A DNA methylation atlas of normal human cell types.
Loyfer N, Magenheim J, Peretz A, Cann G, Bredno J, Klochendler A, Fox-Fisher I, Shabi-Porat S, Hecht M, Pelet T, Moss J, Drawshy Z, Amini H, Moradi P, Nagaraju S, Bauman D, Shveiky D, Porat S, Dior U, Rivkin G, Or O, Hirshoren N, Carmon E, Pikarsky A, Khalaileh A, Zamir G, Grinbaum R, Abu Gazala M, Mizrahi I, Shussman N, Korach A, Wald O, Izhar U, Erez E, Yutkin V, Samet Y, Rotnemer Golinkin D, Spalding KL, Druid H, Arner P, Shapiro AMJ, Grompe M, Aravanis A, Venn O, Jamshidi A, Shemer R, Dor Y, Glaser B, Kaplan T. · 2023
Read A DNA methylation atlas of normal human cell types. by Loyfer N, Magenheim J, Peretz A, Cann G, Bredno J, Klochendler A, Fox-Fisher I, Shabi-Porat S, Hecht M, Pelet T, Moss J, Drawshy Z, Amini H, Moradi P, Nagaraju S, Bauman D, Shveiky D, Porat S, Dior U, Rivkin G, Or O, Hirshoren N, Carmon E, Pikarsky A, Khalaileh A, Zamir G, Grinbaum R, Abu Gazala M, Mizrahi I, Shussman N, Korach A, Wald O, Izhar U, Erez E, Yutkin V, Samet Y, Rotnemer Golinkin D, Spalding KL, Druid H, Arner P, Shapiro AMJ, Grompe M, Aravanis A, Venn O, Jamshidi A, Shemer R, Dor Y, Glaser B, Kaplan T. (2023) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc9811898.txt.
Introduction
Loyfer and co-authors build a DNA methylation atlas of normal human cell types. Methylation marks help fix each cell type's identity. Old data sets covered only a slice of mark sites. They also leaned on cell lines or mixed tissue samples.
The atlas rests on deep whole-genome sequencing of sorted cells. It spans 39 cell types from 205 healthy tissue samples. Fragment level reads expose thousands of type unique markers. Same type samples from different people matched almost exactly. That shows identity programs shrug off outside disturbance. Clustering of the atlas retraced tissue family trees. Some patterns dated back to embryonic development stages. Unmarked spots unique to a type sat in enhancers. They held binding sites for that tissue's regulators. The atlas is offered for gene regulation studies. It also seeds tissue markers for liquid biopsy tests.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Loyfer N, Magenheim J, Peretz A, Cann G, Bredno J, Klochendler A, Fox-Fisher I, Shabi-Porat S, Hecht M, Pelet T, Moss J, Drawshy Z, Amini H, Moradi P, Nagaraju S, Bauman D, Shveiky D, Porat S, Dior U, Rivkin G, Or O, Hirshoren N, Carmon E, Pikarsky A, Khalaileh A, Zamir G, Grinbaum R, Abu Gazala M, Mizrahi I, Shussman N, Korach A, Wald O, Izhar U, Erez E, Yutkin V, Samet Y, Rotnemer Golinkin D, Spalding KL, Druid H, Arner P, Shapiro AMJ, Grompe M, Aravanis A, Venn O, Jamshidi A, Shemer R, Dor Y, Glaser B, Kaplan T. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2023 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A DNA methylation atlas of normal human cell types By Netanel Loyfer, Judith Magenheim, Ayelet Peretz, Gordon Cann, Joerg Bredno, Agnes Klochendler, Ilana Fox-Fisher, Sapir Shabi-Porat, Merav Hecht, Tsuria Pelet, Joshua Moss, Zeina Drawshy Published in: Nature DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05580-6 ABSTRACT DNA methylation is a fundamental epigenetic mark that governs gene expression and chromatin organization, thus providing a window into cellular identity and developmental processes1. Current datasets typically include only a fraction of methylation sites and are often based either on cell lines that underwent massive changes in culture or on tissues containing unspecified mixtures of cells2–5. Here we describe a human methylome atlas, based on deep whole-genome bisulfite sequencing, allowing fragment-level analysis across thousands of unique markers for 39 cell types sorted from 205 healthy tissue samples. Replicates of the same cell type are more than 99.5% identical, demonstrating the robustness of cell identity programmes to environmental perturbation. Unsupervised clustering of the atlas recapitulates key elements of tissue ontogeny and identifies methylation patterns retained since embryonic development. Loci uniquely unmethylated in an individual cell type often reside in transcriptional enhancers and contain DNA binding sites for tissue-specific transcriptional regulators. Uniquely hypermethylated loci are rare and are enriched for CpG islands, Polycomb targets and CTCF binding sites, suggesting a new role in shaping cell-type-specific chromatin looping. The atlas provides an essential resource for study of gene regulation and disease-associated genetic variants, and a wealth of potential tissue-specific biomarkers for use in liquid biopsies. MAIN Understanding how the same DNA sequence is interpreted differently in different cell types is a fundamental challenge of biology. Gene expression, DNA accessibility and chromatin packaging are well-established essential determinants of cellular phenotype. Underneath these lies DNA methylation, a stable epigenetic mark that underpins the lifelong maintenance of cellular identity. Available human DNA methylation datasets suffer from major limitations. Multiple studies that have characterized methylomes of embryonic development, differentiation, cancer or other settings6–9 have relied on the Illumina BeadChip platforms, which are limited to a predefined subset of 450,000 or 860,000 CpG methylation sites, representing just 3% of around 30 million CpG sites in the human genome10. In addition, by measuring each CpG site independently, such assays overlook coordinated patterns of DNA methylation occurring in blocks, the critical functional units of DNA methylation11,12. Most DNA methylation analyses interrogated primarily bulk tissue, thus precluding the study of minority cell types such as tissue-resident immune cells, fibroblasts