A Role for Gene Duplication and Natural Variation of Gene Expression in the Evolution of Metabolism
Daniel J. Kliebenstein · 2008
Read A Role for Gene Duplication and Natural Variation of Gene Expression in the Evolution of Metabolism by Daniel J. Kliebenstein (2008) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0001838.txt.
Introduction
Daniel J. Kliebenstein examined how gene duplication shapes plant metabolism in a 2008 PLOS ONE research article. Most plant and animal genomes have been through whole genome doublings during their history. Studies had shown doubled genes can part from the parent gene by gaining new functions or splitting old ones within one plant.
Kliebenstein adds another process: natural variation of gene expression between plants and groups as a driver of how plant chemistry evolves. The full text lays out the evidence and the argument across plant pathways. Metabolism is where genes meet the environment, so how doubled copies diversify helps explain the chemistry that lets plants make medicines, poisons, and flavors.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel J. Kliebenstein |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2008 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| LICENSE | Creative Commons Attribution License |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | PLOS ONE |
Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0001838
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Role for Gene Duplication and Natural Variation of Gene Expression in the Evolution of Metabolism Authors: Daniel J. Kliebenstein Published: 2008, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001838 ABSTRACT Most eukaryotic genomes have undergone whole genome duplications during their evolutionary history. Recent studies have shown that the function of these duplicated genes can diverge from the ancestral gene via neo- or sub-functionalization within single genotypes. An additional possibility is that gene duplicates may also undergo partitioning of function among different genotypes of a species leading to genetic differentiation. Finally, the ability of gene duplicates to diverge may be limited by their biological function. To test these hypotheses, I estimated the impact of gene duplication and metabolic function upon intraspecific gene expression variation of segmental and tandem duplicated genes within Arabidopsis thaliana . In all instances, the younger tandem duplicated genes showed higher intraspecific gene expression variation than the average Arabidopsis gene. Surprisingly, the older segmental duplicates also showed evidence of elevated intraspecific gene expression variation albeit typically lower than for the tandem duplicates. The specific biological function of the gene as defined by metabolic pathway also modulated the level of intraspecific gene expression variation. The major energy metabolism and biosynthetic pathways showed decreased variation, suggesting that they are constrained in their ability to accumulate gene expression variation. In contrast, a major herbivory defense pathway showed significantly elevated intraspecific variation suggesting that it may be under pressure to maintain and/or generate diversity in response to fluctuating insect herbivory pressures. These data show that intraspecific variation in gene expression is facilitated by an interaction of gene duplication and biological activity. Further, this plays a role in controlling diversity of plant metabolism. INTRODUCTION Most eukaryotic genomes have undergone whole genome duplications during their evolutionary history with angiosperms having a particular enrichment in this process [1] – [4] . In addition to whole genome events, small local events can generate tandem duplicated genes which are often considered younger than segmental duplicated genes obtained from a whole genome duplication [1] , [5] . Following either tandem or segmental duplication events, one of the duplicated genes can be rendered non-functional via the accumulation of deleterious mutations [6] . Alternatively, both duplicated genes can be maintained if the presence of both copies is advantageous. Over time, the function of these duplicated genes can diverge from the ancestral gene or from each other. This divergence can occur via sub-functionalization such that the duplicate copies obtain differential expression patterns in terms of tissue specificity or stress response [7] . Alternatively, one of the duplicates can obtain a novel function, a process known as neo-functionalization. In a number of species, recent work has associated gene duplication with divergent gene expression patterns in response to developmental or abiotic stress cues [8] – [12] . Gene duplication may also allow partitioning of function among genotypes within a species, leading to genetic differentiation/intraspecific variation. This process is contingent upon genetic neo-functionalization and would suggest that duplicated genes should show higher levels of intraspecific variation in gene expression than “unique” genes. Preliminary evidence supporting the hypothesis that duplicated genes show higher levels of intraspecific variation was obtained in a study with yeast and fruit flies [13] . Given that segmental duplications are typically older than speciation events, it is likely that segmentally duplicated genes have fixed different functions and are in essence acting as unique genes. As such, it would be expected that increases in intraspecific variation may only be detected among younger tandem duplicated genes. In Arabidopsis thaliana , several cloned QTL associate intraspecific variation in gene expression with tandem duplication [14] , [15] . Yet to date there is little information on the genomic role of gene duplication in controlling intraspecific genetic variation in gene expression or other traits. Another factor controlling the divergence and maintenance of gene duplicates is the biological function of the gene [5] , [9] , [16] . It is commonly held that some essential biological processes, such as primary energy metabolism, may be constrained in their ability to vary [17] , [18] . However, current studies typically use overarching functional assignments such as “nucleotide binding” or “hydrolase activity” provided by the Gene Ontology consortium. While providing a broad genomic perspective, these categories may obscure the influence of more specific biological function on genetic constraint [19] suggesting the need for a more specific biological definition. A rich source for testing the relationship between biological function, gene duplication and intraspecific genetic variation are databases describing the metabolic pathways known and predicted within a host of organisms [20] , [21] . These databases provide specific metabolic roles for genes acting as a highly refined function prediction. For instance, the Arabidopsis metabolic networks includes genes involved in major energetic and carbon flux pathways that are essential for each cells survival, such as photosynthesis, the calvin cycle, and the TCA cycle (AraCyc; www.arabidopsis.org/biocyc/index.jsp ). The critical function of the genes in these primary metabolic pathways may be constrained in the range of gene expression values that the pathways transcripts can occupy and the more specific definition of their biological activity may enhance our ability to detect this. In contrast to primary metabolism, genes involved in secondary metabolite pathways are marked by a high level of inter and intraspecific variation [22] – [24] . The evolution of this diversity is predicted to be driven by gene duplication and consequent neo-functionalization of enzymes [15] , [25] – [27] . Glucosinolates are sulphur-rich, amino acid-derived compounds that form a major class of secondary metabolites in Arabidopsis. These compounds are hydrolyzed by an endogenous thioglucosidase, myrosinase, releasing toxic products upon disruption of plant cells by harvesting, processing, or mastication [28] . Aliphatic glucosinolates are subject to diverse selection regimes in the wild [27] , [29] , [30] . We hypothesize that such secondary metabolite pathways may have higher levels of gene duplication and greater gene expression diversity than primary metabolite enzymes. Thus, Arabidopsis metabolism provides an excellent model to study how gene duplication and biological function interplay to control constraint, sub-functionalization and/or neo-functionalization following gene duplication. In this study, I investigated the role that gene duplication and metabolic pathway organization play in controlling gene expression variation within Arabidopsis thaliana natural accessions. I also measured gene expression variation in developmental and abiotic stress datasets to allow comparison with other publications focused on gene duplication and divergence of response patterns. Recent tandem and older segmental duplicated genes showed a significant increase in intraspecific variation of gene expression in comparison the average gene, while unique genes showed lower levels of intraspecific variation. Gene expression variation of segmental and tandem duplicated genes was controlled by a greater number of genetic loci, and these loci had larger effects on gene expression variation for tandem duplicated genes. Gene participation in specific metabolic pathways predicted the level of intraspecific variation in gene expression, with major energy and amino acid pathways having relatively lower levels of gene expression variation. This suggests that these primary metabolism pathways are genetically constrained. In contrast, a major secondary metabolite pathway in Arabidopsis showed a significantly increased level of gene duplication and intraspecific gene expression variation, suggesting that this pathway may be structured to cope with fluctuating selection in the wild.