Published for SISSA by Springer Received: March 1, 2015 Accepted: March 24, 2015 Published: April 15, 2015 Miguel Campigliaa and Alok Laddhab a Instituto de Fı́sica, Facultad de Ciencias, Montevideo 11400, Uruguay b Chennai Mathematical Institute, Siruseri 603103, India E-mail: campi@fisica.edu.uy, aladdha@cmi.ac.in JHEP04(2015)076 1 Introduction 1 In [6], this theorem was proved in the holomorphic limit. More general proofs were later given in [7, 8]. See [9–11] for earlier work on soft graviton amplitudes. 2 Based on earlier papers, we refer to the subleading soft theorem as Cachazo-Strominger theorem. 3 Here ‘charge’ refers to what is called ‘flux’ in the radiative phase space literature, i.e. it involves a three dimensional integral over null infinity. 4 We are deviating from the standard radiative phase space terminology in which ‘frame’ denotes a conformal class of [(qab , na )] of metric and null normal [17]. –2– JHEP04(2015)076 A natural question then arises, namely if the subleading soft graviton theorem conjectured by Strominger and proved in [6–8]1 is also a manifestation of Ward identities associated to some symmetry of the perturbative S matrix. In [12] it was argued that the subleading soft theorem can yield Ward identities associated to ‘extended BMS’ symmetries [13, 14]. The extended BMS group is a semidirect product of local (as opposed to global in the BMS case) conformal group of the two-sphere, also known as Virasoro group, and supertranslations. However due to difficulties associated to the singular nature of local conformal Killing vector fields (CKVs) on the conformal sphere, it was not clear how to obtain the subleading soft theorem from Ward identities. In [15], motivated by the precise equivalence between supertranslation Ward Identities and Weinberg’s soft graviton theorem, we argued that the Cachazo-Strominger (CS) theorem2 was in fact equivalent to Ward identities associated not to the Virasoro group but to the group of sphere diffeomorphisms Diff(S 2 ) which belongs not to the ‘extended BMS’ group but to what we called ‘generalized BMS’ group G. This group has the same structure as the (extended) BMS group, but instead of (local) CKVs of the conformal sphere one allows for arbitrary smooth sphere vector fields. That is, G is a semidirect product of diffeomorphisms of the conformal sphere and supertranslations. Based on earlier literature on radiative phase space and asymptotic symmetries [13, 14, 16–20] it was argued in [15] that G is a symmetry of Einstein’s equations (with zero cosmological constant) if one allows for arbitrary metrics on the conformal sphere. We then showed that if the charges3 of the Diff(S 2 ) generators states of the theory were exactly equal to the charges of Virasoro generators given in [12] then the Cachazo-Strominger theorem was equivalent to the Ward identities associated to Diff(S 2 ). A key question left unanswered in [15] was whether the proposed charges could be derived from canonical methods. The difficulty stem from the fact that the action of G does not preserve Ashtekar’s radiative phase space (see [21] for a recent review). More in detail, the radiative phase space Γq depends an a given choice of sphere 2-metric qAB or ‘frame’4 at null infinity. In contrast to the BMS group, G does not preserve Γq since the Diff(S 2 ) factor does not preserve the given frame qAB . Thus, the strategy that had successfully lead to BMS charges [17] could not be applied here. It is then natural to attempt to work in the space Γ ∼ ∪{q} Γq off all radiative phase spaces on which G acts in a well defined manner. However we were so far lacking a symplectic structure on Γ. It is here that we turn to covariant phase space methods [22, 23]. It is well known [24] that the symplectic structure on Γq corresponds to the GR covariant phase space symplectic structure Ωcov evaluated at null infinity. Here we will show that Ωcov naturally defines a symplectic structure on (a suitable subspace of) Γ. By realizing Γq̊ as a symplectic subspace of Γ, we will be able to derive the G-charges that were postulated in [15]. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Spacetimes under consideration As in [3, 4, 12] we are interested in spacetimes that are asymptotically flat at both future and past null infinity. For concreteness we focus on the description from future null infinity; similar considerations apply to the description from past null infinity. We follow closely reference [14]. In Bondi coordinates (u, r, xA ) the 4-metric is parameterized as ds2 = (V /r)e2β du2 − 2e2β dudr + gAB (dxA − U A du)(dxB − U B du), (2.1) with β, V /r, U A and gAB satisfying the r → ∞ fall-offs β = r−2 β̊ + O(r−3 ), V /r = V̊ + r−1 2M + O(r−2 ), 1 gAB = r2 qAB + rCAB + qAB C 2 + O(r−1 ). 