Negative BOLD fMRI Response in the Visual Cortex Carries Precise Stimulus-Specific Information

David Bressler, Nicole Spotswood, David Whitney · 2007

Read Negative BOLD fMRI Response in the Visual Cortex Carries Precise Stimulus-Specific Information by David Bressler, Nicole Spotswood, David Whitney (2007) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0000410.txt.

Introduction

David Bressler, Nicole Spotswood, and David Whitney reported a surprising brain signal in a 2007 PLOS ONE paper. In fMRI scans, most active brain areas show a stronger blood signal, but some show a negative one, a dip called the negative BOLD response. It was often treated as noise or as mere shutdown. The team tested what the dip in the visual cortex actually carries.

The authors found that the negative response holds precise, stimulus-specific information about what the person was seeing. That makes the dip a signal worth reading rather than discarding. Brain imaging studies that use it could extract more detail about how the visual system represents the world.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Bressler, Nicole Spotswood, David Whitney
YEAR2007
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0000410

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Negative BOLD fMRI Response in the Visual Cortex Carries Precise Stimulus-Specific Information Authors: David Bressler, Nicole Spotswood, David Whitney Published: 2007, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0000410 ABSTRACT Sustained positive BOLD (blood oxygen level-dependent) activity is employed extensively in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies as evidence for task or stimulus-specific neural responses. However, the presence of sustained negative BOLD activity (i.e., sustained responses that are lower than the fixation baseline) has remained more difficult to interpret. Some studies suggest that it results from local “blood stealing” wherein blood is diverted to neurally active regions without a concomitant change of neural activity in the negative BOLD regions. However, other evidence suggests that negative BOLD is a result of local neural suppression. In both cases, regions of negative BOLD response are usually interpreted as carrying relatively little, if any, stimulus-specific information (hence the predominant reliance on positive BOLD activity in fMRI). Here we show that the negative BOLD response resulting from visual stimulation can carry high information content that is stimulus-specific. Using a general linear model (GLM), we contrasted standard flickering stimuli to a fixation baseline and found regions of the visual cortex that displayed a sustained negative BOLD response, consistent with several previous studies. Within these negative BOLD regions, we compared patterns of fMRI activity generated by flickering Gabors that were systematically shifted in position. As the Gabors were shifted further from each other, the correlation in the spatial pattern of activity across a population of voxels (such as the population of V1 voxels that displayed a negative BOLD response) decreased significantly. Despite the fact that the BOLD signal was significantly negative (lower than fixation baseline), these regions were able to discriminate objects separated by less than 0.5 deg (at ∼10 deg eccentricity). The results suggest that meaningful, stimulus-specific processing occurs even in regions that display a strong negative BOLD response. INTRODUCTION In functional MRI (fMRI) experiments, the neural response to visual stimulation is inferred from the change in the BOLD (blood oxygenation level-dependent) signal. In a typical experiment, subjects view a stimulus in the test condition and a blank screen in the control condition. When these two conditions are contrasted in data analysis, researchers attribute perceptual and cognitive functions to regions that display a positive BOLD response compared to baseline, since positive BOLD is closely coupled with neuronal activity [1] , [2] . However, researchers routinely discount regions that display a negative BOLD response (a lower level of BOLD response for the stimulus than for the blank screen), because negative BOLD has proven to be much harder to characterize. In this paper, we show that patterns of negative BOLD activity carry meaningful information about stimulus-specific visual processing. Therefore, to understand the neural correlates of visual perception, fMRI studies should consider the negative BOLD signal as informative. Much of the debate over the negative BOLD signal has centered on whether its source is primarily vascular or neuronal. However, neither explanation of the origin of negative BOLD makes strong claims about its meaning . In fact, most research on the negative BOLD signal downplays its relevance to the task or stimulus. Numerous studies have characterized the negative BOLD signal as stimulus-independent, spatially widespread and diffuse, and varying little in position across a variety of tasks [3] , [4] , [5] , [6] . Although a few show some change in the pattern of negative BOLD activity when visual stimulation changes, it is not clear to what extent these changes are precise [7] , [8] , [9] . In this study we use a novel technique to show that patterns of negative BOLD responses, far from being unrelated to the stimulus, are highly informative and stimulus-specific. Our goal was to determine the spatial selectivity of negative BOLD responses. To do this, we presented stimuli in slightly different positions, each of which produced a unique pattern of positive and negative BOLD activity. Within the regions that selectively displayed a negative BOLD response, we cross-correlated patterns of fMRI activity produced by each stimulus. If the information carried in the negative BOLD response is not spatially precise, then there should be no difference in the pattern of negative BOLD activity for objects in slightly different positions. Our results will show that, on the contrary, as the stimuli were shifted further from each other, the correlation in the spatial pattern of activity decreased significantly. The results suggest that meaningful, stimulus-specific processing occurs even in regions that display a strong negative BOLD response. RESULTS The stimuli were four flickering Gabors arranged in one of five locations (see Materials and Methods ; Fig. 1 ). The eccentricity of the peak contrast was identical across all 5 Gabor arrangements (9.05 degrees), but the standard deviation of the contrast envelope was skewed either toward or away from the fovea (by 0.38, 0.19, 0, −0.19, or −0.38 deg relative to the symmetrical Gabor at 9.05 deg; Fig. 1 ). On each trial, subjects reported the magnitude of the Gabor skew (5-alternative forced choice classification task, similar to the method of single stimuli; [10] ). Figure 2 shows the psychophysical results for each subject. With increasing separation between the flickering Gabors, subjects were better able to accurately classify the stimuli (e.g., discriminating between Fig. 1A and 1E is relatively easy). The overall ability varied between subjects, but the trend was consistent across subjects and significant for each subject (least significant log fit to the data was for subject MC, F (1,18) = 9.67, P<0.01). Six of the seven subjects were able to discriminate Gabors separated by 0.19 deg in eccentricity, and all seven subjects were able to discriminate differences of 0.77 deg eccentricity (lowest d′ was 1.2 for subject MC). The precision with which subjects judged Gabor locations is consistent with several previous studies on acuity in the periphery [11] , [12] , [13] , even in absence of references [14] . Further, these psychophysical data confirm previous reports that the method of single stimuli can be used to measure acuity even though subjects must rely on an implicit standard when judging each stimulus [10] , [15] , [16] . A–E. Four flickering Gabors were presented at one of five eccentricities; the standard deviation of each Gabor's contrast envelope was incrementally skewed by ∼0.19 deg toward (A–B) or away (D–E) from the fovea. The Gabors in (E) are skewed away from the Gabors in (A) by 0.77 deg (see Materials and Methods ). While in the scanner, subjects reported which condition they were viewing on each trial (5AFC classification task). The abscissa on the graph shows the difference in the eccentricity between any two of the five conditions (e.g., the difference in skew between Fig. 1A and 1B was 0.19 deg, while the difference between Fig. 1A and 1E was 0.77 deg). The ordinate shows discrimination (d-prime, calculated from the 5AFC classification data [54] ). When two stimulus conditions were similar (e.g., Fig. 1A and 1B ), subjects had difficulty classifying which condition they were viewing, resulting in a lower d-prime. Conditions that were separated by greater eccentricities yielded higher discrimination ability. For all subjects, discrimination improved with an increasing difference in the skew of the envelope. Overall ability varied between subjects, but the

Read the complete text