Evolution of Axis Specification Mechanisms in Jawed Vertebrates: Insights from a Chondrichthyan
Marion Coolen, Tatjana Sauka-Spengler, Delphine Nicolle et al. · 2007
Read Evolution of Axis Specification Mechanisms in Jawed Vertebrates: Insights from a Chondrichthyan by Marion Coolen, Tatjana Sauka-Spengler, Delphine Nicolle et al. (2007) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0000374.txt.
Introduction
Marion Coolen and colleagues used a shark relative to study how body plans evolved, reporting in PLOS ONE in 2007. All jawed vertebrates, from fish to humans, build their bodies along a head-to-tail axis using inherited genetic programs. The team asked how those axis-setting programs changed as jawed vertebrates evolved.
Chondrichthyans, the group that includes sharks and skates, split early from other jawed vertebrates, so their development preserves clues about the ancestral state. Comparing their axis-forming mechanisms with those of other animals shows which parts of the program are ancient and which are new. The work helps explain how a shared body plan diversified across half a billion years.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marion Coolen, Tatjana Sauka-Spengler, Delphine Nicolle et al. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2007 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82 KB |
| LICENSE | Creative Commons Attribution License |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | PLOS ONE |
Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0000374
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evolution of Axis Specification Mechanisms in Jawed Vertebrates: Insights from a Chondrichthyan Authors: Marion Coolen, Tatjana Sauka-Spengler, Delphine Nicolle, Chantal Le-Mentec, Yvan Lallemand, Corinne Da Silva, Jean-Louis Plouhinec, Benoît Robert, Patrick Wincker, De-Li Shi, Sylvie Mazan Published: 2007, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0000374 ABSTRACT The genetic mechanisms that control the establishment of early polarities and their link with embryonic axis specification and patterning seem to substantially diverge across vertebrates. In amphibians and teleosts, the establishment of an early dorso-ventral polarity determines both the site of axis formation and its rostro-caudal orientation. In contrast, amniotes retain a considerable plasticity for their site of axis formation until blastula stages and rely on signals secreted by extraembryonic tissues, which have no clear equivalents in the former, for the establishment of their rostro-caudal pattern. The rationale for these differences remains unknown. Through detailed expression analyses of key development genes in a chondrichthyan, the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula , we have reconstructed the ancestral pattern of axis specification in jawed vertebrates. We show that the dogfish displays compelling similarities with amniotes at blastula and early gastrula stages, including the presence of clear homologs of the hypoblast and extraembryonic ectoderm. In the ancestral state, these territories are specified at opposite poles of an early axis of bilateral symmetry, homologous to the dorso-ventral axis of amphibians or teleosts, and aligned with the later forming embryonic axis, from head to tail. Comparisons with amniotes suggest that a dorsal expansion of extraembryonic ectoderm, resulting in an apparently radial symmetry at late blastula stages, has taken place in their lineage. The synthesis of these results with those of functional analyses in model organisms supports an evolutionary link between the dorso-ventral polarity of amphibians and teleosts and the embryonic-extraembryonic organisation of amniotes. It leads to a general model of axis specification in gnathostomes, which provides a comparative framework for a reassessment of conservations both among vertebrates and with more distant metazoans. INTRODUCTION It is currently clear that the genetic control of development in metazoans relies on a limited number of signalling pathways and broad families of transcription factors, organised into at least partially conserved regulatory networks, which have been repetitively reused and reshaped during evolution in different cellular contexts [1] . The discovery of these conservations had a major impact on the rise of modern embryology, by opening the possibility to transpose the results obtained in a given model organism, such as drosophila, to a much broader range of species, for instance vertebrates. Furthermore, comparisons between distantly related model organisms have shown that even more unexpectedly, similarities are not restricted to the regulatory modules themselves but extend to the developmental processes or the cellular phenotypes that they control [2] , [3] . However, the conservation of the complex sequences of cellular and genetic interactions controlling developmental processes can be difficult to assess, even among relatively