4 U A = r−2 Ů A + O(r−3 ) (2.2) (2.3) Here C 2 ≡ CAB C AB (sphere indices are raised and lowered with qAB ) and the coefficients of the 1/r expansion in (2.2) and (2.3) are functions of u and xA except for qAB which, in contrast to [14], we assume to be u-independent. There is an additional gauge fixing condition det(gAB ) = r4 det(qAB ) –3– (2.4) JHEP04(2015)076 The outline of the paper is as follows. Section 2 provides the background material for our discussion. In 2.1 we describe the class of spacetimes under consideration following closely reference [14]. In 2.2 we review the definition of generalized BMS group G as a symmetry group of such spacetimes. In 2.3 we recall the definition of radiative phase space associated to an arbitrary ‘frame’ an introduce the total space Γ of all such radiative phase spaces. We also introduce certain subspaces with stronger fall-offs in u that play a crucial role in the later discussion. Section 3 is the main part of the paper. 3.1 describes the general idea behind our computation. In 3.2 we show that the covariant phase space symplectic structure induces a symplectic structure on (suitable subspace of) Γ. In section 3.3 we use this symplectic structure to derive the charges associated to the generators of Diff(S 2 ). This represents the main result of the paper. In 3.4 we summarize the analogue results at past null infinity (our detailed calculations take place in future null infinity). Finally in 3.5 we give a brief summary of the results presented in [15] on the equivalence between the Diff(S 2 ) Ward identities and the CS theorem. In section 4 we argue that subleading soft gravitons can be thought of as Goldstone modes of a spontaneous symmetry breaking G → BMS, in complete parallel to how leading soft gravitons are thought as Goldstone modes of a spontaneous symmetry breaking from supertranslations to translations [4]. We end with the conclusions in section 5. which in particular implies that q AB CAB = 0 and that the trace part of the O(1) term of gAB has the form given in (2.3). We take the trace-free O(1) part of gAB to be zero as in the original treatment by Sachs (see discussion following eq. (4.38) in [14]). An important difference with the treatment of [14] is that we do not demand qAB to be proportional to the unit round metric q̊AB . So far it can be any sphere metric. One can verify that Einstein equations still imply the relations given in Equations (4.42), (4.36) and (4.37) of [14]: In section 2.3 we describe conditions on CAB as u → ±∞. 2.2 Definition of G As described in [15], from a spacetime perspective G can be characterized as the group of diffeomorphisms generated by (non-trivial at null infinity) vector fields ξ a preserving the form of the metric (2.1) and such that they are asymptotically divergence-free (instead of asymptotically Killing as in the BMS case). Such vector fields are parametrized by a sphere function f (x̂) (supertranslation) and sphere vector field V A (x̂) according to [14, 15]: ξfa = f ∂u + . . . , ξVa = V A ∂A + uα∂u − rα∂r + . . . (2.7) where α = (DC V C )/2 and the dots indicate subleading term in the 1/r expansion that depend on f and V and in the 4-metric ‘free data’. The relations defining the algebra Lie(G) are obtained by computing the leading terms of the Lie brackets of the vector fields (2.7). One finds: [ξf1 , ξf2 ] = 0, [ξV1 , ξV2 ] = ξ[V1 ,V2 ] , [ξV , ξf ] = ξLV f −αf . (2.8) Thus as in the (extended) BMS case, Lie(G) has a semidirect sum algebra structure, where supertranslations form an abelian ideal Lie(ST) and Lie(G)/Lie(ST) is the algebra of sphere vector fields. Similarly to the BMS case, one can also characterize the group G as diffeomorphisms of an abstract I preserving certain structure (see section 4.1 of [15]). By computing the Lie derivative of the metric (2.1) along the vector fields (2.7) one obtains the following action of Lie(G) on the free data [14, 15]: δf qAB = 0, δV qAB = LV qAB −2αqAB , δf CAB = f ĊAB − 2(DA DB f )TF (2.9) δV CAB = LV CAB −αCAB +αuĊAB −2u(DA DB α)TF , (2.10) 5 This actually is not the totality of free data since there are additional u-independent sphere functions that arise as integration ‘constants’ [14]. These however play no role in our analysis. –4– JHEP04(2015)076 1 1 1 (2.5) V̊ = − R, β̊ = − C 2 , Ů A = − DB C AB , 2 32 2 where R and DA are respectively the scalar curvature and covariant derivative of qAB . Finally, as it will become clear in the next subsection, the natural space of metrics to consider from the point of view of the generalized BMS group G is one where the area form √ √ of qAB is fixed: q = q̊. To summarize, we will be interested in spacetime metrics of the form (2.1) parametrized by ‘free data’ (qAB , CAB )5 satisfying p √ q = q̊, q AB CAB = 0. (2.6) ∂u qAB = 0, where ‘TF’ denotes trace-free part with respect to qAB . In appendix A we verify this action indeed reproduces the algebra (2.8): [δf1 , δf2 ] = 0, [δV1 , δV2 ] = −δ[V1 ,V2 ] , [δV , δf ] = −δLV f −αf . (2.11) 2.3 Radiative phase spaces We first recall the asymptotic conditions on CAB that ensure well-definedness of the radiative phase spaces [17]. The radiative phase space Γq associated to a sphere metric qAB is given by tensors CAB on I satisfying: Γq := {CAB : q AB CAB = 0, ± CAB (u, x̂) = u(ρAB )TF + CAB (x̂) + O(u−ǫ )}, (2.12) where ǫ > 0. Here ρAB is a fixed tensor that depends on qAB ; its definition is reviewed in section 4.1. The radiative phase space traditionally used in the