LIBRARY OF WELLESLEY COLLEGE PURCHASED FROM HOESK)ED 4 I I S I L U R I A. THE HISTORY OF THE OLDEST KNOWN ROCKS CONTAINING ORGANIC REMAINS. WITH A BRIEF SKETCH OF THE DISTRIBUTION OF GOLD OYER THE EARTH. BY SIR RODERICK IMPEY MURCHISON, A 4 viii PREFACE. without presumption), the first which, in extending those results to the north-western edge of Asia, developed a complete ascending series over the larger half of Europe, from the oldest known fossiliferous strata to the youngest tertiary deposits. In perusing the fifteenth and sixteenth chapters, which indicate the parallelism of the palaeozoic rocks of France, Spain, and the United States of America to those of Britain, geologists will at once recognize the vast amount of knowledge which has been contributed by my dear and en- lightened companion, M. Edouard de VerneuiL To my other numerous foreign contemporaries, and especially to M. Bar- rande, who have seen reason to apply to their own lands the classification and nomenclature first elaborated in the ancient kingdom of the Silures, I also tender my grateful acknowledgments. May the following pages not be without use in stimulating them to bring the older rocks of their re- spective countries into a closer comparison with our British types, than I have been able to effect in the present outline! TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAPTER 1. Page Introduction — Original Silurian Researches. — Design of this work - 1 CHAP. 11. Base of the Silurian Rocks, and Earliest Zone of former Life. Outlines, Structure, and Order of the older Rocks. — Earliest Crystalline Rocks. — The lowest Deposits in which a true Sedimentary Origin is seen are usually void of Signs of former Life. Order of Succession from such Unfossiliferous Strata upwards to the lowest Zone in which Fossil Remains have been detected in Great Britain - - - - 17 CHAP. III. Lower Silurian Rocks — continued. The Llandeilo Formation, its Slates, Schists, Sandstones, Limestones, and Interpo- lated Igneous Rocks. (2* and 2 of Map and Coloured Sections.) - - - 45 CHAP. IV. Lower Silurian Rocks — continued. The Caradoc Forsiation. Caradoc Sandstone as developed in North "Wales and Radnorshire. Types of the Formation in Shropshire, Herefordshire, &c. The Caradoc strictly united with the lower Deposits by its Structure and Fossil Contents 78 X TABLE OF CONTENTS- CHAP. V. Upper Silurian Rocks. Page General Character of the Upper Silurian Rocks, as divided into the Wenlock and Ludlow Formations The Wenlock Formation of Shale and Limestone, with its chief Fossils, described in ascending Order - lOO CHAP. VI. Upper Silurian Rocks — continued. The Ludlow Formation, General Character of. Its Subdivision in the Typical Dis- tricts, into Lower Ludlow Rocks, Aymestrj Limestone, and Upper Ludlow Rocks - 124 CHAP. VIL Silurian Rocks of Britain beyond the Typical Region of England and Wales, as seen in Cornwall, the North-west of England, Scotland, AND Ireland 144 CHAP. VIII. Organic Remains of the Lower Silurian Rocks - - - - - 176 CHAP. IX. Fossils of the Upper Silurian Rocks 207 CHAP. X. The Devonian Rocks, or Old Red Sandstone, as Exhibited in the British Isles "241- CHAP. XI. Carboniferous Rocks. Great Primeval Flora the Source of the Old Coal Deposits. — General View of these Deposits and their Organic Remains in the British Isles 267- TABLE OF CONTENTS. xi CHAP. XII. Permian Kocks. Page Changes of the Surface before the Permian Deposits were accumulated. — Origin of the Term Permian as applied to the highest Group of Primeval Deposits. — The Permian Rocks of Russia, Germany, and England. — The Organic Remains of the Group 289 CHAP. XIII. General, View of the Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous Rocks of Scandinavia and Russia - - - - - - - - - - 316 CHAP. XIV. Primeval Succession in Germany and Belgium. General Sketch of the Character of the Older Rocks extending westwards from Po- land and Turkey in Europe into the Alps and Carpathians. Devonian, Carboni- ferous, and Permian Rocks of Sile?ia and Moravia. Silurian Rocks (Lower and Upper) of Bohemia. Lower Silurian, Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian Rocks of Saxony, the Thiiringerwald, &c. General View of the Succession of Devonian and Carboniferous Rocks in the Rhenish Provinces and Belgium - 336 CHAP. XV. Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous Rocks of France, Spain, Portu- GAi., AND Sardinia 333 4 ^ ^ CHAP. XVI. Succession of Primeval Rocks in America. Order of the Palaeozoic Strata in South America, the United States, and British North America ,. 408 CHAP. XVII. On the Original Formation of Gold, and its Subsequent Distribution IN Debris over Parts of the Earth's Surface - «. - - -431 xii TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAP. XVIII. Conclusion. Page Kecapitulation — General View of the Succession of Life from a Beginning as based on positive Observation — The Progress of Creation — Theoretical Specu- lations distinguished from absolute Geological Eesults 459 APPENDIX. A. Vertical Range of Silurian Fossils - - - 485 B. Recent Surveys of the British Silurian Rocks - - - - - -490 C. Traces of Vegetable Matter in the Silurian and older Rocks - - - - 492 D. Unconformity in Ireland of the Longmynd or Bottom Rocks (' Cambrian ' of the Survey) to the Lovs^er Silurian 493 E. Barrande's Silurian System in Bohemia ------- - 493 F. Depth of the Primeval Seas, and Colouring of the Shells of the Mollusca which lived in them - -495 G. Extension of Silurian Rocks in Spain - - - - . - - - - ib. H. Foraminifera in the Silurian Rocks - - - - - - - -496 I. Supposed Anomaly at Neffiez in France explained - - - - -1-497 K. Australian Gold - - ib. It. Produce of Silver ib. M. Silurian Rocks in Silesia ---------- N. Palaeozoic Rocks in Asia Minor 498 O. Discoveries along the Flanks of the Malvern Hills - - - . - - ib. P. Other Reptilian Remains in the Permian Rocks of Russia - - - . ib. Q. On the foraaer Changes of the Alps - -499 INDEX ----- * - 507 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Geological Map -------- Frontispiece WOODCUTS. Page General Order of the Primeval Rocks 22 Contorted Schists at the South Stack Lighthouse, Anglesea - - 24 The Longmynd - - - 26 Section from the Longmynd on the E.S.E. across the Stiper Stones to the Tract of Shelve and Corndon on the W.N. W. - - - 29 Pass of Llanberis from the Lower Lake - - - - 30 Oldhamia • antiqua, from Bray Head, Ireland - - - - 32 Slaty Cleavage and Bedding - - 34 The Western Face of the Stiper Stones 37 The Eastern Face of the Stiper Stones ih. Section of Rocks at Barmouth - 40 Lingula Flags, North Wales - - 42 Hymenocaris vermicauda, Salter. Lin- gula Flags, Dolgelly - - 42 Paradoxides Forchhammeri, Angelin? Black Schists of North Wales - 43 Trilobites from the Black Schists of the Malverns - • - 43 Lovfer Silurian Graptolites - - 46 Section at Llandewi Felfrey, Pem- brokeshire - - - - 49 Whittery Quarries in Harrington Dingle - - - - 55 Volcanic Breccia - - - 56 Ideal Representation of the Manner in which submarine Volcanic Dejec- tions were formed in the Lov/er Silurian Period . - - ih. Lower Silyrian and bedded Trap, tra- versed by eruptive Rocks, the Corn- don Mountain in the Distance - 57 Alternations of Llandeilo Flags and Schists with Volcanic Grits - ib. View of the Breidden Hills near Welshpool, from Powis Castle - 59 Section across the Breidden Hills - 60 Section across the Gelli Hills - - 61 Lower Silurian Rocks in Abereiddy Bay - - - - 64 Llandeilo Schists in Musclewick Bay - 65 View of Skomer Isles, seen from the Mainland - - - - 66 Page Silurian Rocks of Marloes Bay, Pem- broke, dipping under the Old Red Sandstone of Hook Point - - 66 Section at Llandewi Felfrey, Pem- brokeshire - - ~ - 68 View from Dynevor Park, Llandeilo, looking to the Hills above Golden Grove - - - - 69 Noeth Griig - - - - 72 Section near I^langadock. From the Lower Silurian to the Old Red Sandstone - - - - 73 Section near Llandeilo. From the Lower Silurian to the Edge of the great South-Welsh Coal-field - ih. Llanwrtyd Wells - - - 75 Cader Idris - - - - 77 Llandeilo Schists supporting Caradoc Sandstone - - - - 79 Pegwn's Fawr, Borders of Radnor and Montgomery - - - 80 The Caradoc Range - - - 81 Relations of Caradoc Sandstone to the Upper Silurian Rocks in Shropshire 82 Caradoc Fossils - - - 86 Upper Caradoc Fossils - - 87 Section at Corton - - - 90 Unconformable Relations of Llandeilo Flags and Upper Silurian, near Builth - . . _ ih. View of the Malvern Hills from the West - - - - 92 Section from the Malvern Hills to Ledbury - - - - 94 General Order of the Upper Silurian Rocks between the Caradoc Sand- stone beneath, and the Old Red Sandstone above them - - 102 Lower Wenlock at Corton, near Pres- teign - ■• - 103 Altered Amorphous Limestone of Nash Scar - - . . ih. Section at Yat Hill and Hanter Hill - 104 View from Stanner Rocks (Ousal Wood, Hanter Hill, and Hergest Ridge being successively seen in the Distance) - - - - 105 xiv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Page Section across the elevated Valley of Wool hope - - - - 106 Trilobites of the Lower Wenlock or Woolhope Limestone - - 108 View of Wenlock Edge, as seen from the Hills of Ludlow Rock on the S.W. - - - 113 Old Quanies in the Wenlock Lime- stone - - - - 11 4 Dudley, from the Wren's Nest - 1 1 6 Section across the Wren's Nest - 117 The South End of the Wren's Nest - ib. Corals of the Wenlock Limestone - 119 120, 121 Ludlow Castle - - - 125 Section across the Ludlow Promontory 126 Whiteway Head - - - 130 The Palmer's Cairn Landslip - 131 Upper Ludlow Rocks at the Bone Well - - - - 134 Brecon Anticlinal of Ludlow Rocks, throwing off Old Red Sandstone - 141 View of the Cliffs near St. Abb's Head 150 Silurian Rocks of the South of Scot- land - - - - 152 Section across the Bins of Connemara, and Killery Harbour - - 169 I,ower Silurian Zoophytes - - 178 Lower Silurian Crinoid - - 180 Lower Silurian Cystideans - - 181 Lower Silurian Star-fish - - 182 Lower Silurian Orthides - - 184 Lower Silurian Brachiopods - 185, 186, 187, 189 Lamellibranchiata - - - 191 Gasteropoda - - - - 193 Heteropod and Pteropod Mollusca - 196 Cephalopoda - - - - 197 Cephalopods - - - - 199 Annelids ; or marine Worm-tracks - ib. Trilobites typical of the Lower Silu- rian Rocks - - - 201 Trinucleus concentricus, three Speci- mens, distorted by Slaty Cleavage - 203 Other Lower Silurian Trilobites - 204 Section of Stromatopora striatella, D'Orb. - - - - 210 Corals of the Upper Silurian Rocks . 212 Cup Corals of the Wenlock Limestone 213 Upper Silurian Bryozoa - - 215 Ptilodictya scalpellum, Lonsdale - 216 Cystideae of the Wenlock Limestone - 217 Crinoidea of the Dudley Limestone - 21 9 Upper Silurian Starfish - - 221 Upper Silurian Brachiopoda - - 222 Upper Silurian Brachiopoda - - 224 Upper Silurian Lamellibranchiata 225, 226 Upper Silurian Cephalopods - - 231 Upper Silurian Crustacea - - 234 Wenlock Limestone Trilobites - 235 View from the Slaty Lower Silurian Rocks near Llanwrtyd, Brecon, ^ Page overlookmg rounded Hills of Upper Silurian ; with Mountains of Old Red Sandstone in the distance, the latter being defined by the untinted outline - - _ - ib. Section from the Top of the Silurian Rocks, on the N.W., across the whole area of the Old Red Sandstone, to the bottom beds of the S. Welsh Coal Field, on the S E. - - 243 Section across the Old Red of Forfar- shire - 248 Mountains of the West Coast of the Highlands - - _ 249 Old Red Sandstone Fish - - 251 Old Red Fish - - - 252 Old Red Ganoid Fish - - 253 Reptile of the Upper Old Red - 254 Old Red Sandstone Plant - - 255 Section across North Devon - - 256 Shells of the Lower Devonian Lime- stone - 261 Shells of the Upper Devonian Lime- stone - - - 263 Ideal View of the Vegetation of the Carboniferous Era - - - 268 General Relations of the Carboniferous Rocks in the Central and Southern Parts of England - - - 270 Stackpole Cliffs of Carboniferous Lime- stone - - - - 271 Stackpole Rock - - - 272 General Order in Pembrokeshire - ib. Section across the Cornbrook Coal Basin of the Clee Hills - - 273 Slash of Culm - - - 275 Limulus rotundatus, Prestwich - 281 Coral of the Mountain Limestone - 282 Some Fossils of the Carboniferous Limestone - 283 Insect and Shells of the Coal - - 284 Fern from Coal of Coalbrook Dale - 285 Uppermost Limestone of the Coal 285, 286 The Gurmaya Hills of the South Ural Mountains- - 295 Section of the West Flank of the South Ural - - - 296 Permian Rocks of Britain - - 300 Relations of Permian Rocks to the Coal near Hales Owen - * - 301 Position of the Permian Rocks in Shropshire - - _ 303 Permian Plants, &c. - - - 3O6 Permian Shells - . . 309 Permian Fish - - - 312 Lower Silurian Strata of Sweden re- posing on Gneiss - - - 318 Oldest Silurian Strata of Sweden rest- ing on Granite - - - 318 Succession in Norway - - 319 Succession in Norway (continued to the east) - - - . 320 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. XV Page Lower Silurian Rocks— Cliffs near Waiwara - - - - J^24 Asaphus expansus, var. cornutus, from the St, Petersburg!! Limestone - ib. Orthoceras duplex, Wahlenberg - 326 Ravine of the Belaia in the Valdai Hills - . - - 328 Devonian and Carboniferous Rocks in the Gorge of the Tchussovaya River 330 Generalized Section across the Silurian Basin of Central Bohemia - - 342 Inversion in the Eifel explained - 377 Inverted Strata South of Brllon - 378 Section from Sille le Guillaume to Sabl^ - - - - 385 Page Ideal Section across the iVppalachian Chain - - . . 424 General Section across the Older Rocks of Lower Canada near the Mouth of the St. Lawrence - - - ib. View from the Summit of the Katch- kanar, N. Ural - - . 43^^ Lake of Aushkul, S. Ural - - 441 Hills of Cossatchi-Datchi - - ib. Diggings at the Soimanofsk Mines - 442 Gold Diggings at Zarevo Alexandrofsk 444 Gold Shingle near Ekaterinburg - 445 Ideal Representation of the Original Formation of Gold in the Rocks, and its subsequent Translation into Heaps of Gravel - - - 449 PLATES OF FOSSILS, ETC. [ To be placed at the End of the Booh.'] I. — IV Lower Silurian Crustacea. v.— VIII „ „ Braehiopoda. IX. — X „ „ Bivalve and Univalve Shells. XI „ „ Cephalopoda. XII „ „ Graptolites and ' Incertai Sedis.' XIII. — XV Upper Silurian Crinoidea and Annelida. XVII. — XIX „ ,, Trilobites and Crustacea. XX. — XXn „ „ Braehiopoda and Lamellibranchiata. XXIV. — XXV „ Gasteropoda, Pteropoda, and Heteropoda. XXVI.— XXX ni Cephalopoda. XXXIV Upper Ludlow Rock (Tilestone). XXXV Fossils of Upper Ludlow Bone bed. XXXVI.— XXXVII Fishes of Old Red Sandstone. General Map of PALiEozoic Formations. To face p. 475. *A 8 ERRATA. Preface, p. vii. 1. 4. for cession, read succession. Page 13. last line, et passim, for mezozoic read mesozoie. 43. last line but one, omit, The Olenus occurs in Bohemia. 44. 1. 3. omit traces. 47. 1. 7. from bottom, /or has, read have. 64. 1. 18. read (porphyries of Sedgwick), after igneous rocks. 68. 1. 4. from bottom, /or ch. 5., read ch. 8. 74. Note, for PI. 3., read PI. 11. ; also ch. 8. instead of ch. 5. 1. 20. dele Orthis alternata, Foss. 8. ; and 1. 22. dele Asaphus Powisii, pi. 2. See p. 98. 1. 2. for B. ornatus, Conrad, read B. nodo- sus, Salter. 1. 5. for next chapter, read chap. 8. 89. 1. 21. /or sixth, read fifth. 91. letters under Section near Builth, for c, read d. 103. 1. 8. /or girt, read grit. 105. 1. 5. /or amorphorus, read amorphous. 107. 1. 5. et passim, for Petraia bina, Lonsdale, read Petraia bina, sp. lionsd. 112. 1. 2. et passim, for Rhynconella, read Rhynchonella. 116. 1. 5. /or extended, read extruded. 118. 1. 4. /or exterior nucleus, read exterior of the nucleus. 119. 1. 7. from bottom, Fav. cristata,/or Linn., read Blumenbach. 121. Foss. 12. f. 1. the name omitted is Diasto- pora? consimilis (Aulopora id. Sil. Syst.) The Author is-indebted to Mr. Lonsdale for this correction, and also for a suggestion that f. 5. is a distinct species from the S. ramulosa, Goldfuss. 133. 1. 10. /or Avicula reticulata, read Pterinea Sowerbyi. 142. 1. 5. from bottom for fossil, read seed- vessel of a plant. 1. 10. from bottom, for Thelodus parvi- dens, read Onchus Murchisoni. 158. 1. I. for Trenton, read Chazy. 161. 1. 15. /or sarcinulata, read lata. 1. 16. /or Avicular lineata, read Pterinea (Avicula) lineatula. 163. 1. 7. from bottom, for comform, read conform. 164. note 2. add and vol. 5. 2nd ser. p. 1. seq. Page 167. L 5. dele the *. Note. 1. 2. /or vol. iv. old ser., read vol. v. 2nd ser. p. \. et seq. 169. 1. 13. for masses granular, read masses of granular. In the section, for letter o under Glen- keen, read c ; and a letter b should be placed under the dark rocks which rest on the granite (*). See descr. p. 172. 1 72. 1. 10. for a, read c. 184. 1. 8. omit 0. flabellulum, f. 1. 187. 1. 4, for last year, read in 1852 (the page ■was printed in 1853). 188. 1. 6. from bottom for PI. 9., read PI. 5. 192. 1. 2. /or Foss. 10., read Foss. 23. L 7. /or Foss. 12. f. 7., read Foss. 7. f. 12. 195. 1. 18. dele if, f. 7. same species. 196. 1. Q.for triated, read striated. 226. 1. 8. for Mytilus antiquus, read Modiola antiqua. 231. 1. 3. and 12. /or Foss. 21., read Foss. 25. 240. 1. 2. from bottom, for in which, read on which. 244. 1. 19. /or (p), read (/). 245. 1. 7. for usher into, reacZ usher in. 252. 1. 8. for one sgeciesis, read one species is 256. 1. 3. of description, place the (*) with ' Eruptive granite.' 1. 5. transfer 'Club Mosses' to the Cryp- togamte above. 259. 1. 6. dele in. 286. Note, 1. 2, /or tracts, read tracks. 304. 1. 7. from bottom, /or do not sto, read do not stop. 305. 1. 17. for that, read those. 308. 1. 2. after Polycoelia dele the semicolon. 310. I. 9. for Keratophoga, read Keratophaga. 315. P. S., end of, for Ruppendorf, read Rup- persdorf. 322. 1. 19. /or on, read in. 323. 1. 4. from bottom, for Kutorga, read Kutorga. 327. 1. 2. from bottom, for but the, read but to the. 1. 5. from bottom, for Devonian rocks of Russia, read Devonian and Carboni- ferous rocks of Russia. 335. 1. 2. for arise, read rise. 371. L 10. for its, read the. 401. note, /or 1852, read 1853. 421. 1. 11. for Shurman, read Shumard. 508. Index, to references to Dr. Buckland, add Alps, 500. S I L U R I A CHAPTER L INTRODUCTION — ORIGINAL SILURIAN RESEARCHES. — DESIGN OF THIS WORK. The earliest condition of the earth is necessarily the darkest period of its geological history. The favourite hypothesis concerning the origin of the planet, founded on astronomical and physical analogies, is, that it assumed the form of a flattened spheroid from rotation on its axis when in a fluid state. Reasoning upon this idea, and look- ing to the structure of those rocks which either lie at great depths or have been extruded from beneath, the geologist has inferred that the crystalline masses, including granites which issued out from be- low all other rocks, and constitute possibly their existing substratum, were at one time in a molten state. The theory of a central heat, at first sufiiciently intense to maintain the whole terrestrial mass in a state of fusion, but subsequently so far dissipated by radiation into space, as to allow the superficial portion to become solid, has been adopted by the greater number of philosophers who have grappled with the difficult problem of the first conditions of our planet. Most of them likewise have believed that all the great out- bursts of igneous matter, by which the crust has been penetrated and its surface diversified, were merely outward signs of the con- tinued internal activity of that primordial heat, now much repressed B 2 SILURIA. [Chap. 1. by the accumulat ions of ages, and of which our present volcanoes are feeble indications. If, then, the mathematician has correctly ex- plained the causes of the shape of the globe, the geologist confirms his views when, examining into the nature of its oldest massive crystalline rocks, he sees in them clear proofs of the effects of intense heat. This original crust of the earth was subsequently, we may believe, broken up by protruded masses, which, issuing in a melted condition, constituted the axes and centres of mountain chains. Each great igneous eruption gave out substances that became, on cooling, solid rocks, which, when raised into the atmosphere, constituted lands that were exposed to innumerable wasting agencies ; and thus afforded materials to be spread out as deposits upon the shores and bed of the ocean. In these hypothetical views concerning the production of the earliest sediments formed under water, we seem to reach a primary source ; and once admitting that large superficial areas were origi- nally occupied by igneous rocks, we have in them a basis from which the first sedimentary materials were obtained. The earlier eruptions having necessarily occasioned elevations at some points and collapses or depressions at others, such changes of outline, aided by the grinding action of water, would occasion the formation of bands of sediment, which, adapting themselves to the inequalities of the surface, must have been of unequal dimensions in different parts of their range. In this way we may imagine how, by a repetition of the processes of elevation and denudation, the earliest exterior rugosities of the earth would be in some places increased, while in others they would be placed beyond the influence of sedimentary accumulation. May we not also infer, that the nu- merous molten rocks of great dimensions which were suddenly evolved from the interior at subsequent periods, must have made enormous additions to the solid crust of the earth, and have con- stituted grand sources for the augmentation of new strata ? Turning from the igneous rocks to crystalline stratified deposits. Chap. L] INTRODUCTORY VIEW. 3 we now know that a great portion of the micaceous schists, chloritic and quartzose rocks, clay-slates, and limestones, once called primary, were of later origin. Many of these are nothing more than subaqueous sediments of various epochs, which have been altered and crystallized at periods long subsequent to their accumu- lation. This inference has been deduced from positive observation. Rocks, for example, have been tracked from the districts where they are crystalline, to spots where the mechanical and subaqueous origin of the beds is obvious, and from the latter to localities where the same strata are wholly unchanged, and contain organic remains. Transi- tions are thus seen from compact quartz rock, in which the grains of silica are scarcely discoverable with a powerful lens, to strata in which the sandy, gritty, and pebbly particles bespeak clearly that the whole range was originally accumulated under water. Other passages occur from crystalline, chloritic, and micaceous schists, to those clay-slates which are little more than consolidated mud, and from crystalline marble to common earthy limestone, in which organic remains abound. These and similar metamorphoses embrace the consideration of changes, like those, for example, by which or- dinary limestone has been converted into dolomite and sulphate of lime or gypsum, or shale into mica-schist, as is seen in the se- condary and tertiary rocks of the Alps.* Elementary works will have, indeed, informed the student, that such changes of the original sediment have been generally ac- counted for by the influence of great heat proceeding from the interior of the earth, and which at different former periods mani- fested its power in the eruption of granites, syenites, porphyries, greenstones, and other substances formed by fusion. Let it, how- ever, be understood, that the prodigious extent to which the meta- morphism of the original strata has been carried in mountain- chains, and at different periods through all formations, though often * See Alps, Apennines, &c. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. v. p. 157. et seq. B 2 4 SILURTA. [Chap.1. probably connected with such igneous outbursts, must have re- sulted from a far mightier agency than that which was produc- tive of the mere eruptions of molten matter or igneous rocks. The latter are, in fact, but partial excrescences in the vast spread of the stratified crystalline rocks, — symptoms only of the grand changes which resulted from deep-seated causes ; probably from the combination of heat, steam, and electricity, acting together with an intensity very powerful in former periods. Processes now going on in nature on a small scale, or imitated artificially by man, may enable us to comprehend imperfectly in what manner some of these infinitely grander ancient metamorphoses were effected ; and the experimental science of chemistry, when more extensively applied to the analysis of rocks, will, it is hoped, some day reveal still more important truths in this, which is still one of the most obscure points in the range of geological phenomena. But speculations on such physical operations as those which have affected the surface of the earth, are not here called for. At all events, the earliest of the phenomena, with which alone we are at present concerned, or the first formation of the known crust of the planet, belongs to a period in which no definite order, — still less any trace of life, — has been deciphered by human labour.* The design of this work is much more attainable. Its aim is to mark the most ancient strata in which the proofs of sedimentary or aqueous action are still visible, — to note the geological position of those beds which in various countries offer the first ascertained signs of life, and to develop the succession of deposits, where not obscured by metamorphism, that belong to such protozoic zones. In thus adhering only to subjects capable of being investigated, it will * The reader who desires to study the laws by which the superficial tempera- ture of the earth has been regulated in the immensely long subsequent geolo- gical periods, will find them well explained in the profound essay of Mr. W. Hopkins, " On the causes of changes of climate at difierent geological periods," Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. viii. p. 56. Chap. I.] SILURIAN RESEARCHES. 5 be seen, that geology, modern as she is among the sciences, has revealed to us, that during cycles long anterior to the creation of the human race, and while the surface of the globe was passing from one condition to another, whole races of animals — each group adapted to the physical conditions in which they lived — were successively created and exteraiinated. It is to the first stages only of this grand and long series of former accumulations, and to the crea- tures entombed in them, that attention is now directed. The convictions at which I have arrived being the result of many years of research, I have been urged by numerous friends to give a condensed, and, as far as is practicable, a popular view of the oldest sedimentary rocks and of their chief organic remains, and thus to throw into one moderate-sized volume the essence of my large works *, as sustained by the publications of many other authors. Geologists are now pretty generally agreed, that the oldest organic remains which are traceable, pertain to the lower division of the rocks termed Silurian; but before any description of these ancient deposits, or of those preceding them, is given, a few words are required, in explanation of the researches by which our acquaintance with the earliest vestiges of life and order in the protozoic world has been attained. One of the chief steps which led to the present classification, as admitted by my contemporaries, was the establishment of the ' Silurian System ' of rocks and their imbedded fossils. Before the labours which terni.inated in the publication of the work so named, no one had unravelled the detailed sequence and characteristic fossils of any strata of a higher antiquity than the Old Red Sandstone ; and even that formation was only known to be the natural base of the Carboniferous or Mountain limestone, and to contain a few unde- scribed fossil fishes. Not only were the relations and contents of all * See Silurian System, Murchison, 1839; and Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, by Murcliison, de Yerneuil, and de Keyserling (J. Murray, 1845). B 3 6 SILURIA. [Chap. I. the inferior strata undefined, but even many rocks which are now known to be younger than the Silurian, were then considered to be of much more remote antiquity. No one had then surmised, that the great series of hard slates with limestones and fossils, which have since been termed Devonian, is an equivalent of the Old E,ed Sandstone, and younger than, as well as distinct from, the de- posits of the still older Silurian era. On the contrary, British authorities believed (and I was myself so taught) that the schistose and subcrystalline rocks of Devonshire and Cornwall were about the most ancient of the vast undigested heaps of greywacke. In short, the best geologists* of my early days were accustomed to leave off with such rocks, as constituting obscure heaps of sedi- ment, in and below which no succession of " strata as identified by their fossils " could be detected. The result of research, how- ever, has been the elimination of several well-defined groups, all of which were formerly merged in the unmeaning German term * grauwacke.' (See Chap. 14.) Desirous of throwing light on this dark subject, I consulted my valued friend and instructor. Dr. Buckland, as to the region most likely to afford evidences of order, and by his advice I first explored, in 1831, the banks of the Wye between Hay and Builth. Discovering a considerable tract in Hereford, Radnor, and Shropshire, wherein large masses of grey-coloured strata rise out from beneath the Old Red Sandstone, and contain fossils differing from any which were known in the superior deposits, I began to classify these rocks. After four years of consecutive labour, I as- signed to them (1835) the name Silurian, deriving it from the portion of England and Wales, in which the successive formations are clearly displayed, and wherein an ancient British people, the Silures, under their king Caradoc (Caractacus), had opposed a long and * See those classical works, the first Geological Map of Mr. Greenough, and the Geology of England and Wales, by the Kev. W. D. Conybeare. Ch\p. I.] SILUKIAN RESEARCHES. 7 valorous resistance to the Eomans. Having firsts in the year 1833, separated these deposits* into four formations, and shown that each is characterized by peculiar organic remains, I next di- vided them (1834, 1835) into a lower and upper group, both of which I hoped would be found applicable to wide regions of the earth. After eight years of labour in the field and closet, the proofs of the truth of those views were more fully published in the work entitled the ' Silurian System ' (1839). During my early researches, it was shown that the lowest of these (1833) fossil-bearing strata reposed, in the west of Shropshire, on a very thick accumulation of still older sediment, as exposed in the ridge of the Stiper Stones, and the Longmynd mountain ; and the strata of the latter not offering a vestige of former life, they were consequently termed unfossiliferous greywacke. At that time it was also supposed, that the contiguous slaty region of North Wales, then under the examination of Professor Sedgwick, consisted of rocks, in part fossiliferous, and of an enormous thick- ness, which rose up, according to my friend and fellow labourer, from beneath my Silurian types. Hence, another term, or that of Cambrian, was afterwards, or in the year 1836, applied to masses supposed to be inferior, before their true relations to the Silurian strata of Shropshire and Montgomeryshire had been ascertained. This assumed inferiority of position in the slaty rocks of North Wales being considered a fixed point, it was naturally thought, that such lower formations, the fossils of which were then unde- scribed, would be found to contain a set of organic remains, * For the first tabular view of these four formations, the bottom one resting on the unfossiliferous greywacke of the Longmynd, see Proceedings Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. ii. p. 11., Jan. 1834. The characteristic fossil species were even then enume- rated, and hence the classification which is now sustained is essentially twenty years old. It had even been previously stated by me, that the lowest known fossil- bearing formation, or the ' black trilohite schists and flags of Llandeilo^ probably ex- ceeded in thickness any of the superior groups' — Proc. Geol. Soc. vol. i. p. 476. 1833. B 4 8 SILURIA. [Chap. I. differing as a whole from those of my classified and published Silurian system. With other geologists, therefore, I waited for the production of the fossils which might typify such supposed older sediments; for in obtaining all the knowledge I had then acquired, by receding from upper strata whose contents were known, to lower and previously unknown rocks, I had invariably found that the latter were characterized by many distinct and new organisms. This fact, which had been first established in the tertiary and secondary deposits, was thus proved to be universally applicable by the occurrence of similar distinctions in the Carboniferous, Old E-ed, and Silurian rocks. It was, however, in vain that we looked to the production of a peculiar type of life from the ' Cambrian ' rocks. Silurian fossils were alone found in them ; and the reason has since become mani- fest. The labours of many competent observers In the last fifteen years have proved that these rocks are not inferior in position, as they were supposed to be, to the lowest stratified rocks of my Silurian region of Shropshire and the adjacent parts of Montgo- meryshire, but are merely extensions of the same strata ; and hence the looked-for geological and zoological distinctions could never have been realized. In the following chapters it will be shown how Sir H. De la Beche, Professors Ramsay and E. Forbes, with Mr. Salter, and other geologists and palceontologists, have demon- strated, that the fossil-bearing rocks of North Wales are both in their order and contents the absolute equivalents of the chief mass of the strata which had been described and named by me ^ Lower Silurian ' in Shropshire and Montgomeryshire. These Government geologists have used my nomenclature in all their works relating to North Wales, and have, in short, determined the question physically as well as zoologically.* But although in 1839, when my first work was completed, I held, * See also Phillips, on the Malvern and Abberley Hills. — Memoirs, Geol. Surv. Vol. ii. Pt. 1. 1848. Chap. I.] DESIGN OF THE WOKK. 9 in common with Professor Sedgwick, the erroneous idea of the infra- Silurian position of the rocks of North Wales, I soon saw reason to abandon that view, and to adopt (in the year 1841) the opinion which I have subsequently maintained. Thirteen years have elapsed since I was persuaded that the view I then took must be adhered to ; first, because it had been ascertained, that in Scandinavia, Russia, Bohemia, and other countries, the oldest traces of former life were the same as the lower Silurian types of the British Isles ; — and next, because many of the fossils figured in my work as Lower Silurian had been detected in the slates of Snowdon, which were then considered to lie near the bottom of the so-called ' Cambrian rocks.' The leading object, therefore, of the present work is, I repeat, to bring out the ' Silurian System,' not as a mere abridgment of its original form ; but such as it finally became in the year 1849, when it was honoured with the highest distinction which the Koyal Society bestows*, and what it has proved to be, with the geographical and other additions made to it by the government surveyors at home, and by numerous geologists in other countries. In extending my own researches to various distant lands, I found that as the true base of all rocks containing fossil remains was clear in Scandinavia, Russia, and Bohemia, and as the same fact was announced from North America, it was no longer difficult to describe the whole organic series from a beginning, and thus to record the succession of animals from their earliest known developments. In a word, as chroniclers of lost races, my associates and myself were enabled to register in our ' Russia and the Ural Mountains,"' the types of former creatures from their apparent dawn. To the first chapters of that work, the reader is referred as fully ex- planatory of views which are here reiterated, f Then it was, * The Copley Medal. t The reader who desires to consult the documents which explain how my induction was arrived at, is referred to a memoir entitled, " On the meaning at- 10 SILURIA. [Chap. I. that positive proofs, derived from a wide field of observation, enabled us to commence geological history, with an account of the entombment of the earliest animals recognizable in the crust of the globe ; and also to indicate the successive conditions which prevailed upon the surface, in a long series of ages, and during the many changes of outline which preceded the present state of the planet. Then it was, that looking to the whole history of former life, as exhibited in the strata, it was demonstrated from pheno- mena in one great empire alone (as had to a great extent been shown in Britain), that during the formation of the sediments which compose the crust of the earth, the animal kingdom had been at least three times entirely renovated; the secondary and tertiary periods having each been as clearly characterized by a distinct fauna as the primeval series. In the work on Russia the sequence was thus followed out truly, from the most ancient fossil- bearing strata to the most recent stages in the geological series. tached to the term Silurian during the last ten years," which will indicate to him all my successive publications on this subject, including a geological map of England and Wales, published by the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Know- ledge, in 1843. (Journal of Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. viii. p. 173. See also the memoir entitled, " On the meaning attached to the term 'Cambrian System,' and on the evidence since obtained of its being geologically synonymous with the pre- viously established term ' Lower Silurian.' " — Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. iii. p. 165.) At the same time that I must protest against the recent proposal to absorb my Lower Silurian into his Cambrian Rocks, let me record my high estima- tion of the original memoirs of Professor Sedgwick, especially those on J^orth Wales, Cumberland, and the adjacent counties, which stand upon their own in- trinsic merits. The publication on the palteozoic fossils of the Cambridge Museum, which he is bringing out in conjunction with Professor M'Coy, will be, I doubt not, a lasting monument in the history of geological science. If that work had been published eighteen years ago, or in 1836, my friend, seeing that his Bala and my Llandeilo rocks were identical, might have proposed (although my fossils were first named and classified) that the Lower Silurian should be merged in the Cambrian. But, now that the terms Lower and Upper Silurian have been adopted in every country, the question is settled. My deep regret on the oc- casion of this difference of opinion has been expressed in the Preface ; for in general views, as in private friendship, we are cordially united. Chap. I.] DESIGN OF THE WORK. 11 In this volume attention is chiefly restricted to what has proved to be the protozoic, or first era of life. The plan, therefore, pur- sued will be, so far, similar to that which was adopted in the earlier chapters of the work on Russia ; and these first leaves of geological history will be written from the clear traces of a beginning, — a plan which, for want of knowledge, was impracticable in Britain when the ' Silurian System ' was published. After a short sketch of the earliest and unfossiliferous sedi- ments, full descriptions will be given of the Silurian rocks (Lower and Upper), followed by very brief accounts of the three overlying groups of palseozoic life, the Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian. The Devonian rocks were in previous years known only as the Old Bed Sandstone, a name which has, indeed, become classical through the writings of Hugh Miller. These were termed Devonian, because the strata of that age in Devonshire, though very unlike the Old Red Sandstone of Scotland, Hereford, and the South Welsh counties, contain a much more copious and rich fossil fauna, and were de- monstrated to occupy the same intermediate position between the previously described Silurian and Carboniferous rocks. At that time, however, none of the fossil fishes of the Scottish or English Old Red had been found in the sandstones, slates, schists, or lime- stones of Devonshire, or the Rhine, and objections might have been raised to the opinion formed of the age of the deposits. But the discovery made in Russia*, and afterwards extended to Belgium and the Rhenish provinces, of Scottish ichthyolites being associated with numerous mollusca of the Devonshire rocks, firmly established the truth of the comparison. The Carboniferous rocks, so elaborately and usefully developed in the British Isles, have been already well investigated by many writers, particularly by Professor Phillips, and have been found * See Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 64. 12 SILURIA. [Chap. I. to extend, like the Silurian and Devonian, over immense regions in all quarters of the globe. The great primeval or palceozoic series is now known to ter- minate upwards, in Europe, with certain deposits, for which, in the year 1841, I suggested the name of Peruiian. In the early days of geological science in England, this group was classed with the New Red Sandstone, of which it was supposed to form the base. But ex- tended researches have shown from the character of its imbedded remains, that it is linked to the carboniferous deposit on which it rests, and is entirely distinct from the Trias, or Xew E,ed Sand- stone, which, overlying it, forms the base of all the secondary rocks. The chief calcareous member of this Permian group was termed in England the Magnesian Limestone, in Germany the 'Zechstein;' but as magnesian limestones are of all ages, and as the German ^ Zechstein' is but a part of a group, the other members of which are known as *Kupfer Scliiefer ' (copper slate), 'Rothe todte liegende' (the Lower New Red of English geologists), &c., it was manifest that a single name for the whole was much needed. After showing how these variously named strata constituted one natural group, I therefore proposed to my fellow-labourers, de Yerneuil and A. de Keyserling, that the vast Russian territory of Perm should furnish the required name. The term Permian* has, indeed, been adopted by several German authorities, and also by the Govern- ment Geological Surveyors of Britain. In the opening chapter on the geology of Russia, we gave a gene- ral view of this palaeozoic classification, as applied to Germany, France, Belgium, and North America; in all of which coun- tries, as well as in Russia, it was shown, that a similar ascending order prevailed, from a base line of recognizable Silurian life, up through Devonian and Carboniferous deposits. In the nine years which have elapsed since the issue of that work, considerable addi- * ' Pencen' of D'Omalius d'Halloy. (See Chap. 12.) Chap. I.] DESIGN OF THE WOKK. 13 tions have been made to our knowledge, and all of them sustain the truth of our generalization. We then scarcely knew of the existence of true Silurian deposits in Germany ; nearly all the grey- wacke of the Rhenish provinces and the Hartz having been assigned to the Devonian series. But since the opening out of the rich Silurian basin of Bohemia, which, in the hands of M. Barrande, has become the palseozoic centre of the continent, Thuringia and Saxony have been also found to contain Silurian rocks. In Spain, several mountain chains have been shown by M. de Vemeuil to consist of Silurian, followed by Devonian and Car- boniferous rocks ; whilst, in Portugal, Mr. Sharpe has described the first and last of these groups. Even Sardinia has exhibited, under the scrutiny of General A. della Marmora, her Silurian and super- jacent coal deposits. Again, as Devonian and Carboniferous strata overlie older rocks in North Africa, and Devonian fossils occur to- wards Central Africa* and at the Cape of Good Hope, there are already fair grounds for believing, that a similar order pervades the axial lines or ancient mountains of that vast continent. In north-western Asia, the chief features of which are described by Humboldt and Rose, my colleagues and myself have explained, how the Silurian rocks of the Ural chain are succeeded by younger palaeozoic deposits, and Pierre de Tchihatcheff has indicated a great extension of similar formations over large tracts of Southern Siberia and the Altai mountains; whilst in north-eastern Siberia, Adolf Erman has traced such rocks even to the Sea of Ochotsk. In the giant Himalaya mountains, and in HIndostan, where till recently no systematic labours had been devoted to the older strata, we now know, that Silurian rocks, covered by secondary or mezozoic deposits, exist in those the highest mountains of the world ; * For North Africa, see Coquand, Bull, de la Soc. Geol. de France, 2nde Serie, vol. iv. p. 1188. Some of the fossils collected by the enterprisino- traveller Overweg are also Devonian. For South Africa, the reader must consult a Memoir by Mr. Bain, not yet published in the Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. 14 SILURIA. [Chap. I. and that the Upper Punjaub contains a limestone charged with well- known carboniferous fossils, reposing, as in England,, upon a red sand- stone.* There is, indeed, every reason to believe that the mountain chains of Tartary and China are composed, to a great extent, of these older rocks ; for whilst extensive coal-fields have been long worked in the environs of the capital, Pekin, Devonian fossils of the very same species as those of England and the continent have recently been sent from Kwangsi, far to the south of Shangai. Other fossils, identified by de Koninck as Devonian forms, were brought by M. Itier, from the Yuennan province, one hundred leagues north of Canton.t In Australia, where a very short time since reference could be made only to rocks of the Carboniferous and Devonian age J, we hear of true Silurian strata containing fossils like those of the British Isles. Some species seem undistinguishable. § In South America, the lofty Cordilleras and plateaux, whose mineral characters had been so admirably described by Humboldt, are shown by Alcide d'Orbigny to consist in great part of such ancient sediments. StiU more clearly has North America been found to contain a vast succession of these palaeozoic rocks, and especially of their lower members. Numerous geologists of the United States have demonstrated, that their ancient strata followed the same order on a very grand and usually unbroken scale (particularly in the * The Himalayan data are described, by Capt. R. Stracbey ; those of the Upper Punjaub, by Dr. A. Fleming. (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. vii. p. 292., and vol. ix. p. 189.) f See a description of the Chinese coal-field near Pekin, by Kovanko, Ann. des Mines de Russie, An. 1838, p. 191. No geologist can peruse Mr. Fortune's lively description of the Bohea mountains without suspecting, that a fine primeval succession may there be found. For the Chinese fossils, see Davidson, Q. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. ix. p. 353.; and de Koninck, Bull. Acad. Roy. Sc. Belg. vol. xiii. pt. 2. p. 415. I See Strzelecki's Australia, Foss. Fauna, Morris; M'Coy, Ann. Xat. Hist. 1847. § Memoir by the Rev. W. B. Clarke, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. viii. ; see also his collections, and those at the Government Museum. Chap. I.] DESIGN OF THE WOKK. 15 western region); doubtless due to their having been exempted in such tracts from the intrusion of igneous rocks. Spread out in enormous sheets over the southern districts of Upper Canada, the Lower Silurian strata, invariably so called by every American geo- logist % are there based on unfossiliferous slates, limestones and sand- stones reposing on crystalline rocks, which, extending far northwards, are surmounted by other sedimentary masses similar to strata of the United States, and where Silurian fossils have been detected in limestones amid the polar ices. Adjacent to the southern end of this continent, similar remains have been collected bv Darwin in the Falkland Islands. In few of those regions, however, with the exception of North America (certainly not in the British Isles, where the strata are in many parts much obscured by igneous outbursts), is the sequence so undisturbed as in Scandinavia and European Russia. There, the successive primeval deposits extend over a large portion of the earth in regular sequence and in an unaltered state. Hence, though to the unskilled eye, Russia presents only a monotonous and un- dulating surface, chiefly occupied by accumulations of mud, sand, and erratic blocks, its framework, wherever it can be detected, exhibits a clear ascending series. The older sedimentary strata, deviating only slightly from horlzontallty, are there overlaid by widely- diffused masses of those Permian rocks which constitute the true termination of the long palaeozoic period. The following pages, as before said, will be chiefly devoted to the Silurian or first stages of this primeval series. They will be illustrated by woodcuts representing the most important organic re- mains, and certain typical, pictorial scenes, as well as vertical sec- tions, chiefly taken from my original work. Faithful transfers from the original plates of the 'Silurian System' will also be given, * See particularly the works of James Hall and Dale Owen, the Reports of Logan — the chief geologist of Canada — and the new general map of Marcou. 16 SILURIA. [Chap. I. in a rearranged fornix and with the modern nomenclature of the fossils. If all the succeeding primeval rocks were to obtain the same amount of illustration as the Silurian, this work would be expanded far beyond the limits to which I must restrict it. The younger palaeozoic, or the Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian deposits, will therefore receive only such a description as may be sufficient to give the student a general view, and stimulate him to acquire a fuller acquaintance with them by consulting the various works wherein they are circum- stantially described. But even the sketch of them in this volume will, it is hoped, suffice to show, that while the contiguous strata of two natural groups are intimately linked together by containing some species which are common to both, the principal fossils of each are certainly peculiar. Although few mineral changes of the strata can be alluded to, an endeavour will be made to show, that gold, however it may now be spread over the surface, w^as originally accumulated in abundance in the older rocks only (especially in those which have been much altered), and in the associated eruptive masses. Lastly, it is to be observed, that as the true sequence of the oldest fossiliferous strata was first detected in the British Isles, so the geo- logical descriptions in this volume Avill be principally derived from our insular examples. At the same time, a general comparison will be instituted with the contemporaneous rocks of different quarters of the globe. The importance of having, through patient surveys, mastered the obscurities which clouded the history of the earlier periods of animal life will thus, it is hoped, be rendered obvious, in showing that we have now obtained as correct an insight into the first fossil- bearing formations as we had previously acquired of the younger deposits. 17 CHAPTEE 11. BASE OF THE SILURIAN ROCKS, AND EARLIEST ZONE OF FORMER LIFE. OUTLINES, STRUCTURE, AND ORDER OF THE OLDER ROCKS. — EARLIEST CRYSTALLINE ROCKS. — THE LOWEST DEPOSITS IN WHICH A TRUE SEDIMENTARY ORIGIN IS SEEN ARE USUALLY VOID OF SIGNS OF FORMER LIFE. ORDER OF SUCCESSION FROM SUCH UNFOSSILIFEROUS STRATA UPWARDS TO THE LOWEST ZONE IN WHICH FOSSIL REMAINS HAVE BEEN DETECTED IN GREAT BRITAIN. The most ancient rocks in which traces of fossil animals have been detected vary much in structure and outline in the different coun- tries where they have been recognized. Wherever such masses have remained in a state of comparative quiescence, from the period when they were raised up from beneath a primeval ocean and have since been only slightly modified by physical causes, they are necessarily unlike those rocks which, though formed at the same period and even composed of the same materials, have been penetrated by igneous matter, or subjected to alteration and dislocation through the action of heat, pressure, and other agencies. In Russia, for example*, where some of the oldest deposits have been only partially hardened since they were accumulated at the bottom of the sea, and have been merely elevated into low plateaus that have undergone no great change or disruption, they have scarcely any resemblance to rocks of the same age in the British Isles. When, however, we follow these soft primeval strata of Russia * Kussia and the Ural Mountains, by Murchison, De Verneuil, and Von Key- serling, vol. i. p. 26 *. 18 SILURIA. [Chap. II. to the Ural Chain, in which there are numerous rocks of eruptive character, we find that the beds, which on the west consist of mud and sand, have there been converted into crystalline schists, lime- stones, and quartz rocks. Startling, therefore, as it may seem to young geologists, the hillocks of slightly coherent mud, marl, and sand near St. Petersburg are truly of the same age as some of the hard slaty mountains of North Wales ; a fact which geological researches have established by proving, that the deposits of the two countries contain a similar group of organic remains, and occupy the same relative place in the series of formations which compose the crust of the globe. So also in North America, where strata of the same period, as seen in the United States and the British provinces, are usually in the state of ordinary sandstone, shale, and limestone, when traced westwards over vast prairies to the sources of the Missouri, are seen to have been also converted into crystalline rocks. This phenomenon occurs along those numerous ancient cracks in the crust of the earth through which the igneous materials were evolved which specially mark the range of the Kocky Mountains and other prolongations of the Andes.* This is the change which geologists call metamorphlsm. For, as the strata have been penetrated in many places by granites, por- phyries, and other rocks which were once in a state of fusion, so it is inferred that their transmutation has resulted from the action of heat, and usually under the pressure of a former ocean. In such examples the age of the original sediment is the same, though the mineral aspect of the rocks in tracts distant from each other is so very different. * See Stansbury's Exploration of the Great Salt Lake of Utah. Philadelphia, 1852. The fossils collected by this enterprising engineer and geographer are described by Professor James Hall, and prove the existence, if not of Silurian, at all events of Devonian and carboniferous deposits, extending to the Mormon ter- ritory, where some of the lower strata, probably Silurian, are much metamorphosed and mineralized. Chap. II.] OUTLINES OF SILURIAN ROCKS. 19 In like manner it will presently be shown, that the comparatively low hills of western Shropshire, and the contiguous districts of Montgomery, parts of Herefordshire, and the adjacent tracts of South Wales, where the Silurian system was originally established, present to the student, in an intelligible manner, an arrangement and succession of strata little altered, which he will have much more trouble in deciphering amidst the hard, rugged, metamorphic, and crystalline formations of the same age in North Wales ; even now that obscurities have been removed by the labours of the eminent persons who have laboured in the arduous task of bringing that region into order.* He will also see in it the very same phenomenon as in the Ural and Rocky mountains, — the conversion of the oldest of such strata into crystalline schists (Anglesea). In Russia the Silurian rocks form either wide level plains, or low plateaus, whilst in other countries where they have been heaved up into mountains, they have a rounded outline, particularly * See particularly the Memoirs of Professor Sedgwick, descriptive of the North Welsh mountains, in the Proceedings of the Geol. Soc. of Lond., vol. ii. p. 679. ; vol. iii. p. 548. ; Quarterly Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. i. p. 5.; ib. p. 542. ; vol. iii. p. 133.; also the Memoirs of Mr. Bowman, Reports of Brit. Association, 1841 ; Trans. Phil. Soc. Manch., vol. i. p. 194. ; of Mr. Sharpe, Proceedings, vol. iii. p. 74. ; ib. vol. iv. p. 10. ; Quarterly Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. ii. p. 283. ; Davis on Tremadoc, ib. vol. ii. p. 70. See Ramsay and Aveline, Quarterly Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. iv. p. 294. Independently of his works on the Silurian System, and Russia and the Ural Mountains, the author of this volume refers to his memoirs. Lond. and Edin. Phil. Mag. 1835, p. 46. ; Proceedings of the Geol. Soc, vol. i. p. 471.; ib. vol. ii. pp. 11. and 119.; ib. vol. iii. p. 640. ; ib. vol. iv. p. 70.; Quarterly Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. i. p. 467. ; ib. vol. iii. pp. 1. and 165. But, above all, the geologist must consult the recently published maps and sections of the government surveyors, which have finally determined all questions at issue. Of these, and particularly in reference to the complicated tracts of Wales, which he has so skilfully worked out with his associates. Pro- fessor Ramsay will soon publish a descriptive work in the volumes of the Go- vernment Survey, similar to that which has been done for the Malvern Hills and adjacent tracts by Professor Phillips. c 2 20 SILURIA. [Chap. II. where they consist of schists, originally composed of mud, the fine grains of which have given rise to equable atmospheric attrition. When, on the contrary, the shale and schist having been changed into hard slates, the sandstone into quartz rock, or the earthy limestone into crystalline marble, and particularly if the beds are highly inclined, and penetrated by igneous rocks, then striking peaks or abrupt cliffs and gorges are dominant. Thus it is, that the Silurian rocks of different regions put on many external forms. In South Britain they are, necessarily, most varied in districts like western Shropshire, North Wales, and Cum- berland, where igneous and intrusive rocks have diversified the outline by expanding, breaking through, and altering these sediments. Observation has now taught us of what materials the fundamental rocks consist in the different countries where they occur. In Scan- dinavia, for example, as in parts of North America, the masses beneath all those formations in which there are the slightest vestiges of Silurian life, are primary rocks, including granitic gneiss, mica- schist, as well as metalliferous schists and quartzose crystalline masses. In Bohemia, however, as in Great Britain, and other portions of North America *, the lowest zone containing fossil re- mains is underlaid by very thick buttresses of earlier sedimentary accumulations, whether sandstone, schist, or slate, which, though * In North America this formation may also be termed azoic; for along the western portion of Lake Superior, and in the country extending southwards into the State of Michigan, rocks of this class rise from beneath the Potsdam sandstone, or lowest formation in which Silurian fossils are known. Citing the American authors, Foster and Whitney on the azoic rocks of Lake Superior, of King on those of the State of Missouri, of Logan on those of the British frontier, and of Engelmann on Texas, and placing them iii relation to the excellent works of James Hall and Dale Owen, M. Desor has announced to the Geological So- ciety of France, that in those regions there exists a vast formation of strata, in parts metaraorphic, of silicious sandstones, chloritic and quartzose schists, cha- racterized by the absence of organic remains, and a great abundance of iron ore. Bulletin de la Soc. Geol. de France, 2 Ser., tom. ix. p. 342. CiiAP. II.] BOTTOM ROCKS UNFOSSILIFEROUS. 21 often occasionally not more crystalline than the fossiliferous beds above them, have yet afforded no sign of former beings. This is the important fact to which attention is first directed; for in such instances the geologist appeals to the book of nature where its leaves have undergone no great alteration. He sees before him an enormous pile or series of early subaqueous sediment, originally composed of mud, sand, or pebbles, the successive bottoms of a former sea, all of which have been derived from pre-existing rocks ; and in these lower beds, even where they are little altered, he can detect no remains of former creatures. But lying upon them, and therefore evolved after them, other strata succeed, in which some few relics of a primeval ocean are discernible, and these again are every where succeeded by newer deposits in which many fossils occur. In this way, evidences have been fairly obtained to show, that the sediments which underlie the strata containing the lowest fossil re- mains constitute, in all countries which have been examined, the natural base or bottom rocks of the deposits termed Silurian. The hypothesis that all the earliest sediments have been so altered as to have obliterated the traces of any relics of former life which may have been entombed in them, is therefore opposed by examples of enormously thick and varied deposits beneath the lowest fossili- ferous rocks, and in which, if animal remains had ever existed, some traces of them would certainly be detected. A very few words need here be said of those crystalline rocks which in numerous regions have been the nuclei out of whose materials the very oldest recognizable sediments have been composed. Passing over the consideration of the most ancient granites, por- phyries, and other igneous rocks, there are doubtless also stratified crystalline rocks, which either lie under or have been raised from beneath all those deposits in which we can trace the signs of me- chanical and subaqueous action. Such rocks, formed, as I believe, at a period when the heat of the 22 SILURIA. [Chap. IT. surface of the earth was antagonistic to the existence of living beings, unquestionably often form the axes or backbones of continents, upon the sides of which the oldest sedimentary formations have been de- posited. But it is unnecessary here to dwell further upon them; whilst in the sequel we shall have to indicate the metamorphism of many formations of younger date. For the present work is, I repeat, simply intended as a popular sketch of the successive accumulation of those sedimentary strata which succeeded to the primary state of the planet, and in which the remains of the earliest known animals are entombed ; the physical conditions which accompanied such de- posits being duly noted. Now, in some regions where the oldest of these deposits (all of them once sea-bottoms) have been exempted from such change or meta- morphism, or very slightly subjected to it, we observe that the lowest sediments thus accumulated are void of traces of life. Proceeding in our researches, we next find that these, the most ancient grey- wacke grits and schists of geologists, which have been formed under water at the expense of previous rocks, are succeeded regularly, and without disorder, by other strata scarcely at all diflPering from the former in composition, in which, at various points of the surface of the globe, and at the same level or horizon, we here and there obtain the first glimpses of the same group of animal life. Once introduced to these primordial creatures, the inquirer into the subsequent opera- tions of nature meets thenceforward with a never-failing storehouse General Order of the Primeval Rocks. y 1 2a 2 3 4 5 Gneiss, &c. y ; granite x. of animal relics in all the formations which afterwards were suc- cessively accumulated. The accompanying diagram explains at a Chap. II.] ASCENDING ORDER OF STRATA. 23 glance this generalization, as established by an appeal to the struc- ture of several countries, the rocks of which exhibit the first steps in this long series. In 1, the reader sees the older deposits formed out of the pre-exist- ing rocks, consisting of gneiss, &c. y, or granite x, whilst 2^ represents the earliest zone wherein any notable signs of life occur ; and the overlying masses, 2, 3, 4, 5, stand for the mass of the formations into which the earliest primeval system of fossil animals is divided. We will presently consider this ascending order of stratum upon stratum, as it is presented to us in the region where the Silurian clas- sification began, and in the adjacent country of N. Wales, to which that classification has since been extended and applied by the government geological surveyors. In the mean time, let me repeat, that in Bohemia, as well as in N. America, there are crystalline rocks, which, from their underlying position, are known to be of higher antiquity than the azoic greywacke of the previous section. So also it is believed that in the north Highlands of the British Isles, and many other regions, there are equally ancient crystalline rocks. In no part of Siluria and Wales, however, are there any rocks of more remote age than the oldest greywacke in which no fossils are known. The pre-existing masses, out of whose materials the pebble- beds, sandstones, and schists of the Longmynd in Shropshire, and of the Llanberis and Harlech mountains in North Wales were formed, have either subsided and disappeared, or have been covered over by the strata under consideration. For, it is now ascertained that the schists of Anglesea, which from their crystalline character were once supposed to be more ancient than any other rocks of Wales, are simply an altered part of the same greywacke which constitutes the base of the Silurian series of deposits in the adjacent counties of Carnarvon and Merioneth. In other words, the old slate and greywacke of An- glesea have been altered at one spot into chlorite and mica-schist, e 4 24 SILUKIA. [Chap. II. in another into quartz rock. Agreeing with Sir H. De la Beche and the government geological surveyors, that this is the best ex- planation of the case, a small sketch is here annexed, to indicate the amount of curvature which these metamorphosed strata have undergone, as seen at the promontory of the South Stack Light- house, near Holyhead. Contorted Schists at the South Stack Lighthouse, Anglesea. These contorted, crystalline rocks of Anglesea, with their intruded granites, are associated with stripes or patches, capriciously dis- tributed as it were, of different palafeozoic rocks, of Silurian, Devo- nian, and Carboniferous age, thus forming a sort of kaleidoscope, which the most experienced geologist might have difficulty in un- ravelling; the outlines of which, formerly laid down in Green- ough's Map of England, are now very accurately detailed in the sheets of the Government Survey The whole of the bands have a CHA.P. IL] LONGMYND OR BOTTOM ROCKS. 25 direction or strike from S. S. W. to N. N.E., as may be seen in the annexed map. No sooner, however, do we pass the Menai Straits, and advance eastwards towards the west flank of the mountainous range of Snow- don, than we find huge buttresses of very ancient grey wacke grit, schist, slate, and sandstone, having the same direction, from S. S. W. to N. N. E., in which, though their sedimentary character is obvious, and that they have not been altered as in Anglesea, no fossils have been detected through a thickness of many thousand feet. These are the true representatives of the Longmynd or bottom rocks of this work, and of which the crystalline schists of Anglesea are me- tamorphosed members. In other words, these unfossiliferous slaty rocks of North Wales, with their sandstones and grits, are now proved to be the equivalents of the strata of the Longmynd and Haughmond Hills, which were formerly described by me as types of that greywacke, which in Shropshire rises from beneath all the formations containing fossils of the Silurian system. (See section below the map.) It is to these lowest known sedimentary rocks, whether in the Silurian region or in North AVales, that the government surveyors have restricted the term " Cambrian ; " simply implying thereby, not that fossils may not be found in them, but that hitherto no traces of the Silurian forms have been detected in them. But such an ap- plication of Cambrian is not used in this work, because, when in- troduced by Professor Sedgwick, the term was employed, both by him and myself, as applying to a vast succession of fossiliferous strata, containing undescribed fossils, the whole of which were supposed to rise up from beneath the well-known Lower Silurian rocks. The government geologists have shown that this supposed order of infra- position was erroneous, and that all the fossiliferous rocks of North Wales, which had been called Cambrian before their included fossils were described, are physically the same strata as those which 26 SILURIA. [Chap, II. had been laid down as Lower Silurian on the immediate west flank of the fundamental rocks of the Longmynd. Naturally, therefore, these North Welsh or so-called Cambrian rocks have been found to be charged with Lower Silurian fossils. As the same authorities have thus recurred to the original typical tracts of Shropshire, a few words must here be said to explain the structure of that northern portion of Siluria, as laid down in my ori- ginal map and sections, with which the Cambria of Sedgwick has been so clearly placed in parallel. The reader who desires to peruse a full description of these ancient rocks of the Longmynd, which form the mineral axis of Shropshire and Montgomeryshire, and are there seen to rise out from beneath all the fossil-bearing strata, may consult the 21st chapter of the Silurian System," which is exclusively devoted to them and their associated igneous (trap) rocks as seen in the hills of Longmynd, Haughmond, Ratlinghope, Linley, Pontesford, Lyth, &c. To that description I have little or nothing to add, nor am I aware of any correction required to be made in it. The rocks remain still the unfossiliferous bottom beds they were then described to be. Though attaining only a height of about 1600 feet above the The Longmynd. Caer Caradoc. Wenlock Edge. Olee Hills. sea, they are of mountainous character, presenting a very ancient aspect, and the woodcut annexed gives some idea of their forms. Chap. TI.] LONGMYND OR BOTTOM ROCKS. 27 In this view the spectator is looking through one of the depressions of the Longmynd, locally called " gutters," to the tract diversified by the ridge of Caer Caradoc with the Wenlock Edge and Clee Hills in the distance. In the Longmynd, and adjacent hills between that mountain and the Stiper Stones, these elder rocks are exposed in an enormous thickness of about 26,000 feet, of dark imperfect slates and grey schistose strata, with coarse, purplish, ferruginous grit or sandstone, and conglomerate.* According to the government surveyors, who have compared them, these Longmynd rocks are of much more than double the dimensions of strata of like age and position in North "Wales ; and hence they are truly the bottom rocks of the whole region. Striking from S.S.W. to N.N.E., these strata have not afforded the trace of a fossil, after long and assiduous researches. They are vertical in the eastern or slaty portion, and in their western parts, or in the contiguous hills of Ratlinghope, &c., they dip at a very high angle to the W.N.W., under the perfectly parallel bands of schist and grit of the Stiper Stones, which are now classed in the government maps and sections as the lowest Silurian rocks of the region. This succession, which is delineated on a small scale in the section below the map, is sufficiently exhibited in the long * The manner in which certain cavities of these rocks are filled with bitumen, and the veins of copper ores which they contain near the junction of the intrusive rocks, are facts worthy of attention ; it being remembered, however, that these mineral changes were produced very long after the consolidation of such ancient greywacke strata. The same copper veins, i7, also penetrate the sandstone and 3 V 1 limestone with Pentamerus oblongus, 3, which rest unconformably upon the older slates, 1, of the Longmynd, as in this diagram, taken from Sil. Syst., pi. 32. f. 4. 28 SILURIA. [Chap. II. diagram on the opposite page (1). Then follow, in parallel masses, about 14,000 feet thick, the schists of the mining tract of Shelve and Corndon, in which Llandeilo flags, and true Lower Silurian strata, are replete with characteristic fossils (2 of section). In this manner, the conformable succession from an unfossiliferous base, high up into the Llandeilo flags inclusive, is seen in this district of the region originally illustrated by myself. The accom- panying woodcut is, indeed, merely a copy of coloured diagrams representing this order, which were made in the year 1833, and which, having been exhibited to the Geological Society of London, were afterwards published, 1839, in the " Silurian System." * Now, the researches of the last few years, on the part of the government surveyors, have shown that the strata which occupy the loftier mountains of North "Wales, ranging from Snowdon to Bala, are of the same age as these under consideration, which extend from the Shelve and Corndon tract to the Stiper Stones and there rest upon the Longmynd. In other words, the fossiliferous rocks originally described as Lower Silurian types, whether in Shrop- shire and Montgomeryshire, or in South Wales near Llandeilo, have been so clearly unfolded as to prove that they occupy the greater portion of North Wales. The generalized coloured section at the bottom of the geological map annexed, which has been prepared for me by Professor Ramsay, who with his associates Aveline and Selwyn established this im- portant conclusion, will at once render the subject intelligible to every reader ; and my own original detailed section, as given on the next page, completes the comparison. In the two buttresses of the earliest or unfossiliferous greywacke, of the Longmynd on the east, and of Llanberis and Harlech on the west, are represented, therefore, the oldest sedimentary rocks of England and Wales. (See map and coloured section.) * Silurian System, pi. 32. fig. 1. et seq. Chap. II.] SECTION FROM THE LONGMYNT), WESTWARDS. 30 SILURIA. [Chap. II. In fact, these masses constitute, in Wales as in Shropshire, the natural base of the lowest fossil-bearing strata, 2% to which in Britain they are every where conformable, and into which they gradually pass upwards. These first steps in the geological series, which the reader is about to ascend, may be further illustrated by the accompanying pictorial illustration from North Wales. Pass of Llanbekis from the Lower Lake. In this well known scene the spectator is supposed to be looking up to the Pass of Llanberis, from the lower lake of that name, the heights of Snowdon being in the distance on the right hand. In the foreground, and on both sides of the ruined castle of Dolbadarn, the faces of the cliffs exhibit flexures of the oldest strata here visible. These are • the purplish and grey slaty rocks, 1, of the previous section, whose structure and relations in North Wales were formerly so well de- scribed by Professor Sedgwick. Containing the best roofing slates in Chap. II.] BOTTOM ROCKS IN IRELAND. 31 the world*, and subordinate courses of greywacke grit, with rocks of igneous origin intermixed, they are seen to fold over and plunge to the east-south-east, so as to pass under the great and mas- sive succession of schists which constitute the distant heights of the Snowdon range. The reader will observe that faint slanting lines have been introduced into the drawing to represent this ascending order, which the geologist can observe for himself, as he examines the sides of the valley in passing from the unfossiliferous slaty rocks of Llanberis, up to the overlying strata of Snowdon (2% 2 of section below the map), which, by their imbedded organic remains, are known to be of Llandeilo age. In short, the rocks in the foreground stand in the place of the Longmynd, whilst the overlying or distant masses are the equivalents of the rocks of the Stiper Stones, Shelve and Corndon of the previous section, p. 29. A similar succession is visible at Barmouth and other places in North Wales, as will hereafter be noticed. Whilst, however, the lowest rocks of Shropshire and Wales are void of fossils, it must here be noticed, that in Ireland and im- mediately opposite to Anglesea and Carnarvon, rocks of precisely the same mineral characters, and occupying the same place in the geological series, have afforded two species of a peculiar zoophyte. The government surveyors have decided (and after two personal inspections of the ground, I quite agree with them,) that the purple and greenish greywacke of Bray Head, near Dublin, to which the * The best slates lie in the masses to the left hand of the foreground, and are the property of my friend Mr. T. Assheton Smith. Thence they range to the quar- ries of Colonel Douglas Pennant, M.P., on the N.N.E. A very instructive dia- gram, representing the curves of the original strata, at Llanberis, and the man- ner in which they are traversed by planes of slaty cleavage, is given by Profes- sor Sedgwick, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. iii. p. 138. For a correct ac- quaintance with all the faults and fractures of these rocks, the geologist will, of course, consult the subsequently published maps and sections of the government surveyors. 32 SILURIA. [Chap. II. quartz rock of the great and lesser Sugar Loaf is subordinate, cor- responds exactly to the oldest buttresses of the opposite mountains in Wales, and which form the foreground in the preceding sketch. It is in this ancient Irish grey wacke that a very peculiar fossil zoophyte was detected by Professor Oldham, and named after him by Professor E. Forbes. The Oldhamia is a polype of which two species have been detected, and one of them is here given. Fossils, 1. Oldhamia antiqua, from Bray Head, Ireland. The reader may look with reverence on this zoophyte ; for not- withstanding the most assiduous researches, it is the only animal relic yet known in this very low stage of unequivocal sedimentary matter. The term azoic cannot therefore be applied to the Irish rocks of the same age as those which in England and Wales have afforded no such traces of life. A zoological reason is, however, added to the phy- sical arguments above offered, for considering these very ancient de- posits as simply the base of the oldest known series of former beings. Returning then from Ireland, to the region of Siluria and Wales, in whose bottom rocks no fossils have been found, it will be seen by reference to the map, that of the strata containing Silurian organic remains, the lowest bands, or 2, 3, are most spread out on the west or Welsh side, the upper group, or 4, 5, on the English or original Silurian frontier. In great part of South Wales, or in nearly all the hilly region to the S. of Cader Idris, as bounded by the sea on the west. Lower Chap. II.] OLDEST SLATY ROCKS OF NORTH WALES. 33 Silurian rocks only prevail. There also, as in North Wales, they roll over in undulations with a general direction in some parts from N.N.E. to S.S.W., in others from N.E. to S.W.; the dip or in- clination of the strata varying necessarily with each of their great folds. In the south-western parts of Montgomery and Radnor, as well as in Cardigan, and a large portion of Carmarthen, they are much less associated with igneous rocks than in Merioneth and Carnarvon on the one side, or in western Shropshire or eastern Radnorshire on the other. In the three last-mentioned tracts. Lower Silurian rocks are interstratified with felspathic trap; whilst pro- jections of rock of irregular forms have burst through all the sediments at a later period. Viewed in this general sense, and excepting the few oases consisting of the older and unfossiliferous base, all the western region of Wales (excluding the old red sand- stone and carboniferous deposits at its northern and southern ex- tremities) consists of Silurian rocks. (See map.) Let us now make a rapid traverse of the whole region from the higher Welsh mountains to Montgomeryshire and the border English counties of Salop and Hereford, where, as above stated, the Silurian types were first described. The lowest rocks of Carnarvonshire, already adverted to, are much more slaty than those of the same age in the Longmynd of Shropshire. Though it is not compatible with the nature of this work to expatiate upon the structure in rocks called slaty cleavage, I may state that it is a crystalline determination and arrangement of the fine particles of mud of which the rocks were originally composed, into a countless number of thin plates precisely parallel to each other, and which usually cutting across the original lines of deposit, indicate (when observable) the true bedding or stra- tification. The following woodcut will serve to explain the slaty cleavage of rocks as distinguished from the original layers or laminae of deposit. D 34 SILURIA. [Chap. II. This remarkable physical feature of cleavage, which in former days was often mistaken for the true beds of the rocks, is often persistent b h h h Slaty Cleavage and Bedding. a. Strata or beds in undulation, b. Lines of cleavage. (The dark tint represents the portions of a mountain in which the layers of deposit and lines of cleavage coincide.) From Sil. Syst. p. 400. through great portions of a mountain-chain, and those who wish to be better acquainted with it, must consult the admirable memoir of Sedg- wick*, who first threw a clear light upon the phenomena, and referred them to some great chemical change which heat and electricity probably combined to produce. The strata, however, I remind the reader, which are now found in this fine and crystalline state, were at one period nothing more than accumulations of mud ; and there are still parts of the world, as in Russia, where, unaffected by any changes, they have remained almost in their primeval, muddy, and unsolidified condition up to the present day. It is sufficient on this occasion to say, that their crystalline struc- ture, as seen in Wales, and as indicated by the highly inclined lines, of the preceding diagram, was impressed upon the strata or undulating layers, «, very long after their accumulation as submarine mud, and even after they had been subjected to curvatures, as above indicated. Such a cleavage, prevailing at intervals from the lowest unfossiliferous greywacke or bottom rock through the Silurian system, is seen in * See particularly Professor Sedgwick's Memoir on the Structure of large Mineral Masses, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond., N. S. vol. iii. p. 461. Chap. II.] LOWEST FOSSILIPEROUS ZONE. 35 parts of other overlying palaeozoic formations. In all the instances of its occurrence in fossiliferous strata, the separation of the original lines of bedding from the plates of cleavage is naturally much more easy where fossil shells occur * along the layers of deposit, than in those oldest, unfossiliferous, and finely levigated sediments, in which the beds are often only distinguishable by the different colours in the same slaty mass. In all other diagrams or sections used in this work, young geolo- gists must understand, that the divisional lines represent the layers or laminae of true beds as originally and successively formed by depo- sition under water. It is by long and patient labours in the mountains, and by following the curvatures and breaks of these lines of deposit, that the whole symmetry of the rocks has been determined, in spite, as it were, of the obscurities produced by slaty cleavage (which occurs more or less in all the North Welsh Silurian rocks), and also by the interpolation of igneous rocks of various characters. From this allusion to an important physical feature, by which many ancient rocks of different epochs which were originally composed of fine mud have been more or less affected, and particularly in Britain, we must return to the natural order of succession as read off in the earlier pages of primeval history. Lowest zone of animal life in Great Britain. — Near the two ex- tremities of the coloured section of the map, or in Shropshire, on the one hand, and near the Menai Straits on the other, the lowest zone in which any vestiges of former life are discoverable consists of the schists and sandstones, 2% which overlie the unfossiliferous strata, 1, above described. On the west flank of the Longmynd of Shrop- shire, these schists, though of some thickness, are only imperfectly * The reader who would well understand how fossil shells have been distorted by the action which produced the cleavage, must consult an able memoir of Mr D. Sharpe, Quarterly Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. iii. p. 74. See the example of a distorted trilobite in this work, chap. 8. p. 201. 36 SILURIA. [Chap. II. developed in a valley of denudation, and in the slopes between it and the singular quartz rocks called the Stiper Stones. There the lowest beds have only been found to contain fucoids and a rare graptolite, a genus of zoophyte which, as will hereafter be seen, characterizes the Silurian strata from their beginning to their close. Although the section at page 29, which passes from the Long- mynd on the E.S.E. to the mining country of Shelve on the W.N.W. across the quartzose ridge of the Stiper Stones*, will convey a general idea of the succession, the lover of nature f, as well as the geologist, will recognize in the Stiper Stones, objects well worthy of a visit and a close examination. These rocks are made up of a number of broken and serrated ledges jutting out from beneath the heath and turf f, like rugged Cyclopean ruins, to form the summits of the hills which flank the mining district of Shelve, at heights varying from 1500 to 1600 feet above the sea. They are sandstones, which in the highest parts of the ridge have been considerably altered, probably by the former action of the heat evolved during the protrusion of those igneous rocks which abound in the adjacent hills. The first of these sketches represents the general range of these protruding rocks, as seen on their western faces, where they dip at a * It is also worthy of remark, that in the long transverse section below the map, extending in a right line over 90 miles of country, the lowest rocks, near each ex- tremity, are accompanied by much mineralization of the strata. In both, copper and lead veinstones occur, and in parts of Merionethshire gold also occurs in small quantities. These auriferous conditions of the Lower SUurian and other pa- laeozoic rocks will be explained in chap. 16. f The northern summit and slope of one of the elevations of the Stiper Stones (called Bleak Hill in the Ordnance maps), is covered with a forest of holly trees of great size. These hard, old, indigenous tenants of the soil, defying all cold blasts, are appropriate emblems of the extreme antiquity of the rocks of this mountain. The views of the Stiper Stones on the next page are taken from the Silurian System, pp. 268, 282. I See map and sections of the Silurian System, and p. 268. of that work. Chap. II.] THE STIPER STONES. 37 high angle under the schists of the Llandeilo formation, the low country of northern Shropshire being seen in the distance. The Western Face of the Stiper Stones. In the following sketch, on the contrary, the spectator is supposed to be looking southwards along the eastern escarpments of these broken rocks, the hills of Linley being in the distance ; on the left The Eastern Face of the Stiper Stones. In this case the strata dip to the right hand of the spectator, whilst in the preceding sketch they dip to the left. In the upper view the spectator is looking to the N. N.E. ; in the lower to the S. S. W. hand is the valley which has been excavated in the shale which lies between the Longmynd and these Silurian sandstones. D 3 38 SILURIA. [Chap. II. In following these quartzose rocks in their strike from the cul- miating points of the Stiper Stones to the Nils Hill quarries near Pon- tesbury, on the N.N.E., we find the strata gradually assuming the ordinary character of a sandstone and pebbly grit, the beds of which are ocasionally separated by shale occasionally greenish and steatitic. On the surfaces of some of these beds are ripple-marks, so common in all arenaceous deposits which have been formed under water, and also branching raised casts, strongly indicative of organic origin. Some of these are certainly the forms of fucoids which were deposited on an ancient sea-shore or bottom. The rock so characterised is, indeed, very analogous to the lowest sedimentary stratum in Sweden, which there lies at the base of the fossil series of deposits, and which, from its exposing similar forms, was, in another work, called the fucoid sandstone."* In Shropshire, small flakes of anthracite occur, though rarely, in the joints and cavities of these silicious sandstones; and this substance, we may very rationally infer, might have resulted from the conversion into carbon of the original sea-weeds whose casts are still visible in the sandstone. This remarkable ledge of the Stiper Stones, with its underlying schists, a fuller description of which must be sought in the " Silurian System," constitutes, as it were, a divisionary band between the ferruginous, unfossiliferous greywacke of the liongmynd, 1, with its copper veins on the one hand, and the lead-bearing, fossiliferous Lower Silurian schists and sandstones, 2% 2, of Shelve and Corndon on the other. The strata that repose conformably on the silicious grits of the Stiper Stones (see long section, p. 29.) are flagstones, which, weathering to a rusty brown colour, exhibit an internal texture and colour resembling usual forms of greywacke in many countries. They are well exposed, in a vast succession, in highly inclined ledges, dip- ping about 55° to the W.N. W., on the north side of the deep transverse combe of Mytton's Dingle. Their surfaces are also marked * Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 16. ; Sil. Syst. p. 285. Chap. II.] W. SHROPSHIRE AND N, WALES IDENTIFIED. 39 by casts of fucoids; but I have been unable to detect other fossils in them, though they pass up into and form an integral part of the Llandeilo formation. The next overlying strata, which are spread out in undulations over the mining tract of Shelve, are black schists, with occasional bands of earthy sandstone, in parts calcareous and light coloured. These form the chief mass of the Llandeilo formation, with its numerous graptolites, trilobites, moUusks, and other fossils, and will be treated of hereafter. (See section, p. 29.) Miniature as it is by comparison with North Wales, this tract of the Stiper Stones and Shelve, which, with a description of its fossils, was formerly described and mapped as Lower Silurian, and which extends from Shropshire into Montgomeryshire, is, I repeat, now determined to be the geological prototype of the grander undulations of the same rocks, which spread out over so large a portion of the principality of Wales. But whilst the strata in the escarpment of the Stiper Stones have afforded little more than casts of fucoids, and traces of graptolites*, certain districts in North Wales contain remains which mark more definitely the lowest known, shelly band in the British Isles. On the lower flanks both of Snowdon and Cader Idris, where they dip away from the above-mentioned subjacent greywacke grits and slates (the No. 1 of the section), these strata consist of schists, with glossy surfaces of lightish and dark grey and black colours. Occasionally they are much laden with crystallised iron pyrites, and interstratified with felspathic ash-beds or volcanic grit, sometimes calcareous, which proceeded from submarine volcanoes. In this region, such eruptions, of which more notice will be taken in the sequel, have considerably expanded the dimensions of the whole series of beds, whilst here and there irregular and projecting bosses * The Cruziana of the Welsh Lingula beds, p. 42, has also just been detected at the Stiper Stones by Mr. Salter. D 4 40 SILURIA. [Chap. II. of eruptive igneous rock, that have since broken through the strata, have greatly diversified the surface of the country. Still, there are many spots near Harlech, Tremadoc, Llanberis, &c., where the most perfectly conformable and equable passage from lower unfossiliferous schist and grit to the beds under consideration are seen. This, for example, is the succession at Barmouth. a 6 6 b. Lingula Schists with imperfect slaty cleavage. a. Grits and Schists, or Longmynd and bottom rocks. The fossil remains of this primeval zone of life in N. Wales consist notably of the flat bivalve shell, the Lingula, of which ex- amples are here and there to be seen, as on the flanks of Cader Idris and near Tremadoc. It is worthy of remark, that the covering of this animal, as repre- sented f. 1. of the following woodcut, is very horny, and only slightly calcareous ; showing that its inhabitant was suited to the conditions of a sea whose bottom was composed of mud and sand, and which contained little or no lime wherewith to supply the fabric of a thicker shell. It is, indeed, a remarkable fact, that in the vast thicknesses of the inferior or unfossiliferous greywacke before ad- verted to, there is scarcely any lime, and not a trace of a shell ; whilst in these the lowest strata in which calcareous matter is visible, it has only occurred in such small quantities as to afford a very thin testaceous covering to the few animals of this early zone of life. We shall presently see that when the Silurian fauna became abundant, as in the next overlying strata, it was accompanied by a corresponding development of lime which served as the pabulum for the construction of the shells of the imbedded mollusks. In ascending through the different stages of the Silurian system, it will also be seen, that different species of the genus Lingula occurred Chap. II.] LINGULA FLAGS OF N. WALES. 41 most frequently at those intervals in which there was a return to similar sedimentary conditions, L e, whenever the original, muddy sea-bottom was only slightly impregnated with lime. Eeverting to the original typical district of Shropshire, it must be remarked, that the beds immediately underlying the sandstones and quartz rocks of the Stiper Stones, and which stand in the place of the Lingula flags of Wales, are similar in composition to many strata which pervade the whole Silurian system. They are dark grey, fine- grained schists, occasionally containing a little mica, which either exfoliate in rude concretions, or split up into shivery and irregular fragments; the whole mass rapidly decomposing by atmospheric action, and returning into its original state of mud. It is this pre- valent character of large portions of the Silurian rocks, particularly where they have not been intruded upon by igneous matter, or subjected to a slaty cleavage, which led me to apply the term " mudstones " so generally to them. And it is therefore specially to be remembered, that at the foot of the escarpment of the Stiper Stones, or at the base of every thing which contains Silurian fossils, this class of rock prevails. In the mean time it is to. be noted, that a form of Lingula nearly identical with that of North Wales, is also characteristic of the lowest Silurian rock of North America (the Potsdam sandstone). The genus has indeed lived on from the Silurian or primeval days to the present time, though its former associates, the graptolites and trilobites, vanished long ago from the world. The latter, or the earliest crustaceans, abound infinitely more in the Silurian than in the next overlying system of rocks, and of them the earliest which the labours of geologists have brought to light in Britain are the little Olenus and Paradoxides*, one species of the first-mentioned * One species of Paradoxides, p. 43. Foss. 4. (locality unknown) has been found in North Wales, and, although very imperfect, Mr. Salter believes it identical with P. Forchhammeri, of the alum slates of Andrarum in Scania. 42 SILURIA. [CnAP. 11. genus, O. micrurus, Foss. 2. f. 2., having been found associated with the Lingula in this primordial zone as it appears in Wales. Fossils, 2. 1. Lingula Davisii, M'Coy. 2. Olenus micrurus, Salter. Lingula Flags, North Wales. In addition to the Lingula and Olenus, the government surveyors have lately detected a new crustacean of the Phyllopod tribe near Dolgelly, — Hymenocaris vermicauda, Salter. In beds of the same age near Bangor, there have been also found two kinds of fucoid, one of which is the Chondrites acutangulus, M'Coy, and a new species of the curious genus Cruziana (Bilobites, D'Orbigny). The above- mentioned fucoid. Chondrites, is the same species as Professor Sedgwick found in the Skiddaw slate of Cumberland, where it is associated with the Palaeochorda, M'Coy, another genus of fucoids, and with the Graptolites latus. A figure is here given of the Fossils, 3. Hymenocaris vermicauda, Salter. Lingula Flags, Dolgell}-. Hymenocaris vermicauda, from specimens in the collection of the Geological Survey. It occurs plentifully at Dolgelly and Tremadoc, in North Wales, associated with Lingula Davisii, and is therefore a true primordial fossil. Ohap. II.] LOWEST SILURIAN FOSSILS IN WALES, ETC. 43 Fossils, 4. Paradoxides Forchhammeri, Angelin. ? Black Schists of North Wales. The small Olenus is found in the lowest known fossil strata of another British tract. In the black schists on the western flanks of the Malvern Hills, strata which I had termed Lower Silurian, Pro- fessor Phillips detected three species of this genus, viz. O. humilis, W. 5. f. 1. ; O. bisulcatus, f. 2.; 0. scarabaeoides (O. spinulosus. Ph.), f. 3. To these my friend Mr. Hugh Strickland has recently Olenus humilis, Ph. 2. 0. bisulcatus, Ph. hd^^^~^)=i l^^^^* Trilobites from the black schists 3. O. scarabaeoides, Wahl. ? >=^;^^ 2 »^^"^ of the Malverns. 4. Agnostus pisiformis, Brongn. made the interesting addition of the Agnostus pisiformis, Brongn., Foss. 5. f. 4., a fossil only known in the oldest Silurian schists or alum slates of Sweden, of which hereafter. Associated with the Grap- tolite, the Olenus is also found in the same fossiliferous stratum of Scandinavia, which rests on a sandstone in which no other remains have been detected except fucoids, and is made up of the detritus of the subjacent crystalline rocks. Again, the Olenus occurs in Bohemia in the same or lowest horizon of life, and under 44 SILURIA. [Chap. IL similar conditions ; and also associated, as in Sweden, with Agnostus, Paradoxides, and other trilobites, several of which have not yet been discovered traces in our island.* (See chap. 13.) Let it not, however, be supposed, that fossil shelly remains occur in any notable quantity in this the lowest stratum in which they are known in Wales or England. On the contrary, the collections in the instructive public Museum of the Geological Survey teach us how very rare are the species which the labours of a series of years have been able to detect ; and the student who may explore the North Welsh mountains, will duly appreciate the industry that has been required to gather together even these few primordial relics. The Lingulae were first discovered by Mr. Davis in the year 1846, and termed by him Silurian fossils, f In Bohemia, Sweden, and America, as will hereafter be noticed, trilobites are, however, more plentiful in this zone. In the following chapter the reader will be introduced to strata containing the chief mass of the Lower Silurian animals, some of which are similar in kind to the few crustaceans, moUusks, and graptolites already alluded to, but with very numerous additions of genera and species, in these, as well as in other classes; represent- ing, in fact> nearly every known family of submarine beings except fishes. * See the admirable work of M. Barrande, " Le Bassin Silurien de Bolieme" — a monument of the talent and perseverance of the French author, in a foreign land, and one of the most remarkable monographs of our age. The first part only has appeared, in which the numerous trilobites are completely described. ■j- See Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. ii. p. 70. The rocks of that tract had, however, been described at a much earlier period by Professor Sedgwick, who, though he did not detect these fossils, has shown in a subsequent memoir the exact relations of these Tremadoc slates to the subjacent strata of Trawsfynydd and the overlying slates and igneous rocks of Festiniog and Moel-Wyn. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. iii. p. 143. 45 CHAPTEE III. LOWER SILURIAN ROCKS — continued, THE LLANBEILO FORMATION, ITS SLATES, SCHISTS, SANDSTONES, LIMESTONES, AND INTERPOLATED IGNEOUS ROCKS. (2^ AND 2 OF MAP AND COLOURED SECTIONS.) Throughout the northern part of the Silurian region, and the tracts of North Wales already mentioned, the rocks to be described in this chapter have the same direction as the older schists and grey- wacke on which they rest. The direction of the Longmynd from S. S. W. to N. N.E. has, in fact, been impressed on the whole of the Llandeilo formation, the beds of which are perfectly conformable to and graduate downwards into those of the older rocks. (See map and sect, p. 29). In the Silurian region, and in North Wales, as exhibited in the general section below the map, 29, the Lingula zone, described in the last chapter, is surmounted by thick masses of schist, 2, which, with much interpolated igneous matter, pass up into and constitute the lower part of the Llandeilo formation. These relations of super- position will be more clearly understood by referring to the sections across the northern parts of the Silurian region, as formerly described by myself.