Untenable Positions with Regard to the Problem of Immunity to Dental Caries.

Pickerill HP. · 1918

Read Untenable Positions with Regard to the Problem of Immunity to Dental Caries. by Pickerill HP. (1918) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7845215.txt.

Introduction

Pickerill argues against common views on immunity to dental caries. The piece is a journal article in The Dental Register. It was read before a Liverpool dental society in December 1917. Caries kept rising despite wide use of alkaline tooth pastes. The author takes that fact as his starting point.

He holds that several popular stances on caries immunity cannot stand. Many cases strike people who never use any paste at all. Claims built on paste use alone thus miss the mark. The article works through the weak points of rival views. It presses for a sounder account of why teeth decay. The piece shows early dental science arguing over cause and prevention.

Catalog record

CREATORPickerill HP.
YEAR1918
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7845215

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Untenable Positions with Regard to the Problem of Immunity to Dental Caries*Read before the Liverpool and District Odontological Society, December, 1917. Reprinted from The Dental Record, for August, 1905. By H. P. Pickerill Published in: The Dental Register UNTENABLE POSITIONS WITH REGARD TO THE PROBLEM OF IMMUNITY TO DENTAL CARIES* BY MAJOR H. P. PICKERILL, N.Z.M.C., Professor of Dentistry, Otago University, N. Z. Despite the continued use of alkaline dentifrices the incidence of caries increases. Of course, a large propor- tion of caries occurs in people who never use a dentifrice of any kind, but on the other hand, I do not think it will be claimed by anyone that the incidence of caries is reduced amongst civilized peoples in any inverse propor- tion whatever to the enormous consumption of alkaline dentifrices taking place all over the world today. It is interesting do note that •the u-se of alkalies as prophylactics was common for centuries before it was realized that an acid fermentation had any causal rela- tionship to dental caries, and when, after Miller’s work, the present chemico-parasitic theory became generally recognized, alkalies were dropped rather in favor of anti- septics—these were not found clinically to do what was hoped and so the pendulum swung back to alkalies— with just a flavoring of antiseptics. The present idea of the use of alkalies is to neutralize the acid formed from fermenting food substances and so prevent the inception of caries. Therein lies a great fallacy. Lactic acid is formed by the action of organisms upon carbohydrates in the mouth, molecule by molecule slowly and as a nascent acid, and as such it immediately seeks neutralization—it does not and can not accumulate in the mouth and wait until next morning when an overwhelm- ingly strong alkali is used to neutralize it. It would be most convenient if it did. No. it must be neutralized at once either by dentifrice, saliva or lime salts of enamel, and seeing that it is the latter substance which is most * Read before the Liverpool and District Odontological Society, December, 1917. Reprinted from The Dental Record, for August, 1905. constantly present, the results of such action are most commonly seen. Miller’s observations that lactic acid must reach a cer- tain percentage in the mouth before solution can occur are apt to be most misleading, ^because it is not the mouth as a whole we have to consider, but a microscopic area of enamel opposite one molecule of lactic acid, and the-ques- tion always is, can some diluent or neutralizing agent come along in sufficient time to prevent that microscopic area from being attacked—for once attacked and defeated the total destruction of the tooth, except in comparatively rare cases, is only a matter of time. It can not be too strongly insisted on that the fight is at the surface—the surface once being breached in ninety- nine per cent, of cases total defeat is certain. The character of many dentifrices too is harmful, in that the particles consist of sharp angular fragments which, with the friction of the toothbrush, considerably abrade the tooth substance. The particles tend to remain at the gingival margin and so form a nidus for the pre- cipitation of salivary salts. Lastly, alkalies in a solid form can never reach those areas of the tooth most com- monly attacked, i. e., the apex of the interdental angle and the occlusal fissures. The most serious disadvantage of alkalies, however, is that not only do they do no good themselves, but they weaken the natural powers of resistance. In other words, they are salivary depressants. In saliva we have a watery fluid containing alkaline salts always available—if called upon—and eminently adapted to neutralize and wash away each molecule of lactic acid as it is formed. It is a poten- tially perfect mouth wash—no art or device of man could contrive one so beautifully adapted to its purpose. Why then should it not be used? And why, above all, should its use be systematically suppressed by most clumsy and inefficient substitutes? Alkalies may be regarded as “resters” of alimentary excretions. They induce rest of most, if not all, of the alimentary glands—salivary, gastric, pancreatic and he- patic. The results of this are most marked in animals. Animals fed on an alkaline diet firstly do not develop their salivary glands in proportion to the rest of their body, their skins, get out of condition and hair falls out, their bones do not ossify as completely as normal—rickets tends to occur. The excretion of calcium and starch goes up above normal. The body weight is markedly self- normal, and finally the animal dies of a polyneuritis. This condition I can produce with certainty in young animals, and I suggest that a similar condition of affairs is going on to a modified extent in young human animals at the present time. The young human animal has a strong appetite for acid foods—but careful parents invariably eliminate these by practice and precept for fear of subsequent “stomach ache.’’ Instead, children are fed largely on alkali-fla- vored diets. Bread made with soda, butter adulterated with soda, vegetables boiled in soda, and mineral water made with soda, tea often containing soda—confectionery containing alkaline dyes, and last, but by no means least, dentifrices loaded with alkalies. Have you watched a child cleaning its teeth? lie does not spit out all the dentifrice, especially if it happens to look pretty and is nicely flavored. The intrinsic result of all this is that we are robbing children of the normal stimulus to their alimentary organs, and the latter robbed of their stimulus fail to develop to their normal strength. The obvious result is carious teeth due to insufficient salivary secretion—“indigestion,” due to insufficient gastric secretion—malnutrition and ali- mentary toxemia and constipation due to insufficient pan- creatic, hepatic and intestinal secretions. (Here were shown a number of lantern slides illustrating salivary and alimentary secretion.) The second idol which I propose to endeavor to shatter is that the enamel of teeth is a “fixed quantity,” and varies neither with age nor in different individuals. This is a tenet of comparatively recent years. It had, I think, until the researches of Miller, Tomes and Black, been generally supposed that there were such things as “hard" and “soft" teeth. Miller and Tonies, however, by a series of chemical analyses came to the conclusion that the enamel of various teeth did not vary. Black, by a series of experiments with an instrument designed to measure resistance to crushing stress, also came to the conclusion that the enamel of teeth did not vary. But the great mistake has been made in drawing the conclusions from these series of investigations that because enamel did not vary in chemical composition or in resistance to crushing force, therefore it did not vary at all! (This is veritably jumping—not to say kangarooing—to con- clusions !) I now propose to show you that the enamel of teeth of different people of various ages does vary considerably in important physical properties, besides those of chemi- cal composition and resistance to crushing stress; and I would like to emphasize here, too, again that it is the enamel

Read the complete text