Partisanship, health behavior, and policy attitudes in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Gadarian SK, Goodman SW, Pepinsky TB. · 2021
Read Partisanship, health behavior, and policy attitudes in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. by Gadarian SK, Goodman SW, Pepinsky TB. (2021) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc8026027.txt.
Introduction
Gadarian and co-authors ask how party loyalties shaped American responses in the first weeks of COVID-19. They fielded a survey of 3,000 American adults from March 20–23, 2020. The survey covered 38 health-related behaviors, plus policy views and worries. Party ties were gauged three ways: party identity, planned vote for president, and left-right stance. The team adjusted for many traits of the people and places involved.
Party ties explained gaps across a wide range of behaviors and views. News habits, local rules, and local deaths did not erase the gaps. In a LASSO analysis, a party indicator was the most often chosen predictor of all. The split, the authors conclude, was set from the earliest days. Health behavior in a national crisis already ran along party lines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gadarian SK, Goodman SW, Pepinsky TB. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2021 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Partisanship, health behavior, and policy attitudes in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic By Shana Kushner Gadarian, Sara Wallace Goodman, Thomas B Pepinsky, Noam Lupu Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0249596 ABSTRACT Abstract Objective To study the U.S. public’s health behaviors, attitudes, and policy opinions about COVID-19 in the earliest weeks of the national health crisis (March 20–23, 2020). Method We designed and fielded an original representative survey of 3,000 American adults between March 20–23, 2020 to collect data on a battery of 38 health-related behaviors, government policy preferences on COVID-19 response and worries about the pandemic. We test for partisan differences COVID-19 related policy attitudes and behaviors, measured in three different ways: party affiliation, intended 2020 Presidential vote, and self-placed ideological positioning. Our multivariate approach adjusts for a wide range of individual demographic and geographic characteristics that might confound the relationship between partisanship and health behaviors, attitudes, and preferences. Results We find that partisanship—measured as party identification, support for President Trump, or left-right ideological positioning—explains differences in Americans across a wide range of health behaviors and policy preferences. We find no consistent evidence that controlling for individual news consumption, the local policy environment, and local pandemic-related deaths erases the observed partisan differences in health behaviors, beliefs, and attitudes. In further analyses, we use a LASSO regression approach to select predictors, and find that a partisanship indicator is the most commonly selected predictor across the 38 dependent variables that we study. Conclusion Our analysis of individual self-reported behavior, attitudes, and policy preferences in response to COVID-19 reveals that partisanship played a central role in shaping individual responses in the earliest months of the COVID-19 pandemic. These results indicate that partisan differences in responding to a national public health emergency were entrenched from the earliest days of the pandemic. INTRODUCTION The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has affected nearly every aspect of economic, social and political life in the United States. This public health emergency emerged in a media environment saturated with misinformation, rancorous partisan infighting, and messaging from the President that undermined health experts and undercut national unity [1]. As early as January, the administration downplayed its severity by comparing it to the seasonal flu, asserted that it was under control, and even described COVID-19 in racial terms (“Chinese” or “Wuhan” virus). Administrative missteps created further uncertainty, revealing severe mismanagement from the federal government and the Centers from the Disease Control (CDC), most prominently in the lack of nationwide test availability and reversing recommendations on face masking. And, differences in mitigation strategies among state governors exposed the deeply political nature of public health responses [2]. In this conflicting and noisy informational environment, how do individuals interpret a novel public health threat such as COVID-19? Americans, on average, pay little attention to political news [3–5], but in times of high threat, news consumption increases as people seek out steps to mitigate and avoid threats to their physical health and safety [6]. In a public health crisis, mass media provide health information in a very fast-moving environment [7] and mixed or poor health communication can increase risks to public health [8]. When individuals are worried about the risk of diseases and outbreaks directly, they put their trust in medical experts more than political leaders and will undertake behavioral changes to lower their risk as well as support policies framed as increasing their safety [9]. Self-interest does not always motivate political attitudes or decision-making, but in the face of salient threats that are explicitly connected to public policy, people will use their own experiences and interests to guide their attitudes and behaviors [10]. The COVID-19 pandemic is an example of a policy area where we may expect that mediated or direct personal experience with the pandemic would drive respondent to follow steps to keep themselves, their loved ones, and their communities safe in the early stages given its salience and immediate and dramatic policy changes at the state and local level. However, the messages Americans received from the mass media about the coronavirus pandemic varied by media source and what political leaders they trusted. President Donald Trump and conservative media publicly disagreed with public health experts about how serious the coronavirus pandemic and what types of policies can effectively manage it [11], making partisanship a potential component of public responses to the pandemic. Partisanship is among the most powerful forces in American political life, and is particularly meaningful in contexts with conflicting and shifting information. Americans use partisan identification as a guide to help choose political candidates during elections [12], form attitudes [13] and process information [14]. More generally, this happens because partisanship operates as a social identity [15] that is increasingly tied to other important identities [16,17] and even personality type [18]. Finally, increasing partisan polarization on the elite level [19] and the rise of ideologically aligned media [20] combine to make partisans not only prefer their own party members over those in the opposite party [21] but also actively dislike members of the other party [22]. Partisan polarization also affects the public’s evaluations of the president’s performance in health crises as well as their own health behaviors. During the Obama administration, Republicans reported more concern over Ebola than Democrats [23] and Republicans in the public were less likely to get the H1N1 vaccine, particularly if they paid close attention to right wing media sources [24]. The public generally takes cues on what issues to be concerned about from the leaders of their own party [25], and also can use the president’s position to benchmark their own policy preferences [26]. A number of recent behavioral studies use aggregate data to establish correlations between partisanship and social distancing practices during COVID-19 [27–30]. Our individual-level analysis that avoids problems of ecological inference, and contains the rich individual covariates that can isolate partisanship from other factors correlated with it. Although other survey-based analyses have studied individual health behavior in response to COVID-19, ours is unique in two ways: it captures early evidence across the widest range of behaviors and attitudes available at the onset of the pandemic. This is in contrast to work that focuses on partisan affect at a later point in the pandemic [31] or that focuses more narrowly on self-reported social distancing only [32]. Relative to existing individual-level survey research on partisanship and health behavior in the early stages of the US pandemic [28,33], our analysis covers a much wider array of policy responses and attitudes. This manuscript reports results from a novel survey in the first phase of widespread school closures and shelter-in-place policymaking (March 20–23, 2020). This was very early in the pandemic, a week after the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a pandemic at a moment in which Americans were first experiencing lockdown measures, and in which there was great uncertainty about public health recommendations such as mask wearing. We find early, consistent partisan differences among Americans not only in terms of their desired public health and public policy responses, but also on self-reported health behavior, like hand-washing and social distancing practices. In contrast to existing literature on rally-around-the-flag effects in response to national disasters and health crises [34–36], we find that partisan differences emerged early on in the COVID-19