Within-sibship genome-wide association analyses decrease bias in estimates of direct genetic effects.

Howe LJ, Nivard MG, Morris TT, Hansen AF, Rasheed H, Cho Y, Chittoor G, Ahlskog R, Lind PA, Palviainen T, van der Zee MD, Cheesman R, Mangino M, Wang Y, Li S, Klaric L, Ratliff SM, Bielak LF, Nygaard M, Giannelis A, Willoughby EA, Reynolds CA, Balbona JV, Andreassen OA, Ask H, Baras A, Bauer CR, Boomsma DI, Campbell A, Campbell H, Chen Z, Christofidou P, Corfield E, Dahm CC, Dokuru DR, Evans LM, de Geus EJC, Giddaluru S, Gordon SD, Harden KP, Hill WD, Hughes A, Kerr SM, Kim Y, Kweon H, Latvala A, Lawlor DA, Li L, Lin K, Magnus P, Magnusson PKE, Mallard TT, Martikainen P, Mills MC, Njølstad PR, Overton JD, Pedersen NL, Porteous DJ, Reid J, Silventoinen K, Southey MC, Stoltenberg C, Tucker-Drob EM, Wright MJ, Social Science Genetic Association Consortium, Within Family Consortium, Hewitt JK, Keller MC, Stallings MC, Lee JJ, Christensen K, Kardia SLR, Peyser PA, Smith JA, Wilson JF, Hopper JL, Hägg S, Spector TD, Pingault JB, Plomin R, Havdahl A, Bartels M, Martin NG, Oskarsson S, Justice AE, Millwood IY, Hveem K, Naess Ø, Willer CJ, Åsvold BO, Koellinger PD, Kaprio J, Medland SE, Walters RG, Benjamin DJ, Turley P, Evans DM, Davey Smith G, Hayward C, Brumpton B, Hemani G, Davies NM. · 2022

Read Within-sibship genome-wide association analyses decrease bias in estimates of direct genetic effects. by Howe LJ, Nivard MG, Morris TT, Hansen AF, Rasheed H, Cho Y, Chittoor G, Ahlskog R, Lind PA, Palviainen T, van der Zee MD, Cheesman R, Mangino M, Wang Y, Li S, Klaric L, Ratliff SM, Bielak LF, Nygaard M, Giannelis A, Willoughby EA, Reynolds CA, Balbona JV, Andreassen OA, Ask H, Baras A, Bauer CR, Boomsma DI, Campbell A, Campbell H, Chen Z, Christofidou P, Corfield E, Dahm CC, Dokuru DR, Evans LM, de Geus EJC, Giddaluru S, Gordon SD, Harden KP, Hill WD, Hughes A, Kerr SM, Kim Y, Kweon H, Latvala A, Lawlor DA, Li L, Lin K, Magnus P, Magnusson PKE, Mallard TT, Martikainen P, Mills MC, Njølstad PR, Overton JD, Pedersen NL, Porteous DJ, Reid J, Silventoinen K, Southey MC, Stoltenberg C, Tucker-Drob EM, Wright MJ, Social Science Genetic Association Consortium, Within Family Consortium, Hewitt JK, Keller MC, Stallings MC, Lee JJ, Christensen K, Kardia SLR, Peyser PA, Smith JA, Wilson JF, Hopper JL, Hägg S, Spector TD, Pingault JB, Plomin R, Havdahl A, Bartels M, Martin NG, Oskarsson S, Justice AE, Millwood IY, Hveem K, Naess Ø, Willer CJ, Åsvold BO, Koellinger PD, Kaprio J, Medland SE, Walters RG, Benjamin DJ, Turley P, Evans DM, Davey Smith G, Hayward C, Brumpton B, Hemani G, Davies NM. (2022) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc9110300.txt.

Introduction

Howe and co-authors use sibling data to get cleaner estimates of direct genetic effects. Standard genome-wide studies use unrelated people. Their results mix true genetic effects with effects of demography and of relatives. Family-based designs can strip out that extra noise, but large family data sets have been rare.

The team combined data from 178,086 siblings in 19 cohorts. They compared population and within-sibship estimates for 25 traits. Within-sibship effects were smaller for height, schooling, mood, smoking, and several life outcomes. Most molecular traits, like cholesterol, looked much the same either way. The authors also found signs of polygenic adaptation for taller height. The work shows why family data matter for social and health traits.

