USCYBERCOM After Action Assessments of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY
National Security Archive
Read USCYBERCOM After Action Assessments of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY by National Security Archive in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/govdocs-nsarchive-Briefing_Book_cyber-vault_USCYBERCOM_After_Action_Assessments_of_Operation.txt.
Introduction
Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY was Cyber Command's campaign against ISIS online. In January 2020 the Archive released six USCYBERCOM documents obtained through a freedom of information request. They assess how the operation actually went, including a formal review at 120 days.
The documents run from assessment frameworks to judgments on effectiveness. They reveal unprecedented complexity, plus hard problems in coordination and deconfliction with other operations. After-action records like these are rare in public for cyber warfare. They let readers see a military grading its own first large internet campaign while the lessons were still fresh.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | National Security Archive |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | DECLASSIFIED |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13,249 bytes |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | National Security Archive |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
USCYBERCOM After Action Assessments of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY Published: Jan 21, 2020 | Briefing Book # 693 | Edited by Michael Martelle Operation to counter ISIS internet and media operations considered “most complex offensive cyberspace operation USCYBERCOM has conducted to date” Operation “imposed time and resource costs” on Islamic State propaganda New FOIA documents show challenges in operational synchronization, deconfliction, and inter-agency coordination Washington D.C., January 21, 2020 - Today the National Security Archive is releasing 6 USCYBERCOM documents obtained through FOIA which shed new light on the campaign to counter ISIS in cyberspace. These documents, ranging from a discussion of assessment frameworks to the 120-day assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, reveal the unprecedented complexity of the operation, resulting challenges in coordination and deconfliction, and assessments of effectiveness. Background In August of 2018 the National Security Archive combined FOIA released documents we had received with those from Motherboard to produce an in-depth timeline of the formation of JTF-ARES and the planning behind Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY. These documents represent the first time the US Government has officially acknowledged offensive cyber operations. The mission assigned to JTF-ARES was to counter ISIS actions in cyberspace while Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY specifically targeted ISIS use of social media and internet propaganda. JTF-ARES functions also encompass support to kinetic battlefield operations, a role which remains almost entirely classified. While the documents used in the 2018 timeline went into great depth on the planning process, questions remained as to how the experience impacted broader USCYBERCOM operations. Some clues were released in the following years. In an August 2019 interview with NPR’s Dina Temple-Raston, General Paul Nakasone (Director of the NSA, Commander of USCYBERCOM, and original commander of JTF-ARES) revealed that the counter-ISIS campaign was informing how the US approached conflict in cyberspace. As Nakasone’s commands formulated their response to Russian activity during the 2016 US election, they looked at JTF-ARES and, rather than work through the Joint Force Headquarters-Cyber assigned to support US European Command, elected to form another task force called the Russia Small Group. “So this concept of a task force lives on. A lot of that thinking came from what we were doing in 2016. It's powerful to bring a number of different elements of a team together and be able to form something very rapidly to address a threat.” The counter-ISIS mission also informed how USCYBERCOM operated on a more tactical level. A September 2019 National Security Archive posting revealed internal discussions from late November 2018 spearheaded by the command’s Joint Intelligence Operations Center – Combat Targets Division regarding the applicability of the US Military’s Joint Targeting Doctrine to offensive cyber operations . The briefing slides concluded with a note to “Incorporate C-ISIL [counter-ISIL] lessons learned into doctrine”. General Nakasone’s comments linking JTF-ARES and the Russia Small Group as well as briefing slides connecting the counter-ISIS mission to internal discussions of targeting procedures speak to the significance of JTF-ARES and Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY within the United States’ cyber-warfighting community. This significance is underlined by the decision to authorize a series of interviews with personnel involved with Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY. First, NPR published a feature as a part of its “I’ll Be Seeing You” series titled “How the US Hacked ISIS”, once again by Dina Temple-Raston. The piece relied heavily on a Marine, “Neil”, who came up with the concept for Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY. The popular cyber-security podcast Darknet Diaries then released an episode which also featured a Marine with a nearly identical account of planning the operation, presumably “Neil” this time going by “The Commander”. The NPR feature and Darknet Diaries episode provided details from the American side of the operation, and a subsequent Australian Broadcasting Corporation interview provided further information from the perspective of an operator from a Five Eyes partner. These interviews provide personal, anecdotal evaluations of the operation’s impact, but there had not yet been any public documentation of official assessments or after-action reviews. Today the National Security Archive is releasing 6 USCYBERCOM documents obtained through FOIA which shed new light on Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY. These documents range from a discussion of assessment frameworks on the operation’s date of authorization, November 10, 2016, to the 120-day assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY on April 12, 2017. These documents reveal the unprecedented complexity of the operation, resulting challenges in coordination and deconfliction, and assessments of effectiveness. “The Most Complex Offensive Cyberspace Operation USCYBERCOM Has Conducted to Date” Figure 1: Document 5, USCYBERCOM 30-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, Page 2 Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY was a watershed moment for USCYBERCOM due to an operational scope and complexity which forced evolutions in how the command conducted operations. This fact, which had been alluded to in previously secured documents on targeting, is repeatedly underlined in the USCYBERCOM 30-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY [document 5]. The Operation forced the maturation of processes related to target validation, operational deconfliction, and inter-agency coordination. It also revealed shortcoming’s in data exploitation capabilities. The 120-Day Assessment [document 6] goes into further detail on challenges in exploiting data collected through Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY computer network exploitation. The assessment reveals that a key challenge to exploitation was storage of the data itself, an indication of the operation’s scope relative to USCYBERCOM’s capacity at the time. Figure 2: Document 6, USCYBERCOM 120-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, Page 20 The scope of the operation also challenged existing capabilities for performing Political Military Assessments on time-sensitive targets. This point made in the 30-Day Assessment [document 5] goes on to note that the challenge would need to be addressed in a permanent manner “given the likelihood that USCYBERCOM will be conducting more frequent and widely-scoped operations throughout the global internet infrastructure in the future”. Figure 3: Document 5, USCYBERCOM 30-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, Page 23 Playing with Others Perhaps most importantly to the evolution of USCYBERCOM, Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY exercised the command’s ability to operate at scale while coordinating with combatant commanders, other US agencies, and coalition partners. One challenge reported in the 120-Day Review [document 6] was an extension of problems arising from targeting procedures, particularly in how targets are cleared for engagement. Figure 4: Document 6, USCYBERCOM 120-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, Page 20 When planning a kinetic strike, a commander must complete a formal process before nominating a target for attack, at which point the target is cleared for engagement. JTF-ARES operators, however, had to then complete their own vetting and deconfliction process once the Combatant Command formally designated a target for cyber-attack, presumably making it difficult to engage time-sensitive targets. This challenge was particularly salient due to concurrent combat operations in Mosul, which USCYBERCOM was supporting as well according to the 30-Day Review [document 5]. Figure 5: Document 5, USCYBERCOM 30-Day Assessment of Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY, Page 5 To facilitate rapid action and coalition deconfliction the J3 (Operations Officer) for Operation GLOWING SYMPHONY recommended in a November 22 After Action Review briefing [document 4] adopting procedures to pass “aim points” to coalition partners for engagement. The J3 noted questions as to whether partner deconfliction processes were up to the standards required by USCYBERCOM and how partner nations would then manage deconfliction with other US agencies. Figure 6: