Transdiagnostic approaches to mental health problems: Current status and future directions.
Dalgleish T, Black M, Johnston D, Bevan A. · 2020
Read Transdiagnostic approaches to mental health problems: Current status and future directions. by Dalgleish T, Black M, Johnston D, Bevan A. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7027356.txt.
Introduction
Dalgleish and co-authors open a special section on transdiagnostic approaches in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. Standard diagnosis sorts mental illness into set boxes. More and more experts think those boxes no longer serve research or care well. Transdiagnostic work cuts across the lines between boxes, or sets them aside.
Dropping those lines opens new ways to group problems and to think about the processes behind them. It also changes how experts view the start of a problem, what keeps it going, and how treatment and recovery work. The authors first trace the history of the diagnosis-led approach and the troubles it now faces. They then survey newer transdiagnostic schemes and set the scene for the studies gathered in the special section.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dalgleish T, Black M, Johnston D, Bevan A. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2020 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Transdiagnostic Approaches to Mental Health Problems: Current Status and Future Directions By Tim Dalgleish, Melissa Black, David Johnston, Anna Bevan, Joanne Davila, Melissa Black, Tim Dalgleish, Jasper Smits Published in: Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology DOI: 10.1037/ccp0000482 ABSTRACT Abstract Despite a longstanding and widespread influence of the diagnostic approach to mental ill health, there is an emerging and growing consensus that such psychiatric nosologies may no longer be fit for purpose in research and clinical practice. In their place, there is gathering support for a “transdiagnostic” approach that cuts across traditional diagnostic boundaries or, more radically, sets them aside altogether, to provide novel insights into how we might understand mental health difficulties. Removing the distinctions between proposed psychiatric taxa at the level of classification opens up new ways of classifying mental health problems, suggests alternative conceptualizations of the processes implicated in mental health, and provides a platform for novel ways of thinking about onset, maintenance, and clinical treatment and recovery from experiences of disabling mental distress. In this Introduction to a Special Section on Transdiagnostic Approaches to Psychopathology, we provide a narrative review of the transdiagnostic literature in order to situate the Special Section articles in context. We begin with a brief history of the diagnostic approach and outline several challenges it currently faces that arguably limit its applicability in current mental health science and practice. We then review several recent transdiagnostic approaches to classification, biopsychosocial processes, and clinical interventions, highlighting promising novel developments. Finally, we present some key challenges facing transdiagnostic science and make suggestions for a way forward. Keywords: transdiagnostic, mental health, classification, biopsychosocial processes, clinical interventions Distress and suffering are an existential cornerstone of the human condition, yet how we reflect upon and describe the extremes of our mental duress has varied enormously across history. For more than 100 years, certainly in the West, the predominant means of conceptualizing mental health struggles has been to categorize them within formal taxonomic systems (Kendler, 2009), organized according to hypothetical distinctions between different sets of signs and symptoms, and compiled into comprehensive compendia of psychiatric diagnoses. The current leading such taxonomies—the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM; now in its 5th edition) and the International Classification of Diseases (ICD; now in its 11th edition)—are long-established, have global reach, and exert a profound influence over the ways in which we understand, assess, and manage mental ill health. Despite the historical momentum and widespread influence of the diagnostic rubric, there is an emerging and growing consensus that such psychiatric nosologies may be reaching the limits of their research and clinical utility. In their place, there is gathering support for a “transdiagnostic” approach that cuts across the traditional diagnostic boundaries or, more radically, sets them aside altogether, to provide novel insights into how we might understand mental health difficulties. This transdiagnostic approach extends beyond issues of taxonomy. Removing the distinctions between proposed psychiatric taxa at the level of classification opens