closely related species. Different reasons account for this limitation. First, the underlying conservation of developmental processes can be obscured by the use of different experimental approaches, highlighting different aspects of the same phenomena, or by the presence of paralogous genes, resulting in function shuffling [4] , [5] . In the absence of systematic comparative analyses, the gaps in our knowledge of the regulatory networks and successive inductive events that control developmental processes also considerably complicate comparisons between model organisms, certain aspects being particularly obvious in one species but less readily recognisable in another one [6] . Finally, the accumulation during evolution of species- or taxa-specific morphological features, resulting themselves from changes at the molecular level, can make it extremely difficult to define homologies between cell populations and thus establish the link between model organisms on robust bases [7] . The mechanisms which underlie early axis specification in vertebrates provide an illustration of such difficulties. Our current understanding of this process, which mainly relies on studies conducted in the chick, mouse, xenopus and zebrafish, suggests highly divergent mechanisms between amniotes, amphibians and teleosts. The latter two share a number of important characteristics. Both display an early dorso-ventral polarity, which is established upon fertilisation by the relocalisation of maternal determinants towards the dorsal side of the embryo. This results in a complex cascade of inductive events and genetic interactions between the dorsal and ventral sides, which leads to the formation of the organizer and the three germ layers at the onset of gastrulation [reviewed in 8] , [9] . The conservation of these early genetic interactions in amniotes remains an opened question. Until recently, it was generally considered that radial symmetry was only broken at relatively late, pre-gastrulation stages in the chick and mouse, by a coexpression of Vg1 and Wnt8 at the level of the posterior marginal zone (PMZ) in the former [10] , [11] and by the polarised, anterior displacement of an extraembryonic cell population, the anterior visceral endoderm (AVE), in the latter [12] , [13] . This view has recently been challenged in the mouse and it is currently clear that the embryo is endowed with a bilateral symmetry as early as the blastocyst stage [14] – [17] . However, the relationship of this early polarity to the position and antero-posterior orientation of the embryonic axis remains an open question. Furthermore, at least in the chick, this polarity retains a considerable plasticity until pre-gastrulation stages, as shown by experimental manipulations of the blastoderm [18] , [19] , [reviewed in 20] . A further complication for a unifying view of the mechanisms of axis formation in vertebrates comes from the observation that in amniotes, extraembryonic tissues (epiblast but also trophectoderm derivatives in the mouse), play an important part in early antero-posterior patterning [21] – [26] . These tissues have no clear homologues in zebrafish and xenopus, even though candidate AVE equivalents have been proposed [27] – [32] . In order to better understand the link between amniotes, amphibians and teleosts, we have used an evo-devo approach, aimed at the reconstruction of the ancestral molecular mechanisms controlling early axis specification in jawed vertebrates. The rationale for this approach is based on the fact that all species are linked by common descent from the ancestral gnathostome state. A better understanding of this state can therefore help to identify species- or taxa-specific features, which obscure the relationships between current model organisms. In this approach, we chose to focus on a chondrichthyan, the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula . Three main reasons underlay this choice. First, as the sister group of osteichthyans, chondrichthyans provide the closest outgroup to amniotes, amphibians and actinopterygians. This phylogenetic position allows reliable morphological comparisons with vertebrate model organisms, which is important to identify gnathostome primitive characteristics and is less obvious with more distant chordates, such as ascidians or cephalochordates. Similarly, at the molecular level, relatively low sequence divergence rates and the presence of shared orthology classes allow robust phylogenetic reconstructions and the unambiguous identification of orthologues of genes characterised in vertebrate model organisms [33] . Second, embryonic series can be relatively easily obtained starting from early stages and development tables have been established in this species [34] . Finally, the dogfish embryo develops as a broad flat blastoderm lying on a large mass of undivided yolk and displays expanded, distinct, extraembryonic tissues, which can facilitate comparisons with amniotes [34]