Catalog record

CREATORHowe LJ, Nivard MG, Morris TT, Hansen AF, Rasheed H, Cho Y, Chittoor G, Ahlskog R, Lind PA, Palviainen T, van der Zee MD, Cheesman R, Mangino M, Wang Y, Li S, Klaric L, Ratliff SM, Bielak LF, Nygaard M, Giannelis A, Willoughby EA, Reynolds CA, Balbona JV, Andreassen OA, Ask H, Baras A, Bauer CR, Boomsma DI, Campbell A, Campbell H, Chen Z, Christofidou P, Corfield E, Dahm CC, Dokuru DR, Evans LM, de Geus EJC, Giddaluru S, Gordon SD, Harden KP, Hill WD, Hughes A, Kerr SM, Kim Y, Kweon H, Latvala A, Lawlor DA, Li L, Lin K, Magnus P, Magnusson PKE, Mallard TT, Martikainen P, Mills MC, Njølstad PR, Overton JD, Pedersen NL, Porteous DJ, Reid J, Silventoinen K, Southey MC, Stoltenberg C, Tucker-Drob EM, Wright MJ, Social Science Genetic Association Consortium, Within Family Consortium, Hewitt JK, Keller MC, Stallings MC, Lee JJ, Christensen K, Kardia SLR, Peyser PA, Smith JA, Wilson JF, Hopper JL, Hägg S, Spector TD, Pingault JB, Plomin R, Havdahl A, Bartels M, Martin NG, Oskarsson S, Justice AE, Millwood IY, Hveem K, Naess Ø, Willer CJ, Åsvold BO, Koellinger PD, Kaprio J, Medland SE, Walters RG, Benjamin DJ, Turley P, Evans DM, Davey Smith G, Hayward C, Brumpton B, Hemani G, Davies NM.
YEAR2022
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC9110300

