The psychological impact of COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns: a review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies and natural experiments.

Prati G, Mancini AD. · 2021

Read The psychological impact of COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns: a review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies and natural experiments. by Prati G, Mancini AD. (2021) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7844215.txt.

Introduction

Prati and Mancini review the mental health effects of COVID-19 lockdowns. Lockdowns changed daily life across the world. Most earlier reviews leaned on one-time surveys. Such surveys cannot prove that lockdowns caused the harm. This team limited itself to stronger designs.

Only studies that followed people over time were kept. Natural experiments counted as well. The team pooled their results in a meta-analysis. Symptoms such as anxiety, low mood, and stress were tracked. Effects turned out smaller and more mixed than snap polls suggest. Most people coped without lasting harm. A clear minority did suffer, though. The authors call for care aimed at that group.

Catalog record

CREATORPrati G, Mancini AD.
YEAR2021
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7844215

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The psychological impact of COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns: a review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies and natural experiments By Gabriele Prati, Anthony D. Mancini Published in: Psychological Medicine DOI: 10.1017/S0033291721000015 ABSTRACT Lockdowns to control the spread of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) have had profound effects on everyday life worldwide, but their effect on mental health remains unclear because available meta-analyses and reviews rely mostly on cross-sectional studies. We conducted a rapid review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies and natural experiments investigating the relationship between COVID-19 lockdowns and mental health. A total of 25 studies involving 72 004 participants and 58 effect sizes were analyzed. Using a random effects model, we found that lockdowns had small effects on mental health symptoms, g = 0.17, s.e. = 0.05, 95% CI (0.06–0.24), p = 0.001, but the effects on positive psychological functioning, g = −0.12, s.e. = 0.11, 95% CI (−0.33 to 0.09), p = 0.27, were not significant. Multivariate analysis of effect sizes revealed significant and relatively small effect sizes for anxiety and depression, while those for social support, loneliness, general distress, negative affect, and suicide risk were not significant. The results indicated substantial heterogeneity among studies, but meta-regression analyses found no significant moderation effects for mean age, gender, continent, COVID-19 death rate, days of lockdown, publication status or study design. The psychological impact of COVID-19 lockdowns is small in magnitude and highly heterogeneous, suggesting that lockdowns do not have uniformly detrimental effects on mental health and that most people are psychologically resilient to their effects. The spread of the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) has resulted in an unprecedented series of lockdowns worldwide. Although these lockdowns have varied in stringency between and within countries, they have substantially altered people's daily lives globally, affecting their work, leisure activities, livelihood, and capacity for in-person social interaction. It is difficult to draw definitive conclusions regarding the impact of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) lockdowns from prior research, because the COVID-19 lockdowns have marked qualitative differences from those of previous pandemics (e.g. the substantial socio-economic impact, greater degree of stringency, and the variable nature of enforcement). Although one prior systematic review that suggests that general coronavirus infections have minimal effects on symptoms of mental illness (Rogers et al., 2020), this prior review does not address the broader psychological impact of the pandemic lockdowns on general population samples. In the present review and meta-analysis, we sought to focus on the emerging literature on COVID-19 lockdowns to investigate the psychological impact of lockdown on the general population. Specifically, we reviewed and meta-analyzed studies that included between-group or within-group controls, allowing for clearer inferences regarding the impact of lockdown on mental health. Following previous research (e.g. Haider et al., 2020), we defined lockdown as an emergency and temporary measure imposed by governmental authorities that (1) applies to a city, region, or nation to prevent the spread of the COVID-19 virus; (2) is mandatory and applied indiscriminately to a general population; and (3) requires citizens to stay at home and refrain from or limit social and economic activities outside the home. Three recent systematic reviews investigated the broader psychological impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the general public worldwide. Luo, Guo, Yu, Jiang, and Wang (2020) revealed a pooled prevalence of anxiety and depression of 32 and 27%, respectively, among the general public. Similar results emerged in Salari et al. (2020), who found the pooled prevalence of stress, anxiety, and depression, is 29.6, 31.9, and 33.7% respectively. Vindegaard and Benros (2020) also found increased levels of depressive and anxiety symptoms along with general mental health symptoms. Based on their findings, Luo and colleagues concluded that ‘the COVID-19 pandemic has caused heavy psychological impact among medical workers and the general public’ (Luo et al., 2020, p. 7). Similarly, Salari and colleagues indicate that the COVID-19 pandemic ‘has not only raised concerns over general public health, but has also caused a number of psychological and mental disorders’ (Salari et al., 2020, pp. 8–11). Finally, Vindegaard and Benros suggest that ‘currently data is scarce, but indicates that mental health is affected in the general public’ (Vindegaard & Benros, 2020, p. 10). These prior reviews raise important concerns regarding the mental health impact of COVID-19 lockdowns, but they are based on studies with significant methodological limitations, including cross-sectional designs and absence of control groups. As Meda and Slongo (2020) note, caution should be used when reporting conclusions on the psychological impact of the COVID-19 pandemic from cross-sectional studies lacking a proper control group. Given that prior reviews relied largely on cross-sectional studies, a review of more compelling evidence for the mental health effects of lockdown is needed. A stronger evidence base would have critical implications for policymaking and clinical interventions around the world. The degree of media attention devoted to the psychological impact of COVID-19 may also create expectancy effects, consistent with the self-fulfilling prophecy (Merton, 1948) and the Pygmalion effect (Rosenthal & Jacobson, 1968). The capacity for resilience in response to the COVID-19 pandemic (i.e. a relatively stable trajectory of healthy psychological functioning) has sometimes been discounted, though it is the modal response to widely varying forms of acute adversity (e.g. Bonanno, Westphal, & Mancini, 2011; see also: Mancini, 2020). In sum, on the one hand, previous systematic reviews of cross-sectional research suggest that national lockdowns may have a heavy psychological impact. On the other hand, a resilience perspective suggests that the psychological impact of national lockdowns may be relatively small. PURPOSE OF THE PRESENT STUDY In the present study, we took advantage of a growing evidence base using more sophisticated methodologies. When experimental randomized trials are neither feasible nor ethical, both longitudinal within-person designs (with at least one data collection point before and one during the lockdown) and natural experiments involving a control group provide a methodologically more rigorous test of the effect of the COVID-19 lockdown. Because many lockdowns happened at a national level, natural experiments involving an appropriate control group were difficult to undertake. Nevertheless, longitudinal studies that examine within-person change before and after lockdowns provide important information on the psychological impact of lockdowns. The number of longitudinal studies and natural experiments assessing the effect of the COVID-19 lockdowns on mental health among the general population has multiplied during the last months. To provide a more rigorous assessment of the influence of the COVID-19 lockdowns, we conducted a review and meta-analysis of this evidence base to determine the psychological impact of COVID-19 lockdowns on the general population. We focused on broad dimensions of psychological functioning, including mental health symptoms, such as anxiety and depression, and positive psychological functioning such as well-being and life-satisfaction, consistent with the idea that these dimensions are separable but related constructs (Keyes, 2005). In addition, given the effect of lockdowns on in-person social interaction, we also examined feelings of loneliness and social support as ancillary outcomes. METHOD Knowledge synthesis To synthesize the evidence in a timely manner, we chose a rapid review approach (e.g. Arksey & O'Malley, 2005; Khangura, Konnyu, Cushman, Grimshaw, & Moher, 2012; Tricco et al., 2015) over a systematic review methodology. Using guidance from Arksey and O'Malley (2005), we compiled a rapid review protocol (available from the corresponding author upon request).

Read the complete text