literature is the one associated to the unit round metric q̊AB on which (ρAB )TF = 0. √ √ We define Γ as the union of all Γq spaces with given area element q = q̊: [ Γq . (2.13) Γ := √ √ q= q̊ The properties of ρAB in (2.12) ensure that the action (2.10) preserves the form of the linear in u term in (2.12), so that indeed G has a well defined action on Γ. The precise mechanism by which this occurs is described in section 4.1. As in [15], due to infrared issues, the charges associated to (extended and) generalized BMS group will be defined on the following subspace of Γq̊ : Γq̊0 := {CAB ∈ Γq̊ : CAB (u, x̂) = O(u−1−ǫ ) as u → ±∞}. (2.14) We similarly define a subspace Γ on which the covariant phase space symplectic structure will turn out to be well-defined: √ p Γ0 := {(qAB , CAB ) : ∂u qAB = 0, q = q̊, q AB CAB = 0, CAB (u, x̂) = O(u−1−ǫ )}. (2.15) The spaces (2.14) and (2.15) will play an essential role in ensuring integrals in u are finite. We would like to emphasize however that this way of avoiding IR divergences is not entirely satisfactory: Γ0 is not preserved by G and Γq̊0 is not preserved by supertranslations.6 There may be better ways of dealing with these IR issues, for instance by introducing appropiate counterterms (see footnote 7). We hope to return to this point in future investigations. The analogue of the space Γq̊0 that was used in [15] actually allows for a u-independent term and hence is invariant under supertranslations. The stronger condition (2.14) is used here in order to allow for certain integration by parts in u. 6 –5– JHEP04(2015)076 Here δf and δV are understood as vector fields on the space of free data {(qAB , CAB )} satisfying (2.6) (strictly speaking −δf and −δV are the vector fields that provide the representation of the algebra (2.8)). Similar analysis on past null infinity yields a generalized BMS group associated to I − . Thus the total group acting on the spacetimes we are interested in is G + × G − , (G + is what we have been calling G). The proposed symmetry group of the gravitational S matrix is the ‘diagonal’ subgroup G 0 ⊂ G + × G − defined in analogy to Strominger’s BMS0 [15]. 3 Main section 3.1 General idea Ωt,g (δ, δ ′ ) := Σt dSa ωga (δ, δ ′ ), (3.1) be the standard covariant phase space symplectic form [22, 23] evaluated on a t := r + u =constant slice Σt . If we characterize 4-metrics gab by the free data (qAB , CAB ), the t → ∞ limit of (3.1) could correspond to a symplectic product defined at I + . However, one needs to impose conditions on the given fields (qAB , CAB , δ, δ ′ ) in order for this limit to be well defined. For instance, for variations δ, δ ′ such that δqAB = δ ′ qAB = 0 and such that δCAB , δ ′ CAB satisfies appropriate fall-offs in u, this procedures reproduces Ashtekar’s radiative phase space symplectic structure [24]. In section 3.2 we show that if CAB and its variation are taken to be O(u−1−ǫ ) and qAB is allowed to vary, then (3.1) also has a well defined t → ∞ limit. In other words, the covariant phase space symplectic form induces a well defined symplectic form on the space Γ0 defined in eq. (2.15). This is not quite yet what we need, since δV ∈ / T Γ0 due the linear in u term in (2.10). We now explain the computation we are really interested in. Given the phase space Γq̊0 and given a symmetry generator V ∈ Lie(G), we would like to compute its associated charge HV as a function on Γq̊0 . Now in general, given a Hamiltonian Vector field on any phase space, we first compute the differential of the corresponding Hamiltonian function, which upon integration yields the corresponding Hamiltonian. This implies that in our case, given the action of δV what we would really like to compute is Ω(δV , δ) =: δHV (3.2) where the variation δ must be along Γq̊0 . As we will see, the symplectic product needed in (3.2) is still well defined. In other words eq. (3.1) has also a well defined t → ∞ limit when δ = δV and δ ′ ∈ T Γq̊0 . 3.2 Symplectic structure on Γ0 In this section we evaluate the t → ∞ limit of (3.1) on Γ0 . The computation simplifies by working with the symplectic potential Z Θt,(q,C) (δ) := dSa θa , (3.3) Σt  1 √ bc a g g δΓbc − g ab δΓccb . θ := 2 a –6– (3.4) JHEP04(2015)076 In this section we show that starting from the covariant phase space derived from the Einstein Hilbert action, one can obtain a phase space at null infinity which is coordinatized not only by radiative degrees of freedom CAB but also by the 2-metric qAB on the conformal sphere. It turns out that the radiative phase space is a symplectic subspace of this larger space. This will allow us to compute the corresponding charge, which is well defined on a (suitable) subspace of Γq̊ , where q̊AB is the unit round-metric on the 2 sphere. This is the main result of the paper, which combined with the result of [15] show that Ward identities associated to G are equivalent to the CS soft theorem. The main idea can be summarized as follows. Let Z Recall t = r + u so that the relevant component will be θt = θr + θu . The limit is taken t → ∞ with u constant. The variable r will be understood as given by r = t − u. Before proceeding