Work-Related Pain in Extrinsic Finger Extensor Musculature of Instrumentalists Is Associated with Intracellular pH Compartmentation during Exercise
Angel Moreno-Torres, Jaume Rosset-Llobet, Jesus Pujol et al. · 2010
Read Work-Related Pain in Extrinsic Finger Extensor Musculature of Instrumentalists Is Associated with Intracellular pH Compartmentation during Exercise by Angel Moreno-Torres, Jaume Rosset-Llobet, Jesus Pujol et al. (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0009091.txt.
Introduction
Angel Moreno-Torres and co-authors probed aching forearms in musicians who play for a living, in PLOS ONE in 2010. Repetitive light work often brings non-specific pain in upper limb muscles. The finger extensor muscles open the hand and work constantly in instrumentalists. Little was known about the chemistry inside those sore muscles.
The team compared muscle energy metabolism during exercise. Sore muscles split their acidity into compartments oddly as they worked. That pH compartmentation tracked with the players' work-related pain. Hidden chemistry, not visible damage, may explain this common occupational complaint.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Angel Moreno-Torres, Jaume Rosset-Llobet, Jesus Pujol et al. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| LICENSE | Creative Commons Attribution License |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | PLOS ONE |
Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0009091
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Work-Related Pain in Extrinsic Finger Extensor Musculature of Instrumentalists Is Associated with Intracellular pH Compartmentation during Exercise Authors: Angel Moreno-Torres, Jaume Rosset-Llobet, Jesus Pujol, Sílvia Fàbregas, Jose-Manuel Gonzalez-de-Suso Published: 2010, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0009091 ABSTRACT Although non-specific pain in the upper limb muscles of workers engaged in mild repetitive tasks is a common occupational health problem, much is unknown about the associated structural and biochemical changes. In this study, we compared the muscle energy metabolism of the extrinsic finger extensor musculature in instrumentalists suffering from work-related pain with that of healthy control instrumentalists using non-invasive phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy ( 31 P-MRS). We hypothesize that the affected muscles will show alterations related with an impaired energy metabolism. We studied 19 volunteer instrumentalists (11 subjects with work-related pain affecting the extrinsic finger extensor musculature and 8 healthy controls). We used 31 P-MRS to find deviations from the expected metabolic response to exercise in phosphocreatine (PCr), inorganic phosphate (Pi), Pi/PCr ratio and intracellular pH kinetics. We observed a reduced finger extensor exercise tolerance in instrumentalists with myalgia, an intracellular pH compartmentation in the form of neutral and acid compartments, as detected by Pi peak splitting in 31 P-MRS spectra, predominantly in myalgic muscles, and a strong association of this pattern with the condition. Work-related pain in the finger extrinsic extensor muscles is associated with intracellular pH compartmentation during exercise, non-invasively detectable by 31 P-MRS and consistent with the simultaneous energy production by oxidative metabolism and glycolysis. We speculate that a deficit in energy production by oxidative pathways may exist in the affected muscles. Two possible explanations for this would be the partial and/or local reduction of blood supply and the reduction of the muscle oxidative capacity itself. INTRODUCTION Work-related musculoskeletal disorders of the upper limb are common occupational health problems that cause pain, functional deficit, loss of work time and high medical costs. Among the pathologies encompassed by such a label [1] , non-specific muscle disorders are still controversial two decades after the terms “repetitive strain injury” and “overuse syndrome” were coined to describe diffuse non-specific pain in the upper limb muscles of workers engaged in mild repetitive tasks [2] , [3] . The main criticisms have been the lack of scientific evidence to show that subjects exposed to static and/or highly repetitive low amplitude tasks develop tissue damage, the lack of an objective test for diagnosis and the ambiguity of the terminology employed [4] . Despite such criticisms, the condition is recurrently present in epidemiological and clinical studies, and highly prevalent in some segments of the active population. Instrumentalists are particularly prone to develop the condition, which affects up to 50% of professional symphony orchestra musicians and 21% of music students [5] , [6] , and, when untreated, it may severely disable them. Much of the criticism is most probably a consequence of the lack of structural and biochemical information regarding the affected muscles, since studies in humans and animal models are scarce [7] – [11] . Some studies have shown that, in addition to changes in fiber type percentage and hyperthrophy, mitochondrial abnormalities may be present in the affected muscles [8] and data in the work-related myalgic extensor carpi radialis brevis muscle have shown an increased reliance on glycolytic metabolism during exercise [11] . Such evidence would suggest that alterations in oxidative metabolism and a shift towards glycolysis may be associated with the condition. Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy ( 31 P-MRS) is a safe, non-invasive and well proven technique for the rapid monitoring of intracellular changes in high energy phosphates and intracellular pH in the muscle during exercise and provides potential for the detection of energy metabolism alterations [12] . The aim of the present study, using non-invasive 31 P-MRS, was to compare the muscle energy metabolism during exercise of the whole finger extensor musculature in instrumentalists suffering from work-related pain with that of healthy control subjects to detect potentially useful alterations for the diagnosis and understanding of the pathophysiology of the condition. We chose the finger extensor musculature on the grounds that it is the most affected in instrumentalists, especially keyboard and string players [13] . Our results showed an intracellular pH compartmentation in the form of neutral and acid compartments, as detected by Pi peak splitting in 31 P-MRS spectra, predominantly in myalgic muscles, and a strong association of this pattern with the condition. This is consistent with the simultaneous energy production by oxidative metabolism and glycolysis in myalgic muscles, while in non-affected muscles the major contribution to energy production was oxidative. A plausible cause for such processes is a deficit in energy production by oxidative mechanisms in the affected muscles. METHODS Nineteen volunteer instrumentalists were included in the study: 11 patients and 8 healthy controls. Groups were comparable for hand and forearm anthropometry, age and sex ( Table 1 ), and none of the subjects was involved in any regular training activity involving forearm exercise. Patient criteria for inclusion were: self-reported symptoms (diffuse muscle pain, fatigue and persisting focal tenderness) in the finger extrinsic extensor musculature of a minimum 6-month duration (range 7 months to 10 years) that significantly impaired or prevented performance; confirmation of muscle pain and focal tenderness by palpation; and exclusion of other musculoskeletal, peripheral nerve or vascular pathology by clinical examination and MRI. Symptoms were bilateral in 10 patients and one patient showed affectation only in the non-dominant forearm. Inclusion criteria for controls were absence of symptoms and normal physical examination. Detailed information as to the musicians' professional history was collected in the selection visit ( Table 1 ). Both dominant and non-dominant arms were studied for all subjects. Values are mean ± SD. CSA; cross-sectional area. There were no significant differences between patient and control groups in either dominant or non-dominant arms. Significant differences: dominant vs. non-dominant arm, paired data Student-t test, p<0.001. Instrumentalists by instrument (controls/patients): Piano (3/5), Guitar (2/0), Electric guitar (1/2), Saxophone (1/1), Clarinet (1/1), Double bass (0/1), Drums (0/1). TABLE: Descriptive data of subjects included in the study. Controls Patients Subjects (n) 8 11 Sex (Males/Females) 5/3 6/5 Age (years) 22.6±3.2 23.2±5.0 Length of the dominant hand (mm) 179±13 180±10 Muscle forearm CSA (mm 2 ), dominant arm 3013±793 2961±890 Muscle forearm CSA (mm 2 ), non-dominant arm 2804±720 * 2767±821 * Professionals 6 (75%) 7 (64%) Total duration of instrument playing (years) 14.3±4.1 11.6±6.5 Daily practice (hours) 3.8±1.0 3.4±1.4 EXPERIMENTAL PROTOCOL Studies were carried out using a 1.5 T Signa system operating on the spectroscopy 5.8 version (Signa Advantage, General Electric Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI, USA). Subjects were placed in the magnet in a prone position, headfirst with their arm extended and centered. 31 P spectra were obtained with a pre-tuned elliptical transmitter and receiver surface coil (14.5×6.5 cm) centered on the hand extrinsic extensor muscle belly located by palpation and ocular inspection of the dorsal surface of the forearm during a sustained finger extension using a home-built ergometer (see below for details). The exercise involved rhythmic finger extension-flexion (30 cycles x min −1 , 1-second extension and 1-second flexion) performed using a home-built ergometer. The device consisted of a series of rubber bands (elasticity constant = 38.0±5.3 N/m, n = 10; double strand) attached between fingers