Theses on Feuerbach
Karl Marx (Austin Lewis, trans.) · 1903
Read Theses on Feuerbach by Karl Marx (Austin Lewis, trans.) (1903) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/marx-theses-feuerbach-1903.txt.
Introduction
In a Brussels notebook in spring 1845, Marx jotted eleven short theses on the philosopher Feuerbach. Austin Lewis translated them for the 1903 Kerr edition of Engels's book on Feuerbach. The theses run to barely a few pages. Their last line became one of the most quoted sentences in modern thought.
Philosophers, Marx writes, have only interpreted the world; the point is to change it. The other theses attack passive views of human nature and knowledge. Truth, for Marx, proves itself in practice, not in thought alone. These notes mark the birth of his mature outlook. Readers can cross them in minutes and ponder them for years.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Karl Marx (Austin Lewis, trans.) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1903 |
| COLLECTION | BOOKS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 4839 |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Project Gutenberg |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Theses on Feuerbach
Karl Marx (Austin Lewis, trans.) (1903)
========================================================================
PROVENANCE NOTE (Tower of Babel staging): Karl Marx's 'Theses on Feuerbach' (written Brussels, spring 1845) in Austin Lewis's English translation, as the appendix ('Marx on Feuerbach') to the 1903 Charles H. Kerr & Company edition of Engels's Feuerbach: The Roots of the Socialist Philosophy. Sourced from the Project Gutenberg proofread transcription (ebook 27814) of that edition. This 1903 translation is in the public domain.
========================================================================
APPENDIX.
MARX ON FEUERBACH.
(_Jotted down in Brussels in the spring of 1845._)
I.
The chief lack of all materialistic philosophy up to the present,
including that of Feuerbach, is that the thing, the reality, sensation
is only conceived of under the form of the object which is presented to
the eye, but not as human sense-activity, "praxis," not subjectively. It
therefore came about that the active side in opposition to materialism
was developed from idealism, but only abstractly; this was natural,
since idealism does not recognize real tangible facts as such. Feuerbach
is willing, it is true, to distinguish objects of sensation from objects
existing in thought, but he conceives of human activity itself not as
objective activity. He, therefore, in the "Wesen des Christenthums,"
regards only theoretical activity as generally human, while the "praxis"
is conceived and fixed only in its disgusting form.
II.
The question if objective truth is possible to human thought is not a
theoretical but a practical question. In practice man must prove the
truth, that is the reality and force in his actual thoughts. The dispute
as to the reality or non-reality of thought which separates itself, "the
praxis," is a purely scholastic question.
III.
The materialistic doctrine that men are the products of conditions and
education, different men therefore the products of other conditions and
changed education, forgets that circumstances may be altered by men and
that the educator has himself to be educated. It necessarily happens
therefore that society is divided into two parts, of which one is
elevated above society (Robert Owen for example).
The occurrence simultaneously of a change in conditions and human
activity can only be comprehended and rationally understood as a
revolutionary fact.
IV.
Feuerbach proceeds from a religious self-alienation, the duplication of
the world into a religious, imaginary, and a real world. His work
consists in the discovery of the material foundations of the religious
world. He overlooked the fact that after carrying this to completion the
important matter still remains unaccomplished. The fact that the
material foundation annuls itself and establishes for itself a realm in
the clouds can only be explained from the heterogeneity and
self-contradiction of the material foundation. This itself must first
become understood in its contradictions and so become thoroughly
revolutionized by the elimination of the contradiction. After the
earthly family has been discovered as the secret of the Holy Family, one
must have theoretically criticised and theoretically revolutionised it
beforehand.
V.
Feuerbach, not satisfied with abstract thought, invokes impressions
produced by the senses, but does not comprehend sensation as practical
sensory activities.
VI.
Feuerbach dissolves religion in humanity. But humanity is not an
abstraction dwelling in each individual. In its reality it is the
ensemble of the conditions of society.
Feuerbach, who does not enquire into this fact, is therefore compelled:
1. To abstract religious sentiment from the course of history, to place
it by itself, and to pre-suppose an abstract, isolated, human
individual.
2. Humanity is therefore only comprehended by him as a species, as a
hidden sort of merely natural identity of qualities in which many
individuals are embraced.
VII.
Therefore Feuerbach does not see that religious feeling is itself a
product of society, and that the abstract individual which he analyses
belongs in reality to a certain form of society.
VIII.
The life of society is essentially practical. All the mysteries which
seduce speculative thought into mysticism find their solution in human
practice and in concepts of this practice.
IX.
The highest point to which materialism attains, that is the materialism
which comprehends sensation, not as a practical fact, is the point of
view of the single individual in bourgeois society.
X.
The standpoint of the old materialism is "bourgeois" society; the
standpoint of the new, human society, or associated humanity.
XI.
Philosophers have only interpreted the world differently, but the point