Cohesin Is Dispensable for Centromere Cohesion in Human Cells

Laura A. Díaz-Martínez, Juan F. Giménez-Abián, Duncan J. Clarke · 2007

Read Cohesin Is Dispensable for Centromere Cohesion in Human Cells by Laura A. Díaz-Martínez, Juan F. Giménez-Abián, Duncan J. Clarke (2007) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/plos-pone-0000318.txt.

Introduction

Laura A. Díaz-Martínez, Juan F. Giménez-Abián, and Duncan J. Clarke published this chromosome study in PLOS ONE in 2007. Cohesin is the protein ring that holds sister chromosomes together until division. Working in human cells, the authors reach a striking conclusion, stated in the title. Cohesin is dispensable for cohesion at the centromere, the chromosomes' central pinch point.

That result surprised a field that treated cohesin as the glue itself. Something else must help hold centromeres together in human cells. The paper reopened a basic question in cell division and pushed researchers to look for the missing mechanism.

Catalog record

CREATORLaura A. Díaz-Martínez, Juan F. Giménez-Abián, Duncan J. Clarke
YEAR2007
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
LICENSECreative Commons Attribution License
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEPLOS ONE

Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0000318

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cohesin Is Dispensable for Centromere Cohesion in Human Cells Authors: Laura A. Díaz-Martínez, Juan F. Giménez-Abián, Duncan J. Clarke Published: 2007, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0000318 ABSTRACT Proper regulation of the cohesion at the centromeres of human chromosomes is essential for accurate genome transmission. Exactly how cohesion is maintained and is then dissolved in anaphase is not understood. We have investigated the role of the cohesin complex at centromeres in human cells both by depleting cohesin subunits using RNA interference and also by expressing a non-cleavable version of the Rad21 cohesin protein. Rad21 depletion results in aberrant anaphase, during which the sister chromatids separate and segregate in an asynchronous fashion. However, centromere cohesion was maintained before anaphase in Rad21-depleted cells, and the primary constrictions at centromeres were indistinguishable from those in control cells. Expression of non-cleavable Rad21 (NC-Rad21), in which the sites normally cleaved by separase are mutated, resulted in delayed sister chromatid resolution in prophase and prometaphase, and a blockage of chromosome arm separation in anaphase, but did not impede centromere separation. These data indicate that cohesin complexes are dispensable for sister cohesion in early mitosis, yet play an important part in the fidelity of sister separation and segregation during anaphase. Cleavage at the separase-sensitive sites of Rad21 is important for arm separation, but not for centromere separation. INTRODUCTION Faithful chromosome segregation requires that sister DNA molecules remain attached to one another until anaphase. This cohesion allows eukaryotic cells to unambiguously identify chromatids as sisters, attach paired sister chromatids to the mitotic spindle in a bioriented arrangement and to finally partition them among the daughter cells. Thus, without cohesion chromosome segregation would occur randomly in mitotic cells. Two mechanisms contribute to sister chromatid cohesion. Cohesin complexes composed of at least three protein subunits, Rad21/Mcd1/Scc1, Smc1 and Smc3, form a ring-like structure that is thought to encircle DNA [1] . In one model, two cohesin complexes, each trapping one sister DNA molecule, bind to each other to form a cohesive unit [2] . The association alone of cohesin with DNA is not sufficient for cohesion [3] – [5] and a number of other factors that are thought to license or establish cohesin-based cohesion have been described [6] – [14] . These include acetyl-transferases, cohesin binding proteins and, of particular interest, replication fork proteins [14] . Although the steps that accomplish cohesin licensing are yet to be described in detail, the evidence suggests that these mechanisms are biochemically linked to DNA replication. It is the double-helical nature of DNA itself that, when replicated semi-conservatively, produces the second mechanism of sister chromatid cohesion: DNA catenation. Exactly because DNA strands are coiled around each other, their replicative products, the sister DNA molecules, also become physically intertwined [15] . Unlike cohesin, whose licensing is coupled to DNA duplication by biochemical means, DNA catenation is an inevitable outcome of DNA replication because these processes are physically