What the American Medical Association Thinks of the Electronic Reactions of Abrams.
Abrams A. · 1923
Read What the American Medical Association Thinks of the Electronic Reactions of Abrams. by Abrams A. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7872713.txt.
Introduction
Abrams presents what the American Medical Association thinks of his electronic reactions method. The item ran in The Dental Register in 1923. It gathers the AMA journal's answers to doctors' queries. The devices named include the oscilloclast and reflexaphore. Inquiries had poured in for some time.
The AMA's view, as printed, was deeply skeptical. His diagnostic claims rested on unproven electric ideas. The journal warned readers against the devices. Abrams reprints the critique under his own name here. The piece is a period record of a famous medical dispute. It shows organized medicine policing the edge of practice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abrams A. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1923 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What the American Medical Association Thinks of the Electronic Reactions of Abrams By Albert Abrams Published in: The Dental Register WHAT THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION THINKS OF THE ELECTRONIC REACTIONS OF ABRAMS. ALBERT ABRAMS, A. M., M. D., LL. D., F. R. M. S. “ SPONDYLOTHERAPY, ” “ELECTRONIC REACTIONS,” THE ‘ ‘ OSCILLOCLAST, ” THE “ELECTROBIOSCOPE,” ETC. For some time The Journal has received inquiries of which the following recent examples are typical. This from an Ohio physician: “Please give me some information concerning Dr. Abrams and his diagnostic and therapeutic devices known as reflexaphore and oscilloclast. If this is published please withhold my name.” A physician in Massachusetts writes: “Can you give me any information concerning Dr. (?) San Francisco, California, who reports himself able to diagnose syphilis from a drop of blood sent him on a blotting paper. He has caused a patient of mine a great deal of needless worry.” And from Rhode Island a physician facetiously in- quires : “I am interested to know of the ‘Reactions of Abrams.’ Have you any information that you can give me in regard to this matter? They apparently do wonderful things in the West.” While a New York physician acknowledges his failure to keep up with the times thus: “To-day I had occasion to see a patient who mentioned having an Abrams’ test for gonorrheal infection of the prostate. He also stated he wished to have Abrams’ treat- ment for the same condition. Could you enlighten me as to what these are ? I thought I had kept myself up to date as to all new tests and treatments in my line; but evidently I have been delinquent.” According to our records, Albert Abrams, A. M., M. D., LL. D., F. R. M. S., was born in San Francisco in 1864. He was graduated in medicine by the University of Heidelberg, Germany, in 1882. Dr. Abrams has written voluminously. In 1910, his book on “Spondylotherapy” (“Physio- Therapy of the Spine”)' was reviewed in The Journal. “Spondylotherapy” is a neologic creation of Dr. Abrams. According to its disciples, it concerns itself “only with the excitation of the functional centers of the spinal cord” and has been called “the science of evoking the reflexes of the body both to diagnose and to cure disease.” In bringing its review of Abrams’ book on “Spondylo- therapy” to a close, The Journal said: “ * * * one wonders whether this is an attempt to explain osteopathy and chiropractic to the understanding of the regular practitioner, or to exploit the very ingenious percussion devices of the author, or whether it is really true that medical men really know practically nothing about the cure of disease through treatment of the spine. Let us hope that it is the latter and that a careful study of this unique volume may open new avenues of therapy hereto- fore undreamed of.” While the review was obviously critical, yet in advertis- ing the book, the publishers picked out part of the closing sentence, omitted the context, and quoted The Journal as having said: “Let us hope that a careful study of this unique volume may open new avenues of therapy heretofore undreamed of.” When this matter was brought to the attention of Dr. Abrams, he replied, “I fail to see any real difference in the two quotations” and “only one * * * with an astigmatic mentality” could “see any incongruity between the context and the concluding sentence.” Yet, in this same letter which attempted to justify the garbling of a quotation so as to make a critical review appear a lauda- tory one, Dr. Abrams declared that the review in question was “conceived and executed in a malicious spirit.” Between 1912 and 1914 Dr. Abrams gave “clinical courses” on “Spondylotherapy” in various parts of the country—price $50. These “courses” were widely ad- vertised by an Ohio concern that seems to make a specialty not only of handling the advertising campaigns of those members of the medical profession who have unusual or bizarre methods to exploit, but also of acting as an agent for the sale of such devices and publications as may be necessary to the proper practice of the particular brand of therapy that is being exploited. At the time this concern was featuring Abrams’ course it called attention to the alleged fact that “no class were [sic/] so busy as those employing mechanical treatment such as Osteopathy, Chiropractic, Mechanotherapy, etc.” Says Dr. Abrams: “Despite the fury of tongue or the truculence of pen, the osteopath and chiropractor are inspiring the confidence of the community with their systems. Right or wrong in their theory, they are, in vulgar parlance, ‘delivering the goods.’ Spondylotherapy was a product of necessity—the translation of an ignored field of medicine from a chaotic to a scientific basis.” Possibly the following testimonial published by Dr. Abrams as typical of many received, and credited to “Dr. Henry Stacy Dodge, Richmond, Va.,” may explain the field that “Spondylotherapy” is to cover. Incidentally, “Dr.” Dodge is listed in the Richmond telephone directory as a chiropractor: “I have been in practice for fifteen years in Chiro- practic and ten years an Osteopath and I wish to say that during the last three years, I have received more genuine and sincere satisfaction from the application of Spondylo- therapy than all other methods combined. My success in gastrology alone is worth many times the cost of the in- formation.” More recently, Dr. Abrams has advertised that he gives a “course” in Spondylotherapy in San Francisco, begin- ning on the first of each month. The course lasts four weeks. “The honorarium for this course is $200.00.” In 1912 an organization was created devoted to this new therapeutic method: the “American Association for the Study of Spondylotherapy.” Later Dr. Abrams was made Honorary President. Whether the organization is still viable we do not know. ELECTRONIC REACTIONS OF ABRAMS In addition to “Spondylotherapy,” Dr. Abrams has also evolved what he calls the “Electronic Reactions of Abrams.” These are said to make possible long-distance diagnoses, it being necessary only to send a few drops of blood taken from the patient and allowed to dry on a slide. There are, it seems, certain instruments and devices used in the performance of these diagnostic feats. By means of the “Electronic Reactions” Dr. Abrams (while admit- ting the protective factor of vaccination against smallpox) has discovered that practically all the vaccines obtained from reliable firms yield the reaction (“electronic tests”) of congenital syphilis, and that many of them also yield the reaction of tuberculosis and of streptococci and staphylococci. Further, “from the cicatrices of all vacci- nated persons, one can always elicit a reaction of congenital syphilis and in early scars a tuberculous reaction.” Dr. Abrams also declares that exposing vaccine virus for ten minutes to blue light will destroy the syphilitic, strepto- cocci and staphylococci reactions and exposing it for the same period to yellow light will destroy the tuberculous reaction. One of Dr. Abrams’ disciples—Sir James Barr— frequently quoted with evident satisfaction, declares that from a fresh sample of blood spread over four square inches of white blotting paper, “Dr. Abrams can diagnose the