Studies in Paleopathology XX: Vertebral Lesions in the Sabre-Tooth Resembling the So-Called Myositis Ossificans Progressiva, Compared with Certain Ossifications in the Dinosaurs.
Moodie RL. · 1927
Read Studies in Paleopathology XX: Vertebral Lesions in the Sabre-Tooth Resembling the So-Called Myositis Ossificans Progressiva, Compared with Certain Ossifications in the Dinosaurs. by Moodie RL. (1927) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7942713.txt.
Introduction
Moodie presents a study in paleopathology on bone growths in a fossil sabre-tooth cat. The specimens come from the Pleistocene of California. Lesions on the vertebrae look like a human disease called myositis ossificans progressiva. In that disease, bone forms inside muscle and around its tendons. Moodie compares the fossil lesions with similar bone growths in dinosaurs.
Such changes have long been known under the broad heading of myositis ossificans. The medical writing on it is vast, he notes. He restricts himself to the guiding points of that record. The earliest printed reference he cites dates to 1740, a strange case in a boy's back. The paper then weighs how far the fossil growths match the human pattern. It is a study in reading disease across deep time. The comparison spans cats, dinosaurs, and people.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Moodie RL. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1927 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Studies in Paleopathology XX By Roy L. Moodie Published in: Annals of Medical History STUDIES IN PALEOPATHOLOGY XX VERTEBRAL LESIONS IN THE SABRE-TOOTH, PLEISTOCENE OF CALIFORNIA, RESEMBLING THE SO-CALLED MYOSITIS OSSIFICANS PROGRESSIVA, COMPARED WITH CERTAIN OSSIFICATIONS IN THE DINOSAURS By ROY L. MOODIE, PH.D. CHICAGO, ILLINOIS PATHOLOGICAL changes in or ad- jacent to muscle tissue resulting in the formation of isolated plaques, exostosial growths, or of continuous sheets of bone, usually occurring in the belly of the muscle and involving its tendinous endings, have been known for many years under the general heading of myositis ossificans. The medical literature on the subject is vast, one author in 1918 listing nearly nine closely printed octavo pages of references to one phase of the subject. It will obviously be of no advantage to go into a review of this material, so we will restrict our statements to guiding points in this body of literature. Lewis* has recently summarized the sub- ject in relation to its surgical aspects. A number of other recent writers have contributed to our understanding of the sub- ject. Apparently the earliest printed refer- ence to this condition is that of John Frecke,2 who in 1740 described a most unusual condition in the back of a boy. I have not seen this paper myself but doubtless Frecke’s predecessors knew of the hardening of muscle tissue and may have commented on it. Munchmeyer^ is credited by Krause and Trappe'* with having proposed (1869) the name myositis ossificans progressiva for a phase of this rare disease supposed to involve the muscles in a manner making movement increasingly difli- cult, so that in time, if the patient lived, and many of them did, voluntary move- ment became impossible. One individual had such an involvement of bony growths that all his limbs, neck and back were fixed, and if turned on his back his limbs and head were held fixed by these growths. Rosenstirn^ has published a most elaborate review of 120 cases in which the condition of myositis ossificans progressiva was indi- cated. He gives a bibliography of 200 titles. The prevailing cause of the bony growths was found to be trauma. Magruder** has called attention to and gives a roentgenogram of a curious condi- tion of the great toe, which he and Rosen- stirn^ call microdactylia or brachydactylia, often noted as accompanying myositis ossificans progressiva. There is thought to be an hereditary tendency in the associa- tiori of these conditions but I do not find that this phase of the subject has been critically studied. I thought it would be of great interest and importance in fixing a diagnosis of the condition seen, and to be immediately described, in the sabre-tooth {Smilodon) of the Rancho la Brea, Pleis- tocene of California, if indications of micro- dactylia or brachydactylia or even marked exostoses could be determined in the pha- langes of this animal. But after a careful count, examination and even measurements of several thousand phalangeal elements of this giant cat in the collections of the Los Angeles Museum of History, Science and Art, nothing was ascertained that would even suggest such a condition. There are low and usually blunt exostosial growths adjacent to the articular surfaces of the phalanges but these are all of arthritic origin. Fay and LeCount’’ have studied, in the human, the histological nature of the so- called ossifying myositis and have con- cluded that they were not dealing with altered muscle tissue but with results of osteoblastic activity, due doubtless to trauma of an adjacent bone. The lesions are probably parosteal and the term myo- sitis ossificans is misleading. Carey® has studied an interesting case, giving a full account and histological study of the materials. He is not convinced that the so-called myositis is other than parosteal. In view of the fact that there has never been a discussion of this unusual condition in mammals other than man, and none of the condition in extinct forms, the following discussion and attempted interpretations are offered as a contribution to this phase of pathology. It gives yet another suggestion as to the value of paleopathology in an understanding of the nature of disease. Ossified Tendons Since muscle tissue is so largely composed of sarcous material, the contractile part, and of connective tissue or the adventitious and tendinous part, it will be well to enquire into the nature of the tendinous material which is known to have been preserved in fossil form and to compare its structure with that of the lesions seen in the vertebra of Smilodon. This is important because it seems probable that all examples of myositis ossificans are ossifications of the tendinous, connective tissue, material in which the muscle is involved. I know of no involvement of the sarcous material in cases of myositis. The sarcous elements are, however, capable of preservation in fossil form and this has been often noted. It is well known that tendons, under the eft'ects of undue stress or of age, become ossified. Ossification of tendons in fossil vertebrates is well known although there have been no accounts published dealing with the anatomical and histological nature of these structures. Since ossified tendons occur so often and so abundantly in the ancient dinosaurs and since this subject is of interest to us here I am giving a brief account of their nature. A more extensive account will appear elsewhere. I have asked Mr. Charles Gilmore, Cura- tor of Vertebrate Paleontology, U. S. National Museum, Washington, D. C., to write the following account of the ossified tendons found in dinosaurs. He has also furnished the photographs shown in Figures I and 2. Long, attenuated bony rods, found in certain dinosaurian reptiles, lying along the sides of the neural processes of the vertebrae have long been recognized as ossified tendons. When found undisturbed they extend from forward of the mid-dorsal region backward over the sacrum and down onto the distal half of the tail. Their greatest development both in size and numbers is usually above the sacrum. In the specimen of Cory thesaurus, where the tendons occur in the natural relationships, Brown observes® that they are disposed in two layers, an outer and an inner. In each series the rods of bone lie parallel to one another and both series are diagonal to the axis of the vertebral column. He says: “The tendon bones are clearly the calcified terminal parts of the large, deep-seated, muscles that moved the vertebral column segments in series.” Fig. 6. Lesions Resembling Myositis, a. Dorsal Aspect of a Solid Block ofThreeWertebrae (Lumbars4, 5, 6) of the Sabre-Tooth Showing, on the Left, an Advanced Condition of the Lesion Thought to be Myositis Ossificans Progressiva. The Broken End of This Block Indicates That the Lesion Extended on to, at Least, One Other Vertebra and Possibly Others. This is the Most Extensive Lesion Thus Far Seen. Length, 190 mm. B. A Broad Lesion, Apparently That of Myositis, Unites These Two Lumbar (4, 5) Vertebrae Which are Other- wise Normal. Length, 130 mm. c. A Block of Four Vertebrae (Lumbars 2, 3, 4, 5) Showing Large Lesion of Myositis. This Specimen is Shown IN Figure 5, a, b, c, but This Picture, Taken