Should video laryngoscopy or direct laryngoscopy be used for adults undergoing endotracheal intubation in the pre-hospital setting? A critical appraisal of a systematic review.
Pennington E, Bell S, Hill JE. · 2023
Read Should video laryngoscopy or direct laryngoscopy be used for adults undergoing endotracheal intubation in the pre-hospital setting? A critical appraisal of a systematic review. by Pennington E, Bell S, Hill JE. (2023) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7616025.txt.
Introduction
Pennington, Bell and Hill appraise a systematic review on laryngoscopy choice for pre-hospital intubation in adults. Tube placement by paramedics is debated in the UK. Safety gains from new tools need solid proof.
The review under appraisal was done by Hansel and colleagues. It compared video and direct laryngoscopes in practice. Video tools add a camera for a better view. That view may raise success rates for the procedure. This commentary checks the methods of that review. It then expands findings for clinical practice use. Skill, training and rare exposure shape the debate. Most UK paramedics seldom do this procedure in the field. The authors weigh whether video tools should enter routine pre-hospital care.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pennington E, Bell S, Hill JE. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2023 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Should video laryngoscopy or direct laryngoscopy be used for adults undergoing endotracheal intubation in the pre-hospital setting? A critical appraisal of a systematic review By Elspeth Pennington, Steve Bell, James E Hill Published in: Journal of paramedic practice : the clinical monthly for emergency care professionals DOI: 10.1002/14651858 ABSTRACT Abstract The safety and utility of endotracheal intubation by paramedics in the United Kingdom is a matter of debate. Considering the controversy surrounding the safety of paramedic-performed endotracheal intubation, any interventions that enhance patient safety should be evaluated for implementation based on solid evidence of their effectiveness. A systematic review performed by Hansel and colleagues (2022) sought to assess compare video laryngoscopes against direct laryngoscopes in clinical practice. This commentary aims to critically appraise the methods used within the review by Hansel et al (2022) and expand upon the findings in the context of clinical practice. Keywords: Airway management, endotracheal intubation, Laryngoscopy, Pre-hospital, Video laryngoscopy INTRODUCTION Endotracheal intubation (ETI) by paramedics within the United Kingdom (UK) is a contentious topic with its place within the scope of paramedic practice subject to varying opinions regarding the safety and utility of the procedure (Gregory, 2015). Much of this debate stems from the perceived level of skill and competence required to undertake the procedure and the associated education, training, and assessment processes to determine practitioner competency (Gregory, 2015). It is also recognised that for the majority of UK paramedics exposure to undertaking ETI in pre-hospital clinical practice is limited and therefore robust mechanisms are necessary to monitor and ensure on-going clinical competency (Gowens et al, 2018). Given the contention over the safety of ETI by paramedics (Pallin, 2018), any innovations which add to patient safety should be considered for introduction based upon robust evidence of effectiveness. Video laryngoscopy is one such potential innovation with the addition of electronic camera technologies to laryngoscopes offering the practitioner improved views of the glottis during ETI with the inference of improving success rates associated with the procedure (Chemsian et al 2014). The systematic review performed by Hansel and colleagues (2022) sought to assess to compare video laryngoscopes against direct laryngoscopes in clinical practice and provides a contemporary and thorough review of video verses direct laryngoscopy in adult patients. From the outset it should be recognised that the systematic review does not have a pre-hospital or paramedic focus and instead considers the evidence base from all fields of practice associated with ETI. Aim of commentary This commentary aims to critically appraise the methods used within the review by Hansel et al (2022) and expand upon the findings in the context of clinical practice. Methods of the systematic review by Hansel et al (2022) A comprehensive, peer-reviewed, multi-database literature search was carried out from January 2015 to 27 February 2021, with this start date having been chosen due to previous knowledge that no papers on the topic were