Nonlinear control of transcription through enhancer-promoter interactions.
Zuin J, Roth G, Zhan Y, Cramard J, Redolfi J, Piskadlo E, Mach P, Kryzhanovska M, Tihanyi G, Kohler H, Eder M, Leemans C, van Steensel B, Meister P, Smallwood S, Giorgetti L. · 2022
Read Nonlinear control of transcription through enhancer-promoter interactions. by Zuin J, Roth G, Zhan Y, Cramard J, Redolfi J, Piskadlo E, Mach P, Kryzhanovska M, Tihanyi G, Kohler H, Eder M, Leemans C, van Steensel B, Meister P, Smallwood S, Giorgetti L. (2022) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc9021019.txt.
Introduction
Zuin and co-authors probed how enhancers, DNA switches far from genes, control gene output through contact with promoters. The team placed one enhancer at hundreds of positions near a fixed promoter and measured the results. Gene output rose with contact chance, but in a nonlinear way. Models suggest brief contacts feed into slower bursts of gene activity in each cell.
The work also shows why boundary elements can block distant enhancers from reaching their genes. Stronger enhancers raised output and changed how well insulation worked. The authors offer general rules for how chromosome layout shapes long-range gene control.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zuin J, Roth G, Zhan Y, Cramard J, Redolfi J, Piskadlo E, Mach P, Kryzhanovska M, Tihanyi G, Kohler H, Eder M, Leemans C, van Steensel B, Meister P, Smallwood S, Giorgetti L. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2022 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonlinear control of transcription through enhancer–promoter interactions By Jessica Zuin, Gregory Roth, Yinxiu Zhan, Julie Cramard, Josef Redolfi, Ewa Piskadlo, Pia Mach, Mariya Kryzhanovska, Gergely Tihanyi, Hubertus Kohler, Mathias Eder, Christ Leemans Published in: Nature DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-04570-y ABSTRACT Chromosome structure in mammals is thought to regulate transcription by modulating three-dimensional interactions between enhancers and promoters, notably through CTCF-mediated loops and topologically associating domains (TADs)1–4. However, how chromosome interactions are actually translated into transcriptional outputs remains unclear. Here, to address this question, we use an assay to position an enhancer at large numbers of densely spaced chromosomal locations relative to a fixed promoter, and measure promoter output and interactions within a genomic region with minimal regulatory and structural complexity. A quantitative analysis of hundreds of cell lines reveals that the transcriptional effect of an enhancer depends on its contact probabilities with the promoter through a nonlinear relationship. Mathematical modelling suggests that nonlinearity might arise from transient enhancer–promoter interactions being translated into slower promoter bursting dynamics in individual cells, therefore uncoupling the temporal dynamics of interactions from those of transcription. This uncovers a potential mechanism of how distal enhancers act from large genomic distances, and of how topologically associating domain boundaries block distal enhancers. Finally, we show that enhancer strength also determines absolute transcription levels as well as the sensitivity of a promoter to CTCF-mediated transcriptional insulation. Our measurements establish general principles for the context-dependent role of chromosome structure in long-range transcriptional regulation. MAIN Transcriptional control in mammals critically depends on enhancers, which control tissue specificity and developmental timing of many genes5. Enhancers are often located hundreds of kilobases away from target promoters and are thought to control gene expression by interacting with the promoters in the three-dimensional space of the nucleus. Chromosome conformation capture (3C) methods6 revealed that enhancer–promoter interactions predominantly occur within sub-megabase domains known as topologically associating domains (TADs). These mainly arise from nested looping interactions between sites that are bound by the DNA-binding protein CTCF that act as barriers for the loop extrusion activity of cohesin7. TAD boundaries and CTCF loops are thought to favour enhancer–promoter communication within specific genomic regions and disfavour it with respect to surrounding sequences1,3,4,8. However, this view has recently been challenged by reports that disruption of TAD boundaries9,10 or depletion of CTCF and cohesin11,12 do not lead to systematic changes in gene expression, and that some regulatory sequences can act across TAD boundaries13. The manipulation of single CTCF sites has also been reported to result in variable effects on gene expression2,4,10,14–18. The very notion that physical proximity is required for transcriptional regulation has been questioned by the observed lack of correlation between transcription and proximity in single