The Centenary of Lister (1827-1927): A Tale of Sepsis and Antisepsis.
Ashhurst APC. · 1927
Read The Centenary of Lister (1827-1927): A Tale of Sepsis and Antisepsis. by Ashhurst APC. (1927) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7942704.txt.
Introduction
Ashhurst presents a centenary address on Joseph Lister and the war on wound infection. The address was read in April 1927 at the Lister Centenary Celebration in Philadelphia. Surgery, Ashhurst says, rests on three problems. They are the control of bleeding, the prevention of pain, and the care of wounds. France, America, and Britain each led on one of them, he argues.
Paré stands for the control of bleeding. Morton and Long stand for surgical anaesthesia. Lister stands for the healing of wounds without rot. Ashhurst invites his hearers to travel back before antisepsis dawned. He shows the foul conditions in which surgeons once worked. Patients suffered and died from infections that followed sound operations. Against that past, Lister's clean method shines the brighter. The address is a set piece of surgical history, told with pride.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ashhurst APC. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1927 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Centenary of Lister (1827-1927): A Tale of Sepsis and Antisepsis*Read April 6, 1927, on the occasion of the Lister Centenary Celebration of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia. By Astley Paston Cooper Ashhurst Published in: Annals of Medical History [Headband and Initial from Crooke: A Description of the Body of Man. London, 1631.] ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY Volume IX Fall, 1927 Number 3 THE CENTENARY OF LISTER (1827-1927): A TALE OF SEPSIS AND ANTISEPSIS* By ASTLEY PASTON COOPER ASHHURST, M.D. PHILADELPHIA URGERY holds three fundamen- tal problems: the control of hemorrhage, the prevention of pain, and the care of wounds. France, by the intrepidity of Pare, has con- tributed most to the problem of the control of hemorrhage; America, by the introduc- tion of surgical anesthesia, by Morton and by Long, has done more for the prevention of pain than any nation before or since; and Britain, in the person of Joseph Lister, has shown the way along which surgeons must travel to ensure for their wounds an uninterrupted course of healing. I ask you to journey with me backwards, into the mists and uncertainties of the past *Read April 6, 1927, on the occasion of the Lister Centenary Celebration of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia. of surgery, and to observe and note what were the conditions under which surgeons worked and patients suffered before the dawn of antisepsis. It is a long journey, over rough roads: over roads obstructed by quagmires of putrefaction and morasses of phlegmon; over roads which lead through the stench of hospital gangrene, the miasms of septicemia, the fires of erysipelas, and the chills of pyemia; into the by-paths and impasses of angioleucitis; and across deserts where the shifting sands of empiricism often covered the main route, and caused sur- geons to lose their way. It is a sad journey; and if there were no other prospect at its end, it were best forgotten. There were great surgeons before Lister, just as there were brave men before Aga- memnon. The best of these surgeons pos- sessed a reasonable understanding of the normal processes of healing. They recognized that there was no dressing so suitable to be applied to a fresh wound as the opposite side of the wound from which it had just been severed. They found that in the major- ity of cleanly cut wounds, union “by adhesion,” as it came to be known, could be thus secured if the wound was accurately but not too tightly sutured, after checking all bleeding from its surfaces, so as to prevent the collection of blood clots between its lips; for the presence of bloodclots or any other foreign substance in the depths of a wound not only prevented union by adhe- sion, but actually caused suppuration. They had learned that in deep wounds involving muscle it was difficult to secure union by adhesion, even though the wound had been closed promptly by sutures; because these sutures had a tendency to unite the super- ficial parts of the wound, but to allow its interior to gape, and in this gaping interior blood would collect, putrefaction would occur, suppuration would supervene, and the wound would break down and leave a stinking and a painful sore. It is true that some surgeons, very careful and neat in their dressings, were able to apply compresses so skillfully and to use the roller bandage so intelligently, that they could frequently succeed in keeping the deeper parts of these large wounds in contact, and that in many instances they were able to make such wounds unite by adhesion, where their less skillful or less painstaking and attentive contemporaries never could get such wounds to heal unless left wide open from the first. Though this doctrine of adhesion of wounds appears to have been known in the very earliest days of surgery, the medieval surgeons (if surgeons they could be called) seem to have forgotten it, or to have mis- trusted it. In the almost unending wars by which Europe was rent for hundreds of years after the introduction of gunpowder, the great majority of wounds seen by surgeons were frightful in extent, badly lacerated and contused; such, in truth, as could not be made to heal by adhesion even if promptly reunited by sutures. Even sabre wounds, which were frequent in those days of hand-to-hand fighting, were usually very extensive, and always more or less contused or lacerated; so that all hope of securing union in them seems to have been very quickly abandoned. Thus it was that many surgeons brought back with them into civil life a doctrine of despair; a doc- trine to the effect that wounds, especially gunshot wounds, were poisoned, and on that ' account alone could never be expected to heal unless treated by some method to overcome the poison. As a consequence, in the words of the eloquent John Bell, writing one hundred years ago: They never allowed the lips of a wound to fall together: they filled it with dressings and acrid balsams, or distended it with tents and leaden tubes. They were ingenious in every invention to prevent its sudden healing. . . . Every wound was forced into a painful suppuration, which the surgeons of those days were careful to en- courage in proportion as the wound seemed more inflamed. The quantity of matter was again an argument that the wound needed to be thoroughly purged of its foul humours. The pain of a wound and the waste of substance was very great, under their management: the cure was proportionably slow, the scar was broad and unsightly; but they comforted themselves by saying, that this method alone was sure, and consistent with the rules of art. Those few sur- geons who ventured upon the cure by direct and immediate adhesion, went fearfully and timidly to work. They were in a continual apprehension of ill accidents; and having failed to comply with the canonical or regular method, having neglected to purge the wound, the patient never suffered the slightest alteration of his health, even at the distance of years, which was not imputed, either from malice or ignorance, to this sudden and improvident cure. This was the real origin of the secret dressings; and nothing can be more singular than the various inventions which surgeons, in those days, fell upon, to persuade their patients to let their wounds be easily healed, and, at the same time, protect themselves from blame. As Bell points out, the continual protes- tations by LaMotte (1722) and other good surgeons, of their never having, for the sake of gain, used any tents or injections to pro- tract a cure, suggest to our minds some very unpleasant reflections. For while these authors enter their protest against the general conduct of other surgeons, and show their anxiety to proclaim their own innocence, we cannot but see that they point at some practices and motives of conduct which we fain would not believe. In those days, every flap of skin, instead of being reunited, was cut away; every open wound was dressed as a sore, and every deep one was plugged with a tent, lest it should heal. Tents, syndons,