* There, whether near Shelve in Shropshire, or at Llandrindod, Llandegley, and Builth in Radnor, these strata are often interlaced with conformable sheets of contemporaneous igneous matter, which I termed volcanic grits.f They are also broken up by the intrusion * See Silurian System, pp. 268. and 324. As early as the year 1833, 1 described the Llandeilo formation, then termed black trilobite flagstones, as being of more copious development than the overlying deposits. Proc. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. i. p. 476. t The " volcanic ash " of Sir Henry de la Beche and the government surveyors. 46 SILURIA. [Chap. III. of great bands of greenstone, porphyry, and other eruptive rocks. In North Wales, the same deposits are not only to a greater extent similarly aifected by igneous matter, but are also, as before said, much more slaty. The mineral feature, however, by which the upper mass of the for- mation, whether slaty or not, is most distinguished from the strata which preceded it, is in the occasional presence of lime, particularly towards its central portion, where some of the schists, flagstones, and shale become calcareous, and in parts pass into limestone, as at Llandeilo in Carmarthenshire, Llampeter Felfrey in Pembrokeshire, and Bala in Merionethshire. In the lower or schistose parts, where very little calcareous matter is visible, and nearly every bed is argillaceous, the fossils called graptolites most prevail. This genus of zoophyte is supposed by many naturalists to have been nearly allied to the living Vir- gularia, a creature known only in deep seas. Others rather con- sider these extinct forms to belong to corallines or Sertularia. Be this as it may, the geologist has observed that they are, for the most part, found in beds of muddy origin, and exclusively in the Silurian or earliest known system of fossil animal life. The whole group of Fossils, 6. Lower SiLURiAi>r Graptolites. 1. Rastrites peregrinus, Barr. 2. Graptolites Sedgwicki, Portl, 3. G. priodon, Bronn. (G. Lu- densis, Sil. Syst. 4. Diplograpsus pristis, Hising. 5. D, nodosus, Harkness. 6. D. folixxm, Hising. T. D. ramosus, HalL 8. Didymograpsus sextans, Hall. 9. D. Murchisonse SiL Syst. these little serrated creatures has been called Graptolithina, and has been divided into about four genera, as represented in this woodcut. Chap. III.] CHIEF POSITION OP GRAPTOLITES. 47 One of these, the Diplograpsus, M^Coy, f. 4, 5, 6., is distinguished by having double sides like a leaf. A second, Graptolites of Lin- naeus, f. 2, 3., has teeth or serrae on one side only. A third, Kastrites, Barrande, f. 1., has teeth placed like the last, but not so crowded together. There are other branched forms, f. 8, 9., for which the name of Didymograpsus has been proposed, and one of which, the D. Murchisonge, f 9., is the most characteristic fossil of the black shales of the Llandeilo flags of Wales : it has also been found on the continent. Some of these forms are figured on our PI. 12. f. 1. The Diplograpsus, or doubly serrated forms, are chiefly character- istic of the Lower Silurian rocks ; D. pristis, f. 8., and D. foliaceus, PI. 12, f. 2., being the ordinary forms, whilst the one-sided species extend from the Lower to the Upper Silurian. In no palaeozoic rock younger than the Silurian is the true graptolite known, and hence, as types, they are most important to the practical geologist, who, in exploring many tracts of this age in Cumberland, the southern counties of Scotland, Ireland, Central Germany*, &c., meets with scarcely any other fossils. In Sweden, indeed, grap- tolites and fucoids so abound, as to have given a highly bituminous character to the lower strata, which, being also largely impregnated with iron pyrites, has aflbrded so much alum as to have procured for the strata the name of Alum slates. The graptolite also occurs copiously, in the Silurian region of Britain, and in Sweden, Norway, and Bohemia, in the shales of the Upper Silurian rocks. Whilst, how^ever, the mere presence of a true graptolite will at once decide that the rock in which it occurs is Silurian, it is only by finding the genera of these animals which display a double set * Dr. Beck, of Copenhagen, assisted me in describing the few species of grapto- lite published in the Silurian System. M. Barrande has published a most elaborate and valuable treatise on the Graptolites of his Silurian Basin of Bohemia. Dr. Geinitz has systematised all the known forms of graptolites in a work, illustrated by clear and beautiful drawings, entiled, " Die Versteinerungen der Grauwacken Formation in Sachsen." Leipsic, 1852. 48 SILURIA. [Chap. III. of serratures In the same species, that, in the absence of signs of the order of superposition, the field observer may presume he is examining the lower division of the system. Deferring for a moment the consideration of the pseudo-volcanic or igneous rocks, which in some districts characterize the schists last spoken of, let us first take a glance at the great mass of the Lower Silurian rocks, as distinguished by very many organic forms, most of which wilJ be treated of hereafter. (See chap. 8. and plates 1. to 11.) This great group was long ago described in the Silurian region, as made up of Llandeilo schists and flags beneath, and of Caradoc sandstone above ; the names having been taken from the localities where each formation was, as it was thought, most characteristically developed. But, even in 1835, I specially cautioned geologists not to attach im- portance to the character implied by the names of flagstone or sand- stone, for I well knew that such mineral features were partial and evanescent even in my own region, and must necessarily prove much more so in distant countries. The survey of Siluria alone had taught me, that the schistose and slaty beds of one tract became sandy in their extension, or vice versa, and that the same courses which are so calcareous in some districts as to constitute limestone, were mere schists and flagstones in another. Hence I held to the rule, that in studying the primeval, as well as medieval or secondary and tertiary formations, the zoological contents of rocks, when coupled with their order of superposition, were the only safe criteria of their age. In proceeding from the primordial zone described in the last chapter, to younger formations, we find that, in the British Isles at least, calcareous matter, doubtless formerly supplied from subterranean sources, increases upwards, and with it the number of fossil animals.* * The observation in the text is only intended to apply to the number of animal remains found in the lowest formation in which there is any notable quan- tity of lime, by comparison with the subjacent strata where it is not perceptible. The fact, however, of the increase of limestone as the formations become newer, is generally true. Thus, no course of the limestone near Bala exceeds twenty or Chap. III.] LLANDEILO LIMESTONE. 49 At and near Llandeilo, the formation under review chiefly consists of calcareous flags, having a great thickness of schists below them, and sandy and gritty strata above them; but in following the deposit into Pembrokeshire, the calcareous portion is enriched, and becomes in some places, as at Llampeter Felfrey and Llandewi Felfrey, a copious mass of dark subcrystalline limestone with white veins. These rocks, which are there, as elsewhere, underlaid and overlaid by a great thickness of black schist, are thus represented in a section of the government surveyors, little differing from one I formerly published. Section at Llandewi Felfkey, Pembrokeshire. S.S.E. 'N.N.W. d c b'^ 62 b 62 b. Llandeilo schists and limestones, h'^. e. Overlying Silurian rocks, d. Old Eed Sandstone. The contiguity of the Llandeilo formation to the Old Red Sandstone, and the tenuity of all the interjacent Silurian strata, will be explained hereafter. Again, the very same formation as developed in Radnorshire (Builth to the Gelli Hills near Llandrindod), is chiefly schistose and flaggy, with comparatively little lime disseminated, and such also is its composition in. the districts of Corndon and Shelve in Shropshire. The distribution of the limestone is equally irregular and uncertain in those tracts of North Wales which Professor Sedgwick so long explored. The limestone, for example, is visible near Bala, though, from its impure character, it is now no longer worked for use. But on its strike to the N. N. E. or to the S. S. W., it soon dwindles to so insignificant a course, that its position can only be detected by the thirty feet in thickness, and even the same strata in Carmarthen and Pembroke are not more than double those dimensions. The Woolhope, or lowest Wenlock limestone (see chapter 6.), has, probably, about a maximum thickness of twenty-five feet. The chief Wenlock limestone is, in some places, more than a hundred feet thick, and the limestones of South Devon are, perhaps, twice that magnitude ; whilst the carboniferous or mountain limestone is vastly thicker than any of the older calcareous rocks of Britain. E 50 SILURIA. [Chap. III. occasional presence of some of its fossils. A reference to the map at once indicates how this limestone wedges out and disappears a few miles to the south of Bala, thus leaving all the region between North Wales and Carmarthenshire void of any such rock. But besides this Llandeilo limestone, other shreds of calcareous matter are discernible at intervals in the ascending order. One of these, or the Hirnant limestone of Merioneth, a still thinner and more partial course described by Professor Sedgwick, is, probably, on the parallel with certain calcareous bands described by me as occurring near Meifod in Montgomeryshire, and mapped as Llandeilo rocks by the government geologists. To the north-west of Meifod these sand- stones and schists, with partial limestones, seemed to me to repose on flagstones^with the Asaphus tyrannus, as exhibited on the banks of the river Twrch, and described in my old sections. (See Sil. Syst., p. 307. and pi. 32. f. 9.) From their mineral character, I formerly connected the Meifod rocks with the next overlying formation. Their separation from the Caradoc depends upon the researches of Professor Sedgwick and those of the government surveyors. In some parts of Wales, and in the Longmynd and Shelve districts, these rocks are unconformable to the Caradoc sandstone. But the researches of the surveyors have also shown, that this physical phenomenon of unconformity be- tween these two divisions of Lower Silurian strata intimately con- nected by their organic remains is local, and that there are tracts in North Wales, and even in the vicinity of Bala itself, where the Llandeilo formation is conformably surmounted by the Caradoc sand- stone, as represented in the coloured section appended to the map. See also the diagrams in chapter 4. In truth. Sir H. De la Beche and his associates have proceeded on the axiom, that local unconformity of stratification does not con- stitute a ground for the establishment of a line of geological dis- tinction and classification. They have even ascertained that in Chap. III.] LOWER SILURIAN SANDSTONES. 51 South Wales, one portion of the carboniferous series is as uncon- formable to another and older part of the same coal-field, as the example which has been alluded to between the Llandeilo and the Caradoc of the Lower Silurian rocks of certain districts in North Wales and Shropshire. In France, as in Bohemia (see chapters 13 and 14.) and elsewhere in foreign countries, there is always a perfect conformity between the lowest Silurian strata, and those which stand in the place of our Caradoc sandstone. The only great break which is there known occurs between the base of everything fossiliferous, and those great azoic masses of greywacke which represent the bottom rock, of the preceding chapters. In Britain, on the contrary, as already demon- strated, that fundamental rock is the regular and conformable base of all the Silurian strata. It is, indeed, manifest that the break or overlap in Wales, and along the south end of the Longmynd and Corndon tracts of Shropshire, is a local phenomenon. I adhere, then, to my old divisions, under a belief, confirmed by subsequent extensive survey, that in many regions of the earth the geologist will find it impossible to classify by the means of such smaller divisions, and that he must simply view the whole as " Lower Silurian Rocks." Thus, however certain distinctions may be clear and good in typical tracts of Siluria and Wales, there are many parts even of the British Isles, and numberless foreign localities, where separation into the formations of Llandeilo and Caradoc is absolutely impracticable, either by mineral and zoological distinctions, or by dislocations. In my original work it was stated that the so called Llandeilo flags and schists were often underlaid, or their place taken, by sandstones of considerable thickness. Such, for example, are the sandstones of the Stiper Stones, which as before stated (p. 29.), and as represented in the original sections, lie beneath the great mass of the strata now under consideration, and were from the first called Lower Silurian." E 2 52 SILURIA. [Chap. III. On the other hand, the fact now generally admitted was always insisted on, that, however the mineral character might vary, very many of these strata were characterized by similar fossils, par- ticularly by some of the commonest Lower Silurian types. In short, two groups or divisions only were dwelt upon, for the general scale of comparison, and these were Lower and Upper Silurian. (See Sil. Syst, passim.) In tracts where it is unassociated with trap or igneous rocks, the Llandeilo formation above the Lingula schists consists thus in ascending order, first, of the dark schists with graptolites ; next, of hard dark-coloured flags, sometimes slightly micaceous, often cal- careous, with white veins of crystallized carbonate of lime, and which, here and there forming limestones, are specially distinguished by containing the large trilobites, Asaphus tyrannus, Ogygia Buchii, with several species of Trinuclei, as well as numerous shells, many of which are represented in the plates 1 to 10. The upper member is composed of strata of shale, schist, and sandstones, occasionally even conglomerates, in other tracts containing thin courses of calcareous or shelly sandstone. In the neighbourhood of Llandeilo, in Carmarthenshire, where, from the abundance of the above-mentioned fossils, the name was applied, the forma- tion, consisting of schists, limestones, and sandstones, has been estimated by the government surveyors to have a thickness of about 4000 feet. In North Wales, where the rocks are much expanded by the intervention of igneous materials, the dimensions are vastly greater, and even to the west of the Longmynd and Stiper Stones this formation has a thickncGS of several thousand feet. Igneous Bocks associated with the Lower Silurian. — In order to make the reader acquainted with the general aspect and nature of the British Lower Silurian rocks, it is essential to explain how in certain districts volcanic action affected the bottom of the sea during the deposition of the strata, and how they were dislocated by subsequent Chap. III.] CONTEMPORANEOUS IGNEOUS ROCKS. 5S eruptions. In the vicinity of some igneous rocks, these schists and calcareous flagstones have been filled with mineral veins, and have undergone various changes. Besides ores of lead and copper, it will also be shown, in a separate chapter, that rocks of this age were ren- dered partially auriferous in Wales, and largely so in other countries. (See chap. 16.) One of the tracts in the original Silurian region, where the Llan- deilo formation is most metalliferous {lead veins), is that lofty ond rugged district of Shropshire, which lies around the village of Shelve and the Corndon mountain, and which extends from the west of the Stiper Stones into Montgomeryshire. (See Map.) The student of natural phenomena is specially invited to examine this tract, because, together with the adjacent Longmynd and the Stiper Stones, it exhibits nearly the whole series of strata of North Wales in lower hills, and is therefore more easily accessible and com- prehensible than the subcrystalline, contorted, and steep flanks of Snowdon and Cader Idris, which exhibit similar phenomena on a grand scale. In reference to North Wales, I will merely say, that some of the finest examples of the stratified and contemporaneous beds of fel- spathic ash or volcanic grit are exhibited in the environs of Fes- tiniog. There, the interval between the green and grey schists, of the age of the Lingula flags of Tremadoc, and certain black roofing slates of the Llandeilo formation, is occupied by syenite, satiny schists, and volcanic grits, the last being in parts coarse con- glomerates. Again, to the west of Tan-y-bwlch, the latter in the form of ash-beds, which there are very finely levigated, differ chiefly from talc schist in being less quartzose, associating and al- ternating with hard greywacke grit, which is penetrated by large branching veins of white quartz. Occasionally, this felspathic ash, which is separated into thick beds by slightly inclined layers of deposit, is traversed by numerous highly *E 3 54 SILURIA. [Chap. III. inclined lamlnse of slaty cleavage, from which the associated coarse grits are exempt. The repeated alternations of these pseudo-volcanic rocks with the schists and grey wacke of North Wales can alone be well understood by reference to the maps and sections prepared by Kamsay and Selwyn. In the small map attached to this work, and which, as before ex- plained, is simply a reduction of that of the government surveyors, numberless features are necessarily omitted. An adequate acquaintance with such features can only be at- tained by traversing those mountains with the originals of these remarkable illustrations in hand. There, in the space of a few square miles, the geologist meets with numerous grand alternations of in- terstratified volcanic ashes and felspathic conglomerates, sometimes sandy and calcareous, which have been pierced by eruptive igneous rocks, whether syenite, felspar rock, or greenstone, here and there porphyritic. It is sometimes most difficult to separate the contem- poraneous igneous rocks from the subsequently intruded masses (porphyries of Sedgwick) ; as, for example, at Cader Idris, where the succession is represented in a diagram, also taken from the sections of the Survey, which is given towards the conclusion of this chapter. Then, again, let the student take any one of the closely worked quarter- sheet maps of this Survey (particularly those of Snowdon and Cader Idris), and, marking the faults or fractures as delineated by the great number of white lines, he may form some idea of the consummate skill and labour by which such results have been obtained. * But to return to similar Silurian rocks which are seen in the tracts of Shelve, Llandrindod, and Builth, where they were first classified and placed in distinct relation to other deposits, and with which some of the copious masses of North Wales have been * A fine example of this succession to the north of Festiniog was recently pointed out to M. de Verneuil and myself by Professor. Ramsay. Chap. III. j STRATIFIED FELSPAR ROCKS. 55 identified by the government surveyors. Those districts were long ago shown by me to contain two classes of submarine igneous rocks ; the one bedded and regularly interlaced with the strata, and therefore formed contemporaneously with them; the other not bedded, and which had broken through the others. Each of these is similarily divided into several varieties, for an acquaintance with which the reader must consult the original descriptions. * Of the bedded pseudo-volcanic rocks in Shropshire and Mont- gomeryshire, some of the finest examples are to be seen in the pic- turesque defile of Marrington Dingle. There, the lowest strata, exposed at a high inclination in numerous quarries, are felspar rocks of a concretionary structure, which are surmounted by coarse mottled volcanic grits, consisting of a base of lightish and greenish grey granular felspar, mixed with sand and chlorite, and containing an- gular fragments of schists and porphyritic greenstones, the whole arranged in beds from two to four feet thick, and dipping at an angle of 45°, as expressed in this vignette. Whittery Quarries in Harrington Dingle. (From Sil. Syst., p. 270.) In other parts of this district there are both felspathic agglome- rates and ash-beds, or volcanic grits and slaty porphyries, with crystals of felspar. Some of these alternate in thick masses with the schist containing trilobites, others in courses of a few inches thick * See Sil. Syst., pp. 269. 324. and passim. E 4 56 SILURIA. [Chap. III. only, and occasionally including fragments of the Ogygia (Asaphus) Buchii. Other organixj remains are found in beds which are almost exclusively composed of igneous materials ; thus showing that sub- marine volcanic action was rife in the sea-bottom in which these Lower Silurian strata were accumulated. The annexed woodcuts will convey some idea of the manner in which the volcanic breccia or ash, h, which alternates with the beds of schist, a, envelopes other fragments of schist and slate, c. (From Sil. Syst., p. 271.) Another diagram, taken from the coloured sections on the margin of my old map of the Silurian region, explains the manner in which, by the action of submarine volcanoes, such igneous dejections are supposed to have been accumulated, as represented by the light- coloured layers which alternate with the ordinary sediments, and further, how a volcanic cone, similar to that of Graham Island in the Mediterranean, as represented by the dotted line, may have dis- appeared and mixed its scoriae and ashes with the ordinary submarine mud or sand. Ideal Representation of the manner in which submarine Volcanic Dejections WERE formed in THE LoWER SiLURIAN PeRIOD. (From bottom of Map, Sil. Syst.) Chap. III.] VOLCANIC GRITS AND LLANDEILO FLAGS. 57 Some large masses of eruptive trap, which have penetrated the sedimentary and associated volcanic deposits at a subsequent period, are seen in the Corndon Hills as expressed in this view, the undu- lating grounds around them being composed of strata of the Llan- deilo formation. Lower Silurian and bedded Trap, traversed by eruptive Eocks, the Corndon Mountain in the distance. (From Sil. Syst., p. 271.) Equally instructive examples of the alternations of bedded igneous rocks with Lower Silurian strata, and of posterior eruptions, are seen in the hills of Gelli, Gilwern, and Carneddau, near Llandegley, Llan- drindod, and Builth in Radnorshire. Felspar porphyries are there regularly stratified, one example of which, as taken from the illus- trations of my former researches, is here exhibited. Alternations of Llandeilo Flags and Schists with Volcanic Grits. (From Sil. Syst, p. 325.) a a. Coarse slaty felspar rock, sliglitly porphyritic and amygdaloidal, containing elongated con- cretions of green earth. This rock is regularly stratified in beds of three to four feet thick, and forms the mass of the hill, rising into the higher ground, h. Finely laminated greenish- 58 SILURIA. [Chap. III. grey sandy flagstone, apparently hardened near the top. c. Fine-grained granular felspar and courses of clay-stone, some of which are used as oven-stone, d. Altered flags, having a conchoidal fracture, in parts almost Lydian-stone, with crystals of iron pyrites, e. Grey felspar rock, the laminae of deposit marked by feruginous streaks, probably due to the de- composition of some other mineral. /. Black shivery shale, containing a few concretions of argillaceous limestone, with veins of calcareous spar. One of these, which fell under my notice, was a septarium, two or three feet in diameter, containing many impressions of Graptolites. This band of black shale was excavated to a considerable distance in search of coal! on the strike of the beds, by the same individuals who have sought for lead ore. g. Hard thick- bedded porphyritic felspar, h. Flagstone, with Ogygia Buchii, indurated in contact with the trap ; much iron pyrites, i. Grey porphyritic clay-stone, j. Black schist, with some hard stone bands, in parts pyritous. k. Slaty porphyritic felspar. I. Black shale, with stone bands and concretions of argillaceous limestone, m. Thin band of decomposed granular felspar, weathering to a rusty colour, and looking like a coarse oolite, n. Black pyritous schists, much contorted near the mouth of the gallery. Thus, in a thickness of only 350 feet across the beds, this detailed section exhibits bands of felspathic and porphyritic rocks, occasionally both crystalline and amygdaloidal, with clay-stones, granular felspar, and green earth ; which materials alternate, six or seven times, with finely laminated flagstones and black schists, one of which contains graptolites, and another the Ogygia Buchii. (PI. 3. f. 1.) In truth, this little section exhibits an epitome of the structure of vast tracts in North Wales. Examples of such contemporaneous rocks, as well as those of posterior intrusion, are well seen in Salop, Montgomery, and Rad- nor. In and around the Corndon mountain of Montgomeryshire, (see view, p. 57.), in the volcanized and mining tracts of Shelve, the eruptive and intrusive rocks are chiefly coarse-grained hornblendic greenstones and felspar rocks passing into basalt. In many of these cases, the shale or schist in contact with the eruptive rock has been cemented into a complete porcellanite, with surfaces as smooth as the finest lithographic stone. These altered shales are, in fact, the brand-erde, " or burnt earth, of the Germans.* * In England the most curious actual proofs of this conversion occur in the South Staffordshire coal-field, particularly near the town of Dudley, where the spontaneous and long-continued combustion of subterranean coal in abandoned mines has produced in the shale and sandstones of the coal measures a variety of burnt earths, which are of divers colours ; some of them resembling the riband jasper of mineralogists. Chap. III.] THE BREIDDEN HILLS. 59 The Breidden Hills, including the picturesque Moel-y-Golfa, on the right bank of the Severn, near Welsh Pool, also exhibit similar illustrations, both of contemporaneously bedded trap and of posterior or intrusive rocks, which have broken out along the same line at dif- ferent periods, for a better acquaintance with which I must refer to former detailed descriptions.* The annexed drawing, taken from the terrace of Powis Castle, shows these hills in the distance. They mark a line of eruption that separates the Lower Silurian rocks on the left hand or west, from the Upper Silurian of the Long Mountain on the right hand or east. View of the Breidden Hills near Welshpool, from Powis Castle. (From a Drawing by Lady Murchison, Sil. Syst., p. 302.) Now, it has been demonstrated that along this line of eruption some volcanic dejections were thrown down on the sea-bottom during the formation of the Lower Silurian strata ; that other eruptions and dis- locations afterwards took place along it, heaving those strata into highly inclined positions, like those on which Powis Castle stands ; * Silurian System, p. 287. et seq. 60 SILURIA. [Chap. III. that on the edges of these beds carboniferous deposits were after- wards accumulated ; and that again, after all these and other form- ations, including the new red sandstone, were completed, still more recent eruptions occurred along this same line of fissure.* The shortest method of explaining to the reader the structure of the Breidden Hills is to exhibit this small diagram, taken from a section just published by the Geological Survey, and which represents a mass of porphyritic and amygdaloidal greenstone, which in its protrusion has carried up included portions of slaty beds, and has thrown off pebble beds and Upper Silurian rocks to the S. E., and Lower Silurian to the N. W. Section across the Breiddex Hills. N.W. S.E. Rodney's PUlar. b * b * b b* b d b. Lower Silurian slaty rocks, b *. Contemporaneous trap breccia, d. Wenlock shale or base of Upper Silurian. *. Eruptive rocks. One of the igneous rocks most easily examined on this line of habitual outburst in ancient periods, is the largely excavated prismatic mass at Welsh Pool, which seems to cut as a dike through the Lower Silurian strata, which in contact with the igneous matter are much altered. At a little distance, however, these beds contain organic remains, some of which, particularly the Trinucleus concentricus, were originally figured in the " Silurian System." (See pi. 4. f. 2—5.) This prismatic rock, unquestionably of igneous origin, is largely quarried as a building stone, like that of the Whittery quarries. It is remarkable in having its light-green felspar matrix speckled with minute nuts and kernels of calcareous spar, which, together with the finely aggregated state of the felspar, renders the stone sectile and valuable. * For the proofs of this, see Sil. Syst., pp. 299. et seq. Chap. III.] LOWER SILURIAN AND ERUPTIVE ROCKS. 61 Eruptive masses of greenstone and hypersthene rocks, described as cutting through Silurian strata, occur near Old Radnor*; but as these are associated with strata of posterior date to those we are now considering, they will be mentioned in the sixth chapter. The Carneddau Hills, between Llandrindod and Builth, are, however, truly amorphous and eruptive masses of igneous rock, which have broken through and highly altered the Llandeilo flags and associated sandstones. Beautiful examples of this are seen on the banks of the Wye, west of Builth. (See Sil. Syst., p. 332. et seq.) On this occasion one diagram only is selected, as taken from one of the coloured plates in my large work, to show, at one view, first. Section across the Gelli Hills. (From Sil. Syst., pi. 33. f. 5.) b*. Lower Silurian with interpolated contemporaneous trap. *. Eruptive Rocks. how the strata of the Llandeilo formation alternate with bedded igneous rocks, b and next, how they have been altered in contact with eruptive masses, *. It is in these black and hardened schists of contact that films of anthracite have been found, which have led credulous farmers to search for coal.f Another frequent result, in this district, of the contact of the eruptive rock with the schists, is the production of much sulphuret of iron, the decomposition of which gives rise to the various mineral * Sil. Syst., p. 318. I A full exposure of this folly was giveii in the Silurian System, p. 328., with this diagram, representing an actual search after coal ! at a spot called Tin-y-Coed, thus — b, Lower Silurian schists traversed hy a gallery, c, until the eruptive trap rock, *, was reached, where the enterprise was necessarily stopped. 62 SILURIA. [Chap. III. sources of Llandegley, Landrindod, Builth, Llanwrtyd, &C.5 which gush out around this volcauized tract. Lower Silurian of Pembroke and Carmarthen. — Although some allusions have been made, in the preceding pages, to parts of South Wales, and to the general agreement of its structure with that of North Wales, it is necessary to explain, particularly to all those who may have considted the " Silurian System," the general views which I have long ago adopted, and which, though well known to English geologists during the last ten years, may still be little understood by foreigners and the public into whose hands the original work may have fallen. Whilst North Wales and the northern parts of Siluria have been described as consisting of troughs, or undulating masses of Lower Silurian rocks, resting to the west upon the unfossiliferous grey wacke of Carnarvon, and to the east on similar rocks of the Longmynd, the same sedimentary base or bottom rock is again visible in South Wales, but at one spot only. This is at St. David's, in Pembroke- shire, where the oldest greywacke, like the rocks of the Longmynd, Llanberis, and Haerlech, is an intractable, hard, fine-grained, purple and grey sandstone, with slaty schists, in which no organic remains have been found. In North Pembrokeshire, these bottom rocks are followed by Lower Silurian strata, but with much irregularity, owing to the association of vast masses of igneous rocks, which are interpolated in a broken series of quartzose and felspathic conglomerates, grits, sand- stones, and slates. Among the older igneous rocks of contempo- raneous origin, are thick-bedded coarse conglomerates, and among those of intrusive and posterior date, are large-grained greenstones and compact felspar rocks, for a better acquaintance with which the reader must consult other writings as well as my own.* * See Kidd. Trans. Geol. Soc, old series, vol. ii. p. 791. ; De la Beche, Trans. Geol. Soc, new series, vol. ii. p. 1. ; and Silurian System, p. 401. Chap. III.] PEMBROKE LOWER SILURIAN. 63 With the exception then of the old greywacke of St. David's, all these rocks of sedimentary origin in North Pembroke, which were formerly termed Cambrian, have been found by the govern- ment surveyors to be, as in North Wales, mere undulations or ex- pansions of what had been described as Lower Silurian strata in South Pembroke and Carmarthen. Many years have indeed elapsed since I publicly announced my belief in this result of the valuable labours of those geolooiists.* Wherever, therefore (with the above exception), the reader of the original " Silurian System " meets with descriptions of schistose, slaty, or quartzose rocks of South Wales, which were called Cambrian, he must now consider that they merely refer to mineralogical variations of undulating strata of the Lower Silurian age. Of these, there are in Pembrokeshire, some sandstones and schists, which are on the pa- rallel of the Lingula beds of North Wales, though the few fossils of that age have not yet been found in them any more than in Shrop- shire. And in truth, when the geologist examines North Pembroke (where alone in South Wales the bottom rocks are exposed), he will not be surprised that even the sedulous fossil collectors of the geo- logical survey should have failed in procuring from such materials many traces of primordial life ; so much are the strata buried amidst masses of igneous rocks, both contemporaneous and eruptive, and so * In the "Silurian System" it was indeed stated, as an apology (Notes, pp.399, and 402.), that I had given little attention to North Pembroke, to which I only made one rapid excursion. Owing to its highly mineralized aspect, the vast profusion of associated igneous matter, and their highly crystalline nature, all these rocks were, at that day, considered to belong to a system inferior to the Silurian. That erroneous view was publicly renounced by me, many years ago, in two addresses to the Geological Society of London. I also endeavoured to give a wider currency to my views, by publishing, 1843, a general map of England and Wales, at the re- quest of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge. I have, since then, twice visited North Wales, and had all my views confirmed, by inspecting the ground with Professor Ramsay and Mr. Selwyn, in the company, on the one oc- casion, of Professor Nicol, on the other, of M. de Verneuil. 64 SILURIA. [Chap. III. slaty and crystalline is their structure, accompanied, further, by an absence of all calcareous matter.* The lowest beds of that region in which fossils are visible are the black schists with graptolites, formerly described by me either as the base of the Silurian system, or as forming a downward passage into what was then termed Cambrian, under the erroneous supposition of the inferiority of position of another great mass or system with which the schists were connected. The graptolite schists are well exposed at Abereiddy Bay, where the surfaces of slaty cleavage, as formerly pointed out, coincide in one part absolutely with the laminas along which the graptolites, chiefly the G. Murchisoni (see pi. 12. f. 1.), have been deposited as exhibited in this woodcut. Lower Silurian Rocks in Abereiddy Bay. (From Sil. Syst., p. 400.) Coincidence of Slaty Cleavage and Bedding. In the Pembrokeshire section, the next strata in ascending order, or the calcareous flags of Llandeilo, as defined by their trilobites and other fossils, are rarely to be detected amidst the great intrusions of igneous matter, and the enormous breaks, faults, and denudations, by which the whole system has been obscured in this region. Some depressions being filled with overlying old red sandstone and car- boniferous limestone (of which hereafter), and others with highly dislocated troughs of broken stone coal, or culm, the Llandeilo flags are only visible in one locality, along the whole of the rugged coast * See the tracts between the Precelly slates and Strumble Head, west of Fishguard. Chap. III.] LLANDEILO KOCKS OF PEMBROKE. 65 clilFs of this southern extremity of Wales, and just in the place wh'fere I first described them. This is at Musclewick Haven in St. Bride's Bay, where black schists, in parts sandy, are traversed by dingy veins of black cal- careous spar, and contain the usual trilobites (Asaphi and Trinuclei).* The beds there dip at about 35° to the S. S.E., which inclination would convey them under the great mass of the fossil-bearing Silurian rocks, as exhibited in Marloes Bay. There is, however, no visible connection, as the intervening promontory is much overlaid by intrusive igneous rock. This insulated mass of Llandeilo schists is, indeed, flanked by enormous faults or dislocations, by which, on their north side, these Lower Silurian strata are thus brought abruptly into contact with the old red sandstone, f Llandeilo Schists in Musclewick Bay. (From Sil. Syst, pi. 35. f. 11.) 0 6 6 o. Old Red Sandstone. b. Llandeilo Schists. * Eruptive Rocks. In tracing an ascending order in South Pembroke, the inferior strata are seen to occupy the isles of Skomer, where, associated with huge bands of trap rock, they plunge rapidly to the S.E., as represented in the next drawing taken from Wooltack Park and the mainland, and then dip under all the strata of Marloes Bay. In pursuing the ascending order into Marloes Bay on the south-east, we first meet with other bands of slaty grey wacke, which also alternate w^ith igneous rocks, that seem to have cut out the schists Avith the fos- sils of the Llandeilo flags. For, we next pass over the inclined edges * Silurian System, p. 394. f Sir Henry de La Beche estimates this fault between the Llandeilo flags and the old red sandstone, as an upcast of upwards of 2000 feet. F 66 SILURIA. [Chap. III. View of Skomer Isles, seen from the Mainland. (From Sil. Syst., p. 389.) of a great thickness of quartzose sandstones, in which, though also associated with much eruptive trap, remains of encrinites and other fossils have been found ; the whole dipping, like the inferior strata of Skomer, to the S.E. Then follow schists having a slaty- cleavage. All these are overlaid in the cliffs (at Marloes Mire, Kain Kock, and Gateholm), as expressed in this little view, by Hook Point. Silurian Rocks of Marloes Bay, Pembroke, dipping under the Old Red Sandstone of Hook Point. (From Sil. Syst., p. 392.) other sandy schists and sandstones of considerable dimensions. From their position and mineral character, and not having found many fossils, a large portion of the lower beds was classed by me with the Caradoc sandstone ; but in most of these the government surveyors Chap. III.] SILURIAN ROCKS — MARLOES BAY. 67 have since collected fossils which rather refer them to the bottom of the Wenlock, and consequently to the Upper Silurian rocks. Such are the rocks represented in the foreground of the last vignette, and which continue conformably, layer over layer, to the dark-shaded headlands in the middle of the bay, where they plunge, as expressed, at a high angle, under other strata repre- senting the mass of the Upper Silurian rocks, or Wenlock and Ludlow formations, which in their turn are surmounted by the old red sandstone of Hook Point. Reverting hereafter to the great discrepancy in lithological conditions which is here apparent in these Upper Silurian rocks when compared with the typical strata of the same age in Salop and Hereford, attention is specially called to this section, the only one in the British Isles, where a great succession of Silurian rocks is seen in clear relations to the old red sandstone on the sea-coast. We thus learn how difficult it is, even in these fully exposed coast cliffs, to distinguish the upper portion of the Lower Silurian from the lower part of the superior group by the structure of the rocks, and we are, therefore, com- pelled to revert to their fossil contents. Here is a vast thickness of sandstone and sandy schists, which, dipping under strata of shale and calcareous beds with many fossils of the Wenlock limestone, has its surface marked by numerous brown impressions of the stems of encrinites (a character very common in the true Caradoc sandstone). These beds are also affected by a slaty cleavage, giving to them a very antique impress, In truth, they are lithologically and stratigraphically the Caradoc of the Lower Silurian, to be described in the next chapter ; whilst the palaeontologist must range them with the base of the Upper Silurian on account of a prevalence of certain forms. And thus it ever must be in strata so intimately connected as the lower and upper members of this natural system, wherever such clear divisionary features are wanting as those to which attention will be called in the sequel. In F 2 68 SILURIA. [Chap. III. fact, the same slaty impress, which affects all the lower strata in Marloes Bay, is continued upwards through shales and schists which represent the Upper Silurian rocks ; nearly the whole of the Silurian system, up to its beds of passage into the old red sandstone, being here exhibited in the space of less than three miles. The Lower Silurian rocks of Pembroke, composed in some parts of sandstones, in others of schists and flagstones, are much more calcareous as they trend eastward and north-eastward into Car- marthenshire. Rolling out in undulations from the complicated, dis- turbed, and slaty masses of North Pembroke, these strata become much more simple on a zone ranging from Haverfordwest by Sholes- hook and the north of Narbeth to Llandewi Felfrey and Llampeter Felfrey, where the calcareous matter* so increases, that it forms, as before said, by far the finest masses of Llandeilo limestone in all Wales, as in this woodcut, which is here reproduced from p. 49. Section at Llandewi Felfrey, Pembrokeshire. S.S.E. ■ N.N.W. d. Old red sandstone. c. Thin zone of Upper Silurian rocks. b. Llandeilo limestone, with underlying and overlying schists. There the beds, as originally described, are charged with the pre- vailing fossils of the Llandeilo formation, including Ogygia Buchii, pi. 3. f. L ; Asaphus tyrannus, pi. 1. ; Leptasna sericea, pi. 6. f. 13.; Orthis elegantula, pi. 6. f. 5.; with the coral Halysites catenulatus, and also the Echinosphaerites aurantium and E. Bal- ticus, of the lower limestones of Sweden and Russia. (See chap. 5.) When the limestone thins out, its position in the strata of schist and flag is often marked by bands of concretions only, and in other places by flagstones more or less calcareous. The latter type, or that * Silurian System, p. 397. Chap. III.J LLANDEILO FLAGS. 69 of calcareous flagstones, prevails around the town of Llandeilo. There, and in other parts of Carmarthenshire, the Lower Silurian rocks are, on the whole, much less interfered with or expanded by- igneous rocks than in Pembrokeshire or North Wales. Hence, though they do contain some small subordinate bands of greenstone and felspar rocks, analogous to their larger types elsewhere, and are thrown into undulations, their relations are more clearly exposed in a small compass, thus : — View from Dynevor Park, Llandeilo, looking to the Hills above Golden Grove. (From Sil. Syst., p. 347.) Here, all the Silurian rocks, from the Llandeilo flags up to the Ludlow rocks, are exhibited in the vale of the Towy or on the banks of that river ; the old red sandstone forming the distant hills. In reference to my original opinions, I beg the reader to compare the coloured sections in the Silurian System," pi. 34., with those since published by the Government Survey, to see how they both represent the same succession of conformable strata of Lower and Upper Silurian rocks in the environs of Llandeilo. Among the lowest visible strata of these tracts, are schists with an 70 SILURIA. [Chap. III. imperfect slaty cleavage, which contain irregular elliptic masses of silicious grit*, made up of pebbles of quartz and fragments of older greywacke slate ; the former being seen in some places to have indented the latter as if they had been subjected to an enormous pressure. It is in the lower schistose beds of these rocks, that the remains of annelids or red-blooded sea-worms, now so generally found in the Silu- rian rocks of various countries, were first discovered ; and which were described for me by Mr. Macleay.f Occasionally, as between Llandeilo and Llandovery, the upper members of these slaty schists are also marked by other silicious grits, which, from their perfect conformity to the masses of Upper Silurian rocks above them, and to the cal- careous flags and schists of Llandeilo beneath, I naturally considered to be thin and partial representatives of the intermediate Caradoc sandstone. These beds are now classed by the surveyors with the Llandeilo formation. In its prolongation from Carmarthenshire and Cardiganshire, into Brecknockshire, this slaty greywacke group is again distinguished by included quartzose greywacke sandstones, which in Radnorshire swell out into important and continuous mountain masses. Not unfrequent to the east of Aberystwith, these sandstones become of considerable thickness near Rhayader on the Wye, where they contain subordinate conglomerates, some of the finest examples of which are seen in the deep gorge of the river Elain, a tributary of the Wye (Craig-y-voel). Similar rocks, whether silicious grits, pebbly conglomerates or hard iijtractable sandstones, range to the north-west, and occupy the ridges of Gwastaden, Rhiw Gwraidd, Dolfan, Devanner,and the Maen * See Silurian System, vol. i. p. 359, 360. A similar phenomenon has been observed in other countries, as if the pebbles of quartz had indented each other by pressure and friction. t See Sil. Syst., p. 699. Chap. III.] LOWER SILURIAN SANDSTONES. 71 rocks in Eadnor, and Bryn Din and Moel-ben-twrch in Montgomery. Owing to great dislocations on their eastern frontier, they are occa- sionally placed in unconformable relations to the Upper Silurian rocks of that region.* To the west, however, they roll over in great undulations, on cer- tain parallels, as laid down on the maps and horizontal sections of the government surveyors (some of the arenaceous masses being not less than 1000 feet thick), and with a strike which in South Wales is usually N.E. and S. W., the dips being both to the S.E. and N. W., but more frequently in the latter direction. In my former examination, I only detected casts of encrinites in these sand- stones, but the government surveyors have found a sufficient number of forms to enable them to refer these rocks to that portion of the Lower Silurian (Llandeilo division), with which they are physically united. In my opinion, they may be simply considered the central sandstones of the great schistose Lower Silurian group, whose bottom rocks are seen in the Longmynd and at Harlech and Llanberis, and whose highest term is the Caradoc sandstone, to be described in the next chapter. In districts where they have been affected by the intrusion of igneous rocks, the slaty masses of this age in South Wales are much mineralized, just as in Shropshire and North Wales. They contain the lead ores of Nant-y-Moen, and the old Eoman gold mines of Gogofau, the one to the north the other to the west of Llandovery ; both of which mines occur in quartzose bands subordinate to graptolite schists. The mineral sources (Llanwrtyd, Builth, &c.) also rise from points of junction between the intrusive and sedimentary rocks. In some districts, where these South Welsh strata were formerly described by me as charged with characteristic Lower Silurian fossils, * See Sil. Syst., p, 316., where these hard and slaty sandstones are described as being cut oflf from the Upper Silurian by great faults. See also original map of the Silurian region and sections, p. 90., in the next chapter. p 4 72 SILURIA. [Chap. III. they have the antique and slaty impress of the oldest rocks. Thus, in the wild and barren tract of " Noeth Grrug," north of Llandovery, the NoETH Grug. (From the Government Survey.) f e d c b b b. Lower Silurian schists, flags, and slates. c. Lower Silurian grits and sandstone, classed by the surveyors with the schists above and below them. d. Schists. e. Upper Silurian shale and schist, capped b}' tilestone. /. Old red sandstone. (Compare with Section Sil. Syst. p. 352., and pi. 34. f. 3.) strata are seen undulating, as represented by the curved lines, h, and are also traversed by cleavage planes (the highly inclined white lines). Consisting of coarse grits, sandstones, and schists, these strata are in parts replete with Lower Silurian fossils, among which are the Leptaena sericea, pi. 6. f. 14.; Pentamerus undatus, pi. 8. f. 5.*; P. oblongus, pi. 8. f. 3. ; Atrypa crassa, pi. 5. f. 6. ; Or this Actoniae, pi. 6. f. 11.; O. flabellulum, pi. 6. f. 12.; and the Lituites cornu-arietis, pi. ll.f. 2. Though most of these species are found in the slates of Snowdon, the equivalent strata in which they are here imbedded are little more than two miles distant from the frontier of the Old Red Sand- stone ; all the intervening Silurian rocks, which elsewhere occupy vast tracts, being compressed in this district into the small horizontal space exhibited in the woodcut, as reduced from a section of the government surveyors. It is gratifying to me to observe that this diagram is quite in accordance with my old, published, coloured section across the same tract. (See Sil. Syst., p. 352. and pi. 34. f. 3.) And here, in reference to the question whether there be or be not in this section, or in other similar traverses in Carmarthen- * This fossil is termed Atrypa undata in the Silurian System, nearly all the so called Atrypae of which work are now found to belong to the genus Pentamerus. Chap. IIT.] SECTIONS NEAR LLANDEILO. 73 shire and Pembrokeshire, any small representative of the Caradoc sandstone, as I thought, I must specially call attention to the fact, that the correctness of my original sections is confirmed by the detailed works of the geologists employed to survey the tract. For, Section Neak Llangadock. From the Lower Silurian to the Old Red Sandstone. (The Spectator is looking to the south-west.) S.E. TrichrUg. Cairngoch- Tanyrallt. N.W. b. Undulations of Llandeilo schists, flags, and limestone with interstratified trap *. c. Sand- stones, &c. d, e. Upper Silurian. /. Old red sandstone. all these lower strata, in parts coarse sandstones, which overlie the black and grey slaty schists and flags of Llandeilo, are now admitted by those who followed me to be conformable to the Upper Silurian strata or Wenlock and Ludlow formations, as exhibited in these woodcuts, taken from the published section of the surveyors.* Section Near Llandeilo. From the Lower Silurian to the edge of the great South- Welsh Coal-iield. (In this diagram the spectator is supposed to be placed a little south of Llandeilo, looking north-east, or up the Vale of the Towy. Hence the points of the compass are reversed in reference to the foregoing diagram.) N.W. S.E. h. Llandeilo flags and limestone. c. Sandstone, &c. d, e. Upper Silurian rocks. /. Old red sandstone. g. Carboniferous limestone. h. Millstone grit. Such facts indicate the propriety of adhering to two groups only for all general purposes of comparison. In truth, the only Silurian * I beg geologists to compare the several coloured sections of the Silurian System, pi. 34., which represent the succession from the Llandeilo flags to the old red sandstone in Carmarthenshire, with the horizontal sections of the surveyors from which the above diagrams are faithful reductions. 74 SILURIA. [Chap. III. formation which is fully developed in Carmarthenshire is the lower one of Llandeilo with its associated schists and slates; all that overlie it being feebly displayed. Thus, though the Upper Silurian rocks here may be spoken of as a group, they can scarcely be identified with the copious formations of Wenlock and Ludlow, as seen in Shropshire and Herefordshire. Even the chief Lower Silurian formation, or that of Llandeilo on which we have been dilating, is at this spot compressed into the horizontal space of a mile, whilst in North Wales it extends, as has been shown, through undulations and expansions, over a whole region. We also see how in this same tract, and in the longitudinal space of a few miles, the very strata which are so calcareous at Llandeilo, have become slaty sandstones and schists at Noeth Griig, north of Llandovery ; a character indeed which they put on before they reach that town, even at Mandinam and Goleugoed.* With this absence of lime the prevalent trilobites of the Llandeilo flags disappear ; the whole of the lower division assuming so different a lithological aspect, that except by rigid observation of other imbedded fossils the subforma- tions cannot be distinguished. In most parts, indeed, of South Wales, the only broad and clear distinctions are those of lower and upper groups. I dwell, there- fore, upon the fact, that in their range through this part of South Wales, the Silurian rocks, both lower and upper, with the partial exceptions mentioned, are entirely deprived of any subdividing bands of limestone. Hence it is, that in Carmarthen, Brecknock, and Radnor in the interior, or at Marloes Bay on the coast, the lines * This is the only locality in Britain where the rare species Lituites (Nautilus), pi. 3. f. 3., has been found, as well as the unique Diploceras (Orthoceras) bisi- phonatum. (See chap. 5.) I cannot allude to these forms without expressing my deep obligation to my deceased kind friend Mr. W. Williams of Llandovery, and his son, now the Rev. Stewart Williams, for their aid in collecting many of my best fossils, as acknowledged, Sil. Syst. p. 351. Chap. III.] LOWER SILURIAN SLATES OF BRECON. 75 of demarcation between the formations can with great difficulty be drawn. In truth, they are often so slaty and crystalline, that the highly inclined cleavage of the slates, as represented in the foreground of the following sketch, is the only feature visible to the unpractised eye ; the real strata undulating or dipping at a much less angle, as represented in the sloping bank on the left of the foreground of this drawing. Llanwrtyd Wells. (From Sil. Syst., p. 336.) Lower Silurian slaty rocks. View in a combe below the Baths of Llanwrtyd. (From a drawing by Mrs. Traherne.) When viewed, however, on the grand scale, there is no dis- trict more explanatory of the general succession than this very tract between Llandovery and Builth, of which the above vignette repre- sents a part. There, if the spectator stands on the slaty Lower Silurian rocks of the mountain of Esgair Davydd, above the baths of Llanwrtyd, he overlooks a wide area to the south-east, and has beneath his feet, and for a certain distance before him, a mass of the lower slaty rocks now under consideration; whilst in the dull round hills of the middle ground, are spread out the Upper Silurian of the Mynidd Epynt and Mynidd Bwlch-y-Groes. In the background. 76 SILURIA. [Chap. III. the Old Eed Sandstone is seen rising to the Black Mountain of Hereford, and thence into the Fans of Brecon and Carmarthen, the highest mountains in South Wales. The sketch of this grand geological scene being a proper introduc- tion to the description of the Old Eed or Devonian rocks, is therefore given in the tenth chapter, which treats of them ; for in no one district of Wales and England are the Silurian and Devonian rocks so well brought together in a bird's-eye view : nor is the super- position of their groups anywhere, as far as I know, more apparent in the interior of the country and on so grand a scale. (See also large coloured view, Sil. Syst. p. 346.) In the mean time, this long chapter may be concluded by reminding the reader, that the low western headlands of Pembrokeshire are of the same age as the loftier and grander mountains of North Wales ; both of them having been identified with the rocks of the original Lower Silurian districts of Shropshire, Herefordshire, Montgomery- shire, Radnorshire, Brecknockshire, and Carmarthenshire. In many tracts, the copious evolutions of volcanic ashes and dejections have swollen out the earliest formed Silurian strata, and the finer muddy sediments of a primeval sea have since been changed into a crys- talline and slaty condition. But no sooner do we pass from such hard and rugged centres (including the sandstones and conglo- merates of the South Welsh slates), than we find that many of the intervening and central tracts in South Montgomery, Radnor, Car- digan, &c., consist of an undulating series of schists and shale, in which bands of sandstone are rare, and wherein limestones have alto- gether disappeared ; a country, in fact, almost entirely deficient in anything like a stony framework. No more striking example of this change from hard and bold rocks, to those of much less coherent nature and tamer outline, can be given, than by traversing from the low fossil rocks of Cader Idris and its magnificent bosses and depressions, to the soft hills and schistose tracts on the banks of the Dyfi, as in this diagram. Chap. III.] LOWER SILURIAN AND IGNEOUS ROCKS. 77 Cader Idris. N.W. S.B. a * * J * Q a. Summit of the Lingula schists with porphyry, *. Grand masses of porphyry and other trap rocks, with courses of hard slaty Lower Silurian schists. c. Lower Silurian, as- suming its ordinary characters of shale when removed from the igneous rocks. In so doing, the field observer will see that the strata which, on the flanks of the mountain, are crystalline and slaty, are succeeded by other masses, which in proportion as they recede from the igneous rocks partake more and more of the character of " mudstone" — a character which prevails, as before said, in this region, from the base of the system with Silurian fossils, to the very youngest of its rocks. To form some idea of the great development of volcanic or igneous materials in the Lower Silurian rocks of North Wales, the reader will understand, that the porphyries and trap rocks represented in the above diagram, belong exclusively to a set of phenomena which commenced about the close of the deposition of the Lingula schists. Thick as these lower igneous accumulations are, they were followed by others of scarcely less dimensions, which swell out the overlying series of the Snowdon slates*, as explained in the little coloured section beneath the map. The next chapter will be dedicated to the consideration of a forma- tion, in which, through some typical British tracts, sandstone so abounds, as to have induced me to term it the Caradoc sandstone — a rock which forms, in many places, the upper member of the natural group which has been under consideration. * The large horizontal section across Snowdon by the government surveyors has just appeared, and shows in detail how the Lingula flags and certain igneous rocks rise up to the N.W. and S.E. from beneath the elevated trough of Snowdon. Professor Ramsay, who, with his associate, Mr. Selwyn, accomplished this arduous task, has just explained the results to the Geological Society. April 10. 1853. 78 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. CHAPTER IV. LOWER SILURIAN ROCKS — continued, THE CARADOC FORMATION. CAEADOC SANDSTONE AS DEVELOPED IN NOKTH WAJ.ES AND RADNOESHIRE. TYPES OF THE FORMATION IN SHROPSHIRE, HEREFORDSHIRE, ETC. THE CARADOC STRICTLY UNITED WITH THE LOWER DEPOSITS BY ITS STRUCTURE AND FOSSIL CONTENTS. The superior member of the Lower Silurian rocks, or middle Silurian of the government surveyors, is of varied composition in the differ- ent tracts in which it occurs. In the interior of North Wales (Merioneth and Montgomery, and thence extending into West Radnor, &c.) certain sandy masses, overlying the rocks described in the last chapter, have been identified with the Caradoc sandstone of the original Silurian region, and laid down as such in the co- loured sheets of the Government Survey. In these tracts, like the older sandstones and conglomerates of the Llandeilo division, the Ca- radoc is usually a hard, intractable, silicious rock, with many courses of shale or schist, but with few or no traces of calcareous matter, and seldom containing well preserved fossils. In fact, it frequently bears a close resemblance to the very oldest greywacke grits and sandstones in the sedimentary series, or the bottom rocks of the Longmynd, Harlech, Llanberis, and St. David's ; a lithological fact which shows how all these rocks, from their base to the Caradoc inclusive, are included in one natural group. In portions of Wales and Shropshire this formation, as before stated, is either transgressive, or unconformable to the inferior schists Chap. IV.] CARADOC SANDSTONE OF NORTH WALES. 79 and slates.* In many other parts, on the contrary, as in the wild tracts east of Bala, it reposes conformably for many miles in lofty escarpments on the upper Llandeilo rocks, composed of slaty schists with feeble courses of limestone.f A reference to the general section across North Wales, prepared for this work by Professor Kamsay (see bottom of map) completely establishes this position. In following that line of section to the S.E. from the environs of Bala, we see how the Llandeilo formation, rolling over in domes or anticlinal masses, supports basins of Caradoc sandstone and its overlying for- mation of Wenlock shale. In this way even the Upper Silurian rocks are brought by conformable folds into the proximity of the Llandeilo formation, as in South Wales. In the environs of Bala itself, indeed, the Caradoc formation of sandstone and shale occupies a trough flanked and underlaid conformably on the south-east, as well as on the north-west, by the upper division of the Llandeilo formation, as in this section, which has been reduced from one of the plates of the Government Survey prepared by Mr. Jukes. Llandeilo Schists supporting Caradoc Sandstone. ,„ Cwm Cwyn. Sir Watkin's Mynydd Mynyllod. Vale of C p N.W Monument. Edeimion. * ' h c c c b b, Llandeilo formation, with its thin courses of Bala limestone on the N.W. e. Caradoc sandstone, seen at Sir Watkin's Monument to be lying in perfect conformity on the Upper Llandeilo schist, which, rising out from beneath the sandstone in the Vale of Edeirnion, thence ascends to the S. E. to form the north-western flanks of the Berwyn Kange. The powerful faults which atfect the tract are represented by the dark traversing lines. Now, it is the opinion of the surveyors, that in pursuing this section to the S. E. of the Berwyns, and in traversing the vales watered by the * See the memoir of Professor Ramsay and Mr. Aveline, in which this feature is pointed at (Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. iv. p. 294.) The map annexed to this work shows the fact, in the wrapping round of the Caradoc sandstone upon the edges of the Llandeilo flags of the Shelve and Corndon districts, Shropshire. t I examined this tract in 1851, in company with Professor Nicol. 80 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. Tannat and Fyrnwy rivers, the same series of Llandeilo or Bala beds as is represented in the h of the above section is repeated in obscure undulations until the Breidden Hills are reached (see p. 60.), where the Caradoc sandstone seems to be omitted, and the lower series is at once surmounted by the Wenlock shale. In that locality of powerful eruption the suppression of the Caradoc may, indeed, be due to dis- memberments, of which hereafter. But there are tracts where the sandstones of the lower group, which are so expanded in parts of Wales (see p. 70.), naturally thin out and disappear ; and hence I adhere ta my original opinion, that the presence or absence of such sandy rocks is a local feature in a group for which, in many cases, there is no safe term except *^ Lower Silurian." The Caradoc formation is also seen, in the western and mountainous parts of Radnorshire, to fold over in undulations similar to those near Bala, resting conformably on the Llandeilo schists, and overlaid in equal conformity by the Wenlock shale. The next diagram repre- sents a portion of the flexures which these rocks exhibit, as taken from a part of the large and detailed horizontal sections of the Geological Survey, relating to the country along the boundary between the counties of Radnor and Montgomery, in a section drawn from Cader Idris across the Severn and its tributaries to the river Ithon, and the sandstone ridges to the west of Radnor Forest. On this line the same conformability is seen in numerous localities, of which this is one example. Pegwn's Fawr, Borders of Radnor and Montgomery. N.W. c S.E. Junction Beds of the Llandeilo and Caradoc Formations. (From a Section by Mr. Aveline.) b, Llandeilo formation of grey, blue, and purple slates and shale. c. Caradoc sandstone, composed of hard grey grits, with grey and blue schists, &c. Chap. IV.] CAER CARADOC — SHROPSHIRE. 81 These facts, as well as those which are generalized in the section below the map, being the record made by independent and competent observers since the time of my personal researches, demonstrate that the break or dislocation between the Caradoc and Llandeilo forma- tions (which together constitute the Lower Silurian rocks of the original classification) is purely a local phenomenon. And even in the tracts where these two formations have been physically disunited, we shall soon see that they are mutually so characterized by the same organic remains that they cannot be separated in any geological arrangement. In the typical Silurian tract of Shropshire, around the eruptive trap- pean rocks of Caer Caradoc, from whence the formation was named, it is indeed cut off from those inferior deposits, with which it is else- where so intimately associated, by a great mass of igneous rocks, and by a very powerful displacement or fault, which brings it against the Longmynd or bottom rocks. The annexed view of the bold ridge of the Caradoc hills is taken from the slope at the escarpment of the Longmynd, a little to the south of Church Stretton. The Lawley. Caer Caradoc. Hope Bowdler. Broccard's Castle. Ragleath. The Cakadoc Range. (Sketched by Mrs. S. Acton, from the eastern slopes of the Longmynd, overlooking the vale of Stretton, along which ran the old Roman road.) G 82 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. The Caradoc formation is unconformable, at least in its uppermost or calcareous member, to the Llandeilo flags and schists of the Corndon and Shelve district, around the ends of which it wraps in the manner laid down by the government surveyors. (See Map.) On the other hand, however, or towards the east, the formation ex- pands and gradually passes up into the Upper Silurian rocks of Wenlock and Ludlow. In the lithographic view, p. 26., taken from the eastern slopes of the Longmynd, the spectator overlooks this range of eruptive hills of Caer Caradoc, &c., which, flanked on the east by sandstones, are followed by distant ridges of overlying Upper Silurian rocks and old red sandstone, as in this section. Here it is of much more complex Relations of Caradoc Sandstone to the Upper Silurian Rocks in Shropshire. N.w. sj;. Caer Caradoc. Wenlock Edge. * Eruptive rocks, c*. Caradoc sandstone altered by eruptive rocks, c. Caradoc sandstone, &c. d. Wenlock rocks. e. Ludlow rocks. /. Old red sandstone. mineral structure than in North Wales and the mountains of Ead- norshire. For the Caradoc of Shropshire contains good freestone, flagstone, grit, and conglomerate, with courses of limestone and shelly sandstone, and with this composite stony character the formation is much more highly fossiliferous than in any district of Wales with which I am acquainted. The observer who has little time to spare may study the leading features of the deposit, in ascending order, by following the banks of the river Onny from the south-east flank of the Longmynd to Cheney Longville and the Craven Arms ; but he who would endeavour to recognize all its variable, lithological features, must examine the masses as they spread out on their strike to the north-east, and expand in their course from the environs of Acton Scott, by Soudley, Church Chap. IV.] CARADOC SANDSTONES OP SHROPSHIRE. 83 Preen, ChatwalL and Acton Burnell, to the tract on the Severn, between the Wrekin and Coalbrook Dale. In so doing, he will see how the upper portion, chiefly calcareous, dips everywhere con- formably under the Wenlock shale, or base of the Upper Silurian. Along this line he will also see how the lower beds have in many places been fused and changed into quartz rock, and their schistose parts converted into dark brittle clay-stones, wherever they are in contact with the igneous rocks of Caer Caradoc, the Lawley, &c.* As seen in the gorge of the river Onny, or in the various quarries of Soudley, Frodesley, Kenley, &c., the unaltered Caradoc sandstones are of considerable thickness. The lowest masses of the formation which are visible, consist of grits and fine-grained sandstones of brown- ish, yellowish, red, purple, and even white colours, sometimes striped dull red and yellowish brown, sometimes green, and in other instances they are variegated with spots and concretions. They thus resemble portions of the old red sandstone, carboniferous rocks, and even the newer red sandstones. Some of the beds are as easily worked into building stones, troughs, and tombstones as the freestones of those younger formations ; and, when remote from eruptive rocks, are, therefore, very dissimilar to the strata of precisely the same age which have been just mentioned as composing the hard rocks of Wales. The typical Caradoc sandstones of Shropshire are, indeed, remark- able in being the oldest strata of the British Isles which present such a comparatively modern aspect; it having been formerly the sterile privi- lege of the old " grey wacke " of this age to be considered useless except for the construction of rude buildings and stone walls. Such truly is the character of the same sandstones in North Wales, which have been adverted to in the opening pages of this chapter. And yet, notwithstanding this modern aspect, these rocks, as will presently * For a detailed account of the mineral structure of this eruptive range, and of the Wrekin, in which felspathic rocks abound, but in parts of which syenite and greenstone also occur, see Sil. Syst., p. 225. G 2 84 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. be shown, are charged with some of the oldest fossil types of the formation which lies far beneath them. The remains of fossils occur at intervals throughout the deposit in Shropshire, and often so abound as to render some of the courses shelly limestones, which have occasionally been burnt for use ; such local shelly developments being known to the workmen of the neigh- bourhood as " Jacob's Stones." Where the calcareous matter is more diffused in small particles through the mass, the rock becomes a hard calciferous grit, usually of a whitish drab colour, and breaking under the hammer with a conchoidal fracture, and a " chatoyant" lustre. On the banks of the Onny, between Horderly and Wistanstow, the calcareous matter so augments as to form a band of limestone, which is, however, chiefly a pebbly quartzose conglomerate in a cement of lime. Another course of limestone is found at the eastern flank or upper end of the formation. In their north-eastern prolongation to Church Preen and Chatwall, the pebbly and conglomerate beds are not calcareous. The recent cuttings of the Ludlow and Shrewsbury railroad have laid open several hillocks of the Caradoc sandstone, between Church Stretton and the Marsh-Brook station, the rocks of which consist of thick and thin bedded, dull, purple and red earthy sandstones, in parts finely micaceous, with usual partings of green earth, some courses of the shelly beds or Jacob's Stones," and brown calciferous grits. In the cutting nearest to Church Stretton, the rock is very earthy and incoherent, and in it I found Diplograpsus pristis, Foss. 7. f. 14., a common Lower Silurian species which occurs in the Llandeilo schists of South Wales and the Snow don group of North Wales. This variety of the Caradoc sandstone is very concretionary, exfoliates on weathering into balls, and is full of irregular joints, whose surfaces are coated with a film of the dark indigo- coloured oxide of iron which is so common in the Ludlow rocks. Mineralogi- cally, indeed, the formation has already begun to assume the structure Chap. IV.] CARADOC FORMATION, SHROPSHIRE. 85 of the Upper Silurian rocks, to the base of which its upper band is everywhere conformable in this tract. Besides the prevalent building-stones of Soudley and other places, where thick-bedded sandstones are separated by courses of shale, often of a dull greenish colour, surmounted by flags, there- is an inferior mass of shale often laden with fossils. Another variety of the Caradoc sandstone, which assimilates the formation to the in- ferior one of Llandeilo, consists of stratified bands, along the outer flanks of the Caradoc and Wrekin hills, which resemble the volcanic grits described in the last chapter. These sandstones are allied to greenstones of igneous origin, in being made up of green earth and felspar, with only a few fine scales of mica. Like certain strata of the inferior formation, they seem to indicate either a contemporaneous volcanic disturbance in the bottom of the sea, or, that they have been derived from pre-existing igneous rocks. My belief, however, is, that some of these beds were really the result of submarine volcanic dejections, thrown down in the sea-bottom whilst the Caradoc sand- stones were accumulating, and were the precursors of those sub- sequent copious outbursts of the felspar and other trap rocks of the Caradoc and Wrekin. The superior masses of the Caradoc formation in Shropshire, which are well displayed at Cheney Longville, and on the banks of the Onny where that river flow^s across the strata, are chiefly made up of fine-grained, sandy, thin flagstones, of gosling green and dingy olive colours, amidst which some beds of shale occur, with courses of grey-coloured shelly limestone.* Others of these calciferous sands and earthy greenish flagstones begin to assume a lithological aspect, frequent in the Upper Silurian rocks, and particularly in the Ludlow formation, to which other varieties of the rock above alluded to (to the south of Church Stretton) have also an affinity ; they are earthy ; with great spheroidal concretions, and with a general tendency to * The Asaphus Powisii was first found here. Pi. 2. f. 2. *G 3 86 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. exfoliate and decompose to mud. Thus, in composition, some of the varieties of the Caradoc sandstone connect it with the volcanic grit or ash of the Llandeilo formation, and others with the ordinary aqueous deposits of Upper Silurian age. The highest calcareous band of the Caradoc formation is visible on the Onny, and is traceable, to the N. E., by Acton Scott and the Hollies to Cressage and Buildwas.* In this range the portion of the rock which is calcareous, with beds of sandy shale and pipe-clay, dipping under the Wenlock shale, passes conformably upwards into that lowest member of the Upper Silurian rocks, as formerly so defined. (Sil. Syst., p. 217.) The fossils which most frequently occur in the heart of the Caradoc formation are as follow : Caradoc Fossils, 7. 1. Calymene Blumenbacliii. 2. Homalonotus bisulcatus, Salter, 3. Phacops truncato-caudatus, Portl. 4. Tentaculites annulatus. 5. Lingula crumena, Phill. 6. Orthis testudinaria, Dalm, * In a minute re-examination of this district, made by the Government Sm-veyors Avhilst these pages are passing through the press, I learn that they have detected, on the banks of the Onny, a small amount of unconformity between the uppermost of the limestones containing the Pentamerus oblongus and the fossils figured on the opposite page, and the subjacent beds of flagstone shale and impure limestone in which occur the fossils given on this page. That this transgression is local is manifest from the fact, that in other tracts the Caradoc Sandstone and Wenlock Shale are represented by the surveyors to undulate in perfect parallelism. Believing that the limestone with Pentamerus oblongus is truly the bed of transition from the lower to the upper group, it is still my conviction that it must, from its fossils, be classed with the former. For, although the Orthis alternata, Foss. 8. f. 6, (Avhich is a fossil of the beds sub- jacent), has been introduced, by mistake, into that woodcut, I must always consider that a band into which Trinucleus concentricus and Pentamerus oblongus range upwards from the Llan- deilo formation is truly Lower Silurian. I willingly admit that several of the other species of fossils in this bed. are common to the Wenlock and lower deposits ; a fact which strengthens my view of the unity of the Silurian system of life.— R. I. M., 28th May, 1853. Chap. IV.] TYPICAL CArVADOC FOSSILS. 87 7. O. vespertilio. 8. Strophomena tenuistriata. 9. S. grandis. 10. Bellerophon bilobatus. 11. B. ornatus, Conrad. 12. Orthonota nasuta, Conrad. 13. Nebulipora lens, M'Coy. 14. Diplograpsus pristis, His. 15. Graptolites priodon. In addition to the above, the following characteristic fossils are figured in plates 4 to 10., or in the woodcuts of the next chapter : ~ Orthis elegantula. 0. flabellulum. O.^Actoniae. O. calligramma (virgata, Sil. Syst.). Strophomena expansa. S. spiriferoides, M'Coy. Lep- taena sericea, Modiolopsis orbicularis (Avicula, Sil. Syst.). M. modiolaris, Conrad. M. obliqua. Bellerophon acutus. Phacops conophthalmus, Eichw. (Asaphus Powisii, head of, Sil. Syst.). The species with no author's name attached are published in the " Silurian System." After this mention of the chief fossils of this formation, the atten- tion of the reader is again called to the fact that, notwithstanding the differences between the lithological character of these strata of Cara- doc sandstone and those of the Llandeilo formation, all the above- mentioned species of fossils prevail in both deposits ; thus absolutely uniting them in one natural group. Even in the very uppermost stratum of the Caradoc formation, which here graduates into the Wenlock shale and true Upper Silurian Rocks, there are several species, such as the Petraia elongata, Foss. 8. f. 11.; Leptaena sericea, pi. 6. f. 13.; Orthis calligramma, Foss. 14. f. 3.; Trinucleus concentricus (T. Caractaci, Sil. Syst.), pi. 4. f. 2 — 5. ; Pentamerus undatus, pi. 8. f. 5. ; Tentaculites annulatus, Foss. 7. f. 4., &c., which are known to occur on the flanks of Snowdon, or in beds of the Llandeilo age in North and South Wales. Upper Caradoc Fossils, 8. 1. Pentamerus lens. 2. P. oblongus. 3. P. liratus, Sow. 4. Atrypa hemisphaerica. 5. A. reticularis. 6. Orthis alternata. 7. Strophomena compressa. 8. Holopella cancellata. 9. Bellerophon trilobatus. 10. Encrinurus punctatus. 11. Petraia elongata, Pliill. G 4 88 S1L¥RIA. TChap. IV. The above woodcut, Foss. 8., exhibits the chief characteristic fossils of this upper band, some of them, as above stated, being com- mon in the inferior strata ; whilst others, such as the Atrypa hemi- sphaerica, f. 4. ; A. reticularis, f. 5. ; Pentamerus liratus, f. 3. ; P. lens, f. 1. ; and Holopella cancellata, f. 8., are more characteristic of this horizon. On the other hand, Encrinurus punctatus, f. 10., and Bellerophon trilobatus, f. 9., are of frequent occurrence in the Upper Silurian group, of which hereafter. It is therefore manifest that, to whatever extent dislocations may- have acted in producing to the west of the Longmynd in Shropshire, or in some parts of Wales, a break between the Llandeilo and the Caradoc formations, as before explained, or may have excluded the mass of the Caradoc, as is seen along the south end of the Longmynd, the operations were purely local, and had no influence whatever in destroying the races of animals that inhabited the seas of that long period. Those marine creatures lived on ; some of them (judging from their remains) becoming more abundant when the upper Cara- doc beds were accumulated, than when the much older mud and sand which afterwards formed the slates of Snowdon were deposited. With such clear and strong zoological proofs, and the evidences of conformable transition and succession in some portions of this region, which have been already given, the government surveyors, who ob- served the transgressions alluded to, have decided that my general classification was correct. In defining the course of the Lower Silurian Rocks along their eastern or superior frontier, from Shropshire through those counties of South Wales which were included in the region of my former ex- amination, or from the eastern parts of Radnor, Brecon, Carmar- then, to the south of Pembroke, I announced that the Caradoc formation there became unusually thin, and was with diflficulty separable from the Llandeilo flags. \ Chap. IV.] UPPER CARADOC, EAST RADNOR. 89 Strictly, however, considered us the Caradoc of Shropshire, the formation is seen to protrude along a line of fault as an isolated patch* among the Wenlock shale of Brampton Bryan Park, and is again visible further to the S. W. at two points in Radnorshire, the one in a dome to the south of the town of Presteign, the other on the western slopes of the hill of Old Radnor. (See Map.) In these examples it is a quartzose, pebbly conglomerate, passing into a hard greywacke grit (Gorton), in which casts of the Pentamerus oblongus and other characteristic fossils occur, such as Atrypa hemisphserica, and very abundantly Petraia elongata and P. bina. Along this line it is also obviously the uppermost bed of the formation as brought up in domes and arches by a line of igneous eruption, which in evolving the adjacent crystalline hypersthene and felspathic rocks of Stanner, Hanter, and Ousel, has so altered the contiguous sand- stones, schists, and grits (just as around the Wrekin, and the Caer Caradoc) that in Old Radnor Hill and Yat Hill it is difficult to determine which parts of it are metamorphosed rocks resulting from the effect of volcanic eruption, and which have really been in a molten state. The diagrams illustrating this phenomenon, including the metamorphosis of the limestone of Nash Scar, will be given in the next chapter, which treats of the Wenlock formation. In that district of Radnorshire, the uppermost Caradoc is a silicious grit and conglomerate, and is at once conformably surmounted by shale and limestone, which, from their fossils, are grouped with the Wenlock formation of the Upper Silurian rocks, as will be hereafter explained (pp. 102. et seq.). At Corton, near Presteign, where the order is clear, the old exca- vations or quarries exhibit the strata thus ; — the lower beds of the Wenlock formation dipping away from the side of a dome of coarse and pebbly Caradoc sandstone, laden with casts of the Pentamerus oblongus. * Discovered by iny friend the Rev. T. T. Lewis. 90 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. S. c. Caradoc sandstone. d. Lower Wenlock shale with lime- stone (Woolhope), see Chap. G. (7.) Gravel of the Valley of Pres- g?^.fi teign. But whilst we have in this north-eastern part of Radnor, as in Shropshire, so clear and conformable a succession from the Caradoc to the Wenlock formation, we behold a very different state of things by merely following the strata to the south-west into another part of the same county. There, between Llaudegley and Builth, the Llandeilo formation is brought at once into unconformable contact with the Upper Silurian Rocks ; the Caradoc formation being entirely omitted. Nothing short of a most powerful dismemberment will account for such contrasting positions of the strata, as are here ex- hibited in diagrams taken from the large horizontal sections of the survey. In fact, the Llandeilo Rocks must have been upheaved and removed from the influence of those waters under which the Caradoc sand was accumulated, to be afterwards submerged and covered by Upper Silurian strata. Both of the following transverse parallel sections pass across a tract in which the Lower Silurian rocks (Llandeilo), with their Asaphi, Trinuclei, and interposed trap, and also the Upper Silurian Rocks, were formerly described; but I did not then represent what the government surveyors have since made out, the distinct overlap of one set of beds upon the other, and which shows how the equivalent of the Caradoc is entirely omitted. Unconformable Relations of Llandeilo Flags and Upper Silurian. Near Builth. (Taken from Horizontal Sections of the Government Survey.) S.E. N.W. Chap. IV.] LOWER SILURIAN OR MALVERN HILLS, 91 S.E. N.W. c " b ' * b * b * b. Llandeilo formation with Ogygia Buchii, &c. * Trap rocks, d. Wenlock shale resting on the uplifted edges of b, the Caradoc sandstone (or c) being entirely omitted. e. Lower Ludlow. /. Upper Ludlow. The relations of the silicious strata in the neighbourhood of Llan- dovery and Llandeilo have been previously explained, and the reasons assigned for having formerly considered such beds to be the re- presentatives, though in a very diminished form, of the Caradoc of Shropshire. Seeing in that tract the comparative tenuity of all the formations above the Llandeilo, I simply termed the whole of the inferior mass *^ Lower Silurian," as distinguished from another and overlying mass of small thickness, which, being wanting in subdivisionary characters, was called "Upper Silurian" (see sections, p. 72, 73.). It was only in those examples, where strata between the lowest beds with true Llandeilo fossils, and others with Upper Silurian fossils, were of a sandy or silicious nature, that I applied the word Caradoc. And there is, in truth, so perfectly an apparent conformity between all these Silurian rocks in Carmarthenshire (the whole being within the range of a bomb-shell,) that if the phenomena of a disturbance and overlap had not been worked out in another part of the region, any field geologist, looking simply to the order of the beds, the character of the imbedded fossils, and the structure of the rocks, must have come to the same conclusion as myself, and have viewed the sandy strata of Carmarthenshire which lie above the black flags of Llandeilo, as the meagre extensions of a formation which, as Caradoc sandstone, is fully developed only in the more northern tracts of this region. (See coloured sections, Sil. Syst., PI. 34.) The dwindling out of the masses of sandstone in their range from north to south, as laid down in the map (No. 3.), sufficiently indicate the phenomenon. 92 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. Lower Silurian of the Malvern Hills, Woolhope, May Hill, 8fc. — Though less copious in dimensions than in North Wales and Shrop- shire, the Lower Silurian rocks have, to a considerable extent, their representatives on the western flank of the crystalline and syenitic range of the Malvern Hills. The little sketch here annexed repre- sents the northern half of the Malvern Hills, or the North Hill, with the Worcester, and Hereford Beacons, as seen from the undulating grounds below Mathon Lodge, or near the outward flank of the Silurian rocks, the mass of which occupy the intermediate and un- dulating low hills. North Hill. "Worcester Beacon. Hereford Beacon. View of the Malvern Hills from the West. (From a Sketch by Lady Murchison, Sil. Syst., p. 409.) The black schists which rise up to the surface in the elevated grounds between the higher syenitic hills and Eastnor Castle, and which lie to the south-east of the foreground of the preceding sketch, were formerly described by me as probably of the age of the Llandeilo form- ation.* A subsequent discovery made in them by Professor Phillips of the small trilobite Olenus, and a recent one by Mr. Strickland of the Agnostus pisiformis, fossils which are peculiar to the lowest Silurian zone of other countries, have extended that view, and have led me to believe that the black Malvernian schists, however diminutive, may be as old even as the Lingula beds of North Wales. In another chapter, and when treating of the Silurian rocks of Norway and * Silurian System, p. 416. Chap. IV.] LOWER SILURIAN OF MALVERN HILLS. 93 Sweden, it will be shown, that mere thickness of strata is no true test of their age nor of the time which may have elapsed in their de- position. The hundreds of feet in the beds on the west flank of the Malverns may, in short, be the equivalents in time of thousands of feet of strata in North Wales. I also showed, in my former work, the existence of sandstones which, overlying these black schists, and charged with fossils, truly represented the Caradoc sandstone in structure and in fossils. The geologist must, however, consider my first publication as an outline descriptive only of the chief features of these remarkable hills, the detailed features of which have since been more elaborately and ably worked out by Professor J. Phillips, to another of whose discoveries attention will presently be called. On this occasion I must chiefly restrict myself to the notice of a few data which have been brought to light since the publication of the " Silurian System." In a recent excursion* I observed, what had not before been detected ; that the same black schists and sandy flagstones, or a portion of them, which constitute the lowest fossil-bearing sediment of the tract, are thrown off to the east as well as to the west of the eruptive or syenitic chain, at Midsummer Hill to the S. of the Hereford Beacon. This is seen in traversing the ridge near its south end, from Keys End Street on the east, by the White- leaved Oak, to the first arable ground on the west. The Mal- verns are therefore represented in the following diagram, as exhibiting a geological saddle, having a thin and partially metamorphosed flap only on the east side, and several thick flaps on the west, the lower part only of one of which is in an altered condition. Among the oldest strata which are visible on the east flank are the same black schists subordinate to sandy flags, which on the western slope of the ridge of syenite have given to the ground the name of Coal Hill f, * This excursion was made in company with Mr. H, E. Strickland and the Rev. W. P. Brodie. t Absurd trials for coal have been made by ignorant persons in this black Lower Silurian shale on both sides of the eruptive axis. 94 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. and in wHich Professor Phillips has detected the three species of Olenus already mentioned. The reader of my former work will therefore be pleased to look at the woodcut (Sil. Syst. p. 418., and coloured section, pi. 36. f. 8., of that work) as somewhat incomplete, and will understand that the facts are more correctly expressed in this little diagram. Section from the Malvern Hills to Ledbury. W. E. Ledbury. Eastnor. Malvern Hills- j i h g f e f g f e d c b b* * b* This woodcut, as taken from a coloured section in the " Silurian System," and slightly modified (pi. 36. f. 8,), explains the general order and the undulations on the west side of the Malvern Hills, in the parallel of Midsummer Hill, Eastnor Park, and Ledbury. The eruptive rocks * of the Malvern ridge on the right are seen to be flanked, on both sides, by altered Lower Silurian sandstones and schists, b *. To the west these are followed by other schists with Olenus, ft, and Caradoc sandstones and conglomerates, c, the upper portion of which dip down from the Obelisk Hill of Eastnor, and pass under the Woolhope, or Lower Wenlock limestone, d. The latter is followed by the Wenlock shale, e, and the Wenlock lime- stone, /, which last, bending under the Lower Ludlow, g, reappears in a dome that throws oflF towards Ledburj' the whole of the Ludlow formation, h i, after a flexure in Wellington Heath under the old red sandstone, j. Although it is not within the scope of this volume to describe in detail the former effects of the eruptive molten matter in transmuting the character and condition of the sediments through which it burst forth, still I would beg any geological student who has it in his power to examine this natural section. He will then see that as the strata which flank the ridge on either side approach to its centre, which is composed of igneous rocks, they gradually become more hard and brittle, and that, their flaglike character gradually ceasing, the beds pass into thick and subcrystalline amorphous' masses, in which the lines of bedding are lost, and the substance is much altered and fissured by many devious joints with serpentinous coatings. The cen- tral or eruptive mass, as exposed in the extensive quarries of Mid- summer Hill, near the White-leaved Oak, is a compact felspar rock, passing into syenite, but, as formerly noted, the northern extensions of Chap. IV.] SILURIAN ROCKS — MALVERN HILLS. 95 this same eruptive ridge, as seen in the Worcestershire Beacon and the North Hill, contain many other varieties of igneous rocks, such as syenite having a very granitic aspect, greenstone, epidote rock, &c. But returning to the Silurian succession. The Upper and greater portion of the Lower Silurian rocks of the Malvern district were first classed by myself, and subsequently by Professor Phillips, with the Caradoc formation. In my own work they were described as sand- stones and conglomerates, often of purplish, sometimes of green and brownish tints, in which many of the same species of shells occur as in Shropshire and other localities.* Assigning to the Lower Silurian of the Malverns a thickness of 2000 feet, Professor Phillips correctly states, that the Holly-bush sandstone, which contains no fossils except fucoids, is the bottom of the whole series, and even underlies the black shale with certain small points of interposed (intruded ?) trap rock or greenstone. Above the black Olenus shale commence the purple and grey conglomerate and sandstone, called Caradoc sand- stone, here of about 1000 feet thick, as seen at Howler's Heath, Eastnor Obelisk, &c. In delineating with great precision the order of the strata with their flexures and breaks. Professor Phillips discovered, on the west side of the Worcestershire Beacon, that one of the local conglomerates of the Caradoc age, and charged with several of the characteristic fossils, contained also pebbles and fragments of the syenite and other eruptive rocks of the Malvern chain. Hence it was evident, that along this line there had been eruptions which had left a shore or island of hard rock from which the Caradoc conglomerate in question had been derived. It is, however, to be inferred that the eruption, to which I have called attention, at the White-leaved Oak and Keys End Hill, took place at a more remote period, and even that the erupted matter traversed the oldest Silurian strata of the tract, or the Holly-bush sandstones. This agency having ceased, a low ridge * This is the green sandstone described, Sil. Syst. pp. 416 — 418. 96 SILURIA. " [Chap. IV. seems to have been left, to be acted upon by the sea of the subsequent epoch, so as to furnish the fragments of a younger portion of the Caradoc formation. The posterior elevation of the Malvern Hills in a solid state, at a subsequent period, together with the folding back of the strata, so as partially to invert the order and place the Caradoc grits over the Wenlock shale (a phenomenon first pointed out by Mr. Leonard Horner as due to the uprise of the syenite), is one of great interest, and which occurs on a vast scale in the Alps and other countries.* At present, however, I must pass from the consideration of this physical feature, to other natural appearances on the flank of the Malvern Hills, described by Professor Phillips and myself, to show how difficult it is to draw any definite line between the uppermost member of the Caradoc formation and the lowest portion of the overlying Wenlock shale. To the west of the Worcestershire Beacon, or near the north end of the chain, there occurs an impure limestone, occupying precisely the same position at the summit of the Caradoc sandstone, properly so called, as the Hollies limestone of Shropshire (p. 86. )• Now, although this rock contains some fossils which truly belong to the lower group, such as Leptaena sericea, Atrypa hemisphaerica, and Orthis calligramma, it possesses others which are characteristic of the Upper Silurian division. At Woolhope, how- ever, as will hereafter be shown, a limestone occupying nearly the same position is, through every one of its imbedded fossils, an indis- putable member of the Wenlock formation. In Shropshire, on the contrary, the calcareous zone which separates the Lower from the Upper Silurian rocks pertains preeminently, as we have seen, through its organic remains, to the lower, whilst in * This overthrow of the strata, together with an excellent account of the mineral structure of the Malvern Hills, was first given by Mr. Leonard Horner, Geol. Trans., old series, vol. i. p. 281. The nature and succession of the overthrown beds were illustrated in detail by myself, Silurian System, p. 423., and lastly by Professor Phillips, Memoirs Geol. Survey, vol. ii. p. 67. et seq. Chap. IV.J PASSAGE FROM LOWER TO UPPER SILURIAN. 97 Radnorshire, a limestone apparently or very nearly in the same position is altogether Upper Silurian in its fossils. The truth is, that in some tracts we must expect to meet with links, both lithological and zoological, which thus bind together the inferior and superior divisions of the system ; whilst in other districts, their separation will be more neatly marked. The reader may compare my original description of this inter- mediary band of limestone, as it ranges by Stumps Wood and other places west of the Malverns, with the more precise details of Pro- fessor Phillips.* For although it is quite clear that transitions like those above men- tioned must be looked for, and have in fact been found to exist, over large areas of the earth's surface, it is well known that a mass of sedi- ment which in one tract is calcareous often becomes sandy and argil- laceous in another ; and thus in such cases very close examination of the fossils can alone decide the exact line of demarcation. In re- ference to the original Silurian region, the uppermost limb of the Caradoc formation, if fossils decide the case, is an argillaceous lime- stone in Shropshire, and in Radnorshire a pure siliceous grit ; though the localities before alluded to are only a few miles distant from each other. These local extensions of limestone will be still more instruc- tively explained in describing the order of the Upper Silurian rocks. In May and Huntley Hills in Gloucestershire, the Caradoc form- ation, consisting of conglomerate and sandstone, with certain cha- racteristic fossils, indicates a mineral transition upwards into the Wenlock formation through alternating beds of sandstone with shale and impure limestone, which are of considerable thickness. It is * In his memoir of the Malvern and Abberley hills, and their extension to Woolhope, May Hill, &c., Professor Phillips has skilfully and elaborately de- veloped all the physical contortions of the strata in this district, and the mineral and palceontological characters of the rocks. He has further imparted great value to his work by the philosophical reflections with which it is interspersed. It is a monograph which reflects high credit on the Geological Survey of Great Britain. H 98 SILURIA. [Chap. IV. to some of these upper and transition beds of sandstone at May Hill, that Professor Sedgwick has recently directed attention* as being almost exclusively charged with fossils, which Professor M'Coy refers to the Wenlock age. The government surveyors, as well as myself, have, however, collected Pentamerus lens, if not P. oblongus, from the same strata ; both species being in my opinion typical of the lower division. Such transitions and fossiliferous changes must, I repeat, be looked for in the range of all sedimentary systems, and this case, serves only, in my opinion, better to link together the Lower and Upper Silurian rocks.f This subject will be specially reverted to in the eighth and ninth Chapters. * On the separation of the Caradoc sandstone, into two distinct groups. Geol. Soc. Nov. 1852. ^ t In a minute re- examination of the Caradoc district of Shropshire, made by the Government Surveyors whilst these pages are passing through the press, I learn that they have detected on the banks of the Onny a certain amount of unconformity between the uppermost of the limestones (containing Pentamerus oblongus, and the other fossils, figured p. 88.), and those subjacent beds of flagstone, shale, and sandstone, in which, with a few of the same species, the great mass of fossils are those figured in the woodcut Foss. 7. That this physical break is a local phenomenon only, is manifest from the fact, that in some other tracts all the strata of Llandeilo, Caradoc, and Wenlock age are represented by the same surveyors to undulate in perfect parallelism. (Borders of Radnor and Mont- gomery.) It is still my conviction, that whilst the limestone with the Pentamerus oblongus is what I always considered it — the bed of transition from the lower to the upper group, — it ought still, from its fossils, to be rather classed with the former than the latter. For, although the Orthis alternaia^ which is found in the subjacent sandstone beds, has been introduced by mistake into the woodcut Foss. 8., I cannot admit that a band into which Pentamerus oblongus and Trinucleus con- centricus range upwards from the Llandeilo formation, can be otherwise than Lower Silurian. And if several of the other species in this bed are common to the Wenlock, as well as to the inferior deposits, of which there is no doubt, this circumstance only strengthens my view respecting the unity of the Silurian System. In this survey with Mr. Aveline, Mr. Salter observed some new quarries of Caradoc sandstone, to one of which the collector is particularly directed. It is at Gretton, near Cardington. All the characteristic Lower Silurian fossils may be there obtained in a very brief space of time in true and original Caradoc sandstone. Chap. IV.] RESUME OF LOWER SILURIAN. 