Penwell63 , B. S. Peralva26b , M. M. Perego137 , D. V. Perepelitsa27 , E. Perez Codina160a , L. Perini93a,93b , H. Pernegger32 , S. Perrella105a,105b , R. Peschke44 , V. D. Peshekhonov67 , K. Peters44 , R. F. Y. Peters86 , B. A. Petersen32 , T. C. Petersen38 , E. Petit57 , A. Petridis1 , C. Petridou155 , P. Petroff118 , E. Petrolo133a , M. Petrov121 , F. Petrucci135a,135b , N. E. Pettersson88 , A. Peyaud137 , R. Pezoa34b , P. W. Phillips132 , G. Piacquadio144 , E. Pianori170 , A. Picazio88 , E. Piccaro78 , M. Piccinini22a,22b , M. A. Pickering121 , R. Piegaia29 , J. E. Pilcher33 , A. D. Pilkington86 , A. W. J. Pin86 , M. Pinamonti164a,164c,ah , J. L. Pinfold3 , A. Pingel38 , S. Pires82 , H. Pirumov44 , M. Pitt172 , L. Plazak145a , M.-A. Pleier27 , V. Pleskot85 , E. Plotnikova67 , P. Plucinski92 , D. Pluth66 , R. Poettgen147a,147b , L. Poggioli118 , D. Pohl23 , G. Polesello122a , A. Poley44 , A. Policicchio39a,39b , R. Polifka159 , A. Polini22a , C. S. Pollard55 , V. Polychronakos27 , K. Pommès32 , L. Pontecorvo133a , B. G. Pope92 , G. A. Popeneciu28c , D. S. Popovic14 , A. Poppleton32 , S. Pospisil129 , K. Potamianos16 , I. N. Potrap67 , C. J. Potter30 , C. T. Potter117 , G. Poulard32 , J. Poveda32 , V. Pozdnyakov67 , M. E. Pozo Astigarraga32 , P. Pralavorio87 , A. Pranko16 , S. Prell66 , D. Price86 , L. E. Price6 , M. Primavera75a , S. Prince89 , M. Proissl48 , K. Prokofiev62c , F. Prokoshin34b , S. Protopopescu27 , J. Proudfoot6 , M. Przybycien40a , D. Puddu135a,135b , D. Puldon149 , M. Purohit27,ai , P. Puzo118 , J. Qian91 , G. Qin55 , Y. Qin86 , A. Quadt56 , W. B. Quayle164a,164b , M. Queitsch-Maitland86 , D. Quilty55 , S. Raddum120 , V. Radeka27 , V. Radescu60b , S. K. Radhakrishnan149 , P. Radloff117 , P. Rados90 , F. Ragusa93a,93b , G. Rahal178 , J. A. Raine86 , S. Rajagopalan27 , M. Rammensee32 , C. Rangel-Smith165 , M. G. Ratti93a,93b , F. Rauscher101 , S. Rave85 , T. Ravenscroft55 , M. Raymond32 , A. L. Read120 , N. P. Readioff76 , D. M. Rebuzzi122a,122b , A. Redelbach174 , G. Redlinger27 , R. Reece138 , K. Reeves43 , L. Rehnisch17 , J. Reichert123 , H. Reisin29 , C. Rembser32 , H. Ren35a , M. Rescigno133a , S. Resconi93a , O. L. Rezanova110,c , P. Reznicek130 , R. Rezvani96 , R. Richter102 , S. Richter80 , E. Richter-Was40b , O. Ricken23 , M. Ridel82 , P. Rieck17 , C. J. Riegel175 , J. Rieger56 , O. Rifki114 , M. Rijssenbeek149 , A. Rimoldi122a,122b , L. Rinaldi22a , B. Ristić51 , E. Ritsch32 , I. Riu13 , F. Rizatdinova115 , E. Rizvi78 , C. Rizzi13 , S. H. Robertson89,l , A. Robichaud-Veronneau89 , D. Robinson30 , J. E. M. Robinson44 , A. Robson55 , C. Roda125a,125b , Y. Rodina87 , A. Rodriguez Perez13 , D. Rodriguez Rodriguez167 , S. Roe32 , C. S. Rogan59 , O. Røhne120 , A. Romaniouk99 , M. Romano22a,22b , S. M. Romano Saez36 , E. Romero Adam167 , N. Rompotis139 , M. Ronzani50 , L. Roos82 , E. Ros167 , S. Rosati133a , K. Rosbach50 , P. Rose138 , O. Rosenthal142 , V. Rossetti147a,147b , E. Rossi105a,105b , L. P. Rossi52a , J. H. N. Rosten30 , R. Rosten139 , M. Rotaru28b , I. Roth172 , J. Rothberg139 , D. Rousseau118 , C. R. Royon137 , A. Rozanov87 , Y. Rozen153 , X. Ruan146c , F. Rubbo144 , V. I. Rud100 , M. S. Rudolph159 , F. Rühr50 , A. Ruiz-Martinez31 , Z. Rurikova50 , N. A. Rusakovich67 , A. Ruschke101 , H. L. Russell139 , J. P. Rutherfoord7 , N. Ruthmann32 , Y. F. Ryabov124 , M. Rybar166 , G. Rybkin118 , S. Ryu6 , A. Ryzhov131 , G. F. Rzehorz56 , A. F. Saavedra151 , G. Sabato108 , S. Sacerdoti29 , H. F-W. Sadrozinski138 , R. Sadykov67 , F. Safai Tehrani133a , P. Saha109 , M. Sahinsoy60a , M. Saimpert137 , T. Saito156 , H. Sakamoto156 , Y. Sakurai171 , G. Salamanna135a,135b , A. Salamon134a,134b , J. E. Salazar Loyola34b , D. Salek108 , P. H. Sales De Bruin139 , D. Salihagic102 , A. Salnikov144 , 123 292 Page 24 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 J. Salt167 , D. Salvatore39a,39b , F. Salvatore150 , A. Salvucci62a , A. Salzburger32 , D. Sammel50 , D. Sampsonidis155 , A. Sanchez105a,105b , J. Sánchez167 , V. Sanchez Martinez167 , H. Sandaker120 , R. L. Sandbach78 , H. G. Sander85 , M. Sandhoff175 , C. Sandoval21 , R. Sandstroem102 , D. P. C. Sankey132 , M. Sannino52a,52b , A. Sansoni49 , C. Santoni36 , R. Santonico134a,134b , H. Santos127a , I. Santoyo Castillo150 , K. Sapp126 , A. Sapronov67 , J. G. Saraiva127a,127d , B. Sarrazin23 , O. Sasaki68 , Y. Sasaki156 , K. Sato161 , G. Sauvage5,* , E. Sauvan5 , G. Savage79 , P. Savard159,d , C. Sawyer132 , L. Sawyer81,q , J. Saxon33 , C. Sbarra22a , A. Sbrizzi22a,22b , T. Scanlon80 , D. A. Scannicchio163 , M. Scarcella151 , V. Scarfone39a,39b , J. Schaarschmidt172 , P. Schacht102 , D. Schaefer32 , R. Schaefer44 , J. Schaeffer85 , S. Schaepe23 , S. Schaetzel60b , U. Schäfer85 , A. C. Schaffer118 , D. Schaile101 , R. D. Schamberger149 , V. Scharf60a , V. A. Schegelsky124 , D. Scheirich130 , M. Schernau163 , C. Schiavi52a,52b , C. Schillo50 , M. Schioppa39a,39b , S. Schlenker32 , K. Schmieden32 , C. Schmitt85 , S. Schmitt44 , S. Schmitz85 , B. Schneider160a , U. Schnoor50 , L. Schoeffel137 , A. Schoening60b , B. D. Schoenrock92 , E. Schopf23 , A. L. S. Schorlemmer45 , M. Schott85 , J. Schovancova8 , S. Schramm51 , M. Schreyer174 , N. Schuh85 , M. J. Schultens23 , H.