with the details, we summarize certain salient aspects of the computation which critically use the fall-off conditions on CAB . (a) We will see that in the limit t → ∞, conditions CAB = O(u−1−ǫ ) and δ ∈ T Γ0 will ensure finiteness of the integrals as well as cancellation of various boundary terms.7 We will discard total variation terms, since they do not contribute to the symplectic form. θt = rθ1t + θ0t + O(r−1 ), (3.5) which gives the following 1/t expansion: θt = tθ1t + (θ0t − uθ1t ) + O(t−1 ). (3.6) The would-be divergent term tθ1t will turn out to integrate to zero on the space of C’s we are restricting attention to. We now proceed with the details of the computation. The form of the metric (2.1) implies the non-zero term appearing in θt are: 2θt = √ qe2β r2 2g ur δΓrur + g rr δΓrur + 2g Ar δΓrAr + g AB (δΓrAB + δΓuAB )  − g ur (δΓccu + δΓccr ) − g Ar δΓccA . (3.7) There are 6 terms in (3.7), lets call them (1). . . (6). Setting to zero terms that are O(r−1 ) we get: √ (1) = −2 qδM, (2) = (3) = 0, √ ˙ (5) = 2 qδ β̊, √ (6) = Ů A ∂A δ( q) . (3.8) √ For the space we are interested where q is fixed, the term (6) vanishes and the terms (1) and (5) are total variations which do not contribute to the symplectic structure. The only nonzero term is the fourth one in (3.7) so we rewrite θt as: θt = 1 √ 2β 2 AB qe r g (δΓrAB + δΓuAB ). 2 (3.9) The relevant Christoffel symbols are (see [14]): r 1 1 ΓrAB = D(A ŮB) + ĊAB + qAB ∂u (C 2 ) + V̊ rqAB + V̊ CAB + 2M qAB + O(r−1 ) (3.10) 2 8 2 1 1 ur −1 u (3.11) ΓAB = − g ∂r gAB = rqAB + CAB + O(r ). 2 2 7 For slower fall-offs of the type which define Γ (eqs. (2.12), (2.13)) there may be a possibility of obtaining a finite symplectic structure by supplementing the action with counterterms at i0 , i± . We have not pursued this direction here as it is not needed for our analysis. –7– JHEP04(2015)076 (b) We will find that θt has an 1/r expansion of the form: We now evaluate the first term in (3.9): r2 e2β g AB δΓrAB = q AB δΓrAB − r−1 C AB δΓrAB + O(r−1 ). (3.12) In evaluating (3.12) we will discard terms of the form q AB δ(f qAB ) for any quantity f since they give a total variation by the identity √ √ qq AB δ(f qAB ) = δ( qf ) (3.13) 1 1 r r2 e2β g AB δΓrAB = q AB δ(DA ŮB ) − C AB δ ĊAB − V̊ C AB δqAB + q AB δ ĊAB + δ() + O(r−1 ) 2 2 2 (3.14) where δ() indicates a total variation term. When we substitute r = t − u, the linear in r term in (3.14) gives a potential diverging linear in t term and a finite term − 1 u u AB q δ ĊAB = C AB δqAB − ∂u ( δCAB )q AB + δ() 2 2 2 (3.15) which we rewrote up to total derivative in u and a total variation. Now, the condition CAB = O(u−1−ǫ ) implies the total derivative in (3.15) as well as the potential diverging term 2t q AB δ ĊAB give a vanishing contribution upon integration. The second term in (3.9) gives: r2 e2β g AB δΓuAB = q AB δΓuAB − r−1 C AB δΓuAB + O(r−1 ) 1 = − C AB δqAB + δ() + O(r−1 ) . 2 (3.16) (3.17) Note that this term cancels the term in (3.15). Collecting all terms and writing for later convenience q AB δ(DA ŮB ) = DA Ů B δqAB + δ() (3.18) we obtain the following expressions for the symplectic potential Θ(δ) := limt→∞ Θt (δ) at I + : Z    1 √  (3.19) du q −C AB δ ĊAB + 2DA Ů B − V̊ C AB δqAB . Θ(δ) = 4 I The corresponding symplectic form at I + is then: Z  1 √  ′ Ω(δ, δ ) = du q δC AB δ ′ ĊAB − δ(2DA Ů B − V̊ C AB )δ ′ qAB − δ ↔ δ ′ . 4 I (3.20) We have thus obtained a symplectic form on the space Γ0 defined in eq. (2.15). Clearly, the radiative phase space Γq̊0 is symplectic subspace of Γ0 . We conclude with the observation that (3.20) can actually be used for the evaluation of the symplectic product between δV ∈ T Γ and δ0 ∈ T Γq̊0 . By introducing a second variation in all steps above, one can verify that: lim Ωt (δV , δ0 ) = Ω(δV , δ0 ), t→∞ –8– (3.21) JHEP04(2015)076 √ √ that follows from q AB qAB = 2 and 2δ q = qq AB δqAB . Substituting (3.10) in (3.12) we get with Ω given in (3.20). Indeed, there are only two potentially problematic terms in the computation that are described after eq. (3.15). Their contribution to the density ω t (δV , δ0 ) is: u  t δ0 CAB δV q AB , (3.22) − δV q AB δ0 ĊAB + ∂u 2 2 where we used that δ0 qAB = 0. The condition δ0 CAB = O(u−1−ǫ ) implies that both terms in (3.22) integrate to zero. In summary, the symplectic product between δV and δ0 ∈ T Γq̊0 is well defined and given by evaluation on the form (3.20). This evaluation is used in the next section to obtain the charge HV . Diff (S 2 ) charges We now apply the above results to find the charge HV satisfying δHV = Ω(δV , δ), (3.23) for δV given in eq. (2.10) and for δ ∈ T Γq̊0 , i.e. δCAB = O(u−1−ǫ ) and δqAB = 0. Since we already have a candidate for HV , namely the one postulated in [15], we will just verify that such HV indeed satisfies (3.23). HV is a sum of a ‘hard’ quadratic in CAB term and a ‘soft’ linear in CAB term [15]: HV = HVhard + HVsoft , Z 1 √ HVhard := du q Ċ AB (LV CAB − αCAB + αuĊAB ) 4 Z 1 √ HVsoft := du q C AB sAB , 2 (3.24) (3.25) (3.26) with sAB a symmetric trace-free tensor such that its components in (z, z̄) coordinates are given by: szz := Dz3 V z , (3.27) and