99 The most eastern tract in England where the Caradoc sandstone has been protruded to the surface is at the lower Lickey Hills in Worcestershire, and again near Barr in Staffordshire, at both of which localities it supports the base of the Upper Silurian rocks of the adjacent tracts of Dudley and Walsall. At the Lickey, low heathy hills, which are in truth miniature mountains, are chiefly composed of quartz rocks, identical with those masses on the flanks of the Caradoc and Wrekin which have been formed by the fusion of the same sandstone. The Lickey quartz probably owes its litho- logical character to a similar cause ; though in this case the internal heat has not found issue to the surface in the form of trap rock as in Shropshire. In other words, the Lickey quartz rock is supposed to be on a line of former eruption. On its flank this rock graduates into an ordinary grit or sandstone, in which the Pentamerus oblongus occurs, and thus all doubt of its age is removed ; whilst just as in the other tracts above mentioned, this sandstone, particularly on its eastern and southern parts (Colmers and Kendal End), is conformably surmounted by a calcareous shale with a thin course of limestone which, as at Woolhope, Gorton near Presteign, and Old Radnor, con- tains Upper Silurian fossils. In concluding this chapter, we remind the reader that the Caradoc formation has been shown by stratigraphical, lithological, and zoolo- gical proofs to be an integral part of the Lower Silurian rocks, and that its most characteristic fossils are species which also occur in the inferior Llandeilo rocks. It was at the summit of this Caradoc sandstone that I long ago drew the line of demarcation be- tween the inferior and superior masses of the Silurian system ; and observations, since extended to many distant regions, have confirmed the general truthfulness of that division. H 2 100 SILURIA. [Chap. V. CHAPTER V. UPPER SILURIAN ROCKS. GENERAL CHARACTEK OF THE UPPER SILURIAN ROCKS, AS DIVIDED INTO THE WEN- LOCK AND LUDLOW FORMATIONS. THE WENLOCK FORMATION OF SHALE AND LIMESTONE, WITH ITS CHIEF FOSSILS, DESCRIBED IN ASCENDING ORDER. In many parts of the region of England and Wales now under con- sideration, wherever the lower strata of the age of the Wenlock formation are seen to rest upon the older rocks which have been last described, they are linked together in conformable positions; the upper bands of the lower group graduating insensibly into the de- posits we are now about to consider. Of this succession several examples have, indeed, been already cited. (See section below Map). As the older schists and slates of Wales were assuredly at one period nothing more than finely laminated marine mud, so is it still more apparent that such was the former state of the greater portion of the Upper Silurian ; for even at the present day it is an accumulation of similar materials, though in a softer and less coherent state. Whether these argillaceous masses be examined in the wilds of Radnor Forest and the eastern parts of Montgomery, in the western parts of Shropshire (Long Mountain), or in many tracts of North and South Wales (see Map), they present the same " facies " of a thick, yet finely laminated, dark, dull grey shale, in which hard stone of any strength or persistence is the rare exception. Their dominant character is that of " mudstone." Ranging chiefly from S. W. to N. E., and resting conformably upon Chap. V.] UPPER SILURIAN ORDER. 101 Caradoc and lower rocks, in numerous undulations*, these mudstones assume, however, in Denbighshire a much harder, flaglike character, and there they have even been so subjected to the influence of a crys- talline transverse cleavage as occasionally to form roofing slates. On the whole, however, the Upper Silurian rocks of North Wales have very much the lithological structure of large masses of the Lower Silurian of South Wales, where slaty cleavage has only so far operated as to leave the mass in that disjointed, incoherent state of mudstone, the " rotch " of the natives, so useless to the mason and the miner, and so cold and profitless to the agriculturist. In all such tracts, where the subdividing limestones are absent, or very feebly indicated, it is only by close observation of the imbedded fossils, that the formations, so clear and typical in other parts, can be recognized. When, on the contrary, we follow the same deposits from North and South Wales to the exemplar tracts of Herefordshire and Shropshire, where the Upper Silurian rocks were first classified and described, we find them diversified by interpolated courses of limestone; much calcareous matter being also disseminated, both in nodules and in flagstones. With additions like these to the richness and variety of the subsoil, which are so welcome to the proprietor and farmer, the geologist usually discovers a much greater abundance of fossil animal remains than in the same strata of the sterile western tracts. By observing the order of superposition, and by tracing the divisionary limestones, he reads off the order of the strata, and chronicles with precision the succession of their respective fossils. * The strike of the same deposits varies in different districts. Thus, in North Wales, the prevalent strike is nearly N.N.E. to S. S.W. In Shropshire the prevalent direction is nearly N.E., S. W. ; whilst in S. Pembroke all the Silurian rocks range from W. by N. to E, by S., in conformity with the direction of the great South Welsh coal-field (see Map). The conformable undulations of the Caradoc and Wenlock formations in various parts of Wales are represented in several of the published horizontal sections of the Government Survey. H 3 1 02 SILURIA. [Chap. V. In this way the Upper Silurian rocks are seen to consist, as a whole, of the two formations to which I assigned the names of Wenlock and Ludlow ; each of these being subdivided in the manner expressed in this woodcut. General Order of the Upper Silurian Rocks between the Caradoc Sandstone BENEATH, AND THE OlD ReD SaNDSTONE ABOVE THEM. c. Pentamerus limestone on the summit of the Caradoc sandstone.* d^. Wenlock shale with Lower or Woolhope limestone, d^. Wenlock shale, d^. Wenlock limestone, e i. Lower Ludlow. e 2. Middle Ludlow or Aymestry limestone. e^. Upper Ludlow. /. Bottom of Old Red Sandstone. The inferior member of the Wenlock formation which rests on the Caradoc sandstone, as seen in Shropshire and parts of Wales, is chiefly a mass of dull argillaceous dark grey shale, rarely if ever micaceous. Strictly speaking, there is no band of limestone (like d^) subordi- nate to the lower shale below the escarpment of Wenlock Edge in Shropshire ; the rock to which attention is now called being there merely represented, as also in some other tracts, by calcareous nodules. In following the formation from Shropshire into Herefordshire, the great limestone, d^, above the shale, is seen on the banks of the Lugg, west of Aymestry, to be diminished to a thin irregular stratum chiefly concretionary. Further to the south-west, and in Radnorshire, that rock, still diminishing, disappears entirely amid the mudstones above alluded to ; but, to the south of Presteign, an inferior course of limestone sets in in the lowest part of the Wenlock shale. This rock {d^ of the diagram), which has been alluded to in the last chapter, merits special attention. * It has been explained, pp. 86. 98., that the limestone with Pentamerus ob- longus, which rises from beneath the Wenlock shale, is still grouped by me with the Lower Silurian of Britain. For Russia and N. America, see chaps. 13. 15. Chap, v.] LOWEST WENLOCK ROCKS. 103 An examination of quarries now abandoned at Gorton, one mile south of Presteign, shows indeed, that this limestone is fairly subordinate to a shale (there of black colour), which rests on the Caradoc grit and conglomerate before described ; as expressed in this diagram, which is reproduced from p. 90. Lower Wenlock at Corton, near Presteign. c. Cai-adoc sandstone, or coarse Corton girt, with Pentamerus S. Corton. „ Presteign. N. oblongus, &c. d^. Lower Wen- lock shale and Woolhope or Lower Wenlock limestone, q. Gravel of the Valley of Pre- steign. e q And again, at Haxwell, a similar arrangement w^as visible some years ago. But between these two upcasts of the Caradoc sand- stone, which exhibit the true relations of the strata, lies the large and loftier rock of Nash Scar, in which the same limestones, whether thick-bedded or nodular, have been run together into one amorphous mass, in which the stratified character has been destroyed, and the shale driven off, as expressed in this diagram.* Altered Amorphous Limestone of Nash Scar. (From Sil. Syst., p. 313.) c. Arch of Caradoc sandstone throwing off limestone and shale (Woolhope), d followed by d *, or amorphous altered limestone, o. Caverns. In tracing the strata southwards along this axis, other masses of limestone more or less amorphous are seen near Old Kadnor, which, in proportion as they approach the eruptive masses of Stanner and * As the rocks of Nash Scar and Old Radnor are the only great masses of lime- stone in this region, there being no other between this district and the sea-coast, they are of high value to the Welsh proprietors ; the lime being transported to very great distances westwards. H 4 104 SILURIA. [Chap. V. Hanter rocks, and Ousel Hill, or the highly metamorphosed rock of Old Radnor and Yat Hill, are themselves subcrystalline, and unbedded, with coatings of serpentine upon the surfaces of the joints. On the other hand, on receding westwards from that line of eruption and metamorphism, into the Vale of Radnor, to the south- east of Harpton Court*, the limestone begins to resume its bedded character, resting on the pebbly Caradoc conglomerates which range by Old Radnor church and Yat Hill. Whilst this section, taken from one of the coloured sections of the Government Survey, ex- hibits the syenite and greenstone of Hanter Hill throwing off the Ludlow rocks to the south-east, it is also suggestive of the fact, that another body of igneous rock lies subjacent to the Caradoc con- glomerate and crystalline limestone of Old Radnor and Yat Hill, where the coatings of serpentine and brecciated and altered features of the stratified rocks are, in the eye of the geologist, conclusive evidences in favour of such relations. N.W. Yat Hill. Hanter Hill. S.E. e. Ludlow rocks, d"^. Wenlock shale, rfi. Woolhope or Lower Wenlock limestone (par- tially altered), c. Caradoc sandstone (in parts altered). *. Eruptive rocks. (Syenite, Greenstone, and Hypersthene rock.) The eruptive rocks of this tract are very picturesque, and as they offer, in a very small compass, phenomena which characterize large mountain masses, a sketch of them is annexed. The spectator is placed near the south-eastern foot of Stanner rocks, near Kington, which are charged with hypersthene, a mineral which, though common in some foreign countries, and abounding at Loch Scavig, in Skye, has hitherto been found in one other British locality only. * The seat of my esteemed friend the Right Hon. Sir T. Frankland Lewis, who, with his son, Mr. George Lewis, first urged me to put together all my geological documents respecting this region, and thus form the work afterwards called the " Silurian System." Chap. V.] OLD RADNOR LIMESTONE AND TRAP. 105 Hanter. Ousel. Stanner Rocks. View from Stanner Rocks (Ousal Wood, Hanter Hill, and Hergest Ridge being successively seen in the distance). (From Sil. Syst, p. 31 L) Although the greater expansion in Radnorshire of the lower Wenlock limestone, as compared with the few nodular beds of Shropshire, must have been in a great measure due to the original deposit, the form of which, in an unaltered state, is well seen near Presteign, its amorphorus and massive condition at Nash Scar and Old Radnor was doubtless caused by the action of heat issuing along a line of former linear fissure, which, in some places, evolved the hypersthenic rocks and greenstones of Stanner, Ousel, and Hanter, upon the line in question, fused the stratified limestone and the calcareous nodules of the shale into amorphous and heterogeneous masses, more or less crystalline, leaving coatings and films of serpentine on their faces and joints. All the fossils which have been found in the limestone of this tract, whether by Mr. Edward Davis, who discovered most of them, and specially assisted me in studying them, or subsequently by the government surveyors, are truly Wenlock and Upper Silurian forms. 106 SILURIA. [Chap. V. Some of these, such as the trilobites Bumastus Barrlensis, Phacops caudatus, Encrinurus yariolaris, with the shells Leptaena laevigata, and Xerita prototypa, large encrinite stems, and several corals, are well known published fossils of the limestones of Wenlock and Dudley* ; and in addition to these, even the Pentamerus Knightii has also been found, which, as wiU hereafter be stated, is a very marked fossil of the Ludlow formation. Wenlock formation of Woolhope, the Malvern Hills, May Hill, ^T. — In describing the upward development of the Silurian rocks on the we^t flank of the Malvern Hills, a limestone in the same position was described by me as containing a mixture of Caradoc and "Wenlock fossils, and it was shown how somewhat further to the south the same stratum becomes an integral part of the Wenlock formation. It is, however, on the outside of the inner dome of the symmetrical valley of elevation of Woolhope, that the lower Wenlock zone is most clearly exposed. Having been raised equably on the outward face of a central dome or nucleus of sandstone, the nature of the calcareous deposit can be seen in detail on the sides of the roads, whilst the best limestones, which have been largely opened out since I described the tract, afford numerous fossils which were unknown when the " Silurian System " was published.! Sectiox across the elevated Valley of Woolhope. (From SiL Syst.) W.S.W. E.N.E. c. Caradoc sandstone, rfi. Woolhope or Lower Wenlock limestone and shale, d*. Wenlock shale, d^. Wenlock limestone, e^. Lower Ludlow, e^. Middle Ludlow, or Aymestry limestone, e^. Upper Ludlow. /. Old Red Sandstone (base of). * See SU. Svst. p. 313. t It was my want of acquaintance with any of these fossils in the limestone of Woolhope (for they were unknown when I wrote), that led me to class this rock with the upper part of the Caradoc; for if fossils should be detected in it, I naturally inferred that they would be the same as those of a limestone in a similar position in Shropshire, which, from its containing Pentamerus oblongus, was classed by me as the Uppermost Caradoc. (See pp. 86. 98.) Chap, v.] WOOLHOPE OR LOWER WENLOCK LIMESTONE. 107 In ascending order, the beds may be thus described. The top of the Caradoc, or the central dome of Woolhope, c, with its transition beds, is a greenish earthy sandstone, containing the following fossils : Pentamerus lens (Atrypa, Sil. Syst.), Atrypa reticularis. Linn. (A. affinis, Sil. Syst.), Petraia bina, Lonsdale. This course is followed by shale with calcareous, gritty flag- stones, containing the large Pentamerus liratus (Atrypa lirata, Sil. Syst.), Foss. 8. f. 3., and in the more nodular portions abundance of Leptsena transversalis and Atrypa reticularis. Then succeed layers of an impure earthy limestone, containing Stro- phomena depressa, a species which, though occurring in the Lower Silurian rocks of North Wales, becomes much more abundant in the Wenlock formation. In the next overlying bands of shale, calcareous matter so increases as to form strong beds of dark, indigo-coloured, argillaceous limestone, which, as on the west flank of the Malverns, is characterized by cross veins of pink and white calcareous spar. The strongest bed (about 10 feet thick) is a tough, impure, earthy limestone, largely extracted for the roads, which again is covered by a band of purer limestone, followed by shale and an upper bastard limestone. Now, although the whole of this subformation, d ^, does not contain limestone courses which have an united thickness exceeding 20 or 30 feet ; still the rock, together with its interpolated beds of sandy shale, is seen to occupy a very great surface on the map, from its being so equably spread out at a low angle of inclination. Among the chief fossils of the limestone, which I have recently collected on the spot, are the two trilobites of the following woodcut, viz. Bumastus Barriensis, Foss. 9. f. 2., and Homalonotus delphinoce- phalus, f. 1. There are also Phacops caudatus (Asaphus, Sil. Syst.) ; Cornulites serpularius ; Orthoceras annulatum ; Phrag- moceras sp. ; Euomphalus sculptus ; Spirifer elevatus ; Stropho- mena Phillipsi (imbrex, Davidson) ; S. pecten ; S. depressa ; Leptsena 108 SILURIA. [Chap. V. trans versalis, Dalm. ; Orbicula Forbesii ; Atrypa reticularis ; Rhyn- conella Wilsoni, &c. ; and rarely Orthis elegantula. Fossils, 9. Trilobites of the Lower AVenlock or Woolhope Limestone. These figures are about one third the natural size. Here again, as in Radnorshire, we have a great predominance of true Wenlock fossils, and one, the Rhynconella Wilsoni, which, as will presently be seen, is most abundant in the highest Silurian division, or Ludlow rocks ; and thus in every respect, whether as to position or fossils, the Woolhope and Radnorshire limestones are identical. The overlying shale, d'^, and the great limestone, d^, of the preceding section of Woolhope, p. 106., are precisely the same as the chief masses of the Wenlock Edge, and these are surmounted by the Ludlow rocks, e, which dip under the old red sandstone, /. The Silurian rocks, which range from the Malvern Hills and the Woolhope district to May and Huntley Hills in Gloucestershire, exhibit the same general order of succession, accompanied, however, by modifications of the lithological and zoological distinctions of the lower member of the Wenlock formation, which it is right to notice. Instead of being the compact, hard, tough, and strong-bedded rock of Woolhope, it becomes, on the western flank of May Hill, a group of nodules and very irregular courses disseminated in shale, and thus simply forming rather a more calcareous base of the Wenlock shale than what is seen under the Wenlock Edge and other places Chai\ v.] LOAVER WENLOCK — MALVERN — MAY IITLL, ETC. 109 where such nodules occur. Here, indeed, the upward development from a thick nucleus of red-coloured Caradoc sandstone beneath, into a series of interlaminated sandstones and shale, which assume to a great extent the fossil characters of the Lower Wenlock, is well exhibited. At the same time, both the Pentamerus undatus and P. lens, which are Caradoc fossils, occur amongst the shells. It is, in fact, impossible here to draw a rigid line of demarcation between the Lower and Upper Silurian. In one part of this region, as on the west flank of the Malverns, the lower type ascends rather higher, whilst, in another, the upper fauna expands downwards. In no portion of Britain, therefore, are the two formations of Caradoc and Wenlock better linked together than in the Malvern and May Hill region.* This tract, so elaborately described by Professor Phillips, was also carefully studied by Sir Henry de la Beche himself, when the line of demarcation between the Lower and Upper Silurian rocks fixed upon by the government surveyors was made the same as that which had been originally suggested in the " Silurian System. "t On the west flank of the North Malverns, the Caradoc sandstone with characteristic fossils passes upwards into, and is interlaced with, sub- calcareous shales and nodular bands, in which some Lower Silurian species are intermixed, with others which are essentially Wenlock. After lucidly explaining how such transitions are in harmony with well understood operations in nature. Professor Phillips thus writes: — " Though practically we must draw a line of division, let us not forget, * Professor Sedgwick has recently endeavoured to show, that a sandy portion of the beds on the west flank of May Hill, which occupy this intermediate position, ought not to be classed with the Caradoc, as before alluded to, as they have been, by the government surveyors and myself, but should, from their fossils, be ranged with the Wenlock. If this suggestion be adopted, it will only strengthen the opinions of Professor Phillips and myself, as to the difficulty of every where drawing a decisive fixed line between the older and younger groups of this natural system. t See Sil. Syst. p. 442. et seq. 110 SILUBIA. [Chap. V. that in this locality there is no firm and hard boundary between the Lower and Upper Silurian periods; for both by mineral and by organic evidence, the characteristics of these periods are found to overpass each other ; the older characters reappearing within the later deposits, and the later characters showing themselves amidst the earlier deposits." " As a general result," he adds, " it is quite evident, that the successive changes of organic forms, as they are exhibited to us in the successive groups of strata, are not simply dependent on the lapse of time, nor explicable as a series developed in proportion to the time, unless we survey the phenomena over very wide areas, and include in the com- parative terms geological periods long enough to neutralize the in- fluence of peculiar physical conditions. These," he truly says, " on account of their local origin, limited area of effect, and recurrence at indifferent periods, have at almost every geographical point, at some epoch or other, broken or mingled the series of organic life." * This is and has long been my belief, as founded on extensive observation. A limestone subordinate to shale, and bearing precisely the same relations to a subjacent sandstone as that of the localities above cited, occurs on the western and south-eastern flank of the Lower Lickey Hills in Worcestershire. There, the Silurian rocks consist of Caradoc sandstone, with its usual fossils, overlapped on its edge by shale, in which are courses of limestone (at Colmer's End), the whole of the mass having been thrust up as an irregular dome through the overly- ing coal measures and red sandstone. Again, in the adjacent tract near Walsall, and between that town and the Barr Beacon, the same Lower Wenlock or Woolhope limestone, long worked at the Hay Head, dips away from a point of Caradoc sandstone f, to pass at a gentle angle of 8° or W under the great body of the shale with its calcareous nodules and numerous small fossils; the whole being * See Mem. Geol. Surv. of Great Britain, vol. ii. p. 75. t Mr. Jukes recently indicated to the Geological Society the existence of this point of Caradoc sandstone. See also his published Survey of this district, Mem. Qeol. Surv. vol. vi. Chap. V.] LOWER WENLOCK SHALE, ETC. Ill covered by the thick or chief limestone as exhibited in the great quarries of Walsall. There also, as described in my original work, this lower limestone, with which the Woolhope limestone is now identified, is of the same small dimensions as in other localities. In it are nearly all the very same fossils as at Woolhope, and notably the Bumastus Barriensis, Foss. 9. p. 108., named by me from the adjacent village of Barr, and known to fossil collectors as the " Barr Trilobite;" together with many forms common to the whole forma- tion, including orthoceratites or corals.* In this way, proofs have been obtained, that a limestone whose real place I indicated in several detached districts, as being inferior to the great mass of shale, is truly by its fossils the lowest member of the Wenlock formation. Wenlock Shale. — This shale, which is infinitely the largest and most persistent member of the formation, is often distinguished by its layers of deposit being marked by a few small elliptical and round concretions of impure and very earthy limestone, which increase in purity as the strata ascend towards the chief or upper limestone. This shale is well exposed on the banks of the Severn, near Coalbrook Dale and the Iron Bridge, where it is called " Die Earth " by the miners, and is thence to be followed all along the escarpment of Wenlock Edge, occupying a broad valley of de- nudation between it and the ridge of the Caradoc, called Apes Dale, In the Malvern district it is also a mass of finely levigated argillaceous matter, the lowest part of which is more charged with calcareous matter than in Shropshire, and in which a large spheroidal structure is apparent. In that district Professor Phillips estimates the thickness of the shale at about 640 feet. In some parts of Wales the Wenlock shale is as incoherent as in those English counties where it appears; but in Denbighshire, it is a subcrystalline slaty rock. (See map and general section.) The prevailing fossils of the Wenlock shale, exclusive of trilobites and corals, which are mostly of species unknown in the lower * See Sil. Syst., p. 488. 112 SILURIA. [CuAP. V. deposits, are small brachiopodous shells of the genera Leptaena, Orthis, Strophomena, Atrypa, and Rhynconella. In a general way the fossils of this stratum, the chief of which are given in plates 20. and 22., are the same as those of the overlying limestone. The Orthis biloba of Linnaeus (Spirifer sinuatus, Sil. Syst.), O. hybrida, and the large flat Orthis rustica, are characteristic shells in this formation. Leptaena laevigata, and L. transversalis ; Pentamerus linguifer, and Athyris tumida, Dalm. (Atrypa tenuistriata, Sil. Syst.); Khynconella rotundata; R. depressa; R. Stricklandi; R. deflexa, and R. sphaerica; and in some parts R. navicula, are the chief brachiopodous shells. Among them, however, are several common to this deposit and the Lower Silurian rocks, such as Orthis elegantula, so common in the slates of Snowdon ; Strophomena pecten and S. (Leptaena) depressa, Atrypa marginalis, and A. reticularis, and the Spirifer plicatellus. Most of these have a great range, and pass upwards through the Wenlock, high into the Ludlow formation. Aviculae, Nuculae, and a few other bivalve shells occur frequently ; but few of them are characteristic except the Cardiola interrupta. Of spiral shells, Euomphalus funatus and E. alatus, Pileopsis (Nerita) Haliotis, Turbo cirrhosus, Bellerophon Wenlockensis, and B. dilatatus are the most frequent. Theca Forbesii and T. anceps are pteropod molluscs, not uncommon in this deposit. Certain Orthoceratites, such as O. an- nulatum, O. filosum, and O. angulatum, are rare ; but many of the thin-shelled species, O. subundulatum, O. primaevum, and others, abound in these muddy sediments. They are almost the only shells in this formation, as it is exhibited in Denbighshire and other parts of N. Wales, and occur there in the greatest abundance. Phragmo- ceras of one or two species, and certain Lituites, e.g. L. articulatus, L. Biddulphii, and occasionally L. giganteus, are conspicuous forms; but these two last-mentioned genera are not commonly met with. Of trilobites, Encrinurus punctatus and E. variolaris, Calymenc Chap, v.] AV ENLOCK LIMESTONE. 113 Blumenbachii and C. tuberculosa, Phacops caudatus and its variety P. longicaudatus, are characteristic, which, with many other smaller species, are the same with those of the Wenlock limestone. The genera Trinucleus, Asaphus^ and Ogygia are never detected even in the lowest portions of the shale, these forms being essentially characteristic of the Lower Silurian rocks. Cornulites serpularius, pi. 16. f. 6., and other annelides, are sometimes found, as well as stems and portions of encrinites, though the perfect fossils are very rare in the typical region.* With respect to corals, it may be stated generally, that they are the same as those of the Wenlock limestone, but fewer in number; the cup corals, Cyathophyllum, Omphyma, &c., Favosites alveolaris, and Stenopora fibrosa, being the most conspicuous. We ought not to omit to notice Graptolites priodon (Ludensis, Sil. Syst.), which is a most abundant and characteristic fossil of the Wenlock shale, and has been already figured as occurring in the Lower Silurian rocks, Foss. 6. f, 3., and pi. 12. f. 4. Wenlock Limestone. — The upper member of the formation is a limestone usually of lighter grey colours than the lower band already View of Wenlock Edge, as seen fkoini the Hills of Ludlow Kock on the S.W. (From Sil. Syst.) The linear ridge on the left is the Wenlock limestone dipping under the higher ridge of Ludlow Rocks. The valley of Apesdale on the extreme left is in the Wenlock shale. * One of the most elegant of the Silurian encrinites, the Actinocrinus pulcher, Salter, which is found in strata of this age in North Wales, will be mentioned in chapter 9. L 114 SILURIA. [Chap.V. described, and in every respect identical with the well known limestone of Dudley, but which I named after the sharp rectilinear ridge of Wenlock (see Map), because its relations to inferior and superior deposits are there better seen than in any other part of the British Isles. It consists of thick masses of grey, subcrystalline limestone, occa- sionally, but very rarely, of light pink colour, in part very argil- laceous, in others more crystalline, which is highly charged with encrinites and replete with corals. The rock is essentially of a con- cretionary nature, and thus differs much from the flat-bedded Wool- hope limestone ; being for the most part marked by nodules of small size. Occasionally the concretions are very large, and are then locally termed " hailstones." This limestone is underlaid and overlaid by shale of pale grey and greenish tints, copiously charged with small nodules of argillaceous limestone, of very irregular persistence. The large concretions or "hailstones" (some of which near Wenlock have a diameter of Old Quarries in the Wenlock Limestone. The dark cavities indicate the places from whence the ballstone or best crj'stalline limestone has been extracted. The fossils chiefly occur in the surrounding layers of impure earthy limestone and shale. Chap. V.] WENLOCK LIMESTONE. 115 80 feet) being more crystalline, have been quarried out as the best flux for the smelting of iron, and their extraction has left caverns in the quarries, as expressed in this woodcut. But though very thick at Wenlock, this limestone thins out so rapidly in its course to the south-west, that at Haven in the interior of the Ludlow promontory (see woodcut in the next chapter) it is represented by thin courses of small concretions only ; and on the banks of the river Lugg, west of Aymestry (in both of which localities it was first recognized by the Rev. T. T. Lewis), it is alone represented by a few coralline concretions, varying in size from 2 inches to 2 feet, but still full of the characteristic fossils. Thin- ning out entirely in Radnorshire, it is scarcely to be recognized throughout the counties of Brecon, Carmarthen, and Pembroke; its place being only marked in the cliffs of Marloes Bay, to the west of Milford Haven, by some characteristic fossils and a very small quantity of impure limestone immersed in grey and sandy shale. (See lower, vignette, p. 66.) In the districts of Malvern, Woolhope, May Hill, and Uske, however, the Wenlock limestone is copiously and instructively de- veloped; and exhibits in numberless natural sections and quarries the same characters as in Shropshire. On the west flank of the Malverns, where in the Ridgeway of Eastnor Park it assumes the same linear outline as at the Wenlock Edge, the limestone is estimated, by Professor Phillips, as having a thickness of 280 feet. There, in the flexures between the Ridgeway and Ledbury, it is admirably exposed, together with the overlying Ludlow formation. (See section, p. 94.) To the north of the town of Dudley, this limestone rises up into various domes called the Castle Hill, Wren's Nest, and other smaller elevations, which have been protruded from beneath the surrounding coal strata. The Castle Hill is here represented to the left hand of the spectator, who is standing on the slopes of the Wren's Nest, 116 SILURIA. [Chap. V. and looking over the town of Dudley, to the hills of basalt near Rowley. . Castle Hill. Rowley Hills. Hagley Hills. Dudley, from the Wren's Nest. (From a Drawing by Lady Murchison, Sil. Syst., p. 480.) As the signs of violent igneous action are apparent, both in the subterranean rocks of this rich mining tract, and in the various outbursts of basaltic or trappean rocks which have been extended to the surface (Rowley and Pouk Hills, &c.), it is fair to infer that these domes have been thrown into an inflated and arched form by subterranean expansion.* The Wren's Nest and Castle Hill thus exhibit on each side two courses of limestone, which, from its superior quality, has been alone worked out, first in open quarries and afterwards by deep subterranean galleries. The annexed diagram, which exhibits a section through the Wren's Nest, shows how the two bands of the best limestone, d^, have been extracted, leaving * See the account of the igneous rocks of this district, Sil. Syst., p. 496. First described by Mr. Keir and others, and subjected to experiments by Mr. Gregory Watt, their subterranean relations to the strata, were ably described by Mr. Blackwall of Dudley, after the publication of the " Silurian System." The descriptions of these and other phenomena connected with the region around Dudley, are given in detail by the Government Surveyors, Records of the School of Mines, vol. i. pt. 2. p. 240. CiiAP. v.] DUDLEY AND ITS LIMESTONES. 117 Section across the Wren's Nest. (From Sil. Syst., p. 484.) e d'^ d> d-^ d^ e rfi. Lowest Wenlock shale (place of Woolliope limestone?). Wenlock shale, d^. Two bands of limestone separated from each other by bavin. They are represented by the white spaces, from which the best limestone has been quarried, leaving only arches of support, e. Overlying bavin and shale passing up into Ludlow rocks. only a few arches of support ; whilst the other beds, consisting of impure and nodular earthy limestone, thus form the framework of the hill. The dotted arch indicates what the dome must have been when entire, whilst the tinted portion of the drawing repre- sents the body of the hill, the upper surface of which, having been hollowed out towards the centre, has obtained the name of Wren's Nest. It is, therefore, an elevated, inflated dome, which was probably truncated at its summit during the same period of disturbance and denudation which gave to the mass its peculiar form. When viewed from below on its southern face, and where neces- The South End of the Wren's Nest. (From a Sketch by the Rev. W. Whewell, D.D. Sil. Syst., p. 485.) The spectator, looking to the north, sees how the limestone strata fold over a central dome of shale. I 3 118 SILURIA. [Chap.V. sarily the excavated outline of the summit cannot be seen, the flank of the dome of shale and " bavin," from whence the limestone has been entirely removed, presents this appearance. In the exterior nucleus, which also consists of shale, the calcareous matter disappears ; but the limestone itself is quite similar in com- position, colour, and large hailstones, as well as in its small con- cretions, to the rock at Wenlock. At Woolhope in Herefordshire (see p. 106. and woodcut) a similar uprise from the centre has there produced a much grander pheno- menon. Strata lower than any seen at Dudley are there, as be- fore explained, brought to view ; and the denudation of the valleys which lie between the ridges that encircle the central dome has been so complete, as to render it the finest known example, within the British Isles, of a valley of clean denudation as well as of elevation. Not only have no extraneous loose materials been translated to it from other tracts, but every fragment derived from the mass of rocks which must once have arched over it, has been swept out of the central and encircling hollows ; a striking proof of the forcible agency exerted in the denuding operation.* In making an approximate estimate of the thickness of the Wenlock formation in the original Silurian region, I spoke of 700 feet for the shale, and about 300 for the limestones, including the nodular beds. Subsequently measuring the strata of the same age near the Malvern Hills, Professor Phillips gives them a thickness of about 920 feet, which, with the addition of the Lower Wenlock of Woolhope limestone and shale, which were not incorporated in the formation when I wrote, amounts to about my estimate. If, how- ever, the upper or chief limestones, including all the beds of "bavin" or impure nodular limestone, be measured at Dudley, that portion of the formation must be considered as considerably thicker Sil. Spt., p. 436. Chap, v.] WENLOCK LIMESTONE FOSSILS. 119 than in Salop or Hereford. In North Wales, though void of lime- stone, the formation is often of much greater dimensions, amounting probably to more than 2000 feet. In the above-mentioned districts of England, the Wenlock lime- stone passes upwards gradually into a thick mass of pale-coloured shale, undistinguishable from that beneath the solid rock. From its physical relations, and from its forming usually a part of the same hills as the mass of the Ludlow rock, it is classed with that formation ; though the reader must understand, that in reality it is only an intermediate band intimately connecting the Wenlock and Ludlow in the Upper Silurian group, and is almost equally related to both by its structure and fossil contents. The most prominent fossils of the limestone, among which corals abound, have been long known to collectors, who have derived their Fossils, 10. Corals of the Wenlock Limestone. 1. Favosites cristata, Linn. 2. F. Gothlandica, Linn. 3. Do. variety, and 3*, 3**, magnified portions of two varieties. 4. Favosites alveolaris, Goldf. 5. Alveolites Labecbii, Milne Edw. 6. Favosites oculata, Goldf. ? 7. Stenopora fibrosa, Goldf. 8. Do. variety incrusting shells (Alveolites fibrosa, Sil. Syst.). chief supplies from Dudley and its environs. My friends who are searching for Wenlock fossils, may, however, be told that their labour will be better rewarded by a search at the northern end of the 120 SILURIA. [Chap. V. Wenlock Edge, near Coalbrook Dale, than even at Dudley. The corals, encrinites, and shells, along this rich escarpment, are not only more easily detached from the matrix, but are less eagerly collected by dealers. I would particularize Benthall Edge, which overhangs the Severn in so picturesque a form, and Gliddon Hill, as excellent localities.* This rock is indeed distinguishable from all the inferior strata, by the very great abundance of its corals, the profusion of which make it resemble in many places a coral reef. These fossils were admirably described for me in the original Silurian System'* by my valued friend Mr. Lonsdale. Fossils, 11. Corals of the Wenlock Limestone. Millepore Corals of the genus Heliolites (Porites, Sil. Syst.), most nearlj- related to the " blue coral " Heliopora cserulea, Blainv., of the Australian coral reefs. 1. Heliolites tubulata, Lonsd. 2. H. petalliformis, Lonsd. 3. H. megastoma, M'Coy. 4, 5. H. interstinctus, Wahl. Three woodcuts, representing the most common, perhaps, of these corals, will be given in chapter 9. In addition to the Haly sites catenulatus, or universal chain-coral, Foss. 12. f. 6. ; and the Stenopora fibrosa, Foss. 10. f. 7.; which are * Some of the finest corals originally published in the " Silurian System," were collected by the Rev. T. T. Lewis, in the gorge of the river Lugg, above Aymestry. Chap. V.] WENLOCK LIMESTONE FOSSILS. 121 Fossils, 12. Corals of the Wenlock Limestone. no less common in the Lower Silurian rocks (see chap. 8., p. 176.), the following species of corals are everywhere typical of the Wenlock limestone : — Heliolites interstinctus (Pontes pyriformis of my old work), Foss. 11. f. 4., 5., both the large and small-celled varieties; H. tubulatus, f 1.; H. petalliformis, f. 2.; Favosites alveolaris, Foss. 10. f . 4 ; F. cristata, f. 1.; F. oculata, f. 6. ; Coenites juniperiniis, Foss. 12. f. 3. ; Syringopora ramulosa, f. 5. ; and its young or creeping form, fig. 2. (Aulopora serpens, "Sil. Syst.") ; S. bifurcata, f. 4.; Omphyma turbinatum, chap. 9. Foss. 34. f. 4. ; Cyathophyllum truncatum, ib. f. 2., and C. articulatum, f. 1. ; Acervularia ananas, f. 6. ; with many others. Of the crinoids the more perfect of the forms published in my old work are alone reproduced, in the plates of this volume.* Per- haps the large species Periechocrinus (Actinocrinus) moniliformis, pi. 13. f. 1, 2., is the most characteristic; for it covers large sur- faces of the limestone at Dudley, and is found in disjointed fragments in many other localities. Among the mollusks of this formation, which are figured in plates 20. to 33., Orthoceratites are very abundant, O. annulatum and O. Brightii being frequent species. Bellerophon dilatatus, B. Wen- lockensis, and the singularly beautiful Conularia Sowerbyi, pi. 25., are characteristic. Among the most frequent spiral shells are five species of Euomphalus, viz., E. carinatus, E. sculptus, E. discors, E. funatus, and E. rugosus (pi. 24, 25.). Ordinary bivalve shells are less common ; but Orthonota cingulata, ♦ See Plates 13. to 15. 122 SILURIA. [Chap. V Avicula reticulata, Pterinea retroflexa and P. planulata, chap. 9. Foss. 42. are abundant species. Of the brachiopods, Strophomena euglypha ; S. filosa, and especially S. depressa ; Pentamerus galeatus ; Spirifer plicatellus (S. trapezoidalis, S. radiatus, and S. interlineatus, Sil. Syst.); S. crispus and S. elevatus; Orthis rustica, 0. elegantula, and O. hybrida, Leptsena transversalis, and L. laevigata*, are all of them shells described in the " Silurian System ; " and of the Terebra- tulae, Rhynconella borealis (R. lacunosa of my old work), pi. 22. f. 4. is by far the most common species ; it is generally in company with R. cuneata, K. Salterii, and E. Wilsoni — the latter sometimes very abundant. Trilobites are very common; the most frequent of them is the so called Dudley Locust or Calymene Blumenbachii, a species which, as we have seen, also occurs deep in the Lower Silurian rocks, and, as we shall presently find, ascends also into the Upper Ludlow. Other forms of these creatures are also prevalent; a few may be noticed. Encrinurus punctatus, chap. 9. Foss. 46. f. 5. and E. variolaris, f. 6. are very common in both the limestone and the shale. Phacops Downingiae is one of the most characteristic trilobites, par- ticularly in the environs of Dudley. The Phacops Stokesii (Caly- mene macrophthalma of my former work), Phacops caudatus, Acidaspis Brightii, and Cheirurus bimucronatus, are frequent fossils, and, as before stated, belong also to the inferior formations. The Phacops caudatus is especially abundant in the Malvern Hills; whilst the Calymene Blumenbachii is the reigning fossil at Dudley. Bumastus Barriensis and Homalonotus delphinocephalus, which have been cited from the lower Wenlock or Woolhope limestone, are also found in this rock, the former very frequently. The annelides Cornulites serpularius and Tentaculites ornatus occur on almost every specimen of the limestone at Dudley, * See Plates 20. to 22. Chap, v.] WENLOCK LIMESTONE FOSSILS. 123 A further acquaintance with the fossils of the Wenlock formation must be obtained by consulting the 9th chapter, as also the nu- merous descriptive monographs mentioned in the Preface. The object of this work is not to direct attention to rare and curious species, but chiefly to those forms which are characteristic of the rocks. 124 SILUKIA. [Chap. VI. CHAPTER VI. UPPER SILURIAN ROCKS — continued. THE LUDLOW TORMATION, GENERAL CHARACTER OF. ITS SUBDIVISION IN THE TYPICAL DISTRICTS, INTO LOWER LUDLOW ROCKS, AYMESTRY LIMESTONE, AND UPPER LUDLOW ROCKS. In a general sense the Ludlow rocks of the Silurian region of England and Wales must be viewed as a continuation of the same argillaceous masses which prevail in the underlying Wenlock formation. Such, however, is more particularly the case in the lower beds of this deposit. The central portion consists in several tracts of an argillaceous dark-grey limestone. The upper member being more sandy and somewhat calcareous, and yet retaining in parts much of the "mudstone" matrix, is in great measure an im- perfect, thin-bedded, grey-coloured, earthy building stone. Occa- sionally the highest stratum is composed of light*coloured sandy freestones and tilestones, through which the formation graduates lithologically and conformably into the lowest beds of the Old Red or Devonian rocks. Such is the general order near the town of Ludlow, which stands upon the higher strata of the formation. Its central and inferior masses are best seen either in the escarpments of the adjacent hills on the S. W., or in that ridge which for a distance of twenty miles on the N. E. is interposed between the Wenlock Edge and the old red sandstone of Corve Dale and the Glee Hills. The section and view at pp. 102. 113., will give the reader an adequate idea of the succession. (See also Map and coloured section.) In following the formation from the Ludlow tract on its strike or Chap. VI.] THE LUDLOW ROCKS. 125 direction to the S. W., its included limestone, like that of the sub- jacent deposit, is also soon seen to thin out and disappear. Scarcely Ludlow Castle. (From a Sketch by Lady Harriet Clive, Sil. Syst. p. 195.) In this sketch the river i'eme is seen to flow in a chasm of tlie Lpper Ludlow Rocks, the strata on which the spectator is supposed to be standing, being the same as those on which the castle is built The basaltic Titterstone Clee Hill is in the distance. has the geologist quitted the north-western corner of Herefordshire, than he finds the central band attenuated to a mere course of cal- careous grit, which is entirely lost in Radnorshire. There the upper Silurian rocks of the mountain of Radnor Forest, which are laid open in the ravine of " Water break its Neck" and other gullies, expose a gradual succession from the Wenlock through the whole of the Ludlow formation up to the junction beds of the old red sandstone, and with scarcely a trace of limestone. As such also the formation ranges for the most part through Brecon and Carmarthen, the central part being nowhere a workable limestone, and only here and there calcareous, except through the occasional presence of the shelly remains of a few fossils. In Marloes Bay, Pembrokeshire, where the Silurian rocks are exposed in the sea-cliffs (see view, p. 66.), it is difficult to say more than that sandy calcareous shale and very impure limestone containing Wenlock fossils, are surmounted by ferruginous and hard sandstone, rarely calcareous, and in parts a conglomerate, but full of characteristic Ludlow rock fossils. Though the uppermost of these beds are not unlike some of the rocks of 126 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. Ludlow, yet without this change in mineral character, the same order of superposition prevails in Pembroke as in Salop and Hereford, or in the Clyro and Begwm Hills, on the banks of the Wye, between Hay and Builth, where I first marked this succession. (See Map, and Sil. Syst., pp. 5. 312.). Let us now consider the nature of the different members of the Ludlow formation, where they are most conspicuously characterized by a diversity of mineral matter and the greatest quantity of fossil remains. Lower Ludlow Rock. — These strata, which are, I repeat, simply an upward prolongation of the uppermost member of the Wenlock formation, are composed of dark grey shale, very rarely in any degree micaceous, with small concretions of impure limestone. My chief reason for grouping them with the Ludlow rather than with the Wenlock rocks was, that every where in the typical districts of Shropshire and Herefordshire, these shales occupy the base of the escarpments of the same ridges of which the harder masses of Aymestry limestone and Upper Ludlow rocks form the summits and outward slopes. The clearest and finest examples of this are seen in the deeply excavated interior of the Ludlow promontory, particularly in de- scending from the Comus Wood of Milton* into the depression of Section across the Ludlow Promontory. (From Sil. Svst., pi. 31. f. 5.) N.W. " S.B. Brindgwood. Gatlev. Whiteway R. Onny. VVigmore. ' Head. d*. Wenlock shale, d 2. Genlock limestone, ei. Lower Ludlow, e^. Aymestry limestone. e^. Upper Ludlow. /. Old Red Sandstone (bottom beds of). * Milton passed some time in Ludlow Castle, in his day a border Welsh fortress, and his " Mask of Comus" was performed in it. The scene immor- talized by the name of Comus Wood is one of the deep depressions which vary the surface of the Ludlow promontory. Chap. VI.] LOWER LUDLOW ROCK. 127 Mary Knoll Dingle, and thence into the great valley of denudation of Wigmore, in which the Wenlock formation is exposed as ex- pressed in the preceding section. The inferior strata, for the most part argillaceous, are often ar- ranged in spheroidal masses, showing a tendency to concretionary structure, which rapidly exfoliate under the atmosphere, and break into shivery fragments. Calcareous nodules, differing only from those of the Wenlock deposit in being usually of a blacker colour, have often been formed around an Orthoceras, Trilobite, or other fossil, as a nucleus. One of the most prevalent of these fossils is our old friend Caly- mene Blumenbachii, whose acquaintance the collector may have first made in the lower rocks. (See also ch. 8.) It is accompanied very fre- quently by the long-tailed Asaphus, or, as it is now called, Phacops longicaudatus. These two may be considered the characteristic tri- lobites of the formation, though there are several other species. And, with these, the Graptolites priodon, or Ludensis *, occurs abundantly. Nor are the Cardiola interrupta, pi. 23. f. 12., and Murchisonia Lloydii, pi. 24. f. 5., less characteristic fossils. In ascending, the strata become somewhat more sandy, consti- tuting thick, earthy, and very slightly calcareous flagstones, the pendle " of the workmen, in which orthoceratites prevail, the flaglike separation being due to laminae of sand. These strata form the support of the Aymestry or Ludlow lime- stone, from which they are usually separated by soft soapy beds, in parts an imperfect fuller's earth. It is the decomposition of this unctuous fuller's or " Walker's " earth of the natives, be- neath heavy masses of the limestone, which rest upon it, which has occasioned numerous landslips both near Ludlow and in other parts of Herefordshire, one of the most striking of which will presently be mentioned. * Ludensis is the Latin word, signifying " of Ludlow." 128 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. The lower shale occupies the escarpments and contiguous valleys of the Ludlow rocks which range from Shropshire by Presteign to Kadnor Forest, and also large undulating tracts of the western parts of Shropshire or contiguous parts of Montgomeryshire, such as the Long Mountain, and other tracts around Welshpool and Montgomery (see Map). From the escarpments west of Kington, it extends, together with the upper members of the Ludlow rocks, to the banks of the Wye, and is finely exposed in the noble escarp- ment at the western end of the Forest of Mynydd Epynt in Breck- nockshire. A good idea of the outline of that tract is .conveyed by a sketch given in the 10th chapter, where the rounded and soft outline of the escarpment in the middle ground, as seen from the slaty hills on the west, is due to the soft nature of this deposit. The same rock is also well developed in the Malvern tract, where Professor Phillips assigns to it a thickness of about 750 feet. (See also section, p. 94.) In the Woolhope elevation and the group of Usk, or as lying between the Dudley and Sedgley (Wenlock and Aymestry) lime- stones in Staffordshire, it is everywhere the same dull, non-micaceous shale, which, from its incoherence, has, for the most part, been denuded; thus giving rise to a deep valley, which separates the harder parts of the Wenlock and Ludlow rocks from each other. In the environs of Ludlow, and in many parts of the Silurian region, this inferior member of the Ludlow rocks is specially charac- terized by a profusion of straight or curved chambered shells, Ortho- ceratites, Lituites, and Phragmoceras, a genus named by my friend Mr. Broderip, and which was unknown before the publication of the " Silurian System." Orthoceratites abound ; not less than eleven species having been originally figured as characteristic of this rock. But extended researches have shown that, in this case as in many instances of other fossils alluded to, several of these chambered sliells occur in much older as well as much Chap. VI.] LOWER LUDLOW FOSSILS. 129 younger members of the system. Among the orthoceratites, the largest, and perhaps the most common, are the O. Ludense, pi. 28. f. 1., and 0. filosum, pi. 27. f. 1. ; these are generally accompanied by a smaller, thin-shelled species, which appears to be the O. sub- undulatum of Portlock, Foss. 44. f. 3. The others, though often found, are by no means so abundant or characteristic. Of Lituites, the only common species is a very large one, eight or ten inches in diameter — the L. giganteus of pi. 33. f. 1, 2. The Phragmoceras, just noticed, is a most remarkable shell with the mouth or opening contracted into the shape of a key-hole. Some of its forms are flattish, broad, and shaped like a hatchet-head (pi. 32.); whilst others, known as the pear orthoceratites (pi. 30.), are suddenly swelled into a balloon-like shape above, and end below in a tapering point. Among the lamellibranchiate shells, Cardiola interrupta, Broderip, is the most common (pi. 23. f. 12.); yet this same species, formerly believed to be peculiar to this zone, has also been found in the Llan- deilo formation ! Another bivalve equally characteristic, and as yet known only in Upper Silurian rocks, is the Cardiola striata (pi. 23. f. 13.). This, in company with the chambered shells above noticed, is to be found in all the fossil-bearing localities of Shropshire and the neighbouring regions. Orthonota rigida, pi. 23. f. 8., and Pterinea retroflexa, f. 17., are not such common species ; and the latter is far more frequent in the Upper Ludlow rock. Many species of fossils have indeed been found common to this stratum and the Wenlock formation ; and this is especially the case with the brachiopodous shells. Among these may be cited the Pen- tamerus (Atrypa) galeatus, Strophomena depressa and S. euglypha, Leptffina laevigata, Atrypa reticularis, and Rhynconella (Terebratula) Wilsoni. Nor are there any brachiopods strictly peculiar to it, unless it be the small but very characteristic Lingula lata, pi. 20. f. 6. In this view, the Lower Ludlow shale might be classed with the Wenlock formation; but the other forms of mollusks, above K 130 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. noticed, give to it nevertheless a distinct character, and entitle us to class it in the Ludlow formation. Aymestry or Ludlow Limestone, — The want of persistence over wide areas of any mass of solid limestone in the centre of the Ludlow formation has been already adverted to. In some parts of South Wales, where the calcareous matter is absent, it is even diflficult to trace the place of this band in the Ludlow rocks ; but in Hereford- shire and Shropshire, and again at Sedgeley in Staffordshire (near Dudley), it is a dark-grey limestone, worked pretty extensively for use. And even where the lime is very sparingly distributed, the rock is a highly calcareous flagstone, and may generally be re- cognized by its predominant fossils and well-defined joints. This central member of the Ludlow formation was named by me after the beautiful village of Aymestry, where the rock is well laid open, and where its relative position and fossil contents were ela- borately worked out by my friend, the Rev. T. T. Lewis.* It is a subcrystalline, earthy limestone, arranged in beds from one to five feet Whiteway Head, (Escarpment of Amyestry Limestone. Strata dipping to the S. F.) (From Sil. Syst., p. 243. Sketched by the late Rev. W. R. Evans.) * See Sil. Syst., p. 201. Chap. VI.] AYMESTRY OR LUDLOW LIMESTONE. 131 thick; the laminae of deposit being marked by layers of shells and other fossils. In the escarpment of the south-western limb of the Ludlow promontory, this rock is frequently seen to form bluff cliffs, the inclined strata of which appear, as in the centre of the preceding woodcut, resting upon the Lower Ludlow shale, and plunging under the Upper Ludlow rock. When quarried into, the rock is of an indigo or bluish grey co- lour, in parts mottled by the mixture of white calcareous spar. The quarries, like those in all the harder bands of the Ludlow form- ation, present natural backs or divisions, as in the above diagram, usually coated by a dirty yellow or greenish shale. These are the faces of joints more or less vertical, which, when open, occasion the rock to separate into rhomboidal masses, which are easily de- tached where the strata are much inclined. The rock is, therefore, subject to slides or subsidences, particularly where the underlying saponaceous " Walker's, or Fuller's Earth " prevails. Examples of these slides may be seen at many spots, but no where more instruc- The Palmer's Cairn Landslip. (From Sil. Syst., p. 248.) The woodcut exhibits the slope of the beds and the vertical joints, which in conjunction with the upper and lower lines of bedding divide the rock into lozenge-shaped detached lumps. 132 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. lively than at the Palmer's Cairn, or Churn Bank, S. W. of Ludlow, as represented in the foregoing woodcut. The area there affected exceeds fifty acres. This limestone often occupies the summit or capping of the escarp- ment of Ludlow rocks, as in the ridges of Mary Knoll and Brindg- wood Chase west of Ludlow ; and in the hills extending from the View Edge and Norton Camp, where it forms a conspicuous band parallel to, and loftier than, the Wenlock Edge (see woodcut, p. 113.). At Aymestry, the limestone occupies both banks in the gorge of the river Lugg ; but, as above said, it rapidly thins out to the south- west. On the whole it is much less of a concretionary character than the subjacent Wenlock limestone, and partakes more of the flat- bedded character which is observable in the " pendle " beds beneath, and is indeed characteristic of all parts of the Ludlow formation. In the Woolhope valley of elevation, the Aymestry rock (see section, p. 106.) assumes precisely the same external or geographical features as on the flanks of the Ludlow promontory, in having from its hardness resisted denudation better than other portions of the deposit. It thus forms the crest of the external and encircling ridge, and is prominent in the hills of Harden, Seager, and Backbury. Although it there differs in being less of a limestone than near Ludlow, it contains many of the same fossils, even the Pentamerus Knightii, its characteristic shell (pi. 21. f. 10.), having been found in the Woolhope district since the " Silurian System" was published. On the outermost western slopes of the Malvern Hills, and on the sides and summits of their northern prolongation the Abberley Hills, the Aymestry rock, though containing less calcareous matter than near Ludlow, is still the well-defined central portion of the forma- tion. In some of these tracts (as near the Hundred House) it might be used for lime, if the Wenlock limestone of such superior quality were not in juxtaposition. The same may be said of the Chap. VI.] UPPER LUDLOW ROCK. 133 districts of May Hill, Usk, &c., where this limestone is represented by the harder and somewhat calcareous central part of the Ludlow rocks. At Sedgeley, in Staffordshire, the rock again becomes once more a complete limestone, in w^hich the predominant Aymestry fossil, the Pentamerus Knightii, abounds. There it is known as the " black limestone," in contradistinction to that of Dudley, on which, with an intermediate shale or " bavin," it reposes.* The fossils which pervade the Aymestry limestone, in addition to the Pentamerus Knightii, are the Khynconella (Terebratula) Wilsoni, Lingula Lewisii, Bellerophon dilatatus, Avicula reticulata, &c., and many of the same shells, corals, and trilobites, which are common in the subjacent Wenlock limestone. Indeed, except in the less number of species and the occurrence of some of the shells more characteristic of the next member (the Upper Ludlow rock), this limestone is scarcely to be distinguished by its fossil contents from the Wenlock limestone. In some tracts the place of this rock is marked only by the shelly courses, which near Ludlow form its immediate cover ; and wherever that stratum occurs it is replete with the Ehynconella (Terebratula) navicula (pi. 22. f. 12) and the small Lept^ena laevigata. It is this band which forms the base of the Upper Ludlow rock. Upper Ludlow Rock. — This is the most diversified in structure and contents of the three subdivisions of the highest Silurian formation, and is remarkably interesting in exhibiting a transition from its highest members into the next overlying system, the Old Red, or Devonian. Its lowest stratum may be considered the calcareous shelly band, charged with Rhynconella (Terebratula) navicula, which has just been mentioned as forming the roof of the Aymestry lime- stone, and which occasionally attains a thickness of 30 or 40 feet. This is surmounted by grey, argillaceous masses so common throughout the Silurian rocks, and which from their incoherent nature easily de- * See Silurian System, sections, p. 481. etseq. K 3 134 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. compose to mud. Like other sediments of higher antiquity in the same system of rocks and fossils, it has a tendency to run into large spheroids, and occasionally contains small concretions of sandy clay, which, being more destructible than the pure argillaceous matrix, have often weathered out in the faces of the escarpments, and exhibit the lines of stratification by small elliptic cavities like swallow-holes. The chief and distinguishing portion of the Upper Ludlow con- tains more calcareous matter and sand than the beds immediately beneath. It is, on the whole, a slightly micaceous thin-bedded stone of bluish-grey colour within, but weathering externally to a brown and rusty grey, and remarkable for its transverse, symmetrical joints, as exhibited in this view. Upper Ludlow Rocks at the Bone Well.* (From Sil. Syst., p. 250.) * This well is so named because bones of mice, frogs, and other small animals, are from time to time washed out from the open joints of the impending rock, and offer what was formerly considered a great marvel. Old Drayton, in his Polyolbian, makes the bones of frogs into those of fishes : — " With strange and sundry tales Of all their wondrous things ; and not the least in Wales ; Of that prodigious spring (him neighbouring as he past) That little fshes' bones continually doth cast." Chap, VI.] UPPER LUDLOW ROCK. 135 Though quarried extensively, these stones, either when not well selected or not placed in the wall in the direction of the layers, are very prone to decomposition. Some strata of this character appear in the foreground of the vignette, p. 125., which represents the Castle of Ludlow standing on the rock out of which it was built. I have elsewhere compared this member of the Upper Ludlow with the " Macigno " of Italy, and particularly with those dark greyish portions of it which occur between Perugia and Florence. This close lithological resemblance of so old a rock to so young a deposit (for the Italian Macigno is no older than the London clay), is cited to show how similar sandy, muddy, and calcareous materials, collected at the bottom of a sea, often necessarily resemble each other when formed into stone, though originally deposited at such very widely separated periods. In this comparison it is also to be specially noted, that the " Macigno," or young Italian rock, is infinitely more hard, compact, and durable, than the ancient stone of Ludlow.* The surfaces of these Upper Ludlow rocks are occasionally covered by small wavy ridges and furrows, here and there crossed by little, tortuous, raised bands, the first of which are supposed to have resulted from the rippling action of waves, w^hen the sediment was accumulating under the sea, and the last to have been the traces left by worm-like animals frequenting a sandy and muddy shore as the tide receded. It is chiefly in this portion of the formation, that the best de- fined organic remains are found, often preserving the sharpness of their forms, and the remains of their original shelly coverings. Here we meet with a profusion of the following fossils : Chonetes (Leptsena) lata, pi. 20. f. 8. ; Orthonota amygdalina, pi. 23. f. 7. ; Goniophora cymbaeformis, pi. 23. f. 3. ; Avicula lineata, f. 16.; Pterinea retroflexa, f. 17.; Orbicula rugata, pi. 20. f. 1, 2.; Orthis * See my description of the Macigno of Italy, Alps, Apennines, &c. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. v. p. 280., where I showed that it was of tertiary age. 136 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. elegantula (var. orbicularis), pi. 20. f. 9, 10.; O. lunata,f. 11.; Ehyn- conella (Terebratula) nucula, pi. 22. f. 1.; Turbo corallii, pi. 24. f. 1.; T. octavia, f. 4. &c. ; and the coiled shelly serpuline body, Serpulites longissimus, pi. 16. f. 1. The Cornulites serpularius, and a small Tentaculite are far from uncommon. Corals are but scarce ; yet Stenopora (Favosites) fibrosa is found frequently encrusting particular species of shells, — Turbo corallii and Murchisonia corallii, as their names imply, being its favourite habitats ; it is figured in a previous woodcut, p. 119. Foss. 10. f. 8. Orthoceratites, occasionally of large size, occur, and trilobites. Of the latter, Phacops caudatus and the Encrinurus punctatus, with a rare sample of the Calymene Blumenbachii, reach the top, but they are not common ; nor indeed are trilobites at all abundant, except a fine species of the genus Homalonotus, H. Knightii, pi. 19. f. 7., which may be found throughout the whole range of this formation, sometimes of very large size. In the cliffs at Ludlow, the chief rocks are surmounted by what I termed the fucoid bed. This is a greenish-grey argillaceous sand- stone, almost entirely made up of a multitude of small, wavy, rounded, stem-like forms, which resemble entangled sea-weeds. In this mass is found, and always in a vertical position, the singular body (pi. 15. f. 4.) named Cophinus dubius. It is generally of an inversely pyramidal shape, and its sides are scored with elegant transverse grooves. I am assured by Messrs. Sowerby and Salter, who have studied it attentively, that it is the impression made by the stems of encrinites, which, rooted and half buried in the micaceous mud, produced, by their wavy and somewhat rotatory motion, the beautiful pattern, every line of which answers to one of the project- ing bosses or rings of the jointed stem. The best proof that such has been the cause, is that these stems are always present, and lying contiguous to the markings. The slow trailings of these stems have probably left their traces in virtue of the micaceous character of the Chap.VL] upper LUDLOW FISHES. 137 mud, which may have impeded the perfect fusion of the separated portions of the semifluid mass after the stem had passed through them. The Upper Ludlow rock is, in this respect, the most interesting of the divisions of the Upper Silurian group, that it is the oldest band in which any remains of fishes and land plants have been discovered. The upper and lower parts of this stratum, as seen at Ludlow, are finely laminated, earthy, greenish-grey sandstones, containing a few remains of ichthyolites, with several shelly remains characteristic of the Upper Ludlow. It was the central part only of this stratum, or a gingerbread-coloured layer of a thickness of three or four inches only, and dwindling away to a quarter of an inch, which exhibited, when first my attention was directed to it *, a matted mass of these bony fragments, for the most part of very small size and of very peculiar character. These, with a very few remains of shells, and a rare crustacean, the Pterygotus problematicus, occur in a cement in which varying proportions of carbonate of lime, iron, phosphate of lime, and bitumen are disseminated. Some of the fragments of fish were of a mahogany hue, but others of so bril- liant a black, that, when discovered, the bed conveyed the impres- sion of being a heap of broken beetles. The supposed fishes of this bed, as exhibited in plate 4 of my original work, must now, however, be reduced in number. At all events, besides the remarkable Pterygotus, which is here figured in pi. 19. f. 4, 5., and which was removed by Agassiz himself to the class of crustaceans. Professor M'Coy has diminished the list of fish remains by proving, that some of the supposed fish defences should also be removed to that group. One of these, to which he has apphed * This course was discovered by my friends and excellent Ludlow coadjutors, the Rev. F. T. Lewis and Dr. Lloyd, the latter, now alas ! removed by death. By their assistance, and that of the late Rev. J. Evans, I traced this fish-bed in several other parts of the Ludlow promontory. See Sil. Syst. p. 198. 605. 138 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. the name Leptocheles Murchisoni (see pL 19. f. 1, 2.), is figured in my original work as an Onchus, or fish defence.* This bed, enclosing minute fragments of fish-bones and skin or shagreen, has since been detected in tracts very distant from Ludlow. The upper portion of the Ludlow formation, or capping of the bone-bed, is composed of light-coloured, thin-bedded, slightly mica- ceous sandstones, in which quarries are opened out near Downton Castle on the Teme. (The Downton Castle stone, Sil. Syst. p. 197.) The uppermost layers of the whole system, and which form a transi- tion into the Old Red sandstone, consist of tilestones and sand- stones, occasionally reddish, in which, besides other fossils found in the Ludlow rock, the Lingula cornea, pi. 34. f. 2., with crustaceans (pi. 19. f. 1. 3.), and defences of fishes, often occur. Being compelled in my researches to draw a line of demarcation between the upper part of the Ludlow formation and the bottom of the overlying Old Red sandstone, I formerly included the tilestones in the latter ; particularly as in most parts of the region they decompose into a red soil, and thus they afford a clear physical line of demarcation between them and the inferior rocks, which facilitated the construction of the geological map.f Even then, however, the fossils which were figured as charac- teristic of such tilestones exhibited little else, as I showed, than * For further illustration of this point, see Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. ix. p. 12. f The reader, who may refer to my original map, must recollect, that it was constructed between the years 1831 and 1836, when even the geographical outlines of a large portion of the country had not been defined by the publication of the sheets of the Ordnance Survey. Geologists who have had to labour with little topographical assistance in a region like this, which had been wholly unexplored by miners, are not those who will criticise those errors of detail, which have been remedied by the government surveyors who followed me. The classification and chief outlines of my map and sections, as far as they relate to my own Silurian rocks, have indeed been completely sanctioned by Sir Henry de la Beche and his associates ; and this is the highest reward which a pioneer like myself could expect to receive. Chap. VI.] UPPER LUDLOW ROCK. 139 species common to the Ludlow rock itself. This zoological fact, and subsequent researches in other parts of England, above all those of Professor Sedgwick in Westmoreland, where the Upper Ludlow strata are much developed, have, for eleven years, led me to classify these tilestones with the Silurian rocks, of which they form the natural summit. For, even in their range from Shropshire through Hereford and Radnorshire, into Brecon and Carmarthen- shire, whether they are of red or yellow colours, they are charged with Orthoceras buUatum, Chonetes (Leptaena) lata, Spirifer elevatus, Orthis lunata, Ehynconella nucula, Cucullella ovata, Bellerophon trilobatus, B. expansus, Trochus helicites, Holopella (Turritella) obsoleta, and the minute bivalved crustacean, Beyrichia tuberculata. (See pi. 34. and its figures). All of these are the most common fossils of the Upper Ludlow rock ; although a few of them descend as low as the Caradoc sandstone. Including the Downton Castle building stones, this band of transition contains the oldest traces of terrestrial vegetation yet known in the British Isles. The specimens which I found were usually small, and little more than carbonized stains. At the bottom of the detached basin of Old Red sandstone of Clun Forest in Shropshire, I detected thin layers of matted and broken vege- tables (frequently carbonized) in the tilestone or "firestone" beds of that tract (Sil. Syst. p. 19L). Since then, the government collectors have enlarged our acquaintance with them, and in the museum in Jermyn Street there are to be seen many more specimens of this stratum, among which are the minute globular bodies, pi. 35. f. 30., called bufonites " in the " Silurian System," but which, as will presently be explained, are now shown to be vegetables. Though not every where divisible into the portions above de- scribed, the Upper Ludlow rock maintains, on the whole, a decisive aspect and position in its range from Shropshire through Hereford and Radnorshire into Brecon and Carmarthenshire, until last seen 140 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. in the cliffs of Marloes Bay in Pembrokeshire. Frequently some- what calcareous, the deposit is for the most part a harder and sandier stone, partaking much more of the character of the Italian " Macigno," as before said, than any other rock of the Silurian system. On the eastward slopes of Bradnor and Hergest Hills, near King- ton, and particularly in the ridges extending thence by Gladestry and Pains Castle to the Trewerne Hills on the banks of the Wye, this sub-group is admirably exposed in slightly inclined masses re- plete with fossils. In the escarpment of the Trewerne and Begwm Hills *, and in many other places, this grey, shelly, thin-bedded mass of rock is strikingly exhibited, dipping under the bottom beds of the Old Eed sandstone, as in the long sectional woodcut in the 10th chapter. Along the outer or western edge of the Malvern Hills, the Upper Silurian, reposing on the Lower Silurian as before described, p. 94. exhibits, in like manner. Upper Ludlow rocks dipping under the Old Bed marls, descriptions of which, as occurring at many places, from Ledbury northwards, may be consulted in the " Silurian System," and in the monograph of Professor Phillips. f Like passages upwards, from an inferior grey-coloured series, to a superior red system, are observable at Usk, and in tracts around that town, where these beds repose on Wenlock limestone. J In Brecknockshire, to the south of Builth, the Ludlow rocks, sur- mounting a noble escarpment of the other members of the Upper Silurian division on the right bank of the Wye, but in which no limestones occur, exhibit a fine upward development, as they pass under the expanse of the Old Red sandstone in the wilds of Mynydd Epynt (see the long vignette, chapter 10.). There the Upper Ludlow rises from beneath the Old Red, in a rapid anticlinal flexure at Alt- * This was my first Silurian section, 1831, in passing from the known Old Red to the then unknown Ludlow rocks, Sil. Syst. p. 5, 312.. t Mem. Geol. Surv. Gt. Brit., vol. ii. part 1 . J Sil. Syst. p. 408. Chap. VI.] UPPER LUDLOW ROCK. 141 fawr and Corn-y-fan, as here represented; the central and lower members of the formation forming the underlying strata. Brecon Anticlinal of Ludlow Rocks, throwing off Old Red Sandstone. (From Sil. Syst., p. 211.) Alt fawr and O T? e3 / ci. Lower Ludlow, e^. Middle Ludlow with a calcareous band representing the Aymestry lime- stone. e3. Upper Ludlow. /. Old Red junction beds. Thence into Carmarthenshire, the junction of the Ludlow rocks with the Old Red sandstone is well laid open in numerous places, especially in the narrow valley of Cwm Dwr, between Trecastle and Llandovery, where the tilestones on which Horeb Chapel stands, are full of the casts of shells, among which are characteristic forms, such as the Trochus helicites. Turbo Williamsi, Bellerophon trilo- batus, and many others. The banks of the river Sowdde, in Carmarthenshire, east of Llan- gadock, also expose a good junction of these highly micaceous Upper Silurian flagstones with overlying Old Ked marl ; the whole at very high angles of inclination. Thence, in their range to the mouth of the Towy, the Upper Ludlow becomes a compact hard sandstone, every where surmounted by Old Red.* In Pembrokeshire, similar junctions with the Old Red sandstone are seen near Tavern Spite, Narberth, Freshwater East, Freshwater West, and in Marloes Bay. In all these places, strata of dull greenish- grey argillaceous sandstone, minutely micaceous, differing chiefly from the type of the Upper Ludlow of Shropshire in being harder and thicker bedded, and which repose on rocks with Upper Silurian fossils, plunge under red and green strata (the red rab of Pembroke), or bottom beds of the Old Red sandstone. (See p. 66.) * See woodcuts, pp. 72, 73. 142 SILURIA. [Chap. VI. In the valley of Woolhope, the same succession is very apparent all round the external rim of that remarkable elliptical elevation (see diagram, p. 106). In nearly all parts of that circumference, the Upper Ludlow is well exposed, and occasionally contains, in one or two spots, the rare remains of fishes. At Hagley Park, distant only two miles from the north-western end of the Woolhope ellipse, and four miles east of Hereford, the uppermost beds of the Ludlow formation have been recently unco- vered from beneath their covering of red clay and marl ; and there the thin bed, containing fish-bones and the crustacean Pterygotus, has been found by Mr. H. Strickland to be just in the same relative position as at Ludlow.* This spot marks a minor undulation, or dome of the Ludlow rocks, the surface of which only is visible ; whilst a much greater mass of the formation protrudes in the ad- jacent hill of Shucknall, as formerly described (Sil. Syst.). At Hagley Park, the fish bed, scarcely exceeding an inch in thickness, lies between the beds of brownish and yellowish sandstone (the Downton Castle stone) and a grey micaceous shaly rock full of Upper Ludlow fossils. The fish remains are chiefly those of the minute shagreen scales (pi. 35. f. 18.), the fish defences Thelodus parvidens and Onchus tenuistriatus (fig. 15 and 17.), with Coprolites (fig. 21-27.); whilst in the sandy beds above these there are the remains of car- bonized vegetables, and among them Mr. Strickland detected some of the minute globular or spherical bodies mentioned above, which Dr. Hooker has ascertained to be a fossil of the natural order of Lycopodiacese. Similar vegetable traces have been observed, again, at various places around the external rim of the Woolhope ellipse. . Again, in the southernmost prolongation of the Silurian group of May Hill and Huntley Hill, where I formerly described the * I have visited the spot since the discovery, in company with Mr. Strickland. See his descriptions of these beds in the S. of Herefordshire and in Gloucester- shire. Quart. Journ. Geol Soc. Lond. vol. viii. p. 381., and ib. vol. ix. p. 8. CiiAP. VL] RANGE OF LUDLOW BONE-BED. 143 whole Silurian series as reduced to one thin mass of Ludlow rock, having the Old Red sandstone on one side, and the New Red on the other, my friend, Mr. Strickland, has very recently detected the existence of the very same thin fish-bone layer in precisely the same place as at Ludlow. Lastly, in the arched, or dome-shaped masses of Upper Silurian rocks, which rise out from beneath the Old Red sandstone at Pyrton Passage on the Severn, Professor Phillips has noted the remains of small fish-bones in the Upper Ludlow rocks.* The recognition of this thin band of the uppermost Ludlow rock, in which the oldest recognizable land plants and fishes are associated with certain shells for a distance of some forty-five miles from the tract in which I first described it, is truly remarkable. For whilst it shows the value of close and minute researches, it is a strong proof that, after many years of hard labour, the Ludlow rock still re- mains, as formerly described by me, the lowest stage in the crust of the globe in which any ichthyolites have been detected, a fact which will be reverted to in ensuing chapters. * Mem. Geol. Surv. of Great Brit., vol. ii. part 1. The succession of the Silurian rocks in the dislocated tract of Tortworth, to the S.E. of Pyrton Passage, is described in detail in the Silurian System, p. 99. 144 SILURIA. [Chap. Vll. CHAPTER VII. SILURIAN ROCKS OF BRITAIN BEYOND THE TYPICAL REGION OF ENGLAND AND WALES, AS SEEN IN CORNWALL, THE NORTH-WEST OF ENGLAND, SCOTLAND, AND IRELAND. Though occupying large spaces in other parts of the British Isles^ the Silurian rocks, as separated into formations and characterized by fossils, are no where so clearly defined as in that typical region of which we have taken leave. In no other tract of the United Kingdom have geologists been able to show so clearly the relations of the lowest fossiliferous or protozoic rocks to others beneath them which exhibit no signs of former life ; nor is there any where else so clear an ascending order from the Silurian into the next overlying deposit, the Old Eed Sandstone or Devonian rocks. In Cornwall, for example, the discovery Avithin the few last years only of certain fossils, has proved that some of the quartzose sandstones forming its southern headlands are Lower Silurian. The fossiliferous sandstone in question passing to the south of the Dod- man, and coming out to view in Gorran Haven, contains several species of Orthidce as well as trilobites most characteristic of that division.* There, however, no one can show an unbroken descending se- quence beneath those beds, nor an ascending order from them to the contiguous and younger deposits of Devonian age ; and as large * These fossils were collected by Mr. Peach, and, from their inspection and a visit to their chief localities in 1846, I pronounced the rocks in which they occur to be Lower Silurian rocks (Trans. Roy. Geol. Soc. Cornwall, 1846, p. 3l7.)j and, as such, they were inserted in a new edition of my Geological Map of England and Wales, published by the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Know- ledge. Chap. VII.] SILURIANS OF CORNWALL, ETC. 145 portions of the strata of Cornwall have been highly altered, and mineralized, so is this southern tract much dislocated. In such a region, therefore, we cannot expect to meet with proofs of suc- cession. It is sufficient to state, that the band of siliceous grits and quartzites in the south of Cornwall, which I had termed Silurian in 1846, presents much of the character and aspect of the oppo- site rocks of France, which the French geologists have mapped and described as Lower Silurian, as will hereafter be noticed. Thi& is precisely one of those broken and insulated tracts of older sedi- mentary rocks, where the geologist has no other test by which he can recognize their age than by their imbedded organic remains. Professor Sedgwick, who has visited the localities since I de- scribed them, shows, indeed, that these strata are inverted ; the Lower Silurian (which he now calls Cambrian) overlying the De- vonian or Old E-ed rocks. At the same time, the chief fossils de- fined by Sowerby and M''Coy *, consist of the simple plaited Orthidaa so very common in the Lower Silurian rocks, viz., Orthis calli^ gramma, 0. flabellulum, with O. elegantula, and O. testudinaria ; Strophomena grandis ; and the trilobites Homalonotus bisulcatus ;. Calymene brevicapitata of Portlock, and Phacops apiculatus, Salter. That these are true and original Lower Silurian types cannot be^ doubted. In the north-western and mountainous part of England the Silurian rocks appear in great force in the counties of Westmoreland and Cumberland and the adjacent tracts of Lancashire and York- shire. Though some of their members there assume a different lithological aspect to what they maintain in the Silurian and Welsh region, they have been clearly paralleled by several geologists with those original types. Professor Sedgwick, who has most studied the lake region (which I have traversed on three occasions * See Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond, vol. viii. p. 13, L 146 SILURIA. [Chap. VII. for purposes of general comparison), and who has described it in a series of valuable memoirs, has recently grouped the lowest fossili- ferous limestones, or those of Coniston, in his Cambrian rocks, though during several years he identified them by means of the published fossils with the Lower Silurian and even with its upper portion. In truth, the region of Siluria, as geologists now admit, afforded the key by which the fossiliferous strata in the north-western tracts of England were brought into order and had their proper places assigned to them. For, in Cumberland, where the lowest members of this primeval series rise up into the lofty mountains of Skiddaw and Saddleback, the inferior masses of crystallized schists which pass downwards into fine, glossy, chiastolite slates, have been too much metamorphosed by eruptive, granitic rocks, to allow us to hope for the detection in them of any regular order or symmetry, still less of fossil contents. These beds are followed by green slates and porphyries, in which also no fossils have been found, owing, as it is believed, to the great abundance of igneous matter. In vain, therefore, in such a country, does the geologist seek for the equivalents of the bottom rocks, described in the earlier chapters as overlaid conformably by strata with Lingulae and trilobites. No where in the lake region have the repeated labours of geologists or fossil collectors, including that close searcher Mr. John Kuthven, de- tected the lower fossil band or the Lingula flags of North Wales, unless it be represented, as Professor Sedgwick thinks probable, by the few graptolites and fucoids of the Skiddaw slate. With the exception of rare sea-weeds and zoophytes, not a trace of any thing has been detected in the thousands of feet of strata, which, with interpolated igneous matter, intervene between the slates of Skiddaw and the Coniston limestone, with its overlying flagstones, &:c. At that zone only do we begin to find any thing like a true fauna; and judging from its remains it may be admitted to be a repre- Chap. VII.] SILURIANS — WESTMORELAND^ CUMBERLAND, ETC. 147 sentative of the Llandeilo formation of the Lower Silurian rocks. For, among the fossils, the same species of simple plaited Orthidae, with trilobites and corals, are again met with which characterize the limestones of Llandeilo or Bala. From physical data, and the great thickness of the strata, we may indeed hypothetically admit, that Professor Sedgwick is right in assigning to the schists of Skiddaw (in which one or two graptolites alone have been found) as high an antiquity as the lowest fossil beds of North Wales and Shropshire. But all w^e can safely say is, that, reasoning from the graptolites, the whole is a Lower Silurian series, which is metamorphosed and obscured by igneous eruptions in its lower parts, and exhibits beneath it no clear representative whatever of the Longmynd or bottom rocks. In proceeding, however, to the south and south-east from the more crystalline and mountainous part of this north-western tract of Eng- land, the Lower Silurian rocks, whether they be ranged with the Llandeilo or with the Caradoc subdivision, are seen to be suc- ceeded by younger deposits, which, though of very different mineral characters, unquestionably represent by position and fossils the Wen- lock and Ludlow formations. I cannot more tersely and clearly ex- press these relations than in the language which Professor Sedgwick himself applied to this region in 1845, i. e, six years after the publication of the " Silurian System." " Thus, the fossiliferous slates," says he, " present, first, the Lower Silurian rocks in a very degenerate form, and secondly, the Upper Silurian in a noble series,''"'* Nor can I convey a better idea of the succession of rocks in this district than by referring the reader to sections and descriptions by the same author, published in 1846, when combined with his last memoirs of 1852. It is enough for me, on this occasion, to state, that these show a conformable succession of deposits from the crystalline chiastolite schists, resting on a granitic nucleus or centre, * See Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. i. p. 443. 148 SILURIA. [Chap. VII, up through Skiddaw slates, and a vast thickness of green slates and porphyry, to a thin band of limestone (Llandeilo and Bala), and a considerable thickness of overlying flagstone, with Lower Silurian fossils, followed, as the Professor has recently discovered, by the equivalent of the Caradoc sandstone (the " Coniston Grits"). These are surmounted by a copious Upper Silurian series, in which the Wenlock and Ludlow formations are recognized by their position and fossils, though in their mineral aspect they differ much from the original types. This. Upper Silurian series, forming the rocks on both sides of Windermere, and thence extending far to the south, consists in the first instance of the Ireleth slates. These rocks have a slaty cleavage oblique to the beds, are in parts calcareous, and have proved to be the equivalents of the Wenlock formation, or more particularly of its hard slaty form which occurs in Denbighshire. The overlying masses are sandy and pebbly rocks. Then follow other coarse slates, grits, and flags, called by Mr. Sharpe " Winder- mere rocks," in which Lower Ludlow fossils occur, and then a very distinct representative of the Upper Ludlow, as proved both by position and fossils, but differing in being a much harder sandy flagstone than the rocks of like age in Siluria. The series ter- minates upwards in true tilestones, which, on the banks of the Lune and near Kendal, are the exact counterparts of the uppermost Silurian zone, and are charged with numerous fossils, some of the most striking of which will be treated of in chap. 9.*). * The reader who desires to study the data by which our present knowledge of the geology of the Lake district has been acquired must read the various memoirs of Professor Sedgwick in the Proceedings of the Geological Society, vol. ii. p. 675., and the Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. i. p. 442., vol. ii. p. 106., vol. iii. p. 133., vol. iv. p. 216., vol. viii. pp. 35. 136.; the Memoirs of Mr. Sharpe, Proc. Geol. Soc, vol. iv. pp. 23, 70.; and those by Professor Phillips, Geol. Trans. If.S., vol. iii. p. 1., and vol. iv. p. 95. Chap. VII.] SILURIANS OP SCOTLAND. 149 In this region, however, the ascending series is interrupted, as Professor Sedgwick has shown.* Instead of a complete series of the Old Eed Sandstone, as it has been described in Shropshire, Here- fordshire, or South Wales, and a conformable gradation and passage upwards into its overlying sandstones and marls, the Silurian rocks of all ages are at once unconformably overlapped by red masses, chiefly coarse conglomerates, which alone represent the great and complex group to be considered next in order. Silurian Rocks of Scotland, — In the early days of Scottish geo- logy, its illustrious founders Hutton and Playfair considered the schistose mountains in the south of Scotland to be void of all traces of life, until their able associate. Sir James Hall, detected a few fossil shells in a limestone at Wrae Hill, in Peebleshire, which had been considered to be primary. The merit of transferring these strata from the primary to the transition class is also in great measure due to our contemporary Professor Jameson; for though he made little account, as was usual when he wrote, of organic remains, he gave a clear general view of the rocks. " On the one discovery of Sir James Hall at Wrae Hill, our Scottish geologists," says Hugh Miller in a recent sketch, " seem to have hybernated for more than forty years." f It was not until some years after the publication of the " Silurian System" that the researches of Professor Nicol first really indi- cated the relations of the Wrae fossils and the associated schistose * Besides this general transgression and unconformity, it has been pointed out by Professor Sedgwick, that this " old red" contains many fragments of the Silurian tilestones, which must have been solid before the conglomerate was formed. — Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. i. p. 449. •j" For a complete historical sketch, see a notice by Mr. Hugh Miller (Witness newspaper, November 24th and 27th, 1852). A single fossil was found, but not described, by Laidlaw, the friend of Walter Scott ; and orthoceratites were after- wards discovered by Mr. Charles Maclaren in the Pentland Hills, and noticed in his excellent work, entitled " the Geology of Fife and the Lothians," 1839. L 3 150 SILURIA. [Chap. Vir. masses to the known members of the series ; and, since then, other researches of that author, as well as of Moore, Sedgwick, Cun- ningham, Stevenson, Harkness, and myself have brought the Scottish masses into a distinct comparison with their true types. Silurian rocks, and particularly their lower members, are now known to occupy a very large region of the south of Scotland. Ranging on the whole from E.N.E. to W.S.W., they appear in con- siderable masses in Berwickshire and Roxburghshire, and thence spread out in still larger areas over the counties of Selkirk, Peebles, Dumfries, Kirkcudbright, Galloway, Wigton, and Ayr. In short, they constitute, on the whole, the undulating moory hills, which, from their prevalent wildness of aspect, have been called the South Highlands. Subjected, as they have been, to numerous eruptions of granite, syenite, porphyry, greenstone, and other igneous rocks, some of these grey wacke schists have long been known to geologists for the remarkable curvatures they exhibit in the sea-cliffs of Ber- wickshire. A drawing is here annexed, whicli represents such View of the Cliffs near St. Abb's Head. (From a sketch by Sir A. Alison, Bart.) Chap. VII.] SILURIAN AXIS — SCOTLAND. 151 flexures and breaks, as seen in the cove, called Petticur Wick, near St. Abb's Head.* As numerous similar contortions are also seen to have taken place in the western prolongation of the same great series to the coast of Wigton and Ayr, we ought to be cautious in drawing determinate sections across the interior portions of a region where the surface of the round and undulating hills is obscured by moss, heath, and bog, and where exposures of the bare rock are rarely to be met with. Difficult, however, as it has been to determine the oldest portion of these inland masses of the Scottish greywacke, we have now reached that starting-point. When traversing the tract between Dumfries and Moffat, in 1850, it occurred to me that the dull reddish or purple hard greywacke to the north of the former town, which so resembled the bottom rocks of the Longmynd, Llanberis, and St. David's t, would prove to be of the same age, and, therefore, the true South Scottish axis. For, this rock (in great part similar to the hard greywacke of St. Abb's Head) seemed evidently to throw off anthracitic schists, with graptolites, both to the south and to the north. Mr. Harkness established this order, after my visit, by de- tailed sections in that parallel, ranging by the Dryfe Water. | Professor Nicol, who led the way in opening out the proofs, both physical and fossiliferous, that the South Scottish Hills were really Silurian, has now satisfied himself that this real axis of the old un- fossiliferous greywacke ranges by Teviotdale. § Proceeding from * The woodcut is taken from one of several rapid but very clever sketches made in my note-book, in the autumn of 1833, by the historian Sir Archibald Alison, from a boat in which Sir John Hall of Dunglass and Professor Sedgwick were also my companions. Some of the lower buttresses are porphyries and other igneous rocks, which form the adjacent headland of St. Abb's. The convoluted masses form a portion of the Longmynd or bottom rocks of the region. f Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. vii. p. 162. X Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. vii. p. 52., and vol. viii. p. 393. § Meeting of British Association, Belfast, 1852. L 4 SILURIA. [Chap. VII. 'UOIJL'IUJOJ ]B03 pUB •/'ajeaaiuoiSuoo p»jj pio J* span uonug g o IN •S3JBIS aapnuoqx H •sa^Bis uoisauo •suoisanin 3bji^\ •/'auojspnES pay piQ •^'sppg -fBOa pUB 3U01S •iaiqdjoj puB dcax m II <5 tc § " - I o -S ^ ^ S ?2 - SILURIANS OF GALWAY. 169 In proceeding from Round- stone Bay on the south, low isles and headlands of granite, *, fol- lowed by syenitic and horn- blendic rocks, f, throw off highly altered micaceous and quartzose schists, with courses of white and grey crystalline limestone, a, which, as you ascend the moun- tain of Ben Glenisky, one of the twelve Bins of Connemara, are seen to be followed by strong masses granular, white, quartz rock (manifestly an altered sand- stone) which alternate with mica- slate, b. Interlaced in the lower part of this series, and lying in depres- sions between Ben Glenisky and Ben Bawn (2300 feet above the sea), and thence ranging to the west, are certain crystalline lime- stones, one course of which is grey and white, and another is the beautiful green serpen- tinous marble, or serpentine of Connemara. These are again I overlaid by the granular quartz I 2 ^ I I rocks and mica-slates, b, which, S o S ^ occupying the greater portion 1 ^ ^ ^ of these moun tarns, are, in S O O * I " I g some places, surmounted on § a 2 ^ ^^^.^ northern face (with a slight -2 s ^ 2 ^ a O u (D C r2 *^ .2 ^-=3 ^ S E? a, f m » " c« .2 o ^ >> O H « 5 OS I ^ w 1 2 ^ s o fl *^ eS .SO) o <» f3 « «3 S 'I' t; 2 g o •2 g g S 2 tn C3 <» (-" o « s « -S .s "S S '3 '^3 3 5 m Sa, +J ^ 2 S 0_^o&i<:S^jS-^2'-'n?"-' 22 ^ 2 5.:^ " >>5 ^ § ^ ^ -2 J i i I 22 i ^ I § I il § & o § ill o f .a ^Jl ^.gg I ^ 5 ^ -S 1 « 1 3 ^ o *» a O cS O o O o a ^ >■ « o fl o -2 ^ 2 I' S -3 2'S:a akS 2 « O « w a ^ ^ ^ a •5 .r^ 1 ^ ? ^ a ill O) .S ^ eS ^ '-S ,fl S)2.2 -9 I- I C S « X c4 5^ i 5 G oj « CS cs o o o ^ pq ^ « -v. « 2 9 <» o ^ -S J 2" w ^ S .2 '3 c2 ^ " s » ^ a ^ cr to es X3 CO ^ Chap. X.] DEVONIAN OP DEVON AND CORNWALL. 257 Devonian Rocks {the equivalents of the Old Red) in Devon and Cornwall. — The crystalline and slaty condition of most of the stratified deposits in Devon and Cornwall, and their association with granitic and eruptive rocks and much metalliferous matter, might well induce the earlier geologists to class them as among the very oldest deposits of the British Isles. In truth, the south-western extremity of England presented apparently no regular sedimentary succession, by which its grey, slaty schists, marble limestones, and silicious sandstones could be connected with any one of the British deposits the age of which was well ascertained. The establishment of the Silurian System, and the proofs it afforded of the entire separation of its fossils from those of the Carboniferous era, was the first step which led to a right understanding of the age of these deposits. The next was the proof obtained by Professor Sedgwick and myself, that the " culm measures" of Devon were truly of the age of the carboniferous limestone, and that they graduated downwards into some of the slaty rocks of this region. Hence, in the sequel it became manifest, that the rocks now under consideration, were the immediate and natiiral precursors of the coal era, and stood therefore in the place of the Old Red Sandstone of other regions. The highly important deduction, how- ever, of Mr. Lonsdale, that the fossils of the South Devon lime- stones, as collected by Mr. Austen and others, really exhibited a character intermediate between those of the Silurian system and of the carboniferous limestone, was the most cogent reason which induced Professor Sedgwick and myself (after identifying North and South Devon) to propose the term Devonian.* The inference that the stratified rocks of Devonshire and Cornwall, though of such varied composition, are really the equivalents of the Old Eed * See Reports of Brit. Assoc. for the Advancement of Science, 1836. Bristol Meeting. Sedgwick and Murchison, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. v. p. 633., and Phil. Mag. vol. xi. p. 311. Lonsdale, supra. S 258 SILURIA. [Chap. X. Sandstone in the regions alluded to, has since, indeed, been amply supported and extended by the researches of Sir Henry De la Beche, Professor Phillips, and many other good geologists.* The most instructive of the sections published by my colleague and myself to illustrate the general structure of Devonshire, is that of v^hich the diagram in p. 256. is a compiled reduction, f It is a section across North Devon from the Foreland on the Bristol Chan- nel, to the granitic ridge of Dartmoor on the south, and exhibits a copious succession of the Devonian rocks between Linton and II- fracombe on the north, and Barnstaple on the south ; the whole dipping under strata of the carboniferous age J, on the opposite side of a wide trough of which, or on the north flank of Dartmoor, the Upper Devonian strata again rise to the surface. North Devon has thus been selected as affording, on the whole, the best type of succession of the rocks to which the name Devonian was applied ; because it offers a clear ascending section through several thousand feet of varied strata, until we reach other overlying rocks, which are undeniably the bottom beds of the true carboniferous group. For, whether we advance to the south of Barnstaple from the north, or to the north of Petherwin from the edge of Dartmoor on the south (section, p. 256.), we find ourselves in a wide §, overlying trough of much softer nature, and in which the slaty character does not * See Report on the Geology of Cornwall, Devon, and W. Somerset, by De la Beche, 1839, and the Palaeozoic fossils of the same region,by Professor Phillips, 1841. t See Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond. 2nd Ser. vol. v. pi. L. figs. 1. and 2. J The coal-field which is bituminous in Monmouth, Glamorgan, and Carmarthen, becomes anthracitic in Pembroke. There the stone coal, much fractured by dis- locations, differs from that of Devon only in being more productive in broken culm or stone-coal. § The thickness of these lower carboniferous strata must not be estimated by the breadth which they occupy on a geological map : for, owing to countless convolu- tions, the very same beds are repeated over and over. The bottom beds only of these undulations or small portions of each side of the culm trough (g) are repre- sented in the section. Chap. X.] DEVONIAN OF SOUTH DEVON. 