-C. Schultz-Coulon60a , H. Schulz17 , M. Schumacher50 , B. A. Schumm138 , Ph. Schune137 , C. Schwanenberger86 , A. Schwartzman144 , T. A. Schwarz91 , Ph. Schwegler102 , H. Schweiger86 , Ph. Schwemling137 , R. Schwienhorst92 , J. Schwindling137 , T. Schwindt23 , G. Sciolla25 , F. Scuri125a,125b , F. Scutti90 , J. Searcy91 , P. Seema23 , S. C. Seidel106 , A. Seiden138 , F. Seifert129 , J. M. Seixas26a , G. Sekhniaidze105a , K. Sekhon91 , S. J. Sekula42 , D. M. Seliverstov124,* , N. Semprini-Cesari22a,22b , C. Serfon120 , L. Serin118 , L. Serkin164a,164b , M. Sessa135a,135b , R. Seuster169 , H. Severini114 , T. Sfiligoj77 , F. Sforza32 , A. Sfyrla51 , E. Shabalina56 , N. W. Shaikh147a,147b , L. Y. Shan35a , R. Shang166 , J. T. Shank24 , M. Shapiro16 , P. B. Shatalov98 , K. Shaw164a,164b , S. M. Shaw86 , A. Shcherbakova147a,147b , C. Y. Shehu150 , P. Sherwood80 , L. Shi152,aj , S. Shimizu69 , C. O. Shimmin163 , M. Shimojima103 , M. Shiyakova67,ak , A. Shmeleva97 , D. Shoaleh Saadi96 , M. J. Shochet33 , S. Shojaii93a,93b , S. Shrestha112 , E. Shulga99 , M. A. Shupe7 , P. Sicho128 , P. E. Sidebo148 , O. Sidiropoulou174 , D. Sidorov115 , A. Sidoti22a,22b , F. Siegert46 , Dj. Sijacki14 , J. Silva127a,127d , S. B. Silverstein147a , V. Simak129 , O. Simard5 , Lj. Simic14 , S. Simion118 , E. Simioni85 , B. Simmons80 , D. Simon36 , M. Simon85 , P. Sinervo159 , N. B. Sinev117 , M. Sioli22a,22b , G. Siragusa174 , S. Yu. Sivoklokov100 , J. Sjölin147a,147b , T. B. Sjursen15 , M. B. Skinner74 , H. P. Skottowe59 , P. Skubic114 , M. Slater19 , T. Slavicek129 , M. Slawinska108 , K. Sliwa162 , R. Slovak130 , V. Smakhtin172 , B. H. Smart5 , L. Smestad15 , S. Yu. Smirnov99 , Y. Smirnov99 , L. N. Smirnova100,al , O. Smirnova83 , M. N. K. Smith37 , R. W. Smith37 , M. Smizanska74 , K. Smolek129 , A. A. Snesarev97 , S. Snyder27 , R. Sobie169,l , F. Socher46 , A. Soffer154 , D. A. Soh152,aj , G. Sokhrannyi77 , C. A. Solans Sanchez32 , M. Solar129 , E. Yu. Soldatov99 , U. Soldevila167 , A. A. Solodkov131 , A. Soloshenko67 , O. V. Solovyanov131 , V. Solovyev124 , P. Sommer50 , H. Son162 , H. Y. Song35b,am , A. Sood16 , A. Sopczak129 , V. Sopko129 , V. Sorin13 , D. Sosa60b , C. L. Sotiropoulou125a,125b , R. Soualah164a,164c , A. M. Soukharev110,c , D. South44 , B. C. Sowden79 , S. Spagnolo75a,75b , M. Spalla125a,125b , M. Spangenberg170 , F. Spanò79 , D. Sperlich17 , F. Spettel102 , R. Spighi22a , G. Spigo32 , L. A. Spiller90 , M. Spousta130 , R. D. St. Denis55,* , A. Stabile93a , R. Stamen60a , S. Stamm17 , E. Stanecka41 , R. W. Stanek6 , C. Stanescu135a , M. Stanescu-Bellu44 , M. M. Stanitzki44 , S. Stapnes120 , E. A. Starchenko131 , G. H. Stark33 , J. Stark57 , P. Staroba128 , P. Starovoitov60a , S. Stärz32 , R. Staszewski41 , P. Steinberg27 , B. Stelzer143 , H. J. Stelzer32 , O. Stelzer-Chilton160a , H. Stenzel54 , G. A. Stewart55 , J. A. Stillings23 , M. C. Stockton89 , M. Stoebe89 , G. Stoicea28b , P. Stolte56 , S. Stonjek102 , A. R. Stradling8 , A. Straessner46 , M. E. Stramaglia18 , J. Strandberg148 , S. Strandberg147a,147b , A. Strandlie120 , M. Strauss114 , P. Strizenec145b , R. Ströhmer174 , D. M. Strom117 , R. Stroynowski42 , A. Strubig107 , S. A. Stucci18 , B. Stugu15 , N. A. Styles44 , D. Su144 , J. Su126 , R. Subramaniam81 , S. Suchek60a , Y. Sugaya119 , M. Suk129 , V. V. Sulin97 , S. Sultansoy4c , T. Sumida70 , S. Sun59 , X. Sun35a , J. E. Sundermann50 , K. Suruliz150 , G. Susinno39a,39b , M. R. Sutton150 , S. Suzuki68 , M. Svatos128 , M. Swiatlowski33 , I. Sykora145a , T. Sykora130 , D. Ta50 , C. Taccini135a,135b , K. Tackmann44 , J. Taenzer159 , A. Taffard163 , R. Tafirout160a , N. Taiblum154 , H. Takai27 , R. Takashima71 , T. Takeshita141 , Y. Takubo68 , M. Talby87 , A. A. Talyshev110,c , J. Y. C. Tam174 , K. G. Tan90 , J. Tanaka156 , R. Tanaka118 , S. Tanaka68 , B. B. Tannenwald112 , S. Tapia Araya34b , S. Tapprogge85 , S. Tarem153 , G. F. Tartarelli93a , P. Tas130 , M. Tasevsky128 , T. Tashiro70 , E. Tassi39a,39b , A. Tavares Delgado127a,127b , Y. Tayalati136d , A. C. Taylor106 , G. N. Taylor90 , P. T. E. Taylor90 , W. Taylor160b , F. A. Teischinger32 , P. Teixeira-Dias79 , K. K. Temming50 , D. Temple143 , H. Ten Kate32 , P. K. Teng152 , J. J. Teoh119 , F. Tepel175 , S. Terada68 , K. Terashi156 , J. Terron84 , S. Terzo102 , M. Testa49 , R. J. Teuscher159,l , T. Theveneaux-Pelzer87 , J. P. Thomas19 , J. Thomas-Wilsker79 , E. N. Thompson37 , P. D. Thompson19 , A. S. Thompson55 , L. A. Thomsen176 , E. Thomson123 , M. Thomson30 , M. J. Tibbetts16 , R. E. Ticse Torres87 , V. O. Tikhomirov97,an , Yu. A. Tikhonov110,c , S. Timoshenko99 , P. Tipton176 , S. Tisserant87 , K. Todome158 , T. Todorov5,* , S. Todorova-Nova130 , J. Tojo72 , S. Tokár145a , K. Tokushuku68 , E. Tolley59 , L. Tomlinson86 , M. Tomoto104 , L. Tompkins144,ao , K. Toms106 , B. Tong59 , E. Torrence117 , H. Torres143 , E. Torró Pastor139 , J. Toth87,ap , F. Touchard87 , D. R. Tovey140 , T. Trefzger174 , A. Tricoli27 , I. M. Trigger160a , S. Trincaz-Duvoid82 , M. F. Tripiana13 , W. Trischuk159 , B. Trocmé57 , A. Trofymov44 , C. Troncon93a , M. Trottier-McDonald16 , M. Trovatelli169 , L. Truong164a,164b , M. Trzebinski41 , A. Trzupek41 , J. C-L. Tseng121 , P. V. Tsiareshka94 , G. Tsipolitis10 , N. Tsirintanis9 , 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 25 of 30 292 S. Tsiskaridze13 , V. Tsiskaridze50 , E. G. Tskhadadze53a , K. M. Tsui62a , I. I. Tsukerman98 , V. Tsulaia16 , S. Tsuno68 , D. Tsybychev149 , A. Tudorache28b , V. Tudorache28b , A. N. Tuna59 , S. A. Tupputi22a,22b , S. Turchikhin100,al , D. Turecek129 , D. Turgeman172 , R. Turra93a,93b , A. J. Turvey42 , P. M. Tuts37 , M. Tyndel132 , G. Ucchielli22a,22b , I. Ueda156 , R. Ueno31 , M. Ughetto147a,147b , F. Ukegawa161 , G. Unal32 , A. Undrus27 , G. Unel163 , F. C. Ungaro90 , Y. Unno68 , C. Unverdorben101 , J. Urban145b , P. Urquijo90 , P. Urrejola85 , G. Usai8 , A. Usanova64 , L. Vacavant87 , V. Vacek129 , B. Vachon89 , C. Valderanis101 , E. Valdes Santurio147a,147b , N. Valencic108 , S. Valentinetti22a,22b , A. Valero167 , L. Valery13 , S. Valkar130 , S. Vallecorsa51 , J. A. Valls Ferrer167 , W. Van Den Wollenberg108 , P. C. Van Der Deijl108 , R. van der Geer108 , H. van der Graaf108 , N. van Eldik153 , P. van Gemmeren6 , J. Van Nieuwkoop143 , I. van Vulpen108 , M. C. van Woerden32 , M. Vanadia133a,133b , W. Vandelli32 , R. Vanguri123 , A. Vaniachine6 , P. Vankov108 , G. Vardanyan177 , R. Vari133a , E. W. Varnes7 , T. Varol42 , D. Varouchas82 , A. Vartapetian8 , K. E. Varvell151 , J. G. Vasquez176 , F. Vazeille36 , T. Vazquez Schroeder89 , J. Veatch56 , L. M. Veloce159 , F. Veloso127a,127c , S. Veneziano133a , A. Ventura75a,75b , M. Venturi169 , N. Venturi159 , A. Venturini25 , V. Vercesi122a , M. Verducci133a,133b , W. Verkerke108 , J. C. Vermeulen108 , A. Vest46,aq , M. C. Vetterli143,d , O. Viazlo83 , I. Vichou166 , T. Vickey140 , O. E. Vickey Boeriu140 , G. H. A. Viehhauser121 , S. Viel16 , L. Vigani121 , R. Vigne64 , M. Villa22a,22b , M. Villaplana Perez93a,93b , E. Vilucchi49 , M. G. Vincter31 , V. B. Vinogradov67 , C. Vittori22a,22b , I. Vivarelli150 , S. Vlachos10 , M. Vlasak129 , M. Vogel175 , P. Vokac129 , G. Volpi125a,125b , M. Volpi90 , H. von der Schmitt102 , E. von Toerne23 , V. Vorobel130 , K. Vorobev99 , M. Vos167 , R. Voss32 , J. H. Vossebeld76 , N. Vranjes14 , M. Vranjes Milosavljevic14 , V. Vrba128 , M. Vreeswijk108 , R. Vuillermet32 , I. Vukotic33 , Z. Vykydal129 , P. Wagner23 , W. Wagner175 , H. Wahlberg73 , S. Wahrmund46 , J. Wakabayashi104 , J. Walder74 , R. Walker101 , W. Walkowiak142 , V. Wallangen147a,147b , C. Wang152 , C. Wang35d,87 , F. Wang173 , H. Wang16 , H. Wang42 , J. Wang44 , J. Wang151 , K. Wang89 , R. Wang6 , S. M. Wang152 , T. Wang23 , T. Wang37 , X. Wang176 , C. Wanotayaroj117 , A. Warburton89 , C. P. Ward30 , D. R. Wardrope80 , A. Washbrook48 , P. M. Watkins19 , A. T. Watson19 , M. F. Watson19 , G. Watts139 , S. Watts86 , B. M. Waugh80 , S. Webb85 , M. S. Weber18 , S. W. Weber174 , J. S. Webster6 , A. R. Weidberg121 , B. Weinert63 , J. Weingarten56 , C. Weiser50 , H. Weits108 , P. S. Wells32 , T. Wenaus27 , T. Wengler32 , S. Wenig32 , N. Wermes23 , M. Werner50 , P. Werner32 , M. Wessels60a , J. Wetter162 , K. Whalen117 , N. L. Whallon139 , A. M. Wharton74 , A. White8 , M. J. White1 , R. White34b , S. White125a,125b , D. Whiteson163 , F. J. Wickens132 , W. Wiedenmann173 , M. Wielers132 , P. Wienemann23 , C. Wiglesworth38 , L. A. M. Wiik-Fuchs23 , A. Wildauer102 , F. Wilk86 , H. G. Wilkens32 , H. H. Williams123 , S. Williams108 , C. Willis92 , S. Willocq88 , J. A. Wilson19 , I. Wingerter-Seez5 , F. Winklmeier117 , O. J. Winston150 , B. T. Winter23 , M. Wittgen144 , J. Wittkowski101 , S. J. Wollstadt85 , M. W. Wolter41 , H. Wolters127a,127c , B. K. Wosiek41 , J. Wotschack32 , M. J. Woudstra86 , K. W. Wozniak41 , M. Wu57 , M. Wu33 , S. L. Wu173 , X. Wu51 , Y. Wu91 , T. R. Wyatt86 , B. M. Wynne48 , S. Xella38 , D. Xu35a , L. Xu27 , B. Yabsley151 , S. Yacoob146a , R. Yakabe69 , D. Yamaguchi158 , Y. Yamaguchi119 , A. Yamamoto68 , S. Yamamoto156 , T. Yamanaka156 , K. Yamauchi104 , Y. Yamazaki69 , Z. Yan24 , H. Yang35e , H. Yang173 , Y. Yang152 , Z. Yang15 , W-M. Yao16 , Y. C. Yap82 , Y. Yasu68 , E. Yatsenko5 , K. H. Yau Wong23 , J. Ye42 , S. Ye27 , I. Yeletskikh67 , A. L. Yen59 , E. Yildirim44 , K. Yorita171 , R. Yoshida6 , K. Yoshihara123 , C. Young144 , C. J. S. Young32 , S. Youssef24 , D. R. Yu16 , J. Yu8 , J. M. Yu91 , J. Yu66 , L. Yuan69 , S. P. Y. Yuen23 , I. Yusuff30,ar , B. Zabinski41 , R. Zaidan35d , A. M. Zaitsev131,ae , N. Zakharchuk44 , J. Zalieckas15 , A. Zaman149 , S. Zambito59 , L. Zanello133a,133b , D. Zanzi90 , C. Zeitnitz175 , M. Zeman129 , A. Zemla40a , J. C. Zeng166 , Q. Zeng144 , K. Zengel25 , O. Zenin131 , T. Ženiš145a , D. Zerwas118 , D. Zhang91 , F. Zhang173 , G. Zhang35b,am , H. Zhang35c , J. Zhang6 , L. Zhang50 , R. Zhang23 , R. Zhang35b,as , X. Zhang35d , Z. Zhang118 , X. Zhao42 , Y. Zhao35d , Z. Zhao35b , A. Zhemchugov67 , J. Zhong121 , B. Zhou91 , C. Zhou47 , L. Zhou37 , L. Zhou42 , M. Zhou149 , N. Zhou35f , C. G. Zhu35d , H. Zhu35a , J. Zhu91 , Y. Zhu35b , X. Zhuang35a , K. Zhukov97 , A. Zibell174 , D. Zieminska63 , N. I. Zimine67 , C. Zimmermann85 , S. Zimmermann50 , Z. Zinonos56 , M. Zinser85 , M. Ziolkowski142 , L. Živković14 , G. Zobernig173 , A. Zoccoli22a,22b , M. zur Nedden17 , G. Zurzolo105a,105b , L. Zwalinski32 1 Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia 2 Physics Department, SUNY Albany, Albany, NY, USA 3 Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada 4 (a) Department of Physics, Ankara University, Ankara, Turkey; (b) Istanbul Aydin University, Istanbul, Turkey; (c) Division of Physics, TOBB University of Economics and Technology, Ankara, Turkey 5 LAPP, CNRS/IN2P3 and Université Savoie Mont Blanc, Annecy-le-Vieux, France 6 High Energy Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL, USA 7 Department of Physics, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA 8 Department of Physics, The University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington, TX, USA 9 Physics Department, University of Athens, Athens, Greece 10 Physics Department, National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, Greece 123 292 Page 26 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 11 Department of Physics, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA 12 Institute of Physics, Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences, Baku, Azerbaijan 13 Institut de Física d’Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Barcelona, Spain 14 Institute of Physics, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia 15 Department for Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway 16 Physics Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and University of California, Berkeley, CA, USA 17 Department of Physics, Humboldt University, Berlin, Germany 18 Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics and Laboratory for High Energy Physics, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland 19 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK 20 (a) Department of Physics, Bogazici University, Istanbul, Turkey; (b) Department of Physics Engineering, Gaziantep University, Gaziantep, Turkey; (c) Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Istanbul Bilgi University, Istanbul, Turkey; (d) Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Bahcesehir University, Istanbul, Turkey 21 Centro de Investigaciones, Universidad Antonio Narino, Bogota, Colombia 22 (a) INFN Sezione di Bologna, Bologna, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy 23 Physikalisches Institut, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany 24 Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA 25 Department of Physics, Brandeis University, Waltham, MA, USA 26 (a) Universidade Federal do Rio De Janeiro COPPE/EE/IF, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; (b) Electrical Circuits Department, Federal University of Juiz de Fora (UFJF), Juiz de Fora, Brazil; (c) Federal University of Sao Joao del Rei (UFSJ), Sao Joao del Rei, Brazil; (d) Instituto de Fisica, Universidade de Sao Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil 27 Physics Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY, USA 28 (a) Transilvania University of Brasov, Brasov, Romania; (b) National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest, Romania; (c) Physics Department, National Institute for Research and Development of Isotopic and Molecular Technologies, Cluj Napoca, Romania; (d) University Politehnica Bucharest, Bucharest, Romania; (e) West University in Timisoara, Timisoara, Romania 29 Departamento de Física, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina 30 Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK 31 Department of Physics, Carleton University, Ottawa, ON, Canada 32 CERN, Geneva, Switzerland 33 Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA 