Regulatory Whack-a-mole: A Rapid Scoping Review of Gambling Marketing Restrictions and their (in)Effectiveness

Jamie Torrance, Jessica Smith, Alex M. T. Russell, Simon Wright, Leon Y. Xiao, Elen Wyn-Davies, Conor Heath, Philip Newall · 2026

Read Regulatory Whack-a-mole: A Rapid Scoping Review of Gambling Marketing Restrictions and their (in)Effectiveness by Jamie Torrance, Jessica Smith, Alex M. T. Russell, Simon Wright, Leon Y. Xiao, Elen Wyn-Davies, Conor Heath, Philip Newall (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-13585857.txt.

Introduction

Jamie Torrance and co-authors reviewed gambling ad rules worldwide in two thousand twenty-six. Gambling marketing lifts play, spending, and harm. Bans and limits are the main public response. Tobacco and alcohol history shows a whack-a-mole pattern. Each new rule triggers fresh industry workarounds. Firms shift channels, use alibi ads, or exploit gaps.

The review covered rules in force from twenty ten onward. Fifty records across thirteen jurisdictions were synthesized. Restrictions fell into six broad categories. Content, timing, and channel limits were judged first. The authors track how operators adapted to each rule type. Few reviews had mapped those adaptations for gambling before. The lessons can help regulators draft harder-to-dodge rules.

Catalog record

CREATORJamie Torrance, Jessica Smith, Alex M. T. Russell, Simon Wright, Leon Y. Xiao, Elen Wyn-Davies, Conor Heath, Philip Newall
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC13585857

