Effective containment explains subexponential growth in recent confirmed COVID-19 cases in China.
Maier BF, Brockmann D. · 2020
Read Effective containment explains subexponential growth in recent confirmed COVID-19 cases in China. by Maier BF, Brockmann D. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7164388.txt.
Introduction
Maier and Brockmann explain why China's confirmed COVID-19 cases grew more slowly than a simple epidemic curve predicts, in Science. Cases rose from about 330 on 21 January 2020 to more than 17,000 by 2 February, yet the growth bent below exponential. Such bending can mean susceptibles are running out, but here something else was at work.
Their model attributes the slowdown to containment and the public response taking effect, even while headline case counts kept rising. By 28 March, Hubei's total had saturated at 67,800 cases with no new daily cases. The study is an early quantitative verdict that aggressive measures were working in China, offered while other governments chose their own strategies.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Maier BF, Brockmann D. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2020 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effective containment explains subexponential growth in recent confirmed COVID-19 cases in China By Benjamin F. Maier, Dirk Brockmann Published in: Science (New York, N.y.) DOI: 10.1126/science.abb4557 ABSTRACT Containment works National governments have taken different approaches in response to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, ranging from draconian quarantines to laissez-faire mitigation strategies. In data from China collected in February 2020, Maier and Brockmann noticed that, unexpectedly, the epidemic did not take off exponentially. Nonexponential spread occurs when the supply of susceptible individuals is depleted on a time scale comparable to the infectious period of the virus. The results of the authors' modeling approach indicate that the public response to the epidemic plus containment policies were becoming effective despite the initial increase in confirmed cases. Science, this issue p. 742 The outbreak of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) caused by the coronavirus severe acute respiratory syndrome–coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) in mainland China was closely monitored by governments, researchers, and the public alike (1–8). The rapid increase of positively diagnosed cases and subsequent rise of secondary outbreaks in many countries worldwide raised concern on an international scale. The World Health Organization (WHO) therefore announced the COVID-19 outbreak a Public Health Emergency of International Concern on 31 January and eventually classified it as a pandemic on 11 March (2, 3). In mainland China, confirmed cases increased from ~330 on 21 January 2020 to more than 17,000 on 2 February 2020 within 2 weeks (9). In Hubei Province, the epicenter of the COVID-2019 outbreak, confirmed cases rose from 270 to 11,000 in this period; in all other Chinese provinces, the cumulative case count increased from 60 to 6000 in the same period. Yet, as of 28 March, the total case count has saturated at 67,800 cases in Hubei with no new cases per day and reached 13,600 in the remaining Chinese provinces with about 50 new cases per day. An initial exponential growth of confirmed cases is generically expected for an uncontrolled outbreak, as observed e.g., during the 2009 influenza A (H1N1) pandemic (10) or the 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa (11). This initial outbreak is in most cases mitigated with a time delay by effective containment strategies and policies that reduce transmission and effective reproduction of the virus, commonly yielding a saturation in the cumulative case count and an exponential decay in the number of new infections (12). Although in Hubei the number of laboratory-confirmed cases C(t) was observed to grow exponentially in early January (13), the subsequent rise followed a subexponential, superlinear, algebraic scaling law tµ with an exponent μ = 2.3 (between 24 January and 9 February) (compare Fig. 1A). For most of the affected Chinese provinces of mainland China, however, this type of algebraic rise occurred from the beginning of case reporting on 21 January. The exponents μ fluctuate around a typical value of μ = 2.1 ± 0.3 for the confirmed case curves in other substantially affected provinces (confirmed case counts larger than 500 on 12 February), displaying algebraic growth despite geographical, socioeconomical differences, possible differences in containment strategies, and heterogeneities that may have variable impacts on how the local epidemic unfolds (compare Fig. 1, B and C). Eventually, case counts began to deviate from the observed scaling laws around 9 February for Hubei and in early February for the remaining provinces, approaching a saturation behavior. [Figure: Confirmed cases of COVID-19 infections.C(t) in mainland China in late January–early February. (A) Confirmed case numbers in Hubei. The increase in cases follows a scaling law tµ with an exponent µ = 2.32 after a short initial exponential growth phase. On 9 February, the case count starts deviating toward lower values. (B) Aggregated confirmed cases in all other affected provinces except Hubei. C(t) follows a scaling law with exponent µ = 1.92 until 2 February when case counts deviate to lower values. The insets in (A) and (B) depict C(t) on a log-log scale and show example exponential growth curves for comparison. (C) Confirmed cases as a function of time for the eight remaining most affected provinces in China. The curves roughly follow a scaling law with exponents µ ≈ 2 with the exception of Chongqing Province (µ = 1.45) and Jiangxi Province (µ = 2.75).] The appearance of the observed growth behavior for all provinces during the transient phase between onset and saturation suggests that this aspect of the dynamics is determined by fundamental principles that are at work and robust with respect to variation of other parameters that typically shape the temporal evolution of epidemic processes. Three questions immediately arise: (i) What may be the reason for this functional dependency? (ii) Are provinces other than Hubei mostly driven by cases exported from Hubei and therefore follow a similar functional form in case counts, as suggested by preliminary studies discussing the influence of human travel (14–16)? Or, alternatively, (iii) is the scaling law a consequence of endogenous and basic epidemiological processes, caused by a balance between transmission events and containment efforts? In the following, we will provide evidence that the implementation of effective containment strategies that target both susceptibles and infecteds can account for the observed growth behavior. The Chinese government put several mitigation policies in place to suppress the spread of the epidemic (17). In particular, positively diagnosed cases were either quarantined in specialized hospital wards or put under a form of monitored self-quarantine at home. Similarly, suspected cases were confined in monitored house arrest, e.g., individuals who arrived from Hubei before all traffic from its capital Wuhan was effectively restricted. These measures aimed at the removal of infectious individuals from the transmission process. Additionally, introduced social distancing measures aimed at the protection of the susceptible population, induced by behavioral changes as well as the partial shutdown of public life (17). For instance, many people wore face masks in public spaces and followed stricter hygiene procedures concerning hand washing; universities remained closed; many businesses closed down; and people were asked to remain in their homes for as much time as possible, in several places enforced by mandatory curfews. Another standard strategy that Chinese authorities applied was contact tracing (17), where possible transmission chains between known infecteds and their contacts were identified and suspected cases were isolated at home before symptom onset. Although very effective in interrupting the transmission process and thereby shielding large numbers of susceptibles from acquiring the infection, contact tracing becomes infeasible when the number of infecteds grows rapidly in a short amount of time or when an undetected outbreak leads to a large number of unidentifiable infecteds, as was the case in Hubei. The latter containment efforts that affect both susceptibles and asymptomatic infectious individuals not only protect susceptibles from acquiring the infection but also remove a substantial fraction of the entire pool of susceptibles from the transmission process, indirectly mitigating the proliferation of the virus in the population in much the same way that herd immunity is effective in the context of vaccine-preventable diseases. MODELING EPIDEMIC SPREAD UNDER CONTAINMENT EFFORTS On a very basic level, an outbreak such as the one in Hubei is captured by SIR dynamics where the population is divided into three compartments that differentiate the state of individuals with respect to the contagion