34 (a) Departamento de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile; (b) Departamento de Física, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaiso, Chile 35 (a) Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China; (b) Department of Modern Physics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui, China; (c) Department of Physics, Nanjing University, Nanjing, Jiangsu, China; (d) School of Physics, Shandong University, Jinan, Shandong, China; (e) Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University (also affiliated with PKU-CHEP), Shanghai, China; (f) Physics Department, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China 36 Laboratoire de Physique Corpusculaire, Clermont Université and Université Blaise Pascal and CNRS/IN2P3, Clermont-Ferrand, France 37 Nevis Laboratory, Columbia University, Irvington, NY, USA 38 Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Kobenhavn, Denmark 39 (a) INFN Gruppo Collegato di Cosenza, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università della Calabria, Rende, Italy 40 (a) Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, AGH University of Science and Technology, Kraków, Poland; (b) Marian Smoluchowski Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland 41 Institute of Nuclear Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Krakow, Poland 42 Physics Department, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, TX, USA 43 Physics Department, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, TX, USA 44 DESY, Hamburg and Zeuthen, Germany 45 Institut für Experimentelle Physik IV, Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany 46 Institut für Kern- und Teilchenphysik, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden, Germany 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 27 of 30 292 47 Department of Physics, Duke University, Durham, NC, USA 48 SUPA-School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK 49 INFN Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati, Italy 50 Fakultät für Mathematik und Physik, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität, Freiburg, Germany 51 Section de Physique, Université de Genève, Geneva, Switzerland 52 (a) INFN Sezione di Genova, Genoa, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Genova, Genoa, Italy 53 (a) E. Andronikashvili Institute of Physics, Iv. Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi, Georgia; (b) High Energy Physics Institute, Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi, Georgia 54 II Physikalisches Institut, Justus-Liebig-Universität Giessen, Giessen, Germany 55 SUPA-School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK 56 II Physikalisches Institut, Georg-August-Universität, Göttingen, Germany 57 Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et de Cosmologie, Université Grenoble-Alpes, CNRS/IN2P3, Grenoble, France 58 Department of Physics, Hampton University, Hampton, VA, USA 59 Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA 60 (a) Kirchhoff-Institut für Physik, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; (b) Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany; (c) ZITI Institut für technische Informatik, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany 61 Faculty of Applied Information Science, Hiroshima Institute of Technology, Hiroshima, Japan 62 (a) Department of Physics, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, NT, Hong Kong; (b) Department of Physics, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong; (c) Department of Physics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China 63 Department of Physics, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, USA 64 Institut für Astro- und Teilchenphysik, Leopold-Franzens-Universität, Innsbruck, Austria 65 University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, USA 66 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA 67 Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, JINR Dubna, Dubna, Russia 68 KEK, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization, Tsukuba, Japan 69 Graduate School of Science, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan 70 Faculty of Science, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan 71 Kyoto University of Education, Kyoto, Japan 72 Department of Physics, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan 73 Instituto de Física La Plata, Universidad Nacional de La Plata and CONICET, La Plata, Argentina 74 Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, UK 75 (a) INFN Sezione di Lecce, Lecce, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università del Salento, Lecce, Italy 76 Oliver Lodge Laboratory, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK 77 Department of