DNA methylation GrimAge version 2.

Lu AT, Binder AM, Zhang J, Yan Q, Reiner AP, Cox SR, Corley J, Harris SE, Kuo PL, Moore AZ, Bandinelli S, Stewart JD, Wang C, Hamlat EJ, Epel ES, Schwartz JD, Whitsel EA, Correa A, Ferrucci L, Marioni RE, Horvath S. · 2022

Read DNA methylation GrimAge version 2. by Lu AT, Binder AM, Zhang J, Yan Q, Reiner AP, Cox SR, Corley J, Harris SE, Kuo PL, Moore AZ, Bandinelli S, Stewart JD, Wang C, Hamlat EJ, Epel ES, Schwartz JD, Whitsel EA, Correa A, Ferrucci L, Marioni RE, Horvath S. (2022) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc9792204.txt.

Introduction

Lu and co-authors describe GrimAge version 2, a DNA methylation clock that gauges death and disease risk. The first GrimAge read blood methylation marks to score mortality risk. Version 2 adds two new protein gauges read from the same marks. One tracks an inflammation protein and one tracks blood sugar control.

The clock was trained on people aged 40 to 92 years. The team tested it in 13,399 blood samples across nine cohorts. It beat the first version at predicting death in the tests. Gains held across several racial and ethnic groups. It also tied more strongly to heart disease and lung function. Fatty liver measures from scans lined up with its scores. The clock worked in younger people and saliva samples too. There it tracked signs of metabolic syndrome in the data. The authors present it as a sharper aging risk gauge.

Catalog record

CREATORLu AT, Binder AM, Zhang J, Yan Q, Reiner AP, Cox SR, Corley J, Harris SE, Kuo PL, Moore AZ, Bandinelli S, Stewart JD, Wang C, Hamlat EJ, Epel ES, Schwartz JD, Whitsel EA, Correa A, Ferrucci L, Marioni RE, Horvath S.
YEAR2022
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC9792204

