A Pontryagin class obstruction for purely electric and purely magnetic Weyl curvature tensors

Thijs de Kok · 2026

Read A Pontryagin class obstruction for purely electric and purely magnetic Weyl curvature tensors by Thijs de Kok (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-13585834.txt.

Introduction

Thijs de Kok proves, in a 2026 math paper, a barrier to certain kinds of curved spacetime geometry. In relativity, the Weyl tensor captures the part of curvature not fixed by matter at a point. It can split into electric and magnetic parts, by analogy with fields. The question is whether every space that allows a time like metric also allows one whose Weyl part is purely electric, or purely magnetic.

The author shows that for a class of curvature tensors, certain products of Pontryagin forms must vanish. On spaces whose dimension is a multiple of four, that forces matching products of Pontryagin classes to vanish too, when the curvature is purely electric or magnetic. For closed spaces, this gives real barriers to such metrics. The result links to the sorting of exact solutions of Einstein's equations.

Catalog record

CREATORThijs de Kok
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC13585834

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Pontryagin class obstruction for purely electric and purely magnetic Weyl curvature tensors Authors: Thijs de Kok Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractDo all manifolds that admit Lorentzian metrics also admit such metrics that have a purely electric (PE) or purely magnetic (PM) Weyl curvature tensor? To (partially) answer this question, we show that for all algebraic curvature tensors on a 4k-dimensional scalar product space that are even or odd under the action of a orientation-reversing isometry, the products of Pontryagin forms that land in the top-degree exterior power of the dual vector space vanish. We use this to derive the vanishing of all products of Pontryagin classes that land in the top-degree de Rham cohomology of a 4k-dimensional pseudo-Riemannian manifold with a PE or PM Riemann or Weyl curvature tensor. For compact manifolds, this gives nontrivial cohomological obstructions to the existence of such pseudo-Riemannian metrics with globally PE or PM Riemann or Weyl curvature tensors. These obstructions can be linked to the existence of Lorentzian metrics of several Petrov subtypes, which play an important role in classifying exact solutions to the Einstein equations. Moreover, they can be applied to foliations by nondegenerate umbilic hypersurfaces, which may appear as time slices of spacetimes. Keywords: Pontryagin class, Algebraic curvature tensor, Weyl curvature tensor, Purely electric/magnetic, Petrov types, Umbilic hypersurfaces Introduction One of the big efforts in general relativity is finding and classifying exact solutions to the Einstein equations. By now, a vast amount of literature is available on this topic. See, e.g., the book by Stephani et al [49], that gives a survey on all exact solutions known up to 1999. A major tool for classifying exact solutions is by posing conditions on the structure of their curvature tensors. One approach is via the splitting of the Riemann/Weyl curvature tensor of a 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifold satisfying the vacuum Einstein equations into an “electric” and “magnetic” part, based on a fixed timelike unit vector field. This was introduced already in the 1950 s by Matte [37, §4]. The terminology is motivated by the observation that the second Bianchi identity becomes a Maxwell-like equation with source terms [37, §5]. On a 4-dimensional oriented Lorentzian manifold, this splitting is performed [49, Ch. 3.5] by first introducing the complex-valued self-dual Weyl curvature tensor W~ with components where ε is the totally anti-symmetric Levi-Civita symbol satisfying with respect to a local oriented orthonormal basis . Choosing a unit timelike vector field T on M, we can then define the tensor fields E and B as which are the electric and magnetic parts of the Weyl curvature tensor, respectively. The electric part E captures gravitational effects that resemble tidal forces from Newtonian mechanics, whereas the magnetic part B has no Newtonian counterpart [18, p. 607–608]. The Weyl curvature tensor is purely electric (PE) at p∈M if its magnetic part B vanishes and purely magnetic (PM) if its electric part E vanishes. Note that this is a pointwise property. PE spacetimes arise naturally in studying general relativity: All spacetimes with a unit timelike congruence that is shear-free and irrotational have PE Weyl curvature tensors with respect to the congruence [53]. This includes static spacetimes [49, Ch. 6.2], warped products of the form R×fΣ (this follows from a variation of [40, Prop. 42] for the Weyl curvature tensor) and spacetimes with irrotational perfect fluids [4, 5]. On the contrary, some examples of PM spacetimes are known [1, 31, 32] but PM spacetimes are rather elusive in general and do not arise naturally. For example, Van den Bergh [54] showed that there are no PM vacuum solutions to the Einstein equations and Lesame [30] showed that there are no irrotational dust solutions with PM Weyl curvature tensors. More generally, Maartens, Lesame and Ellis [33] showed that metrics with PM Weyl curvature tensors are inconsistent with the Einstein equations in general. A classical result is that a manifold M admits a Lorentz metric if and only if it is either noncompact or is compact and has Euler-characteristic equal to 0. A natural follow-up question to ask is whether a manifold M that admits Lorentzian (or in general pseudo-Riemannian) metrics also admits such metrics with PE or PM Weyl curvature tensors. For 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifolds, the property of having a PE or PM Weyl curvature tensor was found to be closely related to the Petrov type of the Weyl curvature tensor. In particular, the Weyl curvature tensor W of a 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifold M is PE/PM at p∈M if it has Petrov type O, I or D with real/imaginary eigenvalues [25, Rem. 3.8] [38, p. 1556] [53, 55]. Furthermore, Avez [3] showed in the 1970 s that geometric properties of the Weyl curvature tensor can be related to the smooth and topological structure of the manifold via the Pontryagin forms and classes. The Pontryagin forms of a pseudo-Riemannian manifold (M, g) are differential forms which are constructed from the Riemann curvature tensor of the Levi-Civita connection of (M, g). The Pontryagin forms are closed differential forms and therefore define classes in the de Rham cohomology of the manifold M [39, p. 296]. The resulting Pontryagin classes do not depend on the chosen metric g and are proper invariants of M [39, p. 298]. We refer to Sect. 2.3 for a precise introduction of the Pontryagin forms and classes. Clearly, the Pontryagin form ϖk(M) and hence the Pontryagin class pk(M) vanish if 4k is greater than the dimension of M. In particular, for 4-dimensional manifolds M, only the first Pontryagin form and class may be nontrivial. Avez showed that if M admits a locally conformally flat metric—that is, with vanishing Weyl curvature tensor W, which is by definition of Petrov type O—then the first Pontryagin form ϖ1(M) (and therefore also p1(M)) vanishes. Later, Zund [58] and Porter and Thompson [45] extended the result by Avez to other Petrov types, including type D with real or imaginary eigenvalues, which are PE or PM. This shows that on 4-dimensional Lorentzian manifolds, the Pontryagin class p1(M) may function as an obstruction to the existence of Lorentzian metrics with PE or PM type D Weyl curvature tensors. Recently, Hervik, Ortaggio and Wylleman [25] observed that for the Weyl curvature tensor, being PE or PM with respect to a timelike unit vector T is equivalent to being even or odd under the action of the orthogonal reflection along the hyperplane T⊥. Using their characterization, the electric–magnetic splitting naturally extends to algebraic curvature tensors on vector spaces of arbitrary signature and dimension and can be performed for all vectors T that are not null. In this paper, we discuss in what way the Pontryagin classes of a manifold M give an obstruction to the existence of PE or PM Weyl curvature tensors in the sense of Hervik et al. In Sect. 3.2, we will obtain the following precise restrictions on the Pontryagin forms and classes of a manifold admitting pseudo-Riemannian metrics with PE or PM Weyl curvature tensors. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first result relating the property of being PE or PM to the Pontryagin classes of the manifold directly. For the precise statement of the presented results, we refer to the corresponding results in the

Read the complete text