Comparing Patient to Provider Perceptions of Birth Trauma: What are We Missing?
Michelle L Miller, Kylie L Willams, Tiffany R Williams, Cara Berg Raunick, Sarah A Greenwell, Maggie Sullivan, Russell J Ledet, Camila Arnaudo, Kundai Crites, Julian J Spangler, Alissa Conklin · 2026
Read Comparing Patient to Provider Perceptions of Birth Trauma: What are We Missing? by Michelle L Miller, Kylie L Willams, Tiffany R Williams, Cara Berg Raunick, Sarah A Greenwell, Maggie Sullivan, Russell J Ledet, Camila Arnaudo, Kundai Crites, Julian J Spangler, Alissa Conklin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-13585836.txt.
Introduction
Michelle Miller and co-authors set birth tales of new mothers next to the tales of their birth hands, in a study from 2026. Hard births scar health, and talk twixt sick and hands can make or mend the scar. One ward gave polls to past a hundred mothers and near a hundred birth hands.
Two in five mothers called their birth a hard scar by the set marks. Two thirds of those got a talk past birth from their hands, and hands called the birth hard in just two thirds of true cases. Joy in the birth ran far low in the scar group. Most mothers want to be asked. Set ask rounds are the call.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michelle L Miller, Kylie L Willams, Tiffany R Williams, Cara Berg Raunick, Sarah A Greenwell, Maggie Sullivan, Russell J Ledet, Camila Arnaudo, Kundai Crites, Julian J Spangler, Alissa Conklin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparing Patient to Provider Perceptions of Birth Trauma: What are We Missing? Authors: Michelle L Miller, Kylie L Willams, Tiffany R Williams, Cara Berg Raunick, Sarah A Greenwell, Maggie Sullivan, Russell J Ledet, Camila Arnaudo, Kundai Crites, Julian J Spangler, Alissa Conklin Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundTraumatic birth experiences are common and negatively affect the health and wellbeing of the birthing person. Interactions between patients and providers are an important risk factor for experiencing birth as traumatic. The current study investigated both patient and provider perceptions of birth.MethodsParticipants (N = 146) were recruited from a mother-baby postpartum recovery unit and asked about birth satisfaction, if they found their birth traumatic (using DSM-5 Diagnostic Criteria for PTSD), and if their providers debriefed with them post-birth. Providers (N = 95, including obstetricians and midwives) were also asked if the birth was traumatic.ResultsThere were 60 participants (41.1%) that experienced birth trauma, yet only two thirds received a debrief from their providers (n = 40, 66.7%). Only 65.9% of providers accurately endorsed their patient’s birth as traumatic. Participants who endorsed birth trauma reported significantly lower satisfaction with their birth experience than those who did not (mean difference = 2.881, t = 7.217 (144), p<.001, CI [2.092, 3.670]). Most participants endorsed that they wanted to be asked whether their birth experience was traumatic, especially those that had experienced birth trauma (81.8%).ConclusionThere is a mismatch between how patients and providers are viewing the same birth experience. Obstetric providers are working with patients when they may be recovering from a traumatic event, creating an ideal opportunity for trauma-informed care. A universal workflow should include briefly discussing birth experiences, especially if the experience was traumatic, with future research focusing on patient and provider outcomes associated with improved conversations.Keywords: Birth Trauma, Postpartum, Birth Satisfaction, Provider Communication Introduction A traumatic birth experience occurs when childbirth directly causes short and/or long-term distressing reactions that then have negative impacts on the health and wellbeing of the birthing person (Leinweber et al. 2022). Traumatic birth experiences are quite common, as 1 in 3 women (and up to 45%) perceive their birth as traumatic (Ayers et al. 2024; Beck et al. 2018). Adverse experiences associated with birth trauma include strong feelings of failure, self-blame, loss, and anger; increased risk of postpartum depression and suicidality; strained romantic relationships; and not wanting to or being able to have as many children as desired (Ayers et al. 2007; Beck and Watson 2008; Dekel et al. 2019; Di Blasio et al. 2017). Feelings of helplessness and powerlessness during interactions with providers are a powerful predictor of birth trauma as the relationship between obstetric providers and patients is integral to a patient’s well-being pre-, during-, and post-delivery. In a seminal study of over 2000 women who had experienced a traumatic birth, nearly half of participants believed that their trauma could have been reduced or prevented if they had better communication with their provider (Hollander et al., 2017). Further, discrepancy of expectations