A semi-randomised control trial assessing psychophysiological effects of breathwork and cold immersion

Nadia Fox, Hannah Biddell, Jemma King · 2025

Read A semi-randomised control trial assessing psychophysiological effects of breathwork and cold immersion by Nadia Fox, Hannah Biddell, Jemma King (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-12708851.txt.

Introduction

Deliberate short stress from breathwork and cold water is tested against meditation by Nadia Fox, Hannah Biddell, and Jemma King in a 2025 trial. Four hundred four healthy adults spent twenty-nine days in one of three arms: in-person breathwork and cold practice, the same practice done remotely, or mindfulness meditation as an active control.

Daily practice in the breathwork arms lifted momentary energy, mental clarity, and felt coping more than meditation did. Sleep sensors, thinking tests, and mood surveys tracked wider effects across the month. Early drops in self-reported stress were smaller in the breathwork arms, a nuance the authors report plainly. The trial weighs a popular method with care rather than hype.

Catalog record

CREATORNadia Fox, Hannah Biddell, Jemma King
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC12708851

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A semi-randomised control trial assessing psychophysiological effects of breathwork and cold immersion Authors: Nadia Fox, Hannah Biddell, Jemma King Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractThe paradoxical nature of stress lies in its ability to both enhance and hinder psychological, physiological, and cognitive functioning. While chronic stress impairs functioning, acute stress can enhance resilience, cognition, and performance. We examined whether intentional short-term stress induced by cyclic hyperventilation and cold exposure (the Wim Hof Method (WHM)) improves psychophysiological and cognitive outcomes compared to an active control (mindfulness meditation). In this semi-randomised controlled trial, healthy adults (N = 404; 226 females, 177 males, 1 other; mean age = 37) completed one of three 29-day interventions: WHM in-person, WHM-remote, or meditation. Measures included physiological and sleep biometrics, executive function tests, and psychometric event sampling surveys (state and trait change). WHM conditions showed greater momentary improvements in self-reported energy, mental clarity, and ability to handle stress following daily protocol compared with meditation. Although WHM protocols initially resulted in smaller reductions in self-reported state stress, their impact increased across days on protocol, while the impact of meditation decreased. A similar time-condition interaction was also observed for energy, mental clarity, and ability to handle stress, suggesting cumulative, dose-dependent benefits. While minimal significant between-condition trait changes emerged over 29-days, state interaction patterns suggest potential for longer-term state–trait shifts. Executive function, physiological, and sleep results showed nuanced between-condition differences.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41598-025-29187-9.Keywords: Wim Hof Method, Cold exposure, Cyclic breathing, Hormesis, Allostatic load, Stress, Executive function, PhysiologySubject terms: Physiology, Psychology Introduction While acute, controlled exposure to moderate stressors can enhance resilience, vitality, and performance, high or chronic doses can be detrimental1–4. Chronic stress has been shown to not only degrade psychological and physiological functioning but also increase health risks such as burnout5,6. Given this duality of stress, along with the rising prevalence and cost of burnout and other stress-related illnesses7, current approaches to stress management, which typically focus on stress avoidance, reduction8, or changing one’s mindset or appraisals of stress9,10, may be missing a crucial aspect. Specifically, the strategic utilisation of acute stress to optimise psychological, physiological and cognitive functioning. The Wim Hof Method® (WHM) has gained significant attention in recent years as a potential approach to enhancing well-being in a number of domains. The method consists of three pillars: (1) short, controlled bouts of cyclic hyperventilation, (2) brief, controlled cold exposure, and (3) maintaining a “commitment mindset” (i.e., patience and dedication to explore and master the techniques11). Together, these practices increase autonomic nervous system activation (e.g., acute stress response), with emerging evidence supporting a range of physiological and psychological benefits, such as improvements in immune function12–14, and reductions in symptoms of depression15, and perceived stress16. In addition to a vast literature supporting the benefits of cold exposure17 and breathwork practices in isolation18,19, recent findings suggest these practices may be even more effective when combined, as in the WHM (e.g., for reducing perceptions of stress16). Despite promising results, methodological constraints limit the early evidence for WHM’s efficacy, including small sample sizes, a