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Regulatory Whack-a-mole: A Rapid Scoping Review of Gambling Marketing Restrictions and their (in)Effectiveness Authors: Jamie Torrance, Jessica Smith, Alex M. T. Russell, Simon Wright, Leon Y. Xiao, Elen Wyn-Davies, Conor Heath, Philip Newall Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Purpose of ReviewGambling marketing increases participation, spending, and harm. Marketing restrictions represent the best regulatory response. Decades of tobacco and alcohol marketing regulation demonstrate a recurring pattern in which each restriction triggers industry adaptation through, e.g., channel substitution, alibi marketing, and the exploitation of regulatory gaps. However, no review has systematically assessed gambling operator adaptations to marketing restrictions. This review examines the effectiveness of gambling marketing restrictions implemented globally between 2010 and 2026, in light of these potential adaptations.Recent FindingsFifty records spanning 13 jurisdictions were synthesised across six gambling marketing restriction categories. (1) Content, (2) Timing, and (3) Channel Restrictions were consistently undermined by poor operator compliance, redistribution of advertising to less regulated platforms, and narrow regulatory scopes leaving the majority of marketing exposure unregulated. (4) Inducement Restrictions yielded the strongest behavioural evidence, with sustained reductions in customer acquisition and money gambled, though operators restrategised by redirecting promotional effort towards retaining existing customers. (5) Platform-enforced measures curtailed on-platform content but not external gambling website traffic or underage exposure. (6) Comprehensive Bans were circumvented through alibi marketing, transitional exemptions, and reallocation of spend to unregulated, operator-owned media channels.SummaryRegulatory displacement was evident across all six categories. Operators consistently migrated marketing activity to less regulated channels, formats, and strategies following each restriction, mirroring the established regulatory trajectories of tobacco and alcohol marketing. Effective gambling marketing regulation requires statutory, comprehensive, and future-proof frameworks rather than the voluntary, circumventable, and reactive approaches evaluated in this review.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s40429-026-00793-5. Introduction Exposure to gambling marketing is associated with a range of harms [1, 2]. These include increased gambling participation [3–5], increased spending [6], the placement of riskier or unplanned bets [7], the normalisation of gambling among underage audiences [8, 9], and relapse among individuals attempting to reduce or cease their gambling [10, 11]. The public’s awareness of these potential harms has increased in jurisdictions that are worst affected, such as Australia and the UK [12–14], which has led to voluntary industry-led initiatives such as the imposition of warning labels and marketing restrictions. However, these Industry-led initiatives have proven largely ineffective when tested [15, 16], with for example industry-branded harm prevention adverts actually increasing viewers’ urges to gamble, likely due to their use of operator branding and imagery that is consistent with ordinary gambling adverts [17]. Although emerging independently-designed interventions such as inoculation-based videos [18] and counter-industry messaging [19, 20] appear more promising in testing, these strategies cannot compete with the natural consequences of gambling operators’ immense marketing budgets (e.g., high frequency of advertising or use of celebrity endorsements). Restrictions and regulations therefore represent the most promising defence against gambling marketing harms [21]. However, research in other public health domains shows that regulators are often left playing a game of ‘whack-a-mole’, restricting one practice only for industry to deploy new tactics or to exploit regulatory loopholes. Tobacco marketing regulation followed a decades-long trajectory in which narrow channel-specific restrictions were circumvented through sponsorship, point-of-sale displays, and brand stretching [22–24]. Comprehensive frameworks such as the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control eventually closed the most significant displacement pathways [25, 26]. Alcohol marketing has followed a comparable arc, with voluntary codes consistently producing poor compliance and industry-led ‘alibi marketing’ strategies enabling operators to maintain brand visibility through nominally non-promotional channels [27, 28]. In both cases, meaningful reductions in exposure were only achieved when regulation shifted from partial, voluntary, and reactive approaches to comprehensive, statutory, and future-proof ones. A parallel pattern can already be observed in online gambling product design, where regulations targeting specific structural characteristics, such as celebratory sound effects on losses-disguised-as-wins, have led to sounds which satisfy the letter but not the spirit of new regulations [29], and broader platform design interventions have consistently been outpaced by operator adaptation [30, 31]. Despite these precedents, it currently remains unclear whether gambling marketing restrictions are following the same trajectory. Numerous jurisdictions have implemented varied approaches in recent years, though most have focused on advertising, which is only one component of the broader marketing mix that also encompasses product design, pricing, placement, and public relations [32, 33]. Since July 2023, the Netherlands has prohibited untargeted gambling advertising and instead permits targeted online advertising only where operators can demonstrate that at least 95% of the audience reached is aged 24 or over [34]. Conversely, Belgium and Italy have implemented near-total advertising restrictions [35]. Australia has pursued the most varied programme of reform, combining broadcast watershed restrictions, volume caps, inducement bans, blocking of illegal offshore operators, and restrictions on direct marketing to self-excluded consumers through the national BetStop register [36]. From 2027, further measures will require age-verified online advertising and ban stadium and uniform advertising, though exemptions for influencer and podcast content remain [37]. Restriction is also spreading beyond Europe and Australasia. In North America, Ontario’s regulator banned the use of athletes in gambling advertising and restricted celebrities likely to appeal to minors, from February 2024. In Asia, India’s Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act 2025 prohibits any advertisement that directly or indirectly promotes online gambling. In South America, Brazil introduced measures in July 2026 prohibiting urgency cues, portrayals of betting as investment, and commentator recommendations during live sport. Most such measures nonetheless target defined vulnerable groups rather than reducing exposure across the whole population, and because evaluation evidence can only accumulate once restrictions are in force, the geography of the evidence base lags the geography of regulation itself. Limited systematic evaluation of these measures nonetheless leaves policymakers unable to distinguish genuinely effective restrictions from those that merely redirect activity across these channels. This is particularly pressing for jurisdictions such as the UK, where the demonstrated link between marketing and harm [7, 38] has strengthened the case for adopting a public health approach to gambling marketing regulation. Such an approach would prioritise preventing harm at the population level rather than relying on reactive measures targeted at individuals already experiencing gambling-related harm [39]. The gambling marketing restrictions literature spans diverse jurisdictions, regulatory frameworks, methodologies, and outcome measures. This breadth is a potential strength, as converging findings across different regulatory contexts carry more weight than any single jurisdiction’s evidence alone. However, systematic synthesis in this area remains scarce. Previous reviews have compared legislative frameworks across European jurisdictions [40], examined gambling policies’ effects on young people [41], and identified political will rather than evidence as the central catalyst for restriction adoption [42]. Others have drawn attention to a marked asymmetry in the evidentiary standards applied to gambling marketing policy. The liberalisation of gambling marketing remains largely unchallenged, in part because the public are rarely consulted and industry has little incentive to object, while the introduction of restrictions faces demands for robust proof of effectiveness [43]. The UK is a case in point. Despite having the largest evidence base documenting the harms of gambling marketing, it maintains some of the fewest marketing restrictions among comparator countries [42]. Although warranted, these reviews have charted rather than evaluated restrictions, and in some cases have addressed gambling marketing

Read the complete text