Physics, Jožef Stefan Institute and University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia 78 School of Physics and Astronomy, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK 79 Department of Physics, Royal Holloway University of London, Surrey, UK 80 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, London, UK 81 Louisiana Tech University, Ruston, LA, USA 82 Laboratoire de Physique Nucléaire et de Hautes Energies, UPMC and Université Paris-Diderot and CNRS/IN2P3, Paris, France 83 Fysiska institutionen, Lunds universitet, Lund, Sweden 84 Departamento de Fisica Teorica C-15, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain 85 Institut für Physik, Universität Mainz, Mainz, Germany 86 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK 87 CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université and CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille, France 88 Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, USA 89 Department of Physics, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada 90 School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, Australia 91 Department of Physics, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA 92 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA 93 (a) INFN Sezione di Milano, Milan, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Milano, Milan, Italy 123 292 Page 28 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 94 B.I. Stepanov Institute of Physics, National Academy of Sciences of Belarus, Minsk, Republic of Belarus 95 National Scientific and Educational Centre for Particle and High Energy Physics, Minsk, Republic of Belarus 96 Group of Particle Physics, University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada 97 P.N. Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian, Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia 98 Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics (ITEP), Moscow, Russia 99 National Research Nuclear University MEPhI, Moscow, Russia 100 D.V. Skobeltsyn Institute of Nuclear Physics, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia 101 Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Munich, Germany 102 Max-Planck-Institut für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut), Munich, Germany 103 Nagasaki Institute of Applied Science, Nagasaki, Japan 104 Graduate School of Science and Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute, Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan 105 (a) INFN Sezione di Napoli, Naples, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Napoli, Naples, Italy 106 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, USA 107 Institute for Mathematics, Astrophysics and Particle Physics, Radboud University Nijmegen/Nikhef, Nijmegen, The Netherlands 108 Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics and University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 109 Department of Physics, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, IL, USA 110 Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics, SB RAS, Novosibirsk, Russia 111 Department of Physics, New York University, New York, NY, USA 112 Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA 113 Faculty of Science, Okayama University, Okayama, Japan 114 Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK, USA 115 Department of Physics, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, USA 116 Palacký University, RCPTM, Olomouc, Czech Republic 117 Center for High Energy Physics, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR, USA 118 LAL, Univ. Paris-Sud, CNRS/IN2P3, Université Paris Saclay, Orsay, France 119 Graduate School of Science, Osaka University, Osaka, Japan 120 Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway 121 Department of Physics, Oxford University, Oxford, UK 122 (a) INFN Sezione di Pavia, Pavia, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Pavia, Pavia, Italy 123 Department of Physics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA 124 National Research Centre “Kurchatov Institute” B.P.Konstantinov Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute, St. Petersburg, Russia 125 (a) INFN Sezione di Pisa, Pisa, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica E. Fermi, Università di Pisa, Pisa, Italy 126 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA 127 (a) Laboratório de Instrumentação e Física Experimental de Partículas-LIP, Lisbon, Portugal; (b) Faculdade de Ciências, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal; (c) Department of Physics, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal; (d) Centro de Física Nuclear da Universidade de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal; (e) Departamento de Fisica, Universidade