available before this date. There were no restrictions on language or publication status. Only randomised controlled trials (RCTs), of parallel or cross-over design, comparing the use of any model of video laryngoscopy versus direct laryngoscopy with a Macintosh blade, with participants aged 16 years and older, in any setting, were included. Studies focusing on awake tracheal intubation, simulation not involving human participants, and those using manikins or cadavers were excluded. Studies using optical stylets, flexible fibreoptic intubating devices, tracheal tubes with an integrated camera, and McCoy or Miller direct laryngoscopy blades were all also excluded. A thorough screening process of title and abstracts and then full-text articles was undertaken by two reviewers independently, with disagreements being resolved by discussion, or adjudication of a third reviewer. A comprehensive assessment of bias was undertaken by two reviewers using Higgins’ (2011) Risk of Bias 1 tool. Meta-analysis was undertaken using a random effects model due to pre-perceived study level heterogeneity. For all binary outcomes the relative risk (RR) and corresponding 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) were calculated. Heterogeneity was examined using the I2 statistic. The key findings from the review were split into three comparison groups comparing the following different styles of video laryngoscopy devices with direct laryngoscopy: - Macintosh-style video laryngoscopy Vs direct laryngoscopy - Hyper-angulated video laryngoscopy Vs direct laryngoscopy - Channelled video laryngoscopy Vs direct laryngoscopy Results of the systematic review by Hansel et al (2022) The search strategy identified 2344 records after duplicates were removed. After full screening 222 RCTs were included in the review (158 new studies and 64 studies included from the previous version of the review). The included studies were from several different countries across the world and of a mixture of high, middle and low incomes. Most of the studies were from the theatre setting with only 6 from the pre-hospital setting and only half of these pre-hospital studies had data extracted from them for the meta-analysis due to having marked outliers for the key outcome of failed intubation rates. There was moderate certainty evidence that Macintosh-style video laryngoscopy may provide a clinical and statistically significant reduction in risk of failed intubation (RR 0.41 95% CI: 0.26 to 0.65), hypoxaemia (RR 0.72 95% CI: 0.52 to 0.99) and Cormack-Lehane views Grade 3 or 4 (RR 0.38, 95% CI: 0.29 to 0.48). There was low certainty evidence that Macintosh-style video laryngoscopy increases the risk of successful first attempt compared to direct laryngoscopy (RR 1.05, 95% CI:1.02 to 1.09). There was low to very low evidence that there was no evidence of effect for both oesophageal intubation and dental trauma. When comparing hyperangulated video laryngoscopy to direct laryngoscopy, there was moderate quality evidence that there was a clinically and statistically significant reduction in the risk of failed intubation (RR 0.51, 95% CI: 0.34 to 0.76), oesophageal intubation (RR 0.39, 95% CI: 0.18 to 0.81) and Cormack-Lehane views Grade 3 or 4 (RR 0.15, 95% CI: 0.10 to 0.24). There was low certainty evidence that utilising hyperangulated video laryngoscopy may slightly increase the chances of a successful first attempt (RR 1.03 95% CI: 1.00 to 1.05). There was low to very low evidence that there was no evidence of difference for dental trauma and hypoxaemia. When comparing channelled video laryngoscopy compared to direct laryngoscopy there was moderate quality evidence that there was a clinical and statistically significant reduction in risk of failed intubation (RR 0.43, 95% CI: 0.30 to 0.61), hypoxia (RR 0.25, 95% CI: 0.12 to 0.50) and Cormack-Lehane views Grade 3 or 4 (RR 0.14, 95% CI: 0.09 to 0.21). There was very low certainty evidence that channelled video laryngoscopy compared to direct laryngoscopy increased the risk of successful first attempt (RR 1.10 95% CI: 1.05 to 1.15). There was low to very low evidence that there was no evidence of difference for dental trauma and oesophageal intubation. Due to substantial heterogeneity time for tracheal intubation was not meta-analysed for any comparison. Subgroup analyses For the subgroup analysis the post hoc decision was made to compare all techniques combined compared to direct laryngoscopy for the outcome of failed intubation. There was a statistically significant reduction in risk of failed intubation for difficult airway features (RR 0.32, 95% CI 0.23 to 0.44; I2 = 9%) compared to no difficulty (RR 0.54, 95% CI 0.38 to 0.78; I2 = 23%).