Mouse Heterochromatin Adopts Digital Compaction States without Showing Hallmarks of HP1-Driven Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation.

Erdel F, Rademacher A, Vlijm R, Tünnermann J, Frank L, Weinmann R, Schweigert E, Yserentant K, Hummert J, Bauer C, Schumacher S, Al Alwash A, Normand C, Herten DP, Engelhardt J, Rippe K. · 2020

Read Mouse Heterochromatin Adopts Digital Compaction States without Showing Hallmarks of HP1-Driven Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation. by Erdel F, Rademacher A, Vlijm R, Tünnermann J, Frank L, Weinmann R, Schweigert E, Yserentant K, Hummert J, Bauer C, Schumacher S, Al Alwash A, Normand C, Herten DP, Engelhardt J, Rippe K. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7163299.txt.

Introduction

Erdel and co-authors test whether HP1 protein droplets drive the packing of silent chromatin in mouse cells, in Molecular Cell. Heterochromatin is the tightly packed, switched-off part of the genome. It gathers the protein HP1, which can form liquid droplets in a test tube. Whether real chromatin foci work that way was unsettled.

Four findings argue against the droplet model in living cells. HP1 formed droplets only weakly. Focus size and packing did not depend on HP1. No separate liquid HP1 pool existed inside the foci. And packing flipped between two fixed states when a strong gene switch was present. The authors liken the foci to collapsed polymer globules soaked through with the same nuclear fluid as open chromatin.

Catalog record

CREATORErdel F, Rademacher A, Vlijm R, Tünnermann J, Frank L, Weinmann R, Schweigert E, Yserentant K, Hummert J, Bauer C, Schumacher S, Al Alwash A, Normand C, Herten DP, Engelhardt J, Rippe K.
YEAR2020
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7163299

