Accurate estimation of cell composition in bulk expression through robust integration of single-cell information.
Jew B, Alvarez M, Rahmani E, Miao Z, Ko A, Garske KM, Sul JH, Pietiläinen KH, Pajukanta P, Halperin E. · 2020
Read Accurate estimation of cell composition in bulk expression through robust integration of single-cell information. by Jew B, Alvarez M, Rahmani E, Miao Z, Ko A, Garske KM, Sul JH, Pietiläinen KH, Pajukanta P, Halperin E. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7181686.txt.
Introduction
Jew and co-authors present Bisque, a tool that estimates cell makeup from bulk gene expression data. Their study appeared in Nature Communications. A tissue sample mixes many cell types, and bulk sequencing blends their signals. Single-cell data can supply reference profiles for each type. The challenge is matching the two kinds of data despite technical differences.
Bisque learns gene-specific adjustments between single-cell and bulk profiles. Those adjustments make the estimates hold up when study methods vary. The team tested the tool on brain data, among other sets. It linked microglia share to Alzheimer's severity stages as expected. The method runs fast enough for very large datasets. Researchers studying mixed tissues gain a more reliable way to count cell types.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jew B, Alvarez M, Rahmani E, Miao Z, Ko A, Garske KM, Sul JH, Pietiläinen KH, Pajukanta P, Halperin E. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2020 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Accurate estimation of cell composition in bulk expression through robust integration of single-cell information By Brandon Jew, Marcus Alvarez, Elior Rahmani, Zong Miao, Arthur Ko, Kristina M. Garske, Jae Hoon Sul, Kirsi H. Pietiläinen, Päivi Pajukanta, Eran Halperin Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/s41467-020-15816-6 ABSTRACT We present Bisque, a tool for estimating cell type proportions in bulk expression. Bisque implements a regression-based approach that utilizes single-cell RNA-seq (scRNA-seq) or single-nucleus RNA-seq (snRNA-seq) data to generate a reference expression profile and learn gene-specific bulk expression transformations to robustly decompose RNA-seq data. These transformations significantly improve decomposition performance compared to existing methods when there is significant technical variation in the generation of the reference profile and observed bulk expression. Importantly, compared to existing methods, our approach is extremely efficient, making it suitable for the analysis of large genomic datasets that are becoming ubiquitous. When applied to subcutaneous adipose and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex expression datasets with both bulk RNA-seq and snRNA-seq data, Bisque replicates previously reported associations between cell type proportions and measured phenotypes across abundant and rare cell types. We further propose an additional mode of operation that merely requires a set of known marker genes. INTRODUCTION Bulk RNA-seq experiments typically measure total gene expression from heterogeneous tissues, such as tumor and blood samples1,2. Variability in cell-type composition can significantly confound analyses of these data, such as in identification of expression quantitative trait loci (eQTLs) or differentially expressed genes3. Cell-type heterogeneity may also be of interest in profiling changes in tissue composition associated with disease, such as cancer4 or diabetes5. In addition, measures of cell composition can be leveraged to identify cell-specific eQTLs6,7 or differential expression6 from bulk data. Traditional methods for determining cell-type composition, such as immunohistochemistry or flow cytometry, rely on a limited set of molecular markers and lack in scalability relative to the current rate of data generation8. Single-cell technologies provide a high-resolution view into cellular heterogeneity and cell-type-specific expression9–11. However, these experiments remain costly and noisy compared to bulk RNA-seq12. Collection of bulk expression data remains an attractive approach for identifying population-level associations, such as differential expression regardless of cell-type specificity. Moreover, many bulk RNA-seq studies that have been performed in recent years resulted in a large body of data that is available public databases such as dbGAP and GEO. Given the wide availability of these bulk data, the estimation of cell-type proportions, often termed decomposition, can be used to extract large-scale cell-type-specific information. There exist a number of methods for decomposing bulk expression, many of which are regression-based and leverage cell-type-specific expression data as a reference profile13. CIBERSORT14 is a SVM-regression-based approach, originally designed for microarray data that utilizes a reference generated from purified cell populations. A major limitation of this approach is the reliance on sorting cells to estimate a reference gene expression panel. BSEQ-sc15 instead generates a reference profile from single-cell expression data that is used in the CIBERSORT model. MuSiC16 also leverages single-cell expression as a reference, instead