Local Individual Preferences for Nest Materials in a Passerine Bird

Adèle Mennerat, Philippe Perret, Marcel M. Lambrechts · 2009

Read Local Individual Preferences for Nest Materials in a Passerine Bird by Adèle Mennerat, Philippe Perret, Marcel M. Lambrechts (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0005104.txt.

Introduction

Songbirds build nests from local materials. The broad design is typical of the species. Adèle Mennerat, Philippe Perret and Marcel Lambrechts asked about individual taste. Their PLOS ONE paper appeared in 2009. They studied a passerine bird's choices of nest materials. Learning shapes much animal behavior. Nest building might be one case.

Individual birds showed local preferences for particular materials. Two neighbors could favor different stuff for the same job. The choice goes beyond species habit. It suggests learning and experience shape building. The work reveals character in nest construction. Animal personality is a growing field. Even a nest can carry a signature of its builder.

Catalog record

CREATORAdèle Mennerat, Philippe Perret, Marcel M. Lambrechts
YEAR2009
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0005104

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Local Individual Preferences for Nest Materials in a Passerine Bird Authors: Adèle Mennerat, Philippe Perret, Marcel M. Lambrechts Published: 2009, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005104 ABSTRACT Variation in the behavioural repertoire of animals is acquired by learning in a range of animal species. In nest-building birds, the assemblage of nest materials in an appropriate structure is often typical of a bird genus or species. Yet plasticity in the selection of nest materials may be beneficial because the nature and abundance of nest materials vary across habitats. Such plasticity can be learned, either individually or socially. In Corsican populations of blue tits Cyanistes caeruleus , females regularly add in their nests fragments of several species of aromatic plants during the whole breeding period. The selected plants represent a small fraction of the species present in the environment and have positive effects on nestlings. We investigated spatiotemporal variations of this behaviour to test whether the aromatic plant species composition in nests depends on 1) plant availability in territories, 2) female experience or 3) female identity. Our results indicate that territory plays a very marginal role in the aromatic plant species composition of nests. Female experience is not related to a change in nest plant composition. Actually, this composition clearly depends on female identity, i.e. results from individual preferences which, furthermore, are repeatable both within and across years. A puzzling fact is the strong difference in plant species composition of nests across distinct study plots. This study demonstrates that plant species composition of nests results from individual preferences that are homogeneous within study plots. We propose several hypotheses to interpret this pattern of spatial variation before discussing them in the light of preliminary results. As a conclusion, we cannot exclude the possibility of social transmission of individual preferences for aromatic plants. This is an exciting perspective for further work in birds, where nest construction behaviour has classically been considered as a stereotypic behaviour. INTRODUCTION Behavioural plasticity helps individuals to cope with variation in environmental conditions. Such variation in the behavioural repertoire of animals can arise from purely ecological causes (e.g. when local environmental conditions limiting the range of possible behaviours differ among populations), but may also be acquired by learning in a wide range of animal species. Many important behavioural traits can indeed be fine-tuned during life, either by individual learning (i.e. by trial and error) or by social learning (e.g. by imitating the behaviour of other individuals) (reviewed in [1] ). Naïve young animals, in particular, may benefit from observing the behaviour of more experienced individuals by increasing the efficiency with which they perform crucial tasks such as finding food, avoiding predators or choosing a sexual partner, without paying the costs associated with individual learning [1] , [2] . In vertebrates, many components of foraging and reproductive behaviours can be socially transmitted. For example, in Norway rats Rattus norvergicus , long-lasting food preferences are acquired after a few minutes interaction of a naïve individual with a demonstrator [3] . Young roof rats Rattus rattus learn from adults how to efficiently open pinecones [4] . Social learning of foraging routes has been demonstrated in female guppies [5] , [6] . In birds, the most documented example of social learning is the acquisition of the song repertoire of songbirds by imitation of a tutor from the local population [7] , [8] . Social transmission has been studied in a few other avian behavioural traits, most of them being observed on captive birds (e.g. feeding preferences [9] , [10] ; lid opening [11] ; handling of new objects [12] ). These laboratory studies are certainly useful in assessing the learning abilities of animals, disentangling genetic from environmental effects, controlling for confounding factors and testing predictions made from theoretical models (e.g. producer-scrounger models, reviewed in [13] ). Yet they provide little information on the actual occurrence and ecological importance of social learning in wild populations (e.g. [14] ). Many bird species build nests that protect their eggs and chicks from climatic variation and predators. Nest building is closely linked to fitness (e.g. offspring survival) and is therefore under high selective pressure. The assemblage of nest materials in an appropriate structure is often typical of a bird genus or species, although within-species variation in the selection of nest materials can be significant [15] , [16] . Such flexibility can be adaptive, e.g. when the nature and abundance of nest materials vary across habitats, and may be achieved through individual or social learning. In particular, new individuals in a population may gain efficiency from observing how other individuals find and select the proper nest materials and imitating them (e.g. [17] ). In addition to basic nest materials (e.g. moss or twigs), several bird species bring to their nests green plants which are rich in volatile secondary compounds [18] , [19] . The selected plant species often represent a small fraction of the species available in the habitat [18] , [20] . Several studies suggest that nest greenery is beneficial to chick growth, development or survival [21] , [22] . On Corsica, hole-nesting female blue tits Cyanistes caeruleus regularly incorporate fresh fragments of several species of aromatic plants on the top of their nests (e.g. Lavandula stoechas, Achillea ligustica, Helichrysum italicum ), and quickly replenish the nest with fresh fragments after experimental removal [23] – [25] . The maximal dry mass of plant fragments found in nests of blue tits is close to 1.3 g (Mennerat, pers. obs.). The plant species found in nests of blue tits represent only a small fraction of the plants species available in the habitat [24] , and some of them possess in vitro antiseptic, fungicidal or insect-repellent properties [26] , [27] . These aromatic plants reduce both the density and phylotypic richness of bacteria living on nestlings (Mennerat et al., unpublished data) and have positive effects on chick growth, feather development and hematocrit [28] . Strong inter-nest variation in aromatic plant species composition is frequently observed, but there are few quantitative data, and most arguments so far come from qualitative field observations (e.g. [23] ). Here we used both comparative and plant-removal (cf [24] ) approaches to explain spatiotemporal variations in the use of aromatic plants in blue tit nests from one valley in Corsica. We first tested whether the aromatic plant species composition in nests was individually repeatable, both within and across breeding seasons. Variation in the aromatic plant species composition of nests was then explored both across years and between territories within study sites to test the three following predictions. First, the aromatic plant species composition in nests may depend on the presence of these plants in the surrounding territory. If true, we predicted inter-year similarity in nest composition for the same female to be lower between two breeding attempts in different nestboxes than between two breeding attempts in the same nestbox. Second, breeding experience may affect the use of aromatic plants by females. For instance, yearling females may have less information on the aromatic plants available in their environment than experienced females, and therefore be less efficient at finding and bringing plants to their nests. If true, we predicted lower similarity in nest composition across two consecutive years when females passed

Read the complete text