A Roadmap for Genome-Based Phage Taxonomy.
Turner D, Kropinski AM, Adriaenssens EM. · 2021
Read A Roadmap for Genome-Based Phage Taxonomy. by Turner D, Kropinski AM, Adriaenssens EM. (2021) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc8003253.txt.
Introduction
Turner and co-authors present a roadmap for genome-based taxonomy of bacteriophages, the viruses that infect bacteria. Phage classification has been in flux for over four decades. Genome sequencing has piled pressure on the old system, which rested on shape and host. Recent years brought big changes. This paper takes stock and sets the course for what comes next, with rules the field can share.
The roadmap calls for scrapping the old order Caudovirales. Three long-standing families of tailed phages would go with it. In their place, genomes alone would draw the lines. The authors give clear guides for setting species, genus, subfamily, and family ranks. Such rules let new phages be placed the same way by every lab. The paper is a settlement document for a restless field.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Turner D, Kropinski AM, Adriaenssens EM. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2021 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Roadmap for Genome-Based Phage Taxonomy By Dann Turner, Andrew M. Kropinski, Evelien M. Adriaenssens, Terje Dokland Published in: Viruses DOI: 10.3390/v13030506 ABSTRACT Bacteriophage (phage) taxonomy has been in flux since its inception over four decades ago. Genome sequencing has put pressure on the classification system and recent years have seen significant changes to phage taxonomy. Here, we reflect on the state of phage taxonomy and provide a roadmap for the future, including the abolition of the order Caudovirales and the families Myoviridae, Podoviridae, and Siphoviridae. Furthermore, we specify guidelines for the demarcation of species, genus, subfamily and family-level ranks of tailed phage taxonomy. 1. AN ONGOING REVOLUTION IN PHAGE TAXONOMY Historically, phages have been classified according to their morphology, dating from the time before the existence of PCR, sequencing or many of the molecular methods we know today [1,2,3]. For tailed phages, the formal taxonomy was derived from the pioneering classification work of David Bradley (Memorial University, Canada) who classified them into three morphotypes, A (contractile tail), B (long, non-contractile tail), C (short non-contractile tail, based on electron microscopy, a system that was subsequently enhanced by Ackermann and Eisenstark (1974) [4,5]. In 1971, this system was formally adopted by the International Committee on Nomenclature of Viruses (ICNV) but not with the names we are familiar with today. The names Myoviridae, Podoviridae and Siphoviridae were formally accepted by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV) in 1981 and 1984. The order Caudovirales, unifying all tailed phages, was proposed in 1998 by Hans-Wolfgang Ackermann and approved by postal vote. Some of the other phage families have equally long histories with the families Inoviridae, Microviridae, Tectiviridae, Corticoviridae, Plasmaviridae, Leviviridae, and Cystoviridae all formalised by plenary session vote in 1978 (for a history of taxonomy releases see https://talk.ictvonline.org/taxonomy/p/taxonomy_releases, accessed on 5 February 2021). This >40-year-old family-level classification system resulted in the classic textbook figures (Figure 1) on phage taxonomy, easily represented by line drawings. As the age of genomics dawned in the early 2000s, the sequencing of phage genomes revealed a much higher genomic diversity than had previously been considered, especially in bacteriophages belonging to the order Caudovirales, leading to the creation of the first subfamilies within the existing three families Podoviridae [7], Myoviridae [8], and later on Siphoviridae [9]. As the number of phage genomes in databases rose, it quickly became apparent that these three families were not monophyletic and cohesive within a monophyletic order. This paraphyly was illustrated by a number of tools and publications: The Phage Proteomic Tree [10,11], the first phage genome relatedness network representation [12], a bipartite network of shared genes [13], an updated network of shared predicted proteins (vConTACT) [14,15], a composite tool combining gene homologies and gene order (GRAViTy) [16,17], a virus domain orthologous groups approach (VDOG) [18] and a concatenated protein phylogeny of members of the order Caudovirales (CCP77) [19]. Based on this evidence, the ICTV’s Bacterial and Archaeal Viruses Subcommittee started disentangling the web of overlapping and complementary groups of tailed phages by defining new, genome-based families. At the