A national overview of nonprofit hospital community benefit programs to address the social determinants of health
Berkeley Franz, Ashlyn Burns, Kristin Kueffner, Meeta Bhardwaj, Valerie A Yeager, Simone Singh, Neeraj Puro, Cory E Cronin · 2023
Read A national overview of nonprofit hospital community benefit programs to address the social determinants of health by Berkeley Franz, Ashlyn Burns, Kristin Kueffner, Meeta Bhardwaj, Valerie A Yeager, Simone Singh, Neeraj Puro, Cory E Cronin (2023) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/pmc-11103730.txt.
Introduction
Berkeley Franz and co-authors survey hospital community programs in a 2023 US study. Health is shaped heavily by social factors such as housing, food, and income. US nonprofit hospitals must invest in community health, yet how much of that money targets those upstream factors was unclear.
Needs assessments and plans from 613 hospitals were analyzed. About seven in ten named social factors among their top five community needs. About six in ten reported real investment aimed at those factors. Programs split between whole community efforts and help for single patients. The overview shows a field moving upstream, but unevenly across hospitals.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Berkeley Franz, Ashlyn Burns, Kristin Kueffner, Meeta Bhardwaj, Valerie A Yeager, Simone Singh, Neeraj Puro, Cory E Cronin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2023 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A national overview of nonprofit hospital community benefit programs to address the social determinants of health Authors: Berkeley Franz, Ashlyn Burns, Kristin Kueffner, Meeta Bhardwaj, Valerie A Yeager, Simone Singh, Neeraj Puro, Cory E Cronin Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractDecades of research have solidified the crucial role that social determinants of health (SDOH) play in shaping health outcomes, yet strategies to address these upstream factors remain elusive. The aim of this study was to understand the extent to which US nonprofit hospitals invest in SDOH at either the community or individual patient level and to provide examples of programs in each area. We analyzed data from a national dataset of 613 hospital community health needs assessments and corresponding implementation strategies. Among sample hospitals, 69.3% (n = 373) identified SDOH as a top-5 health need in their community and 60.6% (n = 326) reported investments in SDOH. Of hospitals with investments in SDOH, 44% of programs addressed health-related social needs of individual patients, while the remaining 56% of programs addressed SDOH at the community level. Hospitals that were major teaching organizations, those in the Western region of the United States, and hospitals in counties with more severe housing problems had greater odds of investing in SDOH at the community level. Although many nonprofit hospitals have integrated SDOH-related activities into their community benefit work, stronger policies are necessary to encourage greater investments at the community-level that move beyond the needs of individual patients.Keywords: nonprofit hospitals, community benefit, Community Health Needs Assessment (CHNA), social determinants of health (SDOH), health-related social need (HRSN) Introduction Health inequities and lagging health indicators represent a significant and pressing policy challenge in the United States. A growing body of evidence suggests that medical care alone is not sufficient to address the underlying causes of illness and drive meaningful improvements in health outcomes.1 Instead, health experts are increasingly acknowledging the pivotal role of social factors in shaping health and well-being. In response, new policies are encouraging health care systems and other large anchor organizations to invest in addressing these social factors both at the individual patient and community level.2,3 It is hard to overstate the significance of upstream social determinants of health (SDOH), which are responsible for as much as 50% of community-level variation in health outcomes.4,5 Defined by the World Health Organization as “the conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age” and “the fundamental drivers of these conditions,”6 SDOH include factors like education, employment, neighborhood and physical environment,7 and social support.8 Case studies of health care organizations show new patterns of investing in community-level initiatives for housing, targeted employment programs, and bolstering school quality to improve the overall health of the community.9-11 The majority of health care organizations also screen patients for individual-level, health-related social needs (HRSNs) that can be addressed through health care partnerships and health-promotion efforts.12 Beginning in 2024, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) will require hospitals to report the percentage of patients screened for HRSNs, underscoring the significant role of social factors in shaping overall health care needs.13 The HRSNs of an individual can be defined as the downstream manifestations of SDOH within a community.14 For example, food insecurity is an HRSN that is often addressed at the individual level through short-term strategies, such as linking patients to food-distribution programs or federal initiatives to supplement food budgets. While initiatives that provide food to patients have seen some success, patient-centered assistance fails to address the underlying social and economic factors that affect the health of a community,14 and interventions to improve SDOH at the community level remain less common and underfunded.15 Nonprofit hospitals in the United States are required to identify and respond to the most pressing health needs in the communities they serve in return for tax exemption. These organizations must also document these efforts through a community health needs assessment (CHNA) every 3 years, along with an implementation strategy (IS) to address the needs identified in the CHNA.16 Hospitals have historically provided most of their community benefit through uncompensated or subsidized care rather than through investment in SDOH; however, whether these trends are changing is unclear. Experts estimate that hospitals invested approximately $2.5 billion between 2017 and 2019 to address social factors.17 Previous research found that 69% of nonprofit hospitals identified social factors among the top 5 community health needs in their CHNA and 67% implemented at least 1 program to address social factors in the corresponding IS.18 Despite promising evidence that hospitals recognize the value of investing in SDOH, little is known about the nature of these investments, including the extent to which hospitals are addressing patients’ HRSNs rather than investing in broader social factors in the communities they serve. Again, addressing SDOH requires targeted upstream, or macro-level, approaches to health planning that aim to improve the underlying social and economic factors that affect the health of everyone in a community.14 While these interventions can be challenging for health care institutions, they are among the most needed to impact the key institutions, social systems, and public policies that drive health inequities.7 Using a nationally representative database of hospital CHNAs, we assessed hospitals’ strategies to address social factors using the Kaiser Family Foundation's (KFF’s) 6-category framework, conducted a content analysis of commonly adopted programs, and identified significant predictors of hospitals that invest in SDOH at the community level. These findings are the first to operationalize what hospitals mean when they publicly commit to addressing SDOH. This study has significant implications for policy development in the United States and may inform how private organizations invest in SDOH. Data and methods Data and sample We analyzed data from a national dataset of nonprofit hospital community benefit documents, which is representative at the state level. This dataset includes CHNAs and ISs from hospitals’ third post-Affordable Care Act round of reporting, spanning the years 2018–2021. To build this dataset, we obtained publicly available documents from over 600 US nonprofit hospitals’ websites and coded them for identified health needs and corresponding investments. The sample was drawn utilizing a 20% random sample of nonprofit hospitals nationally, stratified by state (n = 613).19 Stratifying by state ensured that a random set of hospitals (20%) were included from every state in proportion to the total number of hospitals in the state. After excluding hospitals with missing community benefit documents, there were 538 hospitals remaining in the analytic sample. This sample was similar to the entire universe of hospitals nationally, with the exception of bed size; the average number of beds of hospitals in our sample was higher than the national average.18 Our coding strategy was developed using a previous round of community benefit documents and is reported elsewhere.20 We coded CHNAs for the top 5 health needs identified, and then coded the top 5 health needs addressed in the corresponding IS. The coding team underwent structured training on the coding strategy, and we tested for interrater reliability with a set of 15 test documents. This process yielded 100% reliability, which is not surprising given the structured nature of community benefit documents. The coding team also met weekly to identify CHNAs/ISs that were not structured clearly, and collaboratively coded these documents. In this first round of coding,