using a weighted non-negative least-squares regression (NNLS) model for decomposition, with improved performance over BSEQ-sc in several datasets. The distinct nature of the technologies used to generate bulk and single-cell sequencing data may present an issue for decomposition models that assume a direct proportional relationship between the single-cell-based reference and observed bulk mixture. For example, the capture of mRNA and chemistry of library preparation can differ significantly between bulk tissue and single-cell RNA-seq methods, as well as between different single-cell technologies17,18. Moreover, some technologies may be measuring different parts of the transcriptome, such as nuclear pre-mRNA in single-nucleus RNA-seq (snRNA-seq) experiments as opposed to cellular and extra-cellular mRNA observed in traditional bulk RNA-seq experiments. As we show later, these differences may introduce gene-specific biases that break down the correlation between cell-type-specific and bulk tissue measurements. Thus, while single-cell RNA-seq technologies have provided unprecedented resolution in identifying expression profiles of cell types in heterogeneous tissues, these profiles generally may not follow the direct proportionality assumptions of regression-based methods, as we demonstrate here. We present Bisque, a highly efficient tool to measure cellular heterogeneity in bulk expression through robust integration of single-cell information, accounting for biases introduced in the single-cell sequencing protocols. The goal of Bisque is to integrate the different chemistries/technologies of single-cell and bulk tissue RNA-seq to estimate cell-type proportions from tissue-level gene expression measurements across a larger set of samples. Our reference-based model decomposes bulk samples using a single-cell-based reference profile and, while not required, can leverage single-cell and bulk measurements for the same samples for further improved decomposition accuracy. This approach employs gene-specific transformations of bulk expression to account for biases in sequencing technologies as described above. When a reference profile is not available, we propose BisqueMarker, a semi-supervised model that extracts trends in cellular composition from normalized bulk expression samples using only cell-specific marker genes that could be obtained using single-cell data. We demonstrate using simulated and real datasets from brain and adipose tissue that our method is significantly more accurate than existing methods. Furthermore, it is extremely efficient, requiring seconds in cases where other methods require hours; thus, it is scalable to large genomic datasets that are now becoming available. RESULTS Method overview (Bisque) A graphical overview of Bisque is presented in Fig. 1. Our reference-based decomposition model requires bulk RNA-seq counts data and a reference dataset with read counts from single-cell RNA-seq. In addition, the single-cell data should be labeled with cell types to be quantified. A reference profile is generated by averaging read count abundances within each cell type in the single-cell data. Given the reference profile and cell proportions observed in the single-cell data, our method learns gene-specific transformations of the bulk data to account for technical biases between the sequencing technologies. Bisque can then estimate cell proportions from the bulk RNA-seq data using the reference and the transformed bulk expression data using non-negative least-squares (NNLS) regression.Fig. 1Graphical overview of the Bisque decomposition method.We integrate single-cell and bulk expression by learning gene-specific bulk transformations (pictured on right) that align the two datasets for accurate decomposition. Evaluation of decomposition performance in adipose tissue We applied our method to 106 bulk RNA-seq subcutaneous adipose tissue samples collected from both lean and obese individuals, where 6 samples have both bulk RNA-seq and snRNA-seq data available (Table 1). Each of the participants gave a written informed consent. The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee at the Helsinki University Hospital, Helsinki, Finland. Adipose tissue consists of several cell types, including adipocytes that are expected to be the most abundant population. Adipose tissue also contains structural cell types (i.e. fibroblasts and endothelial cells) and immune cells (i.e. macrophages and T cells)19. These 5 cell-type populations were identified from the snRNA-seq data (Supplementary Fig. 1a).Table 1Summary of snRNA-seq and bulk expression datasets used for benchmarking Bisque and existing methods.TissueNumber of samplesBulk RNA-seq platformsnRNA-seq platformsnRNA-seq samplesTotal nucleiAverage nuclei per individualNumber of cell typesSubcutaneous adipose106Illumina NovaSeq10x Genomics Chromium610,94718245Dorsolateral prefrontal cortex636Illumina HiSeq10x Genomics Chromium868,028850311 We observed significant biases between the snRNA-seq and bulk RNA-seq data in samples that had both data available. We found that the linear relationship between the pseudo-bulk (summed snRNA-seq reads across cells) and the true bulk expression varied significantly by each gene (Fig.