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mouse Heterochromatin Adopts Digital Compaction States without Showing Hallmarks of HP1-Driven Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation By Fabian Erdel, Anne Rademacher, Rifka Vlijm, Jana Tünnermann, Lukas Frank, Robin Weinmann, Elisabeth Schweigert, Klaus Yserentant, Johan Hummert, Caroline Bauer, Sabrina Schumacher, Ahmad Al Alwash Published in: Molecular Cell DOI: 10.1016/j.molcel.2020.02.005 ABSTRACT Summary The formation of silenced and condensed heterochromatin foci involves enrichment of heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1). HP1 can bridge chromatin segments and form liquid droplets, but the biophysical principles underlying heterochromatin compartmentalization in the cell nucleus are elusive. Here, we assess mechanistically relevant features of pericentric heterochromatin compaction in mouse fibroblasts. We find that (1) HP1 has only a weak capacity to form liquid droplets in living cells; (2) the size, global accessibility, and compaction of heterochromatin foci are independent of HP1; (3) heterochromatin foci lack a separated liquid HP1 pool; and (4) heterochromatin compaction can toggle between two “digital” states depending on the presence of a strong transcriptional activator. These findings indicate that heterochromatin foci resemble collapsed polymer globules that are percolated with the same nucleoplasmic liquid as the surrounding euchromatin, which has implications for our understanding of chromatin compartmentalization and its functional consequences. Keywords: Heterochromatin protein 1, nuclear organization, chromatin compartmentalization, chromatin accessibility, liquid- liquid phase separation, polymer collapse, intracellular viscosity, optodroplets, polarization-dependent fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, epigenetic editing INTRODUCTION Cells partition their genome into distinct chromatin domains with specific functions. Some of them form micrometer-sized chromatin subcompartments in three-dimensional nuclear space (Cavalli and Misteli, 2013, Kundaje et al., 2015, van Steensel and Furlong, 2019). A prominent example is that of the dense heterochromatin foci at silenced pericentric satellite repeats, which are also called chromocenters because of their intense DAPI staining (Probst and Almouzni, 2008). Chromocenters contain elevated levels of DNA methylation, repressive histone modifications like trimethylation of histone H3 at lysine 9 (H3K9me3), and a specific set of proteins, including HP1, that can bind to H3K9me3 via its chromodomain (Bannister et al., 2001). The repressive heterochromatin state can spread to genomic sequences in proximity to pericentric repeats, leading to a phenomenon called position effect variegation (Elgin and Reuter, 2013). Because the accurate position and size of heterochromatin domains is critical for proper cell function (Fodor et al., 2010), it is crucial to understand how chromatin partitioning is faithfully accomplished. Heterochromatin formation involves recruitment of HP1, which can form bridges between nucleosomes (Hiragami-Hamada et al., 2016, Kilic et al., 2018, Machida et al., 2018) and can undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) (Larson et al., 2017, Strom et al., 2017). Both of these properties can, in principle, induce formation of compact heterochromatin domains, as reviewed recently (Erdel and Rippe, 2018). In brief, chromatin bridging can potentially promote formation of ordered and collapsed chromatin globules. These domains would be percolated by the nucleoplasmic liquid but be separated from the surrounding chromatin in the sense that loci within the globule contact each other more frequently than they contact loci outside of it (Cook and Marenduzzo, 2018, Jost et al., 2017, Leibler, 1980, MacPherson et al., 2018, Michieletto et al., 2016, Nicodemi and Pombo, 2014, Nuebler et al., 2018). LLPS of HP1 can potentially form a liquid droplet that encloses heterochromatic sequences. It would separate heterochromatin from the surrounding chromatin by a “boundary” that selectively regulates access of molecules at the interface based on their chemical properties (Banani et al., 2017, Larson et al., 2017, Strom et al., 2017, Taylor et al., 2019). Both mechanisms are not mutually exclusive because interactions among HP1 molecules might drive both chromatin bridging and LLPS. Moreover, weak interactions among lowly abundant HP1 molecules might lead to weak bridging among heterochromatin loci without generating collapsed globules or liquid droplets. Whether heterochromatin is established by droplet formation of HP1, collapse into a chromatin globule, or weak bridging without globule or droplet formation has a number of functional implications. The droplet model predicts that the size of chromocenters increases when the total cellular HP1 level increases, whereas the HP1 concentration inside chromocenters remains constant, a behavior known as “concentration buffering” (Banani et al., 2017). Accordingly, heterochromatin spreading might result from increasing HP1 levels, whereas heterochromatin maintenance might rely on the buffered HP1 concentration in chromocenters. Conversely, the chromatin globule model predicts that the size of chromocenters is not directly coupled to total cellular HP1 levels, whereas the HP1 concentration inside chromocenters follows the total cellular HP1 level. We refer to this behavior as “size buffering.” In this scenario, heterochromatin spreading and maintenance would have to be regulated by other means. For decreasing cellular HP1 levels, droplets should dissolve when the critical concentration is reached (Banani et al., 2017), whereas collapsed globules should transition into a distinct decondensed state (Leibler, 1980, Michieletto et al., 2016). Thus, the globule model predicts switch-like behavior with “digital” compaction states (compacted or decompacted, rarely intermediate). In contrast, the droplet model is compatible with digital or “analog” states depending on the coupling between compaction state and droplet size. Another key hallmark of liquid droplets is preferential internal mixing; because of the dynamic attractive protein-protein interactions that drive LLPS, phase-separating proteins should preferentially move within the droplet. This internal protein pool might have specific properties (e.g., particular posttranslational modifications), creating a chemical environment that is distinct from its surroundings. Attractive protein-protein interactions should also tend to increase the apparent viscosity inside the droplet (Hyman et al., 2014). In particular, interactions that depend on the relative orientation of neighboring phase-separating proteins should decrease their rotational diffusion coefficient. In this manner, the kinetics of binding and enzymatic reactions would be locally modulated in the droplet. In contrast, proteins in a chromatin globule would not experience retardation by increased viscosity or retention by a boundary with interfacial resistance, although diffusion barriers created by obstacles might obstruct molecular transport. It is currently unclear how HP1 drives heterochromatin compartmentalization in living cells and which of the functional consequences above arise from it. To address this question, here we assessed key biophysical properties of chromocenters and the associated heterochromatin proteins in mouse fibroblasts. We compared the capacity of HP1 to form droplets in vitro, in the nucleoplasm and when tethered to chromatin, and found that it does not form stable droplets in living cells. By studying molecular transport in chromocenters and by following their response to forced activation, we found that chromocenters resemble collapsed chromatin globules. Their global compaction, accessibility, and size was independent of HP1. Depending on the presence of transcriptional activators, they toggled between two digital chromatin compaction states. These two states might represent the fundamental compaction modes of chromatin that control long-range chromatin contacts and accessibility to nucleoplasmic factors. RESULTS Mouse HP1α and GFP-HP1α Form Droplets in the Presence of DNA In Vitro It has recently been reported that Drosophila HP1a and human HP1α can form liquid droplets in vitro, which for human HP1α is promoted by phosphorylation, addition of DNA, or removal of salt (Larson et al., 2017, Strom et al., 2017, Wang et al., 2019, Zhang et al., 2019). To test the ability of mouse HP1 to form droplets in vitro, we expressed and purified recombinant mouse HP1α and GFP-HP1α (Figure S1A) and mixed both proteins with a concentrated solution of fragmented salmon sperm DNA. At high protein concentrations, both HP1α

Read the complete text