The use of co-production, co-design and co-creation to mobilise knowledge in the management of health conditions: a systematic review.

Grindell C, Coates E, Croot L, O'Cathain A. · 2022

Read The use of co-production, co-design and co-creation to mobilise knowledge in the management of health conditions: a systematic review. by Grindell C, Coates E, Croot L, O'Cathain A. (2022) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc9264579.txt.

Introduction

Grindell and co-authors systematically review co-production, co-design, and co-creation to mobilise knowledge in health care. These co approaches aim to close the gap between research and practice. Partners work as equals and all forms of knowledge count. The team searched four databases for studies up to April 2021.

They included 24 international studies, mostly qualitative work, case studies, and protocols. Shared traits were equal partnership, creative problem solving, and repeated prototyping. Authors claimed these steps built shared understanding, trust, and ownership. Such gains could yield services that patients accept and staff use. Yet robust evaluation was scarce, so proof of better health outcomes was lacking. The review offers a framework for doing co work well.

Catalog record

CREATORGrindell C, Coates E, Croot L, O'Cathain A.
YEAR2022
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC9264579

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The use of co-production, co-design and co-creation to mobilise knowledge in the management of health conditions: a systematic review By Cheryl Grindell, Elizabeth Coates, Liz Croot, Alicia O’Cathain Published in: BMC Health Services Research DOI: 10.1186/s12913-022-08079-y ABSTRACT Background Knowledge mobilisation is a term used in healthcare research to describe the process of generating, sharing and using evidence. ‘Co’approaches, such as co-production, co-design and co-creation, have been proposed as a way of overcoming the knowledge to practice gap. There is a need to understand why researchers choose to adopt these approaches, how they achieve knowledge mobilisation in the management of health conditions, and the extent to which knowledge mobilisation is accomplished. Methods Studies that explicitly used the terms co-production, co-design or co-creation to mobilise knowledge in the management of health conditions were included. Web of Science, EMBASE via OvidSP, MEDLINE via OvidSP and CINHAL via EBSCO databases were searched up to April 2021. Quality assessment was carried out using the Joanna Briggs Institute qualitative quality assessment checklist. Pluye and Hong’s seven steps for mixed studies reviews were followed. Data were synthesised using thematic synthesis. Results Twenty four international studies were included. These were qualitative studies, case studies and study protocols. Key aspects of ‘co’approaches were bringing people together as active and equal partners, valuing all types of knowledge, using creative approaches to understand and solve problems, and using iterative prototyping techniques. Authors articulated mechanisms of action that included developing a shared understanding, identifying and meeting needs, giving everyone a voice and sense of ownership, and creating trust and confidence. They believed these mechanisms could produce interventions that were relevant and acceptable to stakeholders, more useable and more likely to be implemented in healthcare. Varied activities were used to promote these mechanisms such as interviews and creative workshops. There appeared to be a lack of robust evaluation of the interventions produced so little evidence in this review that ‘co’approaches improved the management of health conditions. Conclusion Those using ‘co’approaches believed that they could achieve knowledge mobilisation through a number of mechanisms, but there was no evidence that these led to improved health. The framework of key aspects and mechanisms of ‘co’approaches developed here may help researchers to meet the principles of these approaches. There is a need for robust evaluation to identify whether ‘co’approaches produce improved health outcomes. Trial Registration PROSPERO CRD42020187463. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12913-022-08079-y. BACKGROUND The term ‘knowledge mobilisation’ is used in the healthcare literature to describe the active, iterative and collaborative process of creating, sharing and using research evidence [1, 2]. Ideally all forms of knowledge, such as experience, values and beliefs are considered in this process—not just scientific factual knowledge [3, 4]. This is in contrast to the term ‘evidence’ where patients’ voices are considered bottom of the evidence hierarchy [4]. Research and healthcare practice inhabit very different worlds, with contrasting goals and using different languages [4]. A shift from hierarchical models of evidence, that favour scientific/medical knowledge, to other forms where patient voice is more at the forefront has been recommended [4]. This has led to a change from linear, rational approaches to knowledge mobilisation to more disordered, relational, context driven ones [4, 5]. Knowledge mobilisation as a concept remains confusing and is often considered an umbrella term for other forms of knowledge sharing and use such as knowledge translation, exchange and dissemination [3, 5, 6]. These terms are frequently used interchangeably within the literature. Involving patients and clinicians in the generation of new knowledge is considered important to ensure research findings are impactful and to reduce research waste [7, 8]. The need to make public services evidence-based remains of high importance [5] in order to improve the management of health conditions such as cardiovascular disease, osteoarthritis and cancer. Many of these health conditions require long term management that place high burden on healthcare services [9]. Sharing and generating knowledge between patients and clinicians can help improve understanding of living with and treating these conditions. This can positively impact disease progression, burden of care and health outcomes [9]. However involving patients and clinicians in research or service improvement is challenging and sometimes tokenistic [7]. Social hierarchies exist which means not all knowledge is valued and considered equally [10]. Co-creative approaches to knowledge production have been advocated to bridge the knowledge-to-practice gap [5, 8]. There are many different collaborative and participatory methods in the health research and service improvement literature [7], with a multitude of approaches being used. Co-production, co-design and co-creation are common terms; these terms have been summarised as ‘co’approaches [11]. The fundamentals of ‘co’approaches have been described in the literature, for example the UK’s National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) principles for co-production [12]. Despite this, there is little consensus about the type of approaches the three terms describe [11, 13]. Common uses of these terms are: 1) co-production of a research project where researchers, practitioners and the public work together throughout the course of the project [12]; 2) co-creation of new knowledge by academics working alongside other stakeholders [8] and; 3) co-design when developing complex interventions [14]. In practice, the three terms are often used interchangeably and adopted and described inadequately and ambiguously [11, 15]. Many ‘co’approaches do not address the egalitarian and utilitarian values of what is considered ‘genuine’ co-production leading to a crowded landscape of terms and approaches beginning with the word ‘co’ that Williams et al. (2019) have described as ‘cobiquities’ [13]. There is currently a lot of interest in knowledge mobilisation and ‘co’approaches in health, with multiple publications about their use. Several reviews have explored the use of specific co-production, co-design or co-creation processes. A recent review undertook content analysis of the co-creation of knowledge for health interventions aiming to reduce the term’s ambiguity and provide a clear definition [15]. The authors developed a new evidence-based definition of knowledge co-creation but included a number of other ‘co’ terms within this, still leaving the reader to address a confusing landscape of ‘cobiquities’. A rapid review of research co-design in health settings had a specific focus on the planning stages of a research project only [16]. Another review sought to understand the outcomes associated with developing and implementing co-produced interventions in acute healthcare settings [17]. The latter reported findings related to understanding the processes of co-designing a service rather than evaluating outcomes themselves. They found different forms of co-production were reported, often uncritically, with a lack of consistent use of terminology to support this diverse range of participatory approaches [16, 17]. To the authors’ knowledge there has yet to be a systematic review that has specifically explored the use of ‘co’approaches in knowledge mobilisation in the management of health conditions. This systematic review aimed to explore why researchers use ‘co’approaches, how researchers think ‘co’approaches can achieve health improvement, the activities they use, and whether they achieve knowledge mobilisation in the management of health conditions (actual or perceived). METHODS This is a mixed studies systematic review, that is, a comprehensive review and synthesis of a wide range of literature of diverse designs [18]. Mixed studies reviews are useful for understanding complex phenomena such as ‘co’approaches for knowledge mobilisation. Seven standard systematic review steps for mixed studies

Read the complete text