Predatory Functional Morphology in Raptors: Interdigital Variation in Talon Size Is Related to Prey Restraint and Immobilisation Technique

Denver W. Fowler, Elizabeth A. Freedman, John B. Scannella · 2009

Read Predatory Functional Morphology in Raptors: Interdigital Variation in Talon Size Is Related to Prey Restraint and Immobilisation Technique by Denver W. Fowler, Elizabeth A. Freedman, John B. Scannella (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0007999.txt.

Introduction

Denver Fowler and colleagues measured the talons of birds of prey for PLOS ONE in 2009. Raptors kill with their feet, yet how claw size varies from toe to toe had drawn little study. The team compared talon size across species with unlike hunting styles.

Claw patterns matched how each bird holds and stills its prey. Species that squeeze and pin prey with force carry a different claw layout from those that strike and release. Talons thus read as tools shaped by technique, a link that helps decode the hunting lives of living and fossil raptors alike.

Catalog record

CREATORDenver W. Fowler, Elizabeth A. Freedman, John B. Scannella
YEAR2009
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0007999

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Predatory Functional Morphology in Raptors: Interdigital Variation in Talon Size Is Related to Prey Restraint and Immobilisation Technique Authors: Denver W. Fowler, Elizabeth A. Freedman, John B. Scannella Published: 2009, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0007999 ABSTRACT Despite the ubiquity of raptors in terrestrial ecosystems, many aspects of their predatory behaviour remain poorly understood. Surprisingly little is known about the morphology of raptor talons and how they are employed during feeding behaviour. Talon size variation among digits can be used to distinguish families of raptors and is related to different techniques of prey restraint and immobilisation. The hypertrophied talons on digits (D) I and II in Accipitridae have evolved primarily to restrain large struggling prey while they are immobilised by dismemberment. Falconidae have only modest talons on each digit and only slightly enlarged D-I and II. For immobilisation, Falconini rely more strongly on strike impact and breaking the necks of their prey, having evolved a ‘tooth’ on the beak to aid in doing so. Pandionidae have enlarged, highly recurved talons on each digit, an adaptation for piscivory, convergently seen to a lesser extent in fishing eagles. Strigiformes bear enlarged talons with comparatively low curvature on each digit, part of a suite of adaptations to increase constriction efficiency by maximising grip strength, indicative of specialisation on small prey. Restraint and immobilisation strategy change as prey increase in size. Small prey are restrained by containment within the foot and immobilised by constriction and beak attacks. Large prey are restrained by pinning under the bodyweight of the raptor, maintaining grip with the talons, and immobilised by dismemberment (Accipitridae), or severing the spinal cord (Falconini). Within all raptors, physical attributes of the feet trade off against each other to attain great strength, but it is the variable means by which this is achieved that distinguishes them ecologically. Our findings show that interdigital talon morphology varies consistently among raptor families, and that this is directly correlative with variation in their typical prey capture and restraint strategy. INTRODUCTION Birds of prey or “raptors” (Accipitridae: hawks, kites, and eagles; Falconidae; Pandionidae: the osprey; and Strigiformes: owls) are among the most familiar and geographically widespread of all vertebrates. They are admired for their predatory ability, but surprisingly little is known about the patterns of physical interaction between predator and prey during capture and dispatch. It has often been assumed that raptors mainly use their sharp talons (a specific term referring only to the claws of birds of prey) to kill their prey [1] . This misconception is rooted in the difficulty of tracking and observing aerial predators after a prey item has been captured [2] – [5] . Even with modern technology, observation of post-capture predator-prey interaction in the wild is still largely opportunistic; consequently, prey immobilisation behaviour is greatly understudied. The term “immobilisation” (where the victim is no longer capable of movement or retaliation) is preferred to “killing” because in some accipitrids at least, if the prey is suitably immobilised and subdued, the raptor will commence feeding even before the death of its victim [6] – [8] . From the limited number of published reports, it is apparent that a combination of the initial strike impact, constriction by the feet, attacks from the predator's beak, dismemberment, and piercing of vital organs by talons are variably employed by raptors to immobilise prey [1] , [6] , [9] , [10] . Experiments in which caged wild raptors were offered live laboratory mice as prey [6] , [10] – [14] found that if the initial strike does not kill a prey item outright, the long, recurved talons are not then used to deliver the killing blow. Rather, the mouse is precisely grasped with one or both feet, targeting the victim's head and torso to avoid retaliatory bites and kicks [6] . The raptor's elongate digits are wrapped around the victim; the talons help to restrain the animal and prevent escape. The toes squeeze strongly (either constantly: Falconini; or intermittently: Accipitridae), causing thoracic compression and death by asphyxiation [1] , [10] . Squeezing may force talons into the flesh, piercing internal organs and hastening death (especially in Accipiter [15] ), although this is not commonly observed [10] . During asphyxiation, occasional blows to the head are delivered to attempt to damage the central nervous system, or to the neck (in the case of Falconini) in order to break it. Falconini might even attempt beak attacks mid-air, if the prey item is held onto in flight [9] . Recent studies of raptor predatory functional morphology have included skull morphometrics [8] , pes tendon systems [16] , musculoskeletal mechanics [17] , and the hindlimb as a whole [18] , [19] Claw morphology has received virtually no attention at all, which is surprising given its importance to predatory success [6] . Indeed, little literature considers claw morphology for any birds. In the most detailed study, Einoder and Richardson [20] took foot measurements (including claws) from a range of extant Australasian raptors, looking for ecological links with prey choice, size, “hunting-killing technique”, and phylogeny. Csermeley and Rossi [21] investigated whether the D-I and III claws of raptors could be differentiated from non-raptors. The few other studies on claws were primarily concerned with ecological analogues of non-raptor fossil birds, usually only taking measurements for D-III [22] – [25] . Most of these previous analyses made the a priori assumption that their choice of measured claw or claws was the most important, which may not be true for all taxa (indeed, our study shows that it is not true; see Supporting Information Text S1 ). Consequently, the authors were not able to note any patterns of interdigital claw size distribution occurring within or among taxa. Studies in which all claws were considered either only measured claw curvature [22] or used only toe-to-claw length ratios (not considering curvature) [20] , and so were unable to note many of the patterns we describe here, or their possible functional correlates. In an initial survey of specimens, we found that claw size distributions vary conspicuously and consistently among families of raptors ( Figure 1 ), an observation which has gone largely unnoticed in previous studies (although see Einoder and Richardson, 2007 [20] . Indeed, in many illustrated guides [26] claw morphology and relative size is often incorrectly illustrated, being overlooked in favour of plumage. To investigate further, we necessarily took a more complete approach than in previous analyses, measuring each claw of each digit, and also lengths of the toes and tarsometatarsus. These data were then assessed alongside new and published observations of raptor predatory activity to look for consistent patterns of behaviour that correlated with variation in talon and foot morphology at the family level. Our method is preferable to those of previous workers as it encompasses a full range of measurements, treating the foot as a whole, and because previously published qualitative accounts of predatory behaviour did not consider the influence of variation in talon morphology, necessitating reinterpretation which we present here. Note the digit length and relative enlargement and curvature of claws within each foot: Accipitridae bear hypertrophied talons on D-I and II; Falconidae have only modest talons on each digit and only slightly enlarged D-I and II; Strigiformes bear

Read the complete text