Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement; Prohibition on Interrogation of Detainees by Contractor Personnel (DFARS Case 2010-D027)

Defense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System · 2011

Read Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement; Prohibition on Interrogation of Detainees by Contractor Personnel (DFARS Case 2010-D027) by Defense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System (2011) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/uslaw-fr-2011-18381.txt.

Description

Rule published in the Federal Register on 2011-07-25 by Defense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System. Text from federalregister.gov (official edition: govinfo). [Pages 44282-44283] From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov] [FR Doc No: 2011-18381] [[Page 44282]] ----------------------------------------------------------------------- DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE Defense Acquisition Regulations System 48 CFR Parts 237 and 252 RIN 0750-AG88 Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement; Prohibition on Interrogation of Detainees by Contractor Personnel (DFARS Case 2010-.

Catalog record

CREATORDefense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System
YEAR2011
COLLECTIONLAW
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE14 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEFederal Register

Source: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/07/25/2011-18381/defense-federal-acquisition-regulation-supplement-prohibition-on-interrogation-of-detainees-by

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement; Prohibition on Interrogation of Detainees by Contractor Personnel (DFARS Case 2010-D027) Citation: us:fr:2011-18381 Creator: Defense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System Year: 2011 Source-URL: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/07/25/2011-18381/defense-federal-acquisition-regulation-supplement-prohibition-on-interrogation-of-detainees-by Context: Rule published in the Federal Register on 2011-07-25 by Defense Department; Defense Acquisition Regulations System. Text from federalregister.gov (official edition: govinfo). [Pages 44282-44283] From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov] [FR Doc No: 2011-18381] [[Page 44282]] ----------------------------------------------------------------------- DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE Defense Acquisition Regulations System 48 CFR Parts 237 and 252 RIN 0750-AG88 Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement; Prohibition on Interrogation of Detainees by Contractor Personnel (DFARS Case 2010- D027) AGENCY: Defense Acquisition Regulations System, Department of Defense (DoD). ACTION: Final rule. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SUMMARY: The Department of Defense (DoD) is adopting as final, without change, an interim rule amending the Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (DFARS) to implement section 1038 of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year 2010. Section 1038 prohibits contractor personnel from interrogating detainees under the control of DoD. DATES: Effective Date: July 25, 2011. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ms. Meredith Murphy, 703-602-1302. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: I. Background DoD published an interim rule at 75 FR 67632 on November 3, 2010, to implement section 1038 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2010 (Pub. L. 111-84). Section 1038 prohibits contractor personnel from interrogating detainees under the control of the Department of Defense. It also allows the Secretary of Defense to waive the prohibition for a limited period of time, with limited redelegation authority, if determined necessary to the national security interests of the United States. The interim rule added coverage at DFARS 237.173 and a new clause at DFARS 252.237-7010 that prescribes policies prohibiting interrogation of detainees by contractor personnel, as required by section 1038 of the NDAA for Fiscal Year 2010. The DFARS also covers permissible support roles for contractors by providing that contractor personnel with proper training and security clearances may be used as linguists, interpreters, report writers, information technology technicians, and other employees filling ancillary positions, including as trainers of, and advisors to, interrogations, if the contractor personnel meet the criteria provided by DoD Instruction 1100.22, Policy and Procedures for Determining Workforce Mix (http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/110022p.pdf); DoD Directive 2310.01E, The Department of Defense Detainee Program (http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/231001p.pdf); and DoD Directive 3115.09, DoD Intelligence Interrogations, Detainee Debriefings, and Tactical Questioning http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/311509p.pdf. The public comment period closed on January 3, 2011. Three respondents provided comments on the interim rule. II. Discussion and Analysis A summary of the comments received and their analysis grouped by category follows. A. Eliminate Waiver Authority Comment: Three respondents provided comments supporting the idea that establishing