or endothelial cells, whereas others analysed cultured cells, which may contain nonphysiological methylation patterns introduced in vitro13. As a partial solution, recent studies used single-cell RNA sequencing data from whole tissues to identify marker genes expressed in specific cell types, then identified specific CpGs whose methylation is anticorrelated with expression. These could be used on array-based methylomes to deconvolute bulk tissue and assess cell type composition or sample purity14,15, but might be insufficiently accurate for identification of rare cellular contributions in liquid biopsies. Some studies of the human methylome did analyse isolated primary cells using whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS), but their scope was limited2,4,5. To overcome these limitations and to accurately characterize the human cell methylome, we performed deep genome-wide sequencing with paired-end, 150 base pair (bp)-long reads at an average sequencing depth of 30× (6.62× or greater) on fluorescent activated cell sorter (FACS)-purified populations of 39 human cell type groups obtained from freshly dissociated adult healthy tissues. We coalesced methylation patterns across the entire genome into blocks of homogeneously methylated CpG sites and used these to study variation in methylation patterns across cell types. Here we identify and characterize genomic regions that are uniquely methylated in a tissue or cell-type-specific manner, provide vignettes of their possible biological function and introduce a fragment-level deconvolution algorithm with applications such as clinical diagnosis based on circulating cell-free DNA methylation. METHYLATION ATLAS OF HUMAN CELL TYPES To portray genome-wide DNA methylation across a variety of cell types, we performed WGBS (150-bp-long paired-end reads to a mean depth of at least 30×) on 205 samples representing 77 primary cell types from 137 consenting donors. These were carefully sorted and mapped to the human genome (hg19, hg38). Average sample purity (that is, proportion of material from desired cell type) was over 90% as determined by flow cytometry, gene expression and DNA methylation analysis. Several samples showed lower purity (for example, colon fibroblasts 78%, smooth muscle cells (SMC) 82%, endothelial cells 86% or adipocytes 87%). Detailed descriptions of sample isolation and purity estimations, as well as sample information, are provided in Supplementary Table 1, Supplementary Figs. 1–3 and Supplementary Information. The cell types analysed (Fig. 1) represent most major human cell types, allowing a composite view of physiological systems (for example, gastrointestinal tract, haematopoietic cells and pancreas), as well as a comparison of similar cell types in different environments (for example, tissue-resident macrophages).Fig. 1Methylation atlas of the adult human body.DNA methylation patterns of 205 methylomes (rows) across 344 CpG sites (columns) are demonstrated in a 18 kb region. Highlighted are regions unmethylated specifically in B cells (blue), neurons (green), thyroid epithelium (yellow) and neurons/oligodendrocytes (oliogodend.) (pink). The 205 methylomes show great similarities between replicates with distinctive changes between cell types in a block-like manner, as shown in Fig. 1. We sought to identify genomic regions differentially methylated in specific cell types to shed light on cell-type-specific biological processes, define cell identity and facilitate development of methylation biomarkers to identify the cellular origin of circulating cfDNA fragments1,11,12,16–21. We developed wgbstools, a computational machine learning suite, to represent, compress, visualize and analyse WGBS data (https://github.com/nloyfer/wgbs_tools). We segmented the genome into 7,104,162 nonoverlapping continuous blocks by identification of change points in DNA methylation patterns across multiple conditions. Each block spans highly correlated CpG sites similarly methylated in each sample but that may covary across cell types (Supplementary Information). We retained 2,783,421 methylation blocks of at least three CpGs with an average length of 544 bp (interquartile range (IQR) = 565 bp) and eight CpGs (IQR = 5 CpGs). Robust analysis of these compact genomic units is more straightforward than individual CpG sites and because of the regional nature of methylation can be viewed as the biological ‘atoms’ of human DNA methylation12. INTERINDIVIDUAL VARIATION IN METHYLATION Methylation patterns were extremely robust across different individuals. For most cell types, 0.5% or less of blocks showed a difference of 50% or more across different donors compared with 4.9% among samples of different cell types (Extended Data Fig. 4). This high similarity in DNA methylation across donors is on a par with the estimated interindividual variability of genomic sequence22. Whereas the definition of 50% is somewhat arbitrary, other thresholds (35–50%) show a similar trend, with 0.5% or less variable blocks. Similar interindividual variation was observed in replicates obtained from different laboratories (Supplementary Table 1). Strikingly, for cell types with n ≥ 3 biological replicates, 195 of 197 samples (99%) showed the highest similarity to another replicate (rather than to another cell type from the same donor). These results demonstrate the reproducibility of preparations but also, in agreement with previous studies6, highlight the fundamental biological phenomenon that DNA methylation is primarily determined by cell lineage and cell-type-specific programmes rather than by genetic or environmental factors. METHYLATION RECORDS DEVELOPMENTAL HISTORY Whereas DNA methylation patterns reflect the functional