Impact of international travel and border control measures on the global spread of the novel 2019 coronavirus outbreak.
Wells CR, Sah P, Moghadas SM, Pandey A, Shoukat A, Wang Y, Wang Z, Meyers LA, Singer BH, Galvani AP. · 2020
Read Impact of international travel and border control measures on the global spread of the novel 2019 coronavirus outbreak. by Wells CR, Sah P, Moghadas SM, Pandey A, Shoukat A, Wang Y, Wang Z, Meyers LA, Singer BH, Galvani AP. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7132249.txt.
Introduction
Wells and co-authors model how international travel and border controls shaped the early global spread of COVID-19, in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Countries rushed in airport screening and travel limits as cases left China. Earlier SARS experience had cast doubt on screening, which missed many cases.
Their analysis finds border measures likely slowed the rate at which cases were exported from mainland China. Most infected travellers, though, arrive while still in the symptom-free incubation period, so screening cannot catch them. The authors conclude that travel limits alone cannot contain global spread. Fast contact tracing, both at the outbreak's centre and where cases land, is presented as essential.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wells CR, Sah P, Moghadas SM, Pandey A, Shoukat A, Wang Y, Wang Z, Meyers LA, Singer BH, Galvani AP. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2020 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Impact of international travel and border control measures on the global spread of the novel 2019 coronavirus outbreak By Chad R. Wells, Pratha Sah, Seyed M. Moghadas, Abhishek Pandey, Affan Shoukat, Yaning Wang, Zheng Wang, Lauren A. Meyers, Burton H. Singer, Alison P. Galvani Published in: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2002616117 ABSTRACT Significance To contain the global spread of the 2019 novel coronavirus epidemic (COVID-19), border control measures, such as airport screening and travel restrictions, have been implemented in several countries. Our results show that these measures likely slowed the rate of exportation from mainland China to other countries, but are insufficient to contain the global spread of COVID-19. With most cases arriving during the asymptomatic incubation period, our results suggest that rapid contact tracing is essential both within the epicenter and at importation sites to limit human-to-human transmission outside of mainland China. In December 2019, a novel coronavirus outbreak, COVID-19, caused by the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), emerged in Wuhan, China, as a cluster of cases exhibiting pneumonia-like symptoms (1). Within a few weeks, the outbreak spread to 24 other countries around the world, including the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, Australia, and Japan (2). As of February 21, 2020, more than 76,000 cases have been confirmed globally, of which 1.8% have been reported outside mainland China (2, 3). The current COVID-19 outbreak marks the third novel coronavirus emergence in the 21st century, after the 2003 SARS and the 2013 Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS). The 2003 SARS epidemic originated in China’s Guangdong province, resulting in 5,327 cases within the country and 8,096 infections globally (4). In response to its global spread, many countries implemented airport screening, which was later found to be ineffective in slowing the spread of disease (5–7). As of February 21, the World Health Organization has reported 566 confirmed cases in 26 other countries, 14 of which have reported human-to-human transmission (8), with an additional 634 cases being confirmed on a cruise ship (8). On January 23, 2020, China enacted a lockdown in Wuhan City to limit the spread of COVID-19 outbreak, which was expanded to 15 other cities in Hubei province on January 24 (9–15). With the global dissemination of SARS-CoV-2 cases out of China, several countries have instituted border measures, including symptom screening and restricting travel to and from China (16–19). Some countries are encouraging passengers from China to self-identify possible exposure via health questionnaires. Despite these interventions, the global case count continues to rise. Currently, there is limited understanding about how international flight connections and border measures are impacting the global dissemination of the COVID-19 outbreak. We used daily COVID-19 incidence data and global airport network connectivity from mainland China to estimate country-level exportation risks of the outbreak. As expected, we found a significant correlation between the timing of global exportation events and airline connectivity with mainland China. We next evaluated the effectiveness of border measures, including travel lockdown, contact tracing at the epicenter, and airport screening in containing the spread of disease. In our analysis, we accounted for early epidemiological estimates of COVID-19 outbreak from the literature, suggesting that the average incubation period of the disease is 5.2 d but can extend to more than 12 d for some individuals (10, 20). Using Monte Carlo simulations, we estimated that about 64% of exported cases were in the presymptomatic incubation period upon arrival, indicating airport screening is unlikely to prevent disease importation on its own. We further found that the Wuhan and subsequent Hubei travel lockdowns reduced the rate of disease exportation by 81% and averted 71% cases by February 15, 2020, compared to no border restriction. Border control measures are thus unlikely to contain the outbreak, but could likely delay further importation of SARS CoV-2 cases at the early stage of the epidemic. RESULTS Exportation Risk and Impact of Border Control Measures. By January 13, 2020 (95% CI: January 11−14), the daily risk of exporting at least a single infected case from mainland China via international travel exceeded 95% (Fig. 1A). We estimated that the first case was exported from mainland China on December 26, 2019 (95% CI: December 24−28), with a SD of 7.2 d. We found that December 31, 2019 (95% CI: December 31, 2019 to January 2, 2020) had the greatest likelihood for the first exportation event out of China (Fig. 1C), corresponding to 23 d (95% CI: 21 to 23) before the initiation of the travel lockdown in Wuhan. These estimates are relatively comparable to the arrival of infected individuals in Australia and Japan on January 6, 2020 (Table 1 and SI Appendix, Table S5). [Figure: Exportation risk of SARS-CoV-2 cases from mainland China. (A) Daily risk, (B) cumulative risk of exportation of at least one case, and (C) risk of the initial exportation event from mainland China between December 6, 2019 and February 15, 2020. (D and E) Expected number of exported cases from mainland China traveling during the incubation period (blue) or symptomatic phase of the infection (yellow) (D) in the absence of travel lockdowns and (E) with travel lockdowns enforced. (F) Cases averted by the travel lockdowns. The colored band in A−C denotes the 95% credible interval. The vertical dashed lines indicate the start of two travel lockdowns in China: January 23, 2020 in Wuhan and January 25, 2020 for other cities in the Hubei province.] [Table: The estimate of the date of an infected case being exported to a given country in comparison to the first arrival of a reported infected case] The two travel lockdowns have reduced the exportation rate from mainland China, but are insufficient to contain geographic spread (Fig. 1). Since the time of the initial lockdown on January 23, we estimate that the number of exported cases would have exceeded 50 by January 25, 2020 (95% CI: January 24−26) without border restrictions, compared to January 28, 2020 (95% CI: January 27−30) under the enforcement of the travel lockdowns. Over the course of the 24 d of the travel lockdowns, we found that an average of five cases (95% CI: 4 to 6) were exported per day, an 81.3% (95% CI: 80.5 to 82.1%) average reduction in the exportation rate predicted in the absence of any border measures. We estimate that the travel lockdowns reduced the number of COVID-19 importations by February 15, 2020, from 779 (95% CI: 632 to 967) to 230 (95% CI: 178 to 298). This is consistent with the 175 confirmed international SARS-CoV-2 infections by February 21, 2020, with travel history to China (8), taking reporting delays and an asymptomatic incubation period into account. We estimated that 64.3% (95% CI: 55.4 to 71.3%) of exported cases were presymptomatic upon arrival at their destination airport. Assuming that only symptomatic cases were detected by airport screening upon arrival, we estimate that screening contained 82 (95% CI: 72 to 95) cases imported from mainland China, while the two travel lockdowns averted 549 (95% CI: 451 to 670) cases being exported up to February 15, 2020. Country-Level Importation Risk. We used the global airport network to estimate the daily probability of an initial importation event