an effective system of managing and overseeing contractors supporting interrogations must be accorded the highest priority. However, the respondents did not support the provision at DFARS 237.173-4 that allows the Secretary of Defense to waive the prohibition on contractor interrogations for up to 60 days on the grounds of national security interests. The respondents considered the function to be inherently governmental, and one that should never be performed by contractor personnel. Response: Section 1038 of the statute specifically provides the Secretary of Defense authority to waive, for a limited time, the prohibition on interrogation of detainees by contractor personnel. Contractor personnel with proper training and security clearances may be used as linguists, interpreters, report writers, information technology technicians, and other employees filling ancillary positions, including as trainers of and advisors to interrogators, in interrogations of detainees, provided that appropriately qualified and trained DoD personnel (military or civilian) are available to oversee the contractor's performance and to ensure that contractor personnel do not perform activities that are prohibited under DoD policy. Such personnel are subject to the same laws, rules, procedures, and policies pertaining to detainee operations and interrogations as those that apply to Government personnel in such positions in such interrogations (DFARS 237.173-3). Accordingly, no change has been made to the DFARS in response to these comments. B. Penalties and Compliance Comment: One respondent stated that DoD must prescribe a clear set of penalties for any violation of the new policy and recommended civil and criminal fines, imprisonment, the withholding of contract award fees, contract termination, and/or suspension and debarment. Response: DoD has no authority to write civil or criminal penalties into the DFARS. Contracting officers have considerable discretion to exercise the usual broad range of contractual remedies, e.g., withholding contract award fees, contract termination, or suspension and/or debarment. Accordingly, no change has been made to the DFARS in response to this comment. Comment: One respondent expressed concern that there would be attempts to evade the new policy by transferring detainees to the custody of non-DoD agencies or foreign governments that are not governed by the DFARS limitations. The respondent also suggested that similar coverage at FAR 7.503(c)(8) should be considered. Response: The acquisition regulations are written based on the presumption that Government employees act in good faith and in accordance with acquisition regulations and the law. Further, since the coverage at FAR 7.503(c)(8) lists ``the direction and control of intelligence and counter-intelligence operations'' as an example of an inherently governmental function, there would be no value added by reiterating this language in the DFARS. C. Clarity of Definitions Comment: One respondent recommended clarification of the definition of ``detainee'' in 237.173-2, which the respondent considered to be silent on the matter of whether the term ``hostilities'' (which is included in the definition of ``detainee'') includes situations in which there has not been a formally declared war (e.g., the detainee is classified as an unlawful combatant rather than a prisoner of war). The respondent noted that the definition's qualifier, ``this includes but is not limited to,'' suggests a broad definition for ``hostilities.'' Response: The term ``detainee'' is defined at 237.173-2 as ``any person captured, detained, held, or otherwise under the effective control of DoD personnel (military or civilian) in connection with hostilities. This includes, but is not limited to, enemy prisoners of war, civilian internees, and retained personnel. This does not include DoD personnel or DoD contractor personnel being held for law enforcement purposes.'' This definition was derived from the ``detainee'' definition in the governing directive, [[Page 44283]] DoDI 2310.01E, The Department of Defense Detainee Program, dated September 5, 2006. Paragraph 2.2 of the directive notes ``This Directive applies during all armed conflicts, however such conflicts are characterized, and in all other military operations.'' In addition, paragraph E.2.1. of DoDI 2310.01E notes that the definition of ``detainee'' includes ``unlawful enemy combatants.'' Accordingly, DoD has determined that clarification is not necessary, and no change has been made to the DFARS definition in response to this comment. Comment: One respondent recommended clarifying the definition of ``interrogation of detainees'' in 237.173-2 by adding the same qualifer, i.e., ``this includes, but is not limited to,'' as is found in the definition of ``detainee.'' The respondent stated that a difference between the two definitions could lead to confusion over whether this includes any other sort of non-``systematic,'' ``formal,'' or ``official'' process of ``questioning,'' or questioning not done ``for the purpose of obtaining reliable information to satisfy foreign intelligence collection requirements'' (see 237.173-2). Response: The definition of ``interrogation of detainees'' was derived from the definition for ``intelligence interrogations'' in DoDD

Read the complete text