do Minho, Braga, Portugal; (f) Departamento de Fisica Teorica y del Cosmos and CAFPE, Universidad de Granada, Granada, Spain; (g) Dep Fisica and CEFITEC of Faculdade de Ciencias e Tecnologia, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Caparica, Portugal 128 Institute of Physics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic 129 Czech Technical University in Prague, Prague, Czech Republic 130 Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University in Prague, Prague, Czech Republic 131 State Research Center Institute for High Energy Physics, Protvino, NRC KI, Russia 132 Particle Physics Department, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Didcot, UK 133 (a) INFN Sezione di Roma, Rome, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Rome, Italy 134 (a) INFN Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Roma Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy 135 (a) INFN Sezione di Roma Tre, Rome, Italy; (b) Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università Roma Tre, Rome, Italy 136 (a) Faculté des Sciences Ain Chock, Réseau Universitaire de Physique des Hautes Energies-Université Hassan II, Casablanca, Morocco; (b) Centre National de l’Energie des Sciences Techniques Nucleaires, Rabat, Morocco; (c) Faculté des Sciences Semlalia, Université Cadi Ayyad, LPHEA-Marrakech, Marrakech, Morocco; (d) Faculté des Sciences, 123 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 Page 29 of 30 292 Université Mohamed Premier and LPTPM, Oujda, Morocco; (e) Faculté des Sciences, Université Mohammed V, Rabat, Morocco 137 DSM/IRFU (Institut de Recherches sur les Lois Fondamentales de l’Univers), CEA Saclay (Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique et aux Energies Alternatives), Gif-sur-Yvette, France 138 Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics, University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, CA, USA 139 Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA 140 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK 141 Department of Physics, Shinshu University, Nagano, Japan 142 Fachbereich Physik, Universität Siegen, Siegen, Germany 143 Department of Physics, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada 144 SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Stanford, CA, USA 145 (a) Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovak Republic; (b) Department of Subnuclear Physics, Institute of Experimental Physics of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, Kosice, Slovak Republic 146 (a) Department of Physics, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa; (b) Department of Physics, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa; (c) School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa 147 (a) Department of Physics, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden; (b) The Oskar Klein Centre, Stockholm, Sweden 148 Physics Department, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden 149 Departments of Physics and Astronomy and Chemistry, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, USA 150 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Brighton, UK 151 School of Physics, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia 152 Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan 153 Department of Physics, Technion: Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel 154 Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel 155 Department of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloníki, Greece 156 International Center for Elementary Particle Physics and Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan 157 Graduate School of Science and Technology, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan 158 Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan 159 Department of Physics, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada 160 (a) TRIUMF, Vancouver, BC, Canada; (b) Department of Physics and Astronomy, York University, Toronto, ON, Canada 161 Faculty of Pure and Applied Sciences, and Center for Integrated Research in Fundamental Science and Engineering, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan 162 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Tufts University, Medford, MA, USA 163 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, USA 164 (a) INFN Gruppo Collegato di Udine, Sezione di Trieste, Udine, Italy; (b) ICTP, Trieste, Italy; (c) Dipartimento di Chimica, Fisica e Ambiente, Università di Udine, Udine, Italy 165 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Uppsala, Uppsala, Sweden 166 Department of Physics, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL, USA 167 Instituto de Fisica Corpuscular (IFIC) and Departamento de Fisica Atomica, Molecular y