time of writing, three new families of myoviruses have been officially ratified Ackermannviridae [20], Chaseviridae [21], Herelleviridae [22,23]; two for the siphoviruses, Demerecviridae [21], and Drexlerviridae [21], and one of podoviruses, Autographiviridae [21]. If we look beyond the traditional tailed bacteriophages, we are observing a similar increase in genomic diversity in other phage clades, but interestingly, these expansions are mainly driven by metagenome-derived information. Using a combination of sequencing, isolation and imaging methods, a new major lineage of non-tailed dsDNA phages was identified in marine bacteria, named Autolykiviridae [24]. Similarly, isolation of a new ssDNA phage and description of the new family Finnlakeviridae links non-tailed icosahedral ssDNA and dsDNA phages together [25,26]. Major lineages of presumed novel dsDNA tailed phages have also been inferred and isolated based on metagenomic/viromic assemblies, including the crAssphage lineage [27,28,29], Lak megaphage [30], and multiple other lineages of “huge phages” [31]. For the filamentous, ssDNA phages, the family Inoviridae has been split into two families, Inoviridae and Plectroviridae which are grouped together in the order Tubulavirales [21], with a potential further increase with five new families based on the analysis of cryptic inoviruses from bacterial genome datasets [32]. In a similar vein, many additional subfamilies have been proposed in the ssDNA family Microviridae, beyond the existing subfamilies Bullavirinae [9] and Gokushovirinae based on the detection in virome data, i.e. the subfamilies “Alpavirinae” [33], “Pichovirinae” [34], “Stokavirinae” [35], and “Aravirinae” [35]. Recently, computational approaches identified a massive expansion in the number of ssRNA phage genomes of the Leviviridae family, first with 158 [36] then with a further 1k complete and 15k partial genomes [37]. Across all the different lineages of bacteriophages it has become clear that fundamental changes to classification are required in order to address this increasing genomic diversity. 2. THE NEXT STEPS FOR TAILED PHAGE TAXONOMY Within phage taxonomy, the most pressing issue remains the paraphyly of the tailed phage families, because they make up the majority of isolated and metagenomically-inferred viruses, illustrated by a dendrogram of hierarchical relations of dsDNA bacterial and archaeal viruses generated by the GRAViTy pipeline (Figure 2, Figure S1) [16,17] and a network-based representation of shared genes generated by vConTACT2 (Figure S2) [15]. In recent years, the ICTV expanded the taxonomic ranks, previously Species to Order, to include 15 divisions up to Realm to assist with describing higher order relationships between groups of viruses [38,39]. For the tailed phages, this has led to the introduction of the class Caudoviricetes comprising all tailed phages. With the creation of the class, we are now able to abolish the order Caudovirales and the families Myoviridae, Podoviridae, and Siphoviridae, and replace them with monophyletic, genome-based families. We have used the creation of the family Herelleviridae as a case study for the delineation and internal structuring of future new families [22] but have not addressed the wider implications for all tailed phages. 2.1. Step 1: Abolish the Order Caudovirales As a first step we propose to abolish the order Caudovirales with all current members automatically assigned to the class Caudoviricetes. This creates the space to define new orders that group families based on underlying evolutionary relationships. A first example of this is the creation of the order “Crassvirales”, currently under consideration by the ICTV, which groups six families of crAss-like viruses (Taxonomy Proposal 2020.039B, under consideration). 2.2. Step 2: Abolish the Families Myoviridae, Podoviridae and Siphoviridae The removal of the classical phage families will in the first instance create a large number of “unclassified Caudoviricetes” subfamilies and genera. While this is a situation that is unsustainable in the long term, in the short term, little taxonomically important information will be lost. For example, the genera Lederbergvirus and Myxoctovirus are both assigned to the family Podoviridae, but their members share no orthologues (verified by CoreGenes 5.0 (coregenes.ngrok.io, accessed on 5 February 2021) as in [40](CoreGenes 3.5 [41]). Therefore, their position as floating genera in the class Caudoviricetes, is a better representation of their genomic relatedness than grouping them together in the family Podoviridae. We do not suggest that the terms myovirus, podovirus, and siphovirus indicating the phage morphology get lost and suggest to use this terminology in publications and