Understanding and applying the RE-AIM framework: Clarifications and resources.

Holtrop JS, Estabrooks PA, Gaglio B, Harden SM, Kessler RS, King DK, Kwan BM, Ory MG, Rabin BA, Shelton RC, Glasgow RE. · 2021

Read Understanding and applying the RE-AIM framework: Clarifications and resources. by Holtrop JS, Estabrooks PA, Gaglio B, Harden SM, Kessler RS, King DK, Kwan BM, Ory MG, Rabin BA, Shelton RC, Glasgow RE. (2021) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc8327549.txt.

Introduction

Holtrop and co-authors clarify the RE-AIM framework for implementation research. RE-AIM sorts programmes by Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance. Many frameworks crowd the field, and some change over time.

Users can misread RE-AIM or cite an outdated form. The paper traces how the model evolved. It corrects errors across 13 specific areas. Resources for correct use are gathered in one place. The authors speak from the framework's own team. Clearer use should sharpen how health programmes are judged. Misuse wastes the comparison the framework was built for. Misconceptions are corrected one by one in the text.

Catalog record

CREATORHoltrop JS, Estabrooks PA, Gaglio B, Harden SM, Kessler RS, King DK, Kwan BM, Ory MG, Rabin BA, Shelton RC, Glasgow RE.
YEAR2021
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC8327549