around birth and lack of involvement in the decision-making process contributed more to the experience of birth trauma than fear for one’s own health or life, indicating a potential intervention target. Importantly, exposure to traumatic childbirth events (e.g., shoulder dystocia, infant death) can also have a significant professional and personal effect on maternity care clinicians (e.g., attending obstetrician physicians, registered nurses; Robinson et al., 2023). In this study, we measured our participants’ and their obstetric providers’ perception of the birth experience immediately post-delivery to better understand (1) how often providers and patients perceived the same experience as traumatic; (2) communication patterns after the experience of birth trauma; and (3) qualitatively examine how participants felt being asked about birth trauma immediately postpartum. Methods Procedures Participants were recruited by research coordinators from the Riley Maternity Tower Postpartum Recovery Unit, a large academic medical center that is also one of only two Level IV hospitals for labor and deliveries in the state. Inclusion criteria: (a) participant was available in the postpartum unit following delivery, (b) at least 18 years old, and (c) spoke and read English. Recruitment occurred from June 2024 to July 2025. Participants were included in the study regardless of birth complications, number of days spent on the mother-baby unit, and method of delivery. There were 230 potential participants that were approached to participate in the study. Of those, 22 (9.5%) declined to participate, 62 potential participants were missed, (e.g., asleep, in the NICU, asked to come back and then discharged before could return), and 146 participants enrolled in the study (see Table 1). To better understand clinic size, in 2024, there were 1,443 deliveries from patients that attended the clinics where recruitment took place. Table 1Missingness on SurveysReason Survey Was Unable to Be ObtainedN (%)Could not locate patient15 (17.9)Patient declined survey22 (26.2)Other47 (56.0)Timing issue (discharged, delivered on weekend, etc.)16 (34.0)Patient in the NICU10 (21.3)Attending to maternal needs (sleeping, showering, etc.)12 (25.5)Attending to newborn needs (breastfeeding, soothing, etc.)3 (6.4)No visitors5 (10.6)Technology issue1 (2.1) Missingness on Surveys Patients who expressed interest in the study were consented in person and then immediately completed an online survey verbally conducted by research coordinators on an iPad with quantitative questions on demographics, birth satisfaction, birth trauma assessment, and qualitative assessments on hospital care. Participants were also offered resources for managing birth trauma, including a self-guided prompt for processing their birth story through writing and information for an outpatient psychotherapy clinic that specialized in treating perinatal mental health. Participants were contacted 4–6 weeks after childbirth to provide feedback on the acceptability of being asked about birth trauma post-delivery. To measure provider perceptions of birth trauma, the obstetrician or midwife who delivered the infant was asked to complete a survey immediately post-delivery on whether they perceived their patient’s birth as traumatic and if they discussed it with the patient. Research coordinators identified the delivering physician or midwife and sent the survey to the appropriate provider. Data was collected through REDCap, a secure, web-based application designed for research provided by the Institute for Clinical and Translational Science (Harris et al. 2009, 2019). Measures Demographics Participants were asked to report on their age, race, ethnicity, gender, and parity. Providers were asked to report their age, gender, occupation type, years of experience, and if they received trauma informed care training. Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised Indicator (BSS-RI) The BSS-RI is a well-validated 6-item measure of birth satisfaction utilizing items from the original Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised (BSS-R; Martin & Martin, 2014; Martin et al. 2017). It is intended to be short, easily administered, and able to evaluate stress as well as perinatal service delivery. The measure is composed of two subscales, stress and emotional response to labor and birth and quality of care. Participants can respond “Agree”, “Somewhat agree”, or “Disagree”. Higher scores represent greater birth satisfaction (item range 0–2). Cronbach’s alpha for this sample was good (α = 0.72). DSM-5 PTSD Criteria We utilized the questions from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5; APA, 2013) to assess if an event can be considered a traumatic event, which is part of the criteria necessary to receive a diagnosis of PTSD. The questions were: (1) Do you think your most recent birth was traumatic?; (2) Did you think that you were