Meta-analysis of the impacts of global change factors on soil microbial diversity and functionality.
Zhou Z, Wang C, Luo Y. · 2020
Read Meta-analysis of the impacts of global change factors on soil microbial diversity and functionality. by Zhou Z, Wang C, Luo Y. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7300008.txt.
Introduction
Zhou, Wang and Luo pool worldwide experiments on how global change factors reshape soil microbes. Their meta-analysis appeared in Nature Communications. Soil microbes drive nutrient cycling, yet their response to warming, extra carbon dioxide, altered rainfall, nitrogen deposition, and land-use change was unclear. The synthesis gathered 1235 observations from studies around the world.
Rare microbial species proved more sensitive to global change than common ones. Diversity did not always fall, and shifts in diversity were explained mainly by changes in soil acidity. Effects on what soil microbes actually do were explained by community structure and biomass rather than diversity itself. The authors note these patterns differ from those in plants and animals, a fact conservation policy for microbial hotspots should respect.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhou Z, Wang C, Luo Y. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2020 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Meta-analysis of the impacts of global change factors on soil microbial diversity and functionality By Zhenghu Zhou, Chuankuan Wang, Yiqi Luo Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/s41467-020-16881-7 ABSTRACT Biodiversity on the Earth is changing at an unprecedented rate due to a variety of global change factors (GCFs). However, the effects of GCFs on microbial diversity is unclear despite that soil microorganisms play a critical role in biogeochemical cycling. Here, we synthesize 1235 GCF observations worldwide and show that microbial rare species are more sensitive to GCFs than common species, while GCFs do not always lead to a reduction in microbial diversity. GCFs-induced shifts in microbial alpha diversity can be predominately explained by the changed soil pH. In addition, GCF impacts on soil functionality are explained by microbial community structure and biomass rather than the alpha diversity. Altogether, our findings of GCF impacts on microbial diversity are fundamentally different from previous knowledge for well-studied plant and animal communities, and are crucial to policy-making for the conservation of microbial diversity hotspots under global changes. INTRODUCTION Human-induced global change factors (GCFs), such as climate warming (W), carbon-dioxide enrichment (eCO2), altered precipitation, atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition, nutrient fertilization, land-use change (LUC), and their combinations, seriously threaten the biodiversity in our planet1,2. LUC is the dominant driver of biodiversity decline in terrestrial ecosystems mainly through loss, degradation, and fragmentation of the habitats1,3. Projected climate changes cause species extinction once the species falls outside its climatic niche4; and 15–37% of species are expected to go extinct under the mid-range scenarios of temperature and CO2 rises5. Enhanced atmospheric N deposition leads to changes in plant species interaction and community composition, results in soil acidification and ion toxicity, decreases the resistance of plants to pathogens and insect pests, and consequently is recognized as the third greatest driver (after LUC and climate changes) of biodiversity loss in the century1,6. Soil microbial communities play a critical role in almost all of the biogeochemical cycling processes in terrestrial ecosystems, such as organic matter decomposition, nutrient cycling, plant diversity, and productivity7–9. However, our understanding of how GCFs affect the biodiversity and its relations to the functionality for microorganism lags substantially behind that for macroorganisms (plants and animals)1–6. These knowledge gaps swamp our predictions of GCFs impacts on microbial diversity and thus constrain the establishment of effective policies to preserve microbial diversity hotspots. Soil microbial communities are surprisingly diverse and abundant10. It has been estimated that 1 trillion (1012) microbial species harbor on the Earth10, and 1 g soil contains up to 1 billion (109) bacterial cells consisting of tens of thousands of taxa, which raise great challenges to investigate microbial diversity8. Scientists have attempted to examine whether microbial diversity displays an environmental gradient like plant diversity, and whether microbial community assembly follows the macroecological theories10–16, such as the metabolic theory, the species energy theory, the stoichiometry theory, and plant–soil interaction (Supplementary Table 1). Yet, such attempts often fail for soil microorganisms13–15. For example, a recent global meta-analysis of 325 soil communities