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding and applying the RE-AIM framework: Clarifications and resources By Jodi Summers Holtrop, Paul A Estabrooks, Bridget Gaglio, Samantha M Harden, Rodger S Kessler, Diane K King, Bethany M Kwan, Marcia G Ory, Borsika A Rabin, Rachel C Shelton, Russell E Glasgow Published in: Journal of Clinical and Translational Science DOI: 10.1017/cts.2021.789 ABSTRACT Abstract Introduction: Understanding, categorizing, and using implementation science theories, models, and frameworks is a complex undertaking. The issues involved are even more challenging given the large number of frameworks and that some of them evolve significantly over time. As a consequence, researchers and practitioners may be unintentionally mischaracterizing frameworks or basing actions and conclusions on outdated versions of a framework. Methods: This paper addresses how the RE-AIM (Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance) framework has been described, summarizes how the model has evolved over time, and identifies and corrects several misconceptions. Results: We address 13 specific areas where misconceptions have been noted concerning the use of RE-AIM and summarize current guidance on these issues. We also discuss key changes to RE-AIM over the past 20 years, including the evolution to Pragmatic Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model, and provide resources for potential users to guide application of the framework. Conclusions: RE-AIM and many other theories and frameworks have evolved, been misunderstood, and sometimes been misapplied. To some degree, this is inevitable, but we conclude by suggesting some actions that reviewers, framework developers, and those selecting or applying frameworks can do to prevent or alleviate these problems. Keywords: RE-AIM, implementation science framework, generalization, PRISM, context, adaptation, sustainability INTRODUCTION Implementation science benefits from theories, models, or frameworks (referred to as TMFs), which are used to (a) guide decisions, hypothesis generation, measure selection, and analyses; (b) enhance generalizability; and (c) improve outcomes or at least understanding [1,2]. Use of a TMF has become a criterion for funding implementation science proposals. Given their critical role, TMFs should also evolve over time to reflect research findings and newer applications [3]. Keeping pace with TMFs, as well as operationalizing and applying them, can be challenging [4]. Because there are so many TMFs in implementation science – over 150 in one recent review [5] – and because they differ in type, purpose, and uses, it is helpful to have ways to organize, understand, and help researchers select the most appropriate TMFs for a given purpose [1]. Equally important, when researchers select or describe a TMF, they should review the most current writings and resources, rather than rely solely on the seminal paper or a review, since TMFs evolve as they are applied to different contexts and behaviors. For example, the PARIHS framework was modified, updated, and reintroduced as iPARIHS [6]. This issue is important because as Kislov et al. have articulated, TMFs need to evolve in response to data, new challenges, and changing context, rather than becoming ossified [3]. Given the complexity of the issues involved and magnitude of the literature on TMFs, researchers frequently – and understandably – refer to foundational papers or reviewer characterizations without searching for more recent articles on a TMF. Early categorizations then get perpetuated through implementation science courses, training programs, textbooks, later studies, review sections, and reviews of reviews. Consequently, researchers may not recognize the evolution, refinement, or expansion of TMFs over time as they are adapted, expanded, empirically tested, or applied in new ways, settings, or populations. This has occurred with the RE-AIM framework [7,8]. Often reviews of TMFs put firm boundaries around types of TMFs (e.g., as either explanatory, process, or outcome; can be used only for evaluation vs planning vs improvement). In reality, these boundaries are often blurry, and some TMFs may fit in more than one category. RE-AIM concepts and measures of key constructs have evolved since the initial RE-AIM publication, in line with emerging data and advances in research methods and implementation science more broadly. These issues and resulting misconceptions are discussed below. It is important to make efforts to prevent and reduce confusion concerning the application of TMFs. Explicitly clarifying misconceptions, either because of misunderstanding or evolution of a TMF over time can accelerate the advancement of implementation science. Advancing understanding will reduce unintended consequences such as pigeonholing the application of TMFs, stifling innovation, and negatively impacting investigators. The purposes of this paper are to (1) summarize key ways that RE-AIM has evolved over time and how this relates to misinterpretations; (2) identify specific misconceptions about RE-AIM and provide corrections; (3) identify resources to clear up confusion around use of RE-AIM; and (4) offer recommendations for TMF developers, reviewers, authors, and users of scientific literature to reduce the frequency of or mitigate the impact of TMF misinterpretations. The Evolution of RE-AIM Many TMFs evolve over time both as a result of their expanded use across settings, populations, and topic areas and also to accommodate scientific developments. For example, the Exploration, Preparation, Implementation, Sustainment (EPIS) framework was initially conceptualized in a more linear form [9], but as a result of its application in the international context, it evolved into a more circular model. The RE-AIM framework was conceptualized over 20 years ago to address the well-documented failures and delays in the translation of scientific evidence into practice and policy [10]. RE-AIM has been one of the key TMFs that highlights the importance of external validity (e.g., generalizability) in addition to internal validity, with an emphasis on transparency in reporting across all RE-AIM dimensions [7]. It has been one of the most commonly used planning and evaluation frameworks across the fields of public health, behavioral science, and implementation science [7]. There have been over 700 publications that explicitly use RE-AIM for planning, evaluation (most often), or both. RE-AIM has been applied in a wide range of settings, populations, and health issues across diverse clinical, community, and corporate contexts [7,11,12], including policy and environmental change. RE-AIM dimensions operate and are measured at both the individual level and multiple ecologic levels (most frequently at staff and setting levels in health systems, although it has also often been applied at community and national levels). Its key dimensions are reach and effectiveness (individual level), adoption and implementation (staff, setting, system, or policy/other levels), and maintenance (both individual and staff/setting/system/policy levels) [7]. Table 1 outlines each RE-AIM dimension with a definition, reporting recommendations, and an example. Reviews indicate that all RE-AIM indicators are not always addressed (e.g., adoption and maintenance are less commonly reported) [13,14], and in recent years, there has been greater emphasis on pragmatic application of the framework a priori with stakeholders to determine which dimensions should be prioritized for improvement, which can be excluded, which measured, and how they should be operationalized [7,15,16]. This evolution is discussed in detail in Glasgow et al. [7] and briefly summarized below. [Table: Clarifications of and reporting on RE-AIM dimension] A soon to be published research topic in the journal Frontiers in Public Health, “Use of the RE-AIM Framework: Translating Research to Practice with Novel Applications and Emerging Directions” provides excellent examples and guidance on the wide range of rapidly expanding applications of RE-AIM for planning, adaptation, and evaluation purposes across diverse settings and populations. The source RE-AIM publication by Glasgow et al. [10] introduced the “RE-AIM evaluation model, which emphasizes

Read the complete text