coupled. The strand passage reaction performed by type II DNA topoisomerases [16] , [17] resolves the numerous sister chromatid catenations that arise during S-phase, many being removed before mitosis [18] but some remaining at centromeres and along chromosome arms until the onset of anaphase [19] – [21] . How removal of the catenations is selectively controlled is not understood [22] – [24] . Similar to the step-wise removal of DNA catenations, at least two pools of cohesin are lost from chromosomes as cells traverse mitosis [25] – [27] . Most chromosomal cohesin dissociates in prophase [5] , [27] – [29] , but some cohesin between chromosome arms and at the centromere regions is thought to be protected from removal by the so-called prophase pathway. One factor that appears to be essential for this protection of some of the chromosomal cohesin is hSgo1, a protein found at centromeres in mitosis [30] – [37] . Anaphase initiation in human cells correlates with separase-mediated cleavage of a small pool of Rad21, that would presumably open the cohesin ring, releasing it from the DNA. Furthermore, this cleavage of Rad21 coincides with a sudden lack of detectable Rad21 seen at human centromeres in metaphase, suggesting that these Rad21 molecules, that probably dissociate from centromeres, might be the same molecules cleaved by separase [27] . These studies provided circumstantial evidence linking Rad21 cleavage at centromeres to centromere separation, but provided no direct test of whether this cleavage is a prerequisite for anaphase initiation or centromere separation. Other studies have, however, described more compelling evidence in favor of this hypothesis. Expression of a non-cleavable Rad21 mutant in human cells was observed to cause a failure in anaphase chromatid disjunction, though it was not determined whether this failure to disjoin chromatids was due to remaining arm or centromere cohesion [38] . Other studies have examined MEFs from separase knock-out mice, finding that chromatid disjunction was blocked without separase, but again it was not determined whether chromosome arms or the centromeres were unable to separate [39] , [40] . Depletion of separase by RNAi resulted in similar cut-telophase phenotypes, but in many anaphase-like cells it was the chromosome arms, not the centromere regions, that failed to separate [41] . Based on these studies it remained open to question what are the roles of separase and cohesin in the regulation of centromere separation in human cells. The above studies did indicate, however, that cohesin cleavage might be essential for anaphase chromatid disjunction. Conversely, recent work described the role of cohesin in sister chromatid cohesion [7] , [11] , [42] – [44] . These studies, in human cells and Xenopus egg extracts, used RNA interference (RNAi) or antibodies to selectively deplete Rad21. While some of the observations made were in agreement, an important conclusion stemming from the studies in egg extracts was incongruent with the human cell studies which claimed that cohesin is essential for sister chromatid cohesion. In Xenopus egg extracts, cohesin depletion did not disrupt centromere cohesion unless chromosomes were bioriented on the mitotic spindle, indicating that another cohesive force is capable of preserving centromere cohesion as long as spindle tension is absent [43] . Here we report that cohesin is dispensable for sister centromere association in human cells. Similar to the findings in Xenopus egg extracts, we did not observe loss of centromeric cohesion in prophase or prometaphase cells. Most cells were in fact able to form normal metaphase plates, indicating functional cohesion at the centromeres. Anaphase occurred aberrantly, however, reflecting a similar requirement for cohesin, as seen in egg extracts, for coordinated separation of the sister centromeres upon spindle attachment and congression to the metaphase plate. In cells expressing non-cleavable Rad21, we also observed aberrant anaphases, but it was the separation of chromosome arms that was perturbed, rather than separation of sister centromeres. We conclude that separation of chromosome arms is promoted by Rad21 cleavage and that cohesin-independent cohesive forces maintain cohesion at centromeres until anaphase. RESULTS In order to provide a comprehensive description of phenotypes resulting from cohesin depletion in HeLa cells, we performed experiments that used nine different siRNAs targeted at different regions of Rad21 ( Fig. 1A ) as well as siRNAs specific for Smc3 (see Materials and Methods ). We tested eight different protocols in which either asynchronous cultures were transfected with siRNA,

Read the complete text