Climate Change, Genetics or Human Choice: Why Were the Shells of Mankind's Earliest Ornament Larger in the Pleistocene Than in the Holocene?

Peter R. Teske, Isabelle Papadopoulos, Christopher D. McQuaid et al. · 2007

Read Climate Change, Genetics or Human Choice: Why Were the Shells of Mankind's Earliest Ornament Larger in the Pleistocene Than in the Holocene? by Peter R. Teske, Isabelle Papadopoulos, Christopher D. McQuaid et al. (2007) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0000614.txt.

Introduction

Peter R. Teske, Isabelle Papadopoulos, Christopher D. McQuaid and colleagues turned to a very old fashion question in PLOS ONE in 2007. Shell beads made from the southern African tick shell are the earliest known ornaments worn by humans. Beads from about 75,000 years ago, found in a cave on South Africa's south coast, were larger than later ones.

Three explanations compete in the title itself: climate change, genetics, or human choice. The authors compare Pleistocene shells with Holocene ones to weigh why the size shifted. A change in taste would say something about early human culture. A change in climate or genes would point to the shells' own biology instead.

Catalog record

CREATORPeter R. Teske, Isabelle Papadopoulos, Christopher D. McQuaid et al.
YEAR2007
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0000614

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Climate Change, Genetics or Human Choice: Why Were the Shells of Mankind's Earliest Ornament Larger in the Pleistocene Than in the Holocene? Authors: Peter R. Teske, Isabelle Papadopoulos, Christopher D. McQuaid, Brent K. Newman, Nigel P. Barker Published: 2007, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0000614 ABSTRACT The southern African tick shell, Nassarius kraussianus (Dunker, 1846), has been identified as being the earliest known ornamental object used by human beings. Shell beads dated from ∼75,000 years ago (Pleistocene era) were found in a cave located on South Africa's south coast. Beads made from N. kraussianus shells have also been found in deposits in this region dating from the beginning of the Holocene era (<10,000 years ago). These younger shells were significantly smaller, a phenomenon that has been attributed to a change in human preference. We investigated two alternative hypotheses explaining the difference in shell size: a) N. kraussianus comprises at least two genetic lineages that differ in size; b) the difference in shell size is due to phenotypic plasticity and is a function of environmental conditions. To test these hypotheses, we first reconstructed the species' phylogeographic history, and second, we measured the shell sizes of extant individuals throughout South Africa. Although two genetic lineages were identified, the sharing of haplotypes between these suggests that there is no genetic basis for the size differences. Extant individuals from the cool temperate west coast had significantly larger shells than populations in the remainder of the country, suggesting that N. kraussianus grows to a larger size in colder water. The decrease in fossil shell size from Pleistocene to Holocene was likely due to increased temperatures as a result of climate change at the beginning of the present interglacial period. We hypothesise that the sizes of N. kraussianus fossil shells can therefore serve as indicators of the climatic conditions that were prevalent in a particular region at the time when they were deposited. Moreover, N. kraussianus could serve as a biomonitor to study the impacts of future climate change on coastal biota in southern Africa. INTRODUCTION The southern African tick shell, Nassarius kraussianus (Dunker, 1846), is an estuarine and shallow water marine snail that has recently been identified as being the earliest known object to be used for ornamental purposes by human beings; shells found in Blombos Cave on the south coast of South Africa ( Fig. 1 ) were estimated to have been worn as a necklace during the Middle Stone Age (MSA; ∼75 000 years ago [1] , [2] ). Fossils of N. kraussianus are absent from south-west African deposits of the Pliocene (1.8–5.3 million years ago; [3] ), but by the late Pleistocene (∼120 000 years ago), the species had become an important component of the coastal fauna throughout much of southern Africa [4] , [5] . Tick shells are also common in deposits from the Late Stone Age (LSA; beginning of the present interglacial, <10 000 years ago [2] , [6] ) and today are among the numerically dominant coastal gastropods in southern Africa [7] . Tick shells from Blombos Cave dated from the MSA were significantly larger than ornamental LSA shells from the same locality and from another fossil site in the region (Die Kelders), as well as from modern specimens collected in estuaries in the region (Goukou and Duiwenhoks) [2] . From this, D'Errico et al. [2] concluded that MSA humans had selected only exceptionally large shells for their necklaces, whereas during the LSA, shells were collected randomly. We question this interpretation for two reasons: Firstly, while several of the 29 MSA shells were more than 10 mm in length, none of the 2 098 LSA shells and none of the similarly sized 2 587 modern shells that were measured exceeded 10 mm. The effort of finding shells that exceeded 10 mm would thus have been exceptional during the LSA. Secondly, not all of the MSA shells were exceptionally large, but they rather comprised a size range from 6.83 to 10.42 mm. This could indicate that instead of a change in human preference, the sizes of shells in the region decreased. We tested two alternative hypotheses, both of which assume that shell sizes of N. kraussianus on South Africa's south coast were larger in the MSA than in the LSA: a) the size difference has a genetic basis and N. kraussianus comprises at least two distinct genetic units and b) the difference in shell size is due to phenotypic plasticity responding to changing environmental conditions. Sampling localities (A–J) from which specimens of Nassarius kraussianus were collected. The sample sizes were: A = 350, B = 104, C = 132, D = 112, E = 47, F = 183, G = 83, H = 54, I = 71, J = 94. Blue circles indicate localities dominated by haplotypes present in the western range of the species' distribution, and red circles indicate sites where haplotypes of the eastern lineage were mostly found. The location of Blombos Cave (where N. kraussianus fossils were found that were worn as beads by human beings during the Middle and Late Stone Age) is indicated. The present-day geographical range of N. kraussianus spans three marine biogeographical provinces in southern Africa [7] : the cool-temperate west coast, the warm-temperate south coast, and the subtropical east coast ( Fig. 1 ). Many marine organisms in the region are associated with more than one of these biogeographic provinces, but each province has its own combination of species [8] – [10] . Genetic data show that some coastal invertebrates with planktonic larvae or direct development that occur in more than one province comprise two or more genetically distinct regional lineages, with boundaries that coincide with those between the biogeographic provinces [11] – [17] . Given the wide distribution range of N. kraussianus and the fact that it disperses by means of planktonic larvae [18] , it is possible that this species may comprise several regional phylogeographic units that differ in shell size, e.g. a large-bodied lineage adapted to cooler water temperature and a small-bodied lineage present in warmer water. Their distributions may have shifted as a result of climate change, with the small-bodied lineage having replaced the large-bodied lineage on the south coast. Alternatively, the larger lineage may have become extinct (e.g. during the last glacial maximum ∼15–25 000 years ago) and been replaced by the smaller lineage throughout its range (e.g. at the beginning of the present interglacial, <10 000 years ago). The two lineage-hypothesis is rejected if a) no genetically distinct lineages of N. kraussianus are found that differ in shell size and b) expansion events from south-eastern to south-western Africa evident in the genetic data do not significantly postdate the MSA. PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY Morphological differentiation in molluscs is often the result of phenotypic plasticity rather than genetics [19] . The fact that both homeotherms and poikilotherms grow larger at colder temperatures [20] , [21] may account for a change in shell size as a result of an increase in water temperatures on the south coast from the MSA to the LSA. This hypothesis is rejected if tick shells in different biogeographic provinces do not differ in shell size. METHODS A total of 1230 specimens of Nassarius kraussianus were collected from

Read the complete text