Comparison of European regionwide and Japanese nationwide surveys on gynecologic robotic surgery

Takashi Takeda, Sergi Fernandez-Gonzalez, Misa Hayasaka, Mihoko Dofutsu, Takuma Yoshimura, Ayako Taima, Hiroaki Komatsu, Christina Uwins, Charlotte Chollet, Dina El-Hamamsy, Daniel Galvin, Manou Manpreet Kaur, Eleni Karatrasoglou, Alberto Munoz Solano, Anumithra Amirthanayagam, Hiroaki Kobayashi · 2026

Read Comparison of European regionwide and Japanese nationwide surveys on gynecologic robotic surgery by Takashi Takeda, Sergi Fernandez-Gonzalez, Misa Hayasaka, Mihoko Dofutsu, Takuma Yoshimura, Ayako Taima, Hiroaki Komatsu, Christina Uwins, Charlotte Chollet, Dina El-Hamamsy, Daniel Galvin, Manou Manpreet Kaur, Eleni Karatrasoglou, Alberto Munoz Solano, Anumithra Amirthanayagam, Hiroaki Kobayashi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-13585811.txt.

Introduction

Takashi Takeda and co-authors compare two big surveys of robot-assisted gynecologic surgery, one from Europe and one from Japan, to find scope for shared training. Robot surgery is spreading, and young surgeons need good training routes. The European survey covered early-career gynecologists across 21 countries. The Japanese survey covered obstetricians and gynecologists nationwide; those within 12 years of graduation were picked to match.

293 replies were studied: 81 European and 212 Japanese. Access to robot systems was much the same, about three quarters in each group. Interest in robot surgery was high in both, a bit higher in Europe. But the Europeans reported far more hands-on work at the console. Equal drive and equal kit, but unequal practice, is just the gap that exchange schemes and shared courses exist to close. The comparison gives surgical societies hard facts for joint training plans.

Catalog record

CREATORTakashi Takeda, Sergi Fernandez-Gonzalez, Misa Hayasaka, Mihoko Dofutsu, Takuma Yoshimura, Ayako Taima, Hiroaki Komatsu, Christina Uwins, Charlotte Chollet, Dina El-Hamamsy, Daniel Galvin, Manou Manpreet Kaur, Eleni Karatrasoglou, Alberto Munoz Solano, Anumithra Amirthanayagam, Hiroaki Kobayashi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC13585811