corresponding complex conjugated expression (the trace-free condition sets sz z̄ = 0). We now verify that HV satisfies (3.23). For the r.h.s. of (3.23) we have Z  1 √  AB AB A B AB du q δV C δ ĊAB − δC ∂u (δV CAB ) + (2D δ Ů + δC )δV qAB , Ω(δV , δ) = 4 (3.28) where we used that δqAB = 0 and V̊ = −R/2 = −1 since we are at qAB = q̊AB . Using (2.10) and the corresponding transformations: δV C AB = LV C AB + 4αC AB + αuĊ AB − 2u(DA DB α)TF δV q AB = LV q AB + 2αqAB , (3.29) (3.30) one verifies that the ‘hard’ terms in (3.28) combine to give δHVhard . By integration by parts one can bring all ‘soft’ terms in a form that is proportional to δC AB . The end result is: Z 1 √ hard (3.31) du q δC AB s′AB Ω(δV , δ) = δHV + 2 –9– JHEP04(2015)076 3.3 where s′AB := TF  1 M 2DA DB α − D(A D δV qB)M + D(A VB) . 2 (3.32) We finally show that s′AB = sAB from which (3.23) follows. From (2.10) and using the identity DM DB XM = XB + 2DB α one finds DM δV qBM = ∆VB + VB . (3.33) Using this we can rewrite (3.32) as (3.34) with 1 1 (3.35) s′A := DA DM V M − DM DM VA + VA . 2 2 Finally, writing (3.35) in (z, z̄) coordinates and using q̊ z z̄ [Dz̄ , Dz ]Vz = Vz one finds s′z = Dz2 V z . (3.36) Going back to (3.34) we conclude that s′AB = sAB as desired. Comment. In order to highlight the role played by the ‘extra’ terms in the symplectic structure (3.20), it is interesting to repeat the computation by writing  the symplectic R  AB ′ 1 ′ (A B) AB ′ structure as Ω(δ, δ ) = 4 δC δ ĊAB + δ(2a D Ů + b C )δ qAB − δ ↔ δ ′ and set- ting the correct values a = −1, b = V̊ = −1 at the end of the computation (for the δ considered here δ V̊ = 0 and so V̊ can be treated as a constant). Doing so one obtains: s′z = Dz2 V z + (1 + a)Dz Dz̄ V z + (a − b)Vz . 3.4 Past null infinity A similar analysis to the one given in the previous two subsections goes through for past null infinity. The form of the metric in that case can be obtained by doing the substitution v = −u in (2.1). The relevant component of the symplectic potential density is now θt = −(θr − θv ). Thus, the symplectic structure at past null infinity can be obtained by the replacement u → −v (up to an overall sign). The result is: Z  1 √  − − − ′ + δ(2DA Ů −B − V̊ − C −AB )δ ′ qAB − δ ↔ δ ′ . (3.37) dv q δC −AB δ ′ ĊAB Ω (δ, δ ) = 4 I − + On the other hand, the transformation rule for CAB is the same as for CAB except that the soft factor comes with opposite sign: − − − − δV CAB = LV CAB − αCAB + αv ĊAB + 2v(DA DB α)TF . (3.38) The corresponding charge HV− has thus the same form as (3.24), (3.25), (3.26), with an opposite sign in the soft term: 3 z s− (3.39) zz = −Dz V . – 10 – JHEP04(2015)076 s′AB = (D(A s′B) )TF 3.5 Diff (S 2 ) Ward identities and CS soft theorem We sketch here how the new symmetry relates to CS soft theorem. We refer to [12, 15] for further details. Given a vector field V A and corresponding charges HV± at future and past null infinity, the proposed Ward identities arise from assuming the S matrix satisfies: HV+ S = SHV− , (3.40) HVsoft+ S − SHVsoft− = −HVhard+ S + SHVhard− . (3.41) or equivalently: A V A (z, z̄) = K(z (z, z̄) := (z̄ − z̄s )−1 (z − zs )2 ∂z s ,z̄s ) (3.42) gives, in the first term of the l.h.s. of (3.41), the insertion of a negative helicity outgoing soft graviton with momentum pointing in the direction determined by (zs , z̄s ). By crossing symmetry the second term in the l.h.s. of (3.41) can be shown to be equal to the first one. Now, the differential operators arising on the r.h.s. of (3.41) for the choice (3.42) A reproduce those of the CS theorem. In short, for V A = K(z , eq. (3.41) reproduces s ,z̄s ) CS soft theorem for a negative helicity graviton (the positive helicity case is obtained by A ). choosing the complex conjugated vector, V A = K̄(z s ,z̄s ) Conversely, the Ward identities associated to the vector fields (3.42) and its complex conjugate (which we just argued are equivalent to CS theorem), can be shown to imply the A (z, z̄) have the Ward identity (3.41) for any vector field V A . Essentially the vectors K(z s ,z̄s ) role of elementary kernels, and by appropriate smearing in the (zs , z̄s ) variables one can reproduce any desired vector field. 4 Goldstone modes of G In the case of supertranslation symmetry, it was argued in [4] that as supertranslations map an asymptotic configuration CAB with zero news NAB = 0 to a distinct configuration with zero news (by creating a soft graviton), the choice of a particular vacuum implies a spontaneous breaking of supertranslation symmetry with soft gravitons playing the role of Goldstone modes. In this section we argue that one can interpret the subleading soft gravitons in a similar manner and that they can be thought of as Goldstone modes associated to spontaneous breaking of G to BMS. At first sight this statement looks obviously wrong as for a given – 11 – JHEP04(2015)076 When one takes the matrix element of (3.41) between a n+ particle state hout| and a n− particle state |ini, the r.h.s. of (3.41) becomes an operator on the scattering amplitude hout|S|ini that consists of a sum of differential operators acting on the individual