William Edmonds Horner (1793-1853).

Middleton WS. · 1923

Read William Edmonds Horner (1793-1853). by Middleton WS. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7935139.txt.

Introduction

Middleton presents a biographical essay on William Edmonds Horner, the anatomist who lived from 1793 to 1853. Horner held the chair of anatomy at the University of Pennsylvania. He followed a line of famous holders, from Shippen and Wistar to Physick. The essay was read before a medical history seminar at the University of Wisconsin in 1922.

Beneath a calm surface, Horner fought deep inner turmoil. His private journal records self-reproach and restless doubt. Wealth and honours came fast, yet they gave him little pleasure. The ties of husband and father also failed to settle him. Middleton traces this struggle through the journal entries. The portrait is of a gifted teacher marked by melancholy. It shows how much private pain can hide behind public success in medicine.

Catalog record

CREATORMiddleton WS.
YEAR1923
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7935139

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

William Edmonds Horner (1793-1853)*Read before the Medical History Seminar, University of Wisconsin, 1922. By William Shainline Middleton Published in: Annals of Medical History WILLIAM EDMONDS HORNER* (1793—1853) By WILLIAM SHAINLINE MIDDLETON, M.D. MADISON, WIS. “and melancholy mark’d him for her own” WILLIAM Edmonds Horner, successor to William Shippen, Caspar Wistar, John Sy ng Dorsey and Philip Syng Physick in the chair of anatomy at the University of Pennsylvania, was endowed by nature with a most sensitive soul. Self-accusation and depreciation as- sailed his every thought and action. Although he was torn by mental anguish unknown to more callous humans, his intro- spective struggle left no mark on his calm exterior, but chronicled in a private journal may be found the personal records of his titanic effort for psychologic supremacy. Thus his mental trend may be traced: Why is it that I still find myself discontented, restless, anxious for the future, frequently despond- ing, and often miserable? Why is it that the possession of money does not give me the pleasure expected from it? Why is it that the honors of my profession, which in the rapidity of their coming have placed me before my competitors, are not felt as such, and are become vapid? Why is it, that unquestionably the most precious ties on earth, those of husband and of father, which promised so much of solid comfort and such a rallying point in *Read before the Medical History Seminar, University of Wisconsin, 1922. life, do not excite in me an active sense of enjoy- ment? . . . Discontented with myself and feel- ing no pleasure or satisfaction in the things around me ... I must now make up my mind to move down the current of life on those terms that destiny, my peculiar nature and my parcicular pursuits seem to have imposed unchangeably on me. His despondency led to solitude and his mental despair to a hopeless floundering search for an explanation. Thus he wrote: “Does this feeling depend upon an act of injustice or of turpitude which I may have committed at a former period of life which now, preying upon my conscience, destroys its rest? None such is in my remembrance, but my actions have not been perfect. I have attempted to walk faithfully before men; but have I walked faithfully before God?” Well might Horner have echoed the cry of the psalmist of old: “ For I have eaten ashes like bread, and mingled my drink with weeping, because of Thine indignation and Thy wrath; for Thou hast lifted me up, and cast me down. My days arc like a shadow that declineth; and I am withered like grass.” Withal, Horner maintained so se- rene a presence as to conceal his melan- cholia from his family and his most intimate friends. Apparently in the written page alone this morose spirit found a silent out- let for his morbid depression. Strangely, a man shackled by such a handicapping psychology came to occupy the highest rank among anatomists of his day. But that was before Freud! By a contemporaneous pen a most strik- ing, although not flattering, picture of the physical Horner is drawn: Five feet, seven inches tall, spare, flat-breasted, sharp-shouldered; high cheekbones; eyes, wide apart, almost without any expression, in fact like glass; a thin chin, a mouth merely split across the face, a wide and not high forehead, a large head, covered by a first-rate black wig, a gait studiously slow and thoughtful, a voice like the sound of a cracked pot; neatly dressed, with a well-polished boot; his whole appearance that of an automaton moved carefully by some judicious master—We have Dr. Horner. More complimentary’ biographers write that he was quiet, dignified and sincere. His attitude bred confidence and respect. Unos- tentatious, he abhorred flattery. Polite, he avoided obsequiousness. Of mediocre mental endowment, he nevertheless surpassed his more brilliant confreres through sheer force of will and indomitable purpose. William Edmonds Horner was born in Warrenton, Fauquier County, Virginia, June 3, 1793. His paternal grandfather, Robert Horner, emigrated to Charles County, Maryland, from England. Later he removed to Prince William County, Virginia. Robert Horner married Mrs. Samuel Claggett, the widow of Reverend Samuel Claggett, who was the daughter of Dr. Gustavus Brown, a graduate of Edinburgh. On the side of the paternal grandmother there was a distinguished lineage of physicians and jurists. Robert Horner died young leaving the widow and two sons, Gustavus Brown Horner, who served under Dr. James Tilton in the Revolutionary Forces, and William, father of William Edmonds Horner. William Horner married Mary, daughter of William Edmonds and Elizabeth Blackwell. William Horner was a merchant by occupation. His earliest business connec- tions were with William Hartshorne at Alexandria, Virginia. The latter was the father of Dr. Joseph Hartshorne, an emi- nent physician of Philadelphia. Later William Horner engaged in a mercantile business on the Potomac and ultimately settled in Warrenton. The Horner family was not blessed with worldly goods, but there were many children and the home ties were very close. The religious atmosphere was cultivated by the parents and a high premium was placed on education. The influence of environment on the plasticity of an impressionable child- hood may well be traced in the life of William Edmonds Horner. From the early asso- ciation with his elders, and particularly with his invalid grandmother who lived with the Horners, there arose a certain characteristic mildness and external serenity remarked throughout his life. Slight of build and of frail constitution, the child shrank from the physical en- counters of boyish games. In these pursuits his physical deficiency made him the butt of many pranks. The natural trend of this diversion of youthful energy was into scholastic activity. The young Horner became a veritable bookworm. The welcome release from physical contest into studious pursuits developed a certain tenacity of memory and ripeness of judgment beyond his years. Yet his cautious expression of conclusions and opinions which arose from a development of mental accuracy, led throughout life to a common belief that he suffered from mental inertia. At the age of eleven years he was sent to school under the Reverend Charles O’Neill, a classical scholar, graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, and Oxford University. When this master moved his school to Dumfries, Prince William County in 1805, William Horner followed to continue his studies. To the influence of Reverend O’Neill may be attributed Horner’s knowledge of and continued interest in the classics. On the completion of his course in the academy in 1809, Horner started the study of medicine as a house pupil under the preceptorship of John Spence. In a necro- Iogic notice (1829) over Horner’s initials an interesting picture of this Scotch practi- tioner is drawn. Developing pulmonary tuberculosis shortly before graduating from Edinburgh, Spence came to America and acted as tutor for a family in Dumfries for three years. When this engagement was completed, he began the practice of medi- cine in the same community in 1791. Spence was an early advocate of vaccination and a consistent contributor to medical litera- ture. The honorary degree of doctor of medicine was bestowed on this worthy practitioner by the University of Pennsyl-

Read the complete text