Nuclear and Departamento de Ingeniería Electrónica and Instituto de Microelectrónica de Barcelona (IMB-CNM), University of Valencia and CSIC, Valencia, Spain 168 Department of Physics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada 169 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC, Canada 170 Department of Physics, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK 171 Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan 172 Department of Particle Physics, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel 173 Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, USA 174 Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Julius-Maximilians-Universität, Würzburg, Germany 175 Fakultät für Mathematik und Naturwissenschaften, Fachgruppe Physik, Bergische Universität Wuppertal, Wuppertal, Germany 176 Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA 177 Yerevan Physics Institute, Yerevan, Armenia 178 Centre de Calcul de l’Institut National de Physique Nucléaire et de Physique des Particules (IN2P3), Villeurbanne, France 123 292 Page 30 of 30 Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:292 a Also at Department of Physics, King’s College London, London, UK b Also at Institute of Physics, Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences, Baku, Azerbaijan c Also at Novosibirsk State University, Novosibirsk, Russia d Also at TRIUMF, Vancouver, BC, Canada e Also at Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY, USA f Also at Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno, CA, USA g Also at Department of Physics, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland h Also at Departament de Fisica de la Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain i Also at Departamento de Fisica e Astronomia, Faculdade de Ciencias, Universidade do Porto, Porto, Portugal j Also at Tomsk State University, Tomsk, Russia k Also at Universita di Napoli Parthenope, Napoli, Italy l Also at Institute of Particle Physics (IPP), Canada m Also at National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest, Romania n Also at Department of Physics, St. Petersburg State Polytechnical University, St. Petersburg, Russia o Also at Department of Physics, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA p Also at Centre for High Performance Computing, CSIR Campus, Rosebank, Cape Town, South Africa q Also at Louisiana Tech University, Ruston, LA, USA r Also at Institucio Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avancats, ICREA, Barcelona, Spain s Also at Graduate School of Science, Osaka University, Osaka, Japan t Also at Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, Taiwan u Also at Institute for Mathematics, Astrophysics and Particle Physics, Radboud University Nijmegen/Nikhef, Nijmegen, Netherlands v Also at Department of Physics, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA w Also at Institute of Theoretical Physics, Ilia State University, Tbilisi, Georgia x Also at CERN, Geneva, Switzerland y Also at Georgian Technical University (GTU), Tbilisi, Georgia z Also at Ochadai Academic Production, Ochanomizu University, Tokyo, Japan aa Also at Manhattan College, New York, NY, USA ab Also at Hellenic Open University, Patras, Greece ac Also at Academia Sinica Grid Computing, Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan ad Also at School of Physics, Shandong University, Shandong, China ae Also at Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology State University, Dolgoprudny, Russia af Also at Section de Physique, Université de Genève, Geneva, Switzerland ag Also at Eotvos Lorand University, Budapest, Hungary ah Also at International School for Advanced Studies (SISSA), Trieste, Italy ai Also at Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA aj Also at School of Physics and Engineering, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China ak Also at Institute for Nuclear Research and Nuclear Energy (INRNE) of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria al Also at Faculty of Physics, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia am Also at Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan an Also at National Research Nuclear University MEPhI, Moscow, Russia ao Also at Department of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA ap Also at Institute for Particle and Nuclear Physics, Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Budapest, Hungary aq Also at Flensburg University of Applied Sciences, Flensburg, Germany ar Also at University of Malaya, Department of Physics, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia as Also at CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université and CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille, France ∗ Deceased 123