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Within-sibship genome-wide association analyses decrease bias in estimates of direct genetic effects By Laurence J Howe, Michel G Nivard, Tim T Morris, Ailin F Hansen, Humaira Rasheed, Yoonsu Cho, Geetha Chittoor, Rafael Ahlskog, Penelope A Lind, Teemu Palviainen, Matthijs D van der Zee, Rosa Cheesman Published in: Nature Genetics DOI: 10.1038/s41588-022-01062-7 ABSTRACT Abstract Estimates from genome-wide association studies (GWAS) of unrelated individuals capture effects of inherited variation (direct effects), demography (population stratification, assortative mating) and relatives (indirect genetic effects). Family-based GWAS designs can control for demographic and indirect genetic effects, but large-scale family datasets have been lacking. We combined data from 178,086 siblings from 19 cohorts to generate population (between-family) and within-sibship (within-family) GWAS estimates for 25 phenotypes. Within-sibship GWAS estimates were smaller than population estimates for height, educational attainment, age at first birth, number of children, cognitive ability, depressive symptoms and smoking. Some differences were observed in downstream SNP heritability, genetic correlations and Mendelian randomization analyses. For example, the within-sibship genetic correlation between educational attainment and body mass index attenuated towards zero. In contrast, analyses of most molecular phenotypes (for example, low-density lipoprotein-cholesterol) were generally consistent. We also found within-sibship evidence of polygenic adaptation on taller height. Here, we illustrate the importance of family-based GWAS data for phenotypes influenced by demographic and indirect genetic effects. Subject terms: Population genetics, Genome-wide association studies MAIN GWAS have identified thousands of genetic variants associated with complex phenotypes1,2, typically using samples of non-closely related individuals3. GWAS associations can be interpreted as estimates of direct individual genetic effects, that is, the effect of inheriting a genetic variant (or a correlated variant) on a phenotype4–6. However, there is growing evidence that GWAS associations for some phenotypes estimated from samples of unrelated individuals also capture effects of demography7,8 (assortative mating9–11 and population stratification12) and indirect genetic effects of relatives13–19 (Fig. 1). For example, Lee et al.14 found that within-sibship GWAS estimates for educational attainment variants were around 40% lower than estimates from unrelated individuals, indicating the presence of demographic and indirect genetic effects. These nondirect sources of genetic associations are themselves of interest for estimating parental effects13,18, understanding human mate choice9–11 and genomic prediction14,19. However, they can also impact downstream analyses using GWAS summary data such as biological annotation, heritability estimation20–22, genetic correlations23, Mendelian randomization (MR)7,24,25 and polygenic adaptation tests26–29. [Figure: Demographic and indirect genetic effects.Population stratification: population stratification is defined as the distortion of associations between a genotype and a phenotype when ancestry A influences both genotype G (via differences in allele frequencies) and the phenotype X. Principal components and linear mixed model methods control for ancestry but they may not completely control for fine-scale population structure. Assortative mating: assortative mating is a phenomenon where individuals select a partner based on phenotypic (dis)similarities. For example, tall individuals may prefer a tall partner. Assortative mating can induce correlations between causes of an assorted phenotype in subsequent generations. If a phenotype X is influenced by two independent genetic variants G1 and G2 then assortment on X (represented by effects of X on mate choice M) will induce positive correlations between G1 in parent 1 and G2 in parent 2 and vice versa. Parental transmission will then induce correlations between otherwise independent G1 and G2 in offspring. These correlations can distort genetic association estimates. Indirect genetic effects: indirect genetic effects are effects of relative genotypes (via relative phenotypes and the shared environment) on the index individual’s phenotype. These indirect effects influence population GWAS estimates because relative genotypes are also associated with genotypes of the index individual. Indirect genetic effects of parents on offspring are of most interest because they are likely to be the largest. However, indirect genetic effects of siblings or more distal relatives are also possible.] Within-family genetic association estimates, such as those obtained from samples of siblings, can provide less biased estimates of direct genetic effects because they are unlikely to be affected by demographic and indirect genetic effects of parents7,17,30–34. GWAS using siblings (within-sibship GWAS) (Fig. 2) have been previously limited by available data, but are now feasible by combining well-established family studies with recent large biobanks that incidentally or by design contain thousands of sibships35–39. [Figure: Population GWAS estimate the association between raw genotypes G and phenotypes X.As outlined in Fig. 1, estimates from population GWAS may not fully control for demography (population stratification and assortative mating) and may also capture indirect genetic effects of relatives. For simplicity we use N to represent all sources of associations between G and X that do not relate to direct effects of G. Circles indicate unmeasured variables and squares indicate measured variables. If parental genotypes are known, G can be separated into nonrandom (determined by parental genotypes) and random (relating to segregation at meiosis) components. Within-sibship GWAS include the mean genotype across a sibship (GF) (a proxy for the mean of the paternal and maternal genotypes GP, M) as a covariate to capture associations between G and X relating to parents. The within-sibship estimate is defined as the effect of the random component: that is, the association between family-mean-centered genotype GC (that is, G − GF) and X. Demography and indirect genetic effects of parents (N) will be captured by GF. The association between GC and X will not be influenced by these sources of association but could be affected by indirect effects of the siblings themselves, which are not controlled for.] Here, we report findings from a within-sibship GWAS of 25 phenotypes using data from 178,076 siblings from 19 studies, the largest GWAS conducted within sibships to date (Fig. 3). Our results are broadly consistent with previous studies comparing population and within-sibship genetic effect estimates in smaller sample sizes13,14,19,40. We found that within-sibship meta-analysis GWAS estimates are smaller than population estimates for seven phenotypes (height, educational attainment, age at first birth, number of children, cognitive ability, depressive symptoms and smoking). We show that these differences in GWAS estimates, which are likely to partially reflect demographic and indirect genetic effects, can affect downstream analyses such as estimates of heritability, genetic correlations and MR. However, we find that genetic associations with most clinical phenotypes, such as lipids, are less strongly affected. We found strong evidence of polygenic adaption on taller human height using within-sibship data. Our study illustrates the importance of collecting genome-wide data from families to understand the effects of inherited genetic variation on phenotypes that are affected by assortative mating, population stratification and indirect genetic effects. [Figure: A flowchart of analyses undertaken in this project.We started by performing quality control and running GWAS models in 19 individual cohorts. We then meta-analyzed GWAS data from 18 of these cohorts with European-ancestry individuals. We then used the European meta-analysis data for downstream analyses including LDSC, MR and polygenic adaptation testing. We performed analyses in the China Kadoorie Biobank separately. QC, quality control.] RESULTS Within-sibship and population-based GWAS comparison For GWAS analyses we used data from 178,076 individuals (with one or more genotyped siblings) from 77,832 sibships in 19 studies. Sample sizes for individual phenotypes ranged from 13,375 to 163,748 (median: 82,760, mean: 79,794). More information on sample sizes from individual cohorts and for each phenotype is contained in Supplementary Table 1. We used within-sibship models which use

Read the complete text