259 exist. And, although this overlying series is in mineral aspect as much unlike the carboniferous series of most other parts of Bri- tain, as the rocks of North Devon are unlike the ordinary Old Eed Sandstone of Central and North Britain, we have clear proofs, besides the analogy with Pembrokeshire before spoken of, that the Posi- donomya black limestone, or the calcareous band (in ^ of the previous section), does represent, on a miniature scale, the mountain or car- boniferous limestone; that the next series of white grit and sand- stone stands in the place of the millstone grit ; and that the over- lying courses of stone coal or culm, with many remains of plants, are consequently the equivalents of some of the coal-bearing strata of other tracts described in the next chapter. The objections, therefore, (which have, however, been only very partially made) to the view taken by Professor Sedgwick and myself, that the Devonian rocks of the above section are the true representa- tives in time of the vast deposits of Old Red Sandstone of Scotland and England, seem to me to be quite untenable. In truth, the long period which was occupied in developing those enormously thick deposits must have produced elsewhere equivalent accumulations ; and the vast series of North Devon thus occupies precisely the position of a succession of strata synchronous to that of the Old Ked Sandstone. And, as every geologist knows, that the crystalline feature of slaty cleavage has been impressed upon these Devonian rocks long after their formation, so must he also admit, that the change from the red sand and mud of Hereford, Brecknock^ and Caermarthen to the red and grey mud of Devon, is by no means abrupt, but resembles the gradual change shown in Pembroke. Nor, is there any difficulty in supposing, how by a less diffusion of iron, and under dissimilar sub- marine conditions, the southern portion of the area of the very same sea should have less of the red and sandy character than the northern. The great eruption of the granite of Dartmoor, which affected both the Devonian and carboniferous strata in contact with it, has so 260 SILURIA. [Chap. X. usurped the place of the regular deposits in South Devon, that in vain do we look, either in that district or in Cornwall, for the same clear order as in North Devon. In fact, the derangement in the western part of South Devon and the adjacent parts of Cornwall is so great, that the Lower Silurian rocks are seen, as already stated, to overlie true Devonian rocks!* The metamorphism and mine- ralization of some of the schists has indeed been carried to such an extent, that they often resemble the oldest primary rocks. Still, there are adequate means of bringing the disjointed and occasionally inverted masses of South Devon into comparison with the clear order of North Devon. This is in great measure accomplished through the fossils f of its extensive lower limestones, being much more numerous and better preserved than those of like age in North Devon. The lowest lime- stones, for example, which are on the parallel of those of Combe Martin and llfracombe (c of the long section), and rise in great masses near Plymouth and Ogwell, ranging at intervals to Newton Bushell and Torquay J, are laden with corals and shells, many species * See p. 145. and Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. viii. p. 13. f The differences between the mineral succession in North and South Devon, on the opposite sides of the great granitic axis of Dartmoor, are explained by Professor Sedgwick and myself, Geol. Trans, vol. v. p. 3. p. 635. I One of the finest collections of the S. Devon fossils was made by Mr. R. A. C. Austen, whose researches in the field, and whose study of the organic remains, have materially contributed to a correct acquaintance with the stratified rocks of Devonshire. See Lonsdale, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. v. p. 721. In a recent Memoir on the Palaeozoic rocks of the Boulonnais (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. ix. p. 244) ; Mr. Austen classes the Petherwin and Pilton beds, like myself, with the Devonian rocks, whilst he separates the S. Devon limestones of Newton and Ogwell from those of Ashburton, Bickerton, and Chudleigh. If in this popular work I retain the older view, and group together the S. Devon limestones, I would in no respect detract from the value of such a subdivision. My present belief is, indeed, that the lower sandstones, conglomerates, and slates (or the a & of the previous section), are truly the equivalents of the Lower Rhenish or Coblentzian, shelly, greywacke sandstone ; thus completing the parallel between the British and Rhenish Devonian rocks, and giving to each a similar base. In respect to the Upper Devonian division, all foreign geologists Chap. X.] DEVONIAN OF SOUTH DEVON. 261 of which occur in rocks of the same age in various parts of the con- tinent of Europe, and notably in the limestones of the Eifel, the Rhenish provinces, and Belgium. Now, many of these fossils are quite peculiar : for whilst they exhibit an intermediary character, approaching in the lower beds of this series to those of the Silu- rian System, and in the upper strata to those of the Carboniferous era, there can be no doubt that on the whole they constitute an inde- pendent group. Among the most typical of these peculiar fossils, and which, wherever they may be found, mark the strata in which they occur as being of Devonian age, are the large moUusks Stringocephalus giganteus, Foss. 52. f. 4., the Megalodon cucul- latus, f. 2., and Calceola sandalina, f. 1., represented in this woodcut, together with Pleurodictyum problematicum, Cyathophyllum caespi- tosum, and Murchisonia bilineata, f. 3. Fossils, 52. Shells of thk Lower Devonian Limestones. 1. Calceola sandalina, Linn. 2. Megalodon cucuUatus, Sow. 3. Murchisonia bilineata, Goldf. 4 Stringocephalus giganteus, Sow. 5. Atrypa desquamata, Sow. who classify by organic remains, have placed the Clymenia and Cypridina limestone in the Devonian system, and I must therefore entirely dissent from a recent proposal of Mr. D. Sharpe, to remove it to the base of the carboniferous rocks. But, if an intermediate band like this may in one region present more of a carboniferous type than in another, and therefore admit of much liberty in drawing the line s 3 262 SILURIA. LChap. X. All the species of Trllobites, known in the Silurian system, have disappeared, and their places are taken by others, of which Brontes flabellifer, Goldfuss, and Phacops latifrons, Bronn, are striking types. In short, Trilobites, which swarmed in the Silurian era, are comparatively very scarce in the Devonian ; two or three only of the very numerous genera of the former era being known in it. Among the mollusca, nearly all the species of Atrypa, Orthis, and Spirifer, differ from those of the Silurian era. One or two exceptions only occur. Great changes in the proportional number of species in such genera also take place, and certain genera which were common in the older period are no longer traceable. Thus, the genus Orthis becomes infinitely less abundant, whilst the Spirifer, comparatively rare in the older rocks, augments much in number of species, and especially in the size of the shell — the large broad winged species being singularly characteristic of rocks of this age, and particularly in the Lower Devonian of several foreign countries. But no form in Britain, is more typical than Atrypa desquamata, Foss. 52. f. 5. One shell, however, the Atrypa reticularis, must here be mentioned as an exception to the prevalent rule of each great group being cha- racterized by distinct forms ; for this hardy species, with which the reader became so familiar in the Silurian rocks (see p. 188), lived on to the Devonian era, and is equally common with the last in the limestones and shale of Devonshire. To return to the section, p. 256. The highest rock which is there classed as Devonian, and is, on the whole, a mere upward con- tinuation of the slaty series with subordinate inferior sandstone, of separation, I can still less admit the comparison sought to be established by the same author, between a few unfossiliferous beds of red sandstone, shale, and conglomerate, which at Pepinster, in Belgium, form a very small portion indeed of the series of Devonian rocks, and the enormous deposit of the Old Red Sand- stone of the British Isles, which, without any break, occupies the vast interval between the Silurian and Carboniferous Rocks. This point will be further ex- plained in describing the Rhenish Devonian Rocks. See Sharpe, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. ix. p. 23. Chap. X.] GENERAL VIEW OF THE DEVONIAN. 263 is occasionally also calcareous, presenting thin courses of limestone, in which many fossils occur. This is the band of Pilton and Barn- staple. Now, whilst the lower sandy strata of this division, as at Marwood and Baggy Point, contain Dolabra (CucuUsea) Har- dingii, Foss. 53. f. 2., and D. trapezium, Sow. ; Bellerophon subglo- batus, M*Coy, with casts of Stigmaria and other land plants, — the upper or calcareous part is charged with small, true, Devonian Trilobites, such as Phacops latifrons, Bronn ; together with Orthis, Pleurotomaria, Spirifer, Terebratula, and Productus, few of which occur in the Carboniferous Kocks. Here again, though with con- siderable mineral variations, we see the same upward succession as in Scotland and Ireland, and in approaching the summit of what has been classed as Devonian or Old Red, we are gradually introduced to the land vegetation of the Carboniferous era. This uppermost course of impure Devonian limestone is repre- sented on the south side of the great trough of culm or coal mea- sures, as expressed in the previous section, by the band of Petherwin, /, in which a great number of fossils have been found, and these clearly identify it with the Upper Devonian of many parts of the continent of Europe. Such are the Phacops granulatus, Foss. 53. f. 5.; Clymenia linearis, f. 1.; C. laevigata, Miinster; Spirifer Verneuili (disjuncta. Sow.), f. 4. &c. Fossils, 63. Shells of the Upper Devonian Limestone. .. Clymenia linearis, Miinst. 2. Dolabra Hardingii. Sow. 3. Strophalosia caperata, Sow. 4. Spirifer Verneuili, Murch. 6. Phacops granulatus, Munster. s 4 264 SILURIA. [Chap. X. This Upper Devonian of South Britain, which occupies, in my opinion, the same place in the geological series as the uppermost red sandstones flanking the Silurian region, — the yellow sand- stone of Fifeshire with shells and plants, — and the sandstones with the Telerpeton in the N. of Scotland — is, I repeat, well exposed in the beds of Petherwin, Pilton, and Marwood, N. Devon (/of the sec- tion). In addition to Phacops granulatus, Clymeniae, and other fossils, above mentioned, this band is also marked by the presence of a minute crustacean, Cypridina serratostriata, Sandb., of which I shall have to speak in treating of the Devonian rocks of Germany. The discovery in Britain of this small crustacean was not made until after the distinguished palaeontologists, the brothers Sandberger, had found it in myriads occupying the upper schistose and calcareous rocks of the Rhine, which Professor Sedgwick and myself had long ago shown to pass immediately under the lowest carboniferous de- posits, and to be the true equivalents of our rocks of Devonshire. The observation of M. F. Sandberger (for it was he who first detected this Cypridina in British rock specimens sent to him) has therefore been peculiarly valuable, as, through the presence of this minute but very characteristic crustacean, we now learn more conclusively, that the limits of the Devonian rocks in S. Britain have been cor- rectly defined ; their equivalents in Germany being similarly so distinguished. In subsequent chapters we shall see that analogous divisions of the Devonian Rocks are also developed in different parts of Europe, and that in the Rhenish provinces especially, a triple division may even be preferred. It will further appear, how, in other tracts, but more particularly in Russia, the ichthyolites of the Old Red Sand- stone of Scotland and the marine mollusca of Devonshire are found united in the same strata : thus demonstrating the simultaneous accumulation of deposits, which, although they differ considerably in mineral aspect, occupy precisely the same place in the series of deposits. Chap. X.] TERRESTRIAL PLANTS OF THE DEVONIAN. 265 In having previously alluded to a shell found in a given tract of the Old Red of Scotland, and to others in the S. of Ireland, as being of fresh-water origin, we must, however, only consider them as ex- ceptions to the general character of deposits which are essentially marine in other parts of the world. It is, in fact, chiefly the upper member of the series, which affords evidence of the spoils of the adjacent land having been swept into estuaries and seas. In quitting this brief consideration of the highly diversified and important group of the Devonian or Old Red rocks of the British Isles, it must not be forgotten, that whilst some of its lowest members have rarely afforded traces of land plants, its uppermost members in Ireland, as in Devonshire and Shetland, contain a greater number, including tree ferns and calamites. We must equally remember, that the latter plants are associated, in Scotland and Ireland, with ichthyolites of the Devonian epoch, and occur in strata which rise out from beneath the lowest beds of the carboniferous rocks. Nay, more, it is in strata of this age that we also first meet with that assemblage of natural products which might be expected ; for the most ancient fresh-water shells and the oldest air-breathing reptile which have been discovered, are the legitimate associates of this early land vegetation. Certain terrestrial plants of this period will be afterwards adverted to as occurring in Germany. In fact, the uppermost member of the Devonian and the lowest division of the Carboniferous are sometimes so linked together, that where the carboniferous lime- stone is wanting, it is no easy matter to draw any positive line of separation between these groups. Such results must, indeed, have invariably followed from the ordinary operation of natural causes, wherever great subaqueous deposits were quietly and successively accumulated. In terminating this chapter the reader must be reminded, that although there is no Upper Silurian in the south-western extremity 266 SILURIA. [Chap. X. of England, Lower Silurian strata have been adverted to, as ranging along a few of the southern headlands of Cornwall, and as being at once flanked by Devonian strata (p. 144.). In subsequent chapters it will be shown, how Lower Silurian rocks are similarly followed by Devonian formations over very large portions of the continent of Europe, to the almost entire exclusion of the Upper Silurian. My friend, the Rev. John Fleming, D.D., to one of whose original papers on the organic remains of the Old Red Sandstone I have already referred, has recently assured me, that the fruit-like body found in Fifeshire and in the Arbroath paving-stones of Forfarshire, (see p. 247.) is unquestionably a vegetable, and cannot be classed as the egg of a mollusk, as suggested by Lyell, or as the egg of a batrachian, as more recently proposed by Mantell. The figure which Dr. Fleming gave in the year 1831, Edin. Journal of Nat. Science, vol. 3, pi. 2. fig. 5., is in itself pretty good evidence in favour of his opinion, that it is an aggregate fruit. Since then he has examined both the upper and under surfaces, and has quite satisfied himself that it is a receptacle, and that the round bodies covering it are carpels or fruits. In the above-mentioned Memoir, Dr. Fleming first pointed out certain terrestrial and freshwater conditions of the Upper Old Red Sandstone of Scotland. Chap. XI.] FIRST COnOUS LAND VEGETATION. 267 CHAPTER XL CARBONIFEPwOUS ROCKS. GREAT PRIMEVAL FLORA THE SOURCE OP THE OLD COAL DEPOSITS. — GENERAL VIEW OF THESE DEPOSITS AND THEIR ORGANIC REMAINS IN THE BRITISH ISLES. Ascending in the scale of deposits, we have now reached another grand accumulation of strata, which is not only replete with many types of animal life peculiar to it and unknown in antecedent pe- riods, but specially characterized by the earliest abundant remains of a terrestrial vegetation. For, the reader will remember, that there are no traces of land plants in the great mass of the Silurian rocks ; and that it is only where their uppermost strata unite with the Devonian, that certain traces of land plants have been sparingly detected. Even in the Devonian rocks such plants, as before stated, are rare, and only begin to prevail as we pass upwards and are sur- rounded by the spoils of this first great woody era. Now, as these primeval plants were the substances out of which the great mass of the mineral termed coal has been formed (all natu- ralists and chemists admitting the fact) ; so, for the first time in mount- ing up from the basement rocks, do we meet with those copious accu- mulations of that mineral in conjunction with the impressions and casts in stone of the numerous plants out of which it has been formed. Some idea of the characters of the rank, luxuriant vegetation which must in this age, have overspread very wide areas of land, from polar to nearly equatorial latitudes, may be formed by inspecting the annexed woodcut, in which an ideal representation is given of a por- tion of the earth's surface, as clothed with plants, the fragments of 268 SILUEIA. [Chap. XI. which bespeak the presence of rich, vascular cryptogamia, whose fossilized stems and leaves are frequently to be detected even in the IdexVl View of the Vegetation of the Carboniferous Era. coal itself. In the standard work of Bronn, von Meyer, and Gop- pert, which gives the most complete, general tabular view of ancient nature hitherto published*, Professor Goppert estimates the total number of known species of fossil plants of what is here considered the carboniferous aera as 934, which are thus distributed : — " Cellulares, including the Fungi, Algae, &c., 19. Vasculares, 915; of which 772 are cryptogamous Plants 934. -{ plants, or Ferns, Calamites, Asterophyllites, &c. ; and 94 are dicotyledonous plants, such as Cycads, Conifers, and Club-mosses. The result, arrived at by this fossil botanist, agrees generally with that of his precursor in this line of inquiry, M. Adolphe Brongniart, who first gave to the world a general and philosophical view of the distribution of former vegetation. On his part M. Goppert has not * Bronn s Geschichte der Natur, vol. iii. part 2. The so called "Transition" plants of Goppert are included in this list ; because it has been ascertained, that nearly all of them occur in strata which, formerly viewed as ancient grauwacke^'"' are now known to be of no higher antiquity than the lower division of the carboni- ferous rocks. Chap. XI.] GENERAL CARBONIFEROUS ORDER. 269 only added considerably to the number of species, but also to the number of dicotyledonous or forest trees. Both, however, of these eminent men, as well as many other botanists are agreed in the opinion, that as the great mass of the plants belong to the vascular, cryptogamic class, the conditions of climate under which such vegetables grew in very various latitudes, is a phenomenon "per se, and especially characteristic of that period which geologists call " Carboniferous." These plants, marking, as above stated, the earliest great vegetable period, are, in fact, as decisive of the Carboniferous as the great abundance of Trilobites and Graptolites is of the Silurian era. But, whilst the earlier sys- tem is marked only by its submarine contents, the carboniferous deposits owe their chief features to the actual presence or contiguity of lands covered with a peculiar vegetation, which, disappearing with the younger primeval strata, was never afterwards reproduced upon the earth. For, no one of the floras of subsequent geological periods possessed those characteristic features of rank, gigantic cryptogamia, indicative of an inter-tropicnl climate, which so prominently marked the vegetation of the epoch which geologists term the Carboniferous. In most of their lithological characters the successive strata of the Carboniferous rocks do not differ essentially from many which have preceded them. Like the Silurian and Devonian, they contain beds of shale, sandstone, pebbles or conglomerate, and limestone, though they seldom exhibit a true slaty cleavage.* But, when examined more closely, they vary considerably in their nature and contents in different parts of the world. In subsequent chapters a few allusions will be made to these variations in other countries ; but for the pre- sent we will only take a cursory view of some of their features in Britain. In the region represented in the map annexed to this work the Car- * In parts of France the carboniferous rocks are very crystalline and slaty, as I have shown in a memoir on the environs of Vichy. Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. vii. p. 14. 270 SILUEIA. [Chap. XI. boniferous rocks are most fully developed in the great South Welsh basin of Glamorgan, Caermarthen and Monmouth, where an ascend- ing order from the summit of the Old Eed Sandstone, through limestone, shale, sandstone and grits, upwards into an enormously thick coal field, is cleai'ly exhibited in lofty escarpments, particularly around the northern, eastern, and western edges of that grand basin. (See lower section, p. 243.) The same succession, though on a smaller scale, is seen around the smaller basin of the Forest of Dean, and again, with certain mineral variations, in the county of Pembroke. Towards the north, however, the calcareous and lower members of the series are more developed, than in South Wales, as observed in the Oswestry coal field, and in Shropshire and Flintshire. This expan- sion of the inferior strata of the system towards the north, becomes still more striking in Derbyshire, Yorkshire, and Xorthumberland. In some of the coal tracts within or adjacent to the Silurian region, as at Dudley and Wolverhampton, the true base of the group, or the carboniferous limestone, is wanting ; the productive fields being there seen to repose at once on Silurian rocks (see woodcut, p. 465.). In those districts, however, and along the banks of the Severn, good evidences are obtained of the relations of the coal strata to the over- lying red deposits now termed Permian, and of which hereafter. When viewed, therefore, as a whole, and in the region of the coloured map, the Carboniferous group {h to g) may be stated to lie between the Old Red a, and the Permian rocks A, thus : — Ge>t:ral Relations of the Cakboxiferofs Kocks et the Ce>-tfvAl axd Southern Parts of Exglaxd. a b c d e * g a. Upper beds of the Old Eed Sandstone (Devonian), b. Limestone shale. c. Carboniferous limestone, d. Millstone grit. e. Coal and ironstone. / Main coal fields, p. Upper coal with a peculiar limestoue. h. Eed sandstone (base of Permian rocks). Chap. XL] CARBONIFEROUS LIMESTONE. 271 As on this occasion it is impracticable to attempt to treat in detail of the various aspects of these carboniferous deposits, strictly so called, in different British districts, a very slight sketch only of some of their striking peculiarities can be attempted. Separated from the upper band of the Old Red Sandstone by beds of dark and party-coloured shale {h of the section), the lime- stone (known as the mountain limestone of geologists c,) is the dominant rock of the lower division. The massive nature of these calcareous rocks and their vast development in Derbyshire, Yorkshire, and Northumberland, are well known to geologists. Even within the region of my original Silurian map, this limestone when traced along the rim of the great South Wales coal field, or from Caermarthen into Pembrokeshire, is seen to be there exhibited continuously, in bold coast cliffs, particularly in the promontory of Stackpole, where it is much contorted, as in these two sketches. The first of them represents the contortions of the rocks, with their numerous clefts Stackpole Cliffs of Carboniferous Limestone. Sketched by Lady Murchison. From SU. Syst. p. 382. and caverns, as seen from Bull Slaughter Bay. The next is a view of one of the detached folds of the same limestone, known as Stack- pole Rock. Though these cliffs seldom exceed 150 feet in height. 272 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. yet, being precipitous and abrupt, they present a very rugged, wild, and picturesque barrier to the sea. Stackpole Rock.* Sketched by Lady Murchison. From Sil. Syst. p. 370. Whilst the carboniferous limestone is separated, as before stated, from the Devonian, or Old Red, by shales (which in Pembrokeshire are in parts both sandy and calcareous), it is there, as in most other districts of England, surmounted by light-coloured sandstones of con- siderable thickness, which are knowm under the name of millstone grit. The following section of the general succession of the strata in Pembrokeshire exhibits, at one view, the whole order from the Silu- rian rocks up to the productive coal above the millstone grit. General Order in Pe^ibrokeshire. e d c 0 a Coal or Millstone Carb. Old Eed Sandstone. Silurian, culm. grit. limest. * These striking cliffs are the property of my esteemed friend the Earl of Cawdor, whose chief residence, Stackpole Court, is situated on the carboniferous limestone, and whose other residence, in Wales, Golden Grove, is on the Llandeilo formation of the Lower Silurian rocks, (see distant edifice, sketch, p. 69.). Chap. XI.] CARBONIFEKOUS ROCKS OF ENGLAND. 273 To pass, however, from a, diagram of the general order to a natural section, the English student may examine with ease and in a small compass the Carboniferous series from its base upwards to the produc- tive coal inclusive, on the south-east slope of the Titterstone Clee Hill in Shropshire.* Ascending from a depression in the Old Red Sandstone near Cleobury to the eastern summit of that hill, he will pass suc- cessively over the three divisions of limestone and shale, millstone grit, and productive coal ; the whole being capped by basalt, which is seen to have been erupted through the entire series, and to have overflowed on the top of the hill. Section across the Cornbrook Coal Basin op the Clee Hills. (From Sil. Syst., p. 113. pi. 30. f. 6.) d * b a a. Upper beds of Old Red or Devonian.^ b. Carboniferous limestone and shale, c. Millstone grit. d. Coal measures. * Eruptive basalt, which has risen through and overflowed the coal. The lower Carboniferous members, or the shale, limestone, and grit (6, c), are, however, of comparatively small dimensions in and around the Silurian region, when compared with their representatives in Derbyshire and the north of England. In that territory, particu- larly in the west of Yorkshire and Lancashire, they swell out into a vastly thicker series. In ascending order those strata consist of the great scar limestone, estimated to vary in thickness from 500 to 1,000 feet ; and that mass is followed, in the west of Yorkshire, by considerable alternations of shale and limestone, considered by Pro- * Any one who is desirous of understanding the peculiarities of this coal-field may refer to the "Silurian System," p. 113., where the proofs of the existence of a vertical mass of basalt (*) rising up through the strata are explained, as well as the extraction of coal by shafts from beneath the overlying table of basalt. T 274 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. fessor Phillips to be about 1,000 feet thick ; while the whole is sur- mounted by 800 feet of millstone grit.* Again, besides its grand protrusions of basalt and greenstone, the bold coast of Northumberland and South Berwickshire exhibits these lower carboniferous limestones opening out into different courses and interlaced by copious masses of schist and several coal seams. One of the calcareous bands, near to the centre of the group, is especially characterized by Posidonomya Becheri (Bronn), a shell which marks tlie thin courses of black or culm limestone in Devonshire. This fossil, which is also of frequent occurrence in the schists and ' kiesel-schiefer ' of the Rhenish provinces of Prussia, both with and without limestone, is therefore a good type of the lower carboniferous age; though in tracts where the limestones expand, it occurs in one of their upper bands. It was by such proofs, and by the relations of the strata, that Professor Sedgwick and myself showed, that the Rhenish schists with Posidonomyae were the exact equivalents of the British carboniferous or culm limestone of Devon, and that the sandstones which overlie them (the ^Jungere Grauwacke,' or * Flotz-lehrer Sandstein' of the Germans), are the representatives of the British millstone grit.f It is in this lower division of the Carboniferous rocks, as composed of schists, and some limestones with Producti and other fossils, and a great underlying sandy series, that the chief Scottish coal-fields are developed. They are truly a con- tinuation of those beds of North Northumberland, which extending into Berwickshire, seem there to graduate downwards into the Old Red Sandstone. Having alluded to the convolutions of the Pembrokeshire lime- stone, it is right to explain, that the violence of the movements which * See the Memoirs of Professor Sedgwick, " On the General Structure of the Cumbrian Mountains," and " On the Carboniferous Chain from Penyghent to Kirkby Stephen." (Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond. N. S., vol. iv. pp. 47. et seq. ; also Phillips, Geology of Yorkshire, vol. ii.) t See Trans. Geol. Soc. London, N. S., vol. vi. p, 228. et seq. Chap. XT.] CARBONIFEROUS ROCKS OF IRELAND. 275 produced them, affected likewise most remarkably all the Carboni- ferous rocks of that region, and particularly the coal. Thus the coal which is there nearly all in the state of stone-coal, culm* or anthracite, has been for the most part shivered into small fragments, and is frequently accumulated in small troughs or hollows, the ' slashes ' of the miners. Of the great lateral pressure and violent fractures to which the strata have been subjected, the following woodcut may convey some idea. Slash of Culm. (From Sil. Syst,, p. 377.) b a. Contorted culm strata with stone coal. b. Fault, c. Slash of finely triturated culm between violently contorted strata, and probably upon a great line of fracture. These great disturbances were produced after the accumulation and solidification of the deposits under consideration. Lower Carboniferous Rocks in Ireland. — There is, perhaps, no country of the same size in which the carboniferous rocks are so widely extended and at the same time so little productive of coal as Ireland. This is doubtless in some measure due to the fact, that by far the greater portion of the Irish Carboniferous series of strata pertain to those lower divisions, which, though very rich in coal in Scotland, exhibit little or none of it in those parts of England which lie in the same latitudes as the mass of the Irish rocks of * The variations in mineral character of the anthracitic or culm trough of North Devon, which was doubtless at one time a mere extension of the Pembrokeshire strata of the same age, have been partially adverted to in the previous chapter. (See p. 260, and section, p. 256.) One thin course of black limestone with Posidonomyae is there the true representative of the great mas- sive calcareous cliffs of the opposite coast of Pembroke, and of the diversified North British Series ; so much for great mineral changes of the same rocks in our own isles ! (See pp. 256. et seq., and 271. et seq.) T 2 276 SILURIA. [Chap. xr. this age. The great overlying and productive coal-fields of England, therefore, either never existed in Ireland, or have been removed by- denudation. Exclusive of the strata which are to be separated as being of Devonian age (see p. 255.), the 'yellow sandstone' of Griffith, so defined where it is inter-stratified with courses of lime- stone and shale with Carboniferous fossils, is the oldest member of the system. This is followed by shale or schist, which assumes a slaty aspect, particularly in the Cork district, and alternates with other courses of limestone. The middle portion of the system is composed of the great lower limestone, followed by the dark grey, earthy limestone, known under the name of * Calp,' whilst the ' Upper Limestone ' of the midland and southern districts of Ireland is covered by the ' Millstone Grit.' This great succession of limestones and shales, the latter occasion- ally affected by a slaty cleavage, is seldom, indeed, seen in one clear and consecutive section, but undulating over very wide areas, is usually much obscured by gravel, shingle, and clay. AVhen, how- ever, the limestones form natural escarpments, as, for example, on the south bank of Lough Erne, and in the hills near Florence Court to the south of Enniskillen, where they exhibit a splendid succession and numerous fossils, includino; lars^e Producti in the lower and Posidonomyae in the higher strata, they contain no seams of coal worthy of notice. In the Cork district, indeed, (where the lower schists are so slaty and crystalline, that they might be mistaken for much older rocks,) some coal has been found ; but the quantity and value of it are little known. The limestone series of Ireland is proved to be of exclusively marine origin, from the multitude of well-preserved fossils it con- tains ; and of these Mr. Griffith (with the assistance of Professor M'Coy) has already prepared a list of about 500 species *, a consider- * A Synopsis of the Characters of the Carboniferous Limestone Fossils of Ireland, 1844 Chap. XI. J UPPER PRODUCTIVE COAL-FIELDS. 277 able number of which are stated to be identical with those of the underlying and Devonian rocks, but altogether different from those of the Silurian system. These lower members of the system, which, unluckily for Ireland, constitute, as before stated, by far the larger portion of all that is called carboniferous, are surmounted (but very partially) by grits and sandstones, in which, at three or four localities (Kilkenny in the south, and Ballycastle, Dungannon, and Coal Island in the north), a few thin beds of coal are situated ; but as they have as yet proved to be of comparatively slight value, and have no special bearing on the object of this work, I forbear to say more respecting them.* Overlying productive Coal-fields. — The lower Carboniferous series hitherto spoken of, or the shale, limestone and millstone grit, is all over Europe and North America essentially of marine origin. It has, indeed, affinities to the upper portion of the underlying Devonian rocks, into which it graduates. It is, however, distinguished from them by its chief animal remains, including many remarkable fishes ; and, above all, by the intermixture of terrestrial plants in an infinitely greater quantity than are known in the preceding epoch. With the repeated evidences of thin seams of coal being intercalated with bands of limestone of exclusively marine or estuary character, it is indeed a fair inference, that the vegetables (often in great matted bodies) out of which such lower coal was formed, were transported from the mouths of great rivers, or broke away from the shores of broad jungles, into the adjacent waters, and so together were asso- ciated with marine remains. * I must not, however, omit to do justice to a recent spirited endeavour of the Marquis of Downshire, who, discovering a fine mass of rock-salt and gypsum on his estates near Carrickfergus, sunk a shaft through it, which, when I visited the spot in 1852, had traversed a considerable thickness of the New Red forma- tion ; it being expected that coal in a good and unbroken state might be found underlying this, the only extensive mass of New Red Sandstone which had then been found in Ireland. T 3 278 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. When, however, we examine the nature of the great overlying coal strata, particularly those of England, another order of things is opened out to us. In most of these, whether in the South Welsh basin, or the northern and Durham fields, we lose all traces of marine life, and can recognize only huge accumulations of terrestrial, lacustrine or fluviatile origin. Thus in South Wales, where the coal measures are estimated to attain the great thickness of 12,000 feet, and one hundred coal beds are intercalated at various levels, we have undeniable evi- dence of successive terrestrial conditions — each of these coal-seams having immediately beneath it a band of sandy shale, called under- clay, and abounding in Stigmaria, or the roots of Sigillaria, one of the plants out of which coal has been generated. For this important fact, science is chiefly indebted to Mr. Logan, who demonstrated that the under-clay of the miner was the real soil of a primeval marsh or jungle. (See also Mammatt's Geological Facts, &c. 1834, p. 73.) The diagram in the beginning of this Chapter is intended to convey a general idea of the nature of the wet and swampy tracts in which the vegetation of this period flourished. The comparative rarity of true dicotyledons or forest trees in this flora, is as remarkable as the extraordinary uniformity in the families of plants of which it was composed. These consisted chiefly, as before said, of Lepidodendra, Equisetaceae, Asterophyllites, and Sigillariae, with some curious extinct pine-trees, a few of which resembled the living Araucaria of Norfolk Island. As many of these are found in the roof of the coal, and sometimes even in the coal itself*, there can remain but little doubt, that, in most of these cases, * Few persons, who are attentive observers of the contents of their cellars, will have failed to detect the forms of plants in the coal itself. Goppert has, indeed, recently demonstrated, by microscopic examination (and Witham in part anticipated him, "Observations on fossil Vegetables," 1833), that the vegetable fibres and tissues of all the families of the plants of this era are to be detected in the coal itself. In some layers all the plants are calamites, in others, ferns. (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. v.; Mem. p. 17.) Chap. XI.] UPPER CARBONIFEROUS FAUNA. 279 the mineral resulted from the fossilization of extensive ancient jungles or marshes. It may fairly be inferred, that this conversion of vegetables into coal, took place at a period in the formation of the crust of the earth, when very different physical conditions prevailed, and when a warmer and more equable (though probably not a hot) climate pervaded our islands, as well as latitudes far to the north and south of them. The supposition of many and suc- cessive subsidences of vast swampy jungles beneath the level of the waters, best explains how the different vegetable masses became covered by beds of sand and mud, so as to form the sandstone and shale of such coal-fields. But this theory of oscillation, or of the sub- sidence en masse of ancient marshes and their re- elevation (with occa- sional sand-drifts), though good in such examples as those of the South Welsh and Newcastle coal-fields in England, as also of the large coal-fields in British North America, to which Sir C. Lyell has re- cently called attention *, can have little application to those other seams of coal which, as before mentioned, are interstratified with beds containing marine shells, the animals of which, such as Producti and Spirifers, must have lived in comparatively deep sea-water. In such examples (and nearly all the older coal beds come into the category) we may, on the contrary, endeavour to explain the facts by the supposition, that ancient streams like the present Missis- sippi and other large rivers, which flowed through groves on low lands and mud banks, transported great quantities of trees, leaves, and roots entangled in earth, and deposited them at the bottom of adjacent estuaries, or that they were carried en masse into the broad, open sea. (See Postscript, p. 288.) The coasts of Northumberland and Berwickshire exhibit fine proofs of such conditions; but the most remarkable confirmation * See an excellent general sketch of the chief carboniferous deposits of Europe and America, with illustrations of the prevailing plants, in the 24th and 25th chapters of Ly ell's Manual of Geology, 1851. See also Ansted's^ " Ancient World." 280 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. of this view of the method by which some of the older coa has been formed, which ever fell under my own observation, occurs in the Russian field of the Donetz, in the Southern steppes. There, besides numerous beds of shale and sand, with remains of plants, bands of limestone, charged with species of Productus, Spirifer, Bellerophon, Nautilus, and other marine shells and many corals, alternate several times with grits, sand, and shale charged with coal*, as well as numerous terrestrial plants, including tree ferns, Sigillariae, Equiseti, Calamitesf, &c. &c. In geology, less indeed, than in other sciences, can we ever hope to account for certain results by one modus operandi only. For, nature appears to have worked out phenomena apparently simi- lar, through distinct paths and by devious processes ; and of this no clearer proof can be given, than that coal was formed out of vege- tables which were accumulated by at least the two methods above described. General Ohservations on the Organic Remains, — In treating of the general physical relations of the Carboniferous rocks of the British Isles, and of some changes which they have undergone beyond the region of the annexed map, it has been stated, that in North Northumberland, as in Berwickshire and other parts of the South of * See Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 89. et seq., PI. i. and large woodcut showing the vertical succession, p. 111. f The old or primeval coal is here spoken of in contradistinction to the secondary and tertiary coals, which were formed at periods long afterwards, and do not exhibit those uniform geological characters or that wide and equable spread which characterize the old coal. The enquirer who wishes to study the British fossil plants of this period must consult the Fossil Flora of Lindley and Hutton. The same subject is developed by M. Adolphe Brongniart, who has given his views in an admirable sketch of the successive floras imbedded in the crust of the earth. The more recent publications on the fossil plants of Germany, by Goppert and linger, are productions of high merit. In comparing these works with those on the coal plants of America, we find that the same species inhabited very distant regions, or had a wide range throughout many latitudes. Chap. XL] LOWER CARBONIFEROUS FAUNA. 281 Scotland, the greater part of the coal is either inferior to lime- stones charged with the remains of marine animals, or interstratified with them. Most of the fossils, indeed, of those tracts, such as Nautilus, Productus and Spirifer, with Crinoidea and Crustacea, were unquestionably inhabitants of the sea. Such was also the case as respects the large sauroid fish, Me* galicthys Hibberti, Agass., whose remains occur both in the lower and middle coal measures, and the shark-like fishes, Gyracanthus formosus, and G. tuberculatus ; the Ctenacanthus ; Hybodus, &c. It is in the lower or purely marine limestones of the Carboni- ferous epoch, that the geologist takes his final leave of Trilobites. Abounding in the Silurian era, these crustaceans had, we see, dwindled to a comparatively small number in the Devonian, whilst, in the lower Carboniferous, the three genera, Phillipsia, Griffith- ides and Brachymetopus, mark the last appearance of any indi- viduals of this family in the ascending scale of natural deposits. On the other hand, it is among the superior coal strata where Trilobites became extinct, that the Limulus appears for the first time, a genus of crustaceans which has lived on to the present day — the great King Crab of the Indian seas being the existing type. Fossils, 54. Limulus rotundatus, Prestwich. From the Coalbrook Dale Coal Field. One example of this primeval Limulus is here given. It is a rarer species than the L. trilobitoides of Buckland.* Limulus anthrax, * See the Bridgwater Treatise, t. 46'^, fig. 3. ; — that very remarkable work of my eminent friend the Dean of Westminster. 282 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. Prestwich, is another rare form from Coalbrook Dale.* We may, however, remark, that the Pterygotus, found in the Silurian Rocks and the bottom beds of the Old Red Sandstone, pertains to the same group of crustaceans. (See p. 237.) Here, also, we last meet with any large Orthoceratites. Those scavengers of the ancient seas had now begun to diminish rapidly, and with them most of the genera of Cephalopods, which have a simple form of air-chamber, their office being taken, in the Triassic and later secondary strata, by other groups of Cephalopoda, such as -Ceratites, Ammonites, &c., in which the air-chambers are minutely foliated at their edges. The true characters of the very numerous genera and species of fossils which occur in this group, must, indeed, be studied in other works ; but in support of the opinion, that the corals of the lower division often lived where they are found, a woodcut is here given of a gigantic specimen of Lithostrotion floriforme fa (Sil. Syst.) the Fossils, 55. Coral of the Mountain Limestone. Lithostrotion floriforme, Fleming, in its natural position in the rock." lower parts of which are rooted in the shale /, whilst the superior portion is imbedded in a limestone, e, with a mass of red con- * Trans. Geol. See. Lond. vol. v. pL 41. f. 1—4. \ My friend, Mr. Lonsdale, who, as before stated, described all the corals in the Silurian System, does not admit the generic word Lonsdalia, as applied to this form by Mr. Milne Edwards ; he, Mr. Lonsdale, having first defined and limited the genus Lithostrotion. See Russia and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 602., and Annals of Nat. Hist., November, 1851. Chap. XI.] LOWER CARBONIFEROUS FAUNA. 283 cretions, d d. This coral, when in its native bed, appeared, there- fore, to be precisely in its original position, and conveyed to me the impression that it had remained undisturbed beneath the sea, whilst fine red sand at one time, and mud with calcareous matter at another, were deposited around it. The small figure, in the woodcut, represents the large shell Productus hemisphericus, which in nature is four inches broad, and shows by comparison the very great size of the coral, which has a width of two feet five inches.* The large Producti are, however, of all its fossils, the most characteristic of the lower carboniferous group, the same species being found in this rock through many degrees of latitude, in Europe, Asia, and America, and even in India and Australia. A few of the characteristic fossils of these formations are exhibited in the next woodcut. Fossils, 56. Some Fossils of the Carboniferous Limestone. 1. Brachymetopus Ouralicus, De Vern. 2. Phillipsia pustulata, Schlotli. (P. gemmulifera, Phill.) 3. Spirifer striatus? Mart, sp. 4. Productus giganteus, Sow. 5. Pleurorhynchus aliformis, Sow. 6. Goniatites crenistria, Phillips. * See Silurian System, p. 107. The coral is from Lilleshall, Shro])tihiie. 284 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. Associated with these species, which are found wherever the lime- stone exists, are fishes of the placoid order — chiefly Cestracionts, their hard bony palates and fin defences being the only portions preserved to us ; but these are sufficient to show, that they were both very numerous, and of many genera. Psammodus, Cochliodus, Ctenacanthus, as well as Megalicthys, Gyracanthus, Hybodus, &c., are familiar types, which, with many others, must be studied in the great work of Agassiz, or in the subsequent publications of Egerton and other authors.* But besides these numerous evidences of the presence of the sea, fresh water shells (Unionidae) every now and then occur in thick layers, as we ascend in the series, and are among the most charac- teristic of the upper portions of the formation. An estuariau intermixture is also observable in coal-bearing strata of parts of Shropshire, Staffordshire, and Lancashire. It is Fossils, 57. Insect and Shells of the Coal. 1. Wing of (Cory- dalis ?) 2. Prodnctus scab- riculus, Sowerby. 3. Unio acutus, Sow. (From. Sil. Svst. p. iOo.) well seen in the district of Coalbrook Dale, where remains even of insects allied to the Corydalis of America, are found associated * See Palaeichthyologic Notes, by Sir Ph. de M. Grey Egerton, Bt., M.P., Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. vol. iv. p. 302 ; vol. v. p. 329 ; vol. vi. p. 1. and Nos. 4, 5. in vol. ix. The collections of ichthyolites made by Sir P. Egerton and his associate the Earl of Enniskillen, are, it is believed, unrivalled. Chap. XI.] UPPER CARBONIFEROUS FAUNA. 285 with marine and fluviatile shells and land plants. The figures in cut 57. represent this case of intermixture as formerly pointed out by myself. A fuller account, however, of it is given by Mr. Prest- wich, in his elaborate memoir on the strata and fossils of that district.* Fossils, 58. Fekn from Coal of Coalbrook Dale. Pecopteris lonchitica, Brongn. (From Sil. Syst. p. 105.) Other probable examples of such associations, indicating the con- tiguity of land on which plants grew, and from which they were transported to marine or brackish water estuaries, are seen near Fossils, 59. Uppermost Limestone of the Coal. 1. Cypris inflata, natural size, and magnified 12 times. 2. Cvclas (or Edmondia?)" 3. Mo- diola, from Ardwick, Manchester, in a some- what similar band of limestone. (From Sil. Syst. p. 84.) * Trans. Geol. Soc. Lend., vol. v. p. 413. One of the plants, Pecopteris lon- chitica (Brongn.), which is given in the upper woodcut, is associated in these tracts with forty or fifty species of terrestrial plants belonging to Calamitaceae, Polypodiaceae, and Lycopodiace£e. Of these, the Stigmaria ficoides (considered to be the root of Sigillaria), Neuropteris cordata, Odontopteris obtusa, and the Pecopteris here figured, are perhaps the most common. 286 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. Shrewsbury, Manchester, and other localities, among some of the younger coal strata. In the environs of Shrewsbury, small shells of the genus Cyclas (?) with the minute crustacean Cypris (or possibly the marine genus Cythere) are commingled in the same limestone with a minute shell, originally termed Microconchus carbonarius, but now referred by naturalists to the marine or estuary genus Spirorbis.* The preceding and following figures (cuts 59, 60.), formerly pub- lished in the Silurian System, explain more particularly the contents of this peculiar limestone of the coal strata. Fossils, 60. Uppermost Limestone of the Coal. (From Sil. Syst., p. 84.) Microconchus (now called Spirorbis) carbonarius, Sil. Syst. The real size is given in the minutest of these figures, whilst the upper figures are somewhat magnified, and the lower very greatly so. In all such cases, and still more where the coal is intercalated among purely marine animal remains, we must believe, that the * Some of the coal sandstones in the environs of Manchester exhibit on their surfaces the clearest indications of havinj^ been shore deposits ; certain tracts being marked on them, of animals which must have crawled at ebb tides. INIr. Binney states also, that the shells of the above Spirorbis occur throughout the whole of the thick series of the Lancashire coal-field, and thus indicate long-continued marine conditions. See " On some Trails and Holes in the Carboniferous Strata, with Remarks on Microconchus Carbonarius," by INIr. E. W. Binney. Trans. Lit. and Phil. Soc. Manchester, vol. x., 1851-2. Chap. XI.] CARBONIFEROUS REPTILES. 287 vegetables from which it was formed were carried down into seas or estuaries fed by freshwater affluents. Whilst researches in all parts of the world have only produced one small reptile from the Upper Devonian rocks, it was stated that the same period afforded comparatively few land plants. The appearance, therefore, of land plants and air-breathing reptiles was, as far as our evidences go, nearly simultaneous. With the proofs in our possession of the large quantities of terrestrial veo;etables which occur in the Carboniferous era now under consideration, accompanied as they are in numerous cases by river and lake shells, and, in other instances, by insects, and land crabs, it might be expected that reptiles would also be found in them. And such has proved to be the case. The first discovery of this nature was made in the coal-field of Saarbriick in Ehenish Bavaria, wherein two species of Archegosaurus, Goldfuss, have been found, — a reptile which Hermann Yon Meyer supposes to be a connecting link between Batrachians and Lizards. Since then, the footsteps of a large reptile allied to the Cheiro- therium, have been discovered in the Carboniferous strata of Pennsyl- vania. Recently, Professor M'Coy detected in the Museum of Lord Enniskillen, the remains of an allied reptile from British coal- fields, which Owen has described under the name of Parabatrachus Colei. Sir C. Lyell has also communicated the still mor^ interest- ing account of a discovery made by Mr. Dawson and himself, in the coal-field of South Joggins, in Nova Scotia *, of a reptile called Dendrerpeton Acadianum, which Owen and Wyman consider to be- long to the perennibranchiate Batrachians. With this reptile were associated many land plants, and the shell of a moUusk, which is supposed to have been air-breathing: if this be so, it is the first true land-shell which has been found in strata of such high antiquity. f * Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. ix. p. 55. I Ibid vol. ix. p. 58. 288 SILURIA. [Chap. XI. These discoveries afford us proofs of associations of organic remains which might, indeed, have been anticipated from what we know re- specting other palajozoic deposits. In the earliest wide and general diffusion of a copious and peculiar vegetation, we further recognize the prevalence of that equable tem- perature and of similar conditions over various latitudes, which must, in my opinion, have also existed in the preceding periods. In the Carboniferous deposits, however, we are for the first time surrounded by proofs of the existence of vast plant-bearing lands. Of these ancient plants, the great mass of the Silurian sediments afford, I repeat, no traces in any part of the world, though they occur in just the same latitudes as the Carboniferous strata, and are very generally in juxta-position, often with, but sometimes without the interposition of the Devonian rocks. The first feeble traces of such vegetation are observable at the close of the Silurian era ; and if the Devonian rocks exhibit here and there proofs of an increase of land plants, it is only in the Carboniferous period that we are presented with the complete materials for the elaboration of vast coal-fields. P. S. — Referring to the preceding pages, let me state, that the reader will find an admirable and succinct sketch of the methods by which coal was accumulated and formed, in a Report by Professor H. D. Rogers of the United States, as published in the Transactions of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1842, p. 433. Having explained the views of various European geo- logists, among whom he justly assigns praise to Mr. Mammatt, for having been one of the first persons who sustained by physical evidences the previous theory of De Luc, M'Culloch, and others, of the formation of coal out of terrestrial vegeta- tion in situ, Professor Rogers, having under consideration the enormous area occupied by the carboniferous strata of North America, endeavours to reconcile conflicting hypotheses. He has, indeed, so ingeniously applied the opinions of his brother, W. Rogers, and himself, respecting the influence of great proxysmal earth- quakes which afi*ected the earth's crust in ancient periods, as to suggest how the rapid alternations of terrestrial and oceanic remains, to which attention has been called in this work (p. 277, et seq.), can be best accounted for. This subject will be in part reconsidered in subsequent chapters. 289 CHAPTER XIL PEKMIAN ROCKS. CHANGES or THE SURFACE BEFORE THE PERMIAN DEPOSITS WERE ACCUMULATED. — ORIGIN OF THE TERM PERMIAN AS APPLIED TO THE HIGHEST GROUP OF PRIMEVAL DEPOSITS. THE PERMIAN ROCK.S OF RUSSIA, GERMANY, AND ENGLAND. THE ORGANIC REMAINS OF THE GROUP. In the two previous chapters, slight allusions only have been made to eruptions of igneous or volcanic materials, which were ejected and spread out on the sea bottom, together with the ordinary sedimentary deposits ; for such volcanic ejections, during the Devonian and car- boniferous eras, were not by any means so abundant in the British Isles as when the Silurian rocks, and especially their lower divi- sions, were accumulated. (See ante, pp. 54. 57. &c.) The great upper coal-fields which we have been considering, were probably formed under conditions which geologists would consider comparatively quiescent. This is supposed to have been particularly the case with all that portion of them, in which, as we have seen, coal beds must, in many cases, have been formed by repeated downward movements of low lands beneath the waters, followed by many elevations of the same into the atmosphere. The close, however, of that period was specially marked by convulsions and ruptures of the crust of the earth, which, from the physical evi- dences placed before us, must have extended over distant regions of Europe, as well as of America. Whatever may have been the u 290 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. previous changes, it was then that the coal strata and their ante- cedent formations were very generally broken up, and thrown, by grand upheavals, into separate basins, which were fractured by numberless powerful dislocations. The order of ancient sedimentary succession was thus very widely, though not universally, interrupted ; and all the strata previously spoken of were so disturbed, as to produce a prevalent break or discordance between the carboniferous and inferior formations and those which succeeded to them. That this disturbance was not, however, general, is demonstrated by the fact, that both in Russia on the east, and England on the west, there are exceptional tracts in which the carboniferous and overlying Permian deposits are apparently in conformable relations to each other. Still, the general effect of the great disseverment alluded to, in de- termining the outline of the earth, is obvious ; for whilst the SUurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous rocks were at that period so heaved up as to constitute portions of mountain chains, the strata which we are now considering, though allied to the carboniferous by their im- bedded plants and animal remains, have been usually spread out in western Europe in less highly inclined positions; constituting, therefore, for the most part, countries with a lower level. Whilst their fossils also are, on the whole, different from those of all pre- existing palaeozoic rocks, they are yet far more connected with the fauna and flora of the carboniferous deposits, than with the organic remains of any secondary or mezozoic rock subsequently formed. The strata, which were accumulated after the great deposits of coal, are those which in England have been severally termed Lower New Red Sandstone, Magnesian Limestone, and marl slate. Similar rocks have been long known in Germany under the names of Rothe- todte-liegende, Kupfer-Schiefer, Zechstein; and with these I have Chap. XIL] THE PERMIAN ROCKS. 291 united an inferior portion of what had been commonly classed with the Bunter Sandstein. Having become satisfied that these strata, so different in mineral character, constituted one natural group only, which must be distinguished from, yet connected with, the carboni- ferous series beneath, and which, from its organic contents, must be entirely separated from all formations above, I proposed in 1841*, to my associates, de Verneuil and von Keyserling, that the group should receive the name of Permian, as taken from an enormous region which composed the ancient kingdom of Permia. To that vast country, my illustrious friend the Baron von Humboldt parti- cularly called my attention when about to revisit Russia with my friend de Verneuil ; and there we found, that all the characteristic features of an independent assemblage were elaborated on a very grand scale. After two explorations of Russia with my companions, I re-exa- mined (1844) the portions of Germany, where the Zechstein and its associated strata, underlying as well as overlying, are best displayed ; and, by placing them in parallel with the Russian and English rocks, my views were confirmed, and thus all the deposits above mentioned were included under the term " Permian." The value of this euphonous name, for a series of strata which constitute one natural mass, soon became so obvious, that, although proposed only in 1841, it has already been adopted by geologists of different nations, including my own. In Germany, where the Rothe-todte-liegende and the Zechstein had long held their head quarters, and where their characters had been described by numerous geologists, from the days of Werner and * The term was first proposed in a letter addressed by myself at Moscow to the venerable and accomplished Russian palaeontologist Dr. Fischer, October, 1841. See Bronn and Leonhardt, Journ. an. 1841, and Phil. Mag., vol. xix. p. 417. 292 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. Schlotheim, to those of the great geologist Leopold von Buch, whose recent loss we deplore, these rocks have been recognized in the works of Naumann of Leipsic, and of Geinitz, and Gutbier of Dresden, as the "Permische System."* In France, M. Alcide D'Orblgny, in his systematic work on Palaeontology, and other authors, have given currency to a name which would indeed have had little or no value without the close palasontological t comparisons of my colleagues, de Verneuil and von Keyserling, as worked out with me in the distant eastern regions of Eussia in Europe. In the north of England, where its most varied and richest fos- siliferous members were first described by Sedgwick J, its organic remains have recently been illustrated by King, under the term Permian ; and the word is now used by Sir Henry de la Beche and the Government surveyors in the construction of the geological map of England. As many persons may not have access to my large work on the geology of the Russian empire, in which a full description is given of the leading characters of the group, and, as I wish to impress the reader with the reasons for the adoption of the name Permian, a few passages from the writings of my colleagues and myself are here re- produced. By the first of these extracts it will be perceived that, in describing the whole structure of Russia, we began, as on the present * See Geinitz and Gutbier, "Permische System in Sacbsen," 1848. Dresden and Leipsic. •f See Cours Elementaire de Pal. et Geol. Strat., par Alcide D'Orbigny, vol. ii. p. 370. I am happy to learn that the French Government have rewarded the labours of M D'Orbigny by naming him Professor of Palseontology in the Jardin des Plantes. My friend Professor Philips had the merit of having first suggested that, on account of its fossils, the "magnesian limestone" of England should be classed with the palaeozoic rocks. Treatise on Geology, p. 189. \ Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. ii. new series, p. 37. et seq. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN ROCKS OF RUSSIA. 293 occasion, with the lowest rocks in which any traces of life could be detected. We then proceeded : " Having worked our way upwards through Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous rocks, we have now to describe the next succeeding natural group. Spread out over a larger surface than any other in Russia, the rocks in question, with certain overlying red deposits, which we cannot sepa- rate from them, occupy the greater part of the Governments of Perm, Oren^ burg, Kazan, Nijni Novogorod, Yaroslavl, Kostroma, Viatka, and Vologda, a region more than twice the size of the whole kingdom of France ! " * After showing to what an extent opinions varied respecting the age of these Russian deposits, most authors referring them to the New Ked Sandstone or Trias, others to the carboniferous era, we next observed f : " Such was the state of the question when we entered upon the survey of Russia. To arrive, therefore, at a sound conclusion respecting the age of these rocks, it became essential to traverse, as far as possible, the countries over which they extended, and compare the phsenomena which had led to such contradictory opinions. The result has been, that though these deposits are of very varied mineral aspect, and consist of grits, sand- stones, marls, conglomerates, and limestone, sometimes inclosing great masses of gypsum and rock salt, and are also much impregnated with copper, and occasionally with sulphur, yet the whole group is characterized by one type only of animal and vegetable life.^^ " Convincing ourselves, in the field, that these strata were connected by their organic remains with the carboniferous rocks on the one hand, and were independent of the Trias on the other, we ventured to designate them by a geographical term, derived from the ancient kingdom of Perm, within and around whose precincts the necessary evidences had been obtained." " With the highest respect for the labours of German geologists upon the Zechstein, and for the researches of those authors who have placed the Magnesian Limestone of England on the same parallel, we are con- ♦ Russia in Europe, vol. i. p. 137. f Russia in Europe, p. 138. u 3 294 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. vinced, that neither in Germany nor in Great Britain do the same accumulative proofs exist, to establish the independence of a geological system. If mineral characters be appealed to, no German writer will contend, that the thin course of * Kupfer schiefer ' is of like import- ance with the numerous strata which in Russia constitute many bands of various structure ; rendering, in fact, the Zechstein itself a mere sub- ordinate member of a vast cupriferous series. Subordinate, however, as it is in some tracts of Russia, the Zechstein is so magnificently displayed, in others, in masses of both limestone and gypsum, that it more than rivals the finest sections of that deposit, whether to the south of the Hartz, or in Thuringia. We object, however, to a lithological name, hitherto reserved for one portion only of a complicated series ; and as the Germans have never proposed a single term for the whole group, which is based upon the Rothe-todte-liegende, and surmounted by the Trias, we have done so, simply because we first found in Russia the requisite union of proofs." Occupying the enormous area before mentioned, the Permian deposits of Russia are flanked and underlaid on the west, east, and north, by upper members of the carboniferous rocks, but with little or no coal. These Permian strata of Russia seldom exhibit a mineral succession similar to that of rocks of the same age in Western Europe; and in different tracts of the vast region ex- plored, they exhibit, as explained in the preceding quotation, many variations in their contents and relations. In some places, as on the river Kama, near the Volga, cupriferous, red grits with plants underlie the chief limestone, to which succeed marls; but along the eastern limits of the system, as flanked by the Ural Mountains, gypseous limestones form the base, followed by the red copper grits, sands, marls, and pebble beds, which extend on all sides around the city of Perm. On the whole, indeed, whether we appealed to the sections on the banks of the great Dwina, above Archangel, or to the western flank of the Ural Mountains, or to the banks of the Lower Volga, near Kazan, localities removed from each other by Chap. XII.] PERMIAN ROCKS OF RUSSIA. 295 vast distances, we found that limestones, often interstratified with much gypsum, prevailed towards the base of the Russian deposits. In some parts of the region salt springs occur. These may, doubtless, rise from bodies of rock salt in older palseozoic rocks, since the mineral is known to occur in the Devonian Old Red Sandstone or Devonian of Western Russia; but in the steppes south of Orenburg, it is certainly subordinate to true, red Permian deposits.* These salt beds range up to the foot of the older palaeozoic and crystalline rocks of the South Ural Mountains to the east of Orenburg, the strata of Permian age being alone visible in the low wooded slopes at the foot of the rocky chain of older rocks represented in this vignette. The Gurmaya Hills of the South Ural Mountains. As seen from the Steppes of Orenburg. (From " Russia in Europe," vol. i. p. 450.) * Russia in Europe, &c., vol. i. p. 184. u 4 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. 21 Along certain portions of the west flank of the same chain the Permian strata occur in almost I apparent conformity to the carboniferous rocks. I There they have manifestly undergone a move- ^ ment impressed on them by great forces, di- \ rected from north to south, or parallel to the \ Ural mountains ; all the strata, whether carbo- \ niferous or Permian, having been raised up and \ thrown off sharply to the west, as represented . ^ I in the woodcut on the side of the page. At the imperial baths of Sergiefsk, and on the banks of the river Sok, a tributary of the Lower Volga, magnesian limestone and marl are surmounted by gypsum, copper ore, native sulphur, with sulphureous and asphaltic springs U in the middle masses, whilst other marlstones § ^ and white limestones form the summit. A con- ^ I siderable volume of gaseous, sulphureous water, ^ J which forms a large pool, issues from these I rocks. (See diagram, Russia in Europe, &c., 1 p. 158.) ^ Near Kazan, about 150 miles to the north of Sergiefsk, huge masses of gypsum («), rising high above the level of the river Volga, are surmounted by limestone cliffs with Zechstein fossils (6), and the latter by red, green, and white marls (c), as here represented. "So 1 § Permian deposits near Kazan. (From " Russia in Europe," p. 162.) Thick deposits of gypsum, h. Limestone with fossils, c. Red and green shelly marls. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN ROCKS OF RUSSIA. 297 On the other hand, in the central tracts between the Ural Mountains and the Volga, as on the Dioma, and Kidash, tributaries of the great river Kama, the limestone, which in some tracts assumes a definite horizon, and is underlaid by coarse grits, is repeated at various levels in a succession of beds, interlaminated with sandstones, and yellow, white, and greenish marls, occasionally containing plants, and small seams of impure coal, — the whole being surmounted by red grits and conglomerates, with copper ore. Now, the calcareous and gypseous deposits which interlace this series are throughout characterized by an analogous group of fossils^ and even by some of the same species, as the Zechstein of Germany and the magnesian limestone of England ; whilst the beds of copper grit, with most of the red conglomerates^ which in Kussia are upper- most, contain bones of reptiles ( Thecodont-saurians), belonging to a genus which in Germany occurs in the copper slate beneath the limestone. In the exploration of Russia, therefore, geologists were taught, by this diversified Permian group, not to dwell on the local mineral dis- tinctions of Central or Western Europe, but to look to the wide spread of certain fossil remains, which, in vastly distant countries, occupy the same general horizon, between the carboniferous rocks be- neath, and all those overlying strata which can be called secondary. The survey further proved, by the extension of some of these fossils upwards into red and green marls and sands far above the chief bands of limestone, that the Zechstein of Germany cannot be pro- perly considered the summit of this natural group. Revisiting the districts of central Germany *, which I had often traversed, and which had been rendered classical by the writings of many native geologists, I ascertained that the Flora of the Rothe- todte-liegende, as collected by Colonel Gutbier and Professor Geinitz, has essentially the same supra-carboniferous type as the Permian Flora of Russia, and that certain fishes of the todte-liegcnde of * In the year 1844, and after my journeys in Russia. 298 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. Silesia are closely analogous to, if not identical with, Russian forms. Further, seeing that the whole of the vast red deposit (which accord- ing to M. Credner, of Gotha, swells out in Thuringia to a max- imum thickness of about 2500 feet) was conformably succeeded by the Zechstein, and was transgressive to the coal beneath it, I natu- rally placed it (this lower red sandstone and conglomerate) as the base of the Permian group in Germany; the more so as by this means the successive strata of that country and England were brought into parallel positions. Next, it was evident, that all the copper slates, marls, and limestones both plain and dolomitic, whether in Russia, Germany, or England, were occupied by a similar fauna. Lastly, I became convinced that the analogy, with Russia on the one hand, and with England on the other, might be completed by grouping with the Zechstein a certain lower portion only of the vast series of red sandstones which overlies that formation in Germany. Any one who looks at the natural succession of those overlying rocks in Hessia, Thuringia, and Saxony will see, that the Bunter Sandstein is divided into two parts, as faithfully, indeed, laid down on maps by several good native geologists. It is the lowest of these only that I have grouped with the Zechstein, of which it frequently forms the natural and conformable cover. As yet scarcely any organic remains have, I admit, been detected in this Lower Bunter Sandstein of the Germans. Still, in several places, the deposit is characterized by the presence of the plant published by M. Adolphe Brongniart as Calamites arenarius, which has quite a palaeozoic aspect, and differs from all known plants of the mezozoic or secondary series.* * la a recent excursion to central Germany, when accompanied by Professor J. Morris, I had an opportunity of confirming the Permian classification, by appeals to nature and to the collec- tions of diff'erent individuals, as well as by reference to maps. In Saxony we examined the grand sections of the Rothe-todte-liegende under the guidance of Professor Geinitz, and ascertained from him how symmetrically that vast, old, coarse formation of conglomerate, sandstone and interpolated porphyries, is there succeeded by the Zechstein, the fossils of which that author has so ably described. (See Permische System in Sachsen.) He further pointed out to us a thin-bedded limestone in the Plauen-Grund W. of Dresden, and considered by him to be subor- Ohaf. XII.] PEKMIAN ROCKS OF RUSSIA. 299 If therefore this view be sustained, it may be said that the Per- mian of Germany is a lower or palaeozoic Triasy the central mass of which is the Zechstein limestone, and base the E-othe-todte- liegende; whilst the Upper or Secondary Trias is marked by its middle limestone, the Muschelkalk, with its underlying red Bunter Sandstein, and its overlying red Keuper marls. But whether this lower " Bunter " be abstracted from the Trias or not, let me again call attention to the fact, that whilst the Permian and Trias are conformable to each other, and exhibit nowhere any of those signs of disseverment which so often mark the close of the coal deposits, their respective fauna and flora are entirely dissimilar ; the one exhibiting the last traces of primeval life, the other being charged with the exuviae of plants and animals entirely distinct from those which preceded them. dinate to the copious lower red sandstones of that tract, which are penetrated to such great depths by shafts that reach productive coal seams. In the south-east parts of Thuringia (Saalfeld), where the higher members of these strata appear' we saw how the Weiss-liegende or upper member of the Lower Red Sandstone, is succeeded by the Kupfer Schiefer and the Zechstein with its subordinate schists and overlying dolomites and gypsum, as described by M. Richter (Einladungs-Programm der Realschule Saalfeld, 1853) ; and again how all these dip conformably under the noble escarpments of Bunter Sandstein which range from Rudolstadt eastwards. At Berlin, through the kindness of M. Beyrich, we inspected many fishes and plants from the Rothe-todte-liegende of Silesia (Friedland, Ruppersdorf, &c.), rocks, which after a former exa- mination, I classed as Permian ; and I was more than ever impressed with the belief, that the ichthyolites which there occur in bituminous schists or micaceous red flagstones (Palaeoniscus, Holacanthodes, 'and Xenacanthus), pertain to the same system of life as the ichthyolites of the Kupfer Schiefer. Again, in the numerous fossil plants of this red sandstone which were laid before us. Professor Morris, who assisted me materially in describing the Permian plants of Russia, was of opinion, that like them, this Silesian flora was to be distinguished from the ordinary carboniferous flora; for among these plants we could perceive no Stigmaria, Lepidodendron, nor any form abundant in the old coal ; but on the contrary, species of Neu- ropteris and Odontopteris, and also those coniferse (Araucarites or Voltzia) which first begin to appear in the Permian era. (See Russia and Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 218., and Plates, vol. ii.) At Gotha we had the advantage of examining the collections of that good geologist and miner, M. Credner, who communicated to me the new part of his geological map of Thuringia, ** Geogn. Karte des Thiiringer-Waldes." The double division of the Bunter Sandstein to which I formerly adverted, as made by M. Althaus, of Rothenburg, and others, has also been clearly laid down in an useful and instructive map by M. Ludwig, ' Petrog. Karte, der gegend zwischen Frankfurt, Giessen, Fulda, und Hammelburg ; Darmstadt, 1853.' 300 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. The general succession, which for the most part applies to Western Europe, Is expressed in this diagram, though, as before said, there are tracts both in Eussia on the east, and in England on -the west, where these Permian rocks repose with apparent conformity on the subjacent coal strata. Permian Rocks of Britain. — Let us now see of what the British Permian rocks (No. 9. of map) consist. In one district of the original Silurian region, or that which lies to the south-west of the Staffordshire coal-field (near the Severn), this group seemed to me occasionally to exhibit, in its lowest part, a sort of transition upwards from the coal measures. Calcareous shale with thin courses of coal is there followed by sandstone with trappean tuff, and quartz pebbles, with fragments of plants, and concretions of iron stone, all of which ought probably to be grouped with the car- boniferous rocks. But the overlying members, — red shale, argilla- ceous marl, and incoherent yellowish sandstone with calcareous laminae, some very thin layers of poor coal, may be viewed as the base of the Permian. These strata are succeeded, in apparent conformity, by dark red sandstone and shale, here and there charo-ed with concretions of dark mottled limestone. These sandstones are surmounted by conglomerates, which in parts are so calcareous as to be burnt for lime, and in others, as at Alberbury near Shrewsbury, become almost compact, yellow, magnesian limestones. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN ROCKS OF BRITAIN. 301 In an adjacent part of Staffordshire and Worcestershire, on the contrary, the older rocks of the coal-field have been heaved up to the surface from beneath a former cover of the red ground or Permian rocks; and hence the formations, as in many places around the Dudley coal-field, are separated by a powerful fault, thus : Relations of Permian Rocks to the Coal near Hales Owen. Kent Hills. Coal near Hales Owen. b a c. Trappean conglomerate, h. Red sandstone with calcareous concretions, a. Coal. In the tract near Hales Owen calcareous matter so abounds in the red Permian rocks, that it constitutes zones of earthy, concretionary limestone {b of this diagram), which are perfectly undistinguishable, as formerly pointed out, from some of the cornstones of the Old Red Sandstone. Thus, the coal of this part of England was shown to lie between two similar red deposits, Sil. Syst., p. 55. In following this succession upwards, the trappean breccia and conglomerate of the great Lickey Hills above Hagley Park is met with, but the order is there no further very distinctly traceable. Fragments of a few other rocks, besides the prevalent trap which I described, having been found in these breccias since my examina- tion, the government geologists, Kamsay and Jukes, view them as stratified aqueous deposits, forming an integral part of the Permian, and as the equivalents of the ordinary conglomerates of the group.* In one portion only of the annexed map do the Permian conglo- merates and sandstones contain any traces of fossils except plants ; and this is to the north of Bristol, where, in the form of a magnesian or dolomitic conglomerate, they have afforded remains of sauroid reptiles, which were first described by Messrs. Riley and Stuchbury * Professor Ramsay and the Government Surveyors are now employed in de- ciphering the real limits and contents of the Permian rocks of central England. 302 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. under the name Thecodonto-saurus, and to which the Khopalodon, Fischer, is considered to be nearly allied by Professor Owen.* The same conglomerate is seen in patches, accumulated on the edges of the carboniferous limestone and old red sandstone, around parts of the southern rim of the South Welsh coal basin. f This rock has usually been placed on the same parallel as the magnesian limestone of the north of England ; and the analogy of the succession in Shropshire, where the lower red sandstone is inter- polated between the coal-fields beneath and the magnesian conglo- merate above, favours the view. There, the upper coal is surmounted by a considerable thickness of red sandstone and shale (the Lower New Eed), which, in their turn, are covered by a yellow magnesian limestone — in some parts highly brecciated, in others a conglomerate, and this rock is again overlaid by red sandstone, marl, &c. The general order in the portions of Shropshire, near Cardeston and Alber- bury is as here given. Position of the Permian Rocks in Shropshire. OL 6 o d. Red sandstone and marl. 1 c. Magnesian conglomerate and yellow limestone . > Permian Rocks. b. Dark red sandstone (Lower Red). J a. Coal measures — upper division with thin courses of limestone. In their range to the north of England, these rocks become more diversified in mineral character and much richer in fossil contents, and therefore more completely represent the Permian of the continent. Thus, at Manchester, the red shale, subordinate to sandstones of this age, is already charged with casts of fossil shells of the genera Schizodus, Avicula, Turbo, Eissoa, &c.t * Russia in Europe, &c., vol. i. p. 637. •j- This dolomitic conglomerate is also finely exhibited near Thornbury, on the east, and Bridgend on the west, of the Severn. (See map.) X See the Fossils of these Manchester rocks, as published by Captain Brown and Mr. Binney, Manchester Geol. Trans., vol. i. p. 63. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN ROCKS IN ENGLAND. 303 Extending northwards, or from Nottinghamshire into Yorkshire^ red marls alternate with sandstones, and, as shown by Sedgwick, overlie the magnesian limestone ; thus offering an ascending series similar to that of the Russian and German examples before cited.* The inferior member of the group, or the " Rothe-todte-liegende " of Germany, where it occurs in Yorkshire, is known as the " Pon- tefract rock" of Smith. f It consists of yellowish sandstones and conglomerates, containing various' plants. Reddish sandstones, re- occur, however, near Ripon, and are not unlike some of the same age in Shropshire and Staffordshire: they there occupy the same position, being covered by the magnesian limestone or Zechstein of the Bedale district, whence they expand over a large tract of central Yorkshire. The succession of strata in the north of England, as originally described by Professor Sedgwick, in his excellent " Memoir on the Magnesian Limestone," and there paralleled by him with the Zechstein of Germany and its associated beds, consists, in the lower part, of flaglike marls, the equivalents of the " Kupfer Schiefer," and in the upper of the yellow magnesian limestone (" Zechstein") of Yorkshire, Nottingham, and Durham. The whole of the series, together with the above-mentioned overlying red beds, are included in the term " Permian." Recently Professor King, who had long studied the fossils of the calcareous members of the group, has placed the detailed component parts still more closely in comparison with the corresponding beds of Germany. Thus, whilst, with Sedgwick, he considers that the lower sandstones of Yorkshire and Durham, whether red, white, or yellow, which lie between the coal and the magnesian limestone, are the true equivalents of the German Rothe-liegende, and that the marl slate, with its fishes, stands in the place of the copper slate * See Sedgwick on the Magnesian Limestone, Geol. Trans. 2nd ser., vol. iii p. 37. f So named by William Smith, the * father ' of English geology, whose lessons in the field along the Yorkshire coast (1826) were of great service to me. 304 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. of Germany — he also shows, that the fossiliferous beds of compact limestone represent the lower, — and the brecciated, concretionary limestones of Durham the upper Zechstein of the Germans, with its overlying beds of dolomite, rauchwacke and " stinkstein." In England, there is, perhaps, no other yellow limestone so charged with magnesia as to form a true dolomite; and hence in the early days of geology, it was natural to define this rock as the Magnesian Lime- stone*, and to associate with it certain subordinate strata. But now that yellow magnesian limestones are known to occur, on a stupen- dous scale (in the Lower Silurian rocks of North America j, and are also of some magnitude in the Devonian and Carboniferous series of Russia) whilst the Jurassic masses of the Alps are to a great extent crystalline dolomites, it becomes necessary to abandon the term " magnesian," and to place the English formation under a name which establishes its synonymy, through fossil contents and position, with rocks of other countries. % The Permian deposits, as developed in Russia, and as applied to Germany and England, do not sto, as before said, in the as- cending order, with the Zechstein. They also include another over- lying red sandstone, which, in many parts of Germany constitutes the conformable roof of the Zechstein, and contains the plant Calamites arenarius, Brongn., which has a quasi carboniferous aspect. In general language, therefore, the Zechstein of Germany, or mag- nesian limestone of England, may be viewed as the calcareous * I am, however, disposed to think that some of the yellow beds of the carboni- ferous limestone of the Clee Hills are exceptions, (See Sil. Syst. p. 119.) ■j- See Dale Owen's Geology of Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota, with Map, on which vast magnesian limestones are laid down as the Lower Silurian of that author. 1853. J True dolomite, whether crystalline or earthy, is known by its containing 45 per cent, of magnesia. Another proof of the inapplicability of mineral terms to designate the age of strata, is the use of the term " oolitic " for rocks, which in England have a structure that is scarcely ever found in their continental equi- valents. It is therefore merely an insular lithological name which misleads. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN FLORA. 305 centre of an arenaceous group, or, as before said, a lower " Trias the upper red marl and sand of Yorkshire, described by Sedgwick, being as much a parcel of it as those red sandstones and conglomerates, or "rothe-todte-liegende," which in Western Europe lie beneath it. There are, indeed, parts of Europe, as in the Ardennes of Belgium, where these rocks, so diversified elsewhere, are represented by a mere band of pebbly, silicious conglomerate, which being sterile of fossils was named Peneen " by M. D'Omalius D'Halloy.* In France, i, e, in the Vosges and at Lodeve in Dauphine, this group has not the distinctive characters, lithologically or zoologically, which it exhibits in Kussia, Germany and Britain, being simply a red sandstone. But even there it is distinguished, as in other regions, by a peculiar flora, containing certain ferns and conifers which M. Adolphe Brongniart classes with Permian plants. Permian Fossil Remains. — The fauna and flora of the Permian rocks are, as before stated, essentially palaeozoic; for whilst in great measure specifically distinct from that of the carboniferous system, the amount of their agreement is surprising when we reflect upon the phenomena, adverted to in opening this chapter, of a great physical revolution which pretty generally affected the known surface of the earth at the close of the preceding or carboniferous era. That disrup- tion, therefore, however violent and extensive, was not universal, but was, we may suppose, so productive of new conditions as to occasion the destruction of many genera and species of plants and animals. The Permian flora has not been yet so developed in the British Isles as to show in what degree it differs from that of the carboni- ferous group, to which, in fact, it every where bears a resem- blance. We know, indeed, that some of the species found in the yellowish sandstones of Pontefract, and in the lower red sandstones which may be classed as Permian, are identical with plants of the * Elemens de Geologie, p. 276. " Peneen," means sterile. X 306 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. adjacent coal-fields ; and at Ashby de la Zouch, Sternhergia has lately been detected, together with silicified wood, by the Rev. W. H. Coleman. Prof. Sedgwick* long ago pointed out the traces of Calamites in the lower New Red Sandstone ; and we here reproduce figures of two fossil plants, found in the marl slate of Durham, from Professor King's elaborate work.f Fossils, 55. Permian Plants, &c. 1. 3. Fenestella retiformis.Schlo- theim ; " Magnesian lime- stone " of Humbleton Hill. The figures, except f. 2, are much reduced. In certain foreign tracts, however, which have been closely ex- amined, the lower Permian strata contain many plants and some thin beds of coal. The sandstone of Lodeve, before adverted to, affords, according to M. Ad. Brongniart, ferns of the genera Sphe- nopteris, Pecopteris, Neuropteris, Alethopteris, Callipteris, with An- nularia floribunda (Sternberg), and several conifers of the genus Walchia4 The sandstone and conglomerates also beneath the magnesian limestone near Zwickau in Saxony, have rewarded the researches of Colonel Gutbier § with about sixty species of plants. One-third only of these are known in the carboniferous epoch ; the other two-thirds are forms which specifically are unknown in any ♦ Proc. Geol. Soc, vol. i. p. 344. f Monogr. Perm. Foss. 1848, pi. 1., &c. + See Russia in Europe, &c., vol. i. p. 219. § Geinitz und Gutbier, Gaea von Sachsen, 1843. " Permische System in Sachsen," 1850. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN FAUNA. 307 other deposit. Among the plants most characteristic of the group, may be mentioned the Sphenopteris erosa, S. lobata, and the great, reed-like Calamites gigas. The large silicified stems of tree ferns called Psaronius, so much admired by collectors for the exquisite conservation of the fibre of the plant, and for the beautiful polish they take, occur abundantly in the lower red (Permian) beds of Saxony.* Whilst in Russia these species of plants are found in beds above all the limestone courses, they are confined to the lower strata of Saxony, and are there commingled with some species known in the upper coal deposits. On the whole, it was the opinion of M. Adolphe Brongniart, to whom the plants brought from Russia were referred f, that they exhibit a continuation of vegetable life of the same general characters as those which prevailed in the carboniferous era. But whilst the genera are the same as those of the coal period, the species, with two or three exceptions, are different. On the other hand, no one of the Russian or Permian genera, Neuropteris, Odontopteris, Lepido- dendron, Sphenopteris, Noeggerathia, &c., occur in the overlying Trias, in ascending into which the geologist has before him an en- tirely different flora. The chief Permian animal remains bear also a strong resemblance to their congeners of the carboniferous era. When the work on Russia was written, my companions and myself were not aw^are of more than 166 fossil Permian species, but, by the publication of the works of Geinitz in Saxony | and King in England, this number has been increased to 230; a small proportion, therefore, when compared with that of the preceding or carboniferous epoch, in which about 1050 species of animals are already described. * The finest collection of these "Psaronites" extant, with which I am acquainted, is that of my valued friend, Mr. Eobert Brown, the eminent botanist, f Russia in Europe, &c., vol. i. p. 218. et seq. X Geinitz, Die Versteinerungen des Deutschen Zechstein gebirges, 1848. X 2 308 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. The corals and Bryozoa, twenty-six in number, have the pa- laeozoic type, the small cup-coral Polycoelia ; apparently showing the quadripartite arrangement of the lamellse characteristic of the cup- corals of the old rocks. The abundant Fenestella retiformis, and Synocladia virgulacea, Foss. 61. f. 3., are also of a type peculiar to the primeval fauna. Crinoids are rare ; but there is in England a species of the genus Cidaris, the earliest known representative of the modern sea-urchins.* The Brachiopods, of which about thirty- eight species are known, offer many Producti, analogous to those of the coal period ; and about five species, including P. hor- ridus, the most common Permian form in Britain and Germany (Foss. 56. f. 2.), and P. Cancrini, are identical with carboniferous forms. Eleven species of Spirifer also occur, one of which, S. undu- latus (f. 1.), is the most characteristic, and S. cristatus is supposed to be common to the carboniferous and Permian rocks. Of the genus Orthis, which prevails so greatly from the Lower Silurian to the carboniferous inclusive, we here find no trace ; nor does it occur in any superior formation. Its place is possibly taken, in the Permian rocks, by the new genus Strophalosia, King (Orthothrix of Geinitz) f, or Aulosteges of Helmersen, which is but rarely found in older strata. Of the few species of Terebratula which are known, two or three are exceedingly abundant, and one, T. elongata of Schlotheim, can scarcely be distinguished from a common carboni- ferous species. The Athyris Roissyi, too, is apparently identical with the Devonian and carboniferous shell. The genus Pentamerus, so characteristic of the Silurian epoch, and so rare in the Devonian strata, but which has also been found * The species of Cidaris often quoted from carboniferous rocks, belong, as has been well shown by M'Coj, to a different family. They are now termed ArchcBo- cidaris. See Annals Nat. Hist. 2 ser. vol. iii. p. 352. t Composed of those species of Producti which have a distinct hinge area and hinge teeth. Chap. XII.] PERMIAN FAUNA. 309 in the carboniferous rocks of England, has not yet been detected in the Permian deposits. In unison, however, with the prevailing evidences of the development of nature, which, in modifying beings at successive periods, often retained some features of the preceding types, the Pentamerus was represented in the Permian division, by the curious terebratuloid shell, named Camarophoria by Prof. King, which offers in its internal arrangement an approach to the structure of the Pentamerus. Two of the most frequent Permian shells, indeed, are C. (Terebratula) Schlotheimi, von Buch, and C. superstes, de Verneuil, both figured in the work on Russia, vol. ii. pi. 8. figs. 4, 5. These singular brachiopods also disappeared at the close of the Permian era, and their places were occupied by genera (Terebratula, Rhynchonella, &c.) which exist even in the present day. The annexed woodcut represents a few of the typical Permian fossils ; the figures being about half the natural width. 1. Spirifer undiilatus, Sow. 2. Productus horridus, id. 3. Schizodus (Axinus) ob- scurus, id. All from the county of Durham. Fossils, 56. Permian Shells. 4. Strophalosia Morrisiana, King. These species, ex- cept, perhaps, the Schizodus, are equally common in Germany and Britain. In the lamellibranchiate shells (the Dimyaria and Monomyaria of most geological works), we note the same diminution of genera and species in reference to deposits of previous eras ; and, whilst not less than 288 species are known in the carboniferous, about fifty- three only have been obtained in the Permian deposits. Modiola is X 3 310 SILURIA. [Chap. XI I. one of the most characteristic genera ; M. Pallasi, and M. septifer, being common forms. Schizodus, King {olim, Axinus), is also a cha- racteristic genus: S. obscurus and S. truncatus are from western Europe ; both of them are however common in England and Russia. S. Rossicus, de Yerneuil, is a Russian species only. The genus Avicula is also abundant; the small spinose A. Kazanensis being common in Russia. The Avicula speluncaria of Schlotheim is one of the most characteristic species of western Europe, whilst A. kerato- phoga and A. antiqua, Miinst., are frequent. Area tumida, Sowerby, and species of Edmondia, Myacites, &c. are British shells of this age. " The Gasteropods appear to have undergone great diminution during the formation of the Permian strata, and to have had great difficulty in accom- modating themselves to new conditions. For, if we pass over the seven minute species of Turbo and Rissoa, occurring in one locality near Man- chester, the number of Gasteropods known throughout England, Germany, and Russia, in rocks of this age, amounts to but fifteen {now twenty-one) species, a number which must appear still more insignificant, when we reflect that as many as 225 species of this class are known in the carboniferous.* These fifteen Permian species are almost all new, three only having been able to live on from the carboniferous to the Permian epoch. The rarity of individual Gasteropods, which are met with in the strata, seems to combine with the paucity of species to make us presume that the causes which were opposed to their free development, produced very extensive effects." " The Cephalopods, which under the forms of Goniatites, Nautilus, and Orthoceras, were so numerous during the carboniferous period, that 160 species (now many more) have been already described from its strata, were almost entirely annihilated previous to the commencement of the Permian era." At least it is remarkable, that, with the exception of a Nautilus, N. * In the work on Russia, the Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian rocks were each designated as " Systems ; " but, as explained in this work, they are now viewed as groups, that constitute the " Upper Palaeozoic System ; " the Silurian being the " Lower Pala30zoic." (See also the last chapter.) Chap. XII.] PERMIAN FAUNA. 