Environmental justice and the SDGs: from synergies to gaps and contradictions

Mary Menton, Carlos Larrea, Sara Latorre, Joan Martínez Alier, Mika R. Peck, Leah Temper, Mariana Walter · 2020

Read Environmental justice and the SDGs: from synergies to gaps and contradictions by Mary Menton, Carlos Larrea, Sara Latorre, Joan Martínez Alier, Mika R. Peck, Leah Temper, Mariana Walter (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/openalex-w3016195942.txt.

Introduction

Mary Menton, Carlos Larrea, Sara Latorre, and colleagues published this article in Sustainability Science in 2020. It asks whether the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, or SDGs, truly serve environmental justice. The goals interact through synergies, trade-offs, and outright contradictions, the authors argue.

Justice, they note, sits inside many environmental problems, yet the goals barely speak its language. Mainstream justice frameworks rest on four principles: fair distribution, fair procedure, recognition, and capabilities. The authors push beyond them toward an approach that faces power, colonial history, and the standing of non-human life. They test the goals against cases in food, water, health, climate, energy, and conservation.

Catalog record

CREATORMary Menton, Carlos Larrea, Sara Latorre, Joan Martínez Alier, Mika R. Peck, Leah Temper, Mariana Walter
YEAR2020
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEOpenAlex / Sustainability Science