up new ways of conceptualizing the underlying theories and processes implicated in mental ill health and provides a platform for novel ways of thinking about onset, maintenance, and clinical treatment and recovery from experiences of disabling mental distress. The transdiagnostic field is nascent yet fast-developing. This Special Section of the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology provides a timely opportunity to take stock of the current state of transdiagnostic science. In this introduction we review where the field has come from and where it is heading, highlighting issues that require some resolution and offering recommendations for progress. DIAGNOSTIC AND TRANSDIAGNOSTIC APPROACHES Although attempts to classify mental health difficulties date back several thousand years, formalized diagnostic models only emerged properly from the biological and Linnaen botanical classification systems of the 19th century. Most prominently, Kraepelin’s Compendium der Psychiatrie in 1883 (Compton & Guze, 1995) exerted a profound influence on the development of the emerging field of clinical psychiatry especially in the United States, laying the foundation for the publication of the first edition of the DSM in 1952 (DSM-I, American Psychiatric Association, 1952). In 1980, the publication of the DSM–III outlined for the first time a thorough multiaxial diagnostic system with carefully operationalized criteria for a wide range of disorders, with no allegiance to any theoretical approach aside from a broad biomedical model. The DSM–III was hailed as a “paradigm shift” (Blashfield, Keeley, Flanagan, & Miles, 2014) for diagnostic psychiatry, rescuing the profession “. . . from unreliability and the oblivion of irrelevancy” (Frances, 2009, p. 2). The current instantiation of the DSM—the DSM–5 – appeared in 2013 after a 14 year gestation and runs to 947 pages covering some 541 diagnostic categories (up from 106 in the DSM-I; American Psychiatric Association, 2013). The DSM and ICD have evolved into self-perpetuating systems that now govern and define all aspects of how we conceptualize mental health. They provide an organizing framework for virtually all core texts in psychiatry, clinical psychology, and abnormal psychology (Cosgrove, Krimsky, Vijayaraghavan, & Schneider, 2006; Marecek & Hare-Mustin, 2009), they guide mental health training across the helping professions, and they define how we assess, manage and treat mental health problems worldwide. The diagnostic systems that they enshrine have created a form of “epistemic prison” (Hyman, 2010) that constrains health insurance and pharmaceutical industry practices, is sanctioned and supported by government and legal policies, and dominates social and public discourse about mental health and illness, as reflected in art, literature and the visual media (Ussher, 2010). There are many factors underscoring this rise to dominance. Some are certainly sociopolitical (Kawa & Giordano, 2012; Khoury, Langer, & Pagnini, 2014) with diagnoses offering a biomedical legitimacy to discourse about mental ill health that has a broad academic, professional, and social appeal. Others are more pragmatic as, without doubt, the diagnostic paradigm offers some clear benefits to clinical and research practice: It provides a lingua franca for describing clusters of symptoms that facilitates communication between users of services, clinicians and researchers; it sets out a common metric for research programs; and it provides an organizing principle for the development and evaluation of diagnosis-led assessment and treatment approaches (Hayes & Hofmann, 2018). Finally, for some, the biomedical model at the heart of the diagnostic approach also brings a legitimacy to the suffering that is experienced, reducing stigma and deflecting pejorative judgments that mental ill health reflects some form of personal weakness on the part of the diagnosed. Despite these advantages of the diagnostic paradigm, there is a gathering apprehension that the taxonomic approach instantiated in the DSM and ICD runs counter to the available clinical and research evidence and may hamper our understanding of mental ill health and consequently how we manage and treat mental distress (Insel, 2014; Kotov et al., 2017). Here we touch briefly on seven areas of concern that have currency within this debate. We focus predominantly on so-called common mental health problems (Craig & Boardman, 1997), captured by the various diagnoses of mood disorder, anxiety disorder, stressor-related disorders, and obsessive–compulsive disorders within the diagnostic manuals, but the arguments of course extend beyond these presentations. SEVEN CHALLENGES FOR THE DIAGNOSTIC PARADIGM The Underlying Biopsychosocial Processes are Transdiagnostic A perhaps unintended consequence of the psychiatric diagnostic paradigm is the notion that