311 Frieslebeni, Geinitz, no well characterized cephalopod has been detected in the whole extent of the formation. " Trilobites are entirely wanting. In the study of the palaeozoic succes- sion we see that the disappearance of this race is regularly announced by a gradual diminution of its numbers during the preceding epochs. Appear- ing among the earliest forms of life, and having their maximum of de- velopment in the Silurian period, trilobites decrease very sensibly in the Devonian strata, and in the carboniferous deposits are reduced to some few small species, of which Phillipsia and Griffithides are the last ex- piring forms. And here we are presented with one of those beautiful links in natural history, of which the strata, forming the earth's crust, have afforded so many proofs. For, with the final extinction of a family destined never more to reappear, its place is taken by an allied crustacean, the Limulus, the earliest form of which was created during the formation of the great coal-fields, and was followed, in our Permian system, by the large and remarkable species as yet peculiar to Russia, the Limulus oculatus (Kutorga). Unlike the trilobite, the Limulus has survived all the numerous revolutions which have followed its creation, and some of its species are coexistent with our own race." * On the whole, therefore, if there are only a few species of mollusks which are common to the older rocks and the Permian, the latter still retains its connection with the former through the genera Productus, Spirifer, Strophalosia, its peculiar group of corals, and of Bryozoa (Fenestellae, &c.). It is the constant diffusion of many individuals of such forms, which induced my associates and myself to hold firm in retaining the term Permian, as marking the close of primeval life, and in separating it from the Trias and secondary deposits, with which it has no form in common. The fossil fishes of this era, of which fifty-three species are known, all belong, like their precursors, to the division with heterocercal tails ; a distinction that becomes more and more evanescent in all the succeeding secondary and tertiary formations, and in our era is confined to the shark and sturgeon families ; * Russia in Europe, vol. i. p. 209, &c. X 4 312 SILURIA. [Chap. XII. nearly all other species now living, about 8000 in number, having homocercal tails. Of true heterocercal fishes of the Permian group, two figures only are here given, by which the reader will see that the backbone Fossils, 57. Permian Fish. Platysomus striatus, Agassiz ; from the " Marl Slate," Durham. is prolonged with a bend into the end of the upper lobe of the tail ; whilst in the homocercal fishes, or those common in the younger rocks and in the present time, it terminates in the middle, between the equally balanced fins of the tail. The Palaeoniscus, Pygopterus, Ccelacanthus, Acrolepis, and Platy- somus, which are the prevailing genera of the Permian era (the same generic forms being found in England, Germany, and Russia), are all known in the Carboniferous epoch, but the species of the younger deposit are wholly distinct. Fossils, 68. Palaeoni3CU3 Frieslebeni, Agassiz ; from the " Kupfer Schiefer " of Mansfeld, in Thuringia. Chap. XII.] PEKMIAN FAUNA. 313 Lastly, in enumerating the chief features of the Permian fauna, we have to recollect, that whilst a very few reptiles have been found in the next subjacent formations (Carboniferous and Devonian), the strata of this newer era contain the relics of The- codont Saurians, which Owen refers to a higher order of reptiles than any of the older fossils of this family, by showing that they are even allied to the living monitor.* The Palaeosaurus and Pro- tosaurus were, according to him, Sauri which occasionally walked on dry land. Struck with this fact of the Permian deposits containing Saurians, Agassiz thought that the group ought to be placed at the base of the secondary rocks, which mark the great era of reptiles. But the recent discovery of Saurians and Batrachians in the Carboniferous rocks of Europe and America, and of one reptile in the Upper Old Red, have satisfied my colleagues and myself, that we were right in being guided by the general facies of the mollusks and plants, and in grouping the Permian with antecedent deposits, with which they are naturally united by many links. In reviewing the few reptiles of the Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian rocks, which have been discovered, we have yet scarcely sufficient materials to enable us to decide on the relative value of such animals in the scale of creation. As far, however, as the above mentioned evidences go, Professor Owen is of opinion, that the solitary, small reptile of the Upper Old Ked Sandstone, found in the vicinity of Elgin (see p. 254.), belongs to the Lacertilia, a higher order than the Batrachia, to which the reptiles of the coal are referred. At the same time the latter possess characters in their skull and teeth which bring them nearer to the Saurian order than any modern Ba- trachian. * See Russia in Europe, vol. i. p. 213, and Professor Owen's description, p. 637, App. 314 SILUKIA. [Chap. XII. The same eminent comparative anatomist affirms, that the The- codonts of the Permian are more nearly allied to the Crocodilians of the Lias, and so to the higher order of reptiles, than any living monitor ; and " just," says he, " as the coal Batrachia are more sauroid, so the lacertilian sauroids of the Trias (New Red) are more Crocodilian than existing frogs and lizards are." In a letter to myself, from which the above view is derived, he adds, " So far as Old Red (Upper), Coal, and Permian reptiles are known, they support the general fact, that the more ancient forms of vertebrata adhered closer to the general archetype of that sub-kingdom than the more modern forms." Thus we learn, that in the oldest rocks (Upper Palaeozoic), in which they first appear, the reptiles are as wonderful and elaborate in structure as the primeval fishes which accompanied them, or as the corals, crinoids, shells, and Crustacea which preceded them during the Silurian or Lower Palasozoic epoch. In concluding this chapter, it may indeed be re-asserted*, that the mass of the organic remains of the Permian system constitute a mere remnant of the earlier creations of animals, the various develop- ments of which we have followed in the preceding pages. They exhibit the last of the partial and successive changes which these creatures underwent before their final disappearance. The dwin- dling away and extinction of many of the types, which were produced and multiplied during the anterior epochs, already announce the end of the long palaeozoic period. In ascending above the highest of the Permian deposits, the geologist takes, indeed, a sudden and final leave of nearly every- thing in nature to which the words primary, primeval, or palaeozoic have been or can be applied. In short, the two greatest revolutions in the extinct organic world * See Kussia in Europe, vol. i. p. 205. Chap. XII.] CLOSE OF PRIMEVAL LIFE. 315 are those which separated the primeval or palaeozoic rocks from the mediaeval or secondary strata, and the latter from the tertiary and modern deposits. To the consideration of these two remarkable and salient features in the history of former races, we shall briefly advert in the con- cluding chapter. P. S. — A good additional palaeozoic form has been discovered in the Zechsteinof Ilmenau, and is described by Professor Geinitz as Conularia Holleleni. Zeitschrift der Deutschen-Geologischen Gesellschaft, vol. ii. p. 465. I may also mention here a fine specimen of the Xenacanthus Dechenii, Beyrich, which, with other Permian fishes (Holacanthodes, &c.), I saw lately in the Museum at Bonn. The fish in question has the fins and tail expanded, and measures 15 inches in length. It is from Ruppendorf. (See p. 339. See also Leonh. and Bronn, Neues Jahrb. 1849, 118.) 316 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. CHAPTER XIII. GENERAL VIEW OF THE SILURIAN, DEVONIAN, AND CARBONIFEROUS ROCKS OF SCANDINAVIA AND RUSSIA. In the last chapter only, which explained the nature of the Per- mian Rocks, has a sketch been given of the development of any palaeozoic deposits upon the Continent. An effort must now there- fore be made, to delineate, if only in the most general manner, the equivalents in other countries of the Silurian, Devonian, and Car- boniferous groups of Britain. Throughout large portions of Western Europe, z.e. Germany, France, Spain and Portugal, the deposits under consideration have been in some tracts so much metamorphosed and crystallized, in others so penetrated by igneous rocks, and even so dislocated, that not- withstanding the researches of numerous good geologists and mine- ralogists, the task of reducing them to a normal order of succession is far from being completed. Deferring, therefore, to a subsequent chapter, such explanation of these complicated regions as may be practicable, let us first take a broad view of the succession of primeval life in Scandinavia and Russia in Europe, where, on the con- trary, the series of the older sediments is exhibited, over very wide areas, in the clearest and most symmetrical order, and usually uninterrupted by the intrusion of igneous or volcanic rocks.* * The limits of this work do not permit any attempt to delineate the mineral structure of the Ural Mountains, except to indicate by the way how clearly they exhibit the metamorphism of the palaeozoic deposits of Scandinavia and Russia in Europe. An acquaintance with their structure must be sought in the works of many authors, from the time of Pallas to the days of the most illustrious of all travellers Humboldt, who explored these regions accompanied by his eminent friends Gustaf Rose and Ehrenberg, and extended the lights of physical science to Chap. XIII.] OLDEST ROCKS OF SCANDINAVIA. 317 In Scandinavia and Lapland, ancient crystalline rocks occupying the chief mass of that territory, and consisting to a great extent of granite and gneiss, with many varieties of schist and quartzose strata in which nothing organic has been discovered, are covered at intervals by true representatives of the Silurian rocks. The lowest beds which are charged with organic remains, are clearly the equivalents of the lowest Silurian strata of the British Isles, Bohemia, and other countries. In some places these strata repose upon the above-mentioned crystalline schists, which are proba- bly altered or metamorphosed primary sediments. The first of the following diagrams represents the succession of Lower Silurian de- posits from a base of crystalline gneiss and associated strata near Kinnekulle in Sweden.* the frontiers of China. Besides the " Keise nach dem Ural, dem Altai, &c,," of those authors, the reader will find a great body of information in the Archiv fiir Wissenschaftliche Kunde Russland, conducted by M. Adolf Erman, the explorer of North-eastern Siberia and Kamschatka. Among the authors who have written on the mineral structure of Siberia, Helmersen and Hoffman also stand out conspicuously, as will be seen by those who consult their publications in the *' Annuaire des Mines de Russie." The splendid work also of M. Pierre de Tchiha- tcheff, on the Altai Mountains, and many others, would have to be noticed ; but as this volume is chiefly an outline of the nature and succession of the older sedi- ments, I cannot here expatiate upon the labours of many of my contemporaries. In the work " Russia and the Ural Mountains," references are given to the authors, both anterior and contemporary, who have illustrated the older sedimentary deposits and their fossils in the Russian Empire. Special allusion is there made to the original sketch, by the Hon. W. Fox Strangways, of the environs of that metro- polis, in Trans. Geol. Soc. Lend. 1 ser. vol. v. p. 392., to the work of Pander on the fossils of the same district, and to the volume of Eichwald, ' Systeme Silurien de I'Esthonie.' Since the publication of our work, my friends and self have been gratified by seeing it translated (1849) into the Russian language by Colonel Osersky, who has added some important data from his own observation and other sources, including corrections of our general geological map. * A detailed geological map of all the crystalline and metalliferous rocks of Sweden and Norway has for some time been in preparation, but is not yet pub- lished. This task was undertaken by MM. Forsells, Erdman, Franzen, and Troilius. 318 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. Lower Silurian Strata of Sweden reposing on Gneiss. (From Russia in Europe, p. 15.) gn. Gneiss. t. Trap or eruptive greenstone. bl. Erratic blocks. In other parts of Sweden, as near the Billingen Hills, the two lower strata a, b, of the above section are seen to rest upon granitic rocks without any intervening crystalline schists. In such cases the lowest sandstone, which is used as a millstone, is simply a re-aggre- gated granite, the arkose of Brongniart ; the materials being de- rived from the subjacent rock. Oldest Silurian Strata of Sweden resting on Granite. (From Russia in Europe, p. 16.) h. Alum schist, a. Facoid sandstone, a!. Millstone, gr. Granite. Now, whether the subjacent rocks be composed of granite, gra- nitic gneiss or flinty slates, quartzose or other crystalline masses, the fundamental strata in which any traces of former life can be detected, are sandstones and schists, which stand in the place of the lowest fossiliferous beds of Britain, and of that primordial zone in Bohemia which will presently be noticed. The bottom beds con- tain fucoids or casts of sea-weeds only; but the lowest band of schist is well characterized by its fossils in several parts of Sweden, and particularly at Andrarum, where it contains trilobites of the genera Paradoxides, Olenus, Conocephalus, Agnostus, &c. Chap. XIII.] SUCCESSION OF NORWAY. 319 The limestones which next overlie (c, of the opposite page), and which abound in Orthidae, large Orthoceratites, Trilobites, and Cys- iidex, are distinctly the equivalent of the British Llandeilo formation of schists, flags, and limestone, &c. Above these, but connected with them, is a considerable mass of shale or schist, chiefly characterized by graptolites, and this is covered by other limestones, which in Goth- land are profusely charged with many species of shells and corals that are found in the limestones of Wenlock and Dudley. The whole of these are capped, in the south of Gothland, by certain sandy strata, which are meagre equivalents of the Ludlow Rocks.* In Norway, all these Silurian rocks, very clearly divisible into ' Lower ' and * Upper ' through their characteristic fossils, are re- gularly exhibited in a very small compass in the Steensfiord, between the river Drammen and Krokleven, to the west of Christiania, where their uppermost member is conformably overlaid by a great accumu- lation of Old Red Sandstone with conglomerate, as expressed in this diagram.! Succession in Norway. I (From Russia in Europe, p. 10.> i E. A Krokleven. Lower Silurian. Upper Silurian. Old Red Sandstone 0. Azoic crj'stalline rocks. a. Lower Sandstones, Schists, and Flags. b. Limestone, with • Pentameri. c. Coralline limestone (Wenlock). d. Calcareous flagstones (Ludlow ?). c. Old Red Sandstone. (p. Rhombic porphyry. t. Other eruptive rocks.) The same strata of Lower and Upper Silurian prevail in the Bay of Christiania; but there they are at many points contorted and penetrated by syenites, greenstones, and hypersthenic rocks, whereby * See details of this succession, by Murchison and De Verneuil, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. iii. p. 1. . f For the particulars of these phenomena, consult " Russia in Europe," vol. i. p. 10. et seq., and Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. i. p. 467. (Murchison "On the Palaeozoic Deposits of Scandinavia, &c., and their Relations to Azoic or more Recent Crystalline Rocks"), 1845. 320 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. the lower alum schists are crystallized, and the limestone, b, con- verted into marble. The next section (a continuation to the east of the preceding diagram) explains their relations, and shows how the undulating and broken masses, regaining their order, fold over and dip under a great mass of Old Red Sandstone, the eastern extremity only of which is represented in the preceding diagram. e. Old Red Sandstone, d. Calcareous flagstones, c. Coralline limestone and shale (Wen- lock), beautifully exposed in many islands of the bay. h. Limestone, in parts a marble (Paradis backen). a. Lower Silurian Schists, &c,, in parts altered, o. Azoic Gneiss, t. Various eruptive rocks. (The t of this section represents most of the intrusive rocks, whether, syenites, greenstones, porphyries, or j'ounger granites, which have been forced through the strata. p refers to the large rhombic porphyry on the summit of the plateau.) Keferring the reader for the general description of Scandinavia and for the detailed description of its fossils to the works of native authors*, let me here only call attention to the general comparison of the lower palaeozoic strata of this region with those of Britain. In doing so, I specially advert to the above sections of a tract which I examined in the company of Professor Keilhau, in the year 1844, when I placed the older strata of Norway in exact parallel with the Silurian and Devonian succession of my own country. For, although the many thousands of feet of the Lower Silurians of Britain are there repre- sented by a few hundred feet only of thickness, these black Norwe- gian schists, with their overlying limestones, are as copiously charged * In this brief sketch, no justice can be done to the numerous works on the rocks and fossils of Sweden and Norway, countries which, from the time of Lin- naeus to the present day, have contributed so much to the progress of Natural History. In the memoirs of Nilsson of our time, in those of Wahlenberg and Gyllenberg of past years, and in the works of Loven and Angelin, which have recently appeared, the fossil organic remains have received much illustration, in addition to the knowledge formerly communicated in the " Lethsea Suecica " (1837) of Hisinger. The " Gaea Norvegica " of Keilhau has great merit for its description and delineation of the various rocks of Norway. Chap. XIII.] LOWER SILURIAN. — SCANDINAVIA. 321 with characteristic trilobites and other fossils, as the enormously ex- panded British rocks of the same age. The latter, as seen in North Wales, have, in fact, been swollen out by a much more profuse and active deposit of materials ; the bottom of the sea, in which they were accumulated, having been subjected to a turbulence produced by contemporaneous submarine volcanos, from which this northern region was exempt. The primordial fauna of Scandinavia, which I long ago character- ized as " the earliest zone of recognizable life," consists, in its lowest stage, of fucoids only. The next stage contains a number of trilo- bites, which have been since elaborately described by M. Angelin*, who has added much to our acquaintance with these fossils. Among the Crustacea of these lowest shales {Regiones A, B, of Angelin), we recognize several of the genera which characterize the lowest fossil beds of the Silurian region of Britain. The most plentiful fossils are the Agnostus pisiformis, and many species of Olenus, one of which probably also occurs in the lowest schists of our Malvern Hills. Then, the Swedish Regiones C and D of Angelin are nothing more, as respects their fossils, than masses of Lower Silurian Rocks, as originally described in England and Wales, and which reappear in great force in the Bay of Christiania, Norway. They are specially identified by the abundance of trilobites, of the same genera ; — Asaphus, Ogygia, Remopleurides, Trinucleus, Illsenus, Ampyx, &c., as our British strata of this age. Several species are identical. Having examined these Lower Silurian Bocks over various tracts of Sweden and Norway, I can assure geologists that, rich as they are in fossils — so rich that they have enabled M. Barrande, as will soon be seen, to parallel every one of their stages, from the lowest upwards, with the 'primordial and succeeding zones of Bohemia — the whole of this Lower Silurian of Scandinavia never exceeds in vertical thickness 1000 feet! And yet this mass is nearly as complete in the development of life, as the 30,000 feet of strata of the same age in * Palaeontologia Suecica, pt. 1., 1852. Y 322 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. Britain ! 'Nay, the general succession is essentially the same as in our islands. For, the Lower Silurian of Sweden and Norway is overlaid by shale and limestone, which completely represents the Wenlock of England ; whilst M. de Verneuil and myself have endeavoured to show, that in the south of Gothland still higher rocks are exhibited, which, though of feeble dimensions, are on the parallel of the Ludlow formation of Britain. And here, in respect to nomenclature, I may observe, that the geologist who should seek to separate the Lower Silurian of Norway from the Upper, and call the higher part only Silurian, would make an effort which could not be applied to any map. For these two groups are there often exhibited in the space of an English mile, and roll over in such frequent and parallel undulations, as to constitute one united mass of very small dimensions. The remarkable resemblance of the fossils of the chief limestones of Gothland, and of certain isles in the bay of Christiania, to those of Wenlock and Dudley, a very great number being common to the two localities, is well known to geologists and collectors. I have already spoken of some of these — the corals — on page 215. Those persons who may wish to understand how the calcareous masses of Gothland repose on graptolite schists, and these again upon the lower Silurian rocks of Oland, or again pass upwards into schists and sand- stones (in the South of Gothland) which represent the Ludlow rocks of England, must refer to the published descriptions of M. de Ver- neuil and myself.* Primeval Rocks of Russia. — Following the older rocks from Scandinavia into the Kussian Baltic provinces, the hard crystalline nucleus subsides, and the lowest Silurian rocks being depressed be- neath the sea-level, the absolute bottom of the fossiliferous strata is no longer visible, as in Scandinavia. Extending from the bed of the Neva at St. Petersburg to the cliffs west of Narva, the lowest strata are shales, often unconsolidated, * Quart. Journ. Geol Soc. vol. iii. p. 28, &c. Chap. XIII.] "LOWER SILURIAN. — RUSSIA. 323 in which little more than fucoidal remains have been found, or bodies which Pander has termed Platydolenites.* This shale, in which green grains and a few thin sandy courses appear, is so soft and incoherent, that it is even used by sculptors for modelling, although it underlies the great mass of fossil-bearing Silurian rocks, and is, therefore, of the same age as the lower crystalline and hard slates of North Wales ; so entirely have most of these oldest rocks in Russia been exempted from the influence of change, throughout those enormous periods which have passed away since their accumulation ! The shale is followed by a sandstone, in parts coherent, which in other tracts is a green-grained calcareous grit (as under the Castle of Narva), containing the little horny Obolus Apollinis (the ' Ungulite' of Pander), one or two species of Siphonotreta, and the Acrotreta of Kutorga. These strata of green sand are covered by and sometimes interlaced with bituminous schist f; whilst the limestone which succeeds is identical, through many of its fossils, with the chief Lower Silurian limestone of Sweden ; some of the * Bullet, de la Soc. Geol. de Fr. t. viii, p. 252. In some greenish, sandy beds subordinate to the lowest Silurian strata of the Baltic provinces of Russia, M. Pander also recently detected very minute bodies, not larger than pins' heads, which he supposed might be the teeth of fishes ; but the naturalists to whom they have been submitted, both in France and England, including M. Barrande and Dr. Carpenter, can see in them, when placed under powerful microscopes, no evidence whatever of hone. They are probably, it is suggested, fragments of the hard, crustaceous ends of the segments of some trilobite. I In addition to various able Memoirs which he has written on the crystalline and palaeozoic rocks of Russia, and to the geological maps which he has prepared, my associate in the Imperial Academy of St. Petersburg, Colonel Helmersen, has published an account of the nature and position of this schist, which in some places contains about 25 per cent, of bitumen and a considerable portion of inflammable gas. It is certainly one of the oldest deposits which have combustible properties, though the anthracitic layers of the South of Scotland seem to lie still lower in the series. It is probable that most of the bituminous and anthracitic beds of these early periods were formed out of the marine vegetables, or fucoids, of which the ancient rocks ofier impressions and casts, occasionally of large size. — (See Helmersen, Sur le Schiste argileux-bitumineux d'Esthonie, Journal des Mines de Russie, 1838, p. 97.) Y 2 324 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. species being also well-known fossils of the British Isles. This lime- stone, for the most part thin-bedded and marly, occupies various low hills south of St. Petersburg, and thence ranges into the cliffs of the Gulf of Bothnia, where it thus appears in relation to the inferior strata. Lower Silurian Rocks. — Cliffs near Waiwara. a. Lower Shale, obscured by fallen blocks. b. Ungulite grit. c. Bituminous schist, vrith graptolites. d. Orthoceratite Limestone (covered by granite blocks which were transported from Sweden in the glacial periods, ' Russia in Europe,' vol. i. pp. 34. 51L, et seq.). These lower limestones, which constitute the chief members of the Lower Silurian of Russia, are filled, as in Scandinavia, with a AsAPHUs expansus, var. cornutus, from the St. Petersburg Limestone. (From "Russia and the Ural Mountains," vol. i. p. 37.) profusion of trilobites, large orthoceratites, univalve shells, and cystideae, characteristic of this age. One of the most remarkable of the trilobites, the Asaphus cornutus, is here represented. Chap. XIII.] UPPER SILURIAN. — RUSSIA. 325 Orthis calligramma and the great Orthoceras duplex among the shells, and Spheronites aurantium among the Cystideae, may be con- sidered quite characteristic of this formation. But we must refer to the works of Pander and Eichwald, and of my colleagues and self, in which these rocks and their contents are described, for a full description of the fossils. Upper Silurian, — Upper Silurian deposits, like those of Gothland, were only spoken of by my companions and self as existing in the Isles of Oesel and Dago. With the little time at our command, and in a flat country much obscured by drift, we could not pretend to draw any well defined line between the Lower and Upper Silurian. Seeing, however, that Pentamerus oblongus occurred in a cal- careous band ranging between the Lower Silurian cliffs of Esthonia and the Devonian rocks of Livonia, it was natural in our rapid sur- vey to refer that stratum, as I had done in England, rather to the top of the lower than to the base of the upper group. Subsequent researches, however, and the preponderance of certain fossils, have led the Russian geologists to class this Pentamerus band with the Upper Silurian.* In truth, the whole series in Russia, as * M. Ozersky, who translated the work of ' Russia in Europe ' into the national language, was the first person to call attention to the succession of those upper calcareous Silurian strata, though, when he wrote, the fossil distinctions above alluded to were not elaborated. Afterwards, in a short article (Erman's Archiv fiir Russland, 1848, p. 236.), M. Pander noticed the superposition of a rock charged with Pentamerus oblongus and many corals, to the well-known lower limestone of St. Petersburg. The most important, however, of these contributions which clear up the subdivisions of the Russo-Baltic Silurians, is by Professor Kutorga, as given in a recent map of the government of St. Petersburg, the result often years of labour (" Compte rendu de la Societe Mineralogique de St. Peters- bourg, 27 Janvier, 1852"). Representing a continuous band of Upper Silurian be- tween the Devonian and the Lower Silurian to the west of St. Petersburg (a tract which I never examined), he admits that, to the south and east of the metropolis, the succession is what my friends and self represented it to be ; viz., Devonian rocks at once resting on Lower Silurian, with one or two minute traces only of the lower band of the Upper Silurian, or the limestone with Pentamerus oblongus. Y 3 326 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. in Scandinavia, is of such very small vertical dimensions — not, perhaps, a fortieth part of the magnitude of the grand British de- posits— that in a region where all these strata are conformable, it is only by close examination of organic remains that such distinctions can be drawn. The lower limestone, with Orthoceras duplex (Foss. 59.), Foss. 59. Orthoceras duplex. Wahlexberg. A characteristic Eussian and Scandinavian Fossil. Orthis biforatus, many Cystideje, Trilobites of the genera Asaphus, Ampyx, Cybele, Illaenus, &c., and many other true Lower Silurian fossils, is conformably overlaid by another limestone, in which certain Wenlock forms, particularly a multitude of corals, predominate, but in which the Pentamerus oblongus also occurs. Both these calcareous masses (Lower and Upper), which are perfectly united and conform- The Russian geologists seem, however, to have to learn, that in Britain this species of Pentamerus ranges from the top of the Caradoc or bottom of the Wenlock shale down into the middle part of the Llandeilo formation; and they will therefore understand the nature of my reasoning pp. 86. 98. ante. Wherever, as in Russia and America, this species appears for the first time., in ascending order., in strata otherwise exclusively charged with Wenlock fossUs, the geologists of such countries have a perfect right to class the rock as Upper Silurian. According to Kutorga, the band of true Lower Silurian limestone above noted is first followed upwards by a course of limestone without fossils, which he leaves in the lower di- vision ; next by a magnesian limestone with Pentamerus, and this again by beds containing fucoids, encrinites, and corals. According to this author, these beds are surmounted, in the islands of Oesel, Dago, and Moen, by still higher Silurian strata. These Russian isles seem, in fact, to be equivalents of the southern end of Gothland (Hoburg), where I have described certain strata which probably >e- present the Ludlow Rocks. (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. iii. p. 1.) In another work, "Uebersicht des Silur-Schichten Systems Lieflands und Esthlands, 1852," M. Schrenk, the well known explorer of the botanical and mineral condition of the north Ural Mountains, has, in conjunction with Professor Schmidt, extended considerably the range of the Upper Silurian. He speaks of a mixture of the fossils of the Lower and Upper Silurian rocks. Chap. XIII.] DEVONIANS. — RUSSIA. 327 able, constitute only what would be called one formation, not dis- tinguishable except by fossils. The upper division occupies the whole of the isles of Oesel, Dago, Wormes, and a narrow zone on the mainland, as indicated on the recent map published by Professor Kutorga. The chief mineral features of these overlying rocks, in ascending order, consist of fine-grained limestone, passing in some beds almost into marble, and thus presenting a contrast to the incoherent Lower Silurian limestones of St. Petersburg; next, of magnesian beds (dolomite) occasionally somewhat crystalline and cavernous, here and there charged with white silicious concretions. In other parts, they are friable and of grey and yellow colours. Rocks having the same mineral aspect, and containing the same fossils, appear, as I am informed by Count A. von Keyserling, along the edge of the Timan Hills, in the distant region of the Petchora, at the mouth of the river Tatchina, and near the shore of the Icy Sea. It is further to be remarked, that in no part of Russia has there been detected the slightest unconformity between the Lower and Upper Silurian ; and that with the exception of some of their probable equivalents in the isles of Dago and Oesel, the Ludlow rocks have no true representatives. The inferior part of the so-called Upper Silurian of the Russian geologists is chiefly characterized by the following fossils: — Pen- tamerus oblongus, P. borealis, Leptsena depressa, Atrypa reticularis, Bumastus Barriensis? Orthoceratites, some Trilobites, Leperditia marginata, and L. Baltica ; with a profusion of corals of the genera Stromatopora, Halysites, Cyathophyllum, Favosites, &c., chiefly known elsewhere in the Wenlock formation. Devonian Rocks of Russia. — This formation constitutes one of the most widely spread deposits of the Empire, and extends over a region more spacious than the British Isles. This great extension is not, however, due to the thickness, but the very slight inclination of the beds, and to their having been but rarely disturbed. Though 328 SILURIA. [Chap. XIII. subjected to broad and very slight bends only, they rise into the Valdai Hills, and also into a broad dome near Orel ; thus constituting the highest eminences of this comparatively low region. In addition to many shells, some of them peculiar to the region, but others well known in strata of this age in Devonshire, the Khenish provinces, and elsewhere, fossil fishes occur in numerous localities, and strikingly characterize this deposit in Russia. Several of them are identical with species of the Scottish Old Red Sandstone, as shown by Agassiz ; whilst, from a microscopic examination of their teeth, Owen has proved that others belong to Dendrodus, a genus * of sauroid fishes, equally characteristic of the formation in North Britain. The forms of Coccosteus, Cephalaspis, Acanthodes, Dipla- canthus, Cheiracanthus, and Cheirolepis, have not, it is true, been found; but other Scottish species not less remarkable have their exact representatives in Russia. Such are the great Asterolepis (Chelonicthys) Asmusii, Ag. ; and the smaller species, A. minor, Ag. ; Glyptosteus favosus, Ag. ; Bothriolepis ornata, Eichw. (Glyp- tosteus reticulatus, Ag.) ; Holoptychius Nobilissimus, Ag. ; Dendro- dus strigatus, Owen ; D. biporcatus, Owen; Cricodus incurvus, Ag. (Dendrodus, Owen) ; Ptericthys major, Ag., &c.f Ravine of the Belaia m the Valdai Hills. (From p. 46. Russia in Europe.) The lower beds a, b, c, d, e, f, con- sist of various sands and marls, in which ichthyolites are disseminated, but of which the bed d is a complete congeries of fish-bones surmounted by a copious mass of red, white, and green argillaceous marls. Then f J* t^^^^ZigZH-^Tr follow bituminous schists (^f, h., i) ■ ^- . with courses of bad coal, constitu- ' / ting the bottom beds of the carbo- jj^ niferous deposits, which, after other alternations of sands and marls ss-z^r J Z), are followed by the carboniferous limestone m, n, with many charac- teristic fossils, including even species ^ri'js'c which are well known in Britain, ^S^^Z-Zi-^— b such as the Productus hemispJuBricus, ^ /^^^^--t-i"^-^-^ -Ir^"^-^"'^^/T P- punctatus, and F. semireticulatus. __2SjM is = 3 II It bo .EC 13 1^ I si .s'J cs o Si IJI p u > u ^ 9) • a> Sch ach- enb fer idb. UW£ in g S § S Si ill il = - s S § 2 u — _g *j ^ 3 o « ° "5 .c ^ <«" S o o -C . i i^-^ 'S V o 2^ •= 3-5 o — o u S ct O B >. 3 S M O t2 u 2'J P3| H OJ ^ OJ ~ ^ .2 .-^ -5 -a oj ■nils ; = 3 «-a j3 =C:E = 5 •qiBp •snoa.ij!UoqaB3 •UBIU0A3Q jaddQ S 3 C o § P U bo ^ w g^ °a § ? .2 o' •UBUI0A3Q 8|"PP!I\[ ,01 nS O '2.1- e Sj= p •UBIUOAaQ A X I F fe 383 CHAPTER XV. SILURIAJf, DEVONIAN, AND CARBONIFEROUS ROCKS OF FRANCE, SPAIN, PORTUGAL, AND SARDINIA. Although the palaeozoic rocks* occupy considerable spaces in France, it is not possible on this occasion to offer more than a slight sketch of their chief features in those tracts where they are clearly exhibited. In Brittany, where they appear in force, the authors of the geological map of France f divide them into two principal masses. The inferior is composed of, 1. Glossy schists (schistes satines luisans) of great thickness, in w^hich a few thin courses of grit and shaly limestone occur. In their mineral aspect, and in their entire want of fossils, these strata remind the geologist of the rocks which underlie the lowest fossiliferous deposits of Bohemia, and they may not unaptly be compared with some of the crystalHne and subcrystalline rocks of Anglesea and the Longmynd, or hardest bottom rocks of the Welsh and English series. Their mean direction in Brittany is, like that of the Longmynd, from east 20° north, to west 20° south, and they were termed Cambrian by E. de Beaumont and Dufrenoy. 2. Under the name of Silurian, these authors include a series of thick and complex fossiliferous strata, which they have again divided into two groups. The lowest of these they thus arrange : — 1st. Conglomerates and silicious sandstones ; 2nd. Bluish schists, which at Angers, Poligny, &c., fur- nish good slates, and correspond through their fossils X to the Llandeilo formation of Britain. So far, the succession in Brittany, as dependent on organic remains, is in unison with that of Britain ; but the chief portion of the next division, consisting of compact limestones and * Often, however, in a metamorpliic state, •j" MM. Elie de Beaumont and Dufrenoy. X Trinucleus and Ogygia, with Illasnus giganteus, &c., are abundant. 384 SILURIA. [Chap. XY. schists, has been abstracted by de Verneuil from the Silurian, and shown to belong to the Devonian system. In this way the order in Brittany is analogous to that of Cornwall on the one hand, and many parts of Grermany on the other, in both of which tracts, as already shown, there is an equally sudden transition from Lower Silurian to Devonian. The second group of the authors of that magnificent work the geolo- gical map of France, is made up, first, of silicious conglomerates, coarse grits, and argillaceous schists, which many persons would term grey- wacke, then of beds with coal, and, lastly, of a limestone specially charac- terized by the presence of Amplexus and Productus. Now d'Archiac and de Yerneuil have demonstrated, that this last and highest group is neither Silurian nor Devonian, but a true member of the Carbo- niferous rocks. It is, in fact, identical, through its fossils, with the carboniferous limestones of many regions. All these fossiliferous deposits, whether Lower Silurian, Devonian, or Carboniferous, are conformably inclined, whatever may be the inclination of the beds; and striking from east 15° south, to west 15° north, they are transgressive to the older unfossiliferous rocks on which they repose. It was the concordance in their direction and inclination which naturally led Elie de Beaumont and Dufrenoy to embrace, in the first instance, all these fossiliferous deposits in the Silurian period. But in the interval which has elapsed since that classification was proposed, Brittany has been examined by many geologists, including Frappoli, de Fourcy, Durocher, Blavier, Rouault, as well as by de Yerneuil and d'Archiac, all of whom agree in adopting the order and nomenclature here announced. The eastern limits of the province, towards the departments of La Mayenne and La Sarthe, have indeed been studied in the greatest detail by M. Triger, to whom the execution of the geological map of the last-mentioned district was confided. The collection of fossils made in the palaeozoic rocks around Cherbourg, by my late old and indefatigable corre- FRENCH PALiEOZOIC ORDER. 385 spondent M. de Gerville, has also contributed essentially to clear away the difficulties at- tending a right classification ; and lastly, the Geological So- ciety of France (during its meeting at le Mans, 1850) under the leadership of M. Triger, made an admirable section across the older rocks to the north of Angers, the resume of which was pub- lished by de Verneuil and de Loriere. This diagram, reduced from their publication, exhibits the principal geological features of the country between Sille le Guillaume and Sable, a dis- tance of about twenty-five English miles ; and it clearly develops a succession of the palaeozoic formations, from the Low er Silurian to the Carbon- iferous rocks inclusive. In this section, the lowest stratum is a white sandstone (1) resting on porphyry. The still more ancient crystalline and glossy schists of Brittany are here wanting, and the lowest beds which are visible 386 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. (1 to 6), and in which some limestone appears, have not yet aiforded any fossils, to serve as equivalents for those of the lower zone of Bohemia and Scandinavia, or the Lingula flags of Britain. The great schistose and slaty mass which follows (Ardoises de Parennes, or 7 of the diagram), forms the inferior limit of Silu- rian life, as known in France. From its wide extension, and its fossils, this formation merits great attention ; for it is doubtless, as M. de Yerneuil states, the representative of the Llandeilo and Bala rocks of Britain, of the second zone of M. Barrande in Bohemia, and of the Orthoceratite limestones of Scandinavia, Russia, and North America. It is, in fiict, the dominant member of the Lower Silurian rocks, so termed by all the authors who have described them in those countries. These slaty masses of Brittany are characterized, like their equi- valents elsewhere, by a profusion of Trilobites. Unfortunately these crustaceans are, for the most part, much flattened and distorted ; but the following species have, notwithstanding, been recognized, some of which were long ago figured by Guettard and Brongniart : — Calymene Tristani, Brong. ; C. Arago, Rouault; C. Yerneuili, Rou- ault ; Asaphus Guettardi, Brong. ; Ogygia Desmaresti, Brong. ; Illcenus gi- ganteus, Burm. (the two last are gigantic species) ; 111. Beaumonti, Rouault ; Acidaspis Bachii, Barr. ; Phacops (Dalmannia) socialis, Barr. ; P. Dujardini, Rouault ; Placoparia Tournemini, Rouault ; Cheirurus claviger, Beyr ; Lichas Heberti, Rouault ; Trinucleus Pongerardi, Rouault,* &c. Mollusks are scarcer than trilobites ; the well-known British spe- cies Bellerophon bilobatus (Sil. Syst.) is, however, not unfrequent. But, as a rule, neither the species of Crustacea nor of shells are the same with those of Britain, while there are many identical with the fossils of Spain and of Bohemia. These Lower Silurian schists traverse an extensive tract, as may l)e seen by referring to the geological map of France, and crop out near * De Verneuil and Rouault, Bull. Soc. Geol. Fr., 2d ser. vol. iv. p. 320. Chap. XV.] LOWER SILURIAN. — FRANCE. 387 the harbour of Brest and Bay of Crozon, where De Verneuil has de- tected in them Calymene Tristani. The spot where the deposit affords the best roofing slates is Angers, where the quarries are 300 to 400 feet deep. There the lines of original deposit and the laminae of cleavage coincide. In fact, the remains of the included trilobites occur along the divisions by which the highly inclined slates are cleaved ; a phenomenon sometimes observed in Britain, where the cleavage is, however, usually transverse to the bedding. (See p. 34.) The peninsula of the Cotentin also contains these trilobite schists, near Siouxville, where M. de Gerville collected the Calymene Tristani.* The lower slaty rocks of Llandeilo age are succeeded in La Sarthe by an arenaceous group, represented by the 8 and 9 of the previous woodcut. In general, this division exhibits, in ascending order, conglomerates, white and reddish silicious sandstones, with some sub- ordinate beds of ' ampelite ' schists containing graptolites, chiefly the G. colonus and the G. testis of Barrande. The position of these beds is probably the same as that of the graptolite schists of Dale- carlia and parts of Sweden. They agree also, according to de Verneuil, with the great schistose member of the American Silurians called the * Hudson river group,' which is equally characterized by graptolites, and which overlies the Trenton limestone or Llandeilo flags, the equivalents, as above said, of the slates of Angers. As to the sili- cious sandstones in which the schists are enveloped, they are identical with the rocks of Jurques, Gahard, and May in Normandy, which have been placed by French geologists without hesitation on the parallel of the Caradoc sandstone of Britain. In some districts the rock is so ferruginous as to be the ^eat of iron mines, and the ore in parts is of an oolitic structure : trilobites are found in it. The sandstones are not rich in fossils, but where I have examined them in company with M. de Verneuil, they contain the British species Bellero- * Crustaces Fossiles. Paris, 1822. 388 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. phon bilobatus, with Conularia pyramidata, some species of Dalmannia, Homalonotus Brongniarti, and H. (Plesiocoma) rara ; the last-mentioned fossil occurs also in the Lower Silurian of Bohemia and Spain. Like the lower and larger portion of my Caradoc formation in Britain, this group of sandstones and schists is distinctly connected by its fossils with the inferior slates. Above all the strata, however, which have been mentioned, there is in France, an upper course of * ampelite ' schist, which, though often confounded with the lower, must be separated from it. These upper ampelitic schists (11 of the section), which are black and occa- sionally bituminous, have, as usual, given rise to wasteful searches after coal. They are distinguishable from the inferior masses by con- taining concretions of black limestone with a brilliant fracture, and are characterized by certain imbedded fossils. The most characteristic are Graptolithus priodon, Orthoceratites and Cardiola interrupta.* As this last-mentioned species is chiefly an Upper Silurian fossil in Britain, and occurs in Bohemia at the base of that division, it would seem fair, in the first instance, to consider this French deposit as of like age. At the same time we must observe, that Cardiola interrupta, on whose presence the comparison was drawn, is occasionally, though rarely, found in the Lower Silurian both of Britain and Bohemia. Whilst, therefore, this zone is clearly recognized, through extensive districts of France, as the highest of the rocks which are referable to the Silurian epoch, and whilst it is clearly at the base of the Upper Silurian, it is by no means an equivalent of the great British formation of Wenlock, and still less has it any reference to the Ludlow Rocks. We must, indeed, recollect that in Britain, as in Bohemia and Sweden, such schists, with Cardiola interrupta and Graptolites, underlie limestones with the well-known fossils of Wenlock, Dudley, and Gothland. * See an account of the extension of this zone of ampelite schists and its inter- calated minerals, by M. de Boblaye, Bull. Soc. Geol. France, 1 ser., vol. x. p. 227. Chap. XV.] LOWER DEVONIAN. FRANCE. 389 In France, therefore, the ascending series of strata is very different from that of Britain. The Upper Silurian is essentially wanting ; the succession being analogous, I repeat, to parts of Germany where the Lower Silurian is succeeded by Devonian rocks, with only graptolitic schists between them. (See p. 354.) France is by no means poor in Devonian equivalents. Numerous species of fossils derived from the strata (12 and 13) of the above diagram have been compared by de Verneuil with those of the lower shelly greywacke of the Rhine and the limestone of the Eifel, and he has found that many of them are identical. Among these, the broad-winged Spirifer macropterus, the Terebratula Archiaci, Grammysia Ilamiltonensis, and Pleurodictyum pro^ blematicum, are striking Devonian forms, unknown in any true Upper Silurian rocks. A still greater number of species in the Lower Devonian limestones of La Sarthe*, and Nehouf in Normandy, are identical with those of the Eifel. Having established the identity between the Devonian rocks of the West of France and the lower portions of the system in the Rhenish provinces, de Verneuil observes, that in such a consecutive development we might expect to meet with some species, which on the continent of Europe and the British Isles are considered to be Silurian. And such is the case. Thus, Bronteus Brongniarti, Capulus robustus, Terebratula eucharis, T. Haidin- geri, Atrypa reticularis, Orthis Gervillei, Leptaena Bouei, L. Bohemica, and L. Phillipsi, are found in the Devonian of France, and also in the uppermost Silurian of Bohemia. And Pentamerus galeatus, Atrypa reticu- laris, with the corals Heliolites interstincta, H. Murchisoni, Stenopora fibrosa, and Chonophyllum perfoliatum, are common to the Upper Silurian of England or Sweden, and the Lower Devonian of France. The Devonian group of Brittany and the West of France is also usually curtailed, like the Silurian, of its superior members, — those which, in the Bhenish provinces, are so fully developed between * De Verneuil and Rouault, ante^ p. 386. t At this locality abundance of Devonian fossils were obtained by M. de Ger- ville, and distributed among his friends. Both trilobites and shells are found there ; and among the latter are the common Devonian species, Spirifer heteroclytu?, Athyris concentrica, and Calceola sandalina. More than 45 species of Brachio- poda were lately found here by Mr. Davidson. c c 3 390 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. the above-mentioned rocks and the base of the Carboniferous system. In the *Bas Boulonnais,' however, we meet with a fair represen- tative of the Upper Devonian, rich in fossils, and on which, in 1840*, I published a short memoir. This member of the system is there immediately overlaid by the carboniferous limestone, and both of the formations extend into Belgium and the Rhenish provinces, occupying the same relative position.! This Upper Devonian is every where * Bull. Soc. Geol. France, vol. xi. p. 229. At that time tlie full relations of the strata had not been determined, and I was deceived as to the nature of a small imperfect body, probably a coralline, which I termed a graptolite, a fossil unknown in Devonian rocks. M. Delanoue, who has recently published a small geological map on this country, has ascertained by sinkings, that the Devonian deposits range underground towards Bethune and Arras. Bull. Soc. Geol. France, 2nd series, vol. ix. p. 399. "j" Mr. Austen, whose former labours threw so much light on the real nature of the limestones of Devonshire, has recently surveyed this district of the Boulonnais in detail, and has endeavoured to show that its lowest strata (limestones, dolomite &c.) represent the rocks of the Eifel, and are charged with the same species of corals, and many of the same moUusks, which are so well known in Devonshire and on the Continent. The overlying calcareous courses with shale he considers to be equiva- lents of the Upper Devonian as exhibited at Petherwin (see p. 256. etseq.) ; the com- parison being further sustained by a description of certain flag-like, light-coloured sandstones, charged with plants, and the same species of Cucullsea — C. trapezium and C. Hardingii, Sow. — as the yellow sandstones of Mar wood and Baggy Point in North Devon, which sandstones constitute one of the upper members of the Devo- nian liocks. Mr. Austen's section does not descend so far in the series as to ex- hibit any representative of the Spirifer Sandstein or bottom fossil rock of the Rhine. But the rest of the Devonian rocks of the Rhine and Belgium have, according to his view, their equivalents in the north of France. (Quart. Jouru. Geol. Soc. vol. ix. p. 231.) It must, however, be stated, that de Verneuil, and others, do not adopt this opinion, and continue to view the chief masses of the Boulonnais as Upper Devonian ; while Sharpe would class them as lower carboniferous. Mr. Austen has successfully dwelt upon the complete conformity and passage up- wards of the^e Devonian rocks of the North of France into the lower carboniferous strata with their two bands of limestone and interstratified seams of coal, and has made some valuable suggestions respecting the probable extension westwards, pven perhaps to England, of the beds of coal which have already been opened out near St. Omer beneath the cretaceous deposits. Chap. XV.] CARBONIFEROUS ROCKS. — FRANCE. 391 recognized by the abundance of its smaller Spirifers, among which Spirifer disjunctus, Sow., and its numerous varieties, are the most characteristic. The Productus subaculeatus and Athyris concentrica are also frequent fossils. The limestone recurs in different bands with dolomites, sandstone, and scliist, composing a group which has been supposed to correspond to the * Etage quartzo-schisteux supe- rieur du terrain anthraxifere^ of the classification of Dumont. Like the Lower Devonian of Brittany, the rocks in the ' Bas Boulonnais ' have a strike from the west-north- west to east-south-east, but are soon overlapped, first by the carboniferous, and then by the cretaceous and younger deposits. Though the Devonian system of France is of no great vertical dimensions, and not comparable in thickness to the deposits of like age in Scotland, England, or the Rhenish provinces, it is of con- siderable economic importance, particularly in certain schistose and arenaceous districts which it traverses, and where its limestone is much used in agriculture. At the extremity of the peninsula of Brittany these rocks appear in the Bay of Brest. In this work it is impossible for me to convey an adequate idea of the Carboniferous system, particularly that portion of it which is developed in the extensive upper coal-fields of France. The follow- ing few observations relate, therefore, only to the lower and calcareous members of the system, 'which immediately succeed to the subjacent rocks ; the great coal-fields of Valenciennes in the north, and those of Lyons and Auzun in the south, are therefore unnoticed. In the Bas Boulonnais there is no gap nor omission, as above stated, in this portion of the series ; for the Upper Devonian is at once followed by the Carboniferous Limestone, with many of its large Producti, and other typical fossils. But in Brittany and the West of France, the lower carboniferous deposits rest at once upon the Lower Devonian ; as is seen between Sable and Juigne (p. 385.), and at the coal pits of Ferce. The anthracitic group of the department of the Sarthe (the C C 4 392 SlLURIA, [Chap. XV. 14, 15, 16, of the preceding section) is composed of conglomerates, sandstones, shale, coal, and limestone, all which unquestionably belong to the Carboniferous system, of which they constitute a lower member, — a rock which in Central and Southern France is always unconformable to the coal-fields above them, A like physical arrangement has been alluded to as occurring near Hof, in Bavaria, where true carboniferous limestone, with large Pro- ducti, was described by Professor Sedgwick and myself, in the year 1839 *, and where that rock is inclined conformably with the Devonian, on which it rests, and is unconformable, as before stated, to the hori- zontal coal-fields of Bohemia. It was this unconformity which led E. de Beaumont to group the inferior carboniferous member with the lower palaeozoic rock to which it is conformable, though their re- spective organic remains refer them to different formations. The geologist, who combines stratigraphical with zoological evidences, is therefore bound to state, that the dislocations of the older rocks on the Continent have occurred at periods different from those of the same age in Britain and America, in both of which countries the great superjacent coal-fields have partaken of the movements which affected the limestones on which they rest. And thus we are more than ever confirmed in the belief, that all fractures of the crust of the earth are local phenomena only. As the strata containing large Producti ( Sable, Ferce, Juigne, LaBazouge, &c.), were shown to be truly of carboniferous age, their fossils being ab- solutely those of the mountain limestone of England, it followed that many other rocks in the east of France, which had been considerably metamor- phosed, but in which such fossils were detected, must also be referred to the same era of formation. Thus de Verneuil and Jourdan have proved, that the schists, slates, and quartz rocks of Central and Eastern France, particularly in the department of the Haute Loire, (Roanne to Lyon ) which, from their crystalline aspect, had been grouped with those of a much older epoch, are clearly to be classed with the Carboniferous system. Though * Trans, Geol. Soc. Lond., 2nd series, vol. vi. p. 298. PI. 23. f. 15. Chap. XV.] PARTIAL ANOMALY. NEFFIEZ. 393 in parts highly altered, and having a very antique and crystalline aspect, they have been found to contain well knoAvn fossils of the Coal period, such as Productus Cora, Chonetes papilionacea, Spirifer bisulcatus, Orthis crenistria, Goniatites diadema, &c. It was in the northern extension of this chain of hills from Thiers to Cusset near Vichy, where the schists have a still more ancient character and are pierced by numerous porphyries and syenitic rocks, that by the help of a few fossils, I was enabled to satisfy myself, that the slaty rocks on the banks of the Sichon belonged to the Carboniferous era.* The Permian Rocks of France may be disposed of in a phrase : for, in truth, they are very inadequate representatives of the diversified and complex assemblage of strata which constitute ' the Permian of Russia, Germany, and Britain. The lower portion of a series of red rocks in the Yosges Mountains, usually known as the * Gres des Vosges,' is considered by E. de Beaumont and myself to be of this age, and it has also been shown how other red sandstones, near Lodeve in the south of France, may from their plants be classed as Permian. But nowhere within the limits of the country is there any limestone to represent the great calcareous centre or Zechstein, and the group is wanting in those animal remains which constitute its essential distinctions. In the hard and subcrystalline rocks of the south of France, which lie to the south of the great granitic plateau of that region, (Lodeve, Pezenas, Beziers,) no clear succession of the older rocks has been determined, and until very recently they were considered, to a great extent, unfossiliferous. Within these few years, however, MM. Fournet and Graflf discovered at Neffiez near Pezenas f a very singular small oasis, not an English mile in length, in which some beds with several characteristic Lower Silurian fossils, and others containing Cardiola interrupta and graptolites occur, also red limestones charged with unequivocal Upper Devonian types, as re- cognized by de Verneuil. These are Goniatites amblylobus and Car- * Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. vii. p. 13. t Bull. Soc. Geol. France, 2nd series, vol. viii. p. 44. 394 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. dium palmatum of Westphalia, Nassau, and the Eifel. This rock is also identical with tlie ' marbre griotte ' of the Pyrenees, which the lamented Leopold von Buch classed as Devonian. Again, we have also in this one little spot, true carboniferous deposits ; for though there are only a few beds of their lower members, their fossils are unequivocal ; viz. Productus gigas, P. semi-reticulatus, Euomphalus acutus, Caninia gigantea, &c. The series is even terminated by some workable beds of coal. Such, says de Verneuil, is the palaeontological order of the strata, if we look only to the fossils, and compare them with those of all other known countries in the world. But whilst this is the universal and normal order in America, Asia, and Europe, these members of the series, so distinct elsewhere, seem to be physically intermixed at this little anomalous spot of Neffiez. In short, the schists, with Graptolites and Cardiola interrupta, appear to be interposed in the middle of the carboniferous group, or placed between the Productus limestone and the coal ! The tract of Neffiez has, however, manifestly been subjected to violent dislocations, and I therefore believe, with my associate de Verneuil, that the apparent anomaly is due to one of those inver- sions or reversals known in the Alps and in America, and to which I have called attention in my remarks on Germany (p. 377.). The paliEozoic formations again protrude to the surface in the Corbieres to the south of the plains of Languedoc, and rising from beneath the younger deposits they also, as has been long known, form a central portion of the Pyrenees. In that chain, the altered limestones, or * Marbres Griottes,'* which occur as concretionary masses in the schists, and are charged with Goniatites, are unquestion- ably Devonian. The schists of Gedre, between St. Sauveur and Gavarnie, contain other fossils of the same age. Just as in the Eastern Alps, the Ural, and many other mountain chains which have undergone much metamorphism, the observer fails to detect here the equivalents of the Lower Silurian Rocks. f But * This ' Marbre griotte ' of the valley of Campan Is well described by M. Du- frenoy. t Bull. See. Geol. Fiance, 2nd series, vol. i. p. 137. Chap. XV.] PALEOZOIC KOCKS. — SPAIN, ETC. 395 in certain spots, though at very rare intervals, the Pyrenees afford traces of one member of the system, as characterized by Graptolites, Cardiola interrupta, and the Orthoceratites, 0. Bohemicum and O. gregarium ; — fossils which have already been spoken of as probably representing the base of the Upper Silurian division. Palaeozoic Rocks in Spain, Portugal, and Sardinia. — To the south of the great chain of the Pyrenees, where several of their members occur in a more or less crystalline state, the Lower Palaeozoic rocks have much the same development as in France. Our acquaintance with the order of these rocks in Spain, is chiefly due to the re- searches, during the last five years, of my colleague de Yerneuil. For, whilst it is true that living Spanish and French geologists and mineralogists of ability, such as Casiano de Prado, Schultz, and Paillette, had made themselves well acquainted with the physical and lithological features of many tracts in which the older rocks prevail, and that an eminent French mining engineer, Le Play, had pub- lished a mineral sketch of the Sierra Morena, it was only by an examination of the imbedded fossils of the strata in each chain, that the relative ao;e of the rocks was at leno-th fixed, and correct com- es o ^ parisons established.* * This observation has reference only to the order and classification of the stratified rocks ; fiar in reference to mineralogy and other departments of geolo- gical science, a vast number of works and memoirs have been written in the last century, by native and foreign authors. See de Verneuil and Collorab, Coup d'CEil sur la Constitution Geologique de quelques Provinces de I'Espagne. Appendice Bibliographique. Bull. Soc. Geol. Fr., vol. x. p. 138., where a very copious list of authors is given, comprising upwards of 160 publications in the last hundred years. At the meeting of the British Association for the advancement of Science in 1850, I presented, on the part of M. de Verneuil, what I believed to be the first geological map of the whole peninsula, accompanied by a short notice. Since that time my colleague has twice revisited Spain. The high antiquity of the crystalline rocks of Gallicia, is affirmed on the authority of M. Schultz, who has made a geological map of that province, and is completing a beautiful map of the Asturias. The tracing of Silurian rocks into the Toledo mountains, is due to the zealous researches of M. Casiano de Prado, to whom we also owe the proofs 396 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. A glance at the map shows that the Peninsula is marked by dominant chains of mountains more or less parallel, which, trending from west-south-west to east-north-east, are separated from each other chiefly by enormous basins of tertiary age that lie at much lower levels. Let us first say a few words on the Guadarama, the chief central ridge of the kingdom, which passes to the north of Madrid. Casiano de Prado, the zealous Spanish geologist, who is charged with the execution of the geological map of the province of Madrid, has shown that the gneiss and other crystalline schists witli subordinate limestones, are pierced by granites, and being much altered, rise to heights exceeding 7000 feet. These are flanked by schists and silicious sandstones, which this author refers to a Lower Silurian age, because they contain a fucoid, Cruziana or Bilobites, like that which occurs in rocks of this age in France and Britain. True Silurian rocks of the lower division, and more clearly deter- minable as such by their fossils, occur in the Sierra Morena, and partially in the mountains of Toledo and those of Arragon. In cross- ing the Sierra Morena from Almaden on the south to Cordova on the north, M. de Verneuil recognized an ascending order. The inferior strata consist of schists and some intercalated dark lime- stones, with quartzose sandstones ; the latter not unlike the British Stiper Stones. (See p. 36.) These, being the hardest and least decomposable portion of the strata, form the summits or peaks of the low ridges, and clearly exhibit the strike or range of the masses, which is from east by north, and to west by south. The cele- that the quicksilver mines of Almaden are in Lower Silurian rocks. Many of the fossils (chiefly Devonian) from the North of Spain were first found by M. Paillette, whose description of the rocks is given in the Bullet. Geol. Soc. France, vol. ii. p. 439. A sketch of a geological map of Spain was also published by M. Esquerra del Bayo in Leonhard and Bronn's Jahrbucb, 1851. In his last excursion M. de Verneuil was accompanied by M. Collomb, who has also given a sketch of the general views they then acquired of the structure of tbe peninsula, in the Bibliotheque Universelle de Geneve. Chap. XV.] SILURIAN ROCKS OF SPAIN. 397 brated mines of quicksilver of Almaden occur at the foot of one of the quartzose ridges of this age, as determined by M. Casiano de Prado.* The Lower Silurian rocks of the Sierra Morena range eastwards into Murcia, where they occupy the largest portion of the mountainous tracts of that province. They have recently been de- scribed by M. Pellico, who states that they are much metamorphosed, and are only recognizable through their large ill-preserved Ortho- ceratites and certain corals. There, the Lower Silurian limestones are the sites of some of the richest mines, particularly near Cartha- gena, and also in the Sierra Almagrera, so famous for its ores of lead and silver, f The fossils found in the Sierra Morena and the Toledo Mountains occur usually in black shivery schist, with occasional graptolites of species well known in Brittany, Normandy, and Bohemia, The most prevalent fossil is perhaps the Calymene Tristani ; but recently many other well-known French forms of trilobites have been detected J, including Illsenus Lusitanicus ? or I. Salteri ; Asaphus nobilis ; Caly- mene Tristani ; C. Arago ; Dalmannia socialis, and D. Phillipsi, Barr. ; Trinucleus Goldfussi, Barr. ; Homalonotus (Plesiocoma) rara; Placo- paria Tournemini ; Orthoceras duplex ; Bellerophon bilobatus ; Re- donia Deshayesiana ; &c. Now, whilst nearly all these species are also found, as has been stated, in the slaty schists of Angers and Vitre, in France, which the French geologists have named and mapped as Lower Silurian, * The mercury of Almaden is said not to occur in veins, but to have impreg- nated the vertical strata of quartzose sandstone associated with carbonaceous slates. The association of mercury with such rocks is still more remarkable in the Asturias, where mines of mercury are worked in coal strata. f It is most probable, that the still more metamorphosed rocks of the Sierra di Gador and Sierra Nevada, with their limestones and rich lead mines, are of the same age. I In an examination by Casiano de Prado, Eusebio Sanchez, and E. de Ver- neuil. 398 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. several are identical with Bohemian species, published as of the same age by Barrande. It is also well worthy of notice, since the general type of the fossils is so iimch that of central Europe, that the very common British species Bellerophon bilobatus, and the remarkable cephalopod Orthoceras duplex (so characteristic of the Lower Silurian fauna of Scandinavia and the North of Europe) should also be found, as M. de Verneiiil remarks, in this southern parallel. Some of these Silurian fossils were first discovered by M. Casiano de Prado, near Molina, in Arragon. They have subsequently been there traced by M. de Yerneuil, and also along the eastern borders of New Castile, where they occur in black graptolite schists, which jut out from be- neath the secondary deposits. These Silurian schists have further been followed by the same author in the mountains of Checa, Horca, Origuela, and Monterde. If any Upper Silurian rocks can be said to exist in Spain, they are only, as in France, thin courses of black schist, with spheroidal, calcareous concretions in which Graptolltes occur, together with the Orthoceras Bohemicum and O. styloideum of Barrande, and the British species Cardiola interrupta. Such rocks, which are feebly exhibited in parts of the Sierra Morena, are also seen on the south flank of the Pyrenees, near Ogasa and St. Juan de las Abadesas, where they are recognized* by the presence of Cardiola interrupta and Orthoceratites. It is also supposed that a band of silicious lime- stone pierced by elvans, or granitic dykes, and which extends along the south side of the chain from Gerona, by Hostalrich, to Barcelona, may be referred to the same age, Orthoceratites having been found in it near the last-mentioned city, f * By M. de Verneuil and M. de Loriere. The fossils near San .Juan de las Aba- desas were discovered by M. Amalio Maestre ; they have been quoted by Prof. Leymerie, from ne£ir St. Beat on the north side of the Pyrenees, and exist also in Sardinia. t By i\Ir. Pratt, F.1\.S., who has successfully explored large tracts in Spain, Chap. XV.] DEVONIAN ROCKS IN SPAIN. 399 Devonian Rocks in Spain. — Devonian rocks are developed in the Sierra Morena north and south of Almaden, occurring in several repetitions troughed by Lower Silurian rocks, the fossils lying gene- rally in sandstones, or in small bands of impure limestone. The most characteristic species are, Productus subaculeatus ; Leptaena Duter- trii; Spirifer Verneuili ; S. Archiaci ; S. Bouchardi; Orthis stria- tula ; Terebratula reticularis ; T. Orbignyana ; T. concentrica ; Pha- cops latifrons ; &c. AH but one (Terebrat. Orbignyana) of these are common fossils at Boulogne ; and there are many others which are well known in French and German localities, besides some species peculiar to Spain. In the southern parts of Cuenca, near Hinarejos, de Ver- neuil and Collomb also detected deposits containing Devonian fossils, including the broad-winged Spirifer of the lower beds of the Khine* : and, last summer, these authors discovered the same deposits at the eastern extremity of the Guadarama range between Senianza and Atienza. Whilst the eastern part of the Sierra Cantabrica, extending west- wards from the high road from Leon to Oviedo, is composed of quart- zose and schistose rocks supposed to be of Silurian age (though no fossils have been detected), the medial part of this chain presents a very rich development of Devonian deposits. These rocks consist of red sandstone, shale, and grey limestones, which, owing to power- ful dislocations, assume bold and peaked forms, which are visible chiefly in the Asturias, the Pyrenees, and Catalonia. For his notice of the Ortho- ceratites, see Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. viii. p. 270. * M. de Yerneull has identified nearly 80 Devonian species, from Sabero in Leon, and from Ferrones, and Aviles, in the Asturias, which ought, he says, to be places of pilgrimage for all collectors. Of the works on this region, see, 1st, " Resena geognostica de principado del Asturias, vistazo geolog. sobre Cantabria," per G. Schulze, Insp. Gen. de Minas. 2nd. "Recherches sur quelqu'unes des roches des Asturies, et les Fossiles qu'elles contiennent," par Paillette, De Vern. et D'Archiac. Bull. S. G. Fr., 2nd series, vol. ii. p. 439. " Sur les Env. de Sabero (Leon)," par Casiano de Prado et de Verneuil. Bull. S. G. Fr., 2nd ser. vol. vii. p. 137. 400 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. at great distances from the plains of Castile. They are as prolific in mineral wealth as in organic remains ; the iron of Mieres and Sa- bero being extracted from them.* Thanks to the labours of Schultz, Casiano de Prado, Paillette, de Verneuil, and d'Archiac, the re- spective formations of these countries are now becoming much better known. Carboniferous Rocks of Spain. — Proceeding to the east, the Devo-- nian rocks of the Sierra Cantabrica are succeeded in the Asturias by the richest coal-field in Spain. Its lower beds consist of massive lime- stones, so resembling the Devonian rocks on which they lie, that except for their respective fossils they could with difficulty be separated. The fossils are, however, decisive of the superior rock, for among them are several well-known British species of Productus, such as P. semi-reticulatus, together with Spirifer Mosquensis, and even Fu- sulina cylindrica, the foraminiferous shell so characteristic of the carboniferous limestone of Russia. Above these masses, beds of coal first begin to alternate with other and smaller courses of lime- stone ; so that here, again, as in Scotland and Pussia, the carbona- ceous portion is subordinate to the lower members of the group. Then follow conglomerates and sandstone with fossil plants, which are said to have a thickness of ten thousand feet, and which, pro- bably representing the millstone grit of Britain, are here copiously charged with coal. About eighty beds of coal have, in fact, been recognised in strata for the most part vertical. The limestones that form the inferior limit of these carbon- iferous deposits, truly vindicate the propriety of the old Eng- lish name Mountain Limestone; for they rise to the highest points of the Cantabrian chain, and constitute the mountains of Cabrales and Cobadonga, as well as the peaks of Europa. They * Thougli the coal of Sabero is apparently included in Devonian rocks, M. Casiano de Prado thinks that this appearance may be due to inverted folds of the strata ; so much has this tract been convulsed. Chap. XV.] CARBONIFEEOUS ROCKS. — SPAIN. 40i also advance to the sea near Ribadesella, and penetrate on the east into the provinces of Santander and Palencia.* The carboniferous deposits of the Sierra Morena range along the southern part of that chain. Like similar formations in the north of Spain, their lower beds generally contain limestones, in which occur the same species of Productus and other marine fossils that are known in many other regions. The coal is chiefly associated with overlying conglomerates and sandstones : some of it, however, as in the Asturias, is in the calcareous series. The best coal-fields of this southern region are near Seville, and in the neighbourhood of Belmez, between Almaden and Cordova : the strata are highly inclined. On the flanks of the crystalline schists, probably metamorphic, which form the Sierras east of Burgos, towards Escaray and the Moncayo, there are also masses of sandstone and shale, with im- pressions of coal plants and traces of coal, associated, as in the other Spanish coal-fields, with a few marine fossils. These rocks are only mentioned to show, how generally the same palseozoic succes- sion has prevailed all over the peninsula, before the country was thrown up into those ridges which now form the lines of separation between its different provinces. Whatever be their direction or inclination, the Silurian, Devonian, and Lower Carboniferous rocks of Spain have all been conformably, and apparently simultaneously elevated, as in France. The existence of Permian rocks in Spain is very doubtful; no fossils of that age having yet been found. Led, however, by the analogy of rocks and stratigraphical indications. Professor Naranjo y Garza has referred to that formation the red magnesian limestone and the gypsiferous marls of Montiel and of the lakes of Ruidera, the * During the summer of 1852, MM. de Verneuil, Casiano de Prado, and Loriere ascended one of the highest of these peaks of Mountain Limestone, and found, by barometrical observation, that it was 2500 metres, or about 7750 English feet, above the sea. It was covered with snow on the 1st August. T> D 402 SILUEIA. [Chap. XV. soarces of the river Guadiana. In the same group this author in- cludes the famous cave of Montesinos in La Mancha, which, in Cervantes' immortal work, Don Quixote is made to explore. Siluriafi and Carboniferous Deposits in Portugal. — Geologists are indebted to jMr. Daniel Sharpe for nearly all that they know of the real structure and succession of the sedimentary rocks of the kingdom of Portugal, whether of palaeozoic or secondary age.* Of the former, the only examples pointed out in previous years, — though probably many more will be detected, in addition to another case to be presently noticed, — occur at Yallongo, in the immediate environs of Oporto. There, the Lower Silurian rocks, precisely of the same mineral type as those of France and Spain, and including the same fossils, together with two or three British forms and some new species, rise up in highly inclined and vertical strata ; and, as at Angers and other places, are quarried for roofing slates. An anomalous arrangement of the lower and higher deposits, is, however, there apparent, which is at variance with the facts observed in other parts of the world. The coal-field of Vallongo, which has supplied a considerable portion of the city of Oporto with coal, and in which are certain plants not distinguishable from those of the Carboniferous era, dips under the Lower Silurian schists with their characteristic trHobites I Xow, if this had been really the normal position of the plant-bearing strata, we should have to believe in the existence of a terrestrial flora before the Lower Silurian formations were accumulated, — a flora composed of the same vegetation as that which, in other regions, we find only when we reach the Upper Devonian deposits, and approach to the horizon of the great coal- fields. Believing fuUy in the accuracy of !Mr. Sharpe's sections, I think that, however, from his own good description of this district and the adjacent tract, we may without difficulty surmise how this apparent anomaly has been brought about. The Lower SUurian rocks and the contiguous coal strata (for the coal is not found within * See Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc- London, vol. v. p. 142. Chap. XV.] PALEOZOIC BOCKS. — PORTUGAL. 403 the body of the lower slates) are both situated between two ranges of eruptive rocks ; the one on which Oporto stands being of granite, and the other, to the east, of syenite. On the flanks of the granite of Oporto, micaceous schists abound, which, if metamorphic, may be of any age. But, even if these be of ante-Silurian date, we have simply to imagine a trough of coal, of the true carboniferous date, placed between these schists, on the one hand, and the clay-slates with Lower Silurian fossils, on the other, and then by a movement, of which we have many well authenticated examples both in Europe and America, this trough has been placed in an inverted and dis- located position. The enormous length of time which must have elapsed between the accumulation of the Lower Silurian and the formation of the Devonian rocks, and during which interval we have no trace of land plants having appeared, forbids us, indeed, to adopt the view of an infra- Silurian coal-field, until we have exhausted every other means of explaining the anomaly. Thus, the plications of the strata in Belgium, as delineated by M. Dumont, those in Westphalia mentioned in this volume, or those in North America, described by the Professors Rogers, explain how strata really inverted in one place, may be followed until they resume their regular order. Wedged in as these Silurian and Carboniferous masses of Portugal are, between two flanking parallel ridges of eruptive rock, it was no doubt diflScult to detect their regular order ; though, even in describing a transverse section from Oporto to Aveiro, Mr. Sharpe himself states, that clay slates lying on gneissose and micaceous schists, are surmounted by carbonaceous shale and red sandstone. This is, I conceive, the natural order: because even in the adjacent districts of the north of Spain, to which the author first pointed attention, as being likely to contain Silurian rocks, there are no traces whatever of anthracitic coal-fields beneath or as- sociated with such ancient rocks ; all the carboniferous deposits of 404 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. that region being, as previously stated, in their usual and normal position. Again, after these pages were written, Mr. Sharpe himself com- municated to the Geological Society of London* the discovery of fossils and other important observations made by M. Carlos Ribeiro, which show the prolongation of the same axis of Silurian rocks from north-north- west to south- south-east, far beyond the Douro. The rocks in question form, in fact, the crest of the Serra de Busaco, on which Wellington and Massena first tried their strength, and thence extend to the south-south-east beyond the river Mondego f into the Serra de Mucella. During the greater part of their course, these Silurian rocks are surrounded or flanked by older unfossiliferous masses, consisting of mica and chlorite schists with clay slate, &c. These crystalline rocks are at once followed by dark brown indu- rated shales, somewhat slaty, which abound in Lower Silurian fossils, among which Mr. Sharpe has recognized numerous species of Leptaena and Orthis, with trilobites, many of them previously un- described. This author has, however, identified the most charac- teristic of the trilobites with species well known elsewhere ; Trinu- cleus Pongerardi, Rou., Calymene Tristani, and C. Arago of Brittany, and Phacops socialis of Bohemia ; so that this lower fossil rock of Busaco is, obviously, in Portugal, as it is in France and Spain, the oldest zone with fossil remains, and the same which Mr. Sharpe described at Vallongo near Oporto. It is surmounted, and chiefly along the middle of the ridge of Busaco, by a band of hard ochreous shale, frequently altered by eruptive masses of greenstone trap, and generally breaking up into prisms, the bedding being scarcely distinguishable. It is probably equivalent to the sandstone * Quart. Geol. Journ. vol. ix. p. 13o. t At the mouth of this river, and at the age of sixteen, the author of this work, then an Ensign in the 36th regiment, disembarked (August 1st, 1808) "from a boat alongside of that which conveyed Sir Arthur TVellesley, the future illustrious Wellington. Chap. XV. J PALAEOZOIC KOCKS. — SAEDINIA. 405 of May in Normandy. This rock is full of small corals, such as Favosites fibrosa, besides species of Keteporee, also many species of the simple plaited Orthides, and some species of trilobites common to the subjacent deposit ; the whole of the evidence proving clearly, that it is simply a superior member of the Lower Silurian group. Again, the uppermost of these Silurian rocks in Portugal is pre- cisely what we have been considering in Spain and France ; viz. a blueish shale or argillaceous schist, containing the well-known British species Cardiola interrupta and Graptoiites Ludensis, with numerous crushed specimens of orthoceratites and other mollusks; fossils which, according to Mr. Sharpe, are referable to the Wenlock shale or inferior portion of the Upper Silurians. Now, all these Silurian rocks are overlaid unconformably by a de- posit of true carboniferous age, the shales and sandstones of which are full of ferns and other plants, of species common in the coal deposits of France and Germany. Thus, when traced out, the true order of the north of Portuo-al is the same as that of other regions. Sardinia, — Extending our inquiry eastwards from Northern Por- tugal and Central Spain, to like parallels of latitude on the other side of the Mediterranean, we again meet in Sardinia with a similar succession of palaeozoic deposits. Geologists owe this determination to the researches of General Albert della Marmora, so long favourably known to geographers for his beautiful topographical map of that island. Judging from certain Orthidae and Orthoceratites, which this author sent to me in the year 1848, I have for some years had no doubt that Silurian rocks existed in Sardinia, as laid down by Collegno, in his geological map of Italy. I have since been in- formed by M. Barrande, who has personally inspected the rocks and fossils in the southern part of the island, near Flumini Maggiore, that in his opinion both Lower and Upper Silurian are there present. In anticipation of a work by General della Marmora which is about to appear, accompanied by an elaborate map, it may be stated, that 406 SILURIA. [Chap. XV. some of the fossils collected by him and his assistant M. Vecchi, which were submitted to Professor Meneghini of Pisa, have been identified with well-known Lower Silurian forms; such as Orthis Lusitanica, Sharpe ; 0. testudinaria and 0. vespertilio, Sil. Syst. &c. Other fossils are, on the contrary, Upper Silurian types, such as Orthoceratites ibex, O. gregarium, Sil. Syst. (?), and several others, besides Cardiola and Avicula.* General della Marmora has informed me, that all these rocks and the metamorphic masses with which they are associated, are distinctly surmounted by strata containing anthracitic coal, charged with many of the same species of fossil plants which prevail in the old coal deposits of other regions. Thus, among the plants from Seni and Sculo, Professor Meneghini has recognized Pecopteris arborescens ; P. dentata; P. unita; P. polymorpha; P. hemiteloides, and several others ; with species of the genera Odontopteris, Neuropteris, Sphe- nophyllum, Annularia, Asterophyllia, Sigillaria, Syringodendron, and an abundance of the well-known Cakmites Suckowii. In fact, the strata in which these coal plants occur, and which terminate downwards in conglomerates t> rest in completely discordant positions on the older rocks, and in this highly altered tract are covered by dolomites of the Jurassic age. The order of the inferior strata in Sardinia is, therefore, the same as elsewhere, and is quite subversive of the idea that any true old coal plants existed during the Silurian or lower palseozoic era. * It is right to state that whilst he has seen unquestionable upper Silurian fossils from Sardinia, which on the part of General della Marmora I submitted to him, M. de Verneuil is of opinion, that some of the fossils (of which, however, he only saw drawings) are of Devonian age. It is, indeed, probable that the succession will eventually be found to be similar to that of Spain. + See my Memoir on the Alps, Apennines, and Carpathians. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond., vol. v. p. 157., and particularly its translation into Italian by Professors P. Savi and Meneghini, entitled " Struttura Geologia delle Alpi, degli Apennini e dei Carpazi," followed by their " Considerazioni sulla geologia della Toscana" (Firenze, 1850), in which these distinguished Italian geologists announce the important discovery of old Carboniferous formations in the hills near Volterra. Chap. XV.] PALAEOZOIC OF ALPS AND APENNINES. 407 Schists and conglomerates, though not so carbonaceous, but con- taining similar plants with those of Sardinia, have indeed been de- scribed by Professors Meneghini and Savi, in the older rocks of Tuscany.* This fact, which was unknown when I published upon the Alps and Apennines, is most important, and leads us to infer, that the traces of coal which are associated with certain land plants in parts of the Western Alps, are also of the old Carboniferous age. For, the conglomerates and schists with which such plants are associated in the Alps are precisely the same rocks as the ^verrucano' and schists of Sardinia and Northern Italy, which lie beneath all strata of Tri- assic, Liassic and Jurassic age. ' It has, indeed, been already stated, that rocks containing fossils which are truly of Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous species, occur in the Austrian or Eastern Alps. With this fact before us, and looking to the prodigious amount of metamorphism, dis- location, and convolution to which the component parts of that chain have been subjected, particularly in their extension to the west, we can have little difficulty in imagining how the Silurian and Devonian strata have there passed into a crystalline state ; while the sole remnants of the carboniferous rocks, identifiable through their organic remains, are the plant-bearing conglomerates and schists of the Valorsine and of the tracts around Mont Blanc. * As long as the question seemed to me doubtful, it was my duty to state, after my own survey, that the apparent intercalation of the coal plants in the Tarentaise, among beds containing belemnites, was so striking, that M. Elie de Beaumont was fully justified in his original conclusion. When that eminent geologist reasoned on this apparent intermixture of old coal plants with Jurassic belem- nites, the phenomena of the rapid interplication of strata of very dissimilar ages, and the entire reversal of order in certain tracts, had not been sufficiently delineated. I cannot now admit, that there is any evidence to disprove the inference that the old Carboniferous Flora, which began to prevail in the Devonian period, expired at the close of the Permian deposits. The fauna and flora of the palaeozoic rocks are, therefore, entirely in harmony. D D 4 408 CHAPTER XVL SUCCESSION OF PRIMEVAL ROCKS IN AMERICA. ORDER OF THE PALEOZOIC STRATA IN SOUTH AMERICA, THE UNITED STATES, AND BRITISH NORTH AMERICA. All the evidences which the researches of geologists have brought to light, indicate a wide diffusion of similar groups of animals over the globe during the primeval periods. A striking proof of this lies in the fact, that the palaeozoic fossils which we have followed over the various countries of Europe, are found to have their exact equivalents in the continent of America. Although the science of the United States has afforded the chief means by which this parallelism has been worked out, I cannot commence even this slight sketch of the older transatlantic rocks, without first alluding to that masterpiece of natural history, the work of Humboldt, wherein he gave to mankind a comprehensive view of the structure of the chain of the Andes, — the main axis of the western continent. The oldest of those slaty and quartzose formations, so eloquently described by the illustrious traveller, have subsequently been re- ferred, through their organic remains, to the Silurian rocks. Follow- ing up the inquiries of his precursor, M. Alcide d'Orbigny has shown, in maps and sections, as well as by elaborate descriptions*, * See Voyage dans TAmerique Meridionale, tome 3me, Partie Geologique, Paris, 1842. In justice to my friend, Mr.Pentland, so well known to geographers by his measurements of the high peaks of the Peruvian Andes, around the lofty lake of Titicaca, let me say that he was the first person who made me acquainted with the occurrence of Silurian trilobites in the slaty rocks of this chain. Chap. XVI.] SUCCESSION IN AMERICA. 409 that these slaty rocks contain the fossil sea-weed Cruziana (or Bilo- bites), with Graptolites, Lingulas, Orthidae, and trilobites of the genera Asaphus and Phacops (Calymene). He has further pointed out, that these Silurian masses are succeeded by sandstones and silicious strata of Devonian age, and these by limestones and other rocks, charged with fossils of the Carboniferous era. The Silurian slates and schists form enormous bands ; and examples of them may be well seen on the declivities of the plateau of Bolivia, as well as on the flanks of the Cordillera, extending from Sorata to Illimanni. They are, in most parts of their range, in a metamorphic state ; and in this form extend from Chili, on the south *, to the Rocky Mountains and the Sierra Nevada on the north. Even in Texas they have been recognized by F. Roemer.f Including the quartz rocks which are associated with them, they constitute the chief matrix of the gold and other metals, so. extensively worked along this great chain. (See next Chapter.) It has been suggested, that the huge bands of stratified quartz rocks described by Humboldt may be the equivalents of the sandstones termed Devonian by D'OrbignyJ, and in which that author detected various characteristic fossil shells. But, whilst in the absence of sufficient proof, doubts may be entertained as to whether these sandstones and quartz rocks of the Andes may be of Upper Silurian rather than of Devonian age, there can be no hesitation in referring the next deposits in ascending order to the Carboniferous or true Upper Palaeozoic group. At numberless places, limestones have been observed charged with well-known carboniferous types. Several of these, such as Productus Cora ; Spirifer striatus ; Athyris Roissyi, &c., are specifically identical with forms that characterize the strata of this era in Europe and other parts of the globe. And as these rocks are associated with, or followed by, accumulations of coal, the general relations of the series are clearly similar to those of other countries. * In the admirable work on "South America," by Mr. Charles Darwin (1846), the only palEeozoic fossils alluded to are those of the Falkland Islands (Silurian ? and Devonian), though it is probable that some of the clay-slates, &c. in the chain of the Chilian Andes, to which he adverts, are also of similar age. f Koemer. Texas, und die physischen, &c. 1849. J See Cordier. " Rapport a TAcademie Royale des Sciences sur les resultats scientifiques du Voyage de M. Alcide D'Orbigny dans I'Amerique du sud, pendant les 8 annees depuis 1826 jusqua 1833." 1842. 410 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. We now know, therefore, (and the recent explorations in Cali- fornia, Oregon, &c., have confirmed the view,) that sedimentary- deposits of Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous age constitute the loftiest ranges and metalliferous plateaux of the American continent. These were, in ancient times, perforated by granites, porphyries, trachytes, and other eruptive matters ; and in the modern era are in some localities the seat of active volcanic forces. To bring, however, the older formations of America into an accu- rate parallel with those of Europe, we must quit the chain of the Andes, and the high grounds of Mexico, and turn to the eastern side of North America. In that region the older strata have been com- paratively exempted from igneous disturbances, and as the arrange- ment of the strata is symmetrical, men of science have been able to demonstrate the order of succession to be the same as that of which numerous proofs have been recited in the preceding pages. Many of the crystalline rocks of North America, composed of granites, porphyries, and other igneous masses, or of stratified gneiss, mica, and chlorite schists, and marbles, are unquestionably more ancient than the oldest rock to which the term Lower Silurian can be applied. For such rocks are seen in Upper Canada (just as in Scandinavia) to be the base on which the oldest of the fossiliferous formations rest — a subject to which we shall return in the sequel. A glance at the geological map of North America by Lyell, as deduced from the various works of the United States' geologists, or at the map of Marcou which has just been issued, will show to what extent these ancient crystalline rocks are spread out along the eastern side of the continent. They there range from S. W. to N. E. along the flanks of the Apalachian and Alleghany chain ; i. e. from South Carolina to Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Maine : they also occupy large spaces, chiefly along the eastern sides, of the British colonies of Nova Scotia, Newfoundland*, and New Brunswick. * See Jukes's General Report of the Geological Survey of Newfoundland, in 1839 and 1840, with map and sections. Chap. XVI.] SUCCESSION IN NORTH AMERICA. 411 Similar granitic rocks, and on an equally grand scale, trend from Lower Canada on the east, to Lakes Superior and Winnipeg on the west, forming a broad low watershed recently termed the Lawrentine Mountains.* It is on the western flank of the Apalachian chain, and to the south, north, and west of the Lawrentine Mountains, that the palaeozoic formations are exhibited. They consist of Lower and Upper Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous rocks, and are repeated in broad undulations, forming basins of a grandeur in extent unknown, as yet, in any other part of the world excepting Russia. In this way they occupy large portions of the southern and western states of Alabama, Tennessee, Arkansas, Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, &c., as well as the newly settled territories of Iowa, Minnesota, and Wisconsin. Such deposits range, too, along the southern side of the great chain of lakes, and are spread over large tracts of New York, Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia, where their stratigra- phical features have been ably and elaborately worked out, and their organic remains described, by American geologists. These native authorities have honoured my labours by assimilating their lower fossiliferous rocks to my Silurian System ; whilst all my contemporaries t who have gone from Europe to explore the United * See History of Canada, by Mr. Fox Garneau. t See Bigsby, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lend. 2 ser. vol. i., and Quart. Journal Geol. Soc, vol. viii. p. 400. ; Featherstonhaugb, Reports on the Countries between the Missouri and Red Rivers, and of Wisconsin, &c. Washington, 1835-6 [My old friend Mr, F. first made known to me the existence of the Silurian series in the United States] ; Lyell, Travels in North America, with general map, 1841-42, London, 1843 ; Lyell's Geological Manual, 3d ed. p. 351. ; Castelnau, Syst^me Silurien de I'Amerique Septentrionale, Paris, 1843 ; De Verneuil, Bulletin de la Socie'te G^o- logique de France, 26 series, vol. iv. Paris, 1847 ; Richardson, Narrative of an Arctic Searching Expedition, 2 vols. London, 1851 ; Logan, Geological Survey of Canada ; Reports to Legislative Assembly, and maps ; Logan with Salter on the Rocks of Lower Canada, Brit. Assoc. Rep. 1852, p. 59.; Quart. Joum. Geol. Soc. London, 2d ser. vol. ix. ; Ferdinand Roemer, Texas und die physischen verhaltnisse des landes, Bonn, 1849, with geological map ; Desor, Bull. Geol. Soc. Fr. 2d ser. vol. ix. p. 342. ; and lastly, M. Jules Marcou, " Geological Map and Description of the United States and British North America," Boston, 1853. This last-mentioned author, a Swiss by birth, has condensed the results of the labours of the numerous American geologists, and has dedicated this work to his friend Agassiz, who has thrown so much new light on the natural history of his adopted country. After a joint personal survey, they have followed a 412 SILUKIA. [Chap. XVI. States, or the adjacent territories, have recognized Silurian rocks, both Lower and Upper, followed by deposits of Devonian and Car- boniferous age. In the Canadas, where Bigsby and others were his precursors, Logan, the director of the geological survey, has mapped enormous tracts both of Lower and Upper Silurian rocks ; whilst K-ichardson, triumphing over all the obstacles of the incle- ment north, has followed Silurian limestones along the western flank of the granitic chain from Lake Winnipeg to the mouth of the Mackenzie river. He has also shown to how great an extent they wrap round the huge granitic nucleus of North America, and form the edges of the continent towards the Arctic Sea. In many of the polar islands, too, Silurian fossils have been detected by the skilful navigators who have sailed in search of Franklin. I shall cull, in the sequel, a few data from some of these British authorities ; but let me first allude to those tracts which, through the labours of American geologists, have been rendered classical in our science, and where the types of comparison have been the most sedulously and accurately described.* The state of New classification which is in harmony with the published opinions of the above-mentioned writers and of the native geologists. The small book and map of Marcou embraces too the facts derived from the extensive new surveys of Dale Owen, Logan, and others. The work also contains a list of all the writers on American geology, together with general transverse sections, and plates of the fossils of each group, from the Lower Silurian or oldest, to the Tertiary or youngest division. It will prove, I doubt not, of great use to all travellers. * My contemporaries in America, whose labours I so highly estimate, will readily under- stand that in a work which is limited to the general history of the palaeozoic rocks, and spe- cially to those of Europe, I have no space to render justice to the numerous able writings which treat of those tracts of the United States or the British Colonies, where such palaeozoic rocks are not developed. Thus, the works of Hitchcock, whose description of the structure of his native state, Massachusetts, and the accompanying map, are models of geological monography, — of Dana, whose insight into the natural history of zoophytes, and whose philosophic reflections on the outlines of the earth, have secured for him a wide reputation, — and the various contri- butions to the excellent volumes of my friend Professor Silliman, — must now be passed over ; although, if general geology were my object, they would be eagerly appealed to. Nor will the reader find in the text, any allusion to the labours of some authors who have been highh' useful in building up the now well-established series of the older formations ; such as Maclure, Eaton, Troost, Emmons, Perceval, Vanuxem, Conrad, Jackson, Foster, Dawson, Thompson, Whitney, Chap. XVI.] ORDER IN THE UNITED STATES. 413 York, for example, presents a noble series of palaeozoic deposits, laid open on the banks of the several rivers which there flow from west to east. Examining these river banks, the geologists of that state have been enabled to describe a detailed order, which is remarkable for its symmetry and unbroken condition from the base of the Lower Silurian to the coal measures included ; the whole being arranged in slightly inclined and conformable strata. It is beyond the scope of this work to endeavour to compare with European deposits all the local subdivisions (about eighteen in number, and of very unequal dimensions) of which the Silurian system, as described by Mr. James Hall, is composed in the state of New York. Independent of these numerous subdivisions, the lower portion of the series is admitted by the American authorities to be divisible, as in Europe, into two groups, each of which is charac- terized by peculiar fossils. Thus, from the " Potsdam Sandstone," or base of the whole fossiliferous series, up to the slates and are- naceous schists overlying the Trenton limestone, the group so composed represents the Lower Silurian. In this view, Lyell, de Verneuil, and Sharpe agree with the United States' geologists. In the lowest of these deposits, at Potsdam, a small Lingula (L. antiqua. Hall) was, for a long time, the only fossil known, except fucoids, and abundant traces of marine worms (Scolithus linearis). Subsequently, foot-prints of a large nondescript animal were dis- covered in rocks of a similar age in Upper Canada, on the north bank of Lake Ontario. In the first instance, those markings were supposed to have been made by the feet of a chelonian reptile. But a further examination of numerous casts taken from the footmarks, and brought to England by the zeal of their discoverer Logan, induced Professor Owen to refer them to crustaceans, — the class of and others. The few works above referred to are necessarily those in which the authors have dilated on the subjects which are specially treated of in this volume, i. e. comparative views of palaeozoic geology. 