particle labels (momentum and helicity). On the other hand, the l.h.s. of (3.41) can be realized as creation operators of gravitons with vanishing energy, where the helicity and smeared momentum direction is determined by V A . The choice choice of the sphere metric, such subleading changes in CAB are not gapless. This can be seen as follows. Given (CAB , qCD ) ∈ Γ, a vector field V ∈ Lie(G) maps it to δV qAB = LV qAB −2αqAB , δV CAB = LV CAB −αCAB +αuĊAB −2u(DA DB α)TF (4.1) Whence it naively appears as if a configuration C (0) which has zero news in say Bondi frame (where the associated qAB = q̊AB ) goes to a new configuration C (0) + δV C (0) whose news is given by δNAB = 2(DA DB α)TF . However the above assertion is wrong as it relies upon the definition of news given by This definition of news is only valid when the metric on S 2 is the unit metric q̊AB . In a generic case there is a slight technicality regarding the news tensor. Given an arbitrary sphere metric qAB there exists a unique symmetric tensor ρAB [q] which is implicitly defined via [25]: ρAB q AB = R[q], D[A ρB]C = 0. (4.2) It can be split into a trace-free part and the trace part as 1 (0) ρAB = ρAB + R[q]qAB , 2 (4.3) and as shown in [25] ρ(0) [q̊] = 0. The news tensor associated to a configuration CAB ∈ Γq is then defined as (see for instance eq. (23) of [26]) (0) NAB (u, x̂) := −∂u CAB (u, x̂) − ρAB (x̂). (4.4) We thus see that as V ∈ Lie(G) change CAB as well as qAB , the corresponding change in news is given by (0) δV NAB (u, x̂) = −∂u δV CAB (u, x̂) − δV ρAB (x̂). (0) (4.5) In section 4.1 we show that δV ρAB (x̂) is precisely such that a zero news configuration is mapped into a distinct zero news configuration. Whence the corresponding change in the news vanishes. That is any element of V ∈ Lie(G) maps a configuration with zero news to a configuration with zero news because the definition of the news before and after the action of V refer to different frames. Hence choosing a qAB (and working with Γq ) implies breaking the G symmetry spontaneously to BMS and the subleading soft gravitons can be thought of as goldstone modes associated to this symmetry breaking as they map one family of vacua (associated to a given qAB ) to a distinct family of vacua associated to a different qAB . – 12 – JHEP04(2015)076 NAB (u, x̂) = −∂u CAB (u, x̂). 4.1 Evaluating δV NAB From (2.10) and the definition of the news tensor (4.4) we have (0) δV NAB = −∂u δV CAB − δV ρAB (4.6) (0) = −LV ĊAB − αuC̈AB + 2(DA DB α)TF − δV ρAB . (4.7) δV ρAB = LV ρAB + 2DA DB α, (4.8) which in turn implies, (0) (0) δV ρAB = LV ρAB + 2(DA DB α)TF . (4.9) When substituting (4.9) in (4.7) the ‘soft’ factors cancel out and one obtains: (0) δV NAB = −LV ĊAB − αuC̈AB − LV ρAB = LV NAB + αuṄAB , (4.10) (4.11) where in the second line we used the definition of the news tensor (4.4) and the fact that (0) −C̈AB = ṄAB since ∂u ρAB = 0. Thus the news tensor transforms homogeneously. In particular if NAB = 0 then δV NAB = 0. 5 Conclusions Analyzing the symmetry structure of the quantum gravity S-matrix is of paramount importance. It has been well known since the 60’s that (at least at the semiclassical level) this symmetry group contains an infinite dimensional group known as the BMS group. The relationship of BMS symmetry to infrared issues in Quantum Gravity (for instance the existence of various superselection sectors) has been rigorously studied by Ashtekar et al. in the beautiful framework of Asymptotic Quantization [16–20]. This relationship (of BMS group to infrared issues in quantum gravity in asymptotically flat spacetimes) got a new lease due to seminal work of Strominger et al. [3, 4, 12]. One of the outcomes of this recent study is the universality concerning subleading corrections to soft graviton amplitudes, referred to in this paper as Cachazo-Strominger (CS) soft theorem [6]. A natural question first posed in [12] was if the CS soft theorem could be understood as Ward identities associated to certain symmetries of the semi-classical S matrix. It was shown in [12] that the Ward identities associated to Virasoro symmetries contained in the so-called extended BMS group can be derived from CS soft theorem. However, the question of how to go in the reverse direction and derive the CS soft theorem from the Virasoro Ward Identities remained unanswered. In [15] we argued in favor of a different possibility: – 13 – JHEP04(2015)076 We now evaluate the last term in (4.7). From δV qAB = LV qAB −2αqAB we have that δV ρAB is a sum of a Lie derivative term plus a scale transformation term. Since the behaviour of ρAB under scale transformation is known [25] the effect of the second term can be obtained explicitly. The total change is found to be: Acknowledgments We are indebted to Abhay Ashtekar for crucial discussions in the initial stages of this work and for his constant encouragement and interest. We thank Vyacheslav Lysov, Michael Reisenberger and Andrew Strominger for their comments on the manuscript. MC is supported by Anii and Pedeciba. AL is supported by Ramanujan Fellowship of the Department of Science and Technology. – 14 – JHEP04(2015)076 if a different generalization of the BMS group (referred to unimaginatively as generalized BMS) G was a symmetry of the gravitational S matrix, then the Ward identities associated to Diff(S 2 ) contained in G were shown to be equivalent to CS soft theorem. Our argument however relied on an ad-hoc assumption that the charges associated to such symmetries had the same form as the charges associated to Virasoro symmetries, which (modulo certain IR issues) could be derived from first principles. The main block for computing such charges was lack of a suitable phase space on which G acted in a well-defined manner and whose corresponding charges were finite. We have filled these gaps in the current paper. Starting from the covariant phase space associated to Einstein Hilbert action, we derive a phase space at null infinity which is coordinatized by the well known radiative degrees of freedom as well as the space of metrics on the conformal sphere. The symplectic structure on this phase space can be used to compute the charges associated to Diff(S 2 ) which is, rather remarkably well-defined on an appropriate subspace of the radiative phase space. Surprisingly these charges turn out to be exactly equal to the charges corresponding to the Virasoro symmetries computed in [12]. This proves the key assumption that we made in [15] and hence completes the proof of the equivalence between Ward identities associated to the generators of Diff(S 2 ) and CS soft theorem. One of the nice corollaries of our analysis is the representation of G on Γ. However the symplectic structure arising from the Einstein Hilbert action is only well-defined in the stronger fall-offs subspace Γ0 ⊂ Γ which unfortunately is not preserved under the action of G. We believe however that the inclusion of appropriate counter-terms to the action at i0 , i± could yield a well-defined symplectic structure on Γ. If this were to be the case, we could hope for the action of G to be symplectic on Γ. This would solve another issue which arose in [15], namely that the charges on radiative phase space which correspond to subleading soft factors do not close to form an algebra. We hope to come back to this point in the near future. We finally wish to emphasize that the physical phase space of the theory really is the radiative phase space (or an appropriate subspace thereof) and the bigger phase space Γ is an “auxiliary” arena which however is an indispensable tool to implement G in classical as well as quantum theory. A Closure of generalized BMS action The first relation (2.11) is easily verified. We now show the second and third relations. Let V3 := [V1 , V2 ]. To shorten notation we will omit ‘V ’ labels and use only subscripts 1, 2, 3. Thus the second equation in (2.11) reads: [δ2 , δ1 ] = δ3 , (A.1) δ1 CAB = L1 CAB − α1 CAB + α1 uĊAB − 2u(DA DB α1 )TF (A.2) and Equations (2.10) for V1 become: (A.3) and similarly for V2 and V3 . For the computation it is important to keep in mind that the √ √ α’s are in fact independent of the 2-metric qAB due to the condition q = q̊. This can √ be seen explicitly by defining α purely in terms of q according to: LV √ √ q = 2α q. (A.4) We first verify (A.1) along the δqAB direction: [δ2 , δ1 ]qAB = δ2 (L1 qAB − 2α1 qAB ) − 1 ↔ 2 = L1 δ2 qAB − 2δ2 α1 qAB − 2α1 δ2 qAB ) − 1 ↔ 2 = L3 qAB − 2(L1 α2 − L2 α1 )qAB = δ3 qAB . (A.5) (A.6) (A.7) (A.8) Here we used the fact that δ2 α1 = 0 since α1 is independent of qAB as mentioned above eq. (A.4). In the last equality we used α3 = L 1 α2 − L 2 α1 , (A.9) which directly follows from the definition of α given in (A.4): √ √ √ √ √ √ 2α3 q = L3 q = (L1 L2 − L2 L1 ) q = 2L1 (α2 q) − 2L2 (α1 q) = 2(L1 α2 − L2 α1 ) q. (A.10) For the δCAB direction, one finds [δ2 , δ1 ]CAB = L1 δ2 CAB − α1 δ2 CAB + α1 u∂u δ2 CAB − 2uδ2 (DA DB α1 )TF − 1 ↔ 2 = L3 CAB − α3 CAB + uα3 ĊAB − 2uL1 (DA DB α2 )TF (A.11) − 2uδ2 (DA DB α1 )TF − 1 ↔ 2 , where we used similar simplifications as when getting (A.8) above. The ‘hard’ term in (A.11) corresponds to the hard term of δ3 CAB . We now show that the ‘soft’ term also matches. This amounts to show the equality: δ2 (DA DB α1 )TF − L2 (DA DB α1 )TF − 1 ↔ 2 = (DA DB α3 )TF . – 15 – (A.12) JHEP04(2015)076 δ1 qAB = L1 qAB − 2α1 qAB , The variation δ2 in (A.12) only involve variations along δqAB . It is convenient to write them as an explicit sum of ‘Lie derivative’ and ‘scale’ terms: δ2 qAB = δ2L qAB + δ2S qAB ; δ2L qAB := L2 qAB , δ2S qAB := −2α2 qAB . (A.13) In this way, the first term in (A.12) takes the form: L S δ2 (DA DB α1 )TF = δ21 AB + δ21 AB (A.14) where: (A.15) (A.16) For the δ S term one obtains: S C δ21 AB = 2D(A α1 DB) α2 − qAB DC α1 D α2 . (A.17) Since it is symmetric under 1 ↔ 2 it does not contribute to the l.h.s. of (A.12). For the δ L term, we notice that from the definition of δ2L one has: δ2L DA = [L2 , DA ], δ2L ∆ = [L2 , ∆], (A.18) from which it follows that (A.15) can be written as: 1 L TF δ21 − DA ∂B (L2 α1 ) + ∆(L2 α1 )qAB . (A.19) AB := L2 (DA DB α1 ) 2 The first term in (A.19) cancels the Lie derivative term in (A.12). Including the 1 ↔ 2 term one recovers Equation (A.12) with