showed that the driver of microbial diversity was often inconsistent among different studies15. Despite recent individual experiments have examined the responses of microbial diversity to GCFs, the effect of GCFs on microbial diversity remains highly elusive and inconclusive. Current evidence of plant community studies supports a positive but saturating relationship between plant biodiversity and ecosystem functioning17,18, which can result from niche complementarity, positive interactions, greater use of limiting resources, decreased herbivory and pathogens, the presence of certain influential species, etc17,18. Consequently, an enormous amount of research claims that ecosystem functioning is threatened by an ongoing loss of species due to GCFs1–3,19. A common notion seems to be developed, largely inspired by the studies on aboveground communities, that microbial diversity drives microbial functionality in terrestrial ecosystems7,8,20,21. However, soil microorganisms are suggested to be too diverse and abundant to assume that the biogeochemical cycling is limited by the microbial diversity22–24. It is still unclear whether the biodiversity loss of microbial communities reduces microbial functionality in the ecosystems under GCFs. Here, we conducted a global synthesis of 1235 GCF experimental observations that measured microbial alpha diversity (number of species coexisting within a local site), beta diversity (the magnitude of similarity in species composition among different sites), and community structure with high-throughput sequencing techniques, and corresponding biomass and ecosystem functionalities from eight types of biomes (agriculture, tundra, temperate/boreal forest, tropical/subtropical forest, Mediterranean vegetation, grassland, desert, and wetland; Supplementary References, Fig. 1, and Datasets 1–3). The microbial groups include bacteria, fungi, and six specialized microbes (i.e., denitrifier, nitrifier, diazotroph, phosphorous (P) mineralizer, methanotroph, and methanogen). The GCFs include seven single-factor experiments (W, eCO2, precipitation addition (PPT+), precipitation reduction (PPT−), N deposition, P addition, and LUC) and four combined-factor experiments (W × eCO2, N × PPT+, N × P addition, and N × P × potassium (N × P × K) addition). The questions we address include: first, what are the effects of GCFs on microbial diversity and community structure worldwide? Are the effects similar to those reported for plants and animals? Second, what are the potential drivers of these responses? As potential drivers of microbial responses to GCFs, climate, biome type, microbial group, soil resources, soil pH, and experimental forcing factors were evaluated by the model selection analysis based on the corrected Akaike information criterion (AIC). Finally, how do GCFs-induced changes in microbial alpha diversity affect the microbial functionality in the ecosystems?Fig. 1Responses of microbial diversity and community structure.a Response ratio (natural logarithm-transformed ratio of treatment to control, RR) of microbial alpha diversity (richness and Shannon index). b RR of microbial beta diversity. c RR of microbial community structure. Weighted means and their 95% confidence intervals of RRs are given. The numbers at the right side of the confidence intervals represent the sample sizes. W warming, eCO2 carbon-dioxide enrichment, PPT− decreased precipitation, PPT+ increased precipitation, P phosphorous addition, N nitrogen addition, LUC land-use change, W × eCO2 warming plus carbon-dioxide enrichment, N × PPT+ nitrogen addition plus increased precipitation, N × P nitrogen plus phosphorous addition, N × P × K nitrogen plus phosphorous plus potassium addition. Source data are provided as a Source Data file. Our results show that microbial community structure is sensitive to GCFs, while GCFs affect microbial diversity inconsistently and do not always lead to the loss of microbial diversity. Conversion from highly diverse natural ecosystems to homogeneous agricultural monocultures has a positive effect on microbial alpha diversity. Soil pH is the most important factor to predict the GCFs effects on microbial alpha diversity. Generally, if a GCF increases the soil pH, the alpha diversity would increase; if it decreases the soil pH, the alpha diversity would reduce; if it has no effect on soil pH, it would not change the alpha diversity. The response of soil functionality to GCFs can be explained by the responses of microbial community structure and biomass rather than the response of microbial alpha diversity. In summary, our findings of GCFs impacts on microorganisms are fundamentally different from previous knowledge for the well-studied plant and animal communities. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION GCFs have little negative effect on microbial biodiversity Pooling all the data across microbial groups and biomes, we found that GCFs do not always cause microbial diversity