414 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. animals which is most commonly met with in rocks of this age. This view being now adopted, we have evidence of a gigantic protozoic crustacean, probably allied to the Limulus or king crab. The great mineral distinction between the rocks which imme- diately lie upon this true Silurian base, as compared with those of like age in Britain, is the much greater prevalence of limestone. A calcareous sandstone, called the "calciferous sand-rock," is suc- ceeded by the Chazy, Bird's eye, and Black River limestones, and these are at once followed by the great Trenton limestone with its associated schists (Utica slate and the Hudson River group). In the lowest of these calcareous masses — the Chazy limestone, the peculiar genus Maclurea (see the figure, p. 193.) is found, together with some corals, Bryozoa, and a few Trilobites (Illaenus, Asaphus, &;c.) ; and the limestones which succeed, and are more or less con- nected with it by their organic remains, contain many enormous Orthoceratites, the singular cephalopod genus Gonioceras of Hall, several univalve shells (Murchisonia, Scalites, &c.), besides some OrthidaB, and other brachiopods. The deposit above these, or the Trenton limestone, has been fairly paralleled with the Llandeilo limestone ; and, as in that British formation, the number of trilobites, gasteropods, and brachiopods increases vastly when compared with the inferior deposits. Besides the large Asaphus (Isotelus) gigas, the characteristic fossil of the stratum, Trinucleus concentricus occurs, with the genera Cheirurus, Lichas, Phacops, and Calymene. Among the shells, Orthis striatula (foss. 19. f. 3. p. 185.), Orthis biforatus or lynx {ib. f. 4.), 0. porcata (ib. f. 5.) (occidentalis. Hall), and Bellerophon bilobatus (PI. 10 f. 8.), are all Lower Silurian fossils, and characteristic of the same rocks in Britain, Scandinavia, and Russia. The Lower Silurian character of this limestone is maintained, too, by the presence of numerous species of Lituites, Orthoceratites, and large plaited Orthides, which are like those of Europe, without being identical. Chap. XVL] ORDER IN THE UNITED STATES. 415 The Trenton limestone is overlaid, throughout a considerable tract in North America, by the Utica slates, which are full of their cha- racteristic trilobite Triarthrus Beckii ; and these are covered by a greywacke schist (the Hudson Eiver group) containing many grap- tolites and most of the fossils of the Trenton rock, with some new species. M. de Yerneuil, who has closely examined the collections and visited the localities of the American fossils, has compared them * with those of Europe. He considers the above-mentioned formations, which constitute the major part of the " Champlain division" of the United States' geologists, to be equivalents of the Lower Silurian group f ; and that the graptolite schists of the Hudson Kiver, above which the fossil types of the older era disappear, form the limit between Lower and Upper Silurian. He therefore connects the conglomerates and sandstones of Oneida and Medina with the Upper Silurian, of which they form the base. Conrad would include a part of this series — the Medina sandstone — in the lower division, to which it has a great resemblance in lithological character; while Hall and most other American authors are very distinctly of opinion that the " Clinton group" forms the base of the upper division in the United States. It is characterized, nevertheless, by the typical Pen- tamerus oblongus, which is never found in any of the succeeding strata. His figures, lately published, show that this persistent fossil attained dimensions quite as grand in the old seas of America as in our own country. (See Preface, and pp. 98, 99.) The chief or central mass of Upper Silurian limestone in North * Bull. Soc. Geol. Fr. 2d ser. vol. iv. p. 646. ; a most instructive memoir. f Out of 45 fossil mollusca, chiefly brachiopods, brought home by Sir C. Lyell from the Lower Silurian of North America, 14, or about 30 per cent., were identi- fied by Mr. D. Sharpe as species common to Europe and America. Among these are the common British types, Leptasna sericea, Orthis biforata, O. parva (ele- gantula), Bellerophon bilobatus, &c. See Sharpe on the Palaeozoic Rocks of North America, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. London, vol. iv. p. 151. 416 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. America is that of Niagara, which, unquestionably, is of the same age as that of Wenlock and Dudley in England, or of Gothland in the Baltic. This rock appears to contain a greater number, than the Lower Silurian strata, of fossils identical with those of Europe. Among these are such forms as Calymene Blumenbachii, Homalonotus delphinocephalus, Bumastus Barriensis, Rhynchonella cuneata, R. Wilsoni, Pentamerus galeatus, Orthis elegantula, 0. hy- brida, Orthoceras annulatum, Hypanthocrinus decor us Bellerophon dilatatus. (See chaps. 8 and 9.) Some of the same large corals, also, prevail, as in Europe, — those wjiich may have been capable of forming reefs, such as Favosites Gothlandica, F. alveolaris, and the chain-coral. There are also many peculiar species. The lower formations of the next overlying or Helderberg division, up to the higher Pentamerus limestone inclusive *, constitute (accord- ing to M. de Yerneuil) the probable equivalents of the Ludlow rocks. But the line of demarcation between these deposits and those beneath them is also drawn with difficulty ; as must, indeed, be the case in countries where the succession is symmetrical and undis- turbed. Again, the much greater abundance of calcareous matter in this division than exists in our own Ludlow rocks, and the absence of that muddy and sandy matrix which characterizes those strata in Britain, have necessarily given to the whole group more the character of the Wenlock formation — a feature which, as we have already seen, is dominant in Gothland, Bussia, Bohemia, &c. Devonian Rocks. — The base of the Devonian rocks of the United States has recently been placed lower than it was in the earlier com- parisons with European deposits. Seeing that a mass of sandstones and conglomerates had there been called " Old Red Sandstone," it was natural, in the first instance, for geologists to suppose, that the * These consist in ascending order of the Onondaga Salt group, the Water- Lime group, Pentamerus limestone, Delthyris shaly limestone, Encrinal limestone, and Upper Pentamerus limestone. Chap. XVI.] DEVONIAN ROCKS. — UNITED STATES. 417 Devonian series in North America did not descend far beneath this rock. But judging from the included fossils, such as goniatites, identical with those of the duchy of Nassau in Germany, with Murchisonia bilineata, Productus subaculeatus, Athyris concentrica, and other fossils, M. de Verneuil has included in this group the Chemung rocks, the Hamilton and Marcellus shales, and the CUff limestone of Ohio and Indiana (Corniferous and Onondaga limestones). The last-mentioned contain fossil fishes analogous to those of Scotland, besides some characteristic Devonian shells. Again, the occurrence of an ichthyolite of the genus Asterolepis in the Schoharrie grit of New York, necessarily placed that rock also in the Devonian series; and, finally, Mr. J. Hall agreed with M. de Yerneuil by even including in the same group, the Oriskany sandstone with its large Spirifers, analogous to those of the Rhine — fossils almost un- known in true Silurian rocks. The Devonian base in America is, therefore, similar to that of the Rhenish provinces (p. 367.). As fossil fishes have everywhere proved the most exact chrono- meters of the age of rocks, the occurrence of Asterolepis, a genus common in the lower beds of this epoch in Scotland, and the inter- mixture of other ichthyoHtes, identical with those of Scotland, with shells of the. Eifel and of Devonshire, are to me the most convincing proofs that these diversified deposits in North America (like those of Russia, the Rhenish provinces, and Devonshire) are simply equivalents, in time, of the very grand British deposits called Old Red Sandstone. For it must be recollected, that under this term, and particularly in Scotland, are included conglomerates, sandstones, grey schists, limestones, and flagstones, as well as sandstones of both red and whitish-yellow colours; in all, many thousand feet thick. (Seep. 246., et seq.) A further reason for placing the Oriskany sandstone at the base of the Devonian rocks of New York consists in the clear indications of its having been deposited in excavations of the in- ferior stratum, as explained by Mr. J. Hall. This phenomenon marks- E E 418 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. £^ previous denudation, and the commencement of a new series. M. de Yerneuil further reminds us, that the Pterinaea fasciculata, Spirlfer macropterus, and Pleurodictyum problematicum of America, are fossils typical of the bottom Devonian beds of the Rhine. In one portion of theCanadas, Mr. Logan has estimated the Devonian rocks to have a thickness of 7000 feet ; and in the state of New York they occupy a space more considerable than the Silurian. But this Devonian series of micaceous sandstones and schists thins out, as it passes westwards into the states of Ohio, Indiana, and Ken- tucky, and disappears entirely on the Mississippi, where the carbo- niferous strata repose at once on those of Silurian age. Carboniferous Rocks, — The Carboniferous rocks are, as is now well known, developed in the United States, in basins of vaster dimensions than in any part of Europe. Through their included fossils, both of the animal and vegetable kingdoms, the American strata are absolutely identified with the deposits of like age in Europe. Great masses of sandstone and schists, once considered to be Devonian, and so coloured in early geological maps of the United States, have been shown by M. de Yerneuil to be, from their imbedded fossils, of Carboniferous age. These masses, which are of considerable thickness, form the true base of the carboniferous rocks of North America, and are probably the equivalents of much of the yellow sandstone of Ireland, as well as of certain rocks in "West- phalia, which were formerly classed with the ' Grauwacke,' but are now known to be the inferior carboniferous beds of the Rhenish pro- vinces. (See p. 376.) Next follows the limestone (Mountain limestone of the early English geologists), including many varieties of Productus ; viz. P. semireti- culatus, P. Cora, P.. punctatus, &c., with species of Bellerophon, Goniatites, Spirlfer, and Terebratula, known not only in Britain, and in many parts of the continents of Europe and Asia, but also in lati- tudes extending from the polar regions far to the south of the equator. Chap. XVI.] CARBONIFEROUS ROCKS. — UNITED STATES. 419 The same may be said with regard to the Foraminifera, a group of which few traces occur in the lower palseozoic strata ; for the very- same species (Fusulina cylindrica), which so abounds in Southern Russia, is also found in the carboniferous rocks of N. America. The lamelliferous corals (Zaphrentis, Lithostrotion, Lonsdaleia, &c.) are not absent ; but they are chiefly of species distinct from those of Europe ; and some of the forms of this group most characteristic of the old continent (Syringopora, Amplexus, &c.) appear to be absent from those of the new. It is unnecessary here to dilate upon the vast overlying productive coal fields, which occupying distinct basins of stupendous dimensions, have been described by numerous native authors, and have been so well depicted to us by Lyell and Dawson. But I must advert to the great similarity — nay, identity — between the plants of these vast coal deposits and those of Europe. It is truly a feature highly worthy of the special notice of geologists, that at this early period the same species of gigantic plants were spread over an enor- mous area of the earth's surface, which, from the nature of its vege- tation must, therefore, have been under the same conditions of atmosphere and climate, if not of physical outline. This short notice of the development of the earlier fossiliferous rocks in the United States, cannot be concluded without a special allusion to some recently made important additions to our knowledge. The researches of Mr. James Hall, as recorded in his work on the palaeontology of the state of New York*, have shown that, with increased observation, the diflficulty is great (except for short dis- tances and in limited tracts), in drawing an arbitrary line between the lower and upper divisions of the Silurian System. The thin- ning out or thickening of the subdivisions termed Medina sandstone, and the Clinton and Niagara groups, are accompanied by just the same kind of interlacing and overlapping of the fossil types, * Part VI. vol. ii. 1852, p. 3. E E 2 420 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. which has been observed, to a greater extent, in the British Isles. Several species, says Mr. Hall, known before only in the lower division are now found at the base of the higher group. But, before we can speak of the number of species which range from the Lower into the Upper Silurian, all the older fossils of North America must have been examined and compared, as those of our own country have been. Even, however, in the one state of New York we learn, that Bellerophon bilobatus, Orthis lynx, Stropho- mena (Leptasna) alternata, and some other forms which are common to Europe and America, and are abundant shells in the Lower Silurian, are found in the higher part of the Medina sandstone, which in that country is intimately united with the upper division. The same elaborate work of Mr. Hall must be consulted for the figures of many species of fucoids common to the Medina sandstone last noticed, and the associated Clinton group. Numerous tracks or trails of gasteropods and Crustacea also occur, indicating that the sediment so marked was accumulated in shallow water, or under ebbing and flowing tides, and on sloping shores. To the considera- tion of these data we shall return in the last chapter, in explaining the conditions under which some of the oldest marine deposits were formed. In the mean time, I may be permitted to doubt one only of the many valuable inferences of Mr. J. Hall, — viz. that any fossil fishes have yet been discovered in the lower members of the Upper Silurian rocks, or the Clinton and Niagara limestones of the United States. The supposed fragments of bones or fish defences * in the Clinton deposit are manifestly much too imperfect and too void of structure * Pal., New York, PI. 31. figs. 6 and 7. In speaking of the presence of fi^Ii remains in the Lower Silurian of Britain, Mr. J. Hall has, it would appear, beon misled by what is now known to be an erroneous statement. (See p. 320.) It has been ascertained, that the supposed fish of the Llandeilo or Bala rocks is a zoophyte. No trace of a vertebrated animal, I repeat, has yet been found in any deposit beneath the upper Ludlow rocks. (See p. 205, ante.) CiiAP.XVL] SILUKIAN. — WISCONSm, IOWA, MINNESOTA. 421 and form to be so considered. And, in reference to the more perfect specimens from the Niagara group (Onchus Dewii *), the author must forgive me if I suggest, that it presents good evidence of having belonged to a crustacean, and is very like those so-called fish-defences of the Ludlow rock, which Professor M'Coy has removed to the crusta- cean genus Leptocheles. (See p. 236.) f Particular notice must here also be taken of the survey of the extensive territories of Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota, which, ably conducted as it has been by Dr. Dale Owen, has extended true palaeozoic classification on a broad scale. The area examined by this author and his associates Drs. Norwood and Shurman, is much larger than Great Britain ; and by far the greater portion of its subsoil is referred by them to the Silurian, Devonian, and Car- boniferous rocks. I This magnificent region is traversed by the Mis- sissippi in its descent from the boundaries of British America and Lake Superior, and is included between that mighty river and its huge afiluent the Missouri. Surrounding and supporting an enor- mous carboniferous tract, the older primeval rocks rise out successively in almost horizontal positions. The results of all others which have most interested me, as proceeding from this grand survey, are, first, the * Pal, New York, PI. 71. t Having requested Mr. Salter to give me his opinion on this subject, I subjoin an extract from his letter to me : — * The specimens figured by Mr. James Hall, and referred by him to the defences of fishes, seem at least equivocal. The fragment figured as such from the ' Clinton group,' as well as that doubtfully called ' the rib of a vertebrate animal ? ' are in all probability tubes ofSerpulina ' — the latter certainly is so. The Onchus Dewii, Hall, from the * Niagara ' group, is undoubt- edly one of the hollow crustacean spines, such as were figured in the Silurian System as Onchus Murchisoni, and which Professor M'Coy endeavoured to show was a part of the pincers of some Limuloid crustacean. The more perfect evidence, however, which M. de Barrande possesses, and which he has lately put forth, convinces me that they are the tail-spines of large Phyllopods, somewhat like Dithyrocaris. We are still, therefore, without evidence of any fish below the horizon of the Ludlow rocks.' J This work, following so many other valuable publications, is a proof that the senate, as well as the state governments, have justly appreciated the value of the application of geological science as a prelude to the settlement of a new country. E E 3 422 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. discovery of two bands, containing trilobites, in the lowest Silurian sandstone, and next that the organic forms of these beds are considered to be referable to the primordial zone (Barrande), such as it exists in Bohemia and Scandinavia, or in the ' Lingula flags' of Britain. (See p. 343.) For, we thus obtain proofs, that the Potsdam sandstone, in its extended form, and as exhibited in these western territories of the United States, does really contain the first recognizable group of fossil animals.* The Lower Silurian, so termed and laid down on the map by these authors, consists in its lowest parts of pebble-beds, grits, and sand- stone of red and greenish colours, which begin to alternate upwards with magnesian limestone. Then, in ascending order, the magnesian limestones with green grains (resembling some of the Russian Lower Silurian) predominate, and are in parts oolitic, in other parts quart- zose and cherty. Again, sandstones, usually white, recur, and are surmounted by shelly beds, which, in Iowa and Wisconsin, represent the Trenton limestone of New York, or the Llandeilo formation of Britain. The Upper Silurian rocks are poorly represented, in these un- trodden tracts, by what Dr. Dale Owen terms the Upper Magne- sian Limestone, consisting of beds with corals and Pentameri; all traces of the equivalents of the Ludlow rocks being absent. The Devonian period is, however, clearly defined, particularly by its broad" winged Spirifers ; whilst the carboniferous limestone is so * The Trilobltes of this, the lowest fossiliferous stratum in America (the Pots- dam sandstone), are termed by Dr. Owen,— Dikelocephalus, Lonchocephalus, &c Judging from the drawings, these genera seem to be referable to the same group as Paradoxides. They are associated with Fucoids and Lingulae. M. Barrande informs me that, after studying the work of Dr. Dale Owen, he is convinced, that the author has established in the New World the proof of the existence of the primordial zone of Bohemia and Sweden, and the same order of succession upwards from it into the mass of the Silurian strata, as in Europe. In this view M. de .Verneuil and Mr. Salter also coincide. Chap. XVI.] SILURIAN ROCKS OF BRITISH N. AMERICA. 423 expanded, as to be distinctly referred to the Yoredale series of Phil- lips, in Yorkshire. The western explorations of Captain Stansbury to the Mormon territory and the Salt Lake of Utah, to which an early allusion was made (p. 18.), have further shown us how strata, charged with Devonian and Carboniferous fossils, extend to the edge of the Kocky Mountains, those great northern limbs of the Andes. Silurian and other Palcsozoic Rocks of British North America. — Old sedimentary rocks, similar to those of the United States, range into the British provinces of North America, where, after a long and able survey, Mr. Logan has shown that they follow precisely the same symmetrical and unbroken order, along the northern shores of the Lakes Superior and Huron, as in the contiguous western coun- tries of the United States. They have, also, in their eastern divi- sion, been thrown into the same contorted and occasionally inverted order, as had been indicated by the Professors H. & W. Rogers, along this line, in more southern latitudes. In the opinion of those geologists, the causes of the rapid curvatures and partial inversions, by which younger strata have been so folded, as to pass under those beds which were formed before them, were grand and paroxysmal earthquakes, the greatest intensity of which has been exhibited where the folds are most rapid and numerous. As the intensity of the shock dimi- nished, the strata are supposed to have rolled on in broad and regular undulations, thus resembling the waves of the sea at a distance from the area of strongest vibration. Although I can here simply advert to this ingenious explanation, it is satisfactory to me, as an historian of the older geological series, to find that, by whatever agency such grand contortions were produced, these inverted strata of North America, like those of Europe already spoken of (p. 377.), can be followed, until they fold out from their overturned positions and regain their natural order. This is explained in the uppermost of the two following sections. 424 • SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. Chap. XVI.] N. AMERICAN SECTIONS. 425 In Lower Canada a great dismemberment is seen to have taken place between the Lower Silurian rocks, «, and the Upper Silurian, h ; the latter being conformably succeeded by the Devonian and Carboniferous strata. As in Britain and other countries, this uncon- formity is, however, a local phenomenon ; for Mr. Logan himself assures us, that in another part of this region, just as in the west of the United. States, all the palasozoic rocks, from the Potsdam sand- stone or Silurian base to the coal inclusive, are strictly conformable. The only great break in that territory, i.e. along the Lakes Huron and Superior, is between the Potsdam or lowest fossil rock and the great wwfossiliferous and inferior mass of bluish shales with sand- stones, chert, and limestones, which are estimated at a thickness of about 12,000 feet. These, again, are seen, by following them in that tract in a descending order, to have been unconformably depo- sited on still older rocks, consisting of micaceous and chloritic schists, gneiss, and granitic rocks.* The oldest of these masses have little connection with any rocks which have been spoken of, except in the first chapter of this work ; but the next in ascending order, or the copper-slates and sandstones of the great lakes, have, to a great extent, the same structure as the Longmynd or ^ bottom rocks' of England. They are, in truth, defined as such by Mr. Logan, being termed by him the equivalents of the Cambrian of De la Beche, Kamsay, and the British Govern- * Mr. Logan, who has laid down a most elaborate and valuable geological map of the Canadas, has pointed out some of the chief incidents in the geology of these regions in his Reports of Progress to the Provincial Government. He also pub- lished a succinct view of the whole ascending order in Upper Canada. There, the Lowest Silurian rock does not repose at once on gneiss and granite, as in the above section across Lower Canada, but is separated from such rocks by the unfossiliferous or bottom slaty rocks above noted. In the same memoir Mr. Salter confirmed the views of Mr. Logan with regard to the age of the strata in Lower Canada, and identified many fossils as equivalents of the New York series. See Trans. Brit. Ass. Adv. of Science, 1852, p. 59., and also Quart. Geol. Journ. vol. viii. p. 199. 426 SILURTA. [Chap. XVI. ment Surveyors. In England and North Wales these old slaty rocks contain no limestone, but in North America they are interlaced with it. Again, whilst in Great Britain and Germany these bottom rocks are succeeded conformably by the Lower Silurian, they have been severed therefrom in America, as in France and Ireland, by a grand disloca- tion.* In thus appealing to the conditions in different countries, we learn the impracticability of classifying sedimentary deposits by the lines of fracture and dismemberment alone. But in stating these facts, I beg not to prejudge the question, so ingeniously developed by my eminent friend, M. Elie de Beaumont, concerning the parallel and discordant directions of mountain chains, as typical of certain epochs. The discussion of this topic would require many chapters, and lead me away from the special objects of this work. In Nova Scotia the older palaeozoic rocks have not been traced, but the productive coal formation is there magnificently developed, f In taking a general view of the physical structure of the northern- most portion of America, Richardson the great Arctic traveller, con- siders that, on the whole, the granitic and crystalline rocks of the central and eastern countries of the Hudson's Bay territories are sur- mounted by few other deposits on the west and north, except by masses of Silurian age, and very young tertiary strata. In his graphic description of the structure of Canada, Lyell expresses the same opinion. ^ I seemed,' says he, ' to have got back to Norway and Sweden, where, as in Canada, gneiss and mica schist, and occasionally * M, Jules Marcou speaks of various dislocations, one of the most violent of which, in the States, has taken place between the Potsdam sandstone and the Trenton limestone, a feature never seen in the regions examined by Mr. Logan. The above mentioned Irish unconformity, between Cambrian and Lower Silurian, has just been discovered. — March 1854. t For full descriptions of these rocks, I must refer the reader to memoirs in the Journal of the Geological Society, by Sir Charles Lyell, Mr. Dawson, and Mr. Logan. I would refer specially to the interesting fact dwelt upon by Lyell — the occurrence of a Batrachian reptile (Dendrerpeton Acadianum, Owen) in the erect stump of a fossil tree; and to Mr. Dawson's last memoir. — Q. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. X. p. 1. Chap. XVI.] BRITISH NORTH AMERICA. 427 granite, prevail over wide areas, while the fossiliferous rocks belong, either to the most ancient or to the very newest — to the Silurian or to deposits so modern as to contain exclusively shells of recent species.'* From the western shore of Lake Winnipeg, a limestone with gigantic Orthoceratites (probably of the age of those described by Dr. Bigsby and Mr. Stokes f, from the Upper Silurian of Drummond Island), and the strange fossil Receptaculites, was traced in hori- zontal sheets stretching westwards over four or five degrees of longi- tude. Though this plateau of limestone is separated from the Rocky Mountains by a broad belt of the prairies of the Sasketchewan, the bed of that river is full of limestone blocks which indicate the per- sistence of the rock. After crossing Me thy Portage, in lat. 56|, Richardson again met with extensive limestone deposits. The fossils which were gathered from this tract (Productus, Orthis, Spirifer, &c.) seem, however, to indicate an ascending order into beds of Devonian and Carboniferous age J, particularly in the wide spread of calcareous matter along the Elk and Slave rivers, and upon the banks of the Mackenzie. Where the last-mentioned river skirts the Rocky Mountains, the limestones, more disturbed than in the Winnipeg basin, occupy, says Richardson, inclined and elevated ridges, the chief of which he considers to be Silurian ; — ridges which, on the Great Bear Lake and the Coppermine River, abut against granite. In a letter to myself, he adds, ' I believe the strata of sandstone and limestone on the north coast of America to be wholly Silurian, though fossils are scarce. Towards the mouth of the Coppermine River there are besides magnificent ranges of trap with ores of lead and copper, including much malachite.' * Travels in N. America, vol. ii. p. 124. "j* Bigsby and Stokes, Geol. Trans. 2nd ser. vol. i. pi. 25, &c. Similar Orthoce- ratites were found by Mr. Logan further to the east, in rocks of Upper Silurian age. I A few specimens of the fossils of these rocks are in the British Museum ; they are Upper Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous. Unluckily numerous fossils brought home by Sir John Richardson in 1826 have been mislaid. 428 SILURIA. [Chaf. XVI. To whatever extent it may be found possible to separate the Silu- rian rocks which range along the Rocky Mountains into a Lower and an Upper group, it would at least appear, from the specimens which have been brought home by our naval explorers employed in the Arctic expeditions, that the great mass of the most northern rocks belong to the Upper Silurian group. This is certainly the case, if we judge from the collections made during the voyages of Parry, Franklin, Koss, Back, Austin, and Oramanney, and the private ex- peditions of Lady Franklin, particularly those of Penny and Ingle- field. -The fossils brought home by these commanders, and the officers and gentlemen accompanying them, have been examined and described* by Mr. Salter; and from his scrutiny it results, that the Crustacea and mollusca are very similar to, and some of them identical with, those of Dudley or Gothland. Among these occur Encrinurus laevis, Angelin ; Leperditia Baltica, His. ; Penta- merus conchidium, Dalm. ; Chonetes (Leptaena) lata ? V. Buch ; with Upper Silurian forms of Orthoceras, Murchisonia, Strophomena, Orthis, Rhynconella, &c., besides Encrinites, and very numerous corals, including the chain-coral, the Favosites Gothlandica, and some other species characteristic of this division of the Silurian system. The same inference has been drawn by the geologists who have surveyed the rocks, and the naturalists who have examined the fossils, of the northern edge of the great granitic region of the Lawrentine * Appendix to Dr. Sutherland's Journal of Captain Penny's Voyage in 1850-51. London, 1852, vol. ii. with plates ; see also Quart. Journ. Geol, Soc., vol. ix. p, 313, 1853. The extent to which the limestones of the Arctic regions are charged with Silurian fossils, was shown last year by my requesting Mr. Wy ville T. C. Thomson (now Professor in the Queen's College, Cork) to break up and examine the common ballast brought home to Aberdeen in the Prince Albert, one of the private exploring ships of Lady Franklin. For, although these fragments of limestone were taken without the slightest reference to their organic contents, they were found by that naturalist to contain the following fossils : Rhynconella Phoca, Salter ; Leperditia Baltica, His. ; Murchisonia, 2 species ; Atrypa reticularis ; with fragments of other genera and species of shells and trilobites. Chap. XVI.] ARCTIC SILURIAN FOSSILS. 429 or Canadian Mountains. Their conclusion is, that whilst on the south side there is an inferior succession through crystalline and metamorphic strata into a copious and diversified Lower Silurian, as above explained, the northern or Hudson's Bay territory is chiefly occupied by Upper Silurian limestones. * This inference is based on the occurrence, at the base of the whole fossiliferous series in that district, of a profusion of corals, several of which are characteristic of the Niagara and Onondaga limestones (Wenlock or Dudley), together with the trilobite Encrinurus punctatus, the shells Atrypa reticularis and Pentamerus oblongus, and forms of Ormoceras, and several other mollusca, indicative of the lower portion of the Upper Silurian group. Looking, indeed, to that vast Arctic region, so little accessible to any man of science, the geologist has good reason to be thankful for the knowledge already obtained, which has enabled him to classify the older sedimentary rocks of icy regions, never trodden by civilized man before the present century. In terminating this outline of the succession of the older fossili- ferous rocks of America, let me remind the reader of the vast extent to which this continent is composed of Silurian, Devonian, and Car- boniferous rocks. In the Western hemisphere, as in Europe, the first clear signs of life are met with at the same low horizon in the crust of the earth ; and the same great groups are clearly distinguish- able. We also observe, that fishes, which were only called into ex- istence at the end of the Silurian period, and were of such peculiar forms in the Devonian epoch, become conspicuous in the carboniferous deposits of America, and exhibit many new types, including the re- markable large sauroid fishes of Agasslz. Again, whilst one small, air- breathing reptile has alone been found in the uppermost band of the * Mr. Logan has found that these limestones at the head of Lake Temiscamang include enormous blocks of the sandstone on which they rest ; so that, in all pro- bability, they are littoral deposits. 430 SILURIA. [Chap. XVI. Devonian or Old Red rocks of Britain, the Carboniferous rocks of America, as well as those of Europe, contain larger animals of this class. ThB only essential difference between the elder rocks of the two hemispheres is, that in America no geologist has yet met with any indication of that termination of palaeozoic life, which in Europe is marked by the Permian deposits. It is probable, therefore, that the early sediments of the West, having been raised into the atmosphere, remained for a long time in that condition ; whilst in our countries the same strata continued beneath the waters which sustained the last remnants of primeval beings. 431 CHAPTEK XVIL ON THE ORIGINAL FORMATION OF GOLD, AND ITS SUBSEQUENT DISTRIBUTION IN DEBRIS OVER PARTS OP THE EARTH's SURFACE. Considering the great quantity of gold which has recently been found in distant regions, it may be expected that an author, who during the last ten years has borne a part in the discussions relative to this phenomenon*, should here devote a few pages to so engrossing a topic. Avoiding altogether, for the present, the question, as to the effect which a great abundance of the precious metal may exercise over the destinies of mankind, the views now put forth will chiefly relate to the geological and mineralogical conditions under which it has occurred* As a clear understanding of this point may tend, in some measure, to allay the fears of those who think that gold may be discovered over regions vastly more enormous than the tracts to which it is restricted, certain data and arguments that I have be- fore advanced in detail, are here brought together. Let us first reflect upon the general fact, that whilst all the stratified formations are composed either of crystalline and palaeozoic rocks, or of secondary and tertiary deposits, gold has never been * See Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, pp. 437., et seq. Trans. R. Geogr. Soc. Pre- sident's Discourses, vol. xiv., 1844, 1845, in the first of which the Australian rocks were compared \vith those of the Ural. Trans. Royal Geological Society, Cornwall, 1846, p. 324., et seq., in which Cornish tin miners were incited to emigrate and work for gold in Australia. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, 1849 (Trans, of Sections, p. 60.). Proceedings of the Royal Institution, March, 1850. Quarterly Review, 1850, vol. Ixxxvii., Article Siberia and California," p. 39. Quart. Journ. Geo. Soc. Lond., vol. viii. p. 134. And lastly, " Further Papers on the Recent Discovery of Gold in Australia," presented to Parliament Aug. 16. 1853, p. 43. ; including my correspondence, in 1848, with Her Majesty's Secretary for the Colonies, on Australian gold. 432 SILtJRIA. Chap. XVII.] found in any appreciable quantity in either of the two last-mentioned classes of strata. The vast areas, therefore, which are covered by all the formations younger than those whose relations we have been considering, are excluded from the application of our reasoning ; and every one who lives amid such rocks may at once be assured, that he can never profitably extract gold from them. Having thus cleared the ground, we may first proceed to consider the nature and limits of the rich gold-bearing rocks, and then oflPer proofs, that the chief auriferous wealth, as derived from them, occurs in superficial detritus. Appealing to the structure of the different mountains, which at former periods have afforded or still afford any notable amount of gold, we find in all a general agreement. Whether, referring to past history, we cast our eyes to the countries watered by the sources of the golden Tagus, to the Phrygia and Thrace of the Greeks and Romans, to the Bohemia of the Middle Ages, to tracts in Britain which w^ere worked in old times, and are now either abandoned or very slightly productive, or to those chains in America and Australia which, previously unsearched, have, in our times, proved so rich, we invariably find the same constants in nature. In all these lands, gold has been imparted abundantly to the ancient rocks only, whose order and succession we have traced, or their associated eruptive rocks. The most usual original position of the metal is in quartzose veinstones that traverse altered, palasozoic slates, frequently near their junction with eruptive rocks. Sometimes, however, it is also shown to be diffused through the body of such rocks, whether of igneous or of aqueous origin. The stratified rocks of the highest antiquity, such as the oldest gneiss and quartz rocks (like those, for example, of Scandinavia and the Northern Highlands of Scotland), have very seldom borne gold; but the sedimentary accumulations which fol- loAved, or the Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous (particularly the first of these three), have been the deposits which, in the tracts Chap. XVII.] GOLD IN BRITAIN. 433 where they have undergone a metamorphosis or change of structure by the influence of igneous agency, or other causes, have been the chief sources whence gold has been derived. The British examples, comparatively small in produce as they have been, will be first briefly alluded to ; because the reader can at once refer, in the coloured map of this work, to two districts of Wales wherein gold has been found, and in one of which it is now in the course of extraction. Gold in Britain. — In the Lower Silurian rocks, about ten miles west of Llandovery, at a spot called Gogofau, near Piimp-saint, large veinstones of quartz in slaty masses were cut into by the Romans, who excavated lofty galleries, which are still open. That enterprising people evidently de- rived gold from the portions of the veinstones in which much sulphuret of iron is diffused; since many gold ornaments have been found at the adjacent Roman station of Cynfil-Cayo, with traces of former aqueducts, probably to convey water to wash the gold. Even the stones * and troughs used in grinding the hard matrix are yet visible. In North Wales, where similar but older strata have been more crystallized, and infinitely more penetrated by igneous rocks, gold has not only been obtained in ancient times, but is still found to a certain extent. In Merionethshire some of the older slaty rocks were ten years ago announced to be auriferous by Mr. A. Dean.f The district then referred to, which lies to the north of Dolgelly, and to the north and west of the small river Mowddach, has lately been resurveyed by Professor Ramsay, who has described the precise geological relations and mineral character of several metalliferous lodes, which, though poor in lead and copper, are, more or less, impregnated with gold. J The lodes are subordinate to the * See Silurian System, p. 367. At the time of the publication of that work (1839) I had not visited the Ural Mountains, and was little acquainted with the nature of gold-bearing rocks and the methods employed for the extraction of the metal, or I should at once have recognized as certain, what I only ventured to suggest, that the rock might formerly have been quarried for the gold it contained. Suspecting that some traces of gold might be detected in the pyritous refuse of the quartz rock, I submitted a little of it to the late eminent chemist. Dr. Turner ; but he could not detect any trace of the precious metal. Recently, however. Prof. Warington Smyth, aided by Dr. Percy, has detected a small quantity of gold diffused in the quartz vein- stone. See also Memoirs of the Geological Survey, vol. i,, with an exposition of the various, relations of gold, by Ramsay, E. Forbes, Jukes, Percy, Warington Smyth, Hunt, &c. t Trans. Brit. Assoc. Adv. of Science, 1844, Proc. of Sect. p. 56. X Quart. Journal, Geol. Soc. Lond. (about to be printed). F F 434 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. Lingula flags or lowest Silurian of the Government surveyors, and these slaty and arenaceous rocks being there traversed by trap dykes (including magnetic greenstone), and being also bounded by a large mass of eruptive rock, are much altered, and often in a talcose and chloritic state, with veins of quartz and much disseminated iron pyrites. The principal loca- lities where the gold has been most observed are Cwm-eisen-isaf and Dol-y-frwynog. One of the veinstones at the latter place consists of white saccharoid quartz, in some of which small flakes of gold are distinctly visible to the naked eye. Professor Ansted, who has examined the same gold veins in situ, had reported to me, that at Dol-y-frwynog, the gold is disseminated both in grains and in irregular bands or veins, parallel to the Lower Silurian schists, and contiguous to a poor lode of copper ore ; the whole lying near to the junction of a greenstone with the slaty rocks. The auriferous bands, he says, are made up of numerous threads of quartz and sulphate of barytes, which, besides the grains and flakes of gold, contain crystals of galena and copper pyrites. The gold is partially present to such an extent (he adds), that in a small quantity removed by himself from one of the threads or thin veins (and richer specimens have since been found) the proportion, upon analysis, was that of 60 oz. to the ton ! * At a few places in Cornwall f and Devonshire, gold has been long known to exist in small quantities, both in the matrix of mineral lodes and occa- sionally in accumulations of rolled materials. One of the spots which now promises, as is said, to be most productive, is the Poltimore mine, near North Molton, Devon, where certain schists of the age of the uppermost Devonian or lowest Carboniferous strata are mineralized to some extent, and were formerly worked for copper. There, the matrix or gossan of the lode is suffused by particles of gold, but so minute as to be for the most part invisible to the naked eye. If this condition be found persistent throughout considerable masses of rock, the proprietors may doubtless derive considerable profit from such mines ; particularly when the gold- * As gold often occurs in small strings or threads which, though rich at the surface, are soon lost in the body of the rock, time alone can determine the value of these British mines — i.e. whether some of them are to prove remunerative, now that new processes for extracting the ore have been discovered. f Mr. S. R.Pattison has just read before the Geological Society (February 1st, 1854) a notice on auriferous quartz rock near Davidstow, North Cornwall, the chief gold-bearing mass of which is the gossan of a dyke in a metamorphosed rock of Upper Devonian age, which, mantling round the granite of Roughtor, is also associated with dykes of trap. Chap. XVII.J GOLD IN BR1TAIN\ 435 bearing matrix is friable. On the other hand, the Cornish, coarse, ancient alluvia or gravel, from whence the tin ore has been extracted, as well as other portions of drift in that county, have afforded small portions of gold ; but although some of the largest fragments have been (though very rarely) of the size of a pigeon's egg, none of these superficial accumulations have been considered worthy of exploration. In Scotland, whilst slender traces * only of gold have been perceived in the older crystalline rocks of the Northern Highlands, the metal was for- merly found in the slates of the South of Scotland (Lead Hills), which, like those of North and South Wales, are of Lower Silurian age. There again it is in a region where the strata have been much penetrated by porphyries and other igneous rocks. These south Scottish gold mines, after affording a small sum, in the reign of James the Fifth, were, however, abandoned as soon as the cost of production exceeded the value of the ore extracted.f In Ireland we read the same lesson. It is from the altered lower Silurian schists of Wicklow, which clasp round the eruptive granite of Croghan-Kinshela traversed by hornblendic greenstones, that the gold known in Ireland has been derived, and is still occasionally picked up in fragments which have been detached from the sides of that mountain, or are washed down by the rivulets which descend from the hill.J Now, if any portion of these old slaty British rocks, or their associated eruptive rocks, had been largely penetrated by gold, then most assuredly much more auriferous debris would have been recognized in the local adjacent gravel: — just as it occurs in all really rich gold-bearing lands. But, as no rich auriferous sand or gravel is known in any part of the * Near Loch Erne Head, a metalliferous veinstone on the property of the Marquis of Breadalbane has recently been found to be partially impregnated with gold. The gold occurs in a glossan, contiguous to the junction of trap with crystalline limestone and schist, and is associated with arsenical pyrites and lead ore. f See Harkness on the "Lower Silurian Rocks of Scotland." Quart. Journ. Geo. Soc. vol. viii. p. 396. X The Earl of Wicklow, whose property is in the vicinity of the mountain of Croghan Kin- shela, has collected several ' pepitas ' of this Irish gold, the largest being about two inches long. They are free from quartz or other rocky matrix, and have been picked out of the debris oi: coarse gravel on that slope of the hill where a rivulet descends through the property of the Earl of Carysfort. No veinstone in situ has ever been detected (Mills and Weaver, Trans. Dublin Society) ; and although poor persons have stealthily procured specimens during this century, the quantity has never been sufficient to lead to the belief that really productive diggings could be opened at the Royal Gold Mine of Croghan. Tinstone is said to have been found with the gold here as in Cornwall and other places. (See Fitton, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond., first series vol. i. p. 270. The phenomena are well developed by Prof. Warington Smyth, Records of the School of Mines, &c., vol. i. p. 3., with a map.) F r 2 436 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. British Isles, we may rest satisfied that in our own country, as in many others, the quantity of gold originally imparted to the rocks, was small and has, to a great extent, been exhausted.* Even in Bohemia, which produced so much gold in the Middle Ages, and where the Silurian strata are, as we have seen, (chap. 14.) penetrated by many igneous rocks (and in parts much metamorphosed), there are now no gold works, though other ores (copper, &c.) are profitably extracted; and, just as in the rocky and mountainous tracts of Britain, very few places only can be cited which were auriferous. The Thiiringerwald, and some chains of Central Germany, also anciently afforded a little gold in rare and widely-separated localities j" ; but these regions, as well as the Penin- sula and its golden Tagus, so auriferous in the classical era, have long since ceased to offer any notable quantity of the ore. TTie Ural Mountains. — No country of the world furnishes a clearer example than Russia, of the dependence of gold on certain geological and mineral relations. Her chief European territories are, as has been stated, occupied by slightly solidified, primeval deposits. Under those conditions, and with a total absence of any crystalline rocks, whether of intrusive or of sedimentary and metamorphic characters, * As these pages are going through the press, a work by Mr. John Calvert has appeared, entitled the " Gold Rocks of Great Britain and Ireland," wherein the author (who has recently returned from Australia) holds out incentives to mine largely for the precious metal at home, though he candidly admits that his main suggestions are at variance with the recorded opinions of Sir H. T. De la Beche, myself, and many geologists. The reader who may have attended to this subject will observe, that the chief argument I have employed in the writings adverted to in the note p. 431., to satisfy the public mind, that auriferous sites in the old countries of Europe would for the most part prove slightly profitable only, was that all such works had ceased in former times for want of remuneration. It is foreign to the purpose of this work to analyze theoretical views respecting the difinsion of gold and its associated minerals. Let me, however, say, that whilst I believe the old gold tracts of Europe have been on the whole exhausted of their wealth, there may still be found spots where some profit is attainable. I would farther guard any inferences I have drawn from our previous state of knowledge, by sajing, that ray opinions were formed irrespective of the new discoveries in mechanical science. Crushing machines, and the improved application of mercury may, indeed, liberate a notable quantity of ore from a matrix of apparently slight value, and thus set at nought the experience of ages. Not pretending to enter into this mercantile part of the question, I cling to the belief expressed throughout the text, that, in the long run, gold will mainly be found in the rocks indicated, and will be worked to great advantage only, as during past ages, in the natural debris of those rocks. t The sands of the river Rhine (which drains so vast a rocky region) are in one pai't slightly auriferous, but the cost of extraction of the gold was too great to repay the speculators. Chap. XVII.] GOLD OF THE URAL MOUNTAINS. 437 not a particle of gold has been discovered in them, over an area larger than the rest of Europe. But where the same formations have been thrown up into inclined and broken positions in the Ural Chain, and have there been pierced by numerous eruptive rocks of porphyry, greenstone, syenite, and granite, in association with huge masses of serpentine, the very same deposits, so soft in European Russia, have been hardened, crystallized, veined, and rendered highly metalliferous ; some even of the igneous rocks being also occasionally auriferous. As the rocks in this chain, which separates Europe from Asia, are now known to be similar in character to those of numerous other auriferous ridges in Siberia and the Altai Mountains of Asiatic Russia, the present description may serve to explain the composition of vastly larger eastern tracts. The study of this Uralian Chain has, indeed, already thrown light, not only on the nature of metal- liferous rocks of other countries, but has enabled us to define, within certain limits, the period when they were chiefly impregnated with gold, and also to suggest that, in this region at least, the metal appears to be of more recent origin than the ores of copper and iron with which it is there associated. With a watershed for the most part not exceeding 2000 feet above the sea, their highest peaks rarely rising above 5000 to 6000 feet, the Ural Mountains, extending from north to south through 18 degrees of latitude, are composed of rocks more or less crystalline ; chiefly the metamorphosed representatives of the Silurian and Devo- nian, and occasionally of the carboniferous age. The Lower Silurian strata are, indeed, to be recognized in a crystalline state only. They are chiefly talcose schists, quartzites, and limestones ; whilst the Upper Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous, though often also considerably metamorphosed (the limestones being frequently con- verted into marble occasionally dolomitic), offer here and there traces of their characteristic fossils. The flexures and fractures of the stratified rocks (Devonian and Carboniferous), as they approach the F F 3 438 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. western flank of the altered and metalliferous axis of the chain, have been represented in the view of the gorge of the Tchussowaya, p. 330. The following rough sketch will convey some idea of the wild, central, and mineralized masses which, in the Northern Ural, peer out, here and there, from amid the forests of the gigantic Pinus Cembra. It was taken by myself from the summit of the Katchkanar*, a View from the Summit of the Katchkanar, N. Ural. (From Russia in Europe, vol. i. p. 392.) The snowy mountains seen in the distance to the north, are the much loftier peaks of Konjakofski Kamen, &c. * The following is the sketch of the approach to this mountain (visited, I believe, by no other European travellers) through the forests, as given in the work " Russia and the Ural Moun- tains," vol. i. p. 392. " A large chaotic assemblage of loose angular blocks nov lay around us, from amid which rose the magnificent Pintis Cembra, towering above all its associates, the rocks being overgrown with paeonies, roses, and geraniums. Such stony features alone would have led us to suppose that we were at the foot of the object of our exploration, when in a few minutes the broken and jagged outline of the Katchkanar burst upon our sight under a fiae bright sun and amid the merry song of birds. The dull, wet, and marshy woodlands, were now exchanged for sunshine, and rocks Accustomed as we have been to the wildest features of the Highlands of Scotland and the Alps, we are unacquainted with any scene presenting a finer foreground of abruptly broken rocks, and never certainly had we looked over so grand and trackless a forest as that which lay around us, and from which some straggling distant peaks (those on the north only being still capped with snow) reared their solitary heads." Chap. XVII.] GOLD OF THE URAL MOUNTAINS. 439 rugged pile of stratified and jointed augitic greenstone, highly- charged with magnetic iron. Platinum, as well as gold, has been washed down from the edges of this mountain and carried into the ad- jacent gorges on the east ; though the sources from whence these metals have been drifted into the coarse alluvium, have not been detected. While the traveller who simply crosses the Ural in the partial depression followed by the high road to Ekaterinburg, will scarcely be aware that he has passed over any dominant ridge, the geologist who explores the mountains along their line of bearing, soon per- ceives that, to the north, their crest is marked by lofty and usually snowy summits, as in the preceding drawing. To the south, the central mass near Zlataust, consists of altered sandstone and quartz- ites, forming sharp peaks, that separate Europe from Asia.* Few chains offer more contrasting outlines than are seen upon the European and Asiatic flanks of the Ural. On the former the lime- stones and other stratified rocks are indeed contorted, fractured, and partially altered, as before represented (p. 330.), whilst in the centre, as on the eastern slopes, the masses consist everywhere either of highly altered and crystalline strata, or of the eruptive rocks which pierce them. There only, and particularly where the schists are traversed by veinstones of quartz, or cut by dykes of igneous rocks, has gold been originally imparted in any quantity to the slaty, talcose, and chloritic strata. Though some efforts were made by the earlier Russian miners to extract gold from the solid matrix by underground mining, such a process was not continued ; it having been found infi- nitely more profitable to extract the ore from the broken accumulations of ancient drift, in which the indestructible gold has been carried down to the slopes of the hills or lodged in the higher valleys wherein small watercourses meander. The only work at which subterranean mining in the solid rock is still * See the frontispiece of " Russia and the Ural Mountains." 440 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. practiced, and at a very small profit, is at Berezovsk near Ekaterinburg. There the shaft traverses a mass of apparently metamorphosed and crys- talline matrix, called 'beresite,' resembling a decomposed granite with veins of quartz, in which some gold is disseminated. The syenite of the Peschanka mines, near Bogoslofsk, is likewise impregnated with particles of gold, and the surface degradation of that rock affords profitable washings. Much farther to the east in Siberia, Colonel Hoffman long ago indicated a tract, where the schistose stratified rocks are equally permeated by the small diffused particles of the metal, imperceptible to the naked eye. Considering, however, the practice which has hitherto prevailed, it is from the broken or drifted materials only, that the Uralian gold has been ground out by water mills and collected for use. This is notably the case on the east flank of the chain*, where the mixed and coarse detritus of all the hard rocks has, at certain spots, proved to be auriferous, and in some cases much more so than others ; there being very large tracts indeed where no trace of gold can be detected even in similar detritus. On the east flank of the South Ural (S. of Miask), where the chain is still auriferous, conical igneous rocks have burst out, as represented in the opposite drawing, and constitute a picturesque scene. The low rich grassy grounds around this lake of Aushkul, in the country of the Baschkirs, are, to some little extent, auriferous ; the gold having been derived by debacles of former periods, which have de- nuded the surfaces of the slaty and quartzose chain (as seen in the distance), or the adjacent conical hills of greenstone, altered schists, porphyries, syenite, and serpentine which surround the lake. The slopes and depressions are partially occupied by the gold-bearing debris.! * The reader must recollect that the superficies of all the localities of the Ural Mountains united, in which gold has been found, amount but to a very small part of the whole chain. Incalculably more is the proportion diminished between rocks which from their nature might be but are not auriferous, and those of similar structure which really contain gold, when we extend researches into Central and Eastern Siberia. Thus, gold- works are only known at one spot in the western side of the watershed, viz., at Chrestovosdvisgensk. It was there that most of the few diamonds found in the Ural chain were detected in coarse ancient drift. They were no longer observed when I visited that place, and thence traversed the wild, wooded chain by the Katchkanar to Nijny Turinsk. See "Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains," pp. 391 —480. et seq. t The rock in the foreground on which we stood is a compound of diallage and serpentine. Chap. XVII.] GOLD OF THE URAL MOUNTAINS. 441 Lake of Aushkul, S. Ural. (From a lithograph, p. 437. Russia and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 359. The Holy Mount of the Tatars is opposite, and the Ural range is seen in the distance.) The extent to which limestones of the carboniferous age have been altered on the eastern flank of the South Ural, is instructively seen at Cossatchi-Datchi, a remote spot visited by my companions and myself, and where also a little gold has been found. Hills of Cossatchi-Datchi. (From Russia and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 439.) The hills forming the background of this sketch, composed of eruptive and is to some extent magnetic; the most striking of the conical mounts is the Holy Hill of the Baschkirs. (" Russia and the Ural Mountains," p. 437.) 442 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. rocks and some old schistose strata, subtend a little basin in which a number of small conical hillocks of limestone, as seen in the foreground, are thrown about. Their form and mineralized condition are probably due to the action of gaseous vapours and change of the original substance ; since not only the traces of bedding are obliterated, but the rock has been rendered fetid and saccharoid ; breaking upon a slight blow of the hammer. In this case the metamorphic action, however it may have been pro- duced, has been just of that degree of intensity, that, whilst in rendering the limestone pulverulent as sugar, it has left numerous organic remains so uninjured, that they are easily removed from the ambient matrix.* At the Soimanofsk mines, south of Miask, great piles of ancient drift or gravel having been removed for the extraction of gold, the eroded edges of highly inclined crystalline limestones have been exposed, which, from being much nearer the centre of the chain than the above, are probably of Silurian or Devonian age. It is from the adjacent eruptive serpentinous masses and slaty rocks, b, that the gold shingle, c (usually most auriferous near the surface of the abraded rock a), has been derived. Diggings at the Soimaxofsk Mutes. (From Russia and the Ural Mountains, vol. i, p. 487.) The tops of the highly- inclined beds a, are, in fact, rounded off, and the interstices between them worn into holes and cavities, as if by very power- ful action of water. Now here, as at Berezovsk (of which hereafter), * After enumerating upwards of thirty species of these fossil shells, mv companions and self thus spoke of them : — " Those alone who have the same respect for a true characteristic fossil as our- selves, can imagine the feelings of delight with which we here found congregated in one natural Siberian storehouse so great a number of shells, some of which we could not distinguish from well-known forms of the mountain limestones of Yorkshire, Westmoreland, and Derbyshire, nor others from species which are abundant in the same formations in Belgium and France ! .... Without this discovery we could not have ventured to affirm, that many other adjacent masses of crystalline limestone immersed among the granites and trappean rocks of these mountains belonged to similar or associated deposits." (" Russia and the Ural Mountains," vol. i. p. 44.) Chap. XVII.] GOLD DIGGINGS. — URAL MOUNTAINS. 443 mammoth remains have been found. They were lodged in the lowest part of the excavation, at the spot to which the small figure of a man is pointing, and at about fifty feet beneath the original surface of overlying coarse gravel c* before it was removed by the workmen from the vacant space under the dotted line. The feeble influence of the streams (n) which now flow, in excavating even the loose shingle is seen at the spot marked o, the bed of the rivulet having been lowered by human labour from its natural level o, to that marked n, for the convenience of the diggers. In sonae spots the alluvium in which the gold occurs is a heavy clay ; in others it is made up of fragments of quartz veins, chloritic and talcose schist, and greenstone, which lie upon the sides of the hillocks of eruptive rocks.* It was from the infillings of one of the gravelly depressions between these elevations south of Miask, that the largest lamp of solid gold was found, of which at that time (1824) there was any record. f The diggings by which the gravel or local drift was cleared away from around the vertical masses of rock whose surfaces have been so much eroded and chan- nelled out, are expressed in the following diagram. No watercourse sufficiently powerful to transport a single block, much less to spread out broad accumulations of such coarse materials, now flows into this upland depression. Nor could the action, during millions of years, of such an agency as that of the puny rivulets, which now meander in parts of the gravel, account for the eroded and highly worn surfaces of the rocks, whether crystalline limestones, quartz rocks, greenstone, porphyry, or serpentine. We are thus necessarily compelled, by numerous evidences, to adopt the belief, that on the Asiatic side of the Ural, as in many parts of Europe, the translation of vast masses of drift was accompanied by powerful * The auriferous shingle, gravel, or sand of the Ural Mountains is poor in per-centage in comparison with what has of late years been discovered in California and Australia. Though very large 'pepitas' ornuggets have occasionally been found, much of the auriferous ground considered worth working in Russia, where labour is cheap, and water power for crushing is every where at hand, would, if situated in Australia or California, be little heeded. t This * pepita ' weighs ninety-six pounds Troy, and is still exhibited in the museum of the Imperial School of Mines at St. Petersburg. 444 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. and long continued aqueous abrasion of the summits and slopes of the adjacent auriferous hills. Gold Diggings at Zareyo Alexandrofsk. a. Ancient rocks consisting of talc schist, with veins of quartz (original matrices of gold), penetrated by concretionary felspar rocks, greenstone, &c. h. Coarse shingle and gravel about twelve feet thick, in which the great " pepita " was found, c. Hills from which the chief debris b has been swept, d. Pyramid erected to commemorate the visit of the Emperor Alexander. Whatever may have been the period when the rock was first ren- dered auriferous, the date of this great superficial distribution of the gold is clearly indicated. For it contains in many places the same remains of extinct fossil quadrupeds that are found in the coarse drift-gravel of Western Europe. The Elephas primigenius or Mammoth, Bos aurochs, Rhinoceros tichorhinus, with gigantic stags, and many other species, including even large carnivores, were, un- questionably, before that period of destruction, the denizens of Europe and Siberia ; and of these the Bos aurochs is the only one which has been preserved to our days.* * The Bos aurochs was probably saved by having inhabited some isolated spot in Western Russia near the forest of Biela vieja in Poland, where the herd now lives, and by having been there locally exempted from the causes of that great destruction which befel their associates. This geological view is fully explained by me, accompanied by an excellent account of the Bos aurochs by Professor Owen. — (" Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains," vol. i. p. 503. etseq.) Chap. XVII.] GOLD DIGGINGS. — URAL MOUNTAINS. 445 This little diagram explains the relations of the coarse auriferous drift with Mammoth bones, as seen at the Berezof mines near Ekaterinburg. Gold Shingle near Ekaterinburg. a. Auriferous rocks in situ. These rocks contain some gold in quartz veins in the mass of a metalliferous lode of soft granitoid composition called, as above said, Beresite, by the Eus- sian miners. It is the only mine in this chain, or in Siberia, which is worked underground, and though very shallow, scarcely repays the expenditure, b. Auriferous debris with Mammoth bones, c. Alluvial clay covered by humus and bog earth. Before we quit the consideration of the Ural Mountains the reader may be reminded that, throughout the length of 500 miles, the rocks are auriferous at wide intervals, and in limited patches only. Having clearly marked the geological period of the superficial gold drift, let me also here advert to a suggestion of my associates and self concerning the period at which the rocks were impregnated with gold.* It has been already stated, that no secondary forma- tion contains veinstones charged with any notable quantity of gold, and that when the metal is found in situ, it is either in metamor- phosed strata of Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous age or in associated eruptive rocks. Now, it would seem as if these rocks must, in the Ural, have been chiefly impregnated with gold, in a comparatively modern geological period. In the first place, the western flank of the Ural chain offers strong evidence, that this golden transfusion had not been effected in this region when the Permian deposits were completed. During that period, vast heaps of pebbles and sand, all' derived from a pre-existing Ural chain, (the older stratified rocks of which had even then undergone much change,) were spread out over the lower country on the west. * See the work on " Russia and the Ural Mountains," vol, i. p. 472. et seq. 446 SILURIA. [Chap. XVJI. Together with fragments of all the rocks, sedimentary or igneous, which are known in the chain, specimens of magnetic iron and of copper ore, which so abound in the range, are not uncommon in this Permian debris ; but no where does it contain visible traces of gold or platinum. Had those metals then existed in the Ural Mountains, in the quantities which now prevail, many remnants of them must have been washed down together with the other rocks and minerals, and have formed part of the old Permian conglomerates. On the other hand, when the much more modern debacles, that destroyed the great animals, and heaped up the piles of gravel above described, proceeded from this chain, then the debris became largely auriferous. It is manifest, therefore, that the principal impregnation of the rocks with gold — i. e. when the chief lumps and strings of it were formed — took place during the intervening time. What then was probably the geological period when these rich auriferous impregnations of the Uralian rocks took place ? We cannot believe that it occurred shortly after the Permian era, nor even when any of the secondary rocks were forming ; since no golden debris is found even in any of the older tertiary grits and sands which occur on the Siberian flank of the chain. If, then^ the mammoth drift he the oldest mass of detritus in which gold occurs abun- dantly, not only in the Ural but in many parts of the world, we are led to believe that this noble metal, though for the most part formed in ancient crystalline rocks, or in the igneous rocks which penetrated them, was only abundantly imparted to them at a comparatively recent period; — i.e. a short time (in geological language) before the epoch when the very powerful and general denudations took place which destroyed the large extinct mammalia.* * In many instances gold is, I know, associated in the same veinstone with other ores — such as silver, or argentiferous galena, and with various ores of copper and iron — magnetic iron being, indeed, a very frequent accompaniment ; whilst the association with tin-stone has before been alluded to. Such occurrences do not invalidate, but strengthen the view derived from the phenomena in the Ural Mountains. For, as copper and iron ores are frequently found in old Chap. XVII.] FORMATION AND DISTRIBUTION OF GOLD. 447 That the gold which occurs in quartz veins in the solid slate rocks resulted from an interior agency, in which heat and electricity were combined with water or vapour, seems to be a natural conclusion, if we judge from the appearance which the strings and expansions of the metal indicate as they ramify through the chinks of the hard rock, or are diffused in grains in its mass. We may also suppose, that the prevalent matrix of quartz, whether ejected from beneath, or poured in from above, was in a soft and gelatinous state when it filled the cavities, resembling the silicious " sinter " which now rises in a fluid spout from Hecla, and, falling, coagulates into a modern quartz rock around the volcanic orifice. In viewing the widely attested fact of the dispersion of auriferous debris derived from the surface of certain rocks during some of their last great denudations, we are naturally led to favour the suggestion of Humboldt, that the formation of gold had some closer relation to or dependence upon the atmosphere than that of the baser metals lead, copper, and iron. An eminent metallurgist. Dr. Percy, who has detected minute quantities of gold in almost all lead ores, is, indeed, disposed to believe, that it may have been thrown down by deposition from an aqueous medium. coDglomerates or pebble beds of secondary age, and lumps of gold have never been detected in them, I see no means (explain the phenomena as we may) of evading the inference, that no great quantity of gold ore was formed (certainly not in the Ural Mountains) until the com- paratively recent epoch indicated in the text. In the work " Russia and the Ural Mountains," vol. i. p. 473., the inference is thus stated : — " Whether, therefore, we judge from the total absence of auriferous matter in the ancient conglomerates on the west, and in the tertiary grits on the east, or from the absolute materials in the whole series of regenerated deposits, we con- clude, that the chain became (chiefly) auriferous during the most recent disturbances by which it was affected, and that this took place when its highest peaks were thrown up, when the present watershed was established, and when the syenitic granites and other comparatively recent igneous rocks were erupted along its eastern edges." The reader who wishes to have fuller information on the subject of Uralian and Siberian gold must consialt Humboldt's Asie Centrale ; Reise nach dem Ural, &c., by Humboldt, Rose, and Ehrenberg, with the valuable mineral description of M. Gustaf Rose ; various memoirs by Helmersen and Hoffman in the Annuaire des Mines de Russie ; and Adolf Erman (Reise um die Erde), as well as an account of the general diffusion of gold and a valuable gold map of the world by that Author. 448 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. Whatever may be the correct hypothesis as to the original mode of formation, the fact is undeniable, that wherever the veinstones in the solid rock have not been ground down by former, powerful denu- dation, but remain as partial testimonials of the origin of gold, the portions which have as yet proved to be the richest, are those which are at or near the surface. Experience too, dearly bought in num- berless instances, has taught the miner, throughout long ages, that in his efforts to follow the veinstones downwards, by deep shafts, into the body of the rock, he has either found the gold diminish in volume, or so difficult to obtain, that the cost of extraction has usually been greater than the value of the metal. The points which have been alluded to, as drawn from personal observation in the Ural Mountains, are found to have a world-wide application in every tract which has been or is still auriferous. Thus, the giant chain of the Andes, which has for ages afforded much gold in its range through Chili, Peru, and Mexico, is essentially of the same composition. The Indians, who lived in tracts adjacent to those mountains, followed the simple process of picking the shining material from the gravel, sand, and shingle derived from the chain. So that when the Spaniards, the best miners of the sixteenth cen- tury, first colonized South America, they naturally inferred, that if ignorant natives could thus gather sufficient quantities of gold to roof the palaces of their sovereigns, they, as skilful Europeans, might extract incredible quantities from the bowels of mountains, the mere detritus of whose surfaces had contributed such a vast amount of gold. But, as frequently as deep mines enriched the speculators who sought for copper and silver, so surely gold mining in the solid rock proved abortive *, owing to the slender, downward dissemination of gold in a hard and intractable matrix. * It has been too much the habit to underrate the capacity and skill of the old Spanish miners, though it is known from Humboldt, that during the government of the monarchy in South America, many of their works were well conducted ; the operations having been para- lyzed chiefly by the political revolutions which have occurred in those regions. Chap. XVJI.] GOLD OF AUSTRALIA. 449 As the phenomena above described are common to many countries, the accompanying diagram is annexed, to convey, as far as possible at one view, a popular idea of the chief relations under which gold has been distributed over the surface, so as to be profitably collected by mankind. Ideal Representation of the Original Forimation of Gold in the Rocks, and its SUBSEQUENT TRANSLATION INTO HeAPS OF GrAVEL. (From a large diagram exhibited in 1850, at the Royal Institution.) a b a b a a b a b a b a The rocks, a, are the ancient metamorphic masses, whether talcose, micaceous, chloritic, fel - spathic, or siliceous slates (altered primeval slaty rocks), which have been traversed by , quartzose and other auriferous veinstones, h. All along their present dark summits a* are seen lighter tinted lines, which represent the outline and condition of the auriferous ridges before their pinnacles were subjected to that agency of destruction and abrasion, by which great heaps of drift and gravel were transported from them, so as to form the hillocks, c, that cover the adjacent slopes and fill up the gorges and depressions, d. The first or highest of these drifts, &c,, constitute the dry diggings of the miner ; the lower heaps, d, in which streams meander, being the wet diggings. It being impossible to represent in one diagram all the conditions under which gold was originally formed in the rocks, I have merely selected the usual case of veinstones, the old or destroyed surfaces of which were the richest. Gold of Australia, — The extraordinary quantity of gold which has been poured into Britain from her Australian colonies during the last two years, has been procured, like the chief masses in the other tracts described, from superficial accumulations of shingle. If the former trials of Spaniards to procure gold with profit from deep mines in the solid rock, and which were proverbially failures, do not satisfy living speculators, let me refer them to similar results in our day, and trials by our own countrymen. Among these, I would specially allude to the well-known mine of Guadalupe y Calvo, near Durango, in Mexico, worked by British skill and capital, where, according to information I received from one of its ablest .directors (my friend the late Colonel Colquhoun, R. A.), the works, which aflforded a moderate profit near the surface, became less productive as the mine deepened, and finally failed alto- gether; the gold having thinned out, and its place being entirely taken by argentiferous galena. See Quarterly Review, Article, ' Siberia and California,' vol. Ixxxvii. p. 410. G G 450 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. gravel, sand, and clay, derived from the wearing away of adjacent hard rocks, whether of aqueous or of igneous origin. Having, in the year 1844, recently returned from the auriferous Ural Mountains, I had the advantage of examining the numerous specimens collected by my friend Count Strzelecki, along the eastern chain of Australia. Seeing the great similarity of the rocks of those two distant countries, I could have little difficulty in drawing a parallel between them; in doing which I was naturally struck by the circumstance that no gold * had yet been found ' in the Australian ridge, which I termed in anticipation the * Cordillera.'* * The announcement that ' no gold had yet been detected,' which was printed in my Presi- dential Discourse, Trans. Roy. Geog. Soc. 1844, is the clearest proof of my ignorance of a trace of the metal having been discovered by any one. In the last two years, however, facts have transpired, which were totally unknown to me when I ventured upon my comparison. Thus it appears, that Count Strzelecki himself discovered traces of gold in 1839 ; but on relating the fact to some friends and to the Governor of New South Wales Sir G. Gipps, secrecy was enjoined, and the Count never more reverted to the subject ; not even in his own work, 1845. It now also appears, that the Eev. W. C, Clarke wrote to a friend in the colony (1841), mention- ing that he had found gold ore; but this circumstance remained as much unknown to myself and all European men of science as the other. My views, whatever they may be worth, were therefore formed quite irrespectively of any such proceedings, as the following extract from a letter of my friend Count Strzelecki to myself, received when these pages are passing through the press, amply testifies: — 'Nothing can give me greater pleasure and comfort at any time, than to bear my humble testimony to the inductive powers which you displayed on the occasion of your predictions in regard to the existence of gold in Australia; and conse- quently, I can affirm now, as I did and do whenever a necessity occurs, that I never men- tioned my discovery or supposed discovery of Australian gold to you, prior to your papers on the subject, nor after their publication.' A claim has recently been made in favour of Mr. G. Windsor Earl as one of the early indi- cators of Australian gold, which, with every respect for the accomplishments of that gentle- man, seems to me to rest on no foundation. In June 1845, and therefore after both my Anniversary Discourses of May 1844 — 1845, in which the subject of the distribution of gold over the world was handled at some length, Mr. Windsor Earl communicated to the R. Geo- gi-aphical Society, a memoir on the general analogy between Australia and the Asiatic countries to the north of it ; (he having resided at Port Essington). Being led to believe, by the great geological authority Leopold von Buch (who was present on the occasion), that the insular tracts extending northwards from Torres Straits were chiefly volcanic, and not of the same mineral structure as any part of Eastern Australia with which we had then been made acquainted, I ventured (verbally) to suggest doubts as to the value of this portion only of Mr. Earl's memoir. But neither Leopold von Buch nor myself made any allusion to metalliferous productions, inasmuch as we only touched upon the broad outline of a general geological com- parison ; and no reference whatever having been made hy Mr. Earl to Australian gold, no Chap. XVII.] GOLD OF AUSTRALIA. 451 Impressed with the conviction that gold would, sooner or later, be found in the great British colony, I learnt in 1846 with satisfac- tion that a specimen of the ore had been discovered. I thereupon encouraged the unemployed miners of Cornwall to emigrate and dig for gold, as they dug for tin in the gravel of their own district. These notices were, as far as I know, thfe first printed documents relating to Australian gold. At that time, California, inhabited only by pastoral Indians and a few missionaries and Spanish herdsmen, was, it will be recollected, equally unknown to be auriferous. Its rich alluvial soil had not then been removed from the surface, and the accident at Sutter's Mill, in 1847, had not exposed the gold in the gravel and shingle beneath it. We can still better understand how this should have been the case with regard to vast tracts of Australia, where similar mineral constants exist, but where, instead of a comparatively advanced people, like the Mexicans or Peruvians, a wretched race, incapable of appreciating the uses of the precious metals, had been for ages the sole inhabitants of a vast continent. Unwilling to offer what must be a very iraperfect epitome pf the distri- bution of gold in Australia, I may, however, be permitted to say a few words on a subject to which I called the attention of my countrymen for several successive years previous to the opening out of the gold fields of that vast region. The geological survey of the British colonies in Australia, to the advan- tages of which, in the opening out of gold mines, I directed the attention of Her Majesty's Government in the year 1848, or three years before their practical development, has been since ably carried into effect by very competent observers. To the general geological descriptions given by Mitchell, Strzelecki, Clarke and Jukes, voluminous details, published for question respecting it was raised. I therefore repeat, that at that time no one, whether in Britain or the colonies, had printed any thing on the auriferous characters of the Australian rocks except myself, and I reiterate my conviction, that my memoirs of 1844, 1845, and 1846, are the earliest publications on the subject. See Trans, of the Eo}'. Geograph. Society, President's Discourses, 1844, 1845 ; and Trans. Roy. Geol. Soc. Cornwall, 1846. G G 2 452 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. the use of both Houses of Parliament, have been added within the last three years, explanatory of the varied mineral condition under which gold occurs in Australia.* Thus Mr. Stutchbury, the Government geologist, gave us clear reports upon several tracts of New South Wales, after Mr. Hargreaves had proved (1851) the value of the diggings. The Rev. W. B. Clarke had, however, previously, or in 1847, publicly called the atten- tion of the colonists of Sydney to the auriferous character of New South "Wales. This zealous geologist has since explored the largest range of its gold-bearing lands over upwards of six degrees of latitude, or from the Peel River on the north to the Australian Alps of Strzelecki on the south, where the watershed or Cordillera, rising in Mount Kosciusko to 6,500 feet above the sea, trends south-eastwards into the province of Victoria. From Mr. Clarke and other authors we learn, that the parallel which I had drawn, in 1844, between the rocks of the Australian * Cordillera' and those of the Ural Mountains is well sustained. Just as in Siberia, the greatest amount of gold is found in the heaps of debris, or old alluvia, adjacent to certain intersections of the older slaty strata by eruptive rocks, whether granites, porphyries, or greenstones. We may also assume, that the chief auriferous slaty rocks of Australia are of the same age as the central and older masses of the Ural, viz. Lower Silurian ; because, like them, they are overlaid by limestones, which contain Pen- tameri, Trilobites, and Corals, indicative of the Upper Silurian Group. The last are followed by other strata, which are probably of Devonian age, and then by true equivalents of the Carboniferous era. Whilst the most prolific sources seem to have been the quartzose vein- stones which traverse the older slates, we are further instructed, that in Australia, as in the Ural Mountains, there are tracts wherein gold is diffused in small and often imperceptible particles through the body of certain granitic rocks f, specially those (according to Mr. Clarke) which are hornblendic or syenitic ; whilst the limestones in both countries are partially auriferous. There is besides, not only this striking coincidence between the Australian Mountains and the Ural, viz. that both have a main meridian * See Papers relative to the recent Discovery of Gold in Australia, presented to both Houses of Parliament, 1852 — 1853. For my own connection with this subject, see the Papers on the same subject, presented August 16. 1853, p. 43. t See Russia and the Ural Mountains, vol. i. p. 483., where it is stated, ' The fact is, then, that though gold has frequently been, and is for the most part, formed in quartzose and other veins which either have penetrated or been separated from the mass of the slate formation (and of these the Ural affords countless examples), it has also been diffused in some tracts through- out the whole body of the rock, whether of igneous or of aqueous origin.' Chap. XVII.] GOLD OF AUSTRALIA. 453 direction ; but also the fact, that each chain is largely and profitably auri- ferous on one side of the watershed only ; in Russia on the eastern or Siberian, and in Australia on the western slopes of the principal range. Looking, then, at the Australian phenomena (including those of Victoria) on a broad scale, there are no essential distinctions between them and the mineral relations of gold in the Old World and America ; except that certain slopes and hollows, notably those of Victoria*, have proved to be much more lucrative than those of any known region, except parts of California. The great sources of wealth, as elsewhere, are depressions which have been filled with debris from the mountains, whether coarse or fine. The sides of these depressions being once defined, and their bottoms being easily ascertained, the period of their exhaustion may be estimated approxi- mately. It matters nothing to the statist whether this golden drift, or accumulation of broken materials, was for the most part aggregated, as I think, by causes now no longer in action, which powerfully abraded the tops and sides of the hills (as explained in the previous pages, and par- ticularly in the diagram, p. 449.), or whether the diurnal atmospheric action alone for thousands of years has been the effective agent. Both causes have unquestionably contributed to spread out and make accessible a material, the search after which in the solid rock, as I have already stated, has hitherto usually been so profitless a speculation. , When the British public hear from our colonial authorities, that 16,000 square miles of a part of New South Wales are auriferous f, they * See Memoir by Mr. Wathen, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. London, vol. ix. p. 74. Mr. G. M. Stephen, Vice-President of the Geological Society of Melbourne, recently arrived from Victoria, lias brought home instructive specimens of crystallized gold, and many small precious stones from different parts of Australia, including topaz, chrysolite, gai^net, zircon, tour- maline, &c. Besides some of these which also occur in the Ural Mountains (including a rare diamond), the gold fields of Victoria have afforded a mineral unknown in Russia, i. e. tin, which is found not only in the form of sand, as now worked by Messrs. C. Terry and Co., but also in small lumps, and highly coloured crystals, described by Mr. G. M. Stephen in a Report published at Melbourne. The reader who wishes to catch a general view of these the most important of the Australian gold diggings, and acquire an insight into the statistics and social condition of the wonderful colony of Victoria, should peruse the recent work of Mr. Westgarth. f Report of the Rev. W. Clarke to the Governor of New South Wales. Parliamentary Papers, presented Feb. 28. 1853. Sir C. Fitzroy's Dispatch, p. 62. See Wyld's Memoir and Maps ; and Arrowsmith's new maps of the auriferous regions of Australia, as compiled from the Government Surveys, on which (particularly that which is printed for the use of the Houses of Parliament) the localities at or near which any appreciable amount of gold has been detected are coloured yellow. In stating that the gold from California and Australia has been chiefly G G 3 454 SILURIA. [CiiAP. XVII. must not suppose that the geologist, who thus reports, intends to say, that profitable researches could be carried out over that vast area. The truly rich sites, he well knows, are very small as compared with the entire country. Again, in those districts where, by degradation for ages, fine particles of gold have been derived from the granitic or other rocks (the chief materials of the matrix perishing, but the gold remaining), we are not to infer, that any human endeavours to break up and grind down mountain masses of such original rock for the purpose of extracting the metal it contains, (seldom visible to the human eye) would be remune- rative, except in some remarkable cases like those before alluded to (p. 437.) At all events, the extent to which such appliances can extend, will ere long, be ascertained through the spirit and intelligence of our country- men : and in the mean time it is satisfactory to reflect, that a basis of all such researches and inquiries has been provided by the good geographical survey of a large portion of this new country, executed by Mitchell and his associates. On that important groundwork, geologists may now record all subsequent observations, respecting a region hitherto almost exclusively pastoral, but which has suddenly become a great and populous centre of commerce through the development of its very rich fields of gold. Conclusion, — Notwithstanding the preceding sketch, it would ill become any geologist who throws his eye over the gold map of the world prepared by Adolf Erman, to attempt to estimate, at this day, the amount of gold which remains, like that of Australia, undetected in vast regions of the earth, as yet unknown even to geographers ; still less to speculate upon the relative proportions of it in such countries. At the same time, the broad features of the case in all known lands may be appealed to, to check extravagant fears and apprehensions re- derived from drifted and broken materials, as in the Ural Mountains, I am quite aware that a small portion of ore has been obtained from veinstones -which ti-averse the schists in situ. But, as few shafts have yet been sunk deep into those rocks (even in California), the specu- lators have yet to learn whether, when the richer surface strings of the metal have been worked out, the lower portions of the veins in those tracts will prove exceptions to the prevailing rule. As far as experience can teach, it is only where the mountains have been shattered, and great mounds of their debris thrown down in former ages upon their sides (as represented in the diagram, p. 449.), that gold can be extracted by human labour. to any considerable profit. The chief exceptions, as in the Brazils, are where the deep mines are in a soft matrix, and are worked by slaves receiving very low wages. The caveat, however, which is inserted in the note * p. 437., must also be considered. CUAP.XVII.] GENERAL VIEW OF GOLD. 455 specting an excessive production of the ore. For, we can trace the boundaries, rude as they may be, of a metal ever destined to remain precious on account of those limits in position, breadth, and depth by which it is circumscribed in Nature's bank. Let it be borne in mind, that whilst gold has scarcely ever been found, and never in any quantity, in the secondary and tertiary rocks which occupy so large a portion of the surface, mines sunk down into the solid rocks where it does occur, have hitherto, with rare exceptions, proved remunerative ; — and, when they are so, it is only in those cases where the rocks are soft, or the price of labour low. Further, it has been well ascertained, whatever may have been the agency by which this impregnation was effected, that the metal has been chiefly accumulated towards the surface of the rocks; and then by the abrasion and dispersion of their syperficial parts, the richest golden materials have been spread out, in limited patches, and generally near the bottom of basin-shaped accumulations of detritus. Now, as every heap of these broken auriferous materials in foreign lands, has as well defined a base as each gravel pit of our own country, it is quite certain, that hollows so occupied, whether in Cali- fornia or Australia, must be dug out and exhausted, in a greater or less period. In fact, all similar deposits in the old or new world have had their gold abstracted from heaps whose areas have been traced, and whose bottoms were reached. Not proceeding beyond the evi- dences registered in the stone-book of Nature, it may therefore be affirmed, that the period of such exhaustion in each country (for the deposits are much shallower in some tracts than in others) will, in great measure, depend on the amount of population and the activity of the workmen employed in each locality. Anglo-Saxon energy, for example, as applied in California and Australia, may in a few years accomplish results, which could only have been attained in centuries by a scanty and lazy indigenous population ; and thus the 456 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. present large flow of gold into Europe from such tracts, icill, in my opinion, begin to diminish tvithin a comparatively short period. In defining the general character of the most productive auriferous rocks, the geologist must, however, necessarily admit a considerable number of exceptions to any prevailing rule. For, whilst the chemist, as before said, has recently detected traces of gold in lead and copper ores, — a discovery of considerable interest, doubtless, in regard to the theory of the origin of the precious metal, — the re- searches of the miner teach us, that, in any auriferous region where certain quartzose lodes are surcharged with ores of iron, particu- larly the oxides and sulphurets, there some amount of gold will probably be found. Again, the diffusion or dissemination of small particles of gold throughout the body of various rocks both of igneous and aqueous origin is, as before said, a phenomenon dwelt upon by certain authors. Humboldt, indeed, asserted long since, that in Guiana * gold, like tin, is sometimes disseminated in an almost imperceptible manner in the mass itself of the granitic rocks without the ramification or interlacing of any small veins.'* In Mexico the gold mine of Guadalupe y Calvo, above alluded to was in por- phyry. In Australia (districts of Braidwood, and others south of Sydney), a peculiar variety of felspathic granite is described by Mr. Clarke as being permeated by small particles of gold ; whilst in Siberia, Hoffman had some years before spoken of its distribution in such minute quantities in clay-slate, that it was only by pounding up large lumps of the rock that any perceptible quantity could be extracted. J In all regions, therefore, where such rocks occur, we may find gold either in the coarse debris or the fine alluvia resulting from their decomposition. Felspar and quartz being their chief com- ponent parts, we can easily imagine how their former destruction * Voyages, vol. ii. p. 238. f P^ige 449. X Reise nach dem Goldwaschen Ost Sibiriens, by Enist Hofmann, St. Petersburg, 1847. Chap. XVII.] GENEKAL VIEW OF GOLD. 457 on a great scale would leave as a residue large heaps of that pipe- clay (the decomposed felspar), or those gritty pebbles (the abraded quartz), which with the accompanying ores of iron (particularly the black magnetic oxide) are so frequently the gold-bearing matrices in the drift of auriferous countries. But whilst it is an admitted fact, that gold has sometimes been so diffused in minute and imper- ceptible particles in certain rocks, we have yet to learn whether such diffusion extends far downwards into the body of any mountain. Even if it be so, the extraction of ore so diffused might, if the rocks were hard, prove too costly an operation. At all events, the indisputable fact is, that the chief quantities of gold, including all the considerable lumps and pepitas, having been originally imbedded in the upper parts of the veinstones, have been broken up and trans- ported with the debris of the mountain-tops into slopes and adjacent valleys. In conclusion, let me express my opinion, that the fear that gold may be greatly depreciated in value relatively to silver — a fear which may have seized upon the minds of some of my readers — is unwar- ranted by the data registered in the crust of the earth. Gold is, after all, by far the most restricted — in its native distribution — of the precious metals. Silver and argentiferous lead, on the contrary, expand so largely downwards into the bowels of the rocks, as to lead us to believe, that they must yield enormous profits to the skilful miner for ages to come ; and the more so in proportion as better machinery and new inventions shall lessen the difficulty of subter- ranean mining.* It may indeed well be doubted whether the quan- tities both of gold and silver, procured from regions unknown to our progenitors, will prove more than sufficient to meet the exigencies of an enormously increased population and our augmenting commerce * A recent report from Col. Lloyd, H. M. Charge d' Affaires in Bolivia, communicated .through H. R. H. Prince Albert to the Royal Geographical Society, shows to what an enor- mous extent silver may yet be extracted from Copiapb and other South American mines. This was, indeed, the view taken long ago by Humboldt. 