Stochastic Resonance Reveals “Pilot Light” Expression in Mammalian Genes

Andrey Ptitsyn · 2008

Read Stochastic Resonance Reveals “Pilot Light” Expression in Mammalian Genes by Andrey Ptitsyn (2008) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0001842.txt.

Introduction

Andrey Ptitsyn proposed a data trick to find faint gene activity in a 2008 PLOS ONE research article. Microarrays gauge the activity of thousands of genes in a sample, but the detail they can show is limited by background noise. Faintly read genes are detected poorly, and many genes are never detected at all.

Ptitsyn applies stochastic resonance, an effect where noise boosts weak signals, to reveal 'pilot light' expression: very low, steady gene activity that standard analysis misses. The full text gives the method and the chip data it found. Genes expressed at pilot light levels may still matter in living cells, so a method that rescues them expands every dataset already gathered.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrey Ptitsyn
YEAR2008
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0001842

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stochastic Resonance Reveals “Pilot Light” Expression in Mammalian Genes Authors: Andrey Ptitsyn Published: 2008, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001842 ABSTRACT Microarrays are widely used for estimation of expression of thousands of genes in a biological sample. The resolution ability of this method is limited by the background noise. Low expressed genes are detected with insufficient reliability and expression of many genes is never detected at all. We have applied the principles of stochastic resonance to detect expression of genes from microarray signals below the background noise level. We report the periodic pattern detected in genes called “Absent” by traditional analysis. The pattern is consistent with expression of the conventionally detected genes and specific to the tissue of origin. This effect is corroborated by the analysis of oscillating gene expression in mouse ( M.musculus ) and yeast ( S. cerevisae ). Most genes usually considered silent are in fact expressed at a very low level. Stochastic resonance can be applied to detect changes in expression pattern of low-expressed genes as well as for the validation of the probe performance in microarrays. INTRODUCTION Microarrays have become a standard technique in biological research. From the beginning, the focus in microarray experiments has been on taking the simultaneous snapshot of a large number of genes, rather than exact measurement of expression level for a small number of selected genes. Over the years the technology has undergone a significant evolution, allowing a reliable identification of functional relation of co-expressed genes and a good estimation of expression level for particular genes [1] , [2] . However microarray performance is still limited by the background noise. Advanced normalization and summation algorithms [3] , [4] can improve signal to noise ratio for the low-expressed genes. However, none of the contemporary algorithms can help with identifying expression of the genes expressed at such low level that the luminescent signal reading from the spot does not exceed the reading from the space between spots. It is commonly assumed that genes whose expression could not be identified by either microarray or RT-PCR experiment are silent. This assumption is intuitive, but not founded in biology. In contrast, most recent studies indicate the presence of eukaryotic transcription initiation complexes at the promoters of majority of “silent” genes for which no transcripts could be detected [5] . On the other hand, the situation where the signal to be detected is weaker than the ambient noise and could not be registered directly is not new in the other areas of science. The effect of Stochastic Resonance (SR) is well studied and widely applied in physics [6] , [7] and even some areas of biology [8] , [9] . Stochastic resonance is a counter-intuitive effect of amplification of a weak periodic signal by an increase of ambient noise (see Supplemental Figure S1 ). But what periodic signal in gene expression could be detectable with SR approach? In 2006–2007 we have published a series of papers characterizing the oscillating patterns of gene expression in metabolically active peripheral tissues in mice. The circadian oscillation we reported extends far beyond the commonly accepted 10–15% of genes directly regulated by the circadian molecular clock [10] , [11] , [12] , [13] . The accumulated evidence allows us to postulate that oscillation is a basic property of expression of all genes, not necessarily connected with any specific gene function. However, the oscillatory properties, such as phase and amplitude are dependent on the gene function and differ between tissues and experimental conditions [13] . Oscillatory patterns of expression in major housekeeping genes responsible for the energy balance (PPAR) and basic transcription (TBP) are bound to impose the same patterns on all transcribed genes regardless of the volume of transcription. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The heat map plot in Figure 1 shows the pattern of circadian expression in approximately 30% of all genes interrogated by the Affymetrix mouse expression microarray. At first glance the pattern of two red (zenith) and two green (nadirs) areas over two-day period is remarkably similar to the previously published circadian expression patterns in mice [10] , [14] . However in this case none of the genes selected for analysis has been called “Present” even once at any of the 12 time points. This effect is not specific to a particular tissue and observed in all mouse and yeast data sets considered in this paper. In spite of being considered silent most genes called absent are expressed in a daily changing pattern of elevated (red) and lowered expression level (green) over the 48h period of alternating light and darkness (bottom), consistent with circadian pattern in highly expressed genes. The plot shows four phase groups (roman numbers) in four murine tissues (data from [10] and [12] ). On each pane expression profiles are stacked in order of autocorrelation with 24h lag (Ac, vertical axis). In most studies such “silent” genes are excluded from further analysis on the early stages. The filtration criteria are usually more stringent, selecting only genes called “Present” in at least half of all time points [15] . In the previous publications we have reported circadian oscillation in nearly 100% of all genes [13] . But the oscillating pattern does not show a strong dependence on the absolute level of expression or any regard to the signal/background noise ratio of the Affymetrix GeneChip. Figure 2 shows relations between likeliness of circadian oscillation (estimated by a periodicity test p-value) and the overall median of expression signal in time series. There is no indication of a threshold associated with presence or absence call. Genes expressed below the noise level (typically with signal reading under 150) generate the same pattern as highly expressed genes. This finding is corroborated by the results of periodicity tests performed on the subset of non-present genes (see Table 1 ). As expected, the number of “absent” genes for which a periodic pattern is observed with the confidence level of p<0.1 is lower and the expression profiles are generally noisier compared to analysis of entire set of transcripts [13] . However, in spite of the lower signal to noise ratio the underlying baseline circadian, oscillation is detectable in majority of the profiles. This pattern and the proportion between phase groups are consistent with that of the “present” genes or the mixture of “present” and “absent” genes (transcripts). These observations lead to the conclusion that the criteria separating “present” from “absent” genes is arbitrary. The low signal emitted from the microarray probes can be below the noise level for the chip at each particular time point. However, it reflects the pattern of gene expression rather than an ambient noise. This point can be further illustrated by Figure 3 which shows expression pattern of transcripts called “Absent” and “Present” in the contexts of a biological pathway (a fragment of insulin signaling pathway, data from Metacore database, GeneGo Inc.). In spite of the absence call for the insulin receptor the white adipose tissue is known to respond to the insulin signal [16] . The profile for the “Absent” insulin receptor is pronouncedly circadian and perfectly synchronized with production rate of the insulin receptor substrate, which is called present. Transcripts called present are plotted with a red line on a white pane,

Read the complete text