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

DNA methylation GrimAge version 2 By Ake T. Lu, Alexandra M. Binder, Joshua Zhang, Qi Yan, Alex P. Reiner, Simon R. Cox, Janie Corley, Sarah E. Harris, Pei-Lun Kuo, Ann Z. Moore, Stefania Bandinelli, James D. Stewart Published in: Aging (Albany NY) DOI: 10.18632/aging.204434 ABSTRACT We previously described a DNA methylation (DNAm) based biomarker of human mortality risk DNAm GrimAge. Here we describe version 2 of GrimAge (trained on individuals aged between 40 and 92) which leverages two new DNAm based estimators of (log transformed) plasma proteins: high sensitivity C-reactive protein (logCRP) and hemoglobin A1C (logA1C). We evaluate GrimAge2 in 13,399 blood samples across nine study cohorts. After adjustment for age and sex, GrimAge2 outperforms GrimAge in predicting mortality across multiple racial/ethnic groups (meta P=3.6x10-167 versus P=2.6x10-144) and in terms of associations with age related conditions such as coronary heart disease, lung function measurement FEV1 (correlation= -0.31, P=1.1x10-136), computed tomography based measurements of fatty liver disease. We present evidence that GrimAge version 2 also applies to younger individuals and to saliva samples where it tracks markers of metabolic syndrome. DNAm logCRP is positively correlated with morbidity count (P=1.3x10-54). DNAm logA1C is highly associated with type 2 diabetes (P=5.8x10-155). DNAm PAI-1 outperforms the other age-adjusted DNAm biomarkers including GrimAge2 in correlating with triglyceride (cor=0.34, P=9.6x10-267) and visceral fat (cor=0.41, P=4.7x10-41). Overall, we demonstrate that GrimAge version 2 is an attractive epigenetic biomarker of human mortality and morbidity risk. INTRODUCTION We previously established DNA methylation based (DNAm) GrimAge for predicting mortality risk and showed it outperformed several widely-used DNAm biomarkers of aging [1]. While first generation clocks such as the pan tissue clock (Horvath, 2013) [2] and Hannum et al.’s blood based clock [3] estimate chronological age, second generation clocks estimate mortality risk e.g. the mortality risk score (Zhang et al., 2017 [4]), DNAm PhenoAge (Levine et al. [5], 2018), DNAm GrimAge [1] (2019), and longitudinal data based clocks such as DunedinPoAm [6] and Pace of Aging [7]. Comparative studies in epidemiological cohorts show that DNAm GrimAge often outperforms the aforementioned clocks in terms of a) predicting mortality risk and b) associations with age-related conditions research groups ([8–17]). GrimAge has been used to study many conditions including COVID [13], autism [15], major depression disorder [18], post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Here we describe a second version of GrimAge, GrimAge2, and demonstrate that it outperforms the original GrimAge with respect to its strength of association with a host of age-related conditions including mortality risk, computed tomography data, cognitive assessments, lifestyle factors, and applicability to saliva. We validate version 2 of GrimAge in almost 13,400 blood samples across nine human cohorts with participants of Hispanic-, European-, and African ancestries. Review of version 1 of GrimAge The first version of GrimAge was defined as a composite biomarker (weighted linear combination) of seven DNAm surrogates of plasma proteins, a DNAm-based estimator of smoking pack-years, age, and sex. GrimAge relied on the fact that some (but not all) plasma protein levels can be estimated based on cytosine methylation levels. In the following, we denote a DNAm-based surrogate marker by adding the prefix “DNAm” to the respective variable name. To adjust for confounding by chronological age, we define age adjusted measures of DNAm-based variables as the residuals resulting from regressing the DNAm variable on chronological age. For example, we defined the age adjusted version of GrimAge, referred to as age acceleration AgeAccelGrim (in units of year), based on DNAm GrimAge [1]. Thus, a positive (or negative) value of AgeAccelGrim indicates that the DNAm GrimAge is higher (or lower) than expected based on chronological age. We use the same terminology to define AgeAccelGrim2 based on DNAm GrimAge2. DNAm GrimAge was established based on a two-stage approach [1]. We trained and tested the GrimAge using individuals from the Framingham heart study (FHS) Offspring Cohort [19]. In the first stage, we established DNAm surrogates of plasma proteins as well as smoking pack-years (DNAm PACKYRS). In the second stage, we developed a predictor of mortality by regressing time-to-death due to all-cause mortality (dependent variable) on the following covariates: DNAm surrogates selected from the first stage, chronological age (Age) and sex (Female: 1 indicates females, 0 males), and batch effect as needed. RESULTS GrimAge version 2 The first version of DNAm GrimAge was defined as a linear combination of chronological age (Age), an indicator of female sex (Female), and eight DNAm biomarkers including DNAm PACKYRS and seven DNAm proteins that are implicated in kidney function, mitochondria dysfunction, inflammation, etc. (Supplementary Note 1). The 1030 unique CpGs underlying version 1 of GrimAge are proximal to genes which play a role in MHC class II, cytokine-mediated signaling pathway and other gene sets from GO, KEGG and PANTHER [1]. We used the same set of 1030 CpGs to construct version 2 of GrimAge. We randomly split the Framingham Heart Study data into training (n=1833) and test (n=711) data (Methods). The mean age of individuals in the training set and test set was 66 and 67 years, respectively. These participants in the training and test datasets have similar demographic profiles and number of years for follow-up (Table 1). [Table: Overview of the cohorts for validating DNAmGrimAge2.] We started out by developing two new DNAm based estimators of high sensitivity C-reactive protein (CRP) and hemoglobin A1C, respectively. CRP is a widely used biomarker of inflammation while hemoglobin A1C levels are used to assess the short term history of blood glucose levels. To arrive at DNA methylation based surrogates of these plasma proteins, we used two elastic net regression models to predict log-transformed (base e) versions of high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (log CRP) and hemoglobin A1C (log A1C), respectively. Both elastic net regression models used the following candidate covariates: 1030 CpGs, Age and Female. The two elastic net regression models selected 132 CpGs (for log CRP) and 86 CpGs (for log A1C), respectively (Supplementary Table 1). The predicted values resulting from these regression models will be denoted by DNAm logCRP and DNAm logA1C, respectively. The Pearson correlation coefficients between the DNAm variables and their target proteins are biased in the training dataset (Supplementary Figure 1A, 1B) due to overfitting. Our unbiased analysis in the test dataset leads to the following: Pearson correlations r=0.48 for DNAm logCRP and r=0.34 for DNAm logA1C (Supplementary Figure 1C, 1D). To define GrimAge2 we used a Cox regression model to regress time-to-death (due to all-cause mortality) on the following candidate covariates: eleven DNAm-based surrogates of plasma proteins, DNAm PACKYRS, Age, Female (Methods, Supplementary Table 1). We remind the readers that the first version of GrimAge was based on Age, Female, DNAm PACKYRS, and seven DNAm-based proteins: adrenomedullin (ADM), beta-2-microglobulim (B2M), cystatin C (Cystatin C), GDF-15, leptin (Leptin), PAI-1, and tissue inhibitor metalloproteinases 1 (TIMP-1, Supplementary Note 1). Interestingly, the Cox regression model with a elastic net penalty picked up the exactly same seven DNAm proteins, DNAm PACKYRS, as well as the two new biomarkers (DNAm logCRP and DNAm logA1C). Thus, GrimAge2 is based on 12 covariates: 10 DNAm based biomarkers and 2 demographic characteristics: Age, Female (Figure 1). The linear combination of covariates resulting from the elastic net Cox regression model can be interpreted as an estimate of the logarithm of the hazard ratio of mortality.

Read the complete text