α3 given in (A.9). This concludes the proof of eq. (A.1). We finally show the last relation in (2.11): [δV , δf ] = −δLV f −αf . (A.20) Along δqAB direction this relation trivializes to 0 = 0. Evaluating the commutator along δCAB one finds [δf , δV ]CAB = (LV f − αf )ĊAB + 2α(DA DB f )TF + 2f (DA DB α)TF + 2δV (DA DB f )TF − 2LV (DA DB f )TF . (A.21) The ‘hard’ term in (A.21) matches the hard term of δLV f −αf . That the ‘soft’ term (displayed in the second line) also matches can be shown along similar lines as for the soft term of [δV1 , δV2 ] computed above. Writing δV qAB = δVL qAB + δVS qAB as in eq. (A.13) and using relations as those given in eqs. (A.17) and (A.19) and finds that the last two terms in (A.21) combine to 2δV (DA DB f )TF −2LV (DA DB f )TF = −2(DA DB LV f )TF +4D(A αDB) f −2qAB DC αDC f. (A.22) The first term in the r.h.s. of (A.22) is the soft factor of δLV f . The remaining terms combine to give the soft factor of δ−αf due to the identity: (DA DB (αf ))TF = α(DA DB f )TF + f (DA DB α)TF + (2D(A αDB) f )TF . – 16 – (A.23) JHEP04(2015)076 1 L 1 L L L δ21 AB := δ2 (DA )∂B α1 − δ2 (∆)α1 qAB − ∆α1 δ2 qAB 2 2 1 S 1 S S S δ21 AB := δ2 (DA )∂B α1 − δ2 (∆)α1 qAB − ∆α1 δ2 qAB . 2 2 Open Access. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited. References [1] H. Bondi, M.G.J. van der Burg and A.W.K. Metzner, Gravitational waves in general relativity. 7. Waves from axisymmetric isolated systems, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 269 (1962) 21 [INSPIRE]. [3] A. Strominger, On BMS Invariance of Gravitational Scattering, JHEP 07 (2014) 152 [arXiv:1312.2229] [INSPIRE]. [4] T. He, V. Lysov, P. Mitra and A. Strominger, BMS supertranslations and Weinberg’s soft graviton theorem, arXiv:1401.7026 [INSPIRE]. [5] S. Weinberg, Infrared photons and gravitons, Phys. Rev. 140 (1965) B516. [6] F. Cachazo and A. Strominger, Evidence for a New Soft Graviton Theorem, arXiv:1404.4091 [INSPIRE]. [7] J. Broedel, M. de Leeuw, J. Plefka and M. Rosso, Constraining subleading soft gluon and graviton theorems, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 065024 [arXiv:1406.6574] [INSPIRE]. [8] Z. Bern, S. Davies, P. Di Vecchia and J. Nohle, Low-Energy Behavior of Gluons and Gravitons from Gauge Invariance, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 084035 [arXiv:1406.6987] [INSPIRE]. [9] D.J. Gross and R. Jackiw, Low-Energy Theorem for Graviton Scattering, Phys. Rev. 166 (1968) 1287 [INSPIRE]. [10] S.G. Naculich and H.J. Schnitzer, Eikonal methods applied to gravitational scattering amplitudes, JHEP 05 (2011) 087 [arXiv:1101.1524] [INSPIRE]. [11] C.D. White, Factorization Properties of Soft Graviton Amplitudes, JHEP 05 (2011) 060 [arXiv:1103.2981] [INSPIRE]. [12] D. Kapec, V. Lysov, S. Pasterski and A. Strominger, Semiclassical Virasoro symmetry of the quantum gravity S-matrix, JHEP 08 (2014) 058 [arXiv:1406.3312] [INSPIRE]. [13] G. Barnich and C. Troessaert, Symmetries of asymptotically flat 4 dimensional spacetimes at null infinity revisited, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 111103 [arXiv:0909.2617] [INSPIRE]. [14] G. Barnich and C. Troessaert, Aspects of the BMS/CFT correspondence, JHEP 05 (2010) 062 [arXiv:1001.1541] [INSPIRE]. [15] M. Campiglia and A. Laddha, Asymptotic symmetries and subleading soft graviton theorem, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 124028 [arXiv:1408.2228] [INSPIRE]. [16] A. Ashtekar, Asymptotic Quantization of the Gravitational Field, Phys. Rev. Lett. 46 (1981) 573 [INSPIRE]. [17] A. Ashtekar and M. Streubel, Symplectic Geometry of Radiative Modes and Conserved Quantities at Null Infinity, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 376 (1981) 585 [INSPIRE]. – 17 – JHEP04(2015)076 [2] R.K. Sachs, Gravitational waves in general relativity. 8. Waves in asymptotically flat space-times, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 270 (1962) 103 [INSPIRE]. [18] A. Ashtekar, Radiative Degrees of Freedom of the Gravitational Field in Exact General Relativity, J. Math. Phys. 22 (1981) 2885 [INSPIRE]. [19] A. Ashtekar, Quantization of the Radiative Modes of the Gravitational Field, In Quantum Gravity 2, C.J. Isham, R. Penrose and D.W. Sciama eds., Oxford University Press, Oxford U.K. (1981). [20] A. Ashtekar, Asymptotic Quantization, Bibliopolis, Naples, Italy (1987). [21] A. Ashtekar, Geometry and Physics of Null Infinity, arXiv:1409.1800 [INSPIRE]. [23] J. Lee and R.M. Wald, Local symmetries and constraints, J. Math. Phys. 31 (1990) 725 [INSPIRE]. [24] A. Ashtekar and A. Magnon-Ashtekar On the symplectic structure of general relativity, Commun. Math. Phys. 86 (1982) 55. [25] R. Geroch, Asymptotic structure of space-time, in Asymptotic structure of space-time, L. Witten ed., Plenum, New York U.S.A. (1976). [26] C. Kozameh and E.T. Newman, A note on asymptotically flat spaces. II, Gen. Rel. Grav. 15.5 (1983) 475. – 18 – JHEP04(2015)076 [22] A. Ashtekar, L. Bombelli, and O. Reula, The covariant phase space of asymptotically flat gravitational fields, in Analysis, Geometry and Mechanics: 200 Years After Lagrange, M. Francaviglia ed., North-Holland (1991).