lack of active control conditions, absence of pre-registered published protocols, and predominantly subjective markers (detailed in 12). Recent investigations have revealed mixed results, with some studies finding no positive effects of these practices on cardiovascular or psychological health20. These inconsistencies may stem from variability across methods, protocols, dosages, and theoretical framework guiding research questions and outcome measures. On the other hand, WHM appears to be particularly beneficial for stress and inflammatory response categories12. While not a cure-all, repeated practice of the WHM (cold exposure and hypoxia induced by cyclic hyperventilation) may inoculate against chronic stress through the dose-dependent stress response (also known as hormesis2,21. Specifically, low to moderate (usually intermittent) doses of certain stressors (e.g., “microdosing” stress) can trigger adaptive responses and promote resilience and improved health outcomes, while high or chronic doses are detrimental22. This process of hormesis is broadly applicable, being observed across cells, systems, plants, and humans21,22 and may explain how WHM practices impact stress-related outcomes. We also propose that repeated practice of the WHM may help specifically to recalibrate metacognitive beliefs about the capacity to effectively anticipate, adapt to, and recover from stress. Allostasis refers to the processes by which the brain anticipates and adapts to changing conditions (including stressors) to maintain stability through change5. Allostatic processes involve the production of stress mediators, such as adrenaline and cortisol, in response to anticipated challenges5. While these mediators are crucial for promoting adaptation to acute stress, chronic or prolonged activation of the body’s stress response systems can lead to allostatic overload (i.e., wear and tear) on various physiological systems, increasing one’s risk of health problems5. Chronic dyshomeostasis (e.g., prolonged stress) can also foster implicit beliefs that one is ineffective at regulating stress responses. This belief is theorised to diminish subjective wellbeing, manifesting as increased fatigue and depressive symptoms23. Frequent intentional exposure to and recovery from short-term stress, such as that elicited by acute cold exposure and hypoxia induced by cyclic hyperventilation, may help adjust expectations about allostatic regulation. By overcoming default stress reduction strategies (e.g., avoiding or fleeing from the source of stress), intentional practice of the WHM may be encoded by the brain as experiences of successfully overcoming stress, adjusting the brain’s expectations about allostatic self-efficacy, and the range (or boundary conditions) of stress that one can cope with and recover from. Repeated intentional hormetic stress, as practised in WHM, may facilitate recalibration of the brain’s expectations about stress and thus lead to improved stress resilience and allostatic self-efficacy over time. Guided by this framework, the present study employs a semi-randomised controlled trial with a large sample size, an active control condition, event sampling methodology (ESM), physiological biometric capture, and online cognitive testing to examine the effects of the WHM on psychological, physiological, and cognitive functioning. WHM has previously been linked to reduced inflammation and improvements in energy, fatigue, and breathing12, suggesting it may also influence physiological regulation (e.g., allostasis24,25). To better understand the physiological effects of the WHM, we also included objective metrics that reflect autonomic recovery and sleep processes. We assessed heart rate variability (HRV), resting heart rate, respiratory rate, and sleep architecture (slow wave sleep (SWS), rapid eye movement (REM)) to supplement self-report data and detect changes outside of conscious awareness. This extends previous research19 by evaluating the full WHM protocol, including breathing and cold exposure, over a longer intervention period. Methods Ethics & OSF This study received ethical approval from the Human Ethics Sub-Committee at the University of Queensland (ID: 2023/HE000736). All methods were performed in accordance with relevant guidelines and regulations. Informed consent was obtained from all participants involved in the study. All study protocols, hypotheses, data collection procedures, and planned analyses were pre-registered prospectively on the Open Science Framework (OSF; see https://osf.io/mdwpq; registered 25/07/2023). This study was also registered as a clinical trial with the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (ACTRN; ACTRN12623000913673; registered 25/08/2023). Deviations from our pre-registration (OSF) and retrospective ANZCTR registration are detailed at the end of the methods section (see Deviations from Pre-registration). Recruitment Participants were recruited across Australia and New Zealand via three channels: (a) targeted LinkedIn advertisements, (b) outreach to existing biometric capture device users (WHOOP Inc), and (c)

Read the complete text