Epidemiology of Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Review of Worldwide Prevalence Estimates Since 2014.

Chiarotti F, Venerosi A. · 2020

Read Epidemiology of Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Review of Worldwide Prevalence Estimates Since 2014. by Chiarotti F, Venerosi A. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7288022.txt.

Introduction

Chiarotti and Venerosi review worldwide estimates of autism spectrum disorder prevalence published since 2014. Their review appeared in Brain Sciences. Reported autism rates have climbed sharply in recent decades, prompting talk of an epidemic. Counts come from two sources: surveillance systems mining health and education records, and dedicated population studies.

Estimates vary widely between countries, which the authors attribute largely to differences in how cases are found and counted. Within each region, though, estimates keep rising over time. Reliable counts matter for planning services, training professionals, and funding support for people with autism and their families. They can also reveal which groups face unequal access to developmental evaluation, a gap the review keeps in view.

Catalog record

CREATORChiarotti F, Venerosi A.
YEAR2020
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7288022

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Epidemiology of Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Review of Worldwide Prevalence Estimates Since 2014 By Flavia Chiarotti, Aldina Venerosi Published in: Brain Sciences DOI: 10.3390/brainsci10050274 ABSTRACT Abstract The prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) has increased dramatically in recent decades, supporting the claim of an autism epidemic. Systematic monitoring of ASD allows estimating prevalence and identifying potential sources of variation over time and geographical areas. At present, ASD prevalence estimates are available worldwide, coming either from surveillance systems using existing health and educational databases or from population studies specifically performed. In the present article, we present a review of the ASD prevalence estimates published since 2014. Data confirm a high variability in prevalence across the world, likely due to methodological differences in case detection, and the consistent increase of prevalence estimates within each geographical area. Keywords: prevalence estimate, autism, predictors, surveillance review 1. INTRODUCTION In the last decades, a large increase in the prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) has been observed, generating claims about an “epidemic” of autism [1,2]. Correct estimates of ASD prevalence rates are important, firstlyin order to determine the economic and health services burden of this condition and to allocate sufficient funding and adequate services for children and adults with ASD and their families. A growing population of people with ASD implies the necessity of increased service availability including training of professionals, as well as identification of additional resources that can emerge by the recognition of cases in the population [3]. Furthermore, accurately determining ASD prevalence can help to understand which groups are exposed to disparities in healthcare access for developmental evaluations [4], besides being more at risk for ASD due to geographical and environmental factors [5]. Studies that estimate ASD prevalence result in wide variability of prevalence rates that call for paying attention on possible reasons for the observed changes in prevalence, and advice for caution when claiming that there is an autism epidemic [2,6]. One important source of variation in prevalence estimates are the methodological differences in case definition and case-finding procedures. In particular, some studies are carried out on existing administrative databases such as special education data, health or social records of national registers for case identification, or specific condition registers (defined as “administrative data” when relying on one database, or “multisource” when combining data from multiple databases). Other studies rely on a two-stage or multistage approach to identify cases in underlying populations; the first stage is often based on questionnaire requesting behavioural descriptions or checklist based on DSM, where informants could be in turn teachers, parents or health professionals (defined as “ad hoc studies”). Finally, some studies are surveys based on interviews to parents or teachers, who are required to state if the child presents a condition that can be related to ASD (defined as “reports”). Obviously, sample size and catching area represent further characteristics of the studies that can affect prevalence estimates [7]. Indeed, surveyed areas vary in terms of service development as a function of the specific educational or health care systems of each country and of the year of the study [6]. Moreover, socio economic factors [8,9] and autism awareness [10] can influence assessment of the case and consequently prevalence estimate. Case definition is the other challenge that affects prevalence estimate. Diagnostic category (AD, ASD, PDD), as well as age range considered are very important sources of prevalence estimate variation [7]. Changing definitions and labelling practices that change over time, as in the case of the introduction of diagnostic manuals’ revisions, can produce change in labelling but also “diagnostic substitution” whereby similar symptoms can be classified under different disabilities during different time periods [11,12]. Lastly, cultural influence can affect the definition of case causing differences in the estimation of prevalence in different ethnic/cultural groups [13,14]. In the present paper, we present a brief narrative review of the most recent ASD prevalence estimates worldwide. We describe evidences according to two main criteria, i.e., the geographical setting and the case-finding procedure of the study. Finally, we attempt to demonstrate if these criteria act as predictive factors for underestimating or overestimating prevalence figures. 2. PREVALENCE ESTIMATES Many prevalence studies have been performed worldwide since 1966. In 2012, Elsabbagh et al. [7] published a comprehensive review of the studies performed until 2012: these studies differed with respect to diagnostic category, diagnostic criteria, age at prevalence evaluation, extent of the targeted geographical area, and source of data on the diagnoses. These methodological differences, together with the large time span (almost 50 years from the first to the last study included in the review), at least partly account for the large differences observed in the estimated prevalence. Overall, estimates ranged from 0.19/1000 to 11.6/1000. The former estimate refers to the Autistic Disorder (AD), diagnosis based on Rutter’s criteria (1978), age range 0–14 years, geographical area of West Berlin (Germany), and on data extracted from the registry of the university clinic of child psychiatry and/or the German Society for Autistic Children (1986). The latter refers to the Pervasive Developmental Disorder (PDD), diagnosis based on ICD-10, age range 9–10 years, geographical area of South Thames (UK), ad hoc study (2006). Taking into account the diagnostic category, the median prevalence estimates were 1.00/1000 for AD (from 0.19/1000 in Germany to 7.26/1000 in Sweden) and 6.16/1000 for PDD (from 3.00/1000 in Denmark to 11.6/1000 in UK). When considering PDD, the median prevalence was similar to the USA overall ASD prevalence estimated in 2000–2002, but much lower than the USA prevalence estimates since 2006. In 2014, Tsai updated the review by [7], but only negligible differences emerged in the median prevalence estimates, which were confirmed to be 1.32/1000 for AD (from 0.19/1000 in Germany to 7.26/1000 in Sweden) and 6.19/1000 for PDD/ASD (from 3.00 in Denmark 2002 to 12.3/1000 in Netherlands) [15]. The review by Tsai included almost all papers evaluated by [7], specifically 59/59 = 100% for AD and 33/35 = 94.3% for PDD prevalence studies. In his review, Tsai examined 15 and 28 additional studies estimating AD and PDD/ASD prevalence, respectively. Table 1 reports a summary of the results of the reviews by [7,15]. [Table: Summary of PDD prevalence estimates of the studies included in the reviews by [7,15] *.] Since the publication of the reviews by Elsabbagh et al. and Tsai, more prevalence studies have been performed worldwide. In the following, we report the prevalence studies published since 2014 according to the geographical area of reference. Some studies yield ASD prevalence estimate at different calendar year and/or in different age classes: where possible, we selected the more recent estimate of prevalence that referred to age 8. The list of studies with details and prevalence estimates are presented in Table 2, Table 3 and Table 4. [Table: Summary of prevalence studies published since 2014 in Europe and Middle-East.] [Table: Summary of prevalence studies published since 2014 in Asia, Australia &New Zealand.] [Table: Summary of prevalence studies published since 2014 in North America.] 2.1. Europe In Sweden, a prevalence study was performed in 2011 based on data from the Stockholm Youth Cohort (SYC) [16]. SYC is a record-linkage study collecting data longitudinally from 2001 to 2011 on all children from 0 to 17 years of age residing in Stockholm County

Read the complete text