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparison of European regionwide and Japanese nationwide surveys on gynecologic robotic surgery Authors: Takashi Takeda, Sergi Fernandez-Gonzalez, Misa Hayasaka, Mihoko Dofutsu, Takuma Yoshimura, Ayako Taima, Hiroaki Komatsu, Christina Uwins, Charlotte Chollet, Dina El-Hamamsy, Daniel Galvin, Manou Manpreet Kaur, Eleni Karatrasoglou, Alberto Munoz Solano, Anumithra Amirthanayagam, Hiroaki Kobayashi Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractGynecologic robotic surgery is increasingly adopted worldwide, and effective surgical education is essential for expanding training opportunities among early-career surgeons. Previously published surveys conducted by the Young European Advocates of Robotic Surgery (YEARS) and the Japan Society of Gynecologic Robotic Surgery (JSGRS) evaluated robotic surgery in Europe and Japan. This comparative analysis explored opportunities for international educational collaboration. This study was a secondary comparative analysis using two previously published survey datasets. The YEARS survey targeted early-career European gynecologists (< 4 years post-fellowship), whereas the JSGRS survey included Japanese obstetricians and gynecologists. Respondents within 12 years after graduation were selected from the JSGRS cohort. A total of 293 respondents were analyzed, including 81 respondents from 21 countries in the YEARS and 212 respondents from the JSGRS survey. The availability of robotic systems was comparable (77.8%vs 74.1% for YEARS and JSGRS, respectively), and interest in robotic surgery was also high in both groups (81.0% vs. 70.3%). Respondents in the YEARS survey reported substantially greater hands-on experience. While 66.7% performed robotic surgery weekly in the YEARS survey, only 3.8% of JSGRS respondents had experience with more than 51 robotic procedures annually. This difference was particularly evident among residents (26.7% vs. 0%). This exploratory comparative analysis suggests that Japanese respondents showed similar interest in robotic surgery to the YEARS cohort but had fewer opportunities for surgical experience. Future studies using standardized multinational surveys are warranted to better characterize regional differences and support the development of robotic surgery education.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s11701-026-03825-4.Keywords: Robotic surgical procedures, Education, Gynecology, Surveys and questionnaires, Internship and residency Introduction Robotic surgery has become increasingly widespread in gynecology over the past two decades, driven by technological advancements and expanding clinical applications. Compared with conventional laparoscopy, robotic surgery offers several advantages, including improved ergonomics, enhanced visualization, and a potentially shorter learning curve. The global number of robotic surgical systems has rapidly increased, particularly in North America, Europe, and Asia, reflecting growing adoption of robotic surgery in gynecologic practice. In Japan, the first robotic hysterectomy was performed in 2009. Although national insurance coverage for robotic hysterectomy in benign disease and endometrial cancer was introduced in 2018, the indications remain limited compared with those in many other countries. Consequently, opportunities for robotic surgical training, particularly among early-career gynecologists, have developed differently from those in Europe [1]. Historically, Europe, especially France, was famous for performing hysterectomy by vaginal and laparoscopic routes as a minimally invasive surgery, which was mainly laparotomy in the US previously. This trend drastically changed to a minimal invasive route after the appearance of the Da Vinci system in the US [2]. The US is the leading country for robotic surgery, although Europe is the second-largest area where robotic surgery is performed. This is also supported by the analysis of the number of academic manuscripts in the gynecologic robotic field [3, 4]. Even though the healthcare system differs in each European country, they attempted to gather evidence of robotic surgery from their countries’ data [5–7]. Previous studies have demonstrated that robotic surgery offers favorable perioperative outcomes [6–9], and a shorter learning curve than conventional laparoscopy [10–13]. Even though there is an advantage to robotic surgery, there is an obstacle for the younger generation to learn and start their robotic surgery in Japan. This is because the delayed insurance coverage has limited the robotic procedure to only experienced, consultant-level gynecologists. To facilitate the widespread of robotic surgery in gynecology, education system in robotic surgical field plays an important role. The Japan Society of Gynecologic Robotic Surgery (JSGRS), which is established in 2018, promotes the safe expansion of robotic surgery through a proctoring system in which certified proctors by the society provide surgical guidance during the introduction of robotic systems at institutions nationwide. And also, the Japan Society of Gynecologic and Obstetric Endoscopy and Minimally Invasive Therapy (JSGOE) established the certification system for gynecological robotic surgical [14]. Meanwhile, the Society of European Robotic Gynaecological Surgery (SERGS), which is established in 2009 has managed European multicentric collaborative tasks to strengthen the scientific weight of their publications in benign and oncological procedures. SERGS put emphasis on education with the policy that the scientific society has to provide a standardized robotic training with the era of increasing robotic platform. They outlined a Pilot Curriculum for standardized education of robotic use in gynecological surgery in 2015 and now they have well-organized education and fellowship programs with lots of webinars and video portals [15]. Young European Advocates of Robotic Surgery (YEARS), young members of SERGS, played an important role in the curriculum, for mentoring and support. The YEARS group and the young members of the JSGRS independently conducted surveys to assess attitudes toward gynecologic robotic surgery during a similar time period. As a collaborative initiative between these two groups, we performed a secondary comparative analysis of the two previously published surveys to explore similarities and differences in robotic surgical training and education and to identify opportunities for future international collaboration. Methods Survey datasets The YEARS group developed a 28-item questionnaire mainly regarding gynecologic surgical training and the surgical activity of both the respondent’s department and the individual surgeon [16]. The survey targeted early-career gynecologic surgeons, including trainee/resident enrolled in a national obstetrics and gynecology training program, gynecology clinical fellow, and recent consultant (within the past 3 years) of a fellowship or subspecialty training program. The survey was hosted on SurveyMonkey and distributed through the social media accounts of YEARS and SERGS from December 2022 to September 2023. In parallel, young members of JSGRS developed the 26-question survey asking about demographic information, current state of robotic surgery implementation, barriers to adoption and skill acquisition, and education in robotic surgery [17]. The survey was distributed to all members of the Japan Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology (JSOG) and collected through Google Forms from September to November 2023. The original questionnaires can be found in Supplement Table 1 (Table.S1). Table 1Similar questionnaires between the YEARS and JSGRS surveys [16, 17]TopicYEARSJSGRSGenderWhat is your gender?What is your gender?Area of Interest / SubspecialtyWhat is your Gynecological subspecialty or area of interest?What is your subspecialty?FacilityWhere do you work?Which type of facility do you work?Level of experienceWhat is your level of experience within your current role?How many years after graduated?Availability of Robotic DevicesIs there a surgical robotic device at your workplace?Installation status of robotic surgical systems at the facilityDepartmental Robotic Surgery ActivityHow often does your department perform robotic surgery?Annual number of robotic surgeries at the facilityExperience as a Robotic SurgeonDo you operate as a main surgeon by robotic approach?Robotic experience as a primary surgeonWillingness to Perform Robotic SurgeryWould you like to operate more often by a robotic approach?Do you personally want to be involved in gynecologic robotic surgery?Learning OpportunitiesWhat learning tools do you access most frequently about robotics (more than one allowed)?Do you think online education is effective for acquiring robotic surgery skills? Similar questionnaires between the YEARS and JSGRS surveys

Read the complete text