Superpose3D: A Local Structural Comparison Program That Allows for User-Defined Structure Representations
Pier Federico Gherardini, Gabriele Ausiello, Manuela Helmer-Citterich · 2010
Read Superpose3D: A Local Structural Comparison Program That Allows for User-Defined Structure Representations by Pier Federico Gherardini, Gabriele Ausiello, Manuela Helmer-Citterich (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0011988.txt.
Introduction
Pier Federico Gherardini, Gabriele Ausiello, and Manuela Helmer-Citterich presented in 2010 software for comparing protein structures piece by piece. Local comparison finds shared patches, such as enzyme active sites, even when whole proteins differ. The catch is that results depend heavily on how the structure is represented for comparison.
Their program, Superpose3D, lets users define their own structure representations instead of accepting one fixed scheme. Flexibility matters because a representation good for one question can hide the answer to another. Giving researchers control over the representation makes local comparisons a more honest tool for finding functional similarities between proteins.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pier Federico Gherardini, Gabriele Ausiello, Manuela Helmer-Citterich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| LICENSE | Creative Commons Attribution License |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | PLOS ONE |
Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0011988
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Superpose3D: A Local Structural Comparison Program That Allows for User-Defined Structure Representations Authors: Pier Federico Gherardini, Gabriele Ausiello, Manuela Helmer-Citterich Published: 2010, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0011988 ABSTRACT Local structural comparison methods can be used to find structural similarities involving functional protein patches such as enzyme active sites and ligand binding sites. The outcome of such analyses is critically dependent on the representation used to describe the structure. Indeed different categories of functional sites may require the comparison program to focus on different characteristics of the protein residues. We have therefore developed superpose3D, a novel structural comparison software that lets users specify, with a powerful and flexible syntax, the structure description most suited to the requirements of their analysis. Input proteins are processed according to the user's directives and the program identifies sets of residues (or groups of atoms) that have a similar 3D position in the two structures. The advantages of using such a general purpose program are demonstrated with several examples. These test cases show that no single representation is appropriate for every analysis, hence the usefulness of having a flexible program that can be tailored to different needs. Moreover we also discuss how to interpret the results of a database screening where a known structural motif is searched against a large ensemble of structures. The software is written in C++ and is released under the open source GPL license. Superpose3D does not require any external library, runs on Linux, Mac OSX, Windows and is available at http://cbm.bio.uniroma2.it/superpose3D . INTRODUCTION The increasing number of structures available as a result of structural genomic initiatives has generated great interest in the development of structure-based function prediction methods [1] , [2] . Similar to sequence analysis the most straightforward approach is to compare the protein to be characterized with a set of proteins of known function. Global structural comparison methods, such as Dali [3] , Vast [4] SSM [5] and CE [6] , can be used to identify remote homology relationships that defy traditional sequence analysis. In addition, since the function of a protein usually depends on the identity and location of a small number of residues, local structural comparison methods (reviewed in [1] ) represent the ideal tool to focus the comparative analysis on the residues which are critical to function. Therefore one can compare a protein of unknown function with a set of well-characterized structures in order to check whether there are local similarities involving the known functional patches. Alternatively, from the analysis of a number of structures sharing some property, it is possible to derive a structural template encoding the function-determining residues, and use that to screen the proteins of interest. The local comparison problem comprises two different tasks: finding a suitable representation for the protein structure searching for the correspondence between the descriptors used that is optimal according to some criteria (e.g. length, RMSD, or a combination of both). As we will show, the type of representation used can greatly influence the kind of results that are obtained by the application of these methods. Indeed different functional sites may require a residue description focused on different physicochemical properties. In terms of search strategy three approaches are commonly used: recursive branch and bound algorithms, subgraph isomorphism and geometric hashing. The first two algorithmic strategies are equivalent in practice. A recursive branch and bound algorithm is used by RIGOR/SPASM [7] , Query3d [8] and PINTS [9] . Methods based on subgraph isomorphism include ASSAM [10] , CavBase [11] and eF-Site [12] . Methods relying on geometric hashing include C-alpha Match [13] , Prospect [14] , SiteEngine [15] and ProteMiner-SSM [16] . However the two tasks of representing the structure and searching for correspondences can be decoupled. Indeed, once a structure representation has been calculated according to the specific method used by the program, however complex this step may be, the problem simply becomes that of finding a correspondence between two sets of descriptors in space. We present here a novel program that leverages this observation. This program is called superpose3D and is available under the open source GPL license at http://cbm.bio.uniroma2.it/superpose3D . Superpose3D allows users to flexibly specify the way that residues are to be represented during the computation and the pairing rules. To the best of our knowledge the only downloadable, open-source methods for local structural comparison are RIGOR/SPASM and PINTS. RIGOR/SPASM allows the user to specify the residue substitutions. However, in terms of structure representation, the only option is whether to use the CA, the geometric centroid of the side chain or both. The residue definition syntax of PINTS is much more flexible. Users are required to assign arbitrary types to different atoms. Atoms of the same type are part of the same equivalency group and therefore can be matched with each other. Therefore it is not possible to specify that atoms A–B of residue X must match atoms C–D of residue Y and have to be paired as A;C B;D. In other words it is not possible to specify constraints that involve more than one equivalence group at the same time. Moreover when multiple atoms are selected for the same residue PINTS always uses the geometric centroid. In this work we describe superpose3D and the syntax used to specify different residue descriptions. We will also discuss several examples that highlight the advantages of using three types of structure description with varying levels of detail. These examples underscore the importance of using a residue representation that is tailored to the analysis at hand. - finding a suitable representation for the protein structure - searching for the correspondence between the descriptors used that is optimal according to some criteria (e.g. length, RMSD, or a combination of both). METHODS Superpose3D was written in C++ and does not require any external library. The software runs on Linux, Mac OSX and Windows. The program needs as input a file specifying which structures are to be compared, and eventually which residues in each chain, and another file containing the residue representation to be used together with a number of additional parameters. The residue description syntax is built around the notion of “pseudoatom”. A pseudoatom is a point used by the program to represent a residue or part of it. The number of pseudatoms that are used to represent each residue clearly influence the level of detail of the representation. Such points may correspond to an actual protein atom, e.g. the CA of a residue. However this is not necessarily the case. For instance one could define a pseudoatom corresponding to the geometric centroid of the side chain or any other set of atoms. This allows to include information about the location of specific chemical groups without necessarily increasing the complexity of the representation. Moreover when groups are represented this way there is more room for positional variation as it is not required for all the atoms to align exactly. The syntax of superpose3D allows users to define the pseudoatoms that represent each residue (including modified amino acids) by referring to the standard PDB atom naming convention. Once pseudoatoms have been defined it is necessary to describe the rules with which they can be paired to form a structural match. The software package includes