cells19,20. Thus, it is highly debated whether there are indeed general principles that determine how physical interactions enable or prevent enhancer action21. Enhancer–promoter genomic distance might also contribute to transcriptional regulation22,23, but it is unclear whether an enhancer acts uniformly within a TAD24,25, or whether its effect depends on the genomic distance from a promoter23,26. ENHANCER ACTION DEPENDS ON GENOMIC DISTANCE Addressing these questions requires a quantitative understanding of the relationship between transcription and enhancer–promoter interactions in conditions in which confounding effects by additional regulatory and structural interactions are minimized. Here we provide such a description using an experimental assay in which an enhancer is mobilized from an initial location and reinserted at large numbers of genomic positions with respect to a promoter. This enables the measurement of transcription levels as a function of the enhancer location and, therefore, of enhancer–promoter contact frequencies (Fig. 1a). Specifically, we generated mouse embryonic stem (mES) cells carrying a transgene in which a promoter drives the expression of enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP). The eGFP transcript is split in two by a piggyBac transposon containing the cognate enhancer of the promoter (Fig. 1b). After expression of the PBase transposase, the transposon is excised and reintegrated randomly into the genome, but preferentially in the vicinity of the initial site27. Excision leads to reconstitution of functional eGFP of which the expression is used to isolate clonal cell lines by sorting single eGFP+ cells (Fig. 1c, d). This enables the rapid generation of hundreds of cell lines, each with the enhancer in a distinct genomic position. Enhancer position and eGFP expression are then determined in every cell line (Fig. 1d).Fig. 1Enhancer action depends on the genomic distance from the promoter and is constrained by TAD boundaries.a, Mobilization of an enhancer around its target promoter to measure transcription as a function of their genomic distance. b, Schematic of the transgene: a promoter drives transcription of an eGFP gene split by a piggyBac-enhancer cassette. ITR, inverted terminal repeats. c, After expression of PBase, the piggyBac-enhancer cassette is excised and randomly reinserted, occasionally leading to eGFP expression. d, Sorting of single eGFP+ cells results in cell lines in which the enhancer drives transcription from a single position. Splinkerette PCR and flow cytometry analysis are used to determine the enhancer position and promoter expression levels. e, Capture-C (6.4 kb resolution) analysis and genomic datasets in mES cells across 2.6 Mb centred around the selected TAD with both of the internal CTCF motifs deleted (dashed squares; ΔΔCTCF, double CTCF site deletion ). The dashed line indicates the position of the future insertion of the transgene carrying the Sox2 promoter and SCR. A, active; N, neutral; R, repressive; Chr, chromosome. f, Representative flow cytometry profiles from founder mES cells, a promoter-only control cell line and eGFP+ cell lines with mobilized SCR. The light blue line indicates the mean eGFP levels in the promoter-only line. The numbers show the median eGFP intensities. AU, arbitrary units. g, eGFP levels in individual eGFP+ cell lines over cell passages. The numbers show the median eGFP values. h, Normalized mean eGFP intensities in individual eGFP+ cell lines as a function of SCR genomic position. The red dots are data from 135 individual cell lines; data are mean ± s.d. n = 3 measurements on different days. The black dots show the average values within equally spaced 20 kb bins. The dashed red line shows the spline interpolation of average values. Mean mRNA numbers were inferred using smRNA-FISH calibration (Extended Data Fig. 1h). The light blue area shows the interval between the mean ± s.d. of eGFP levels in three promoter-only cell lines. i, Data as in h, colour-coded according to SCR genomic orientation. To minimize confounding effects, we integrated the transgene within a 560 kb TAD on chromosome 15 carrying minimal regulatory and structural complexity. This TAD does not contain expressed genes or active enhancers, is mostly composed of ‘neutral’ chromatin28 except for a repressive ~80 kb region at its 3′ side (Extended Data Fig. 1a), and displays minimal structure mediated by two internal forward CTCF sites (Extended Data Fig. 1a, b). To further decrease the structural complexity, we deleted the two internal CTCF sites. This led to the loss of the associated loops (Extended Data Fig. 1c) and resulted in a simple homogeneous internal structure, as revealed by capture-C with tiled oligonucleotides spanning 2.9 Mb around the transgene (Fig. 1e and Extended Data Fig. 1c). We first heterozygously inserted a single copy (Extended Data Fig. 1e) of a version of the transgene carrying