CAUTION () (Jewish Encyclopedia article)

Executive Committee of the Editorial Board., S. Mendelsohn · 1906

Read CAUTION () (Jewish Encyclopedia article) by Executive Committee of the Editorial Board., S. Mendelsohn (1906) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/jewish-encyclopedia-1906-caution-4158.txt.

Introduction

Caution is the warning given to witnesses before they testify. Neither Bible law nor rabbinical law asks a witness to confirm testimony by oath. Jewish jurists held that a man who would lie without an oath would also lie with one. So an oath adds nothing, and a warning takes its place.

In criminal cases, witnesses are first told to speak only of what they saw themselves. They are warned against guesswork and hearsay, and told to expect close questioning. The Mishnah's formal warning then stresses the weight of the act. In civil suits, falsehood costs money, which can be repaid. In criminal cases, the blood of the victim and of his unborn offspring falls on the false witness. Yet honest witnesses must still speak, since letting the guilty escape harms the innocent.

Catalog record

CREATORExecutive Committee of the Editorial Board., S. Mendelsohn
YEAR1906
COLLECTIONREFERENCE
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE3 KB
LICENSEPUBLIC_DOMAIN
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEJewishEncyclopedia.com — Jewish Encyclopedia (1906)

Source: https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/4158-x

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Warning given to witnesses before testimony. Neither Biblical nor rabbinical law requires a witness to confirm his testimony by an oath. Jewish casuists are of opinion that the witness who would not tell the truth without an oath would not scruple to depose a falsehood with an oath (Tosef., Ḳid. 43b, s.v. "Hashta"; compare Josephus, "B. J." ii. 8, § 6).

Instead of an oath, rabbinical law prescribes in criminal cases a preliminary caution or admonition, in the course of which the witnesses are exhorted to testify to such matters only as have come under their personal observation, and are warned not to state anything based on imagination or hearsay. They are told that the court will subject them to a careful examination and a searching cross-examination. Finally, the formal caution laid down in the Mishnah (Sanh. iv. 5; Maimonides, "Yad," Sanh. xii. 3) proceeds as follows:

Responsibilities of Witness.
"Know ye that the responsibilities devolving upon the witness in criminal cases are vastly more serious than those of the witness in civil suits. In civil suits a man makes good the losses sustained through his falsehood, and is forgiven; but in criminal cases the blood of the victim of falsehood and the blood of his possible offspring to the end of time, which is cut off by his undeserved death, fall on the head of the false witness. That such is the case is evident from God's rebuke administered to Cain, who slew his brother (Gen. iv. 10), where it is said, 'The voice of thy brother's bloods cry unto me.' Now, since the Bible says 'Thy brother's bloods ( ), and not 'Thy brother's blood ,' it teaches that Cain was considered guilty of shedding the blood of Abel's possible progeny, as well as that of Abel himself. Also the fact that, at the beginning, God created one man only, should teach thee that whosoever destroys a single innocent life is as guilty as if he had destroyed a whole generation; and that, on the contrary, whosoever saves a single innocent life is as meritorious as if he had saved a whole generation. . . . Say not, however, 'Why should we mix ourselves up in these troubles?' Scripture declares (Lev. v. 1), 'The witness who hath seen or known, and doth not tell it, shall bear his iniquity.' Nor must ye scruple about becoming the instruments of this man's death. Remember the Scriptural maxim (Prov. xi. 10), 'When the wicked perish there is shouting.'"

Object of Warning.
The object of the closing admonition is to remind the honest man of his duty to bear witness even against a person tried for his life, to impress upon him the verity that the escape of the guilty is an injury to the innocent, while the punishment of the wicked is a benefit to the public. Therefore, although the criminal's deed can not be undone, no mawkish compassion should prevent the giving of testimony leading to conviction (Deut. xix. 13; Sifre, l.c. 187); therefore, too, the honest witness must not scruple to testify against the accused, in the event of whose conviction he, the witness, must act as executioner (Deut. xvii. 7; Sifra, Ḳedoshim, viii.; Sifre, Deut. 89). See Capital Punishment , Warning .

Read the complete text