Source: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-020-00789-8

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sustainability Science (2020) 15:1621–1636 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-020-00789-8 SPECIAL FEATURE: ORIGINAL ARTICLE Exploring Interactions among the Sustainable Development Goals: Case Studies from Three Continents Environmental justice and the SDGs: from synergies to gaps and contradictions Mary Menton1 · Carlos Larrea2 · Sara Latorre3 · Joan Martinez‑Alier4 · Mika Peck1 · Leah Temper5 · Mariana Walter4 Received: 14 January 2019 / Accepted: 19 February 2020 / Published online: 9 April 2020 © The Author(s) 2020 Abstract Through their synergies, trade-offs, and contradictions, the sustainable development goals (SDGs) have the potential to lead to environmental justices and injustices. Yet, environmental justice (EJ), and social justice more broadly, are not currently embedded within the language and spirit of the SDGs. We part from the premise that “many ‘environmental’ problems are, by their very nature, problems of justice” (Lele, Wiley Interdiscip Rev Water 4:e1224, 2017). We review progress in EJ frameworks in recent years, arguing for the need to move beyond a focus on the four principles of mainstream EJ (distribution, procedure, recognition, and capabilities) towards a more intersectional decolonial approach to environmental justice that recognises the indispensability of both humans and non-humans. EJ frameworks, and the SDGs should recognise power dynamics, complex interactions among injustices, and listens to the different ‘senses of justice’ and desires of theorists, activists, and other stakeholder from the Global South. We analyze how EJ frameworks are, or fail to be, incorporated in the SDGs with a focus on the food–water–health nexus (SDG2, 3, 6); climate-energy (SDG7, 13), conservation (SDG14, 15); and poverty and inequality (SDG1, 10). We call attention to the ‘elephant in the room’—the failure to go beyond GDP but instead include economic growth as a goal (SDG8). We argue that sustainable degrowth and intersectional decolonial environmental justices would create better conditions for the transformative changes needed to reach the broader aim of the SDGs: to leave no one behind. Keywords Injustice · Just sustainability · Environmental justice · Social justice · Intersectionality · Decoloniality Introduction In 2015, the United Nations launched the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, which outlines 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (UN 2015) (Table 1). The Handled by Joseph Alcamo, University of Sussex, United Kingdom. * Mary Menton [email protected] 1 Sussex Sustainability Research Programme, University of Sussex, Brighton, UK 2 Simón Bolívar Andean University, Quito, Ecuador 3 Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Quito, Ecuador 4 Autonomous University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain 5 McGill University, Montreal, Canada SDGs have been the subject of extensive research, political support, and civil society engagement but also critique. Some point out that they are a marked improvement on the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), both in terms of the role of civil society in contributing to their creation and in transitioning from including the environment in only one goal (MDG 7, Environmental Sustainability) to integrating environmental targets into each of the goals (see discussion in Omisore 2018). The SDGs are intended to be more integrated and produce synergies, but the interactions among them also lead to trade-offs. One study of interactions amongst the SDGs, based on a time-series of data reported by countries, found that the number of synergies outweighed the trade-offs (Pradhan et al 2017). Yet, as Nilsson et al (2016) show in their framework for assessing trade-offs and synergies among the SDGs, the magnitude and direction of the interaction can vary between countries, dependent on national circumstances. 13 Vol.:(0123456789) 1622 Table 1 Sustainable development goals SDG 1: No poverty SDG 2: Zero hunger SDG 3: Good health and well-being SDG 4: Quality education SDG 5: Gender equality SDG 6: Clean water and sanitation SDG 7: Affordable and clean energy SDG 8: Decent work and economic growth SDG 9: Industry, innovation, and infrastructure SDG 10: Reduced inequality SDG 11: Sustainable cities and communities SDG 12: Responsible consumption and production SDG 13: Climate action SDG 14: Life below water SDG 15: Life on land SDG 16: Peace, justice, and strong institutions SDG 17: Partnerships to achieve the goals The SDG framework has been questioned by many (Washington 2015; Kopnina 2016). In his discussion of the fallacies of the SDGs, Easterley (2015) argues that the inclusion of weak language and “escape clauses” creates a situation in which the only thing that all the authors could agree on “was that the SDGs did not actually bind them to anything” (p 323). In many instances, the SDGs fail to combat the global economic and geopolitical systems that create gender and other injustices in the first place (O’Manique and Fourie 2016; Kopnina 2016). Although the 2030 Agenda document (Transforming Our World—TOW) speaks of transformation, we argue that it will not be possible to achieve a "win win" when the very systems which create poverty, hunger, inequalities, and unsustainable development are upheld. These win-wins are not achievable against a sustainable imaginary, given the oxymoron of ‘sustainable growth’ (Bartlett 1994). As O’Neill et al. (2018) found: no countries currently meet all the needs of its populations at globally sustainable levels of resource use. As global population increases, the tendency to overshoot these boundaries will increase if rates of consumption are not reduced. The Sustainable Development Index created by Hickel (2020) evaluates the environmental sustainability of the production and consumption models of different countries. Many of those furthest along towards meeting the SDGs (e.g., Norway, UK) are amongst the worst in environmental sustainability. As such, there are in fact many potential contradictions between the SDGs and environmental justice (EJ) and the human right to a healthy environment. States have the legal obligation to protect against violations of the human right to a healthy environment (Knox 13 Sustainability Science (2020) 15:1621–1636 and Pejan 2018), and human rights violations arising from climate change (Knox 2009). In light of recent rulings by human rights tribunals that assert States’ obligations to protect human rights that are compromised by environmental harm, Knox (2015) found that the language of the SDGs was “neither concrete nor closely linked” to these obligations. These environmental human rights are closely linked to EJ, particularly in the Global South (Adeola 2000; Agyeman et al. 2002). Although some authors point to philosophical problems underlying the human rights paradigm (Mutua 2013; Barreto 2014) and particularly related to the link between human rights and EJ (Woods 2006), the embeddedness of human rights within international policy arenas could provide impetus in support of EJ which could improve justice outcomes for both humans and non-humans. In seeking the protection of environmental rights, progress has also been made towards recognising the rights of nature and protecting non-human species. For example, Colombia’s Supreme Court recently recognised the rights of the Amazon River ecosystem (STC4360-2018). Ecocide, the large-scale and systematic destruction of nature, has been proposed for inclusion as criminal offense in international criminal courts (Higgins 2012). We do not assume that ‘sustainable development’ and ‘environmental justice’ are synonyms given that they are concepts that arise from different schools of thought with priorities that are not always consistent. While sustainability often focuses on policy-making at multiple scales aimed at intergenerational equity (protecting the needs of future generations), EJ has tended to focus on local, present-day policies and power asymmetries that disproportionately burden particular groups (Agyeman et al 2002). Sustainability agendas have arisen from top-down policy processes, whereas

Read the complete text