Note on Lyman Kirkpatrick's 'The Real CIA,' December 29, 1972

Unknown

Read Note on Lyman Kirkpatrick's 'The Real CIA,' December 29, 1972 by Unknown in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/govdocs-archive_org-nsia-CIAKirkpatrickLymonBJr_CIA_Kirkpatr.txt.

Introduction

Lyman Kirkpatrick had been the CIA's inspector general, and his book The Real CIA was an insider's defense of the agency. This note, dated December 29, 1972, was written by a reader who was not persuaded, and who did not sign the critique.

The note attacks Kirkpatrick's picture of the agency, taking up his claim about its real purpose being a state of perpetual self-reorganization, and treating the book as an apologia. Marginal warfare like this filled the files of the intelligence debate: readers grading the insiders' memoirs line by line. The single note is preserved as a specimen of that argument.

Catalog record

CREATORUnknown
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE5,023 bytes
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Lyman Mrkpa trick Bay Pigs HW 12/29/72

In one of the parts of COUP that had to bo cut out of F-U, I refer to ids book, "The
AL oal Cia", saying at long last we -Jiew the real purposes of the CIa, to reorganise itself.

And how fortunate it was that each successding director was more brilliant tlian those who
proceeded liiu in effective more magnii'icent reorganization. There is nothing else "the
^eal CIa" ever did, according to K.

1 found myself wondering in reading it is ho were rational, and before the end I had
the sane question a out his editor and publisher. Unless they considered anything pro-
CIA save and anything on it would sell enough to pay its cost. Or were subsidized. The
USIA alono could nake it break oven.

The whole speech at the Newport R.l. Naval War College was rubbish, a3 reported by
Jeremiah Q , Leary via the 4 *imeo service, i3— I 12/13/72 O'L. is a Btor staffer and the
story carries a Washington dateline, not Newport.

Becausseoof the late hour. I'll quote and make feu com onts (for me, anyway!)

"...2iser to have trained tho invasion force inside the United States to preserve the
security of the anti-Castro operation." absolute nonsense, liade no diffei-ence where if the
recruits were Cubans. All their families ould have known, none could keep secrets, and
Castro had all the anti-Casrro groups well penetrated. I tliink ho used then regularly to
plant what he wanted believed in the USgovernment. The problem had nothing to do with tlxe
fact of the operation being known in advance. The CIa was worst of all in tills. K con-
veniently forgets those B25s that landed in Florida with an untenable cover story, well
pointed, and that seems to have been an indiapensible part of the CIA plan. **unt et al.

K:"If the President (sic) make the policy to get rid of Castro. • .Of course, I am
being critical of the President (Kennedy) ... " Parens, caps in original. Now if there is
one thing that crooked bastard knows it is that this was NOT Kennedy's decision, that it
was well within the Lisenhower administration, ana nobody ever told JFK f the whole truth.

"3 a hould be at a much lower level of government than the president s of fice"0' Leary's
words. The only time it got there is when the CIa took it upon itself to get the UB armed
forces openly involved \fithout ever taiJLng it up with tho President, and what the hell was
he to do, let the CIa be President?

Blame belongs on the CIa # not the military, where he says JFK placed it. I think JFK
took tho blano rather dramatically and personally. However, the military was given a choice
of two plana and did not disapprove ei ther. I tliink they gave sort of approval to both,
and both were Insane. Blame for more than tho failure belongs on the CIA. Blame for desi/mng
a failure belongs to both th-.; CIA and tho military. They both wanted to use that failure to
get us involved in an invasion to throw Castro out. There is whore JFK bridled. The astounding
think is that K spalls thi3 out and nobody caught it:"... the President never roallyuXdeiw
stood that this proposal entailed a military operation in the true sense of the word."

No aasualt force, even if a good one, of a mere 1,500 fits thi3 description, ijid thero
never was any concept tiiat they'd all be infiltrators. What tho holl did they set up the
CRC for? The \/H knew all about tiiat. it was to lxi the government inexile, then do facto.Not
by infiltration!

Recruiting was under goldfishbowl conditions in Miami and u antral America. Any other
possible way. That j"not even helms wa3 involved is beyond belief, unless hunt was really
chief of operations instead of Helms.

If onJy two documents in op osition were written, the CIa succeeded, ^ts purpose was
to keep it secret from the UB and the government, -^f more had known, there ’would have been
more op .position for failure wa3 built-in

How 1500 men could be recruited from the loudest and longest and freest talking people
in the hemisphere only a K can understand , 30 there is childishness in his saying it should
have been done on a UB base for security. With defections to be supressed, US soldiers to
know, aJU those arounut.io camp to see or the brigade to be prisoners? Rubbish, lovdrade

In today's world such tilings remain vital! And not nor to do stupid things or reprehensible <
or anti-U^mucratic ones is not "the most vital lesson". That is "the failure to secure
accurate intelligence." Protty good for the world's top (ask it!) intelligence agency!

Aims alone they failed. Not bio-degradable!

How CIa survived him or how he survived hio own career provoke wonder. Almost as

Read the complete text