458 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. and luxury. But this is not a theme for a geologist ; and I would simply say, that Providence seems to have originally adjusted the relative value of these two precious metals, and that their relations, having remained the same for ages, will long survive all theories. Modern science, instead of contradicting, only confirms the truth of the aphorism of the patriarch Job, which thus shadowed forth the downward persistence of the one and the superficial distribution of the other : — ' Surely there is a vein for the silver The earth hath dust of goldJ^ * The Book of Job, chap, 28. P. S. — Since this chapter was in type, Mr. A. R. C. Selwyn, of the Geological Survey, whose labours were so successful in North Wales (see p. 28.), having recently gone to Victoria in the capacity of Government Geologist, has sent home an excellent sketch, accompanied by map and sections, of the structure of the country around Mount Alexander, distinguishing the true stratification of the sedimentary rocks (Lower Silurian?), whether micaceous felspathic sand- stones, flagstones, or clay slates, from an intense and vertical slaty cleavage which runs through them from north to south, and with which the course of the auriferous quartz veins and the strike joints are coincident. He also shows how the granite has metamorphosed the contiguous slaty rocks, and has injected * el van' dykes into them. Mr. Selwyn coincides with Mr. Wathen (p. 453.), and others, in stating, that the auriferous drift is local, and although lying at various heights is usually richest at or near the bottom of these accumulations. In reference to New Zealand, the Governor, Sir G. Grey, has communicated to myself a letter addressed to him by Mr. C. Heaphy, giving an account of the gold diggings (not yet extensive) at Coromandel, on the east coast of the Northern Island, where the chief rocks are quartzose and granitic. Lastly, Mr. J S. Wilson, who after a residence in South Australia, passed three years as a gold miner in the Sierra Nevada of California, has communicated a memoir, on the auriferous rocks of that region, to the Geological Society of London. The views resulting from his own obser- vation and experience, confirm decisively the opinions stated throughout the text, in aflirming the fact of the downward impoverishment of gold-bearing quartz veins, and in demonstrating that the richest produce is essentially derived from loose superficial debris, piled up on the mountain sides and slopes, or in ravines, and at various and considerable altitudes above the sea. The quicksilver (cinnabar) which is extracted from the coast range, occurs in veinstones, in clay slate (Silurian ?), as in the Sierra Morena of Spain. These memoirs will appear in the Journal of the Geological Society of London. In this chapter I have necessarily abstained from alluding to many tracts more or less auriferous, but not rich in produce, which come under the same laws of distribution as those described in the text. Such, for example, are the phenomena of the southern provinces of the United States (S. Carolina, &c.), and also of the British province of Canada, whence a certain amount of gold has been derived from metamorpliic rocks, which, according to Mr. Logan, are probably of Lower Silurian age. 459 ^ CHAPTEE XVIII. CONCLUSIOIN^. RECAPITULATION — GENERAL VIEW OF THE SUCCESSION OF LIFE FROM A BEGINNING AS BASED ON POSITIVE OBSERVATION THE PROGRESS OF CREATION THEORETICAL SPECULATIONS DISTINGUISHED FROM ABSOLUTE GEOLOGICAL RESULTS. Reverting to the main object of this work, — the history of the primeval rocks, — let us now see what inferences may be drawn from data established by the researches of the geologist. Passing rapidly over the earliest stages of the planet, which are necessarily involved in obscurity, our sketch of ancient nature began with the first attainable evidences of the formation of sediments composed of mud, sand, and pebbles. It was shown, that the lowest accessible of these deposits, though of enormous dimensions, and occasionally less altered than strata formed after them, are almost entirely azoic, or void of traces of inhabitants of the seas in which they were accuniulated. One solitary genus of zoophytes has been alone detected in such bottom rocks ; the heat of the surface during those earlier periods having been, it is supposed, adverse to life. Proofs were then adduced to demonstrate that in the next forma- tions, scarcely differing at all in mineral character from those which preceded them, observers in various regions had detected clear and unmistakeable signs of a contemporaneous appearance of animal life, as shown by the presence of a few genera of crustaceans, mollusks, and zoophytes, occupying layers of similar date in the crust of the earth. Proceeding upwards from this protozoic zone, wherein organic remains are comparatively rare, we then ascended to other sediments, in which, throughout nearly all latitudes, we recognize a 460 SILUKIA. [Chap. XVIII. copious distribution of submarine creatures, resembling each other very nearly, though imbedded in rocks now separated by wide seas, and often raised up to the summits of high mountains. Examining all the strata exposed to view, that were formed during the first long natural epoch of similar life termed Silurian, %e found that the successive deposits were charged with a great variety of forms, — of the trilobite a peculiar crustacean, — of the orthoceratite, the earliest chambered shell, — as well as with numerous exquisitely formed mol- lusks, crinoids, and zoophytes; the genus graptolite of the latter class being exclusively found in these Silurian rocks. In short, my contemporaries have assembled from those ancient and now desiccated marine sediments or repositories of primeval creatures, examples of every group of purely aquatic animals, save fishes. The multiplied researches of the last twenty years have failed to detect the trace of a fish, amid the multitudes of all other marine beings in the variojis sediments which constitute the chief mass of the Silurian rocks. Of these, though they are the lowest in the scale of the great division vertehrata, we are unable to perceive a vestige until we reach the highest zone of the Upper Silurian, and are about to enter upon the Devonian period. Even on that horizon, the minute fossil fishes, long ago noticed by myself, are exceedingly scarce, and none have since been found in strata of higher antiquity. In fact, the few fragments of cartilaginous ichthyolites of the highest band of Silurian rock, still remain the most ancient known beings of their class. (See PI. 35.) Looking, therefore, at the Silurian System as a whole, and judging from the collection of facts gathered from all quarters of the globe, we know, that its chief deposits (certainly all the lower and most extensive) were formed during a long period, in which, while the sea abounded with countless invertebrate animals, no marine vertebrata had been called into existence. The Silurian (except at its close) was, therefore, a series in which there appeared Chap. XVIII.] PROGRESS OF CREATION. 461 no example of that bony framework of completed vertebrae, from which, as approaching to the vertebrate archetype, the comparative anatomist* traces the rise of creative power up to the formation of man. Whether, therefore, the term of * progressive,' or of that of * suc- cessive,' be applied to such acts of creation, my object is simply to show, upon clear and general evidence, that there was a long period in the history of the world, wherein no vertebrated animal lived. In this sense, the appearance of the first recognizable fossil fishes, is as decisive a proof of a new and distinct creation, as that of the placing of man upon the terrestrial surface, at the end of the long series of animals which characterize the younger geological periods. Nor have we been able to disinter from the older strata of this long period of invertebrate life, any distinct fragments of land plants. But just in the same stratum wherein the few earliest small fishes have been detected, there also have we observed the first appearances of a diminutive, yet highly organized, tree vegetation. (See Appendix C.) If it be granted that the position of the earliest recognizable vertebrata is good positive evidence on which to argue, still it might be contended that such forms may at a future period be found in lower strata. In this work, however, I reason only on known data. Nor is it on this testimony alone, strong, clear, and universal as it is, that my view is sustained ; for as soon as we pass into the formation immediately overlying, and quit the zone wherein the first few small fishes are to be detected, we are furnished with collateral * See Owen on the Homology of the Vertebrate Skeleton : Reports, Brit. Assoc. Adv. Science, 1846, p. 169. The general reader will find a powerful essay, em- bodying the opinions of the same high authority, on the proofs of a progression in creation, Quarterly Review, 1851, p. 412, et seq. The arguments there em- ployed have been strengthened by subsequent discoveries alluded to in this volume. I would also specially refer the reader to Professor Sedgwick's ' Dis- course on the Studies of the University of Cambridge,' for a masterly and eloquent illustration of several of the views which are here advocated. 462 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. proofs that this was the earliest great step in a progressive order of creation. In the following or Devonian period, we are sur- rounded by a profusion of larger fossil fishes, with vertebrae for the most part very imperfectly ossified, and with dermal skeletons of very singular forms ; all differing vastly from anything of their class in existing nature. These fishes were thus clearly added to the other forms of marine life. Again, in this Devonian era, we are presented with well defined land plants, also of much larger dimensions than the very rare specimens in the uppermost Silurian ; while, towards the close of the period, we meet with an air-breathing reptile. The little Telerpeton had groves of tree ferns or lycopo- diaceous plants, and even of ConiferaB, amid the roots of which he could nestle. (See p. 254.) Just as the introduction of cartilaginous fishes (^Onchus e. g.) is barely traceable at the close of the long Silurian era, so becoming soon afterwards more abundant, they are associated in all younger formations with true osseous fishes, whose remains are found intermixed with the other exuvias of the sea. Putting aside, there- fore, theory, and judging solely from positive observation, we may fairly infer, first, that during very long epochs the seas were unoccu- pied by any kind of fishes ; secondly, that the earliest discoverable creatures of this class had an internal framework almost incapable of fossilization, and so left in the strata their teeth and dermal ske- letons only ; and thirdly, that in the succeeding period, the oldest fishes having bony vertebrae make their scanty appearance, but become numerous in the overlying deposits. Are not these absolute data of the geologist clear signs of a progress in creation ? In like manner, there is a progress in the productions of the land ; the great Carboniferous period being marked by the first copious and universally abundant terrestrial flora, the prelude to which had ap- peared in the foregoing Devonian epoch. This earliest luxuriant tree vegetation, the pabulum of our great coal-fields, is also specially CflAF. XVIII.] PROGKESS OF CREATION. 463 remarkable for its spread over many latitudes and longitudes ; and together with it occur the same common species of marine shells, all indicating a more or less equable climate from polar to inter-tropical regions ; a phenomenon wholly at variance with the present distribu' tion of animal or vegetable life over the surface of the planet. Lastly, while the Permian era was distinguished by the disappear- ance of the greater number of the primeval types, and by essential modifications of those w4iich remained, it still bore a strong resem- blance, through its plants and animals, to the Carboniferous period ; whilst, in unison with all the great facts elicited by our survey of the older strata, it was marked by the appearance of an animal of a higher grade than any one in the foregone eras, — a large thecodont reptile — allied (according to Owen) to the living Monitor. In speaking of the Silurian, Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian rocks, let me however explain, that whilst each of the three latter groups occupy wide spaces in certain regions, no one of them is of equal value with the Silurian, in representing time or the succes- sion of animal life in the crust of the globe. When the Silurian system was divided into lower and upper parts, our acquaintance with younger formations simply sufficed to show a complete distinction between its animal remains as a whole and those of the Carboni- ferous rocks, from which it is separated by the thick accumulations of the Old Red Sandstone. At that period, the shelly, slaty rocks of Devonshire were not known to be the equivalents of such Old Red Sandstone ; still less had the relations and fossil contents of the strata now called Permian been ascertained. tTudging from the fossils then collected, it was believed, that the Lower Silurian contained organic remains very distinct from those of the Upper Silurian ; and yet the two groups were united in a system, because they were characterized throughout by a common fades. This so-called system was, in short, typified by a profusion of Trilobites and Graptolites, with Orthides and Pentameri of a type wholly unknown in the Carboniferous 464 SILUEIA. [Chap. XVIII. rocks. And whilst fishes were seen to exist in the intermediate masses of Old Red Sandstone, no traces of them could be detected below the very uppermost zone of the Silurian rocks. Nineteen years have elapsed, and, after the most vigilant researches in various regions of both hemispheres, these great features remain the same as when first indicated. The labours, however, of those who fol- lowed me, have infinitely more sustained the unity of that system*; for its lower and upper divisions are now proved to be connected, not only by such generic types and analogous forms, but further by the community of a very considerable number of identical bodies. In a broad classification of primeval life, one eminent naturalist f views the Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian rocks as simply the Upper Palasozoic ; the Silurian rocks constituting the Lower Palaeozoic, But, whether this ancient series be divided into double or triple classes (some palaeontologists preferring to hold the Devonian as a separate and intermediate type), the result of the researches of the numerous authors appealed to in this volume has unquestionably justified the application of the term * system,' to the Silurian rocks. At the close of the Permian era, an infinitely greater change took place in life, than that which marked the ascent from the Silurian system to the overlying groups. The earlier races then disappeared (at least all the species), and were replaced by an entirely new creation, the generic types of which were continued through those long epochs which geologists term secondary or mesozoic (the medi- eval age of extinct beings). In these, again, the reader will learn, by consulting the works of many waiters, how one formation fol- * See the works of John Phillips, E. de Verneuil, Edward Forbes, Joachim Barrande, James De C. Sowerby, James Hall, J. W. Salter, D. Sharpe, T. Davidson, John Morris. The most recent researches in Britain give the large number of nearly 100 species of fossils, common to the Lower and Upper Silurian. (See also the Preface, and Table A. in the Appendix.) t Edward Forbes. Chap. XVIII.] MINERAL CONDITIONS. 465 lowed another, each characterized by different creatures ; many of them, however, exhibiting near their downward and upward limits certain fossils which link on one reign of life to another. In surveying the whole series of formations, the practical geologist is fully impressed with the conviction, that there has, at all periods, subsisted a very intimate connection between the existence, or at all events the preservation of animals, and the media in which they have been fossilized. The chief seat of former life in each geo- logical epoch, is often marked by a calcareous mass, mostly in a central part, towards which the animals increase from below, and whence they diminish upwards. Thus, the Llandeilo limestone of the Lower Silurian and the Wenlock of the Upper Silurian, are respectively centres of animalization of each of those groups. In like manner, the Eifel limestone is the truest index of the Devonian, the Mountain limestone of the Carboniferous, and the Zechstein or Eng- lish Magnesian limestone of the Permian. Throughout the secondary rocks the same law prevails more or less ; and wherever the typical limestone of a natural group is absent, there we perceive the deposits to be ill-characterized by organic remains. For example, the Trias, so rich in fossil contents when its great calcareous centre the Mus- chelkalk is present, as in Germany and France, is a miserably sterile formation in Britain, where, as in our New Red Sandstone, no such limestone exists.* Whilst it is beside my present aim to enter upon descriptions of such secondary deposits, still less of those called tertiary, which intervened between them and the sediments of the present day, we may still cast an eye over the general order admitted by geologists, to * The observation in the text does not apply to the oolitic series of England, throughout which lime is diffused at many stages ; nor to many limestones which may have been formed by deposit from chemical solution. For a full ex- planation of the origin of such deposits and the associated phenomena, the reader is referred to the instructive work by Sir H. T. De la Beche, ' The Geological Observer,' 1853. H H 466 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. see how it harmonizes with what has been related of the succession of animals belonging to the older rocks, as proving a succession from lower to higher grades of life. Proceeding into the secondary strata, which often constitute vast mountain masses, we pass first through the Trias, then traverse the Lias, and afterwards the long series of the Oolitic or Jurassic formations, all of which are charged with many animal and vegetable remains, and laden with a great profusion of curious and large Saurians, very unlike the lizards which preceded them. Besides numerous land plants, insects now become abundant, — a tribe which began to appear in the Carboniferous era, or in the first great forests ; and with these are found bones of that large-winged reptile, the ^ pterodactyle ' of geologists. But still, surrounded as we are in these secondary strata by the spoils of the land, we have to journey through nearly a half of them, before we obtain any other evidences of the exist- ence of mammalia, than two or three teeth of a carnivorous animal said to be found in a bone bed of the Trias* (but which may pos- sibly be the bottom bed of the Lias), and the scarce fragments, in the Stonesfield Oolite, of the Amphitherium, formerly named Didel- phis Bucklandi by Broderip. This last-mentioned creature, which is allied to living marsupials, though discovered many years ago, has had no companions added to it by the hordes of collectors who have sought for them, except the small but highly curious Phascolotherium of Owen.j * See Lyell's Elements of Geology, 4tli edit. p. 13. t See Owen, British Foss. Mammalia, p. 31. On the point, indeed, of the absence of mammalia in the older rocks, I may be allowed to quote, if not the words, at least the sentiments, of the same eminent contemporary. ' Had mammalia existed in the same number and variety in the ancient forests, that have contributed to the coal strata, as in the actual woods and swamps of the warmer parts of the globe, — had armadillos and ant-eaters been then created to feed on the insects, sloths on the leaves, monkeys on the fruits of the coal plants, as they do now in the Brazilian forests where the mammals pre- Chap. XVIII.] GENERAL GEOLOGICAL ORDER. 467 After this, we have plentiful evidences of successive shore deposits at many periods, with abundant examples of sediments formed in lakes and rivers (an order of things of which vestiges were first apparent towards the close of the primeval period), and with con- tinual signs of adjacent lands affording numerous forms of plants and insects. The Wealden, of such vast thickness, is, indeed, exclu- sively tenanted by land and fresh-water remains ; and yet, though its strata are full of plants and the gigantic fossil lizards of the period, not one bone of a mammal has been exhumed from them ; while bones of birds make their first appearance only in the greensand and chalk. We have to work through the whole cretaceous series and its pro- lific fauna, to take leave, in short, of the secondary rocks, and enter upon the tertiary epochs, before such remains are at all plentiful. Then, for the first time in this incalculably long series of forma- tions, we have before us, on all sides, the bones of the higher order of mammalia; and these having been drifted from adjacent lands, are constantly associated with the exuviae of marine creatures, which, though of classes known in the earlier formations, are entirely different in species. Animals of every sort thenceforward abound in each succeeding formation; and exhibit an increasing quantity and variety of both sea and land mammalia as we approach the superficial accumulations. In the last are entombed the bones of gigantic quadrupeds, — quadrupeds which once inhabited our present continents, and which must have required for their sustenance a range over lands as exten- sive as those now occupied by man and his associates. ponderate over reptiles, we might have expected the first evidences of an air- breathing vertebrate animal to have been a mammalian !' Quarterly Review, 1851, p. 423. H n 2 468 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. Let the reader dwell on these remarkable facts which the labours of geologists have elicited in the last fifty years. Let him view them progressively and in the order indicated by Nature herself. Let him execute a patient survey from the lower deposits upwards, and he will find everywhere a succession of vertebrated creatures, rising from lower to higher organizations, — a doctrine first promul- gated by the illustrious Cuvier, but from much less perfect data than we now possess.* Guided by facts only, he will everywhere recog- nize signs of a similar primordial life registered on the same lower tablets of stone ; and thence examining upwards, he will admit the proofs of the advancing steps above indicated. These views of the successive creation of different races are, it is true, mainly based upon the progressive rise in the scale of the ver- tebrate sub-kino-dom. Of that class we can best reojister a beginning:, and thence trace the distinct progress which sustains our general inference. When we turn to other and inferior classes, crustaceans, mollusks and corals, naturalists assure us (and I willingly subscribe to their dicta) that many of the earlier leading groups were quite as highly organized as any of their representatives in subsequent ages or at the present day. Nay, even whilst I close this volume, one of our leaders in the philosophy of Natural History has propounded a new theory, which he terms 'The Manifestation of the relation of Polarity in the Distribution of Generic Types in Time.'f Kegarding all the epochs after the Trias to be combinedly equi- valent to those preceding (or the palasozoic), he maintains that the * The paleozoic or primeval fossils were necessarily little known to that great comparative anatomist, who drew his conclusions from data within the scope of the knowledge of his day; i.e. from the higher orders of vertebrata which appear in the more recent epochs only. t Address to the Geological Society of London, Feb. 17. 1854, by Professor E. Forbes, President. Chap.xviil] geological hypotheses. 469 development of types of life, as manifested by generic combinations during the long secondary and tertiary epochs, styled by him ' Neozoic,' is in opposition to, or in a relation of polarity with, the comparable phenomenon during the * Palaeozoic' period. This is indicated by the concentration of the maximum of what he terms 'ge- neric ideas/ in some of the earlier stages of the older, and towards the termination of the more recent period; w^hilst, as we approach to the interlacing point, (i.e. the Trias) there is a poverty in the origination of generic types. This polarity, he contends, is evident in both directions within each great group of invertebrate animals, as well as in the assemblage of plants; but in the vertebrata, the main direction of development of generic ideas is, he admits, towards the newer or Neozoic pole. This ingenious speculation does not interfere with my chief argu- ment, as based on facts which indicate great periods wherein few or no animals existed, followed by a long, invertebrate epoch. At the same time, let me repeat, that the earliest signs of living things, announcing as they do a high complexity of organization, entirely exclude the hypothesis of a transmutation from lower to higher grades of being. The first fiat of Creation which went forth, doubtlessly ensured the perfect adaptation of animals to the sur- rounding media ; and thus, whilst the geologist recognizes a begin- ning, he can see in the innumerable facets of the eye of the earliest crustacean*, the same evidences of Omniscience as in the comple- tion of the vertebrate form. Yet, however they admit the facts, some of my speculative con- temporaries think that they can so explain them, as not to justify the inference of progressive creations. They suppose, that nearly all the strata of date antecedent to those in which the first signs of life have * See Dr. Buckland's clear and beautiful illustration of this phenomenon in his Bridgwater Treatise. H H 3 470 SILURIA. [Chap. XVII. been detected, are often in so crystalline a state, that if they originally contained remains of animals, the traces of them must have been ob- literated by changes since effected in the structure of the rock. Now, if this supposition had been supported by the researches of late years, we must doubtless have admitted that the origin of life in the globe was buried in a hopeless obscurity. But the hypothesis has been set aside, as before explained, by the fact of the existence of deposits many thousands of feet thick, and scarcely at all altered, which, made up of sand, mud, and pebbles, constitute the very foundations of the fossil bearing strata. In these huge lower sediments a zoophyte only has been detected; but immediately above them, in various and distant countries, we perceive the oldest known small group of animals. If the opposing argument had been derived from the evidences collected in one region only, it might have been su£fi2:ested, that as the same formation which is barren in life over one district, teems with signs of it in another, so the infra- Silurian or bottom rocks (the Cambrian of the Geological Surveyors) may still prove to be fossiliferous. But, even if a few types should hereafter be discovered in those lower strata, the reasoning would in no wise change its character, if such infra-Silurian fossils were not found to pertain to higher forms of life, — a result which would be in manifest contradiction to all the ascertained facts respecting geological succession. Nor can we allow this hypothesis, founded on an exceptional possibility, to countervail the universal data that have been registered, and which demonstrate in many countries the unfos- siliferous character of the lowest sedimentary formations. Again, when the explorer of the older formations produces his specimens of fossils from various parts of the world, to show that the mass of the Silurian rocks contains all classes of marine life with the exception of fishes, his antagonist might reply, that gelatinous fishes, void of backbones (like the solitary little Amphioxus now living), may have been the only creatures of their class which swarm in the Chap. XVIII.] GEOLOGICAL HYPOTHESES. 471 broad seas then prevailing : and if so, that no traces of them could exist; their boneless bodies perishing and leaving no sign of their former existence. As an old student of Nature's works, I cannot allow this bare possibility to be placed in opposition to the very numerous and well recorded facts, which announce the perfection of all the other classes of the ancient submarine kingdom. If thousands of invertebrate animals have left their coverings behind, is it rational to suppose, that every form of the great class of fishes should be wanting in that framework which, whether consisting of dermal plates or of bony vertebras, characterizes them in the strata of all succeeding epochs ? Nay more, we see that in this same long period in which no traces of fishes appear, there specially prevailed a superabundance of cephalopods ; and as creatures of that structure are well known to be carnivorous, little doubt can be entertained, that they acted the part of fishes, and were the scavengers of the Silurian seas. Another hypothesis which has been advanced in opposition to the mass of positive evidence is, that although such earlier rocks are void of ichthyolites, the sediments may have all been formed in limited zones around the earth; just as it is believed by some naturalists, that there are seas subject to certain currents and conditions of the bottom in which no fishes are now living. But here, again, the applica- tion of such a theory is, I would suggest, still more negatived by the facts adduced. Silurian rocks similar in structure, and containing the same organic remains, are not confined to any one segment of the earth's surface however broad, but are largely developed in nearly all known regions. The argument is, therefore, untenable in face of the knowledge we have acquired, that amidst a profusion of all the other forms of aquatic life, fishes only are absent from strata of this early age. This prevalence of a widely spread, primeval ocean, and of a sur- face which had not yet been subjected to those innumerable variations H H 4 472 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. of outline which have since changed and modified the different climates of the earth, when connected with a belief in the former greater radiation of heat from its interior, are the chief data required to satisfy us, that physical conditions then prevailed, with which the nature and extensive spread of the earlier groups of animals are in harmony. Admitting that in the remote sedimentary periods, large areas of land (though probably of no very great altitude), as well as vast rivers, must have existed as sources of the enormous primeval deposits, we may still well believe that such lands were widely separated by seas ; and that hence we ought necessarily to meet with a smaller number of shore animals and a s^reater number of oceanic forms. Takino^ advantage of this simple fact, some persons have suggested, that we may have as yet discovered only the deep-sea products of the Silu- rian period ; and that when the true edges of its lands come to be detected, we may then find plants and many creatures now unknown to us. To this I confidently reply, that many proofs have already been adduced of lands which were contiguous to the marine Silurians, both Lower and Upper. Innumerable pebble beds, coral reefs, and trails of animals that crawled upon the mud, are the principal evidences required, and to these I will presently revert. It has also been said, that the great number of fioating shells or cephalopods, particularly the Orthoceratites, which abounded in the Silurian era, are in themselves indicators of deep seas, remote from land, into which, therefore, terrestrial spoils were little likely to be transported. Now, the Silurian chambered shells may, indeed, have required a certain depth of water, and yet many of them, like the Nautilus Pompilius of the present day, may have lived at no great distance from the land of that time. For, in the succeeding Carboniferous period, when the mountain limestone was formed, we find no lack of floating shells, and other mollusca equally charac- teristic of certain depths of water, and yet these are associated with Chap. XVIII.] PEIMEVAL CONDITIONS. 473 abundance of plants which were drifted from land ; simply, as I would say, because the earth then bore an arboreal or tree vegetation, whereof we can discover no traces in the Silurian time, notwith- standing the certain existence of contiguous lands and of large streams at that early period. So is it, indeed, in every subsequent formation of the geological series. Thus, in the secondary deposits of the Lias and Oolites, we meet with an equal, if not a greater, number of floating shells than in the Silurian. The Ammonites and Belemnites of that period, requiring the same depth of water, have taken the place of the Orthoceratites ; and yet associated with them, we have everywhere proofs of the proximity of the land, in the abundance of fossil plants and wood derived from terra Jirma, doubtless then much more extensive and diversified than in the earliest times, and also clothed with a rich vegetation. If the old continents and islands, which existed during the accumu- lation of the marine Silurian deposits had borne large trees, the numerous researches of geologists in all quarters of the globe must have brought to light some signs of them. For, whilst we know that there are rocks of considerable extent, which, from the fine nature of their materials, may probably have been deposited in an ocean at some distance from a shore (though we have as yet little or no evidence as to the accumulation of sediment in deep seas, where no currents prevail); there are, on the other hand, many Silurian districts of the Old and New World, where the form and structure of the deposits bespeak the action of waves and surge, and where the im- bedded seaweeds, zoophytes, and other remains, compel us to adopt the same view. And if the primeval fauna does aiford fewer spiral uni- valve shells, than are seen among the animals of the laminarian zones of our modern seas, we may suggest that shore lines, as we under- stand them, must have been much less numerous in primeval epochs than at the present day ; now that the surface has been diversified by lofty dividing ridges on the land and corresponding depressions 474 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. in the ocean. With this important reservation, we do, however, obtain as many of those signs of shores as we can expect to find in the earlier deposits. Take, for example, the illustrations of this point furnished by the American geologists, from a very wide extent of their country, where the strata are nearly horizontal, and where, without any ambiguity, our kinsmen have traced life downwards in the successive crusts of the earth, to the same primordial zone as their contemporaries have done in Britain*, Scandinavia, and Bohemia. The Americans have evidences in their lowest Silurian beds of numerous trails or tracks of animals, whether crustaceans or gasteropods, which moved over a film of mud or sand formed by one tide before another covered the impressions, and left them as proofs to future ages of layers which were deposited on the shores and edges of former lands. Again, in other Silurian beds of the far West, there exists the same abundance of coral reefs as in Britain, and the still stronger evi- dence of pebbly shores, which, though they must have been beaten by waves, never contain the trace of a land plant. Why, therefore, wander from such plain facts into the region of theory ? And why not admit what is, indeed, in accordance with all we have observed, that the very long Silurian era had nearly passed away before trees grew upon the land or fishes swam in the waters ? In the fundamental facts described in this volume, we cannot, therefore, but recognize arrangements, which, though perfect as respected all truly primeval creatures and plants, were essentially different from those of our own time. For, if the then existing con- tinents or islands had borne trees, some fragments of them must have been transported into adjacent estuaries, and mixed in the mud and sand, like the vegetables of every subsequent epoch, by the * Even after these pages were written, Mr. Salter has described a trail of the Hymenocmns vermicauda, in the Lingula Flags of North Wales (Lowest Silurian of the Geological Survey). See Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc. Lond. (May, 1854.) Chap. XVIII. j PKIMEVAL CONDITIONS. 475 agency of those great streams, of whose mechanical power we have such decisive proofs. The Silurian rocks extend over areas as large, if not larger, than any great system of the following periods ; and yet in them alone, I repeat, is there an entire absence of an arborescent vegetation, derived from the then adjacent lands. (See Appendix C.) And here it is well to remind the student of the wide, if not uni- versal spread of the primeval strata. In the annexed small general map of the world are represented all the regions over which one or more of the primeval fossil groups are known to exist, as well as those crystalline rocks, which were formed before, or are associated with them.* In viewing the dark tint of this map we may suppose, that when such extensive palaeozoic sea bottoms were raised into lands, the former continents, from which the sediments had been derived, were submerged. But be this as it may, it is a fact, that in all quarters of the globe, Silurian strata constantly lie in juxtaposition to the other overlying palaeozoic formations ; and hence it is impos- sible to apply to the lowest strata any reasoning which does not equally refer to those which repose upon them. For, as the Silu- rian rocks are constantly found in the same longitudes and latitudes as the Devonian and Carboniferous, why is it that in the one there are never found traces of vertebrata and land plants, and that in the same places, remains of both these classes abound in the other ? By no theoretical suggestion, therefore, can the fair inference be evaded, that things which did not exist during the Silurian period, were created in the very same tracts during the following ages. The uniformitarian who would explain every natural event in the earliest periods by reference to the existing conditions of being, is thus stopped at the very threshold of the palace of former life, * The reader must not be critical as to the exact demarcation assigned to the palaeozoic and crystalline rocks by the dark tint of this map, which marks the relative proportions of the primeval to the secondary and tertiary rocks. The chief intention is to direct the eye to all the regions where the older rocks prevail. 476 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIIL which he cannot deprive of its true foundations. Nature herself, in short, tells him through her most ancient monuments, that though she has worked during all ages on the same general principles of destruction and renovation of the surface, there was formerly a dis- tribution of land in reference to the sea, very different in outline from that which now prevails. That primeval state was followed by outbursts of great volumes of igneous matter from the interior, the extraordinary violence of which is made manifest by clear evidences. Fractures in the crust of the earth, accompanied by oscillations that suddenly displaced masses to thousands of feet above or beneath their previous levels, were necessarily productive of such translations of water, as to abrade and destroy solid materials, to an extent infinitely surpassing any change of which the historical era affords an example. I could here cite the works of Leopold von Buch, Elie de Beau- mont, Sedgwick, Studer*, and numerous other geologists, for count- less proofs of this grander intensity of former causation, by which gigantic masses were inverted, and strata forming mountains have been so wrenched, broken, and twisted, as to pass under the very rocks out of whose materials they were constructed. The reader who may travel to the Alps and other mountain chains, will there see signs of such former catastrophes, each of which resulted from convulsions utterly immeasurable and inexplicable by any reference to those puny oscillations of the earth which can be appealed to during the times of history. (For my own views on this point see Appendix Q.) But restraining my pen on these collateral points, I must adhere to our immediate subject, the proofs of successive creation coincident with such former conditions apart from great physical revolutions. If we reflect upon the succession presented to us in the primeval rocks, we have, I repeat, cumulative evidence, that the wide-spread * See particularly Studer's new work, ' Geologie der Schweiz,' vol. ii. 1853. XVIII.] PKIMEVAL AND SUBSEQUENT CONDITIONS. 477 and general diffusion of the same types of animal and vegetable life was due to a former temperature and outline of the surface essen- tially distinguished from those of our day. To whatever extent continents and islands may have existed during these long early periods, and however we may speculate on the extent of pristine shores, it seems certain, that the lands accessible to our survey and bearing any such vegetation, increased very considerably in the car- boniferous times. In those days, the very same species of marine animals lived, from the latitude of Spitzbergen to the parallels of Peru and Australia.* Yast, low deltas then also extended them- selves, which, on being desiccated, bore an absolutely uniform terres- trial vegetation nearly all over the globe. Many of the ancient tree ferns must have grown on tracts little above the water, and jungles larger than Britain must have been successively and repeatedly sub- merged and re-elevated to form new lands, covered by the vege- tation that supplied the elements for the construction of great coal- fields. These phenomena assure us, therefore, that a very great portion, if not the whole surface of the earth, enjoyed at that time an equable and warmer climate. (See Sketch, p. 268.) Believing, as I do, with many geologists, that this former tem- perature of the earth was, in great measure, caused by the radiation of its internal heat, independently of solar action, other physical as well as zoological phenomena lead me further to suppose, that the land of those early days could not have been thrown up into very lofty mountains. For, if so, such great elevations must have been accompanied by corresponding deep chasms in the sea bottom, and these would necessarily have been impassable barriers to the numerous primeval submarine creatures which have been described as co- existent over the most remote region. Profound abysses of the * See the observations of d'Orbigny, p. 409. Colonel Lloyd has just brought home from the Peruvian Andes several species of carboniferous mollusca identical with British forms. The same occur in Australia. See McCoy, Ann. Nat. Hist. 1847. 478 SILURIA. [Chap. XVIII. ocean are, it is well known, as complete barriers to the migration of marine creatures, as lofty mountains are to inhabitants of the land. The recent discovery, therefore, of the vast profundity of the ocean midway between the Cape of Good Hope and Cape Horn, amount- ing to 7000 fathoms or nearly double the height of the loftiest moun- tains (even allowing for some amount of error in the sounding), is, indeed, the strongest possible illustration of the impassable nature of such subaqueous barriers. These have resulted from oscillations of the surface, which occurring since primeval times, have necessarily caused great variations in the marine provinces of life, placing them in strong contrast with the uniformity of the ancient faunas. (See Appendix F.) Duly estimating the great value of the submarine knowledge acquired and applied by a naturalist, whose researches, coupled with those of Loven and other contemporaries, have thrown new lights on many phenomena previously unexplained, let us guard against the inference, that because such acquaintance with the natural operations of our own era is applicable to the last geological data or those of tertiary age, it should also apply to the quasi universal, and therefore very diiFerent, physical conditions under which pri- meval creatures existed. During the tertiary period, the crust of the earth had, as we know, approximated considerably to its pre- sent varied outline, and before it drew to a close, great changes had taken place, b)^ which regions formerly occupied by animals and plants requiring a warm and equable climate were covered even by ice and glaciers. Whilst, therefore, we thank Edward Forbes for dredging the sea bottoms, and teaching us that deep sea mollusks are now living near high lands in the Mediterranean, whence pebbles may be so washed down as to lie in juxtaposition with the tenants of the deep ; — either this argument cannot bear upon the primeval era, in which there is no evidence whatever of high lands and detached mediterranean seas; or if applied, it is the strongest evidence to Chap. XVIII.] PEIMEVAL AND SUBSEQUENT CONDITIONS. 479 show, that the supposed primeval cliffs and grounds were void of terrestrial vegetation. On what data, it may be asked, is founded the beautiful and rational theory of Lyell, which explains the successive changes of the climate of the earth ? Is it not mainly dependent on those diversified evolutions proceeding from beneath the surface, which have caused changes in the outline of former lands and seas, equivalent in extent, although different in position to, our present continents and oceans ? And, if such a varied distribution of earth and water as the present had existed in the pristine periods we have been considering, how could the same groups of animals, manifestly requiring the same conditions, the sa*me temperature, and the same food, have had an almost universal diffusion ? Although it is quite true, that specific distinctions are seen to have frequently prevailed in the fossils of the Lower Silurian rocks of coun- tries situated at no great distance from each other, as explained in the chapters which treat of the distribution of the fauna of that age, the fact is by no means antagonistic to my reasoning. Should it, for example, be even said, that the variety in the distribution of Silurian species is as great as in the same areas of sea of the present day, I reply, that it is not to species but to the classes, groups, and genera, that the objector must appeal. If unable to explain why in the ear- liest primeval times, so many Trilobites, Orthides, Orthoceratites, and Corals of analogous forms were spread out over enormous distances, it is enough for us to feel assured, that the various associates of the Calymene Blumenbachii, or any other well-known Trilobite, must have required just the same temperature and surrounding media in whatever part of the world they lived. It is not because the land animals of Europe are dissimilar in species to those of Africa that the faunas of the two regions are so distinct, but that we have not among our European associates the same groups as those which live in hotter climes. I therefore conceive, that the fact of the diffusion of the 480 SILURIA. [Chap. XYIII. same families and genera of Trilobites, Corals, and other fossils, however they may vary as to species, must have required an equably diffused temperature and similar conditions for their existence. Still more clearly is this inference sustained by the spread of the same old vegetation, and often of the same species of plants over half the globe. Resting then on these universal facts as a firm basis, the geologist who explores his way upwards, sees, as before stated, that the forma- tions which w^ere next accumulated in the same latitudes and longi- tudes as the Silurian rocks, and sometimes in actual and conformable contact with them, do contain land plants mixed with marine remains. And yet the only unequivocal vegetables found in the elder strata are sea-weeds ; whilst the later formed and contiguous rocks, though equally charged with exuviae of the sea, are laden with many spoils of the land, both vegetable and animal. Patient researches having thus demonstrated, that in the primeval eras all living things differed completely from those of our own times, so we see how the animals subsequently created, were adapted to new and altered physical conditions. Proceeding onwards from the early period in which we can trace no sign of land plants or ver- tebrata, and in which the solid materials, inclosing everywhere a similar fauna, were spread out with great uniformity, we soon begin to perceive the proofs of powerful revolutions, chiefly commencing after the coal formation*, by which the earth's surface was so corrugated, * I by no means deny that much perturbation prevailed in the earlier stages of the planet, as explained in the two first chapters. On the contrary, I admit the powerful emission of much igneous matter, the transmutation of sedimentary into crystalline rocks, and the presence of great terrestrial masses anterior to the accu- mulation of any of the deposits which are now under consideration. But I deny that there are indications of the existence of any very lofty mountains, until the crust of the earth had undergone some of the subsequent mutations alluded to ; particularly those which followed the accumulation of the carboniferous strata., and which were repeated at so many subsequent periods, notably and powerfully in the tertiary times. Chap. XVIII.] CONCLUSION-. 481 that, after many perturbations, the groups of animals and plants were infinitely more restricted than before to given regions and climates. And, as the highly diversified conditions of the latest geological era and of the present day were wholly unknown in the primeval epochs, so it follows, that we should greatly err, if we endeavoured to force all ancient nature into a close comparison with existing operations. (See Alps, Appendix Q.) The numerous, positive evidences of a former wide distribution of similar animals and plants, enable us fairly to bring before our mind's eye the physical geography of those great epochs when such large portions of our present continents were under the waters, and forests of tree-ferns occupied very extensive low lands, subjected during a long period to numerous oscillations. Not less clearly do we infer from other physical evidences, how eruptive forces subsequently acted ; breaking out with great violence after the close of the car- boniferous era, and throwing the strata into those grand undulations and contortions, accompanied by stupendous fractures, which have given to the coal basins their curvatures and limits. Thenceforward was continued that lons^; series of additional and repeated emissions of volcanic matter from within, of elevations of the sea bottom, and corresponding depressions of land, combined with the metamorphism of strata (these changes being often accompanied by corresponding new creations of animals suited to the existing conditions), during the secondary and tertiary periods. By these great physical operations, our planet was eventually brought to possess the climatal relations which have for so long a time prevailed. That these elevations and depressions finally produced a state of things altogether distinct from that of the earlier eras, is, in short, registered by a multitude of well-attested data. Among the terrestrial changes to which science clearly points, there is no one which better deserves to be recorded in a few parting words, than that great mutation of surface and its accompanying I I 482 SILURIA. [Chap. XVllI. loss of warmth, by which extensive fields of ice were first formed upon the sea, and large glaciers upon the land. As very lofty mountains in moderate latitudes, and masses of land and water in Arctic or Antarctic regions, are now essentially the seats of glaciers and ice- rafts ; so we know that these bodies alone have the power of trans- porting huge, erratic blocks from their native mountains to con- siderable distances by land, or for hundreds of miles over the sea in floating icebergs. Now, of the translation of such blocks we have no evidence whatever in any former geological period ! On the contrary, whilst every boulder of the primary, secondary, or older tertiary rocks bears on its surface the signs of having been water- worn or rounded by aqueous or atmospheric agency, the great blocks of the later cold period (gigantic in comparison with all that preceded them) are often angular or nearly in that state in which they left the mountain side, before, in short, they were wafted over seas or lakes to be dropped, at remote distances from their parent rocks, upon sediments which by subsequent elevation have been made portions of our continents. Hence, independently of the indications of a more equably diffused and warmer temperature in older times than at the present day, these large erratics are in themselves decisive testimonials of that intense cold which, it is believed, was principally due to the great, elevated masses of land which specially characterize the modern period. Receding backwards from this glacial phenomenon, which con- tinuing into our own times, has been so skilfully illustrated by eloquent writers*, it is specially my province to endeavour to impress upon the reader the Importance of endeavouring to form an esti- mate of the physical geography of the earth during those remote periods when the Palasozoic deposits were accumulated. If very lofty mountains did not then exist, we have, indeed, in this single phe- * Charpentler, Agasslz, and James Forbes. (See Appendix Q). Chap. XVIII.] CONCLUSION^. 483 nomenon, what may have been one of the chief causes of that equable and warm climate so indispensably requisite to harmonize with the facts recorded in this volume. And if we add the inference adopted by many philosophers and geologists, that the earth, in cooling down from its original molten state, must, during long succeeding ages, have diminished in heat over its whole surface, we are enabled, by reference to physical changes alone, to satisfy ourselves, that w^e have in them the chief elements required to explain all climatal results. Finally, if this retrospective survey of the changes of the earth be but the outline of a picture which must be filled up by an assiduous study of the works of nature, let me say that it has not been at- tempted without deliberate consideration and extensive researches amid the younger as well as the most ancient deposits. And, if any theoretical portions of the preceding pages be objected to, they can easily be separated from those historical facts which are established upon positive observation. The leading object of this volume is simply to call attention to the oldest vestigea of life which have been discovered in the crust of the globe, and accurately to chronicle the order in which other early races followed them. From the effects produced upon my own mind through the study of these imperishable records, I am, indeed, led to hope, that my readers will adhere to the views which, in common with many con- temporaries, I entertain of the succession of life. For, he who looks to a beginning, and traces thenceforward a rise in the scale of being, until that period is reached when Man appeared upon the earth, must acknowledge in such works repeated manifestations of design, and unanswerable proofs of the superintendence of a Creator. FINIS. I APPENDIX. Vertical Range of Silurian Fossils, The following table is designed to show the number of species ascertained to be common to the Lower and Upper Divisions of the Silurian System. It is compiled by Mr. Salter, chiefly from data in the Museum of Practical Geology, and those supplied by Prof. M'Coy in his descriptions of the fossils in the Woodwardian Museum of Cambridge. A few other works have been referred to, but it has been thought best not to swell the list from less authentic sources. Where the species has been catalogued in the lists of the Geological Survey, the authority is marked G. S., for its occurrence either in the Lower or the Upper Silurian. W. M. signifies those species for which Professor M'Coy is responsible in the work above alluded to. There being at present a difference of opinion as to the precise geolo- gical relations of the ' Upper Caradoc ' (some authors regarding it as the base of the Upper, and others as the top of the Lower Silurian), this band has been omitted in the first estimate. If it be included in the Lower Silurian Division, as in the original Silurian System and in this work, the number of species common to the two divisions would be considerably increased above the number indicated in this Table. Note. — A few of the species quoted by Professor M'Coy as occurring in the Lower Division are omitted ; there being reason to doubt their geological position. Lower Silurian (Llandeilo and Caradoc*). Species which range from the Llandeilo into the Wenlock or Ludlow Formations. Upper Silurian. (Wenlock and Ludlow). Foreign Upper Silurian. G. S. G. S. Graptolithus priodon, Bronn. - Retiolites Geinitzianus, Barr. - G. S. G. S.? Barrande (Bohemia) Only the lower or typical Caradoc is here intendtd, *i I 3 486 APPENDIX. Lower Silurian and Caradoc). Species which range from Ihe Llandeilo into the Wenlock or Ludlow Formations. Upper Silurian (Wenlock and Ludlow). Foreign Upper Silurian. Kjr. O. Stromatopora striateila, D Orb. (jr. O. (jr. S. Helioiites interstincta, vVanl. - G. S. W. M. petallitormis, Lonsd. G. S. AV. M. tuDulata, Lonsd. G. S. G. S. megastoma, M'Coy - MilneEdw. M'Coy inordinata, Lonsd. IVTi 1 n p TT.fl w irxiiuc Xjyi »v • G. S. Favosites alveolaris, Goldf. G. S. G. S. Gothlandica, Linn. - G. S. G. S. Stenopora (Favosites) fibrosa, Goldf., G. S. both the branched and amorphous varieties. G. S. Halysites catenulatus, Linn. - G. S. W.M. Nebulipora papillata, M'Coy - W. M. W. M. Omphyma turbinata, Linn. G.S. G. S. Sarcinula organum, Linn. Milne Edw. (Gottland) Lonsdale Petraia bina, Lonsd. - - _ G. S. I IjitHiUUV J G. S. Ptilodictya lanceolata, Goldf. - G S G. S. Glauconome disticha, Goldf. G S W. M. Fenestella Milleri, Lonsd. G. S. W.M. subantiqua, D'Orb. - G. S. G. S. Cornulites serpularius, Schloth. G. S. G. S. Tentaculites annulatus, Schloth. G. S.? \Y. M. ornatus. Sow. G. S. W M oerpuiiies uibpdr, odiier - W. M. ? Tt ■ 1 • X I. 1 J- 1T^•• 3 Beyrichia tuberculata, Kloden G. S. G S. Cyphaspis megalops, M'Coy G. S. • G. S. Lichas bulbiceps, Phi 11. & Salter G. S. G. S. anglicus, Beyrich G. S. Eichvvald verrucosus, Eichw. G. S. (Russia) G. S. Acidaspis Brightii, Murch. G. S. G. S. Cheirurus bimucronatus, Murch. G. S. APPENDIX. 487 Lower Silurian (Llandeilo and Caradoc). W. M. Barrande G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S.? G. S. G. S. W.M. Sowerby G. S. G. S. G. S. W.M. G. S.? W. M. W.M. W.M. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. W. M. G. S. G.S. G.S. G. S. G. S. W.M. G. S. Species which range from the Llandeilo into the Wenlock or Ludlow Formations. j- Staurocephalus Murchisoni, Barr. Encrinurus punctatus, Briinnich. Phacops caudatus, Brongn. Stokesii, Milne Edw. Calymene Blumenbachii, Brongn. Proetus latifrons, M'Coy Stokesii, Murch. Crania (Patella) implicata, Sow. Spirifer crispus, Linn. - plicatellus (radiatus), Linn. Atrypa reticularis, Linn. marginalis, Dalm. cuneata, Dalm. - Rhynchonella depressa, Sow. - borealis, Schloth. Lewisii, Davidson Nucula, Sow. rotunda, Sow. Pentamerus undatus, Sow. (the same as P. linguifer, Sow. ?) - Orthis biloba. Linn. _ - . calli gramma, Dalm. elegantula, Dalm. hybrida. Sow. - insularis, Pander reversa, Salter - testudinaria, Dalm. Strophomena rhomboidalis, Wabl. (depressa, Dalm. and of this work) pecten, Linn. ■ simulans, M'Coy corrugata, Portl. - *i I 4 Upper Silurian (Wenlock and Ludlow). G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G.S G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. W. M. G. S. G.S. G.S. W. M. G. S. 488 APPENDIX. Lower Silurian (LlandeUo and Caradoc). Species which range from the Llandeilo into the Wenlock or Ludlow Formations, Upper Siliurian (Wenlock and Ludlow). Foreign Upper Silurian. G. S. Strophomena antiquata, Sow. - G. S. G. S. euglypha, Dalm. G. S. de Vemeuil imbrex, Pander. G. S. Davidson. W.M. Leptaena laevigata, Sow. - G. S, W.M. minima, Sow. - - - G. S. G. S. quinquecostata, M'Coy W.M.? G. S. sericea. Sow. - G. S. G. S. transversalis, Dalm. - G. S. W.M. Pterinea pleuroptera, Conrad - W . M. G. S. retroflexa, Wahl. G. S. W. M.? tenuistriata, M'Coy - W. M. TT. ^L Modiolopsis antiqua. Sow, G.S. W.M. Orthonotus semisulcatus, Sow. G. S. G. S. Cardiola interrupta, Goldf. G. S. W.^L Area Ldmonduformis, M'Coy W.M. W. M. OucuUella (Clidophorus r) antiqua, Sow. - - - - - G. S. Xucula Anglica, D'Orb. (ovalis, Sil. Sj-st.) G. S. G. S. Acroculia (Z^erita) Haliotis, Sow. - G.S. G. S.? Theca Forbe-sii. Sharps - G.S. (Hamage (T. triangularis. Hall, is a distinct Lower Grange, SUarian species, found in Scotland.) Shropshire.) G. S. Conularia Sowerbji, Defrance (C. cancellata, Sandberger and M'Coy) Lr. o. G. S. Scalites (irocnus) lenticularis, bow. *V . AL (jr. i5. rSelleropnon culatatus, oow. n G Kjr. b. W.M.? expansus, Sow. - G. S. G.S. trilobatus, Sow. - G.S. G. S. carinatus, Sow. G. S. G. S. Orthoceras angulatum, Hisinger G. S. W. M. filosum, Sow. G. S. G.S. annulatum, Sow. - G. S. W.M. laqueatum, HalL - ^y. M. APPENDIX. 489 Lower Silurian (Llandeilo and Caradoc). Species which range from the Llandeilo into the Wenlock or Ludlow Formations. Upper Silurian (Wenlock and Ludlow). Foreign Upper Silurian. G. S. Orthoceras primasvum, Forbes G. S. G. S. subundulatum, Portl. W.M. G. S. tenuicinctum, Portl. G. S. W. M. ■ ventricosum, Sliarpe G. S. G. S. Ibex, Sow. - - - G. S. G.S. subannulatum W. M. G. S. Lituites cornu-arietis, Sow. G. S. 96 species Llandeilo Formation. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. W.M. W.M. G. S. W. M. Hall (America) G. S. G. S. W.M. 18 species Additional Llandeilo Species "which range into the ' Upper Caradoc ' or intermediate formation, but not into the Wenlock or Ludlow rocks. Petraia elongata, Phill. - - - Trinucleus concentricus - - - Spirifer (Atrypa) percrassus, M'Coy Atrypa hemispherica, Sow. Pentamerus globosus, Sow. oblongus, Sow. lens, Sow. - - - undatus, Sow. Orthis Actoniae, Sow. - - - vespertilio, Sow. - Strophomena compressa, Sow. Rhynchonella decemplicata, Sow. Modiolopsis orbicularis. Sow. - Clidophorus ovalis, M'Coy Nucula? post-striata, Emmons Holopella cancellata, Sow. Pleurotomaria (like P. balteata,Plijll.) Bellerophon subdecussatus, M'Coy - Upper Caradoc. G. S. G. S. W.M. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. Forbes G. S. G. S. G. S. G. S. W. M. W. M. G. S. G. S. W. M. A marked species. 490 APPENDIX. If, instead of regarding it as a distinct intermediate formation, the Caradoc band be classed either with the Upper or the Lower Silurian, these species must, in that case, be added to those before given; thus making a total of 114 species common to the Lower and Upper groups. It is believed that many more species exist in the Upper Caradoc forma- tion which occur also in the Llandeilo flags. No notice has been here taken of the very peculiar assemblage of fossils found in the Silurian sandstones of Galway. These beds constitute, as explained in the text (p. 170.,) a considerable thickness of Silurian strata. If they be classed with the ' Upper Caradoc ' or intermediate formation, 10 or 12 more very characteristic Lower Silurian fossils must be added to the above common list. Or, if they be regarded as equivalents of the Llandeilo or Bala rocks, to which, as developed in the South of Scotland, they bear a strong analogy, then the unity of the Silurian System is still more sustained, inasmuch as they are crowded with characteristic Upper Silurian species ; no less than 63 common Upper Silurian forms, associated with the above-mentioned and other Llandeilo flag species, being found in this single district. B. Recent Surveys of the British Silurian Rocks, There are some points of detailed research made while the work was in progress, to which I may here direct attention. Certain typical tracts of the British Silurian rocks have been re-surveyed by the Government geologists, and results have been obtained which seem to me to support the inferences recorded in the text. In re-visiting North Wales, and in searching for more complete fossil evidences in the 'Lingula Flags, or Lowest Silurian' of the Survey, Mr. Salter has made important additions to our knowledge by the discovery of fossils, which prove that this deposit, like the protozoic band described by M. Barrande in Bohemia, has a marked and peculiar facies. At the same time, it is to be remembered that two of the few genera of Trilobites in this lowest zone of life, (Agnostus and Olenus), occur also in the Llandeilo or Bala group. A few words are also called for to remove any doubt respecting the zoolo- gical contents of the strata that constitute the intermediate or debateable ground, now termed Upper Caradoc, between the Lower and Upper Silurian. In truth, the whole of the formation which I grouped under the term of Caradoc, having undergone a special scrutiny by Professor Ramsay, and Messrs. Salter and Aveliue (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. x. p. 62.), ArrENDix. 491 has been divided by those authors into lower and upper parts, the former constituting by its fossils a portion of the Llandeihj or Bala formation. This fact is partially alluded to above (pp. 80. 86. 97. et seq.), and it has been rendered clearer since my pages were printed. The partition just effected, was, indeed, previously suggested, on fossil evidence, by Professors Sedgwick and M'Coy.* But in respect to Shropshire, the Government Surveyors have proved, that the older of these shelly sandstones, as ex- hibited along the flanks of Caer Caradoc, is, as I described it, laden with fossils which are identical with types of the Llandeilo formation, most of which were published in my original work. Even in the * Silurian System,' p. 305. pi. 32. fig. 9. and elsewhere, the geologist will see that, although I was unacquainted with the division recently indicated of Lower and Upper Caradoc, the rocks of Meifod, described as Caradoc sandstone, are truly the same in fossil contents as the greater mass of the rocks on the flanks of Caer Caradoc itself, which are now classed by the Government Surveyors as Llandeilo. My general term for all such rocks, whether sandy, flag -like, schistose, or slaty, was and is simply Lower Silurian.' The same fossils, indeed, not only pervade the districts of Shropshire and Mont- gomeryshire, or the Lower Silurian of my old map, but spread over North Wales, down to the Snowdon slates, and even below that horizon; and thus the reasoning I formerly employed in urging the broad application of the term * Lower Silurian' is sustained to an extent much beyond my early anticipations. For, until the physical structure and fossil con- tents of the whole region had been precisely elaborated, no one could have imagined, that the soft shelly sandstones on the sides of Caer Caradoc were of the same age as the hard, slaty rocks of Bala and Snowdon ! The Upper Caradoc, on the contrary, as seen under the shale of Wenlock Edge, where it is now shown to be transgressive to the older strata, and conformable to the Wenlock shale, or in the tract north of Bishop's Castle, where it flanks unconformably the southern ends of the Longmynd and Shelve districts, or as ranging along the west flank of the Abberley and Malvern Hills to May Hill, or, again, as re-appearing in Radnorshire and adjacent parts of Wales, is unquestionably of an intermediate character. I classed this rock with the Lower Silurian, chiefly from its mineral cha- racters and infra position to the Wenlock shale and limestone, and as indicating the highest sandstone of the lower group ; and also because two or three of its fossils which seemed to me most characteristic * Quart. Journ. Geol. See. Lend. vol. ix. p. 215. 492 APPENDIX. are not found in the Upper Silurian division. Hence I have adhered to my old tabular arrangement. But I must now clearly state, that whilst in Shropshire and Radnorshire this upper sandstone retains such forms of the Lower Caradoc and Llandeilo strata, as Pentamerus oblongus and Atrypa hemispherica, it is charged in many places, particularly at May Hill, as indicated by Professors Sedgwick and M*Coy, with numerous species of the overlying Wenlock formation, which here make their appear- ance, for the first time, in the ascending order. Whatever, therefore, may be its name, whether Upper Caradoc, May Hill Sandstone, or Lower Wenlock grit, it is truly a transition band, which unites the Lower and Upper Silurian, and is to be regarded as identical with the stratum I have described as occupying the same position in E-ussia, and with that in America which is known by the name of the Clinton Group. It must here also be noted, that the transgression recently detected in Shropshire, between the lower and upper Caradoc, is a local pheno- menon, which does not extend to large portions even of the annexed map. The Government Surveyors have, indeed, published sections across the Silurian rocks of Wales, which, as in America, Bohemia, and many foreign countries, exhibit conformable passages between all the strata, from those of azoic age, through the Llandeilo and Caradoc, to the true Upper Silurian of Wenlock and Ludlow inclusive. c. Traces of Vegetable Matter in the Silurian and older Rocks, Although, as stated in the preceding pages, no remains of plants have been discovered below the Ludlow rocks, which are recognizably of ter- restrial origin, I have long known of the presence both of bitumen and anthracite in even the oldest greywacke, or the Longmynd rocks (see Sil. Syst. p. 261. et seq.) Theoretically I have inferred that these substances were derived from masses of sea-weeds. (See Russia and Ural Moun- tains, p. 14., Nicol, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. iv. p. 204., and Harkness, ib. vol. viii. p. 393.) In justice, however, to my friend Professor Nicol, it is right to state, that he detected under the microscope, a tubular^ fibrous structure in the ashes of anthracite derived from the Lower Silurian greywacke of Peebleshire, and also observed, among those rocks in Liddesdale, fragments of what he supposed might be reeds, like the imperfect remains of such vegetables in APPENDIX. 493 the coal sandstones. (Quart. Journ. Geol. See. Lond., vol. vi.) In any en- deavour to form a correct view of the origin of life, it is doubtless im- portant to try to settle this point by a rigid scrutiny. But, even if these very rare vegetable remains should prove to belong to the land and not to the sea, my general argument would not be invalidated by the existence of a very scanty terrestrial Flora (not amounting in size to arborescence) which was coincident with the first traces of animal life. Mr. John Kelly informs me that anthracite has been discovered in the old greywacke of Cavan, Ireland, the courses of which dip with the strata. D. Unconformity in Ireland of the Longmyndor Bottom Rocks Cambrian^ of the Survey^ to the Lower Silurian, An excellent and clear account of this phenomenon, with sections, has been published by Mr. J. Beete Jukes, the director of the Survey in Ireland, and Mr. Andrew Wyley, entitled, " On the Structure of the N« Eastern part of the County of Wicklow." (Proc. Geol. Soc. Dublin, December, 1853.) It would appear that the black slates ranging from the counties Wicklow and Wexford, to Dublin, and forming the inferior portion of the Lower Silurian rocks of the S.E. of Ireland, rest quite unconformably on the upturned edges of the so-called * Cambrian ' rocks* The Lingula flags seem to be absent. The physical relations of these rocks in Ireland are therefore distinct from those of Wales, Siluria, Bohemia, Scandinavia, and parts of N. America, where such inferior masses are perfectly conformable to the Lowest Silurian with fossils. On the other hand, their position in Ireland accords with the physical disruption noticed in France by Elie du Beaumont and Dufrenoy, where the * primor* dial zone' of Lingula flags is also wanting. E. Barrande^s Silurian System in Bohemia, In addition to what is stated (p. 340. et seq.) I may here take notice of a few memoranda made by myself last summer in the cabinet of M. Bar- 494 APPENDIX. rande at Prague, though they imperfectly allude to phenomena which he has described or will describe in full detail. Among the Bohemian graptolites the C. priodon (Ludensis^ Sil. Syst.) is beautifully preserved, — its smaller end is incurvated. Of corals there occur quite as many Silurian forms as are known in England, perhaps seventy or eighty. The Cystideas of the Lower Silurian (stage D. of Barrande) are occasionally of great size, and some of them, resembling the Echino-encrinites of Scan- dinavia and Russia, ascend into the stage E. or Upper Silurian. Among the Cephalopoda the Orthoceratites (Foss. 59. p. 326.), with a large lateral siphuncle, are as rare as in Britain — shells which are very common in Russia and Sweden. In reference to one group of Ortho- ceratites, M. Barrande shows how a field geologist may erroneously re- cognize forms as identical, from a perfect similarity of outline, but which are clearly distinct when the ornamental features of the shelly covering are magnified. The profusion of chambered shells in the basin of Prague has enabled him to trace many gradations between the generic types Gompho- ceras, Phragmoceras, Troclioceras, Cyrtocera?, &c. ; and in the centre of two specimens of these he has detected animal matter in the state of Adipocere! These bodies are, therefore, he justly considers, the oldest mummies ever exhumed ; since they occur in Lower Silurian rocks with Trinuclei ! The most ancient Xautilus yet found is probably the N. tyrannus Barr., a huge form of a genus which, as mentioned in the text, the author has traced through all its stages of growth. There are some Goniatites of forms approaching Nautilus ; but no species is a known Devonian type ; not even in the very highest strata near Prague. It may also be remarked, that the singular genus of bivalves of the Lower Silurian rocks of Busaco, described as Ribeiria by Mr. D. Sharpe, occurs also in the middle of the Lower Silurian of Bohemia. Besides the genera of Trilobites enumerated at p. 342. of this work, as occurring in the primordial or lowest zone, that band also contains the minute Hydro- cephalus, so named by Barrande from its monstrous head, and the Ario- nellus, a large flat form, as yet unknown elsewhere. In the mass of the Lower Silurian, or stage D. of the author, occur the Beyrichia (Agnostus) lata of Sweden and America, and the Acidaspis Buchi, described also by M. Bertrand Geslin from rocks of this age near Nantes ; whilst the Cytherinae (of which there are about twenty species) range from the Lower Silurian to the highest of the Upper Silurian limestones. Space does not permit of an examination of the analogies and identities APPENDIX. 495 prevailing among the Bracliiopods and Gasteropods of the basin of Pragiief as compared with those of Silurian age in other countries. Suffice it to say, that when fully elaborated, the whole of the fossils will probably amount, under the discrimination of M. Barrande, to about 1500 species! F. Depth of the Primeval Seas, and colouring of the Shells of the 3IoU lusca which lived in them. In discussing the subject of the probable depth of the primeval seas, it might have been inferred, that assuming the quantity of water upon the surface of the earth to have been constantly the same, it necessarily follows that during those long periods when the crust had undergone comparatively few variations of outline, there must have been a great uniformity in the depth of the waters. This inference has been incidentally strengthened by Professor E. Forbes, who having shown in a short memoir recently read before the Royal Society, that no mollusca which live beneath the depth of 50 fathoms exhibit those distinct pattern-colours which mark the shells of the animals inhabiting higher zones, brought this observation to bear on the fact, that some palaeozoic types (specially those of the carboniferous age) still retained their colours, and hence that such animals could not have lived at any great profundity or far removed from the influence of light. MM. d'Archiac and de Verneuil did, indeed, advert many years ago (1839, Trans. Geol. Soc. Lond. vol. vi. p. 360.) to shells of Devonian age which were partially coloured, and Mr. Salter has called my attention to Silurian fossils in the Government Museum which also exhibit colour. G. Extension of Silurian Rocks in Spain. Since the text was printed, I learn that M. Casiano de Prado has dis- covered Graptolites in several parts of the Guadarrama chain, where they occur in black schists associated with large masses of silicious grits (quarzites). This enterprising geologist has also traced such schists to near Salamanca, and has further satisfied himself, that there is an absolute 496 APPENDIX. continuity of Lower Silurian rocks from the Sierra Morena into GalHcia ; the range passing through Estramadura and by the Sierras of Gata and Francia. Most of the mountains which, extending from S. to N. form the boundary between Spain and Portugal may thus be considered to be of the same age. The Sierra Morena and the environs of Almaden have again been specially explored by M. Casiano de Prado, who has prepared a geological map of that tract, which will shortly appear in the Bulletin of the Geolo- gical Society of France, and has discovered many Silurian and Devonian fossils which will be described by MM. Barrande and de Verneuil. The Silurian rocks (lower) are very rich in Trilobites, and have already afforded about 20 species of those crustaceans, among which occur the greater number of the forms described by Mr. Sharpe from Portugal (p. 404.) ; such as Calymene Tristani, Phacops socialis, P. Dujardini, Placoparia Tournemini, Illa3nus Lusitanicus, &c. An important suggestion too has been made by M. de Prado, and par- tially confirmed by M. Barrande, viz. that the equivalent of the primordial zone, with its peculiar fauna, exists in Spain. One imperfect fossil only has however been yet found. MM. de Verneuil and de Loriere liave also detected Silurian rocks in two ridges directed from N.N.W. to S.S.E», which range from near Moncayo towards Montalban in Aragon. H. Foramtnifera in the Silurian Rocks. Mr. H. C. Sorby has the merit of having been the first to discover Foraminifera under the microscope in the Silurian Rocks. The forms in the Aymestry or Ludlow Limestone (the black limestone of Sedgley) are very clearly recognisable ; those of the Wenlock Limestone (from Easthope) being less so. These Foraminifera are related to the genus Endothyra^ found by Professor Phillips in the Mountain Limestone of Yorkshire and Westmoreland. I regret that 1 was unacquainted with an able memoir of Mr. Sorby on Slaty Cleavage when the earlier chapters were printed. (See Edin. New Phil. Journ., 1853.) APPENDIX. 497 I. Supposed Anomaly at Neffiez in France explained. Allusion having been made (p. 393.) to a physical intermixture of Silurian with Carboniferous fossils at this one little spot in the South of France, I have the satisfaction to announce, that M. Fournet himself, who first described the phenomenon, is now convinced that it is simply due to a violent contortion and inversion of the strata, as suggested by de Ver- neuil, and supported by myself, (p. 394.) K. Australian Gold. The reader who may wish to be acquainted with the amount of the pro- duce, as well as with the history and nature of the Australian Gold Mines, will find a clear and able digest of the whole subject by M. Delesse, of Paris, printed in the Annales des Mines, 1853, Tom. iii. Serie 5, p. 185. The same memoir was printed in the " Moniteur." L. Produce of Silver. In confirmation of the view taken (p. 457.) of the future augmentation of the quantity of silver, and in allusion to Humboldt's anticipation of that increase mentioned in the note of that page, let me say, that the same illustrious friend again expressed his conviction to that effect to me last autumn, in Berlin, and reminded me that Spain (the seat of the richest silver mines in the days of Hannibal) had of late years proved to be argentiferous to a prodigious extent. M. Silurian Rocks in Silesia, Since this work was printed. Professor Goppert, of Breslau, has informed me, that Graptolites have been found in rocks underlying the well-known Devonian formations of Silesia (see p. 338.), thus leading us to suppose that adequate researches will elucidate a similar succession in other parts of Germany. K K 498 APPENDIX. N. Pal(2ozoic Rocks in Asia Minor. M. Pierre de Tchihatclieff has just communicated to the French Insti- tute a sketch of the succession of Silurian, Devonian, and Carboniferous rocks in Asia Minor. (Comptes Rendus, 3 Avril, 1854.) The newly dis- covered large coal-field near Eregli (Heraclea) on the Black Sea, is in the Carboniferous Limestone. 0. Discoveries along the Flanks of the Malvern Hills, My friend the Rev. W. S. Symonds, F. G. S., (who has obligingly prepared the Index of this work,) has recently informed me that, in sinking shafts on the new railroad from Worcester to Hereford, the Woolhope beds have been observed in nearly vertical position opposite Winning Farm, on the west flank of the ridge. The strata at this place are charged with Bumastus Barriensis, and other characteristic fossils. Again, in a deep excavation for the foundation of the new house of Messrs, Burrows' at Great Malvern, a bright red sandstone was found beneath the detritus of the hill, and quarried to the depth of twenty feet, dipping to the east at an angle of 70^. The age of this rock, whether Triassic or Permian, has not yet been determined. p. Other Reptilian Remains in the Permian Rocks of Russia, My friend Major Wangenheim von Qualen, to whom my associates and myself were much indebted for information respecting the structure of the Permian Rocks of Orenburg, has since our visit detected bones of another reptile which occurs, not like the remains of the Rhopalodon (Fischer) in the sandstone and conglomerate, but in the limestone of the formation. The preservation of the head of this animal has enabled M. Eichwald to assign to it the name of Zygosaurus Lucius, and to compare it with the crocodile. On referring M. Eichwald's description (Bull. Soc. Imp. Nat. Moscow, 1852, No. 4.) to Professor Owen, that celebrated comparative anatomist thus writes to me: — "The characters which M. Eichwald points out in his fossil, as resembling those in the crocodile, also occur in APPENDIX. 499 the fossil skulls of the Labyrinthodont reptiles ; and the observation upon the number and comparatively small size of the teeth, in the Permian reptile, would lead to a suspicion that it may really belong to the Laby- rinthodont family. All doubt would be removed by an inspection of the occiput of M. Eichwald's fossil ; if that part presented a single condyle for articulation with the neck-vertebrae, it would determine the accuracy of his views of its affinities : but if the occiput showed a pair of condyles it would prove the fossil to be a Sauroid Batrachian." Q. On the former Changes of the Alps. (This abstract of a discourse addressed to the Royal Institution, March 7th, 1851, is given, to illustrate briefly the chief mutations of a moun- tain chain in comparatively recent geological periods.) The complicated structure of the Alps so baffled the penetration of de Saussure, that after a life of toil, the great and original historian of those mountains declared, 'there was nothing constant in them except their variety.' In citing this opinion. Sir Roderick Murchison explained how that obscurity had since been gradually cleared away by the application of modern geology, as based upon the succession of organic remains. He then proceeded to specify the accumulations of which the Alps were com- posed, and to mark the changes or revolutions they had undergone, be- tween the truly primeval days when the earliest recognizable animals were created, and the first glacial period in the history of the planet. His object being to convey, in a popular manner, clear ideas of the physical condition of these mountains at different periods, he prepared for the occasion three long scene-paintings, which represented a portion of the chain at three distinct epochs. The first of these views of ancient nature exhibited the Alps as a long, low archipelago of islands, formed, in great part, out of the Silurian and older sediments which had been raised above the sea; the lands bearing the tropical vegetation of the carboniferous era. (See woodcut, p. 268.) He then stated that there were in the Alps no relics of the formations to which, as marking the close of the primeval or palaeozoic age, he had assigned the name of Permian, and rapidly reviewed the facts gathered together by many geologists from all quarters of the globe, maintaining that they unequivocally sustained the belief, that there had been a succes- K K 2 500 APPENDIX. sion of creations gradually rising from lower to higher types of life, as we ascend from inferior to superior formations. He carefully, however, noted the clear distinction between such a creed, as founded -on the true records of creation, and the theory of transmutation of species ; a doctrine from which he entirely dissented. In the second painting (an immense lapse of time being supposed to have occurred), the Alps were represented as a mountainous ridge in which all the submarine formations from the secondary to the older ter- tiary or Eocene had been elevated upon the flank of the primeval rocks. Each rock system was distinguished by a colour peculiar to it, and the nature of the animals contained in each of these deposits was succinctly touched upon. Between the youngest of the primary formations and the oldest of the secondary rocks, it was stated, that there is not one species in common in any part of Europe ; the expression being that " an entirely new creation had succeeded to universal decay and death." In speaking of the Alpine equivalents of the British Lias and Oolites, Sir R. paid a sincere tribute to Dr. Buckland, who led the way, thirty years ago, in recognizing this parallel. Leopold von Buch was also par- ticularly alluded to as having established such and other comparisons, and as having shown the extent to which large portions of these mountains have been metamorphosed from an earthy into a crystalline state. In treating of the cretaceous system it was shown that the Lower Green Sand of England, so well illustrated by Dr. Fitton, was represented in the Alps by large masses of limestone, since called Neocomian by foreign geologists. Emphasis was laid upon the remarkable phenomena, that every where in the south of Europe (as in the Alps) the Nummulite rocks, with the * flysch' of the Swiss, and the *macigno' of the Italians, have been raised up into mountains together with the chalk (Hippurite beds and Inoceramus rock) on which they rest. Hence it was, that before Sir Roderick Murchi- son made his last survey of the Alps, the greater number of geologists classed the Nummulite rocks with the cretaceous system, and considered them both to be of secondary age. But judging from the mass of fossils, which differ entirely from those of the chalk, and also from their super- position, he had referred these Nummulite rocks to the true lower tertiary or Eocene of Lyell. Beds of this age, though once merely dark-coloured mud, have been converted into the hard slates of Glarus with their fossil fishes (among which eels and herrings first made their appearance). Some strata of this date at Monte Bolca contain well known fishes, and others APPENDIX. 501 again have been rendered so crystalline amid the peaks of the Alps as to resemble primary rocks ; so intense has been the metamorphosis ! Dwelling on the atmospheric conditions which prevailed after the ele- vation of the older tertiary, Sir R. inferred that a Mediterranean and genial climate prevailed during all the long period while the beds of sand (Molasse) and of pebbles (Nagelflue) were accumulating under the waters both of lakes and of the sea, derived from the neighbouring slopes of all the pre-existing rocks. The marine portions of the Molasse and Nagelflue contain the remains of some species of shells now living in the Medi- terranean ; whilst in alternating and overlying strata, charged exclusively with land and fresh water animals, including numerous insects, not one species among many hundreds is identical with any form now living. This point, on which he first insisted on his return from the Alps in 1848, Sir R. considered to be of paramount importance in proving, that terrestrial life was much less endowed with the capacity to resist physical changes of the surface than submarine life ; for here we have a land fauna which is Pliocene in the order of the strata, and yet is scarcely Eocene when we regard its organic contents. A certain number of the more remarkable animals that lived during this younger tertiary age were then adverted to, such as the Rhinoceros and other large quadrupeds, the fossil Viverrine fox *, collected by himself (the original of which was on the table), the huge Salamander (Andrias Scheuchzeri) and a Chelydra which Professor Bell has described as analogous to the snapping turtle of the southern states of North America. These creatures, with quantities of plants, including small palms, were all indicative of a warm and genial climate. On such sure grounds the second diagram represented the Alps as covered with a subtropical vege- tation ; several of the above-mentioned animals being sketched in the fore- ground. The author had satisfied himself f, in common with Studer, Escher, and all the geologists who have well explored the Alps, that everywhere along their northern flank terrific dislocations have occurred, amounting in many places to a total inversion of mountains, whereby tertiary deposits accumu- lated beneath the waters during the period he had just been describing, were thrown under the strata of former date. He then briefly pointed out what he had demonstrated in detail elsewhere : viz. that the sands and * Now in the British Museum. t Quart. Joum. Geol. Soc. London, vol. v. p. 157. 502 APPENDIX. pebble-beds of that age had been suddenly heaved up from beneath the waters along the outer or northern flank of the chain, so as to form moun- tainous masses, the inverted and truncated ends of which had been forced under the edges of the very rocks out of whose detritus they had been formed. Before this great revolution had taken place no large erratic blocks were known, but after it they became common, and were the necessary products of that intensely cold climate to which the Alps were then subjected — a change of which their surface bears many distinct evidences. During the same period the low countries of northern Europe were, it is well known, covered by an Arctic sea. The Jura and the Alps having also then, as it is believed, been subtended by water, icebergs and rafts must have been detached from the higher range, carrying away blocks of stone northwards to be dropped at intervals ; just as it has been de- monstrated that the Scandinavian blocks, which floated southwards, were dropped in Prussia, Poland, and the low lands of Russia, when all those regions were under the influence of an Arctic sea. In short, Bavaria and the lower parts of the Cantons Vaud, Neufchatel, and Berne, must then have been covered by waters which, whether salt or fresh, bathed the foot of the Alps. The inference that the change from a former genial climate to the first great period of cold was sudden, was further sustained by the fact, that the inclined strata in which the Mediterranean animals are buried, are at once covered transgressively and unconformably by other beds of gravel, shingle, and mud, in which the remains of plants and animals are those of a cold climate. The third scene, therefore, exhibited the beds of sand and pebbles of the genial tertiary period thrown up into mountains on the flanks of the chain, the peaks of which were probably then covered for the first time with snow ; and from the ravines, whether opening upon the sea-shore or into deep fiords or bays, into which glaciers and their moraines advanced, giving birth to icebergs on which rocks were floated away. In concluding. Sir Roderick thus expressed himself : — " Having thus now conducted you rapidly through the most prominent changes which the Alps have undergone, from the first period when they had emerged, pro- bably as an archipelago of low islands in a hot climate, to that epoch when the animals and plants living upon them indicated a Mediterranean temperature, and then to that Arctic period, the conditions of which I APPENDIX. 503 have just been discussing, I have no longer to call for your assent to any inferences of the geologist, which all of you are not perfectly competent to understand. *' To convert the Alps of the earliest glacial period into the Alps of the present day, you have only to figure them to yourselves, as raised 2000 or 3000 feet above the altitude which they are supposed to have in the dia- gram last exhibited. All their main features remaining the same, you would then have before you, the present Alps and their valleys bathed by lakes and rivers instead of bays ; and in place of the waters sketched in beyond them in the painting, with ice-bergs floating upon them, you will then have dry mounds of gravel, sand, and blocks, which were accu- mulated beneath these waters : such, in a word, as now constitute the low hills and valleys and all the richest land of Switzerland and Bavaria, where man has replaced the rhinoceros and turtles of one period, and the ice-bergs of another. You who have not visited this noble chain, and who wish to judge of its gorges, peaks, and precipices, may consult the views sketched by our associate Brockedon, and thus have Nature, in her present mood, brought in a telling manner before you. But those of you, • who really wish to grapple with the geological wonders of former days, may look at the flanks of the Rigi from the lake of Lucerne, where even from the deck of the rapidly passing steamer, you may see how that great pile of pudding-stone, every pebble of which has been derived from more ancient rocks in the chain, has been lifted up from beneath the waters in the manner here pictorially represented ; whilst, if you continue the same traverse up the lake to Altorf, you will pass by extraordinary folds, inver- sions, and breaks of the secondary limestones, and of the older Tertiary or Nummulitic rocks. . Such a doubling or crumpling up of these strata, you may then perchance agree with me in thinking, was in a great measure the result of lateral pressure between two great masses ; viz. the axis of the crystalline rocks of the chain towards the south, and the newly upraised deposits, of which the Rigi is a small part only on the north. The latter having been intruded upon the terrestrial surface, necessarily compressed the pre-existing formations into a smaller compass. If more adventurous, you should climb to the peaks, rising to 8000 or 9000 feet above the sea, and flanking the central summits, you may there satisfy yourself, that deposits which were once mere mud, formed during the same time as our slightly consolidated London clay, have been in many parts converted into schists and slates, as crystalline as some of the so-called primary rocks of our islands ! 1 504 APPENDIX. " In speaking of the last changes of the Alps as stupendous, I know it may be said that, in reference to the diameter of the planet, the highest of these mountains and the deepest of these valleys are scarcely perceptible corrugations of the rind of the earth. But, when we contrast such aspe- rities with many other external features of this rind, they are truly stupen- dous. Let the observer, for example, travel over vast surfaces such as those of Russia, where he cannot detect a single disruption — not one great fracture, and no outbursts whatever of igneous and volcanic rocks, but, on the contrary, a monotonous and horizontal sequence of former aqueous deposits, which, simply dried up, have never been disturbed by any violent revolutions from beneath, — and then compare such features with the ad- jacent Ural mountains, or still better with the loftier Alps, and he will be truly impressed with the grandeur of such changes. *' And here my auditors will recollect, that even beneath and around this metropolis they can be assured, by finding extinct fossil mammalia, that such also have been the changes, though on a less striking scale, in our own country. The large extinct British quadrupeds necessarily required a great range for their sustenance. They had doubtlessly roamed from dis- tant tracts to our lands before the straits of Dover were formed and before the region of Britain was broken up into isles. One of our great insu- lating dislocations was, I conceive, coincident with that striking pheno- menon in the Alps on which I have tried to rivet your attention, when the first glacial and icy period affected so large a portion of this hemisphere, and when large portions of our northern lands formed the bottoms of an Arctic sea. But such tracts were bidden to rise again from beneath the waters and constitute the present continents and islands before man was placed on the surface. Our race, in short, was not created until the greater revolutions of which I have treated had passed away. " These grand dislocations belong, therefore, distinctly to former epochs of nature, and their magnitude is enormous when compared with any thing which passes under our eyes, or has been recorded in human history. At the same time geologists have shown upon clear evidences, that during the long periods which were repeatedly interrupted by great revolutions, there was a constant exhibition of diurnal agencies precisely similar to those which now prevail in the world. In those elder times, rain must have fallen — volcanic forces must have been active in scattering ashes far and wide, and in spreading them out together with sheets of lava beneath the waters — gradual movements of oscillation, and moderate elevations and APPENDIX. 505 depressions must also have occurred — and long continued abrasion of the sides of mountains must have produced copious accumulations of * debris * to encroach upon lakes, the overflow or bursting of which may have steri- lized whole tracts. " All such ordinary changes of the surface of the globe, with occasional slight breaks in the long career, were doubtlessly common to all epochs. But, whilst no such operations can be compared as to effect with those phenomena of disruption and overturning of mountain masses which have been specially dwelt upon this evening, so also, according to my view, it is impossible, that any amount of these small agencies, though continued for millions of years, could have produced such results. " In thus attempting to shadow out in the space of little more than an hour the chief formations and transmutations of a chain like the Alps, I have probably laboured to effect what many persons may deem impossible ; but I have thought that some at least of these evening discourses should awaken the mind to the larger features of a science, the details of which must be followed out by a careful survey of nature. I would beg, therefore, those persons who have not studied geology practically, to dwell on the facts brought forward, and to believe that they are indisputably and clearly proven. They tell us unmistakeabiy how different animals and vegetables are entombed in these vast sepulchres of ancient nature, and they reveal to us, that the successive inhabitants of each creation lived during very long periods of time. They announce to us, in emphatic language, how ordinary operations of accumulation were continued tranquilly during very lengthened epochs, and how such tranquility was broken in upon by great convulsions. " Being thus led to ponder upon the long history of successive races and also upon some of the most wonderful physical revolutions this chain has undergone, we cannot avoid arriving at the belief, that, in addition to many other great operations, the disruption which upheaved the middle and younger Tertiary formations from beneath the waters, and threw them up into mountain masses, accompanied by the production of the first great arctic period known in the history of the planet, was a change of immeasurable intensity. That change, in short, by which a period of snow, ice, glaciers, floating ice-bergs, and the transport of huge erratics far from the sources of their origin, suddenly followed a genial and Medi- terranean clime!'* INDEX. Abberley Hills, Silurian Rocks of, 97, 132. Abb's (St.) Head, view of cliff near, 150. Aberdeen, coast section near, 164. Abereiddy Bay, Lower Silurian rocks, 64. Abergavenny, Old Red Sandstone, 244. Aberystwith, Lower Silurian rocks, 70. Abich, on Devonian rocks, Mount Ai*arat, 335. Acroculia, 230. Acton, Mrs. S., sketch by, 81. Acton Burnell Hills, Salop, 83. Acton Scott, 82. Africa, palaeozoic rocks in, 13. Agassiz, on Pterygotus problematicus, 137. 237.; on Devonian (Old Red Sandstone) fishes, 245, 253.; Permian fishes, 313.; North American geology, 411.; on glacial phenomena, 482. Agger and Lenne', Devonian group of, 369, 382. Agnostus pisiformis, a trilobite of lowest Silu- rian rocks, 92. Albert, H. R. H., Prince, 457. Alison, Sir A., sketch by, 150, 151. Alberbury, Shrewsbury, magnesian limestone, 300. 302. Almaden, Spain, quicksilver mines, 397. Alps, metamorphosis of tertiary rocks, 3.; pa- laeozoic rocks, 337. 407.; and Apennines, memoir on, 406.; changes of. Appendix Q. Altai Orientale, by Pierre de Tchihatcheff, 334. Alum schists and slates in Norway and Sweden, with trilobites, fucoids, and graptolites, 47. 318. 320. America (South), Silurian strata, 14. 409. &c.; (North), Silurian and other palgeozoic rocks, 14. 18. 20. 23. 279. 288. 410.; suc- cession of primeval rocks, 408.; United States, palasozoic rocks, 412. et seq.; British North America, 425. 428.; gold only in the ancient rocks, 432. Ammonite, first appearance of, 282. Ampelite shale, 385. 387. Amphitherium of the Stonesfield ooHte, 466. Ancient rocks, first traces of fossil animals in, 17. 459. etseq. Andes, altered and igneous rocks of. — See Cor- dillera, 18. 409. Angelin, work referred to, 321. Angers, France, slates of (Llandeilo), 383. 385. 387. Anglesea, schists and slates of, Longmynd or Bottom rocks, 23. 25. ; contorted rocks of, 24. ; Irish equivalents of, 165. Appendix D. Animal life, its apparent dawn, 5. 9. 459. et seq. Annelids in Lower Silurian, 70. 199.; of Upper Silurian, 113. 233. Ansted, D. T , " Ancient World," 279.; on gold in Wales, 434. Anthracite in Lower Silurian and older rocks,. 38. 61.; formed of Silurian fucoids, 323. Anthracitic schists in France, 385. Ant stone, " Kramenzel-stein," 373. 382. Apalachian and Alleghany Mountains, 410. 424. Ararat, Mount, Devonian rocks of, 335. Arboreal vegetation, no indication of in chief Silurian periods, 139. 473. Arbroath, paving stones of, 247. Archangel, Permian deposits near to, 294.; Devonian and carboniferous rocks of, 329. Archegosaurus, 287. Archiac, d', and de Verneuil, on Rhenish fossils, 366.; on Spanish fossils, 400. Arctic Regions, Silurian rocks and fossils of, 412. 428, 429. Ardennes, slaty rocks of, 367. ; Lower Devonian of, 369. 382. Arran, Nicol on the geology of, 163. Arragon, Silurian rocks in, 396. Arrowsmith, map of the gold regions of Aus- tralia by, 453. Ashby de la Zouch, Permian plants, 306. Asia, Silurian rocks, 13. Asia Minor, palasozoic rocks of, 335, Appendix N. Asturias, coal fields, 400. Atrypa, 188. Aveline, memoir and section by, 79, 80. Aushkul, lake in South Ural, 440. Austen, R. A. C, on Devonian fossils, 260.; the Devonian of Germany, 381.; the Devonian of the Boulonnais, 390. Australia, Silurian fossils in, 14.; gold of, 449.; first printed documents concerning gold of, 451.; produce of gold. Appendix K. Aymestry limestone, or middle Ludlow rock of, 130. 143. ; fossils of, 133. Ayrshire, Silurian rocks, 150. 157. Baggy Point, North Devon, section at, 256. Bala limestone and fossils (Llandeilo), 10. 46. 49.; cystide^ of, 182. Preface; Appendix B. Balmae Head, Upper Silurian, 161, 162. Ballynahinch Lake, section across, 169. Barr, Staffordshire, Caradoc near, 99. ; Trilo- bite, (Bumastus), 111. Barrande, J., Preface, on Graptolites, 44. 47. 321. 332. ; classification appUed to North Wales, 44. ; on Conularia of Bohemia, 196.; on the Silurian Crustacea of Bohemia, 236. ; 508 INDEX. work on the rocks and fossils of the Silurian Basin of Bohemia, 340 — 349.; additional notice of his labours, A ppend'ix E. Barmouth, Lower Silurian deposits, 31. 40. Barnstaple, section passing bv, 2.56. 258. Basalt, of Comdon and Shelve, 58.; eruptive ovei-flowing coal of Clee Hills, 273, 274. Bas Boulonnais, France, Upper Devonian^ 390. Base of Silurian rocks, 17. 459, et seq. Bassin Silurien de la Boheme. — (See Barrande,) 44. 340. Batrachians, of Carboniferous period, 313. Batrachian reptile in fossil tree, 426. Bavin, provincial term, 133. Beaumont, EHe de, on dislocation of mountain chains, 362. 476.; on the Palseozoic rocks of France, 383.; on the Permian rocks of France, 393. ; on parallel directions of mountain chains, 426.; on catastrophes, Appendix D. Beck, Dr., on graptolites, 47. Belgium, Devonian strata, 261.; primeval suc- cession, 336.; Devonian rocks, 371.; Car- boniferous rocks, 375.; table of the older rocks, 382. Bellerophon, in Lower Silurian, 195.; in Upper Silurian, 231. Belmez, Spain, coal fields, 401. Ben Gleniskv, Connemara, section across, 169. Benthall Edge, Wenlock fossils, 120. Ben "Wvvis, mountain, 250. Beresite. gold in matiis so called, 440. Berezovsk, Eussia, Mammoth remains, 442. Bemer, Herr, collector of Silurian fossils in Ger- many, 354. Berwickshire, Silurian rocks, 150.; Carboni- ferous rocks, 274. Bevrich, M., geological map bv, 338. Beyrichia, 236. Bigsbv, J. J., on X. American Geologv, 411. 429. Binney, E. W., on trails and holes in coal strata, 286.; on Permian fossils, 302, Bins of Connemara, Ireland, 168 — 171. Birds, bones of in greensand and chalk, 467. Birds-eye limestone of America, 414. Bituminous schist formed from fucoids, 323. Bitumen, in cavities of ancient rocks, 47. and Appendix C. Black Mountain, Old Red Sandstone of, 242, 243. Black River limestone of America, 414. Boblaye, De, on ampelite schists, 388. Bogoslofsk, gold near, 440. Bohemia. — (See BaiTande,) oldest traces of Hfe in the primordial zone of Bohemia, Scandi- navia, Wales, and America, 9. 20.; Trilobites of, 43.; Graptohtes in Upper Silnria, 47.; Silurian rocks, 340, et seq.; gold only in ancient rocks of, 432. Appendix E. Bolivia, Silui-ian rocks, 409. Bothnia Gulph, Lower Silurian, 324. Bottom Rocks (Cambrian of the Government Survey), unfossiliferous in Great Britain, 21.; of Scotland, 151. ; of Ireland, with a zoophyte, 32.165.; great break between and Silurian of Ireland, A ppendix D. Bone Well, sketch of Upper Ludlow rocks, 134. Bone-bed of Ludlow rocks, 143.; with fishes and crastaceans, 237. Bos-aurochs, fossil and living, 444. Boulogne, Devonian and Cai-boniferous fossils near to, 390. Brachiopods of Lower Silurian, 183 — 191, ; Upper Silurian, 221—225.; Old Red Sand- stone, 260. 263.; Carboniferous, 283.; Per- mian, 308. Brachymetopus, 281. Bradnor Hill, Upper Ludlow rock, 140. Brand-erde, or burnt earth, 58. Brazils, gold in deep mines, 454. Breadalbane, Marquis of, gold in Scotland, 435. Brecknockshire, Upper Ludlow rocks, 140. ; ichthyolites in cornstone, 245. Brecon, Lower Silurian slates, 75.; Upper Lud- low rocks, 125. 134.; anticlinal of Ludlow rocks, 141.; succession of strata and Fans of, 242. Breidden Hills, bedded trap and section, 59, 60. Brickenden, L., 254. Bridgend, Permian conglomerate, 302. Brilon, AVestpbaha, sti'ata inverted, 378. Brindgwood Chase, section across, 126. Bristol, magnesian (Permian) conglomerate, 301. Britain, Great, lowest fossil remains in, 20.; gold in, 433. British Isles, dissimilar mineral characters of the Silm-ian rocks of, as compared with those of Eussia, 17.; increase of limestone in as the formations become younger, 48. ; vertical dimensions of Silurian rocks, 1 73. ^ British North America, palaeozoic rocks, 427. Brittany, Silurian rocks, 145, 383.; Devonian rocks, 391. Broccard Castle, 81. Brocken, the (Hartz Mountains), 363. Broderip, W. I., Phragmoceras named by, 128.; Didelphis Bucklandi, 466. Brongniart, Adolphe, on fossil botany, 268. 280. ; on Permian plants, 298. 305. Brown, Robert, his Psaronites, 307. Brown, T., on Permian fossils, 302. Bro^vn Clee Hills, cornstone of, 244. Buch, Leopold von, application of Silurian classification to Eussia, Preface; on the cystideje, 181.; on the Hartz and Ehenish provinces, 363, 370.; on the geology of Australia, 450.; on the Alps, 476. Buckland, Eev. W. (Dean of Westminster), suggestion to the author, 6.; Bridgewater Treatise, 469. Builth, Ludlow rocks near to, 140.; igneous rocks of, 45. 57.; Llandeilo formation in contact with Upper Silurian, 90. Bumastus Barriensis, 111. Bunter-sandstein, division of in Germany, 298; 300. Busaco, Portugal, Silurian rocks, 404. Cader Idiis, Lower Silurian and trap rocks of, 32. 39.; section across, 77. INDEX. 509 Gaer Caradoc, views of, 26. 81.; trap rocks of, 81. Caermarthen, faiis of, 242.; carboniferous rocks, 270,271. Cairnsmuir, granite, 162. Cairn-Ryan, graptolite slates, 1 ^6. Caithness, flagstones and ichf .yolites of, 248. 250. 2.53. Calamites in Old Bed Sandstone, 255. 265. Calcareous rocks, chief seats of former life, 465. Caledonian canal, valley of, 250.; railroad, Silurian rocks, 1 55. California, gold, 450. 455. 458. Calvert, John, on gold rocks of Britain, 436. Cambrian, term when and how applied, Pre- face, 7, 8. 10. 25.; rocks with fossils first named Lower Silurian, Preface, 26. 63. Cambridge Museum, pala30zoic fossils of, 10. Canada, Upper, Silurian rocks, 15. 410.; gold in Lower Silurian, 458. ; thickness of Devonian rocks in, 418.; Lower, section across, 424; geological map of, by Mr. Logan, 425. Cantyre, rocks in, 163, 164. Cape of Good Hope, fossiliferous rocks, 13,; depth of the sea between and Cape Horn 478. ^ Caradoc (Caractacus), king of the Silures, 6. ; sandstone, connection with the Llandeilo . flags, 50. 90.; formation described, 78. et ■ 562-. ; relations of to Upper Silurian, 82. Ap- jpendixA, B ; modern aspect of sandstones of in - Shropshire, 83.; Lower, fossils of, 86.; Upper, , fossils of, 88.; and Llandeilo formation united, 88.; of Malvern Hills, 95. (Upper), sandstone at May Hill and Huntley, 97.; at Lickey Hills and Barr, 99.; conglomerates of Old Radnor, Howler Heath, &c. 95. 104. ; sandstone, equivalent of in Nor- mandy, 387. Carboniferous series, unconformable within it- . self, 51.; strata unconformable to Scotch Silurian, 162.; limestone of S. Welsh coal basin, 242.; of Devonshire, 256.; era, vege- tation and general order of, 268, 269, 270., • . of France crystalline and slaty, ' 269, j limestone and fossils of Britain, 271 272* • 273. 282.; rocks, Ireland, 275.; reptiles^ , 287.; Upper Fauna, 279—285,; Lower Fauna, 281,; with Devonian rocks in Russia, 330. 333,; system, lowest members only developed in Russia, 332, ; rocks of Thu- ringia, 359.; the Rhine, 375.; France, 391.; Spain, 400. 402.; Flora, types of ceasing in the Permian era, 407. ; rocks, United States, 418.; insects first appear in, 284. 466.; period, succeeded by violent changes, 480.; Asia Minor, Appendix N. ' Cardigan, Silurian rocks of, 76. Cardiola, 227. Carinaria allied to Bellerophon, 196. Caermarthen, Upper Silurian, 125. 139. 141.; Lower Silurian, 33.; thickness of Llandeilo limestone, 52. Caernarvonshire, base of paleozoic deposits, 23. ; lowest rocks, 33. Carneddau, bedded igneous rocks, 57.; eruptiv^ trap, and altered Llandeilo flags, 61. Carpathian mountains, crystalline rocks, 336. Carrickfergus, salt of and trial for coal near, 277. Carthagena, mines in Lower Silurian lime- stones, 397. Casiano de Prado, on the Silurian and other palaeozoic rocks in Spain, 395—401.; traces a great extent of Silurian rocks in Spain, Ap-i pendix G. Cawdor, Earl of, 272. Cephalaspis, fossil fish in old red sandstone, 2451 Cephalopods of Lower Silurian, 197. ; of Upper Silurian, 231.; ancient forms of, 310; the scavengers of the Silm-ian seas, 471. Ceratite, 282. Cestracionts, 284. Charpentier, J. de, on the glacial period, 482. Chasy limestone, of America, 414. Cherbourg, palseozoic rocks, 384. Cheney Longville, Caradoc sandstone, 82. Cheviot Hills, 152. China, Devonian fossils, 14. Chlorite slates, 23. ^ Chondrites, 42. Christiania (Norway), Silurian succession, 320. Church Stretton, Salop, 81. Cidaris (Sea urchin), 308. Clarke, Rev. W. B. on the paleozoic rocks of Australia, 14.; gold in Australia discovered and described by, 450, 452. Cleavage, slaty, in Silurian and older rocks, 33. 34, ; in Devonian rocks, 259. ; rare in car- boniferous rocks, 269. ; not uncommon in carboniferous rocks of Ireland, 276. Clee Hills, distant view of, 26. ; succession of strata near, 242. ; (Salop), carboniferous rocks of, 273. Clent Hills, 301. Climate, during the pala?ozoic rocks, 463. ; warmer in primeval times, 1. 477. Clinton group, of America, 159. Clun Forest (Shropshire) tilestones, 139. Clymenia (Devonian) limestone, 263. 356. 371. 382. Coal, absurd searches for in Lower Silurian, 61. 93,; basin of South Wales, 244,; Forest of Dean, 244.; anthracitic in Pembroke, 258,,- Island, north of Ireland, 277. ; measures, thickness of in S. Wales, 278.; fossil Limulus' of, 287. ; insects, shells, fishes, and ferns of, 284. ; its relations to the British Permian rocks, 301, 302. ; fields Upper, wanting in Russia, 334.; wasteful search for in Siluriari schists of France, 388. Coalbrookdale, Wenlock shale at, 111.; car- boniferous strata of, 284. ' Cobrales (Spain), carboniferous limestone of, 400. Cobadonga (Spain), mountain limestone, 400. ' Cocccsteus, fossil fish of Scottish Old Red Sand- stone, 252,; of Devonian rocks in Germany, 371.; of Devonian rocks in Russia, 328. * Coleman, Rev, W. H., Permian plants detected by, 306. Collomb, M., and de Verneuil on Spain, 396., 610 INDEX. Colmers end, Woolhope limestone at, 110. Colquhoun, Colonel, on Mexican gold, 449. Combe Martin (N. Devon), 260. Comus wood, Ludlow, 126. Conditions, primeval, of the earth's surface, 473. Conglomerates, in the Silurian rocks of Wales, 70.; of Malvern hills, 94.; in the Silurian rocks of Ayrshire, 160. Coniston limestone, equivalent of Llandeilo lime- stone, 146. 147.; grits, equivalent of Caradoc sandstone, 147. Connemara, Silurian rocks, 168 — 171.; Bins of altered Lower Silurian? 171. Constantinople, Silurian and Devonian rocks near, 335. Continents, aboriginal, mostly submerged, 475. Conularia, 196. 231. Conybeare, Eev. W. D., geology of England and Wales, 6. Copper ore, veins of penetrating from Longmynd rocks into Pentamerus limestone, 27.; veins of at the Longmynd, 38. ; at the Stiper stones, 39.; in Lower Silurian, 53. Coprolites m Upper Ludlow rock, 142. 238. Corals, of Wenlock shale, 113. ; of Wenlock limestone, 119.; Lower Silurian, 178.; pa- Iseozoic, unknown in present seas, 210.; Upper Silurian, 212. 215. ; Devonian, 256. 260. 371.; carboniferous, 282. ; Permian, 308. Coral reefs, evidences of contiguity of land, 472. Corbieres, palseozoic formations, 394. Cordier, Baron L., rcport of, 409. Cornbrook coal basin, 273. Cordillera, Silurian rocks, 14. 409. ; term why applied to the range of eastern Australia, 450. Cork, carboniferous rock, 276. Corndon, Salop, Lower Silurian schists, 28.; Hill, sketch of, 57.; Upper Caradoc near, 82. Cornstone, of Old Eed Sandstone, 244. ; fragm.ents of fishes in, 245.; of Murray Firth, 251.; of the Permian deposits, 301. Cornulites, of Lower Silurian, 200. Cornwall, Lower Silurian and Devonian of, 145. 260.; inversion of strata, 145. 379.; gold in, 434. ; tin miners of, recommended by the au- thor to dig for gold in Australia, 451. Corton, Upper Caradoc, 90. ; Lower Wenlock (or Woolhope limestone), 103. Cotta, B., on the geology of Saxony, 351. Cossatchi Datchi, hills of, 441. Coul-beg, mountain of west coast of Highlands, 249. Coul-more, mountain of west coast of Highlands, 250. Crania, in Lower Silurian, 187. Creation, progress of, 460. ; of different succes- sive races, 468, 469. Credner, Herr, map of Thuringia, 299. 360. Criffel, granite hills of, 162. Crinoids of Lower Silurian, 1 80. ; of Upper Silu- rian, 219. ; rare in Permian strata, 308. Cromarty, fossil fishes of, 251. Crustacea, of Lower Silurian, 200.; of Upper Silurian, 234.; of Devonian rocks, 264. Crustacea, gigantic traits of in Lower Silurian' 413. Crossopodia, annelid in Lower Silurian, 199. Cruziana (Bilobites), in England, 42. ; in Lower Silurian of Spain, 396. Cuenca, fossils near, 399. Culm, or fractured stone coal, Pembroke and Devon, 258, 259.; slash of, in Pembroke, 275. Cumberland, graptolite schists, 47. ; Silurian rocks, 145.; Devonian rocks, 257. Cumming, Lady Gordon, on fishes of Old Red Sandstone, 251. Cuvier, Baron, on the succession of vertebrata 468. ; Old Red fishes described by, 253. Cwm-eisen-isaf (N. Wales), gold at, 434. Cwm Cwyn, section across the hill of, 79. Cwm Dwr (Brecknockshire), junction of Silu- rian and Old Red Sandstone, 141. Cyclas, in Old Red Sandstone, 254. Cyclopteris, plant of Old Red Sandstone, 255. Cyrtoceras, genus of cephalopod, 197. Cytheropsis, a bivalve Crustacean, 236. Cystideffi, of Lower Silurian, 181.; of Upper Silurian, 217. Dago, island of, 327. Dale, Owen D.— (See Owen) works, 15. 422. Dartmoor, eruptive granite, section to, 256. Darwin, C, Silurian fossils and works, 15. 409. Davidson, T. on Devonian fossils in China, 14.; on Silurian brachiopods, 176. 222. 389. Davis, E., Lingula in oldest Silurian beds dis- covered by, 44. ; on fossils of Lower Wenlock, 105. Dawson, on coal-fields and a reptile therein, 426. Dean, Mr. A., gold found by, 433. Dean, Forest of, carboniferous rocks, 270.: coal basin of, 244. Dechen, H. von, works of, 338. 378. Delanoue, geological map by, 390. De la Beche, Sir H. T. — (See Dedication, Pre" face, Appendix^ On the Silurian rocks of Wales, 8. ; on fossiliferous Cambrian being the equivalent of Lower Silurian, 8.; and asso- ciates on unconformity of stratification, 50. ; on a fault at Musclewick Bay, 65. ; sanc- tions the Silurian classification, 138. 168; on iron oxides. 241.; on Devonian rocks, 258.; sanctions the term Permian, 292. Desor, on American azoic rocks, 20. 411. Denbighshire, slaty Wenlock shale. 111.; al- tered mudstones, 101. Dendrerpeton Acadianum, 287. Denudarion, valley of, 118. Derbyshire, coal field, 270.; development of car- boniferous limestone, 271.; thickness of coal strata, 273. Devon, North, section across, 256. Devonian rocks, formerly merged in * Grau- wacke', 6.; term why apphed, 11.; rocks of Britain, 241.; fossils in Ireland, 255.; rocks described, 256. 263.; term proposed by Sedg- wick and Murchison, 257. ; of Devon and Cornwall, 257.; of South Devon, 259. ; of Rhenish provinces, 261. 365.; shells of Lower, INDEX. 511 261.; trilobites of, 262.; shells of Upper, 263.; equivalents in Germany, 264.; terres- trial plants of, 265.; or Old Red Sandstone of Eussia with salt, 295.3 27.; and carboni- ferous rocks in Russia, 330.; of Germany, 335.; of Saalfeld, 357.; Lower, or ' Spirifer , Sandstein' of Germany, 367.; Upper of the Rhine and Belgium, 371. 373.; of France, (Lower), 389.;"(Upper), 390.; Spain, 396.; United States, 417.; fishes of mostly void of osseous vertebra?, 462. Devonshire, gold found in, 434. Dicotyledons, rare in coal flora, 278. Die-earth, or Wenlock shale, 111. Diggings (gold), at Soimanofsk mines, Russia, 442.; at jZarevo Alexandrofsk, sketch, 444.; " wet" and *' dry" of the mines described, 449.; California, 458. Dingle Bay, Silurian fossils, 167. Diploceras, 198. Dnieper river, coal field between it and the Don, 332, ; Silurian and Devonian strata on the, 335. Dolgelly fossils, 42.; gold near to, 433. Dolomite, term inapplicable in classification, 304. Dol-y-frwynog, gold near, 434. Donegal, crystalline rocks of, 173. Donetz, coal-field of (South Russia), 280. 333. Don River, coal field between it and the Dnieper, 332. Down, schists of, 166. Downshire, Marquis of, trial for coal by, 277. Downton Castle Stone, (Ludlow), 138.; oldest traces of arboreal vegetation in, 139. Drammen River, section across, 319. Drift, containing Mammoth bones, the oldest detritus containing gold, 440. Dublin Bay, geology of, 165. Dudley, effects of combustion of coal at, 58.; limestone identical with that of Wenlock, 114. ; seen from the Wren's nest, 116.; limestone, 117.; crinoidea, 219. Duff, P., on reptile of Old Red Sandstone, 254. Dufrenoy, P. A., on the palaeozoic rocks of France, 383. 394. Dumfries, Silurian greywacke of, 149.; bottom rocks of, 151. Dumont,A., work referred to, 364.; Tableau des Terrains compared, 381,382. Dunker, W. and H, von, Meyer Palasonto- graphica, 371. Durham, coal strata, 278.; Permian beds, 303. Dwina River, (Russia in Europe), Permian sections on the banks of, 294. Dynevor Park, view from, 69. Earl Windsor, a memoir by, 450. Eastnor Obelisk, Caradoc sandstone, 95. Ecculiomphalus,Pteropod in Lower Silurian, 196. Edeiraion, section across vale of, 79. Edwards, Milne, on Corals, 179. 209. Egeberg, (Norway), section across, 320. Egerton, Sir P. de Grey, on fossil fish, 284. Ehrenberg, G., referred to, 316. Eifel, Devonian strata of the, 369.; limestone, 371.; inversionin the, explained, 377.; shells of, their equivalents ] in America, 417.; lime- stone, a centre of animal life, 465. Ekaterinburg, underground mining for gold, 440. ; gold shingle near, 445. Elgin, Old Red Sandstone reptile, 254. Encrinites, and their food, 230. Englehardt, collection of fossils, 351, 352. Englemann, on Texas, 20. Enniskillen, carboniferous rocks of, 276. Enniskillen, Earl of, his collection of ichthyo- htes, 284. 287. Epynt, forest of, 128. Erbreich, his labours, 378. Erman, Adolf, explorer of Siberia, 317.; map of the gold fields of the world, 447. 454. Erratics, transported by icebergs, 482. Appen- dix Q. Escar, local Irish terai for drift, 1 72. Euomphalus of Lower Silurian, 193.; of Upper Silurian, 229. Europa (Spain), mountain limestone, 400. Evans, Rev. J., on fish bed of the Upper Lud- low rock, 137. Falkenberg (Prussia), carboniferous fossils, 338. Falkland Islands, Silurian fossils at, 15. 409. Fans of Brecon and Caermarthen, sketch of, 243. Faults, in N. Wales, 54.; at Musclewick Bay, 64.; great in America, 425.; in the Alps, Appendix Q. Fauna, Lower Silurian, 205.; Upper Silurian, 207. et seq.', Devonian, 263.; Lower carboni- ferous, 281. et seq.; Upper ditto, 279.; Per- mian, 307. Featherstonhaugh, G. H., reports by, 411. Felspar porphyries stratified, 57.; rocks (Lower Silurian) at Marringtoii Dingle, 55.; asso- ciated with gold, 456. Felspathic ash of Lower Silurian, 53. Fermanagh (county of), Landeilo fossils, 1 66. Festiniog, volcanic grit, 53.; slates, 44. Fifeshire, Old Red Sandstone and carbon iferou.'j in, 247. Fishes of Upper Ludlow rock, 137. 142.; ab- sent in Lower Silurian, 205.; defences of in Upper Ludlow rock, 238. ; of Upper Ludlow, the most ancient of their class, 239. 460.; of Old Red Sandstone, 251.; carboniferous rock.^, 277, 281. 284.,- Permian, 312.; and arboreal vegetation contemporaneous, 461.; of the Devonian period, 462.; argument derived from their absence in the lower primeval rocks, 471. Fisher, Dr. G,, palaeontology of Russia, 291. Fitzroy, Sir C, dispatches on gold, 453. Flaxley, bone beds near to, 237.; ichthyolite in lowest beds of Old Red Sandstone near, 245. Fleming (Dr. A.), on fossils of the Upper Pun- jaub, 14. Fleming, the Rev. Dr., on the geology of Fife- shire, 247.; on plants in the Old Red Sand- stone of Shetland, 255, 256. Fletcher, T. W., collection of Silurian fossils, 234. Flintshire, coal field of, 270. Floetz-lehrer Sandstein (Germany), the equi- valent of millstone grit, 274. 376. 512 INDEX. Flora, Permian flora of Germany and Russia identical, 297.; great primeval, the som-ce of . coal deposits, 267. 280.; peculiar Devonian type of in Germany, 358. Florence, macigno of, 135. Footmarks, supposed impressions of in Lower Silurian, are marks of shell fish, 205. Footprints of the Creator, work by Hugh Miller, 250. Forbes, Edward, on Lower Silurian of North Wales, &c., 8. ; on Old Red Sandstone plants, 255.; his classification, 468.; on submarine knowledge, 478.; on coloured fossils, ^jj- pendix F. Forbes, James, on glacial phenomena, 482. Forest of Dean, coal basin of, 244.; carboni- ferous limestone of, 270. Forfarshire, 164.; Upper Silurian? 247. Fossils, earliest primeval system of, 23.; Old- hamia antiqua, 32.; of Lingula flags, &c., 42 — 44. ; Lower Silurian graptolites, 46. ; of the Llandeilo formation of South Wales, 68. ; of Lower Silurian Sandstones of South Wales, 72.; of Lower Caradoc, 86, 87, 88.; of Upper Caradoc, 88.; trilobites of Lower Wenlock or Woolhope limestone, 108.; co- rals of Wenlock limestone, 119 — 121.; of Ludlow rocks, 129. 133. 135, 136.; of tile- stones or transition beds, 138.; Cornwall, 145.; Scotch Silurians, 157.; Lower Silu- rian zoophytes, 178.; crinoid, 180.; cysti- , deans, 181.; starfish, 182.; orthides, 184.; brachipods, 185 — 189.; lamellibranchiata, 191,; gasteropoda, 193.; heteropod and ptero- pod mollusca, 196.; cephalopoda, 197. 199.; . annelids, 199.; trilobites, 201.; Trinucleus concentricus distorted, 203.; trilobites, 204.; of the Upper Silurian rocks, 207.; corals, 210 — 213.; bryozoa, 215, 216.; cystideas, 217.; crinoideaof, 219.; starfish, 221.- brachiopods, 222. 224.; lameUibranchiata, 225, 226.; cephalopods, 231.; Crustacea, 234, 235.; , ichthyolites, 238.; Devonian, or Old Red Sandstone fishes, 252, 253.; reptile, 254.; plant, 255.; shells of Lower Devonian, 261.; shells of Upper Devonian, 263. ; carboni- ferous Limulus rotundatus, 281.; coral, 282.; various, 283. ; insect, shells, and fern from the . coal, 284, 285. ; Upper limestone of the coal, 285, 286.; Permian plants and shells, 306—309.; Permian fishes, 312.; Asaphus cornutus, 324.; Orthoceras duplex, 326. Foster and Whitney, on azoic rocks of Lake Superior, 20. Fournet (M.) and Graff, their memoir on anoma- lous disposition of rocks atNefiiez,France,393. France, conformity of Lower Silurian and Upper palaeozoic, 51. ; Lower Silurian of 145.; palasozoic rocks altered, 316. 383.; Silurian rocks in, 383. ; lowest Silurian life in, 386.; Upper Silurian rocks wanting, 389.; Lower Devonian rocks, 389. ; carboniferous rocks, 391.; Permian rocks, 393. Franconia, Devonian rocks of, 355. 373. Freestone of the Caradoc formation, 82. Fucoids in Lower Silurian, 36. 38. 318.; with anthracite schists, 323. Ajypendix C. Fucoid bed in Upper Ludlow rock, 136. Fusion, granite once in a state of, 18. Fusulina3, Foraminifera?, 333. Galloway, Silurian, 149. Galway, Silurian, 169.; metamorphic Silurian, 171. Ganoid fish of Old Red Sandstone, 253. Garneau, Fox, History of Canada by, 411. Garza, Naranjoy, on supposed Permian beds in Spain, 401. Gaspe Limestone, Upper Silurian, Canada, 424. Gasteropoda, Lower Silurian, 192.; not abun- dant in Upper Silurian, 229.; number dimi- nish in Permian strata, 310. Gatley (Ludlow), section across, 126. Gedre, Devonian schists, 394. Geinitz, H. B., on graptolites in Germany, 47.; on palasozoic rocks of Saxony, 354. et seq. Geinitz and Gutbier, on Permian rocks and plants in Saxony, 292. 297.; on the Rohte-todte- hegende, 298. Gelli Hills, section, 61. " Geognostische Beschreibung der Eifel," by Steininger, 369. Germany, Central, graptolites in Lower Silu- rian, 47.; crustaceans in Devonian rocks of, 264.; fossil plants, 280.; Zechstein of, 297.; Permian rocks of, 297. 300. ; palaeozoic rocks altered, 316.; primeval succession in, 336.; Upper palaeozoic rocks, 339.; gold in, 436. Gerville, M. de, fossil collection of, 384. 389. Girard, Dr., on parts of Westphalia, 376. Girvan, Ayrshire, Lower Silurian rocks in, 157 —160. 172. Glacial period, 482. Glaciers, no evidence of in early geological periods, 482. Glamorgan, carboniferous rocks of, 270. Glocker, Prof. (Breslau), collections of, 340. Gloucester, railroad cutting near, 237. Glyptocrinus, Lower Silurian crinoid, 180. Gneiss, Silurian strata reposing on, 22. 318. Go-gofau (S. Wales), gold mines of, 71.; gold near, 433. Gold found in the older strata and igneous rocks only, 16. 53. 431. 455. ; of Merionethshire, 36.; of Scotland, 155. ; in Britain, 433. ; Ural Moun- tains, 439.; superficial distribution indicated, 444. ; when the rocks were impregnated with, 445. ; search for in the solid rock often pro- fitless, 448. 453.; of Australia, 449.; will be exhausted in each new auriferous tract, as formerly in the Old World, 456.; in lead and copper ores, 456.; fear of its depreciation in reference to silver unwarranted, 457. Goldfuss, Prof., his works alluded to, 371. Goleugoed (S. Wales), rare species of trilobite, 74. Goppert, Prof., on land plants, 268.; on fossil vegetables, 278 — 280. Gorran Haven, Cornwall, Lower Silurian, 144. Gossan, gold matrix, 434, 435. INDEX. 513 Gothland (Sweden), Silurian corals of, 215.; fossils equivalents of those of Wenlock and Dudley, 319. Graham Island, 56. Grammysia, genus in Upper Silurian, 227. Granite, strata altered by, 18.; Silurian strata reposing on, 22. 318.; intruded at Anglesea, 24,; gold in, 452. Graptolites, exclusively in the Silurian system of life, 46.; chief position in Britain, 47.; schists at Abereiddy Bay, 64.; in Wenlock shale, 113.; of Skiddaw slates, 146.; in Silu- rian of Scotland, 151.; in Upper Silurian, 208.; Sweden and Norway, 318.; Silesia, Appendix M.-^ Bohemia, 343.; Saxony, 351. seq. ; Thuringia, &c., 354. et seq. ; France, 387.; Spain, 397. et seq.; Portugal, 405.; America, 409. 415. et seq., Appendix D. Grauwacke," a mineral term, geologically in- appropriate, 359. Gravel, gold drifted into heaps of, 449. Greenough, G. B., geological map of England by, 6. 24. Greenstone of Breidden hills, 60. ; of Old Rad- nor, 61.; has altered Silurian strata, 104. Greifenstein, Pentamerus conglomerate, 368. Gretton, Lower Silurian fossils abundant, 98. Grey, Sir George, on gold of New Zealand, 458. Greywacke oldest, or bottom rocks of Longmynd, North Wales, 23. et seq. ; of Bray Head, Dub- hn, 31, 32., Appendix T>; of St. David's, 62.; Scotland, 150, 150. et seq.; Bohemia, 342. et seq. ; America, 425. et seq. Grieston slates, trilobites of, 153. GrilBths, R., geological map of Ireland, 164.; carboniferous rocks of Ireland, 176; Silurian ditto, 165. 276. Griffithides, trilobite in lower carboniferous lime- stone, 281. 311. Guadarrama (Spain), geology of the, 396. Gurmaya Hills (Russia), sketch of, 295. Gutbier, on fossil plants, 306. — See Geinitz. Hag] ey Hills, sketch of, 116.; park, Hereford, 142.; park, Worcestershire, 301. Haime Jules, on Silurian corals, 179. 209. Hales Owen, section near, 301. Hall, James, work alluded to, 15. 18.; on the geology and palceontology of New York, 413. 419. 420.; United States, 417. H ant er Hill, section and sketch, -geology, 104, 105. Hargreaves, Mr., Australian gold diggings, 452. Harkness, Prof. R., on the Silurian rocks of Scot- land, 151. 155. 162. 435. Harlech, unfossiliferous grit, 23. 28. Harpton Court, seat of Sir T. F. Lewis, 104. Hartz mountains, Devonian rocks, 363. Haverfordwest, Lower Silurian, 68. Haughmond Hill, 25. Hausmaun, Prof. J. L., works referred to, 363. Haute Loir€, carboniferous rocks, 392. Haxwell, lowest Wenlock rocks at, 103. Hay, Ludlow rocks near, 126.; section, 243. Heaphy, C., gold diggings in New Zealand, 458. Heat, theory of a central, 1.; and electricity producing slaty" cleavage, 34.; internal ra- diation of, one cause of former temperature of the earth, 477. Helderberg division. Upper Silurian, 416. Heliolites, (Porites), Wenlock coral, 120. Helmersen and Hotfman, work referred to, 317. Helmersen, Col., geological map by and account of bituminous schist, 323.; on Devonian of Russia, 332, Herefordshire, part of Siluria of, 6.; Silurian strata little altered in parts of, 19,; Beacon, sketch of, 92,; Old Red Sandstone, 242.; ichthyolites in cornstone, 245. Hergest Ridge near Kingston, 105. 140. Heteropod mollusca in Lower Silurian, 196. Hibbert, Dr., work referred to, 355. Highlands, rocks of high antiquity, 23.; moun- tains of west coast of, 249. Himalaya, Silurian and pateozoic rocks in, 13. Hindostan, carboniferous rocks in, 13, 14. Hingenau, Prof, von, publication by, 340. Hirnant limestone (Lower Silurian), 50. Hitchcock, Prof., on the geology of Massachu- setts, 412. Hoffman, Colonel, on gold in Siberia, 440. 456. Hollies limestone, equivalent of Woolhope, 96. Hollies' farm, 86. Holly Bush sandstone, bottom rocks Malvern, 95» Holopella, genus in Lower Silurian, 194. Holopea, genus in Lower Silurian, 194. Holoptychius, genus of fossil fish in Old Red Sandstone, 245. Holyhead, metamorphosed strata, 24. Homm.aire de Hell, on Devonian of Persia, 335. Hook Point, Old Red Sandstone of, 66. Hooker, Dr. Joseph, on Upper Ludlow plants^ 238. ; on Devonian plants, 255. Hope Bowdler, sketch of, 81. Hopkins, W., on changes of climate, 4. Horderley, 84. Horeb Chapel, Brecknockshire, tilestone of, 14L Horner, Leonard, on the Malvern Hills, 96. Howler's Heath, Caradoc sandstone, 95. Hudson Bay, Upper Silurian, 429. Hudson river group, American Lower Silurian, 415. Humboldt^ Baron A. von, on Permia, 291.; on Russia, 316.; on the Andes, 408, 409.; on gold, 447. 456, 457.; on silver. Appen- dix L. HuntlyHill, Upper Caradoc, 97.; fish bed, 143, Huron Lake, 423. Hutton and Lindley, Fossil Flora, 280. Hymenocaris vermicauda, crustacean in Lower Silurian, 42. 204. 474. Jacob's-stones, shelly limestone of Caradoc, 84. Jameson, Prof. Robert, on the transition rocks of Scotland, 149. Icebergs, transporters of erratic blocks, 482. Ichthyolites of Upper Ludlow, 143.; of Old Red Sandstone, 245. ; clear indicators of the age of rocks, 246.; of Caithness, 248.; Murray Firth, 251.; Lower carboniferous, 281.; Per- mian rocks in Germany, 299. Jermyn Street Museum, Dedication, 181. 198. L 514 INDEX. Igneous rocks, Silurian strata altered by, 20.; deposits affected by, 46,; associated with Lower Silurian, 52. ; bedded with Lower Si- lurian, 57.; traversing Lower Silurian, 81. Ilfracombe, section, 256.; limestone, 260. Insects, first appearance in the carboniferous rocks, 466. Inverness-shire, Old Red Sandstone, 251. Inversions, in Cornwall, 144.; in the Eifel, 377.; South of Brilon, 378. ; Germany and Belgium, 379.; France, 394.; America, 424, eiseg-.; Alps, 497. Johnston, James, natural history of, 377. Jourdan, M. and de Verneuil on carboniferous rocks of France, 392. Ireland, lowest or bottom rocks contain a Zoo- phyte, 31, 32.; (south) graptolites of Lower Silurian rocks, 47.; Silurian rocks, 164.; bottom rocks in, 165.; (north) Lower Silu- rian, 171.; fossils in Old Ked Sandstone, 255.; carboniferous rocks, 275.; New Red Sand- stone, 277.; gold in, 435.; unconformity at base of Lower Silurian, 493. Appendix D. Ireleth slates, Cumberland, equivalents of Wen- lock, 148. Iron, sulphuret of and mineral springs, 61.; red colour of rocks derived from, 250.; in Caradoc group in Normandy, 387. Ithon river, 80. Itier, Jules, on Chinese fossils, 14. Jukes, J. B., discourse, p. vii.; section by, 79.; on Woolhope hmestone at Hay Head, 110.; Irish Silurian, 168.; Permian deposits, 301.; Newfoundland, 410. ; Australian geology, 451. ; unconformity in Ireland, 493. Jurassic dolomite of Alps, 304. Appendix Q. Kama river, (Russia) Permian deposits, 294. Katchkanar, Ural Mountains, view from, 438. Kazan, (Russia) Peruvian deposits, 294. Keilhau, Professor, Gsea Norvegica referred to, 320. Kelly, John, on Irish Silurian rocks, 173. Kenley, Caradoc of, 83. Kerry, (Ireland), Silurian rocks of, 167. Keuper, marl and lias of, 299, 300. Keys End Hill, Malvern Hills, 98. Keyserling, Count A. von, on the geology of Russia, 5. 291. 327. passim; on Devonian of Germany, 340. Kidd, Dr., 62. Killarney, lakes of, 167. Killery, harbour, section at, 169. Kilkenny, coal of, 277.; Devonian fossils found by Government surveyors at, 255. King, Mr., on rocks in Missouri, 20. King, Professor, on Permian deposits and fossils, 303. 306. Kington, trap rocks near, 1 04. ; Lower Ludlow rocks of, 128.; Upper Ludlow near, 140. Kircudbrightshire, Silurian rocks, 149. 161. Koninck, L. de, on Devonian fossils, 371.; car- boniferous fossils of Belgium, 375. Knockakesheen, (Ireland) granite, 169. Knocktopher, Devonian fossils, 255. Krocklc\en, SweJen, section across, 319. Kutorga, Professor, map by, 325. Kwangsi, China, Silurian fossils from, 14. La Sarthe, Lower Devonian limestones of, 389. Lamelhbranchiata of Lower Silurian, 191,; Upper Silurian, 225.; rare in Permian, 309.; carboniferous, 309. Lammermuir Hills, Lower Silurian, 1 54. Lancashire, Silurian, 145.; coal strata, 273. Landslip, of Palmer's Cairn, woodcut, 131. Lapland, oldest rocks of, 317. Lawley, the, sketch of, 81. Le Play, mineral sketch of the Sierra ilorena, 395, Lead ore in Lower Silurian, 53, Lead Hills, (Scotland) gold in, 155, 435. Lepta;na of Lower Silurian, 186. Lerwick, fossil plants of Old Red Sandstone, 255. Leuchtenberg, H. L H, the Duke of, 181, Lewis, Sir f, F., Right Hon., referred to, 104.' Lewis, G. C, referred to, 104. Lewis, Rev. T. T., Preface, on Caradoc Sand- stone in Brampton Bryan Park, 89. ; Wenlock limestone, 115.; corals, 120.; on Ludlow fish bed, 137.; on Aymestry limestone, 130. Lickey Hills, Upper Caradoc at, 99.; conglome- rate of, 301.; quartz, Caradoc sandstones fused into, 99, Lime, rare in the earliest deposits, 40. ; increases in higher part of Lower Silurian, 46,48.; wanting in Silurian of South Wales, 74. Limestone in Caradoc sandstone, 82.; altered and amorphous, 103.; Dudley, Crinoidea of, 219. ; Silurian altered into marble, 320. ; highly fractured, 331.; of the Eifel, 371.; in Ame- rican bottom rocks, 426.; conical, altered hillocks of, in Russia, 441, 442. Limulus, of coal, 281.; Pterygotus problematicus allied to, 237. 282. 414.; of the Permian beds, 311. Lindley and Hutton, fossil flora of, 280. Lingula, flags of N. Wales, 31.; Davisii, 42.; first discovered by Mr. E. Davis, 44.; flags, zone in Siluria and N. Wales, 45.; parallel of Pembrokeshire, 63.; of Cader Idris, 77.; Malvern, 92. ; ' Zone Primordiale ' (Bohemia), 342.; in Sweden, 321 ; in North America, 415. 422. 425.; thickness of, 175.; Lower Silurian Lingula?, 187,; Upper Silurian ditto, 224, Linley Hills, 37, LinuiBus, on Cystideans, 181.; on Gothland Corals, 214. Linton, North Devon, section at, 256. Little Ross Head, Scotland, Upper Silurian, 162. Lituites, in Lower Silurians, 198. Llampeter Felfry, 45. 68. Llanberis, Bottom rocks, 28.; pass of, sketch, 29. Llandegley, Llandeilo formation at, 45. Landrindod, igneous sti'atified rocks of, 57. ; mineral springs of, 62.; Landeilo formation, near in contact with Upper Silurian, 90. Llandeilo rocks, 10.; flags, of Corndon and Shelve district, 26.; Snowdon strata of that age, 30. ; formation described, 45. ; limestone, 49. 68.; formation, where conformable to Ca- IMDEX. 515 . radoc, 50.; formation, order of, 52.; metalli- ferous, 53. ; flags interstralified with volcanic grits, 57.; schists, Musclewick Bay, 65.; town of and flags, 69.; section near, 73.; schists, supporting Caradoc sandstone, 79.; formation, junction beds of and Caradoc, 80. ; formation, break between and the Caradoc local, 81.; united with Caradoc, 88.; flags, where unconformable to Upper Silurian, 90. ; ■ equivalent in Sweden, 319.; equivalents in France, 383. ; limestone, a centre of animal life, 465. Llandewi Felfry, section at, 46. 49. 68. Llandovery, gold near, 433. Llandrindod, Llandeilo flags near, 45. ; mineral springs, 62. Llangadock, section near, 73. Llanwrtyd, mineral springs, 62. ; wells, sketch, 75. ; view from near, 243. Lloyd, Dr., on Upper Ludlow fish-bed, 137. Lloyd, Col., fossils from the Peruvian Andes, 477.; on silver in S. America, 457. Loch Erne Head, Scotland, gold near, 435. Loch Scavig, hypersthene rocks, 104. Lockerby, graptolitic schists, 155. Logan, W. E., reports on Canada, 15. 20.; on casts of fossils, 205.; on coal plants, 278.; map, sections, and survey of Canada, 411.418. 424. 425. Long ]\Iountain, Montgomeryshire, 128. Longmynd mountain, bottom rocks of, 7. ; Cam- brian rocks of Wales identified with, 23. 25.; view of and section, 26, 27, 28. 62, ; direction of, 45.; rocks of same age in Scotland, 149.; conglomerates in, 160.; rocks ofL-eland, 165.; vast thickness in Shropshire, 174.; equivalents in France, 383.; in Bohemia. •Lonsdale, Preface^ v.; corals described by, 120. 209. 282.; fossils of South Devon, 257. .Loriere, de, and de Verneuil, on Spanisli Silurian, 398. Lothians, section across, 152. Lovens, works on Swedish fossils, 320.; sub- marine researches of, 478. Lough Corrib (Ireland) Silurian, 168. Lough Erne, carboniferous rocks, 276. Loxonema in Upper Silurian, 230. Ludlow, Upper, 102. 133.; formation, general character of, 124.; castle, sketch of, 125.: Lower, 102. 127.; passing into the Wenlock shale, 126.; promontory, section across, 126.; Lower, fossils of, 127. 129. ; limestovie (Aymostry), 130. 143. ; rocks, sketch of, 134.; rocks, fucoid bed, 136.; fish remains of, 137 — 139.; rocks, thickness of, 175.; fossils of, 215. et seq. Lugg, river, Aymestry limestone near, 132. Lyell, SirC, Manual of Geology, 248. 279.; on reptile of the coal, 289.; map of North Ame- rica, 410.; travels in North America, 426.; Elements of Geology, 466. ; theory of climate, 479. Lyons, coal fields of, 391. Maam (Ireland), Upper and Lower Silurian fossils mixed, 170. L M'Callum, Alexander, of GIrvan, 247. Macigno, Italian tertiary beds compared with Upper Ludlow, 135. Macgillicuddy's Reeks, Old Red Sandstone, 167. M'Coy, Frederick, Pnjf., on fossils of the Cam- bridge Museum, 10.; May Hill fossils, 98.; Upper Ludlow fishes, 137.; Silurian fo.ssils of Scotland, 159.; of Ireland, 165—176.; sy- nopsis of Woodwardian Museum, 228. ; Upper Silurian Crustacea, 236.; on coal reptiles, 287.; Silurian fossils, 485. 491. 492. Macculloch, Dr. J., on the Western Islands, 250. IMacleay, W., Annelids described by, 70. Maclurea Logani, 193. Madrid, geological map of province, 396. Magnesian limestone equivalent of the Zechstein, 12. 296. 303, 304.; Prof. Sedgwick on, 303.; in Lower Silurian of America, 304. 422.; a centre of animal life, 465. Malvern and Abberley Hills, memoir on (J. Phil- lips), 8.; black schists equivalents of the Lingula beds of North Wales, 92. Malvern Hills, Lower Silurian of, and view of, 92. ; absurd trials for coal in black schists, 93. ; section to Ledbury, 94. ; raised in a solid state, 26.; Silurian succession, Holly- Bush sandstone, Olenus black shale, &c,. 95. ; Woolhope limestone, 109. ; Wenlock shale, 111. ; Wenlock limestone, 115. ; Lower Ludlow rock, 128.; Aymestry rock, 132.; Upper Ludlow, 140. ; succession, 242.; recent discoveries at, Aj^pendixO. ]\Limmalia, first evidences of in Triassic group, 466.; abundant in Tertiary deposits, 467. Mammatt's Geological Facts, 278. Mammoth remains in auriferous gravel, 443. 445. Manchester, coal strata, 286 ; Permian, 302. Mangerton (Ireland), Old Red Sandstone, 167. Mantell, Dr. G. A., description of Telerpeton Elginense, 254. Map of Siluria and Wales, Preface, p. v\. passim; of the palajozoic formations, 475. Marbres Griottes (altered limestones) of the Py- renees, Devonian, 394. Marcou, Jules, geological work and map by, 411. 426. Marden Hill, Aymestry rock, 132. MarloesBay, Silurian rocks, 65, 66, 67. 125. 140. Marmora, Gen. A. della, on Siluiian rocks in Sardinia, 13.; map by, 405. Marrington Dingle, woodcut, 55. May Hill, Caradoc formation, 97.; Lower Wen- lock (Woolhope limestone), 109.; Wenlock limestone, 115.; Aymestry rock, 133.; Upper Ludlow and fish bed, 142, 143.; succession of strata, 242.; fish remains in Old Red Sandstone, 245. Mealfourveny, Inverness-shire, 250. Medina sandstone (America), 420. Megahcthys Hibberti of the coal, 281. Meifod rocks, Lower Silurian, 50. Memoirs of Geological Survey alluded to 8. et passim. Mcnai, straits of, 25.; lowest zone of life, 35. 610 INDEX. Jleneghini, Prof,, on fossil plants of Italy and Sardinia, 406. Merioneth, base of deposits in, 23. ]\[erioiietbshire, gold in, 36. ; Cai-adoc formation in, 78. Metaraorphism, change by means of, 18, 19. ; of formations, 21. Metamorphosed strata, near Holyhead, 24.; Si- lurian, 163. Mexico, gold not found in deep mines, 449. Miask (Ural), gold near, 443. Midsummer Hill (Malvern), felspar rock, 93, 94. Milford Haven, Old Eed Sandstone of, 246. ^Miller, Hugh, works referred to, 11.; his- torical sketch by, 149.; on fishes of Old Eed Sandstone, 240.; description of the Pterichthys, 251.; footprints of the Creator, 252.; plants and. shells in Old Eed Sand- stone, 253, 254. Millstone (Sweden), re-aggregated granite of Silurian age, 318. Millstone grit, representative of in Devonshire, 259. ; at Cornbrook coal basin, 273.; Ireland, 276.; its representative in Germany, 376.; in Spain, 400. Milne Edwards, on Silurian corals, 179. Milton.— (see Ludlow Castle,) 126. Mineral features not persistent, 48.; veins in Lower Silurian, 53.; springs resulting from decomposition of sulphuret of iron, 61. ; changes in carboniferous rocks, 275.; conditions of former geological epochs, 465. Mississippi, transportation of vegetable matter by, 279. Missouri, Silurian of the, 18. Mitchell, Sir T., on Australia, 451. Moel y Golfa (Breidden Hills), 59. Moel Wyn, igneous rocks and slates of, 44. !Modiolopsis in Lower Silurian, 191. 226. Moffat, Silurian greywacke, 149. Moldau Eiver (Bohemia), 344. Mondego Eiver, Portugal, 404. Montgomery, Silurian strata, 19. Montgomeryshire, Cambrian rocks are mere extensions of Lower Silurian, 8.; bedded vol- canic rocks, 55.; stratified felspar rocks, 55.; Caradoc formation in, 78.; borders of, section, 80. Monitor, animal allied to in the Permian, 463. Monmouth, carboniferous rocks, 270. Moore, J. C., on Silurian of Scotland, 156. Moravia, palaeozoic rocks of, 340. Morris, Prof John, and Sir E. I. Murchison on palaeozoic rocks of Saxony. &c., 351.; onPer- niianflora, 298, 299.; and Sir E. L M., on Thuringian coal strata, 359. Moscow, carboniferous limestone, 532. Moselle river, rocks of, 364. Mountain limestone, a centre of animal life, 465. Mudstone, term how applied, 41.; near Cader Idris, 77.; provincial name for incoherent Silurian rocks, 1 00. ; Upper Silurian altered, 101. Munster, Count, palajontological works, 354. Muschelkalk, a centre of animal life, 465. Murchison, Lady, sketches by, 59. 69. 92. 116. 271, 272. Murchison, Sir E. I., former opinions of. Preface^ 9. 274.; on Silurian rocks of the Ural chain, 13.; Memoir in London and Edinburgh Phil. Mag. 19.; Eussia in Europe and the Ural mountains, 19. 11. 17. 38. 293. 295. 317. et passim; de Verneuil and Eamsay, North Wales, 54. ; map for the Society for the Dif- fusion of Useful Knowledge, 63. ; J. Kelly, on Irish' Silurian, 173.; term Permian proposed, 291.': and Prof Nicol, 78.; and Prof Sedg- wick, on the Geology of Devonshire, 257. 259. 260. 264.; Prof. Sedgwick, on pala3ozoic rocks in Saxony, 361. 378.; and Prof Morris, on German Permian flora, 298, 299. 360.; and Prof Sedgwick, on the Thuringerwald, 350.; and Prof IMorris on Thuringian coal strata, 360. ; Memoir by, on the Alps and Apennines, 406.; and Prof Nicol, 170.; changes of the Alps, Appendix Q. Murchisonia, of Silurian, 193. ; Devonian, 261. Muschelkalk, in Triassic group, 299.; diagram of succession, 300. Musclewick Haven, 65. Museum of Geological Sumy, Preface, 44. 181. 198. Mynydd Epynt, Brecon, Upper and Lower Silu- rian, 75. 118. 243. Mynydd Bwlch y groes, 75. ]\Iynydd Mynyllod, section across, 79. Mynydd Aberedu, section across, 91. Myrianites, in Lower Silurian, 199. Mytton dingle (Salop), 38. Nant y Moen, lead ores of, 71. Nash Scar, amorphous limestone of, 103. Nassau, Upper Devonian of, 372. Nauniann, Prof, igneous rocks mapped by, 354.; on geology of Saxony, 351, Nefiiez, apparent anomaly of rocks explained, 393. 495. Nehou (Nonnandy), Devonian fossils of, 389. Neozoic, secondary and tertiary groups, 469. Nereites, of Lower Silurian, 199. 352. et seq. Neva river (Eussia), 322. Nevin, Mr. (Waterford), Silurian fossils, 167. New Brunswick, Silurian, 410. Newcastle, coal field of, 279. Newfoundland, Silurian I'ocks, 410. Newton Bushell, Devonian limestone, 260. New South Wales, reports on, 452. New York, palaeozoic deposits of, 413. New Zealand, gold diggings at, 458. Niagara group, representative of Wenlock lime- stone, 217.; rocks of Upper Silurian, 416. Nicol, Prof. J. on the Silurian of Scotland, 149. 151. 154.; on metamorphosed Silurian, 163.; and Sir E. I. Murchison, 170.; on anthracitic plants. Appendix C. Nils Hill, quarries of, 38. Nilsson, Prof S., work referred to, 320. Nodules, in Upper Silurian, 101. Noeth Griig, section at, 72. Norfolk Island, Araucaria of resembling coal plants, 278. INDEX. 517 Normandy, equivalents of Caradoc beds in, 387. North America, (see America). North Devon, section across, 256. 258. North Foreland, section at, 256. North Hill, (Malvern,) sketch of, 92.; igneous rocks of, 95. North Pembroke, Cambrian rocks, now ascer- tained to be Lower Silm-ian. 63. Northumberland, development of carboniferous limestone in, 27.; coal field, 270.; carboni- ferous limestones of, 274. 279. North Wales, nomenclature of rocks in, 8.; the organic remains similar to those of St. Peters- burg, 18; Silurian strata, metamorphic in, 19.; rocks, equivalent of the Longmynd, Shelve Corndon, and Stiper stones, 25. 128.; West Shropshire succession, 39.; lime- stone feebly developed in, 49.; epitome of, in Radnorshire, 58. ; Caradoc formation, 78.; Upper Silurian of, 101.; gold in, 433. Norway, succession of Paljeozoic rocks in, 319. Norwood, Dr., territory examined by, 421. Nottingham, Permian beds, 303. Nova Scotia, fossil reptile and land shell in coal, 287.; Silurian of, 410.; coal formation of, 426. Nucula, in Lower Silurian, 191. Nummulite, the Fusulinaa of the carboniferous limestone, prototypes of, 333. Obolus, species of (allied to Lingula,) 187. Ochotsk, sea of, Silurian rocks traced to, 1 3. Oldham, Prof. T., zoophyte in bottom rocks detected by, 32. Oldhamia antiqua, sketch of, 32. 165. Oesel Island, of Upper Silurian, 327. Old Padnor, Silurian strata, altered by greenstone, 61.; Caradoc of, 89.; altered limestone and trap, 103. Old Red Sandstone, 11.; overlying Silurian, at Hookpoint, 66.: of Britain, 241.; escarp- ment of Black Mountain, 242.; decomposition of, forming rich soil, 244.; England and Wales, 245.; Scotland, 246. 253.; Forfarshire, section across, 248.; Hugh Miller on, 249.; fishes, 250, 254.; shells, 254.; reptile, 254.; plants, 254.; freshwater shells and tree ferns in Ireland, 255.; of Devon and Cornwall, 557. Olenus, one of the earliest tribolites, 41.; shale, Malvern Hills, 95. Olmutz, Devonian fossils near, 340. Olonetz, Russian government, carboniferous limestone of, 332. Omallus, d'Halloy Pene'en, 12.; works of, 364. Onchus, fossil fish in Upper Ludlow, 239.; in Old Red Sandstone, 245.; Dewii, 421. Onega, Lake, Russia, Devonian of, 329. Onny River, Caradoc sandstone on, 84.; section, 126. Onondaga Rocks, (America,) Upper Silurian, 416. Oolitic group of rocks, animal remains of, 466. Oporto, Lower Silurian Rocks, 402.; granite of, 403. Orbicula, in Lower Silurian, 187. Orbigny, d', on the palasozoic rocks of the Andes, 14. 292. 408. L Ord of Caithness, 250, Order of Upper Silurian rocks, 102. Orenburg, Russia, Permian salt of, 295. Organic remains, oldest, 5.; registered from their apparent dawn, 9. ; of Llandeilo and Caradoc essentially the same, 81.; of Lower Silurian, 176.; of Permian or Old Red Sandstone, 251. 263.; of carboniferous strata, 280.; Upper Silurian, 287.; Permian. 305. et seq. Oriskany sandstone (America), equivalent of Rhenish lower Devonian, 374. 417. Orkney Islands, Old Red flagstones of, 250, Orthis, in Lower Silurian, 184.; in Upper Silu- rian, 223, 224. Orthoceras, in Upper Silurian, 112. 232.; abun- dant in Lower Ludlow, 128.; in Lower Si- lurian, 197.; last met with in the Carboni- ferous series, 282. Orthonota (Cypricardia, Sil. Syst.) in Lower Silurian, 192.; in Upper Silurian, 226, 227. Osersky, Colonel A., translator into Russian of Russia and the Ural Mountains, 317. 325. Oswestry, coal field of, 270. Owen, Dr. Dale, Trilobites described by, 343.; geology of North America, 304. 321. Owen, Prof. Richard, on footmarks in Potsdam sandstone, 205. ; reptile of the coal, 287. ; Per- mian reptiles, 302. 313. 497.; on gigantic crustacean of Lower Silurian, 413; homology of the vertebrate skeleton, 461.; British fossil mammalia, 466. Ousel Wood, sketch of, 105. Oeynhausen, C. von, referred to, 338. ; geo- gical map by, 379. Pacht, Raimund, on the Devonian fossils of Russia, 332. Paillette, A., Devonian rocks of Spain, 396. Palmer's Cairn, landslip of, 131. Pala30chorda, a period of Lower Silurians, 42. PaIa30ntographical Society, 176. Palajozoic rocks, first era of life. Preface, vi., 9 — 11. ; at Anglesea, 24.; cleavage in rocks of that age, 35. ; system divided into upper and lower: (see Rocks), 310.; period, the Per- mian system the close of, 315.; Alps and Poland, 337.; formations, map of, 475. Pander, C. H., on Platydolenites, 323. Paradoxides, one of the earliest trilobites, 41.; Forchammeri, 43. Parennes, France, section across, 385. Pattison, S. R., on gold in Cornwall, 434. Patella, in Lower Silurian, 123. Pebble beds, evidences of the contiguity of the land, 472. Peebles-shire, section of, 1 52. Pegwyn Fawr, section acrass, 80. Pekin, coal fields of, 14, Pellico, M,, Lower Silurian of Murcia, 397. Pembrokeshire, Llandeilo formation in, 49. ; Lower Silurian of, 63 — 68, ; Upper Silurian of, 141,; Carbonlfe^rous rocks of, 270, 271. ; general order in, 272. Pennant, Col, Douglas, slate quarries, 31. Peneen, local geological term, 305. 518 INDEX. Pentamerns, limestone, 8G. 98. 102.; Knlghtii in Lower Wenlock, 106. 132.; in Lower and Upper Silurian, 190. 223. Pentland Hills, greywacke of, 154. Pentland, J. B., on Trilobites in the Andes, 408. Perm, city of, deposits near, 294. Permia, region of Piussia furnishing tlie name of a group of strata, 12. 193. Permian, origin of the term as applied to the highest gronp of primeval deposits, 12. 289, 290.; relations of to coal strata, 270.; rocks, changes of the surface before deposited, 289. ; connected with the carboniferous, 291.; name, whence derived, 291. Permische system in Sachsen, 292. Permian deposits, salt springs in, 295.; rocks of Russia, 292. 300.; Fanna and Flora, 299.; general succession of, 300.; of Germany, 297. 300. 339.; base of in Britain, 300.'; rela- tions to coal (section), 301.: sauroid reptiles of, 301.; position of, in Shropshire, 302.; Flora, 305.; Fanna, 307.; shells, 309.; fish, 312.; deposits chse of primeval life, 315.; rocks of France, 393.; Fauna and Flora resembling the carboniferous, 463. Perthshire, Scotland, limestone rocks in, 1 64. Petchora, North Russia, Devonian strata of, 331. Petherwin, Devonian rocks of, 256. 263. Phascolotherium. fossil Marsupial. 466. Phillips, Prof. John, on the Malvern and Abberley hills, 8. 93. 95. 96, 97. 176.: Oleni dis- covered by, 43. 92.; ancient trilobites dis- covered by, 92.; division between ITpper and Lower Silurian, 110.; thickness of Wenlock shale. 111.; Wenlock limestone, 115.; Lower Ludlow rock, 128.; Upper Ludlow, 140.; fish bed at Pyrton passage, 143.; on Lamelh- branchiata, 228.; fossils of Devonian rocks, 258.; Lancashire coal field, 274.; Permian fossils, 292. Phillipsia, trilobite in the carboniferous lime- stone, 311. Phrygia and Thrace, gold only in ancient rocks of, 432. Phyllopod, a rare crustacean of that order in Lower Silurian, 42.; crustacean of that tribe in Upper Silurian, 236. Pilton, Devonian rocks of, 256. Planet, hvpothesis concerning the origin of our, 1.5. Plants, land, earliest in Upper Silurian, 139. 238.; in Old Red Sandstone, 245. 255. Plants. teiTestrial of Devonian, 265.; of the car- boniferous era, 268. ; forming coal, 277.; Per- mian, 306. ; fossil of the Devonian and Car- boniferous rocks in Germany, 358, 359. Platinum, in the Ural mountains, 439. Permian debris, no gold in, 446. Platydolemites, fragments of trilobites, 323. Pleurorynchus, in Lower and Upper Silurian, 192.'225. Plymouth, limestones of, 260. Poille, section across, 385. Poland, palaeozoic rocks of, 337. Polarity, doctnne of its relation to the distribn- tion of generic types, 468. Poltimore mine, Devonshire, gold in, 434. Pomeroy, Tyrone, geology of, by Col. Portlock, 164. P(5n-sandstein (Germany), an equivalent of the lower limestone shale, 376. Pontefract, Yorkshire, Permian beds, 305. Pontesbury, 38. Pontesford', 25. 26. Pontefract rock, equivalent of the Rothe-todte- liegende, 303. Porphyries, felspar, stratified, 57. Porphyry, once in a state of fusion, 18. Portlock, Col. J. E., on Silurian fossils of Ty- rone, 176.; Irish Lower Silurian, 229. Portugal, Silurian rocks in, 13.; palaeozoic rocks altered, 316 ; paleozoic rocks in, 403. Posidonomya Becheri, 274. 375, 376.; lime- stone, Devon, carboniferous limestone, 259. Potsdam sandstone, North America, lowest strata containing Silurian fossils, 20 ; Lingula of, 41.; Lower Silurian, 413. 422. Powerscourt, waterfall of, 165. Povris Castle, Silurian rocks near, 59. Prague, the Silurian System around, 341.; stands upon Lower Silurian, 343. Pratt, S. P., on geology of Spain, 398. Presteign, Caradoc of, 89, 90.; Woolhop - stone at, 103. Prestwich, J., on fossils of the coal, 285. Primary rocks in Scandinavia and North Ame- rica, 20. Primeval conditions of the earth's surface, 471. 480. ; strata, wide spread of, 475. Protozoic, or first era of life, 1 1 . Prout, Dr., his analysis of Upper Ludlow copro- lites, 238. Prussia, carboniferous rocks of, 274.; palaeozoic rocks of, 337.; Silurian rocks of, 496. Psaronius, a tree fern of Permian age, 307. Pterichthys, fossil fish of Old Red Sandstone, woodcut, 251. Pteriuea, in Lower Silurian, 191.; in Upper Si- lurian, 225 Pteropods, Upper Silurian, 231.; of WerJock shale, 112.; in Lower Silurian, 196. Pterotheca, in Lower Silurian, 196. Pterygotus, at Hagley park, (Hereford,) 142.; in the Upper Caradoc of Malvern, 237.; in Silurian rocks of Bohemia, 346.; problema- ticus, crustacean of Upper Ludlow, 142.; in Arbroath paving-stones, 247. Ptvchacanthus, fossil fish in Old Red Sandstone, 245. Pyrenees, palaeozoic formations of, 394. Pyrton passages, fish bed, 143. Quartz sandstone altered, 20.; of Lickey, (Ca- radoc sandstone altered), 99. ; Caradoc sand- stone of Salop changed into, 83. ; associated with gold, 71, 456. 447. Radnor, Silurian tract of, 6.; volcanic grits in, 45.; Forest, Silurian rocks of, 80. lOO. 125.; Old, Upper Caradoc conglomerates, 89. ; Old, amorphous limestone and trap of, 103. 105.; succession of strata in county of, 242. INDEX. 519 Kaglcath Hill, sketch of, 81. Ramsay, Prof'., Lower Silurian rocks of North Wales identified with those of Salop, Preface, 8. 19.; section on map prepared by, 28. 54.; memoirs in Geological Journal, 79.; Permian rocks of England, 301.; additional observa- tions, Appendix B. Eastrites peregrinus, woodcut, 46. Eatlinghope, 26. Eeise nach dem Ural, 317. Eeptile of Old Eed Sandstone, 254. ; of coal strata, 287. ; of the Permian rocks of Eussia, 297. ; Permian strata, 313. Ehayader, Lower Silurian sandstones, 70. Elienish Provinces, Devonian rocks, order of older rocks in, 365. 382. Ehine, greywacke of compared with Devonian sti-ata, ,256. ; crustaceans in Devonian of, 264. ; rocks of, 364. ; ascending series on, 369.; Upper Devonian of, 371.; Carbonife- rous of, 375. ; sands slightly auriferous, 436. Ehynconella in Lower and Upper Silurian, 189. 222. Eibeiro, Carlos, Silurian rocks in Portugal, 404. Eichardson, Sir J., narrative of Arctic expedition, 411. ; rocks of Hudson's Bay, 426. Eichter, E., of Saalfeld, 351. ; plants, &c. dis- covered by, 358. ; on Silurian and Devonian of the Thiiringerwald, 357. et seq. Eothenberg, Devonian of, 358. Eiesen Gebirge (S. of Breslau), Palajozoic rocks of, 338. ; Permian rocks of, 339. Eiley, Dr., on Permian reptiles, 301. Eingerigge (Norway), section across, 320. Eipple marks, in Lower Silurian, 38. Eipon (Yorkshire), Permian sandstones, 303. Eocks, oldest crystalline effects of great heat, 2. ; nuclei of the oldest sedimentary deposits, 21. ; general order of the primeval, woodcut, 22. ; oldest sedimentary in England, 28. ; igneous, near mineral veins, 53. 55. ; Lower Silurian and eruptive, 61. 77. ; palaeozoic of Alps and Apennines, 407. ; carboniferous, 418. Eocky Mountains, Silurian rocks of, 18. 409. 427. Ebemer, Adolf, on the Hartz, 362, 363. Ebemer, Ferdinand, on Ehenish rocks, 368. 370. 371. et seq.; on American Silurian rocks, 409. Eogers, Prof. Henry D., on formation of coal, 288. ; section by, 424. Eogers, Profrs. H. and W., United States, 379. 423. Eose, Gustav, on Eussia, 316. 447.; mineral chai-acters of rocks in Prussia, 338. Eoss, county of Scotland, 250. ; railroad cutting to, 237. Eotch, provincial term for mudstone, 101. Eothe-todte-liegende (Lower Permian deposit), 12. ; Flora of, 297, 298. ; succession of, 300. Eoundstone Bay (Ireland), section across, 169. Eowley Hills, basalt of, 116. Eoxburghshire, section across, 152. Euppersdorf, Permian rocks and fishes of, 315. 339. Russell, Lord John, address at Leeds, 250. Eussia, types of British Lower Silurian, 9. ; Silurian rocks, their sequence in an unaltered state, 15. ; oldest deposits only partially- hardened, 17, ; forming level plains in, 19. ; Cystidete of, 19. 181. ; Silurian strata un- solidified, 34. ; organic remains of Old Red Sandstone identical with those of Scotland and Devon, 264. ; southern steppes of, 280. ; Permian rocks, 292. 300. ; primeval rocks of, 322.; Lower Silurian, 323. ; Upper Silu- rian, 325.; Devonian, 327. 332.; Carbonife- rous, 333, 334. " Eussia in Europe, and the Ural Mountains," 5. 9. 11. 17. 138. 293. 295. ; work translated into Russian, 317. Saalfeld, Germany, Lower Silurian of, 353 ; De- vonian, 339. 357. Saarbriick (Rhenish Bavaria), coal reptile of, 287. Sabero (Spain), coal apparently in Devonian rocks, 400. Sable', section to, 385. St. Abb's Head, view of, 151. St. Bride's Bay (Pembroke), Lower Silurian, 65. St. David's, Longmynd rocks, 62. St. Omer, beds of coal near, 390. St. Petersburg, rocks same age as those of Snowdon, 18.; Lower Silurian, 322. Salt in Permian deposits, 295. Salter, J. W., contributions to this work. Preface and passim ; on fossil-bearing rocks of N. Wales, 8. ; Cruziana and Hymenocaris de- scribed by, 39. ; on Silurian encrinites, 113. ; organic remains of the Lower Silurian, 176. et seq. ; Upper Silurian, 207, et seq. ; on North American fossils, 421.; table of fossils common to Lower and Upper Silurian, Ap- pendix A. Sanchez, Eusebio, on Spanish geology, 397. ; Sandberger, F., works on fossil remains, 264. 345. 365.; (the brothers) on slaty rocks, 369. 371. Sandstone, Lower Silurian, 51. 71. Sardinia, Silurian and other palaeozoic rocks, 13. 405. Sarthe, anthracite, 392. Savi, P., memoir, 406. Saurians Carboniferous, 313. ; Permian, 313. ; abundant in the Oolitic group, 466 ; Ap- pendix P. Saxony, Permian tree ferns of, 309.; Silurian, Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian rocks, 12. 349, et seq. ; contains no Upper Silurian, 361. Scandinavia, oldest traces of life in, 9. 15. 20. 43. 317. 321. Schists altered into slates, 20. ; contorted at Anglesea, 24.; black, of Malvern, 92.; in the Highlands of Lower Silurian age?, 163. 248. Schleitz, geological changes near, 354. Schrenk, A. G ., on Upper Silurian of Eussia, 326. Schultz, M., on rocks in Gallicia, 395. Scotland, south of, Silurian rocks and fossils, 47. 149, et seq. ; section of Silurian rocks, 152. ; 520 INDEX. Old Red Sandstone of, 246. 253. : gold in, 435. Secondary rocks, gold wanting in, 432. ; suc- cession of, 464, et seq., Appendix Q. Sections, general order of primeval rocks, 22. ; unconformity of Longmynd to Pentamerus limestone, 27.; from the Longmynd across the Stiper Stones and Lower Silurian, 29. ; Bar- mouth (Lingula Flags), 40. ; Llandewi Felfrey (Llandeilo Flags), 49. ; and Llandeilo flags with volcanic grits, 57. ; across the Breidden Hills, 60. ; Abereiddy Bay, 64. ; Llandeilo schists in Musclewick Bay, 65. ; Llandewi Felfry (Llandeilo), 68. ; Lower Silurian to Old Red, Noeth Griig, 72.; Lower Silurian to Old Red (Llangadock), 73. ; Llandeilo (Lower Silurian to Carboniferous), 73. ; Cader Idris (Lower Silurian), 77. ; Llandeilo schists con- formable to Caradoc Sandstone, 79, 80.; from Upper Caradoc to Old Red Sandstone, 82. ; Presteign (Upper Caradoc and Lower ,Wen- lock), 90, 103.; Builth, 90, 9L ; from Mal- vern to Ledbury (Lower Silurian to Old Red), 94. ; General order of Upper Silurian, 1 02 ; al- tered limestone. Nash Scar, 103.; Kington (trap and Silurian), 104. ; Wren's Nest (Dudley), 117.; across the Ludlow promontory, 126. ; Brecon Anticlinal, 141.; Silurian Rocks S. of Scotland, 152. ; across the Bins of Conne- mara, 169.; from Upper Silurian to the South Welsh coal-field, 243.'; across the Old Red Sandstone of Forfarshire, 248. ; across N. Devon, 256. ; general order of carboniferous rocks in the central and southern parts of England, 270. ; Pembrokeshii e (succession of strata), 272. ; across Cornbrook coal- • basin, 273. ; slash of culm, 275. ; on west flank of the South Ural Mountains, 296. ; showing relations of Permian rocks to coal, 301.; Permian rocks in Shropshire, 302.; lowest Silurian of Sweden (two diagrams), 318.; from Lower Silurian to Old Red Sand- stone in Norway, 319, 320. ; Lower Silurian cliffs at Waiwara, Russia, 324. ; Valdai Hills, Russia, 328. ; across the Silurian basin of Bohemia, 342.; inversion of rocks in the Eifel, 377. ; inverted strata at Brilon, Westphalia, 378. ; Silurian succession of France, 385. ; succession in the United States, 424.; suc- cession in Lower Canada, 424.; gold diggings in the Ural Mountains (three diagrams), 442. 444, 445.; ideal, showing the formation and distribution of gold, 449. Sedgeley (Staffordshire), Lower Ludlow of, 130. ; . Aymestry rock of, 133. Sedgwick, Adam, Rev., term Cambrian how em- ployed hj, Pi'eface, 7 — 25.; N. Wales and Cumberland, 10 — 30.; on the paleozoic fos- sils of the Cambridge museum, 10. 177.; the north Welsh mountains, 19.; slaty cleavage, 34. ; structure of mineral masses, 34. ; Tre- madoc slates, 44. ; Hirnant limestone, 49. ; separation of Caradoc beds at May Hill, 98. 104.; the inversion of rocks in Cornwall, 145,; Silurians of Cumberland, 146. et seq.; classification of Old Red Sandstone, 254.; anJ Murchison on the geology of Devonshire, 257. 259, 260. 264.; culm rocks of Devon, 276.; Permian rocks described by, 305. 392. ; on the Thiiringerwald, 350. ; and Murcliison on the paljBOzoic rocks of Saxony, 361. 378.; on Rhenish provinces, 365. 377. Selkirk, Earl of, Silurian fossils collected by, 182. 208. Selkirkshire, section across, 152. Selwyn, A. R. C, maps and sections by, 54. ; on Australian gold, 458. Seraphim, crustacean of Old Red Sandstone, 237. Sergiefsk (Russia), baths of, 296. Serra de Busaco, Silurian rocks of, 404.; de Mucella, Silurian rocks of, 404. Sertularia, 46. Severn river, Permian deposits near, 270. Seville, coal fields of, 401. Shangai (China), Devonian fossils, 14. Sharpe, D.,on Silurian rocks of Britain, Preface; on Silurian rocks in Portugal, 13. 402.; on slaty cleavage, 35. 256.; on Silurian rocks of Cumberland, 148.; on palaaozoic rocks of America, 374. 415.; Devonian rocks of the Rhine and Belgium, 381. Shelve, Lower Silurian schists 14,000 feet thick (section of) 28, 29. 39.; volcanic grits, 45.; lead veins in Lower Silurian, 53. Shetland Isles, Old Red Sandstone plants, 255. Shrewsbury and Ludlow railroad, 84.; coal strata near, 286. Shropshire, early researches in, 6, 7. ] hills of Silurian rocks little altered, 19.; igneous rocks, effects of, 20. ; Longmynd and Silurian rocks of, 23. 26.; bottom rocks of, 26.; lowest rocks of, void of fossils, 31.; lowest zone of animal life in, 35. ; (west) N. Wales identi- fied with, 39. ; Corndon and Shelve district, 39 — 45.; equivalents of the Lingula flags, 41.; volcanic rocks in, 55. ; volcanic grits in, 55.; Caradoc formation in, 81, et seq.; Cara- doc of, 88. ; thickness of Silurian rocks, 1 74. ; coal field of, 270.; position of Permian rocks in, 301. Shucknall Hill (Hereford), Upper Ludlow rock, 142. Shurman, Dr.B. F. (for, read Shumard, American geologist), 421. Siberia, crystaUine palceozoic rocks, 334. ; gold of, Sidlaw Hills, rocks of, section, 247. Sierra Morena, in Spain, Lower Silui'ian rocks, 396. ; Almagrera, lead and silver ores, 397. ; Cantabrica, Devonian rocks, 399. ; Nevada, Silurian rocks, 409. Sierras Gata and Francia, Appendix G. Silesia, Palaeozoic rocks analogous to those of Moravia, 340. ; graptolites recently found, Appendix M. Sille' le Guillaume, France, section, 385. Silliman, Prof., works by, 412. Silver, deep veins of, 457. Silures, an ancient British people, 6. Siluria, Preface and introductoiy view and INDEX. 621 origin of name, 1 — 6. ; design of the work, 9. Silurian system established. Preface, 10.; rocks, base of, 17. ; external forms of, 20. ; Lower, Cambrian rocks identified with, Pre- Jace, 26.; rocks contain lowest fossils of North Wales, 43. ; Lower, with interpolated trap, 61. ; of. Pembroke and Carmarthen, 62. ; of Marloes Bay, 66. ; break between Upper and Lower, 81. ; Lower, unity of, 87. ; Upper, rocks, where unconformable to Llandeilo flags, 90. ; Lower, of Malvern Hills, 93. ; rocks, Malvern Hills, 95. ; pas- sage from Lower to Upper, 97. ; IJpper, general character and section of, 100 — 102. ; Silm-ian of Cornwall, 145. ; of Scotland, and section of, 149. 152. ; metamorphosed, Scot- land, 163., Ireland, 171. ; of Ireland, 165— 172. ; British, thickness of rocks, 173. 175. ; fossils originally described by J. De C. Sow- erby and J. W. Salter, 176. ; Lower, rocks, organic remains, and woodcuts, 176 — 206. ; corals originally described by W. Lonsdale, 179.; Upper, organic remains (woodcuts), 207 — 240. ; Lower, of America, dolomitic, 304. ; Scandinavia, 321. ; Eussia, 323. ; Upper, Eussia, 325. ; Silurian rocks, Bo- hemia (see Barrande), 341. 349. ; in France, 381. 383. 387.; Spain, 397. etseq. ; Por- tugal, 402. ; Sardinia, 405. ; South America and United States, 408—423. ; British North America, 423 — 430. ; Lower, of Australia and the Ural, chiefly auriferous, 452. ; de- posits offer no signs of arborescent vegetation, 473, 474. Skiddaw, graptolites of, 146. ; schists, part of Lower Silurian, 149. Skomer, Isles of, 66. Skye, hypersthene rocks, 104. Slash, local term for troughs of broken coal, 275. Slates, best roofing, 31. ; Snowdon, Lower Si- lurian fossils, 72. Slaty cleavage and bedding, woodcut, 34. ; cleav- age coinciding with laminaj of deposit, 64. Smith, T. Assheton, grand slate quarries of, 31. Smith,William, the father of English geology, 303. Smyth, Warington, on British gold, 433. 435. Snowdon, slates and fossils of, 9, 25, 28, 29, 30, 31. 39. Soimanofsk, Ural, gold diggings, 442. Sondley, Salop, Caradoc sandstone, 83. South America, Silurian and other palasozoic rocks of, 14. 408. et seq. South Devon. Devonian, 259.; Lower Silurian rock, 260.' South Stack light-house, Anglesea, view of, 24. South Wales, Silurian rocks little altered, 19.; Silurian rocks of, 62. et seq. South Welsh coal field, 224. 270. 278. Sowerby, J. De C, on fossils of the Silurian System, Preface, 138. 176. Spain, Silurian rocks of, 13.; palssozoic rocks altered, 316.; pateozoic rocks, 395.; Silurian rocks, 397.; Devonian rocks, 399.; carboni- ferous rocks, 400 — 402. ; and Portugal, fron- tiers, Silurian rocks, Appendix G. Spaniards, fail in extracting gold from deep mines, 448. Spha^ronites, 181. Spirifer, genus, very rare in Lower Silurian, 188.; sandstein (Germany), Lower Devonian, 367. Spitzbergen, palasozoic fossils of, 335. Stackpole Cliffs, carboniferous limestone, 271. Stanner Hill, Eadnorshire, hypersthene rocks of, 89.; rocks, view from, 105. Stansbury, Captain, exploration of the lake of Utah, 18. 423. Steensfiord (Norway), section across, 319. Steininger, Prof., work by, 369. Stephen, G. M., on Australian minerals, 453. Steppes, Eussian, carboniferous rocks of, 280. Stevenson, W., on Silurian and Old lied of Dunse alluded to, 154. Stigmaria, roots of sigillaria, 278. Stinchar river, Scotland, Silurian rocks, 157. Stiper stones, Shropshire, lowest Silurian, 7. 27.; section across, 29.; views of,' 37.; altered Silurian sandstone, 36.; Cruziana, a raro fossil of, 39. Stonehaven (Scotland) coast section of, 164. Strachey, Captain E., on rocks and fossils of the Himalaya, 14. Strata, ascending order o^ 23. ; mere thickness of no test of age, 93. Strathmore, section across, 248, Strickland, H. E., discovers Agnostus pisiformis in Malvern schists, 43. 92.; on Pterygotus problematicus, 142.; Pterygotus in Upper Caradoc of Malvern, 237.; lamentable death of, 245. Strike of Silurian rocks, 101. and passim. Stringocephalus, Limestone, Devon, 256. ; Ehe- nish provinces, 369. 382. Strophomena, of Lower Silurian, 188.; of Upper Silurian, 223. Strzelecki, Count, work on Australia alluded to, 14.; gold discovered by, in Australia, 450. Stutchbury, S., on Permian reptiles, 301.; re- ports on New South Wales, 452. Studer, Prof. B., Geologic der Schweiz. 476. Stumps Wood, Woolhope limestone, 97. Sudeten Mountains (Germany), 340. Suilvein, mountain of Highlands, 249. Superior, Lake, North America, 423. Superposition, criterion of age of rocks, 48. Surveyors, geological, of government sections bv, Preface, 23, 24. 28, 60. 98. 109, Sutherland, Dr., Journal of Captain Penny's Arctic voyage, 428. Sutherland, sketch by the late Countess of, 249; mountains of, 250. Sweden, trilobites in Lower Silurian, 44.321.; alum slates, 47. 318.; fucoid sandstone, 38. 321.; Lower Silurian (sections), 318. Upper Silurian, 322. Syenite, Hanter Hill (Kington, Eadnorshire), 104.; of Ural Mountains with gold, 440. Symonds, Eev. W. S., on recent discoveries near Malvern, 496. System. See Silurian, 28. 522 INDEX. Systems, Upper and Lower Palaeozoic explained, 310. 464. Syzran (Russia), Carboniferous limestone, 333. Tagus, gold of the, 432. Tan-y-bwlch, volcanic grits of, 53. Tartary, mountain chains, 14. Tate, G., carboniferous flora, 377. Tchihatcheff, Pierre de, work on the Altai mountains, 334.; palaeozoic rocks of Asia Minor, Appendix N. Tchussovaya river, gorge of, 330. Telerpeton Elginense, reptile of the Old Red Sandstone, 254. Teme river, banks of, 125. Tentaculites, Lower Silurian, 200. Terebratula, Silurian, now called Rhynconella, 138, 183. Tertiary deposits, gold wanting in, 432.; formed when the. earth approached to its present out- line, 478.; great dislocations posterior to, Appendix Q. Teviotdale, unfossiliferoas greywacke, 151. Texas, Silurian rocks, 409. Theca, Lower Silurian, 196.; Upper Silurian, 231. Thelodus parvidens. Upper Ludlow fish, 238. Thomson, Prof.Wyville, on Silurian of Scotland, 159.; Arctic fossils, 428. Thornbury, Permian conglomerate, 302. Thornielee slates, graptolites, 153. Thuringia, Silurian and Devonian rocks, 353. 355.; Lower carboniferous rocks, 359.; con- tains no Upper Silurian, 361. 373. Thiiringerwald, gold, 436. Tilestones, Upper in Silurian beds, 138.; fossils of, 139.; oldest traces of vegetation in, 139. Turbo, common in, 230.; Upper Ludlow fossils, 242. Tin-y-coed, Radnorshire, useless search after coal, 61. Tin, found in Cornwall and Australia, 400. 453. Titterstone Clee, (Salop) basaltic, 125.; carbo- , niferous rocks, 273. Toledo mountains, Lower Silurian, 396. Tarentaise, apparent intercalation of belemnites with coal explained, 407. Tongueland, (Kircudbrightshire), porpliyiy of, 162. Torquay, Old Red Sandstones, 260. Towy, vale of, 69. Tracks made by marine worms, 199. Trachyderma, wrinkled tubes of annelids, 233. Trails of animals, evidences of contiguity of land, 472. 474. Transmutation of strata by heat, 1 8. Trap of Corndon Hills, 57. ; bedded with Lower Silurian, woodcut, 57. Tree ferns in Old Red Sandstone, 265. Tremadoc, rare crustaceans, 40. Trenton limestone (America), Lower Silurian, 413. Trewerne Hills, Upper Ludlow, 140.; section across, 243. Trias, the fauna and flora different from those of Permian, 299- Trias, bone bed, 466. Triger, M., geological map by, 384. Tri nucleus concentricus, 60. Trilobites, the earliest crustaceans, 41, 42.; of St. Bride's Bay,65.; Lower Wenlock, or Wool- hope limestone, 108.; Wenlock shale, 112. ; Lower Silurian, 201.; common in Wenlock limestone, 122. 235. ; Silurian of Scotland, 58. ; Silurian of Ireland, 166. ; Devonian, 262.; distorted by slaty cleavage, 35.; Upper Silurian, 233. ; last appearance in carboni- ferous limestone, 281.; Devonian, 346.; me- tamorphosis, 349. ; wanting in Permian strata, 311. ; Sweden and Norway, 318. ; Russia, 324.; Bohemia, 342.; Thuringia and Saxony, 351.; Rhenish Provinces, 368. 382.; France, 386.; Spain, 397.; Portugal, 404.; America, 408. et seq. Tuffnell, H., Right Hon., Old Red fossil plants, 255. Turritella, (see Holopella), 192. Turkey, in Europe, general sketch of its older rocks, 336. Valdai Hills, ravine of the Belaia, 328. Valenciennes, coal field of, 391. Valentia, island, 167- Vallongo (Portugal), coal field, 402. Valorsine, palaeozoic rocks, 407. Vegetation, oldest traces of, 139. 267. ; ideal view of that of the coal period, 268. ; De- vonian, 358. ; and fishes contemporaneous, 461. ; palEeozoic uniformity of, 477. Veinstones of gold, 449. ; of silver, 457. Verneuil, Ed. de, contribution to this work. Pre- face ; Russia and the Ural Alountains, 5. 7. ; on Permian, 291. 322.; palccozoic rocks of America, 374. 417. et seq.; on Silurian rocks of France and Spain, 384. 393. et seq. Vertebrated animals, not called into existence in the greater portion of the Silurian jjeriod, 205. 239. 460. Vichy, carboniferous rocks near, 269. Victoria, (Australia), gold fields of with tin, 453. Virgularia, allied to graptolites, 46. Unger, Professor, on Upper Devonian plants, 358. Ungulite schists (Russia), 324. United States, rocks, 18.; Devonian rocks of, 417.; gold in Silurian rocks, 458.; Silurian rocks and geological succession in, 15. 415. etseq.; Devonian rocks of, 416.; works on the geology of, 412. Univalve shells. Upper Silurian, 229.; Lower Silurian, 195. Volborth, on Echino-encrinites, 181. Volcanic grits, 45. 57.; and Llandeilo flags, woodcuts, 57.; submarine dejections during Caradoc period, 85. Volcano, submarine, of Lower Silurian, 56. Volga river, Permian rocks, 269. 293.; carbo- niferous limestone, 333. Voltzia, a Pennian plant, 299. Vosges, mountains, Permian beds of, 393. Ural mountains, Silurian rocks of, 10.; Permian INDEX. 523 deposits on West flank of, 294, 295.; section of the West flank of, 296. ; carboniferous lime- stone on, 333.; gold of, 437. et seq.; meta- morphosed Silurian and Devonian, view from, 437, 438.; Lake of Aushkul, 441.; when it became chiefly auriferous, 447.; parallel be- tween and the Australian mountains, 452. Uraster obtusus, Lower Silurian star fish, 182. Usk, Lower Ludlow, rocks of, 128.; Aymestry, rocks of, 133.; Upper Ludlow of, 140.; Wen- lock limestone of, 115.; Old Red Sandstone near, 244. Utah, Great Salt Lake of, 18. Utica Slates, Silurian rock of America, 415. Waiwara, (Gulf of Bothnia), cliffs, 324. Waldenberg, Silesia, Devonian and carboniferous of, 338. Wales, lowest rocks of, void of fossils, see N. and S. Wales, 31.; crystalline rocks of, 34.; thickness of Silurian strata in, 174. Walkers earth, producing landslips, 127. 131. Waterford, Lower Silurian, 165, 166. Water break its neck, Ludlow rock, 125. Wathen, Mr., memoir by, 453. Wealden, secondary freshwater group, 467. Weaver, T., on geology of Ireland, 164, 167. Wellfield, Builth, section near, 91. Welsh Pool, 59.; prismatic dyke at, 60. Wenlock Edge, views of, 26. 113.; (Lower) Woolhope limestone at Gorton, near Presteign, 103.; lower limestone shale, 102, 103, 111. ,• fossils of, 1 11.; limestone, 114.; thickness of! 118.; corals of, 119—123. Westgarth, Mr., on Victoria, Australia, 453. Westmoreland, Silurian rocks, 145. Westphalia, Devonian rocks at, 372. Wexford, Lower Silurians of, 166. Whewell, Rev. Dr. W., sketch by, 117. White Sea (Russian), Devonian strata of, 329 Whiteway Head, section across, 126.; sketch of escarpment, 1 30. Wicklow, LowerSilurian, 165.; mountains, 1 68. ; Earl of, his nuggets of Irish gold, 435.; gold in Lower Silurian schists, 435. Wigmore, valley of, denudation of, 12. Wigton, Silurian of, 149. 157. Williams, Rev. Stewart, 74. Wilson, Mr. S. S., Californian gold rocks, 458. Windermere, Upper Silurian, 148. Winstanston (Salop), 84. Wissenbach, slates of, 368. Witham , H., on fossil vegetables, 278. Wolverhampton, 270. Woodwardian Museum, Cambridge, 177. 181. Woolhope limestone, 96, 97.; position of, 102.; limestone altered, 103.; section across the valley of, and descriptions, 106, 118. 142.; Lower Wenlock limestone described, 107.; fossils in limestone of, 107,tl08.; in Radnor- shire, 108.; Malvern and May Hill, 109.; Lower Lickey Hill, Worcester, 110.; Ludlow Rocks, 128. 132.; fish bed of Upper Ludlow, 142. ' Worcester Beacon (Malvern), view, 92. ; igneous rocks, 95. Wormes (island in Baltic)^ Upper Silurian, 327. Wrae Hill, Scotland, fossils of, 149.; parallel of Llandeilo limestone, 153. Wrekin, the, felspathic trap rocks, 83. 85. Wren's Nest, Dudley, south end view and sec- tion, 117. Wye (river), igneous rocks near Builth, 61.; Lower Silurian sandstone on, 70.; Upper Ludlow rocks, 140.; Old Red conglomerate in gorges of, 244. Wyld, W., memoir and map on gold, 453, Wynn, Sir Watkin, his monument, 79. Xiphosura, crustacean allied to Pterygotus, 237. Yat Hill, Radnor, altered rock of, 104. Yorkshire, Silurian rocks, 145.; coal fields, 270. ; development of carboniferous limestone' 271. 273.; Permian rocks, 303. Zarevo Alexandrofsk, (gold diggings, Ural), 444. Zechstein, limestone in Permian rocks of' Ger- many, 291. 300. ; equivalent of magnesian limestone of England, 303. ; wanting in France, 393. ; the centre of Permian life,°465. Zoantharia, corals, 209. Zone, lowest containing animal life in Great Britain, 35. ; Primordiale, Barrande (Bohe- mia), equivalent of Lingula Flags, 342.; in Sweden, 321.; in America, 413. 422. 425. et seq. Zoophyte oldest, Oldhamia antiqua, in bottom rocks of Ireland, 32. Zoophytes, Lower Silurian, woodcuts, 32. 177, 178.; Upper Silurian, 209.; the first created' animals, 459. THE END. London: A. and G. A. SpottiswoodE, New- street- Square. I I ANNKI.IDA & CRHSTACEA. Pl.l, PLATE I. (The figures in this and the following plates are all transferred from the original engravings m the "Silurian System." In every case where the old names have been changed in accordance with the modern nomenclature, the name used m the original work is inserted m brackets, for the purpose of reference.) LOWER SILURIAN CRUSTACEA. Fig. 1. TENTACULITES ANNULATUS, Schlotheim. a, portion magnified. Acton Scott, Shropshire. 2. , the same. Interior casts in sandstone. (T. scalaris.) 3. ASAPHUS TYRANNUS, Murch. Tail of a young specimen. Llandeilo. 4. The largest specimen known. Same locality. The original of this figure is in the British Museum. It is a mould in sand- stone of the exterior ornamented surface. a PLATE 11. LOWER SILUHIAN CRUSTACEA. Fig. 1. ASAPHUS TYRANNUS, Murch. Tail, and two thorax segments, of a moderate-sized inc^vidual. Llandeilo, Caernaarthenshirc. 2. ASAPHUS POWISII, Murch. Body and tail of full-sized speci- men. Welshpool, 3,4. HOMALONOTUS (Asaphus) VULCANI, Murch. Cornden Hill, Shropshire. L ■© WEM ^ H IL TLJ m I A M . PLATE HI. LOWER SILURIAN CRUSTACEA. Pig. 1. OGYGIA (Asaphus) BUGHII, Brongniart. Builth, Radnorshire, 2. Hypostome, or upper lip of ditto, fixed to the underside of the head. Llandeilo. 3. A very young specimen. Builth. (Trinucleus Asaphoides.) 4. OGYGIA (Asaphus) CORNDENSIS, Murch. From near the flanks of the Cornden Hill, Shropshire. The figure (4) is omitted, it apphes to the right hand specimen, at the top of the plate. 5,6. ENCRINURUS (Calymene?) PUNCTATUS, Briinmch. Upper Caradoc sandstone, Bogmine, Shropshire. 7. CALYMENE (Asaphus) DUPLICATA, Murch. Wilmington, Salop. 8. AGNOSTUS McCOYII, Salter. (A. pisiformis.) Builth, Radnor- shire. Natural size, and the head magnified. a 2 PLATE lY. LOWER SILURIAN CRUSTACEA. Fig. 1. STYQINA (Ogygia) MURCHISON^, Mvircb. Mount Pleasant, Caermartheu. 2. 4, 5. TRINUCLEUS CONCENTRICUS, Eaton. (T. Caractaci.) Welahpool. 3. Portion of fringe, highly magnified. 6. TRIN. LLOYDII, Murch. Llangadock, Caermarthenshire. 7. TRIN. FIMBRIATUS, Murch. Builth. 8. TRIN. RADIATU3, Murch. Welshpool. 9, 10. AMPYX (Trinucleus) NUDUS, Murch. Builth, Radnorshire. 11, 12. PHACOPS CONOPHTHALMUS, Bosck. (Head of Asaphus Powisii, Sil. Syst.) Horderley, and Acton Scott, Shropshire. 13, 14. ILL^NUS PEROVALIS, Murch. N. E. end of the Corndcn IIill, Shropshire. CRUSIACEA PI. 1'. PLATE VI. LOWER SILURIAN BRACHIOPODA. . 1, 2. ORTHIS TESTUDINARIA, Dalman. Horderley ; Meifod, 3, 4. ORTHIS (Terebratula) UNGUIS, Sow. Horderley and Cheney Longville, Shropshire. 5. O. ELEGANTULA (canahs), Dalman. Meifod ; Bala. 6. O. (Spirifer) ALATA, Sow. Mount Pleasant, Carmarthen. 7, 8, 9. ORTHIS CALLIGRAMMA, Dalm. (Spirifer phcatns, Orthis callactis, O. virgata.) LlandoTery ; Horderley ; Bala. Fig. 8. is from Upper Caradoc beds, Shropshire. 10. O. RADIANS, Sow. Near Builth. 11. O. ACTONI^, Sow. Acton Scott, Shropshire ; Bala. 12. O. PLABELLULUM, Sow. Hopesay, Shropshire ; Bala. 13, 14. LEPT^NA SERICEA, Sow. Bala ; Whittingslow and Horderley, Slirop shire ; Meifod; Llandovery. 15. L. TRANSVERSALIS (duplicata), Dalm. Robeston Wathen, Pembrokeshire. HHACHXOPOJJ.4 PI. 6. JD C uov^erhf PI . 7. PLATE YIL LOWER SILURIAN BRACHIOPODA. Fig. 1. STROPHOMENA EXPANSA, Sow. (Orthis expansa, and O. Pecten.) Meifod. 2. STROPH. COMPRESSA, Sow. Upper Caradoc, Hope Quarry Shropshire. 3. S. (Leptaena) TENUISTRIATA, Sow. Gmlsfield, Welshpool. 4. ORTHIS ALTERNATA, Sow.. Cheney Longville, Shropshire; Bala. 5. STROPHOMENA (Leptsena) COMPLANATA, Sow. Acton B-urnell, Shropshire. 6, 7. S. (Orthis) GRANDIS. Soudley and Acton Scott, Shropshire; Bala. a 4 PLATE VIIL LOWER SILURIAN BRACHIOPODA. 1, 2, 3. PENTAMERUS OBLONGUS, Sow. Uppermost Caradoc, Shrop- shire ; Llandeilo flags, Llandovery, &c., in S. Wales. 4. Broader variety of the same (P. leevis). The Hollies, Shropshire ; in Upper Caradoc. 5, 6, 7. PENTAMERUS (Atrypa) UNDATUS, Sow. Llandovery ; and Pembrokeshire. 8. P. (Atrypa) GLOBOSUS, Sow. Gorllwyn fach, Llandoveiy. 9,10. P. (Atrypa) LENS, Sow. Llandovery; in Llandeilo flags. Lickey Quartz, Bromsgrove (Upper Caradoc). 11. Portion of ditto (Spirifer J laevis). Upper Caradoc, May Hill. LO-TEM SIILTLJISil AH. BRACHIOPODA n.8. J.D CSowwiy. PLATE IX. LOWER SILURIAN BIVALVE AND UNIVALVE SHELLS. Fig. 1. MODIOLOPSIS or MODIOLA (Avicula) ORBICULARIS, Sow. Horderley, Shropshire. 2. MODIOLOPSIS? (Avicula) OBLI QUA, Sow. Soudley, Shropshire. 3. NUCULA LiEVIS, Sow, Pensarn, near Caermarthen. 4. NUCULA? (Area) EASTNORI, Sow. Upper Caradoc, Malverns. 5, 6. NUCULA? SUBiEQUALIS (Area Eastnon), McCoy. Same locality. 7. PLEUROTOMARIA ANGULATA, Sow. Mandinam, Llandovery. 8, TURBO ? PRYCE^, Sow. Llandovery. Same locality. PLATE X. LOWER SILURIAN UNIVALVES. Fig. 1. HOLOPEA (Littorina) STRIATELLA, Sow. Horderley. 2. SCALITES (Trochns) LENTICULARIS, Sow. Old Storridge Hill., Worcester ; Upper Caradoc. 3. MACROCHEILUS (Buccin-um?) FUSIFORME, Sow. Upper Caradoc, Nash Scar, Presteign. 4 HOLOPELLA (Torritella) CANCELLATA, Sow. Llandovery. 5. BELLEROPHON PERTURB ATUS, Sow. (Euomphalus tenui- striatiis.) Middleton, Cornden Hills. 6. EUOMPHALUS CORNDENSIS, Sow. Leigh Hall, Cornden. (a, magnified.) 7. BELLEROPHON ACUTUS, Sow. Horderley. 8, 9-. BILOBATUS, Sow. Horderley. 10. (Euomphams) PERTURBATUS, Sow. Pensarn, Caermarthen, in Llandeilo flags. (See also fig. 5.) J^D C. Smreriy I, © W M M 'S t JL "iiJ IE i A , CP PllAl.OPODA PI 11 PLATE XL LOWER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. 1. LITUITES CORNU-ARIETIS, Sow. Var. «, placed here for comparison, is from the very base of the Upper Silurian at Gorton, Presteign ; but it is also found in the Upper Caradoc of Bogmine, Shropshire, and at Bala in Llandeilo flags. 3. : Var. /3, Cefn-y-Garreg, Llandovery ; in Llandeilo flags. 3. LITUITES (Nautilus) UNDOSUS, Sow. Blaen-y-cwm, Llan- dovery. 4. CyRTOCERAS (Orthoceras) APPROXIMATUM, Sow. Eastnor Park, in Upper Caradoc. 5. DIPLOCERAS (Orthoc.) BISIPPIONATUM, Sow. Gorllwyn fach, Llandovery. PLATE XII. GRAPTOLITES AND " INCERT^ SEDIS," LOWER SILURIAN. rig. 1. DIDYMOGRAPSUS (Graptolithus) MUKCHISON^, Bceck. Llan- drindod HiUa, Radnorshire. 2. DIPLOGRAPSUS (Grapt.) FOLIACEUS, Murch. Meadow Town, near Shelve, Shropshire. Accompanied by the small ORBI- CULA PORTLOCKI, Geinitz. 3. GLYPTOCRINUS sp. Upper Caradoc, Nash Scar, Presteign. The disjointed stems of this genua are very common, both in the sandy portions of the Llandeilo flags, and m the Caradoc sandstone. The central canal is always very large. UPPER SILURIAN. 4. GRAPTOLITHUS PRIODON (Ludensis), Bronn. 4a, magmfied. Llanfair, Welshpool. 5. SPONGARIUM INTERRUPTUM Milne Edw. (a Calciphyte). Upper Ludlow Rock, Birchen Common, Aymestry. 6. ISCHADITES KONIGII, Murch. Probably a Cystidean. Lower Ludlow Rock, Ludlow. PLATE XIII. UPPEK SILURIAN CRINOIDEA. Fig. 1. PERIECHOCRINUS (Actmocrinus) MONILIFORMIS, Miller. Dudley. 2. Stem and pelvis of ditto. 3. Pelvis of CROTALOCRINUS (Cyathocrinus) RUGOSUS, Miller. Dudley. 4. DIMER0CRINU3 ICOSIDACTYLUS, Phill. Diidley. 5. D. DECADACTYLUS, Phill. Dudley. PLATE XIY. UPPER SILURIAN CRINOIDEA. Fig. 1. MARSUPIOCRINUS CGELATUS, Phill. Dudley. 3. EUCALYPTOCRINUS (Hypanthocrinus) DEOORUS, Phill. Dud- ley. 2a, outlines of the pelvic plates. 3. ICTHYOCRINUS ? (Actmocrinus) GONIODACTYLUS, Phill. Dudley. 4. CYATHOCRINUS TESSERACONTADACTYLUS (Actinocrinites simplex), Hisinger ? Dudley. 5, 6. CYATH. TUBERCULATUS, Miller. Dudley. 7. ICTHYOCRINUS ? (Actmocrmus) ARTHRITICUS, Phill. Dudley. 7^., a few joints with tentacles, magnified. 5. ICTH. (Cyathocrinus) PYRIFORMIS, Miller. Dudley. 9. ACTINOCRINUS RETIARIUS, Phill. Dudley. PI 14^. PI 15 PLATE XV. UPPER SILURIAN CRINOIDEA. Fig. 1, 2. GLYPTOCRINUS (Actinocrinus) EXPANSUS, PhiU, Dudley. 3. ICTHYOCRINUS? (Actinocrinus) CAPILLARIS, PhiU. Pig. 3a, a magnified portion of the finger, Wenlock and Dudley. 4. Irregular inverted pyramid, formed in the mudstone of the Upper Ludlow Rock, by the rotary motion of Encrinite stems (one is seen at the extreme left hand of the fossil) m the soft micaceous matrix : see p. 137. (Cophinus dubius, Sil. Syst.) Upper Ludlow Rock, Ludlow. PLATE XVI. UPPER SILURIAN ANNELIDA; Fig. 1. SERPULITES LONGISSIMUS, Murch. Ludlow. 2. SPIRORBIS LEWISII, Sow. Natural size, on the inner surface of a Lituites, and 2a magnified. Wenlock Limest. Ledbury, Common in Upper Ludlow Rock. 3 to 9. CORNULITES SERPULARIUS, Schloth. 3 to 7- Are of the nat\iral size, and show the tubes attached in twos or threes to shells, &c. Fig. 8. is a longitudinal section of a full grown tube, and shows the cellular structure at the successive varices of growth. 3a, and 9. Are magnified portions of young tubes, shewing the cuter striated coat covering the cellular layers. These layers are better seen in fig. 10. as well as the pits left by them on the edges of the internal cast ; also the impressed longitudinal lines running down the inner surface. Malverns. 11. TENTACULITES ORNATUS, Sow. Natural size, magnified, and a section. Dudley. 12. T. TENUIS, Sow. Natural size, and magnified. Usk, Monmouth shire, in Upper Ludlow Rock. PI 16 I CRUSTACEA. P1.17 PLATE XVTI. UPPER SILURIAN TRILOBITES. ^■ig. 1. CALYMENE BLUMENBACHII, Brongn. W. L .» Dudley. 2. PHACOPS (Asaphus) CAUDATUS, Brongn. W. L. Dudley. t3 to 6. P. LONGICAUDATUS, Murch. W. Sh. Wistanstow and Burrmgton. Shropshire. 7. PROETUS (Asaphus) STOKESII, Murch. W. L. Dudley. 8. PROETUS— sp. Wenlock Limestone, Ledbuiy, Malverns. 9 to 11. ILLCENUS (Section-Bumastus) BARRIENSIS, Murch. 10. Side View of the Head and Eye. Woolhope Limest., Barr, Staffordshire ; Malverns, &c. * In this and the succeeding pages, U. L. stands for Upper Ludlow ; A. L., Aymestry Limestone ; L. L., Lower Ludlow ; W. L Wenlock Lunestone ; W. Sh., Wenlock Shale. t Figs. 3 to 5 are omitted - they are at the left hand upper corner. b PLATE XVIIL UPPER SILURIAN CRUSTACEA. F)g. 1. PHACOPS (Asaphus) CAUDATUS, Brongn. W. L. Dudley. 2, 5. PHAC. (Calymene) DOWNINGI^, Mmxli. W. L. Dudley. 3, 4. Tails of young Specimens, (Asaphus Cawdori, and A. subcaudatu.s, Sil. Syst.) From Ludlow Rocks, Pembrokeshire. 6. PHACOPS STOKESII, Milne Edw. (Calymene macrophthalma.) W. L. Dudley and Wallsall. 7.8. ACIDASPIS BRIGHTII, Murch. (8. Paradoxides quadiuiuucrouatus. W. L. Dudley. 9. ENCRINURUS (Calymene) VARIOLARIS, Brongn. W. L. Dudley. 10. CALYMENE BLUMENBACHII, Brongn. W. L. Dudley. 11, C. TUBERCULOSA, Salter. (C. Blumenbachu var., Sil. Syst.^ W. Sh. Burrington, Shropshire. I I PLATE XIX. UPPER Silurian: TRiLOBiTEs, and other CRUSTACEA. igs. 1, 2. LEPTOCHELES (Onchus) MURCHISONI, McCoy.— spines of tnu Tail. 'Uppermost Ludlow Rock, near Ludlow. 3. LEPTOCHELES— sp. frag-ment of tail spina. Same locality. 4,5. PTERYGOTUS PROBLEMATICUS, Agass. Portions of the Carapace, nat. size, and magnified. Ludford, in the ' Bone Bed.' 6. Portion of the Base of one of the jaw-feet. Same locality. 7 to 9. UOMALONOTUS KNIGHTIT, (including H. Ludensis, S. Syst.) Upper Ludlow Rock, Ludlow. LU, 11. CHEIRURUS (Paradoxides) BIMUCRONATUS, Murch. 10, the Bo ay Segments ; and 11, the tail : the former is placed in. an inverted position, the anterior end downwards. (It was so engraved m the original work.) Wenlock Limestone, Malverns. PLATE XX. UPPER SILURIAN BRACHIOPODA. 1, 2. ORBICULA RUGATA, Sow. U. L., Ludlow. 3. — — STRIATA, Sow. U . L., Delbury, Shropshire. ' 4. CRANIA (Patella) IMPLICATA, Sow. W. L., Abberley. 5. LINGULA LEWISII, Sow. A. L., Mary Knoh, Ludlow. 6. L. LATA, Sow. L. L., Elton. 7. L. ? STRIATA, Sow. L. L., near Aymestry. 8. CHONETES (Leptsena) LATA. Von Buch. U. L., Ludlow. 9. ORTHIS ELEGANTULA, var. ORBICULARIS. (0. orbicularis, Sow.) Exterior and internal cast. U. L., Ludlow. 10. ORTHIS CALLIGRAMMA, Dalm. Var. RUSTICA. (O. rustica, S. Syst.) W. L. Valley of Woolhope. 11. O. LUNATA, Sow. Exterior and internal casts of both valves. U. L., Ludlow. n. O. ELEGANTULA (canahs), Dalm. W. L., Dormington, Woolhope. 13. O. HYBRIDA, Sow. W. L., Wallsall. 14. O. BILOBA, (smuata), Lmn. W. L., Wallsall. 15. LEPTyENA L.^VIGATA, Sow. W. Sh., Bui-rington. 16. L. MINIMA, Sow. Natural size and magnified. W, Sh., Burrington. 17. L. TRANSVERSALIS, Dalm. W. Sh., Buildwas. 18. STROPHOMENA (Leptsena) ANTIQUATA, Sow. W. Sh., Woolhope. 19. S. (Leptcena) EUGLYPHA. Dalm. W. L., Dudley. -20. S. (LcpbtJini DEPRESSA, Sow. W. L., Dudley. ► r r-1.21 B K A C H I I' { ) D A . PLATE XXI. UPPER SILURIAN BRACHIOPOD A . Fig. 1. SPIRIFER PLICATELLUS, Lmn. var. INTERLINEATUS, iin-erliiieatiis) . A. L., Aymestry. 2. SPIRIFER PLICATELLUS (radiatus), Lirm. W. L. Malverns. 3. S. TRAPEZOIDALIS, Dalm. U. L., Usk. 4. S. CRISPUS, Linn. W. L., Dudley. 5, 6. S. ELEVATUS, Dalm. (octoplicatus). W. L., Abberlcy. 7. S. ? PISUM, Sow. W. L , Wallsall. S, 9. PENTAMERUS (Atrypa) GALEATUS, Dalm. W. L., Wenlock Edge; Dudley; Pembrokeshire. 10. P. KNIGHTII, Sow. A. L. Downton on the Rock ; Sedgley. 11. var. AYLESFORDII. Same localities. 12, 13. ATRYPA RETICULARIS (affinis), Lmn. A. L.,W.L., Shropshne ; May Hill ; Dudley, &c. Woolhopc L. Woolhopc. PLATE XXII. UPPER SILURIAN BRACHIOPODA. ] , 2. RHYNCHONELLA NUCULA, 8ow. (TerebretvQa lacuuosa & T. nucula.) U. L. Radnorshire ; Shropshire. 3. R. (Terebrat ) PENTAGONA, Sow. U. L., Delbmy, Shropshire. 4. R. BOREALIS, Schloth. (Terebrat. lacunosa.) W. L., Wenlock Edge. 5. var. DIODONTA (Ter. bidentata.) W. L., Dudley. 6. R. (Ter.) CRISPATA, Sow. Woolhope hmestone, Nash Scar. 7. R. (Ter.) CREBRIC03TA, Sow. W. S., Tynewjdd, Llandovery. 8. ATRYPA (Ter.) CUNEATA, Dalm. W. L., Dudley. 9. RHYNCHONELLA (Ter.) SPHCERICA, Sow. W. S., Wallsall. 10. R. DEFLEXA, Sow. (Terebr. de^exa, & T. mterphcata). W. L., Wenlock Edge ; W. S., Wallsall. 11. R. (Ter.) STRICKLANDI, Sow. W. L., Longhope. W. S., Usk. 12. R. (Ter.) NAVICULA, Sow. A. L., Ludlow ; Usk. W. S.,Builth. 13. R. (Ter.) WILSONI, Sow. A. L., Aymestry. 14. TEREBRATULAI L^VIUSCULA, Sow. W. S., Tynewydd, Llan- dovery. 15. RHYNCHONELLA DIDYMA, Sow. (Ter. didyma & T. canalis)' U. L., A. L., Usk, Abberley. 16. R. (Atrypa) OBOVATA, Sow. L. L., Malverns. 17. R. (Atrypa) DEPRESSA, Sow. W. S., Stumps Wood, Malverns. 18. R. (Atrypa) ROTUNDA, Sow. W. L., Wenlock Edge. 19. ATRYPA (Ter.) MARGINALIS, Dalm. (mcluding T. imbricata, W. L.). Wenlock, &c. 120. ATHYRIS TUMIDA, Dahn. (ten\nstriata\ W. L., Malverns. 21. PENTAMERUS (Atrypa) LINGUIFER, Soav.' W. Sh.. Stumps Wood, Malverns ; WaUsall, &c. 22. RHYNCHONELLA' (Atrypa) COMPRESSA, Sow. Woolhope Lime- stone, Woodside & Nash, Prestiegn. I V 'I^l^^M-R ]L U M If A iAMEia^IBKANCHIATA. PLATE XXIII. UPPER SILURIAN LAMELLIBRANCHIATA . 1. MODIOLOPSIS (Pullastra) COMPLANATA, Sow. U. L., Nca.- Bridgnorth. 2. GONIOPHORA (Cypricardia) CYMB^EFORMIS, Sow. U. L., Ludlow. 3. ORTHONOTA (Cypricardia) IMPRESSA, Sow. U. L., Dcibury. 4. O. (Cypric.) UNDATA, Sow. U. L., near Aymestry. 5. O. (Mya) ROTUND ATA, Sow. A. L., Caynliam Camp, Ludlow. 6. (Two figures,) O. (Cypricardia) AMYGDALINA, Sow. U. L., Ludlow, &c. 7. Variety of Ditto, (Cypricardia retusa. Sow.) U. L., Delbury. 8. O. (Psammobia) RIGIDA, Sow. L. L., Garden House, Aj-mestry. 9. O. (Cypricardia?) SOLENOIDES, Sow. L. L., near Ludlow. 10. NUCULA ANGLICA (ovalis;, D'Orb. U. L., Trewerne Hills, Radnorshire. 11. CARDIOLA FIBROSA, Sow. L. L., Mary Knoll Dingle, Ludlow. 12. 0. INTERRUPTA, Broderip. L. L., Aymestry ; Radnorshu-e, &c. 13. C. (Cardium) STRIATA, Sow. A. L., Aymestry. 14. MODIOLA ANTIQUA, Sow. W. Sh.. Glass House Hill, E. of May Hill, Gloucestershire. 15. PTERINEA SOWERBYI, McCoy. (Avicula reticulata), A. L., Croft, Aymestry. 16. P. LINEATULA, D'Orb. (Avic. Imeata), U. L., Ludlow. 17. P. (Avic.) RETROPLEXA. Wahl. U. L., Malverns PLATE XXIV. UPPER SILURIAN GASTEROPODA. Fig. 1. TURBO CORALLII, Sow. U. L., Radnorshire. 2. MURCHISONIA (Pleurotoma) ARTICULATA, Sow. U. L., Ludlow. 3. LOXONEMA SINUOSA, Sow. L. L., Ayraestry. 4. TURBO OCTAVIUS (carinatus), D'Orb. U. L., Trewerne Hills, Radnorshire. 5. MURCHISONIA (Plenrotomariaj LLOYDII, Sow. L. L., Shelder- ton ; Aymestry. 6. PLEUROTOMARIA UNDATA, Sow. L. L., near Ludlow. 7. MURCHISONIA (Pleurotoma) CORALLII, Sow. U. L., Bradnor Hill, Kington. S. ACROCULIA PROTOTYPA, PhiU. (Nerita spn-ata). Woolhope Limestone, Presteign. 9. ACROC. (Nerita) HALIOTIS, Sow. W. L., Ledbury 10. TURBO CIRRHOSUS, Sow. W. S., Wenlock. 11. EUOMPHALUS CARINATUS, Sow. A. L., Aymestry. Yl. E. DISCORS, Sow. W. L., Wenlock Edge. 13. E. RUGOSUS, Sow, Same locahty. i PLATE XXV. . UPPER SILURIAN GASTEROPODA, PTEROPODA, AND HETEROPODA. 1. NATICA PARVA, Sow. U. L., Fownhope, Herefordshire. 2. EUOMPHALUS SCULPTUS, Sow. W. L., Ledbury. 3. E. FUNATUS, Sow. W. L., Wenlock Edge. 4. E. ALATUS, Sow. W. S. 5, 6. BELLEROPHON DILATATUS, Sow. W. L., Burrington, Ludlow. 7. B. WENLOCKENSIS, Sow. W. L., Croft, Malvern. 8. B. EXPANSUS, Sow. U. L., Ludlow. 9. CYRTOLITES ? (Cyrtoceras) L^VIS. L. L., Abberley. 10. CONULARIA SOWERBYI (quadrisulcata), Sow. The figure (10) 13 placed too near fig. 6. W. L., Wenlock Edge. C • PLATE XXVI. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. 1. ORTIiOCERAS ANNULATUM, Sow. W. L., Hay Head, Wallsall. 2. var. FIMBRIATUM. (O. fimbriatum, Sow.) W.S. Aston, May Hill ; Malvcriis, &c. 3. 0. ATTENUATUM, Sow, W. S., Onny River, Shropshii^e. 4. O. DISTANS, Sow. L. L., near Aj-mestry. 5. O. NUMMULARIUS, Sow. W. L.. Whitfield Quarry, Tortworih. J.D. O.SoM erh^ Sa d- t> IVut JrMif ktA PLATE XXVIl. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. Fig. 1. ORTHOCERAS FILOSUM, Sow. L. L., Lcmtwardane. 2. O. GEEGARIUM, Sow. L. L., near Ludlow. 3. 4. O. EXCENTRICUM, Sow. Woolhope Limest., Old Radnorshire. 5. ORMOCERAS (Orthoceras) BRIGHTII, Sow. - broken open. W. L., Malvcms. The Siphuncle, shghtly ma^milc.]. PLATE XXVIII. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. Fig. 1, 2. ORTHOCERAS LUDENSB, Sow. L. L., Ludlow. 3. O. CANALICULATUM, Sow. W. S., Ledbury. 4. O. ANGULATUM (virgatum), Hismger. L. L., Mocktree Forest. 5. O. DIMIDIATUM, Sow. L. L., Water-break-its-neck, Radno Forest. lUFFJg IE SIJLnmJiAW. CJ- P H .A T.OPOl) A. PL 28. f PLATE XXIX. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. Fig. 1. ORTHOCERAS BULLATUM (or stnatiim), Sow. U. L., Ludlow. 2. O. MOCKTREENSE, Sow. A. L., Mocktree Hays, Shropshire. 3, 4. O. IBEX, Sow. (Including O. articulatum.) Near Ludlow- 5, 6. O. PERELEGANS, Salter. (Lituites Ibex, and L. articulatus.; L. L., Elton, fig. 5 ; Shelderton, fig. '/. 7. O. IMBRICATUM, Wahl. L. L., near Ludlow. PLATE XXX. UPPER SILURIAN CEP?IALOPODA. 1, 3. PHRAGMOCERAS mhoceras or Gon^ptoceras, PYEIFORME, Sow. L. L., Lemtwardine. 4. P. INTERMEDIUM (arcuatum/S), McCoy. L. L., Shelderton. CEPHA J OI'OT>A ?130 I, } 1 lUFFEM g HILUIFil AH, C£ PHA I. OPODA. PI . 31. PLATE XXXI. ' UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. I^ig.l.a. PHRAGMOCERAS NAUTILEUM, Sow. W. S., Myddelton Caermartlien. 3. P. ARCUATUM, Sow. L. L., near Ledbury. 4. P. C0MPRE3SUM, Sow. L. L.. near Aymestry. 5. LITUITES BIDDULPHII, Sow. W. L., Ledbury. 5. L. IBEX, Sow. L. L., near Ludlow. PLATE XXXII. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. PHRAGMOCERAS VENTRICOSUM, Steininger. L. L., war dine. I PI. 33 C£PHALOPOI)A. PLATE XXXIII. UPPER SILURIAN CEPHALOPODA. Figs. 1, 2, 3. LITUITES GIGANTEUS, Sow. L. L., Mocktree Hays. 4. LITUITES ? TORTUOSUS, Sow. L. L. ? Between Welshpool and Berriew, Montgomeryshire. d PLATE XXXIV. UPPER LUDLOW ROCK (TILESTONE). g. 1. ONCHUS MURCHISONI, Agassiz. A true fish defence. Tm Mill, Downton. 2. LINGULA CORNEA, Sow. Same locality. ^ 3. CUCULLELLA CAWDORI, Sow. m Upper? Ludlow Rock, Fresh- water East, Pembrokeshire. 4. PTERINEA (Avicula) RECTANGULARIS, Sow. Horeb Chapel, Llandovery. 5. ORTHOCERAS SEMIPARTITUM, Sow. (perhaps a Diploceras). Same locahty. - 6. O. TRACHEALE, Sow. Same locahty. 7. MODIOLOPSIS (Pullastra) LtEVIS, Sow. Horeb Chapel. S. BELLEROPHON CARINATUS, Sow. do. . 9. B. TRILOBATUS, Sow. Felmdre, 10 m. W. of Kmghton. 10. HOLOPELLA (TiirriteUa) CONICA, Sow. Horeb Chapel. 10a. H. (Turritella) GREGARIA, Sow. Horeb Chapel. 11. H. (Turritella) OBSOLETA, Sow. Horeb Chapel ; Felindre. 12,13. TROCHUS? HELICITES, Sow. do. 14. TURBO WILLI AMSII, Sow. do. 15. GONIOPHORA (Cypncardia) CYMB^FORMIS, Sow. Fehndre. 16. CUCULLELLA (Cucullaea) ANTIQUA, Sow. Horeb Chapel. 17. C. (Cucullaea).OVATA, Sow. do. 18. CHONETES (Leptaena) LATA, Von Buch. do. 19. BELLEROPHON MURCHISONI, D'Orbigny? (B. stnatus). do. 20. B. EXPANSUS, Sow. Yoimg. (B. globatus). Felmdre. 21. BEYRICHIA (Agnostus) TUBERCULATA, Kloden. Lodge Banl-;, Downton. I PLATE XXXV. FOSSILS, CHIEFLY FISHES, OF THE UPPER LUDLOW BONE BED. Pig. 1. Skm of SriiAGODUS, Agass.— la, and 2, magnified portions. 3— S. PLECTRODUS MIRABILIS, Agass. Jaws and teeth, natural size and magnified. 9-12. P. (SCLERODUS) PU5TULIFERUS, Ag. 13. 14. ONCHUS MURCHISONI, Ag. 15—17. O. TENUISTRIATUS, Ag. 13. Shagreen scales, probably of Onchus tenuistriatus, (Thclodus parvidens, Ag.) The stratum is chiefly made up of these. 19, 20. Indeterminable fragments, of bony texture. 23—28. Coprohtes (probabl3* of Plectrodus), and containmg—Orthocci as semipartitum, fig. 22 ; Encrmitc stems, fig. 23, 24 ; Lingula cornea, fig. 25 ; Holopella conica, fig. 26; Orbicula ruguta, fig. 27 ; Bcllerophon expansup, fig 28.— all shells of the Upper Ludlow Rock. 29. ORTHTS IJJNATA, Sow. Frequent m this bed. 30. Seeds or spores of oomc Cryptogamic land-plant, (Pr. HuoI.cj ;. All the above are from the Bone bed at Ludford, Ludlow. (I 2 PLATE XXXVL FISHES OF THE OLD RED SANDSTONE. Fig. 1, 2. ASTEROLEPIS. Interior arid exterior view of a bony plate from the head. Elgin. 3. Bony armo-ar of the head of ASTEROLEPIS, from the same locahty. Eig. 3* (wrongly numbered 2*), a portion magnified. 4, 5. ONCHUS SEMISTRIATUS, Agass. Tenbury. 6. CTENACANTHUS ORNATUS, Ag, The imddle portion of a dorsal spine. Sapey, west of Worcester. 7, 8. ONCHUS ARCUATUS, Ag. Bromyard. 9. HOLOPTYCHIUS NOBILISSIMUS, Ag. One-third the natural length. Clashbinnie, Perthshire. 10. Ventral scales, natural size. 11. HOLOPTYCHIUS GIGANTEUS, Ag. Same locality. 12. Under side of the scales. 13. Tooth of HOLOPTYCITIUS, Elgin. 14. Dorsal plate of COCCOSTEUS (called Cephalaspis in the ' Sil. Syst.'), Herefordshire. 15, 15.* Serrated fish defence? PTYCHACANTHUS ? DUBIUS, Ag. nat. size, and magnified. Herefordshire. PLATE XXXVII. FISHES OF THE OLD RED SANDSTONE. Figs. 1 to 3. CEPHAIASPIS LYELLII, Ag. Forfarshire. 4. Side view of the head. 5. Exterior plates or scales of the head, highly magmtied. 6. Scales from the sides of the body, magnified. 7. Scales from the flank. 8. Scales from the sides of the tail. _ 9. CEPII. LEWISII, Agass. Whitbatch, Shropshire. • 10. CEPH. LLOYDII, Agass. Herefordshire. 10*. A portion of the surface, and the texture of the under layer, magnified. 11. CEPH. ROSTRATUS, Ag. Head with the outer surface removed. Whitbatch, Shr'opshire. ;3 Date Due ■ 8 1995 ■ Library Bureau Cat. no. 1137 0E661.M95 S cm 3 5002 00232 4841 Murchison, Roderick Impey Siluria. The history of the oldest known GEOLOGY USRARX 19290